The program of sex chromosome pairing in meiosis is highly conserved across marsupial species: implications for sex chromosome evolution

Marsupials present a series of genetic and chromosomal features that are highly conserved in very distant species. One of these features is the absence of a homologous region between X and Y chromosomes. According to this genetic differentiation, sex chromosomes do not synapse during the first meiotic prophase in males, and a special structure, the dense plate, maintains sex chromosome association. In this report we present results on the process of meiotic sex chromosome pairing obtained from three different species, Thylamys elegans, Dromiciops gliroides, and Rhyncholestes raphanurus, representing the three orders of American marsupials. We have investigated the relationships between the axial structures organized along sex chromosomes and the formation of the dense plate. We found that in the three species the dense plate arises as a modification of sex chromosomal axial elements, but without the involvement of other meiotic axial structures, such as the cohesin axes. Considering the phylogenetic relationships among the marsupials studied here, our data reinforce the idea that the dense plate emerged early in marsupial evolution as an efficient mechanism to ensure the association of the nonhomologous sex chromosomes. This situation could have influenced the further evolution of sex chromosomes in marsupials.     

Sex chromosome pairing during male meiosis in marsupials

The pairing of the sex chromosomes at pachytene has been examined in twenty-two species of Australian marsupials, including four with complex sex chromosome systems. The axial elements of the sex chromosomes associate in all but one species. However, no synaptonemal complex has been observed between the axes of the X and Y chromosome in any of the examined species. Both the type of association between the sex chromosome axes, and the structural modifications of these axes are conserved within taxonomic groupings. In three species with complex sex chromosome systems, the t(XA), Y, A trivalents do not have a favoured relative orientation of the axes of the Y and A chromosomes, whereas in a fourth species with a t(XA₁), t(A₂YA₂), A₂ system the t(XA₁) and A₂ axes are in a cis arrangement with each other.     

Involvement of synaptonemal complex proteins in sex chromosome segregation during marsupial male meiosis

Marsupial sex chromosomes break the rule that recombination during first meiotic prophase is necessary to ensure reductional segregation during first meiotic division. It is widely accepted that in marsupials X and Y chromosomes do not share homologous regions, and during male first meiotic prophase the synaptonemal complex is absent between them. Although these sex chromosomes do not recombine, they segregate reductionally in anaphase I. We have investigated the nature of sex chromosome association in spermatocytes of the marsupial Thylamys elegans, in order to discern the mechanisms involved in ensuring their proper segregation. We focused on the localization of the axial/lateral element protein SCP3 and the cohesin subunit STAG3. Our results show that X and Y chromosomes never appear as univalents in metaphase I, but they remain associated until they orientate and segregate to opposite poles. However, they must not be tied by a chiasma since their separation precedes the release of the sister chromatid cohesion. Instead, we show they are associated by the dense plate, a SCP3-rich structure that is organized during the first meiotic prophase and that is still present at metaphase I. Surprisingly, the dense plate incorporates SCP1, the main protein of the central element of the synaptonemal complex, from diplotene until telophase I. Once sex chromosomes are under spindle tension, they move to opposite poles losing contact with the dense plate and undergoing early segregation. Thus, the segregation of the achiasmatic T. elegans sex chromosomes seems to be ensured by the presence in metaphase I of a synaptonemal complex-derived structure. This feature, unique among vertebrates, indicates that synaptonemal complex elements may play a role in chromosome segregation.     

