Soluble suppressor activity of concanavalin A-activated spleen cells on B-lymphocyte colony formation in vitro.

Supernates from concanavalin A (Con A)-activated mouse spleen cell cultures suppress the formation of B-lymphocyte colonies (BLC) in soft agar culture by 30 to 95%. Con A-induced BLC suppressive culture supernates can be heated at 80 °C for 1 hr without losing activity. The BLC suppressive activity is eliminated totally by trypsin treatment and partly by treatment with β-galactosidase. Activity is unaffected by treatment with DNAse, RNAse, and α-glucosidase. By ultrafiltration the BLC suppressive factor(s) was shown to have a molecular weight greater than 300,000. These data suggest that BLC suppression is mediated by a protein-carbohydrate complex. BLC suppression was obtained when normal spleen cells were preincubated in Con A-activated supernates for only 1 hr at 37 °C. BLC suppressor activity was absent in the supernatant fluid of Con A exposed anti-θ-treated spleen cells, nonadherent spleen cells, extensively washed spleen cells, and spleen cells from nude (athymic) mice suggesting that cells responsible for Con A-induced BLC suppression are adherent, fragile cells of the T lineage. Con A-activated spleen cell supernates do not suppress colony formation in soft agar by normal mouse granulocyte-macrophage precursors, by plasmacytoma cells, T-lymphoma cells, or by carcinoma cells. However, colony formation by Abelson's murine leukemia virus transformed B-lymphoma cells was suppressed by 95% suggesting a relationship between this immature B-lymphoma line and B-lymphocyte colony-forming cells. Con A-activated spleen cell supernates do not suppress lymphocyte activation in liquid culture by phytohemagglutinin, Con A, or lipopolysaccharide. Heat-treated supernates—which inhibited BLC development by 90–95%—did not suppress the plaque formation by spleen cells immunized in vivo or in vitro by sheep red blood cells.     

Suppressor factor from tumor-allosensitized spleen cells--its effect on in vitro proliferation of tumor cells and in vivo skin allograft survival

C57BL/6 mice are sensitized ip with allogeneic P-815 mastocytoma cells. Fifteen days later the spleen cells of the sensitized mice are used in the production of suppressor factor or treated with mitomycin and used as suppressor cells. Sensitized spleen cells incubated with the specific alloantigen (DBA/2 m-treated spleen cells) release suppressor factor (SF)² which inhibits cell proliferation in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) as well as the in vitro generation of cytotoxic cells (CML). SF is most effective when added eary during MLC. SF also inhibits mitogen responsiveness of normal spleen cells. In addition to inhibiting lymphocyte function in vitro, suppressor cells as well as SF inhibit the in vitro proliferation of tumor cells. This inhibition is specific for the tumor to which the suppressor cells are induced. The inhibition of tumor cell proliferation is not due to the presence of cytotoxic cells in the spleen of the tumor-allosensitized mice. Suppressor cells from neonatal mice do not inhibit the in vitro proliferation of tumor cells. SF injected iv into C57BL/6 mice decreases the mixed lymphocyte reactivity of the host spleen cells and decreases the ability of the host to reject skin allografts. We interpret these data to suggest that tumor-allosensitized spleen cells, and the SF they produce, not only affect lymphocyte function but also inhibit tumor cell proliferation. This dual effect of suppressor cells could be an important part of the immune surveillance against tumors.     

Regulation of the in vitro anamnestic antibody response by cyclic AMP. II. Antigen-dependent enhancement by exogenous prostaglandins of the E series.

