Recombinant RNase Z does not recognize CCA as part of the tRNA and its cleavage efficieny is influenced by acceptor stem length

One of the essential maturation steps to yield functional tRNA molecules is the removal of 3'-trailer sequences by RNase Z. After RNase Z cleavage the tRNA nucleotidyl transferase adds the CCA sequence to the tRNA 3'-terminus, thereby generating the mature tRNA. Here we investigated whether a terminal CCA triplet as 3'-trailer or embedded in a longer 3'-trailer influences cleavage site selection by RNase Z using three activities: a recombinant plant RNase Z, a recombinant archaeal RNase Z and an RNase Z active wheat extract. A trailer of only the CCA trinucleotide is left intact by the wheat extract RNase Z but is removed by the recombinant plant and archaeal enzymes. Thus the CCA triplet is not recognized by the RNase Z enzyme itself, but rather requires cofactors still present in the extract. In addition, we investigated the influence of acceptor stem length on cleavage by RNase Z using variants of wild-type tRNATyr. While the wild type and the variant with 8 base pairs in the acceptor stem were processed efficiently by all three activities, variants with shorter and longer acceptor stems were poor substrates or were not cleaved at all.     

Sequence changes in both flanking sequences of a pre-tRNA influence the cleavage specificity of RNase P.

The cleavage specificities of the RNase P holoenzymes from Escherichia coli and the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe and of the catalytic M1 RNA from E. coli were analyzed in 5'-processing experiments using a yeast serine pre-tRNA with mutations in both flanking sequences. The template DNAs were obtained by enzymatic reactions in vitro and transcribed with phage SP6 or T7 RNA polymerase. The various mutations did not alter the cleavage specificity of the yeast RNase P holoenzyme; cleavage always occurred predominantly at position G + 1, generating the typical seven base-pair acceptor stem. In contrast, the specificity of the prokaryotic RNase P activities, i.e. the catalytic M1 RNA and the RNase P holoenzyme from E. coli, was influenced by some of the mutated pre-tRNA substrates, which resulted in an unusual cleavage pattern, generating extended acceptor stems. The bases G - 1 and C + 73, forming the eighth base pair in these extended acceptor stems, were an important motif in promoting the unusual cleavage pattern. It was found only in some natural pre-tRNAs, including tRNA(SeCys) from E. coli, and tRNAs(His) from bacteria and chloroplasts. Also, the corresponding mature tRNAs in vivo contain an eight base pair acceptor stem. The presence of the CCA sequence at the 3' end of the tRNA moiety is known to enhance the cleavage efficiency with the catalytic M1 RNA. Surprisingly, the presence or absence of this sequence in two of our substrate mutants drastically altered the cleavage specificity of M1 RNA and of the E. coli holoenzyme, respectively. Possible reasons for the different cleavage specificities of the enzymes, the influence of sequence alterations and the importance of stacking forces in the acceptor stems are discussed.     

Cleavage efficiencies of model substrates for ribonuclease P from Escherichia coli and Thermus thermophilus.

We compared cleavage efficiencies of mono-molecular and bipartite model RNAs as substrates for RNase P RNAs (M1 RNAs) and holoenzymes from E. coli and Thermus thermophilus, an extreme thermophilic eubacterium. Acceptor stem and T arm of pre-tRNA substrates are essential recognition elements for both enzymes. Impairing coaxial stacking of acceptor and T stems and omitting the T loop led to reduced cleavage efficiencies. Small model substrates were less efficiently cleaved by M1 RNA and RNase P from T. thermophilus than by the corresponding E. coli activities. Competition kinetics and gel retardation studies showed that truncated tRNA substrates are less tightly bound by RNase P and M1 RNA from both bacteria. Our data further indicate that (pre-)tRNA interacts stronger with E. coli than T. thermophilus M1 RNA. Thus, low cleavage efficiencies of truncated model substrates by T. thermophilus RNase P or M1 RNA could be explained by a critical loss of important contact points between enzyme and substrate. In addition, acceptor stem--T arm substrates, composed of two synthetic RNA fragments, have been designed to mimic internal cleavage of any target RNA molecule available for base pairing.     