The relationship between chromosomes and axes in the chiasmatic XY pair of the Armenian hamster (Cricetulus migratorius)

The XY pair of the Armenian hamster has been studied in spreads and in three-dimensional reconstructions during the main stages of first meiotic prophase and metaphase I. The general pattern of the axes is similar to that of other mammals. There is a differential and a common region. In the latter a synaptonemal complex (SC) is formed by the pairing of the axes. This SC is longer than in other mammals. Heteropycnosis in the differential region is mirrored by differential chromatin packing at the ultrastructural level. The differential regions of the X and Y chromosomes can be identified both at the light and at the electron microscope level. The location of the axes at the interchromatid space in the differential region has been established. The visualization of the axes with the light microscope is facilitated by their bulgings at the beginning of mid-pachytene. These intermittent deformities change into a coiled and thinner axis during mid-pachytene. A chiasma originates in the common region of the XY body and it is seen near the ends of the sex chromosomes at diakinesis and metaphase I. The ultrastructure of this chiasmatic region is similar to that of autosomal chiasmata in the mouse. The axes separate from each other and leave a remaining piece of SC in which the central space is replaced by dense fibrillar material. During metaphase I the ultrastructure of this chiasmatic region cannot be identified because of the partial loss of the marker axes.     

Sex chromosome-autosome translocations in the leaf-nosed bats, family Phyllostomidae. II. Meiotic analyses of the subfamilies Stenodermatinae and Phyllostominae

Analyses of meiotic pairing and synaptonemal complexes of the composite sex chromosomes of male phyllostomid bats with X-autosome or X- and Y-autosome translocations were performed using Giemsa and silver staining procedures. Typical mammalian sex vesicles were absent in all species analyzed. Stenodermatine species with X-autosome translocations possessed an open ring and tail configuration of the XY1Y2 trivalent. Species with both X- and Y-autosome translocations possessed a closed ring and tail configuration of the neo-XY bivalent. In both cases, the tail represented the autosomal short arm of the X paired with its homologue, either the Y2 in XY1Y2 species or the autosomal arm of the composite Y in neo-XY species. Autosomal pairing of the composite sex bivalent in neo-XY species replaced an association between the original X and Y in late prophase I. The absence of a sex vesicle, the unusual pairing configurations of the composite sex chromosomes, and the presumed absence of meiotic nondisjunction in these species is discussed in light of current hypotheses of sex chromosome behavior in male gametogenesis in mammals.     

Synaptonemal complex analysis in spermatocytes of tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus (Pisces, Cichlidae).

Some adaptations of the synaptonemal complex (SC) whole-mounting technique first used in plants permitted its application to meiotic studies in tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus. Direct observation of the chromosome pairing process and bivalent structure during the meiotic prophase of this fish species by light and electron microscopy permitted the analysis of SCs in autosomes and the possible identification of sex chromosomes. The analysis of SCs in spermatocytes of O. niloticus revealed that all 22 bivalent chromosomes completely paired, except for the occurrence of a size heteromorphism in the terminal region of the largest bivalent associated with the presence of an incompletely paired segment during the synapsis process, which may be the cytological visualization of an XX/XY sex chromosome system in this species.     

The morphological sequence of XY pairing in the Norway rat Rattus norvegicus

The sequence of XY pairing at meiotic prophase in the Norway rat, Rattus norvegicus, has been studied in spread preparations of spermatocytes obtained from pubertal males. As in most mammals, sex chromosome pairing is delayed in relation to that of the autosomes. At one stage in pachytene, the Y is fully paired in synaptonemal complex association with about one-third of the X. Observation in spread preparations at pachytene and diplotene and in air-dried metaphase I preparations indicates that the long arm of the Y pairs with the short arm of the X. Pairing of the Y with both ends of the X is seen in about 4% of pachytene spermatocytes. The possibility that XY pairing in the rat may be nonhomologous (Ashley 1983) is considered, and the view is expressed that the XY synaptonemal complex may be incomplete in fine structural detail, thus not providing for the effective pairing required in true reciprocal recombination. The same mechanism that excludes crossing over from heterochromatic regions of autosomes may also operate to minimize or prevent crossing over in the sex pair of mammals.     