The spleen cells from CFW/D mice injected with dimethylbenzanthracene-induced leukemia virus exhibited a progressive decline in the in vitro response to heterologous erythrocyte antigens in parallel with tumor growth. Cell transfer experiments revealed that this immunodepressed state may involve a B-cell defect rather than extrinsic factors in the cellular environment since: (i) nonresponsiveness could be transferred to irradiated non-tumor-bearing mice with spleen cells, and (ii) T cells from tumorbearing mice cooperated with normal bone marrow cells, but bone marrow from tumorbearing mice did not cooperate with normal T cells. In addition, T cells from the thymic tumor could cooperate with normal bone marrow cells upon transfer to irradiated recipients. TL 485-2 cells, a T-cell line derived from the tumor, could be specifically activated with SRBC thereby indicating that the virus transformed T cells were immunocompetent. Suppressor cells, which appeared in the spleen concomitant with immunodepression and tumor development, may directly raise B-cell thresholds for T-dependent triggering signals since the antibody response of spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice could be restored by adding agents such as LPS, 2 mercaptoethanol, or T cells exogenously preactivated in normal animals. The suppressor cell could be enriched by adherence to plastic and was removed by treatment with carbonyl iron. In addition, it was unlikely that the suppressor cell was a virus-infected cell since transformed, virus-infected cells from the tumor or TL 485-2 cells were not suppressive when added to spleen cells in vitro but rather resulted in a marked, polyclonal enhancement of the PFC response. The interaction of TL 485-2 cells and normal spleen cells resulted in the release of a stimulatory factor which increased DNA synthesis in resting cells as well as increasing PFC. The role of these enhancing factors and suppressor cells in controlling tumor growth remains to be elucidated.     

The immunoregulatory role of bone marrow. II. Characterization of a suppressor cell inhibiting the in vitro antibody response.

The addition of bone marrow cells (BMC) to spleen cell cultures suppressed the antibody response in a dose-dependent manner. This suppression required viable cells. Treatment of BMC with anti-thymocyte serum did not affect the suppressive activity and BMC, but not spleen cells, from nude mice inhibited the antibody response to the same degree as marrow from normal littermates. BMC which had been depleted of macrophages with antimacrophage serum or carbonyl iron showed increased suppressor activity. Furthermore, fractionation of BMC by velocity sedimentation and resetting revealed the suppressor cell to be a medium-to-large Fc receptor-positive lymphocyte. Absence of detectable B or T cell markers on the suppressor cell indicates this cell to be an Fc-positive null lymphocyte, possibly a precursor cell, which inhibits the response of mature lymphocytes     

Immunologic significance of nonspecific suppressor cells in spleens of tumor-bearing mice.

Spleen cells from mice bearing a progressively growing syngeneic tumor failed to respond to stimulation with mitogens in vitro. This lack of reactivity was due to the presence of nylon wool-adherent cells in the population that could inhibit the mitogen response of normal lymphocytes. Paradoxically, at times when strong suppressor cell activity could be detected in tumor-bearing mice, the animals responded normally to in vivo immunization with sheep erythrocytes and allogeneic tumors, and to in vitro sensitization with allogeneic tumor cells. Regression of a highly antigenic syngeneic tumor also was unaffected by the presence of these suppressor cells. Thus, the occurrence of nonspecific suppressor cells in the spleens of tumor-bearing mice did not influence the overall immunologic competence of these animals.     

Properties of reticulum cell sarcomas in SJL/J mice: II. Fate of labeled tumor cells in normal and irradiated syngeneic mice

Transplantable reticulum cell sarcoma (RCS) cells were labeled with ³H-uridine or ³H-thymidine in vitro and injected intravenously into normal and irradiated syngeneic SJL/J mice. RCS cells exhibited typical B cell migration characteristics in peripheral lymphoid organs in both normal and irradiated recipients, localizing in follicles in a pattern resembling that of labeled normal bone marrow cells. However, over the first 72 hr after transfer, RCS cells diluted their label much less in irradiated than in normal recipients, reflecting their inability to proliferate in the irradiated hosts. The presence of unlabeled tumor cells did not significantly affect the distribution of labeled normal bone marrow or lymph node cells in the recipients. Thus, RCS fails to grow in irradiated recipients in spite of undisturbed homing characteristics and in the absence of any evidence of cytotoxic influences from the host.     