Targeted cleavage of RNA molecules by human RNase P using minimized external guide sequences

The endoribonuclease RNase P processes tRNA-like structures that are assembled out of two separate strands. In these bimolecular constructs, one of the strands is cleaved by the enzyme, and the other one is called the external guide sequence (EGS). A number of EGS with different mutations and deletions were tested for the ability to induce cleavage with human RNase P. Different domains of the original tRNAtyr-like structure were deleted or modified. The anticodon stem and loop and the variable loop could be deleted without a detrimental effect on recognition by RNase P. Modifications in the lengths of T stem and aminoacyl acceptor stem led to a decrease in the relative amount of cleavage, whereas modifications of the D stem were more permissible. Single nucleotide deletions in the T loop reduced cleavage to different extents, depending on the position. Values for the Kd of complex formation of bimolecular constructs with annealing arms of varying lengths ranged from 0.2 nM to 28 nM. A cleavage rate of 1 min(-1) was measured for both the bimolecular target-EGS complex and tRNA precursor.     

The kinetics and specificity of cleavage by RNase P is mainly dependent on the structure of the amino acid acceptor stem.

Cleavage by RNase P of the tRNA(His precursor yields a mature tRNA with an 8 base pair amino acid acceptor stem instead of the usual 7 base pair stem. Here we show, both in vivo and in vitro, that this is mainly dependent on the primary structure and length of the acceptor stem in the precursor. Furthermore, the tRNA(His) precursor used in this study was processed with a change in both kinetic constants, Km and kcat, in comparison to the kinetics of cleavage of the precursor to tRNA(Tyr)Su3. Cleavage of a chimeric tRNA precursor showed that these altered kinetics were due to a difference in the primary structure and in the length of the acceptor stems of these two tRNA precursors. We also studied the cleavage reaction as a function of base substitutions at positions -1 and/or +73 in the precursor to tRNA(His). Our results suggest that the nucleotide at position +73 in tRNA(His) plays a significant role in the kinetics of cleavage of its precursor, possibly in product release. In addition, it appears that the C5 protein of RNase P is involved in the interaction between the enzyme and its substrate in a substrate-dependent manner, as previously suggested.     

Secondary structure in formylmethionine tRNA influences the site-directed cleavage of ribonuclease H using chimeric 2'-O-methyl oligodeoxyribonucleotides

In order to cleave RNA at specific positions in Escherichia coli formylmethionine tRNA, RNase H and complementary chimeric oligonucleotides consisting of DNA and 2'-O-methyl-RNA (Inoue et al. (1987) FEBS Lett. 215, 327] were used. Specific cleavages in the D loop, anticodon loop, T psi C loop, anticodon stem, and acceptor stem were investigated. Virtually unique hydrolyses with RNase H were observed at the T psi C loop, anticodon stem, and acceptor stem when relatively longer chimeric oligonucleotides (20-mer) were used. An efficient cleavage at the anticodon was obtained with a chimeric 13-mer when the higher structure of the tRNA was broken by hybridization with a 20-mer at the acceptor as well as the T psi C stem region. It was found that stabilities of hybrids with chimeric oligonucleotides and the presence of minor nucleosides affect the cleavage of tRNA by this approach.     

The plant tRNA 3' processing enzyme has a broad substrate spectrum.

To elucidate the minimal substrate for the plant nuclear tRNA 3' processing enzyme, we synthesized a set of tRNA variants, which were subsequently incubated with the nuclear tRNA 3' processing enzyme. Our experiments show that the minimal substrate for the nuclear RNase Z consists of the acceptor stem and T arm. The broad substrate spectrum of the nuclear RNase Z raises the possibility that this enzyme might have additional functions in the nucleus besides tRNA 3' processing. Incubation of tRNA variants with the plant mitochondrial enzyme revealed that the organellar counterpart of the nuclear enzyme has a much narrower substrate spectrum. The mitochondrial RNase Z only tolerates deletion of anticodon and variable arms and only with a drastic reduction in cleavage efficiency, indicating that the mitochondrial activity can only cleave bona fide tRNA substrates efficiently. Both enzymes prefer precursors containing short 3' trailers over extended 3' additional sequences. Determination of cleavage sites showed that the cleavage site is not shifted in any of the tRNA variant precursors.     