The synaptic behaviour of the X and Y chromosomes in the marsupial Monodelphis dimidiata

The pairing behaviour of the X and Y chromosomes of Monodelphis dimidiata was studied with light and electron microscopy. Pairing of the sex chromosomes is delayed with respect to autosome synapsis. Both the X and the minute Y chromosome show an axis attached by its two ends to the nuclear envelope. Synapsis of the sex chromosomes occurs by the joining of the chromatin sheaths that surround the axes and by a small, three-layered structure close to the nuclear envelope. The X and Y chromosomes remain joined to each other during the diffuse stage and diplotene-diakinesis but they do not show a synaptonemal complex. During the diffuse stage a dense plate is formed at the boundary between the X-Y body and the nuclear envelope. During early metaphase a folded sheet is attached to the periphery of the X-Y body. This sheet is formed by a piece of the nuclear envelope carrying the dense plate and it shows transverse fibrils and a central element similar to synaptonemal-complex remains. No evidence of a non-chiasmate segregation mechanism was observed. Polarization of the axial ends of the sex chromosomes is observed after X-Y synapsis. These important departures from the X-Y pairing pattern of eutherian mammals are discussed and assumed to present a special mechanism for holding the minute Y joined to the X chromosome in this marsupial.     

A synaptonemal complex-derived mechanism for meiotic segregation precedes the evolutionary loss of homology between sex chromosomes in arvicolid mammals

Synapsis and reciprocal recombination between sex chromosomes are restricted to the pseudoautosomal region. In some animal species, sex chromosomes do not present this region, although they utilize alternative mechanisms that ensure meiotic pairing and segregation. The subfamily Arvicolinae (Rodentia, Cricetidae) includes numerous species with achiasmate sex chromosomes. In order to know whether the mechanism involved in achiasmate segregation is an ancient feature in arvicolid species, we have compared the sex chromosomes of both the Mediterranean vole (Microtus duodecimcostatus) and the water vole (Arvicola terrestris). By means of immunofluorescence, we have found that sex chromosomes in M. duodecimcostatus are asynaptic and develop a synaptonemal complex-derived structure that mediates pairing and facilitates segregation. In A. terrestris, sex chromosomes are synaptic and chiasmate but also exhibit a synaptonemal complex-derived filament during anaphase I. Since phylogenetic relationships indicate that the synaptic condition is ancestral in arvicolids, this finding indicates that the mechanism for achiasmate sex chromosome segregation precedes the switching to the asynaptic condition. We discuss the origin of this synaptonemal complex-derived mechanism that, in turn, could counterbalance the disruption of homology in the sex chromosomes of those species.     

Silver-Stained accessory structures on human sex chromosomes

Summary Using a combination of silver-staining and light microscopic techniques on human male meiotic preparations, it is feasible to study the morphology and behavior of both autosomal synaptonemal complexes and sex chromosome axes. During leptotene and early zygotene, the X and Y chromosomes are separate; their axes appearing as thin, filamentous structures. During late zygotene/early pachytene, the sex chromosomes come close to each other and a distinct sex vesicle is formed. We confirm the existence of a short synaptonemal complex between the terminal ends of the X and Y chromosomes. In our preparations, a number of accessory structures can be seen along the axes of the sex chromosomes. These structures appear to be similar in morphology to those previously observed in several other mammalian species.     

家鸡联会复合体的亚显微结构分析

本文以表面铺展——硝酸银染色技术,对家鸡的联会复合体(Syneptonemal Complex,SC)作亚显微结构分析。根据对10个精母细胞和10个卵母细胞SC的测量结果,绘制组型图。发现雌雄家鸡的常染色体的SC组型相同。在精母细胞中,性染色体(ZZ)的行为与常染色体相似。在卵母细胞中,性染色体ZW的长度不同,长轴为Z,短轴为W,两者之间只有部分配对,形成SC。从早粗线期到晚粗线期,由同源配对调整为非同源配对。另外,在一只雌鸡中,第一次观察到,有些细胞的常染色体能正常配对,而性染色体完全不配对的现象。     