Suppressor T cells in thymus-reconstituted nude mice: regulation of mitogen-induced transformation

A population of glass-wool-adherent splenic cells which could suppress the response of other spleen cell populations to T-cell mitogens was isolated from thymus-reconstituted nude mice. Such adherent cells were characterized as sensitive to anti-Thy 1.2 and complement treatment. Glass-wool-adherent cells from athymic mice do not have suppressor activity to self or normal littermate NAC; however, these mice possess precursor suppressor cells as demonstrated by isolation of glass-wool-adherent T regulatory cells in thymus-grafted nude mice. Such cells are generated in either freshly obtained or in vitro cultured thymus. Evidence for suppressor T cells of host genotype was supported by their sensitivity to host-specific anti-Thy serum treatment as well as their generation in alymphoid thymus grafts. Prior anti-Thy 1.2 treatment of GAC partially removed the suppressor activity: however, macrophages and B lymphocytes were shown not to be secondary regulatory cells or suppressor mediators, thus mature T lymphocytes with low amounts of Thy 1.2 antigen may be responsible for this residual suppression. Further characterization of GAC indicates that active cell growth is required for their regulatory function, as irradiation removed the suppressor activity. This report provides evidence for the presence of a T-lymphocyte subpopulation which has a regulatory function and requires a thymus in the generation of these cells.     

Cooperation between mouse T-cell subpopulations in the cell-mediated response to a natural poxvirus pathogen.

Irradiated CBA anti-DBA/2 cells (10⁶ cells/culture) suppressed the production of effector cells in cultures containing 10⁷ unprimed CBA (responder) and 10⁶ irradiated DBA/2 (stimulator) spleen cells per culture. The suppressive element was cellular and suppression was specific for the stimulating antigen. The suppressive activity resided in the cytotoxic cell population in that both suppressive and cytotoxic activities were found in cells of the same size range, predominantly in T-cells, were produced in response to similar doses of stimulator antigen, and were produced with the same time course following establishment of first sensitization cultures. Eventual suppression correlated with the cytotoxic activity introduced into second sensitization cultures by suppressor cells. The short-term cytotoxic activity and suppressor activity were both highly radioresistant. These studies indicate that the suppressor cells formed in an in vitro mixed lymphocyte culture are cytotoxic to stimulator cells.     

Suppression of cell-mediated immune responses after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI). I. Characterization of suppressor cells of the mixed lymphocyte reaction

Total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) was administered to (BALB/c X C57BL/6)F1 mice in eight daily doses of 200 rad (total 1600 rad). Spleen cells isolated from mice after treatment with TLI do not respond to alloantigens in vitro in a one-way mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), but normal reactivity recovers after approximately 2 mo. Radioresistant, antigen-nonspecific suppressor cells are documented in the spleens of TLI-treated mice immediately after radiotherapy, but suppressive capacity gradually disappears within 30 days. After TLI, the spleen is repopulated with large cells, the proportion of which is greatest at a time when theta-bearing cells are still depleted. Radioresistant suppression is mediated predominantly by the large cell subset and is thymus independent. Suppressor function can be abolished by lethal physicochemical procedures including formaldehyde fixation, multiple freeze-thawing, and heating to 56 degrees C, and it cannot be conferred by supernatants of TLI-suppressed MLR suspensions. Suppression cannot be overcome by adding various cell factors including T cell growth factor (TCGF) and lymphocyte-activating factor (LAF), nor is it affected by a prostaglandin inhibitor. Equally potent radioresistant suppressive activity is documented by co-culturing cells derived from other sources enriched in large, immature hematopoietic cells, including fetal liver cells and bone marrow cells obtained from normal and congenitally athymic mice. The presence of a large cell population and MLR suppressor function is also documented in the spleens of mice treated with single dose or fractionated doses of lethal whole body irradiation, followed by reconstitution with bone marrow cells obtained from normal mice. The data suggest that MLR suppressor cells, which are large, immature and predominantly radioresistant, can be induced after a short and well-tolerated TLI regimen.     

Bone marrow T cells. II. Thymic dependency

Mouse bone marrow contains cells capable of responding in vitro to the T cell mitogens PHA and Con A. These cellular responses are not demonstrable in the marrow of athymic nude mice (when compared with heterozygous littermates) and are depressed 47% in the marrow of neonatally thymectomized LAF₁ mice (when compared with sham-operated littermates). Therefore, the population of “bone marrow T cells” is thymus dependent.     