The unusually long amino acid acceptor stem of Escherichia coli selenocysteine tRNA results from abnormal cleavage by RNase P.

The nucleotide sequence of the gene encoding the Escherichia coli selenocysteine tRNA (tRNA(SeCys] predicts an unusually long acceptor stem of 8 base pairs (one more than other tRNAs). Here we show by in vivo experiments (Northern blots, primer extension analysis) and by in vitro RNA processing studies that E. coli tRNA(SeCys) does contain this additional basepair, and that its formation results from abnormal cleavage by RNase P.     

The effects of matrices of paired substitutions in mid-acceptor stem on Drosophila tRNA(His) structure and end-processing

End-maturation reactions, in which the 5' end leader and 3' end trailer of precursor tRNA are removed by RNase P and 3'-tRNase, respectively, are early, essential steps in eukaryotic precursor tRNA processing. End-processing enzymes may be expected to contact the acceptor stem of tRNA due to its proximity to both cleavage sites. We constructed matrices of pair-wise substitutions in mid-acceptor stem at nt 3/70 and 4/69 of Drosophila tRNA(His) and analyzed their ability to be processed by Drosophila RNase P and 3'-tRNase. In accord with our earlier study of D/T loop processing matrices, we find that tRNA end processing enzymes respond to sequence changes differently. More processing defects were observed with 3'-tRNase than with RNase P, and substitutions at 4/69 reduced processing more than those at 3/70. We evaluated tRNA folding using structure probing nucleases and investigated the contribution of K(M) and V(Max) to the processing efficiency of selected variants. In one substitution (C3A), mis-folding correlates with processing defects. In another (C69A), a disruption of structure appears to be transmitted laterally to both ends of the acceptor stem. Poor processing of C69A by RNase P is due entirely to a reduction in V(Max), but for 3'-tRNase, it is due to an increase in K(M).     

Intracellular mRNA cleavage induced through activation of RNase P by nuclease-resistant external guide sequences

Most antisense oligonucleotide experiments are performed with molecules containing RNase H-competent backbones. However, RNase H may cleave nontargeted mRNAs bound to only partially complementary oligonucleotides. Decreasing such "irrelevant cleavage" would be of critical importance to the ability of the antisense biotechnology to provide accurate assessment of gene function. RNase P is a ubiquitous endogenous cellular ribozyme whose function is to cleave the 5' terminus of precursor tRNAs to generate the mature tRNA. To recruit RNase P, complementary oligonucleotides called external guide sequences (EGS), which mimic structural features of precursor tRNA, were incorporated into an antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide targeted to the 3' region of the PKC-alpha mRNA. In T24 human bladder carcinoma cells, these EGSs, but not control sequences, were highly effective in downregulating PKC-alpha protein and mRNA expression. Furthermore, the downregulation is dependent on the presence of, and base sequence in, the T-loop. Similar observations were made with an EGS targeted to the bcl-xL mRNA.     

Site selection by Xenopus laevis RNAase P

Investigation of the mechanism of cleavage site selection by Xenopus RNAase P reveals that the acceptor stem, a 7 bp helix common to all tRNA precursors, is required for cleavage. We propose that Xenopus RNAase P recognizes conserved features of the mature tRNA and that the cleavage site is selected by measuring the length of the acceptor stem. In support of this, we demonstrate that insertion of 2 bp in the acceptor stem of yeast pre-tRNA(3Leu) relocates the cleavage site 2 bases 3' to the original one. In addition, insertion of 1 bp in the acceptor stem of the end-matured yeast pre-tRNA(Phe) generates an RNAase P cleavage site: the enzyme produces a mature tRNA with the characteristic 7 bp stem and releases one 5' flanking nucleotide. Since it has previously been shown that cleavage sites of the splicing endonuclease are determined by the length of the anticodon stem, RNAase P and the splicing endonuclease apparently use different stems to determine their cutting sites.     