Achiasmatic sex chromosomes in Pitymys duodecimcostatus: mechanisms of association and segregation

The meiotic behavior of the sex chromosomes of Pitymys duodecimcostatus was studied by electron microscopy of whole-mount synaptonemal complex preparations. The results established that the sex chromosomes of this species are achiasmatic and remain unassociated throughout meiotic prophase I in most spermatocytes. In other cells, nonspecific association of the X and Y occurred by means of filamentous bridges. Pitymys duodecimcostatus represents an additional example of a mammalian species lacking a homologous pairing segment in its sex chromosomes and extends current knowledge about this controversial subject. In this regard, we suggest that sex-chromosome association is a characteristic that probably followed different evolutionary paths in different mammals, leading to loss of the homologous segment in some species and its conservation in others. It is also suggested that in P. duodecimcostatus, and probably in many other species as well, three mechanisms may act in concert to permit joining of the X and Y chromosomes during meiotic prophase, and, consequently, to ensure proper segregation during anaphase I: (1) joining of the sex-chromosome axes at their ends to the nuclear membrane, (2) formation of fibrillar structures to hold the sex chromosomes together, and (3) cohesiveness due to sex-vesicle formation.     

Meiotic behavior of gonosomically variant females of Akodon azarae (Rodentia, Cricetidae)

The meiotic behavior of sex chromosomes has been investigated in variant females of Akodon azarae, both in pachytene oocytes and metaphase I. In somatic cells, these females have a heteromorphic sex pair, in which the minor chromosome has been previously interpreted as a major deletion of the long arm of the X chromosome (dX). After microspreading for synaptonemal complex analysis, pachytene oocytes show two axes of very different lengths (100:17.1), which correspond to the sex chromosomes X and dX. True synapsis is abnormally restricted (43.3%) between these sex chromosomes; on the other hand, self-synapsis of both the X and dX chromosomes is frequent (60%). Single, nonsynapsed axes or axial segments are thickened. Strong chromatin condensation occurs around nonsynapsed axes or axial segments, giving many of these sex pairs an appearance similar to an XY body ("sex vesicle"). The minor gonosome axis differs from that of the Y chromosome of male meiosis, as the former is shorter (relative to the X) and has a different synaptic behavior. In 17 metaphases I from XdX variant females, only heteromorphic, end-to-end joined sex pairs were observed. These variant females differ from the variant females of the wood lemming Myopus schisticolor in several respects, but a similar mechanism seems to be prevalent in other species of the genus Akodon. Self-synapsis of unequal gonosomes in oocytes is assumed as an escape from functional deterioration, following the hypothesis put forward by others.     

Chromosome banding in Amphibia. XXII. Atypical y chromosomes in Gastrotheca walkeri and Gastrotheca ovifera (Anura,Hylidae)

The chromosomes of the rare South American marsupial frogs Gastrotheca walkeri and G. ovifera were extensively reexamined with various banding techniques. The karyotypes of both species are distinguished by a new category of XY female symbol /XX male symbol female sex chromosomes. The unusual Y chromosomes are characterized by containing the least amount of constitutive heterochromatin in the karyotypes. This is in contrast to all previously known amphibian Y chromosomes and does not fit the evolutionary model of early XY differentiation in vertebrates. In male meiosis, the heteromorphic XY chromosomes of both species still exhibit the same pairing configurations as the autosomes. DNA flow cytometric measurements show the nuclear DNA amount of G. walkeri to be 10.90 pg. The significance of the XY/XX sex chromosomes of these marsupial frogs, the various classes of constitutive heterochromatin detected, and the data obtained from meiotic analyses are discussed in detail.     