Inhibition of in vitro antibody synthesis by cyclophosphamide-induced suppressor cells

A population of suppressor lymphocytes appears in the spleens of mice 5 to 14 days after treatment with a high dose of cyclophosphamide (100–200 mg/kg body wt). Removal of carbonyl iron adherent cells or Ig^? cells from cyclophosphamide (CP)-treated spleen cells does not abolish suppressive activity. These suppressors are, however, sensitive to removal by treatment with anti-Thy-1.2 and rabbit complement. CP-treated spleen cells can suppress the in vitro primary response of normal spleen cells to the soluble hapten-protein conjugate DNP-MON or the particulate antigen HRBC when added at time of culture initiation or up to the second day of culture. CP-treated spleen cells can themselves respond in vitro to DNP-MON, as well as to HRBC, but with altered kinetics from that of normal spleen cells. Collectively, the data suggest that the CP-induced suppressors act late in the in vitro antibody response, possibly by prematurely shutting off antibody synthesis by B cells.     

Suppressor T cells and suppressor macrophages induced by Corynebacterium parvum

Corynebacterium parvum, injected intravenously into C57B1/6 mice (H-2^b) previously alloimmunized with P815 (H-2^d) mastocytoma cells, generated splenic suppressor cells that inhibited the development of primary cytotoxic lymphocytes in vitro. These suppressor cells differed from those generated by intravenous C. parvum injection of naive C57B1/6 mice. The former suppressor cells were effectively induced by administration of 700 μg of C. parvum whereas the latter suppressor cells were dependent upon higher doses (1400 μg) of adjuvant for their activation. Furthermore, suppressor cells generated in alloimmunized mice could only suppress C57B1/6 anti-P815 in vitro cytotoxic responses whereas suppressor cells generated in naive mice could suppress C57B1/6 anti-CBA (H-2^k) responses as well. Suppressor cells were not H-2 restricted in their action. Fractionation of spleens from alloimmunized, C. parvum-treated mice revealed the presence of suppressor T cells and suppressor macrophages. We were unable, however, to determine which cell was responsible for “antigen specificity” of suppression since the fractionation procedures seemed to trigger both suppressor cell types prior to adding them to the primary culture.     

In vitro sensitization to transplantation antigens. VII. Enhanced graft-vs-host activity of in vitro allosensitized lymphoid cells

We have previously demonstrated that C57BL/6J lymphoid cells sensitized in vitro to C3H/He transplantation antigens, present on macrophage monolayers, can transfer an accelerated C3H allograft response to recipient C57 mice. The present report indicates that C57 lymphoid cells sensitized to C3H alloantigens, present on macrophage monolayers, can also mediate a graft-versus-host (GVH) reaction in (C3H × C57) F₁ newborn mice. This GVH reaction is of greater magnitude than that produced by noncultured C57 cells. The magnitude of the augmented GVH reaction produced by cultured C57 cells is dependent on the source of lymphoid cells: lymph node, spleen, and bone marrow cells are consistently more active than cultured thymus cells—the reduced capability of cultured thymus cells to mediate the GVH reaction parallels their reduced ability to transfer allograft immunity. To test whether monolayers, other than macrophages, can sensitize lymphoid cells in vitro we incubated C57 lymphoid cells on C3H-derived L cells. Lymph node cells incubated with L cells demonstrate an increased GVH reaction in newborn mice. The in vitro sensitization of spleen and bone marrow cells on L cells is less consistent. Thymus cannot be sensitized by L cells. Monolayers of L cells are therefore not as efficient a sensitizing source as macrophages.     