The acceptor stem in pre-tRNAs determines the cleavage specificity of RNase P.

As the result of an unusual RNase P specificity, some special, mature tRNAs have acceptor stems with eight instead of the common seven base pairs. The data from numerous studies suggest that some features in the tRNA domain of pre-tRNAs are important for this behaviour. Here, we show that only five base pairs in the acceptor stem of bacterial histidine tRNAs are required to obtain the changed cleavage site in an unrelated eukaryotic serine tRNA.     

Interaction of structural modules in substrate binding by the ribozyme from Bacillus subtilis RNase P.

The ribozyme from bacterial ribonuclease P recognizes two structural modules in a tRNA substrate: the T stem-loop and the acceptor stem. These two modules are connected through a helical linker. The T stem-loop binds at a surface confined in a folding domain away from the active site. Substrates for the Bacillus subtilis RNase P RNA were previously selected in vitro that are shown to bind comparably well or better than a tRNA substrate. Chemical modification of P RNA-substrate complexes with dimethylsulfate and kethoxal was performed to determine how the P RNA recognizes three in vitro selected substrates. All three substrates bind at the surface known to interact with the T stem-loop of tRNA. Similar to a tRNA, the secondary structure of these substrates contains a helix around the cleavage site and a hairpin loop at the corresponding position of the T stem-loop. Unlike a tRNA, these two structural modules are connected through a non-helical linker. The two structural modules in the tRNA and in the selected substrates bind to two different domains in P RNA. The properties of substrate recognition exhibited by this ribozyme may be exploited to isolate new ribozyme-substrate pairs with interactive structural modules.     

Nuclease footprint analyses of the interactions between RNase P ribozyme and a model mRNA substrate.

RNase P ribozyme cleaves an RNA helix substrate which resembles the acceptor stem and T-stem structures of its natural tRNA substrate. By linking the ribozyme covalently to a sequence (guide sequence) complementary to a target RNA, the catalytic RNA can be converted into a sequence-specific ribozyme, M1GS RNA. We have previously shown that M1GS RNA can efficiently cleave the mRNA sequence encoding thymidine kinase (TK) of herpes simplex virus 1. In this study, a footprint procedure using different nucleases was carried out to map the regions of a M1GS ribozyme that potentially interact with the TK mRNA substrate. The ribozyme regions that are protected from nuclease degradation in the presence of the TK mRNA substrate include those that interact with the acceptor stem and T-stem, the 3' terminal CCA sequence and the cleavage site of a tRNA substrate. However, some of the protected regions (e.g. P13 and P14) are unique and not among those protected in the presence of a tRNA substrate. Identification of the regions that interact with a mRNA substrate will allow us to study how M1GS RNA recognizes a mRNA substrate and facilitate the development of mRNA-cleaving ribozymes for gene-targeting applications.     

UV cross-link mapping of the substrate-binding site of an RNase P ribozyme to a target mRNA sequence.

RNase P ribozyme cleaves an RNA helix that resembles the acceptor stem and T-stem structure of its natural ptRNA substrate. When covalently linked with a guide sequence, the ribozyme can function as a sequence-specific endonuclease and cleave any target RNA sequences that base pair with the guide sequence. Using a site-directed ultraviolet (UV) cross-linking approach, we have mapped the regions of the ribozyme that are in close proximity to a substrate that contains the mRNA sequence encoding thymidine kinase of human herpes simplex virus 1. Our data suggest that the cleavage site of the mRNA substrate is positioned at the same regions of the ribozyme that bind to the cleavage site of a ptRNA. The mRNA-binding domains include regions that interact with the acceptor stem and T-stem and in addition, regions that are unique and not in close contact with a ptRNA. Identification of the mRNA-binding site provides a foundation to study how RNase P ribozymes achieve their sequence specificity and facilitates the development of gene-targeting ribozymes.     