Ultrastructure and behavior of the achiasmatic,telosynaptic XY pair of the sand rat (Psammomys obesus)

The behavior of the X and Y chromosomes in somatic and testicular cells of the sand rat (P. obesus) has been investigated with light and electron-microscope procedures. The Y chromosome has been identified as the fourth longest of the complement, both by C-banding and by its meiotic behavior. The X chromosome is the longest of the complement and carries two major C-heterochromatic blocks, one in the distal part of the long arm and the other forming most of the short arm. During presynaptic stages in spermatocytes, separate C-heterochromatic blocks, representing the sex chromosomes, are observed in the nuclei. An XY body is regularly formed at pachytene. During first meiotic metaphase the X and Y chromosomes show variable associations, none of them chiasmatic. Second meiotic metaphases contain, as in other mammals, a single sex chromosome, suggesting normal segregation between the X and the Y. — Electron microscopic observations of the autosomal synaptonemal complexes (SCs) and the single axes of the X and Y chromosomes during pachytene permit accurate, statistically significant identification of each of the largest chromosomes of the complement and determination of the mean arm ratios of the X and Y axes. The X and Y axes always lie close to each other but do not form a SC. The ends of the X and Y axes are attached to the nuclear envelope and associate with each other in variable ways, both autologously (X with X or Y with Y) and heterologously (X with Y), with a tendency to form a maximum number (four) of associated ends. Analysis of 36 XY pairs showed no significant preference for any single specific attachment between arm ends. The eighth longest autosomal bivalent is frequently partially asynaptic during early pachytene, and only at that time is often near or touching one end of the X axis. — It is concluded that while axis formation and migration of the axes along the plane of the nuclear envelope proceed normally in the X and Y chromosomes, true synapsis (with SC formation) does not occur because the pairing region of the X chromosome has probably been relocated far from the chromosome termini by the insertion of distal C-heterochromatic blocks.     

Role of the pseudoautosomal region in sex-chromosome pairing during male meiosis: meiotic studies in a man with a deletion of distal Xp.

Meiotic studies were undertaken in a 24-year-old male patient with short stature, chondrodysplasia punctata, ichthyosis, steroid sulfatase deficiency, and mild mental retardation with an inherited cytologically visible deletion of distal Xp. Molecular investigations showed that the pseudoautosomal region as well as the steroid sulfatase gene were deleted, but telomeric sequences were present at the pter on the deleted X chromosome. A complete failure of sex-chromosome pairing was observed in the primary spermatocytes of the patient. Telomeric approaches between the sex chromosomes were made at zygotene in some cells, but no XY synaptonemal complex was formed. The sex chromosomes were present as univalents at metaphase I, and germ-cell development was arrested between metaphase I and metaphase II in the vast majority of cells, consistent with the azoospermia observed in the patient. The failure of XY pairing in this individual indicates that the pseudoautosomal sequences play an important role in initiating XY pairing and formation of synaptonemal complex at meiosis.     

Sex chromosomes, synapsis, and cohesins: a complex affair

During first meiotic prophase, homologous chromosomes are held together by the synaptonemal complex, a tripartite proteinaceous structure that extends along the entire length of meiotic bivalents. While this feature is applicable for autosomes, sex chromosomes often escape from this rule. Many species present sex chromosomes that differ between them in their morphology, length, and gene content. Moreover, in some species, sex chromosomes appear in a single dose in one of the sexes. In all of these cases, the behavior of sex chromosomes during meiosis is conspicuously affected, and this includes the assembly and dynamics of the synaptonemal complex. We review in this study the structure of the synaptonemal complex in the sex chromosomes of three groups of organisms, namely: mammals, orthopterans, and hemipterans, which present different patterns of sex chromosome structure and behavior. Of special interest is the analysis of the organization of the axial/lateral elements of the synaptonemal complex in relation to other axial structures organized along meiotic chromosomes, mainly the cohesin axis. The differences found in the behavior of both axial structures reveal that while the organization of a cohesin axis along sex chromosomes is a conserved feature in most organisms and it shows very little morphological variations, the axial/lateral elements of the synaptonemal complex present a wide range of structural modifications on these chromosomes.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at The synaptonemal complex—50 years