Suppression of the polyclonal B-cell responses by concanavalin A-treated bone marrow B cells in vitro

A suppressor cell that inhibits the development of a polyclonal antibody response of splenic B cells to lipopolysaccharide is generated in the bone marrow cell culture in response to a mitotic dose (10 micrograms/ml) of concanavalin A (Con A). The Con A-responding suppressor cell is radioresistant and found in a bone marrow B (BM-B) cell population of normal as well as athymic mice. The suppressor activity of Con A-treated BM-B cells was consistently higher (P less than 0.01-0.0001) than those of untreated BM-B and fresh BM cells. The BM-B cell population recovered from short-term (3-day) cultures with Con A contained about 65% surface immunoglobulin (Ig)-positive cells, about 6% T cells, and less than 0.5% plastic-adherent cells, the latter two of which did not contribute to the suppressive activity. Thus, cytolytic treatment with various anti-T-cell antibodies could not eliminate the suppressive activity of the Con A-treated BM-B cells, and the Con A-treated macrophage population provided no significant suppression. The Con A-treated BM-B cells adherent to anti-Ig or anti-Con A dishes exhibited highly enriched suppressive activity. It was therefore concluded that an immature B-cell population of bone marrow could develop in response to stimulation with Con A into surface Ig-positive suppressor cells, contributing to the regulation of nonspecific B-cell responses.     

Differences in antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity against tumor cells in in vitro differentiating mononuclear phagocytes from bone marrows of normal and inflamed mice

Mononuclear phagocytes, differentiated in vitro from bone marrow cells of mice inflamed in vivo with either Corynebacterium parvum or thioglycollate, expressed a higher activity in antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against tumor cells, than those of normal mice. A good correlation between the cytolytic activity and chemiluminescence activity of the different mononuclear phagocyte populations was observed. The ADCC activity of BMDMP from normal mice was inhibited by exogenous prostaglandin E₂ (PGE₂) to a higher extent than that of BMDMP of inflamed mice. When the three BMDMP populations were cultured in the presence of aspirin (without exogenously added PGE₂), the ADCC was significantly increased. The three populations gave identical high values. This suggests that the differential ADCC activity of BMDMP from normal and inflamed mice is due to their differential response to endogenous prostaglandins. PGE₂ showed also a differential effect on the mononuclear phagocyte-forming capacity of bone marrow macrophage precursor cells from normal and inflamed mice. Bone marrow precursor cells from inflamed mice showed a higher resistance to the suppressive effect of PGE₂ (10^?5M) on mononuclear phagocyte-forming capacity than those of normal mice which were totally suppressed. It is concluded that the observed differential properties of the three bone marrow-derived mononuclear phagocyte populations originate at the level of bone marrow precursor cells and that, therefore, the similar functional differences observed in inflammation-induced peritoneal macrophage populations, observed by our and other groups, stem at least partly from differences at the level of bone marrow precursor cells.     

Accessory cell requirements for lymphoma growth in vitro and in irradiated mice.

Growth of the transplantable B-cell lymphoma, PU-5, is markedly diminished in γ-irradiated as compared to normal BALB/c mice. Transfer of bone marrow, but not of lymph node or peritoneal exudate cells, partially restored the ability of irradiated mice to support lymphoma growth. In vitro growth of PU-5 cells is promoted by silica-sensitive, adherent cells, bearing surface Ia antigen and present in peritoneal exudates, spleen and lymph node, but not in bone marrow. Their action on PU-5 growth can be shown only in rocking cultures; the cells do not have to be histocompatible, they act synergistically with 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) in the medium. The growth-promoting action in vitro is decreased 24 hr after γ-irradiation of the adherent cells in vitro. Growth of transplantable reticulum cell sarcoma in SJL/J mice has previously also been shown to be inhibited by prior irradiation of the host and to be restored by transfer of lymphoid cells including a phagocytic component, but in the present studies no consistent growth-promoting effect of accessory cells on reticulum cell sarcomas has been shown in vitro. Both lymphomas are stimulated by the presence of 2-ME in stationary cultures. The relationship between the in vivo and in vitro lymphoma growth-promoting activities of macrophage-like cells is discussed.     

Mouse fetal liver cells manifest antigen-specific suppressor activity

Liver cells obtained from C57B1/6J mice at different stages of development suppress the primary in vitro induced immune response. Fetal liver cells showed the strongest suppression of the PFC response, an effect which was gradually lost after birth. Thymic or splenic cells were ineffective in suppressing the PFC response under conditions where fetal liver cells from the same donors were highly active. Liver cells from newborn C57B1/6J athymic nude mice were equally suppressive as cells from their normal thymus-bearing littermates. Preculture of liver cells from 18-day-old fetuses with antigen homologous to that used in the indicator system increased suppressor activity severalfold compared with other experimental groups in which cells have been precultured in medium alone or with the addition of a heterologous antigen. The data suggest that antigen-specific suppressor activity is present in fetal liver cells. The possible relevance of these findings in relation to acquisition of self-tolerance is discussed.     