A novel endonucleolytic mechanism to generate the CCA 3' termini of tRNA molecules in Thermotoga maritima

The tRNA 3'-terminal CCA sequence is essential for aminoacylation of the tRNAs and for translation on the ribosome. The tRNAs are transcribed as larger precursor molecules containing 5' and 3' extra sequences. In the tRNAs that do not have the encoded CCA, the 3' extra sequence after the discriminator nucleotide is usually cleaved off by the tRNA 3' processing endoribonuclease (3' tRNase, or RNase Z), and the 3'-terminal CCA residues are added thereto. Here we analyzed Thermotoga maritima 3' tRNase for enzymatic properties using various pre-tRNAs from T. maritima, in which all 46 tRNA genes encode CCA with only one exception. We found that the enzyme has the unprecedented activity that cleaves CCA-containing pre-tRNAs precisely after the CCA sequence, not after the discriminator. The assays for pre-tRNA variants suggest that the CA residues at nucleotides 75 and 76 are required for the enzyme to cleave pre-tRNAs after A at nucleotide 76 and that the cleavage occurs after nucleotide 75 if the sequence is not CA. Intriguingly, the pre-tRNA(Met) that is the only T. maritima pre-tRNA without the encoded CCA was cleaved after the discriminator. The kinetics data imply the existence of a CCA binding domain in T. maritima 3' tRNase. We also identified two amino acid residues critical for the cleavage site selection and several residues essential for the catalysis. Analysis of cleavage sites by 3' tRNases from another eubacteria Escherichia coli and two archaea Thermoplasma acidophilum and Pyrobaculum aerophilum corroborates the importance of the two amino acid residues for the cleavage site selection.     

In vitro selection of external guide sequences for directing RNase P-mediated inhibition of viral gene expression

External guide sequences (EGSs) are small RNA molecules that bind to a target mRNA, form a complex resembling the structure of a tRNA, and render the mRNA susceptible to hydrolysis by RNase P, a tRNA processing enzyme. An in vitro selection procedure was used to select EGSs that direct human RNase P to cleave the mRNA encoding thymidine kinase (TK) of herpes simplex virus 1. One of the selected EGSs, TK17, was at least 35 times more active in directing RNase P in cleaving TK mRNA in vitro than the EGS derived from a natural tRNA sequence. TK17, when in complex with the TK mRNA sequence, resembles a portion of tRNA structure and exhibits an enhanced binding affinity to the target mRNA. Moreover, a reduction of 95 and 50% in the TK expression was found in herpes simplex virus 1-infected cells that expressed the selected EGS and the EGS derived from the natural tRNA sequence, respectively. Our study provides direct evidence that EGS molecules isolated by the selection procedure are effective in tissue culture. These results also demonstrate the potential for using the selection procedure as a general approach for the generation of highly effective EGSs for gene-targeting application.     

Distinct modes of mature and precursor tRNA binding to Escherichia coli RNase P RNA revealed by NAIM analyses

We have analyzed by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) pools of precursor or mature tRNA molecules, carrying a low level of Rp-RMPalphaS (R = A, G, I) or Rp-c7-deaza-RMPalphaS (R = A, G) modifications, to identify functional groups that contribute to the specific interaction with and processing efficiency by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA. The majority of interferences were found in the acceptor stem, T arm, and D arm, including the strongest effects observed at positions G19, G53, A58, and G71. In some cases (interferences at G5, G18, and G71), the affected functional groups are candidates for direct contacts with RNase P RNA. Several modifications disrupt intramolecular tertiary contacts known to stabilize the authentic tRNA fold. Such indirect interference effects were informative as well, because they allowed us to compare the structural constraints required for ptRNA processing versus product binding. Our ptRNA processing and mature tRNA binding NAIM analyses revealed overlapping but nonidentical patterns of interference effects, suggesting that substrate binding and cleavage involves binding modes or conformational states distinct from the binding mode of mature tRNA, the product of the reaction.