Properties of Immature Myeloid Progenitors with Nitric-Oxide-Dependent Immunosuppressive Activity Isolated from Bone Marrow of Tumor-Free Mice

Myeloid derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) from tumor-bearing mice are important negative regulators of anti-cancer immune responses, but the role for immature myeloid cells (IMCs) in non-tumor-bearing mice in the regulation of immune responses are poorly described. We studied the immune-suppressive activity of IMCs from the bone marrow (BM) of C57Bl/6 mice and the mechanism(s) by which they inhibit T–cell activation and proliferation. IMCs, isolated from BM by high-speed FACS, inhibited mitogen-induced proliferation of CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T-cells in vitro. Cell-to-cell contact of T-cells with viable IMCs was required for suppression. Neither neutralizing antibodies to TGFβ1, nor genetic disruption of indolamine 2,3-dioxygenase, abrogated IMC-mediated suppressive activity. In contrast, suppression of T-cell proliferation was absent in cultures containing IMCs from interferon-γ (IFN-γ) receptor KO mice or T-cells from IFN-γ KO mice (on the C57Bl/6 background). The addition of NO inhibitors to co-cultures of T-cells and IMC significantly reduced the suppressive activity of IMCs. IFN-γ signaling between T-cells and IMCs induced paracrine Nitric Oxide (NO) release in culture, and the degree of inhibition of T-cell proliferation was proportional to NO levels. The suppressive activity of IMCs from the bone marrow of tumor-free mice was comparable with MDSCs from BALB/c bearing mice 4T1 mammary tumors. These results indicate that IMCs have a role in regulating T-cell activation and proliferation in the BM microenvironment.     

Mixed lymphocyte reactivity in spleen cells from F-9 tumor-bearing mice. II. Functional cross-reactivity between F-9 cells and testicular cells

Previous serological analysis has revealed cross-reactive antigens on F-9 cells and mouse germ cells. Therefore, we investigated whether suppressor activity in spleen cells from F-9 tumor-bearing mice can be restimulated in vitro by adding F-9 cells or testicular cells to mixed lymphocyte cultures. We found equal potentiation of suppressor T-cell activity with F-9 cells and with syngeneic testicular cells; as shown by sensitivity to anti-Lyt 2.2 plus complement treatment. Suppressor activity of spleen cells from other tumor systems tested was not enhanced. The data suggest that the same or cross-reactive antigens on F-9 teratocarcinoma cells and testicular cells may have similar regulatory functions.     

Stimulation of hematopoiesis and bone marrow suppressor cells by the subcutaneous injection of linoleic acid

The effects of injection of linoleic acid into C57Bl/6 mice on hematopoietic and immunological parameters were examined. Administration of linoleic acid stimulated hematopoiesis as it increased spleen weight and cellularity, increased the number of bone marrow and splenic granulocytic-monocytic progenitor cells, and increased the colony stimulating factor activity in the serum of the treated mice. Associated with the hematopoietic stimulation in linoleic acid-treated mice was a decline in the spleen cell blastogenic responses and the appearance of bone marrow suppressor cells which were inhibitory to normal spleen cell blastogenesis. The linoleic acid-induced bone marrow suppressor cells resembled cells of the monocyte lineage in that they were sensitive to treatment with L-leucine methyl ester, partially sensitive to treatment with anti-Ia antibodies and complement, and their suppressor activity was minimized by indomethacin, a prostaglandin synthesis inhibitor. These results suggest that administration of linoleic acid results in hematopoietic stimulation and, concurrently, in the appearance of suppressor cells in the bone marrow. The bone marrow suppressor cells resemble immature cells of the monocyte lineage and appear to mediate their suppressive effects through the production of prostaglandins.