Interplasmidic illegitimate recombination in Bacillus subtilis

Summary The illegitimate recombination between Staphylococcus aureus plasmids pE194 (or pGG20, the hybrid between pE194 and Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322) and pBD17 (plasmid pUB110 without HpaII C-fragment) was studied in Bacillus subtilis. Cointegrates were generated with the frequency of 1–3x10^-8. Among 22 hybrids analysed 9 types of recombinants were found. Nucleotide sequences of all three parental plasmids were involved in intermolecular recombination. Nucleotide sequencing of recombinant DNA junctions revealed that in 8 cases recombination occurred between short homologous regions (9–15 bp). One recombinant was formed using nonhomologous sites. The similarity was demonstrated between nucleotide sequences of the recombination sites of two types of cointegrates and those used for pE194 integration into the B. subtilis chromosome. Possible mechanisms of illegitimate recombination are discussed.     

Interplasmid illegitimate recombination in Bacillus subtilis cells

The illegitimate recombination between S. aureus plasmids pE194 (or pGG20-the hybrid between pE194 and E. coli plasmid pBR322) and pBD17 (plasmid pUB110 without Hpa-II-C-fragment) in B. subtilis was studied. Plasmid cointegrates were generated with the frequency of 1-3.10(-8). Among the 22 hybrids analysed 9 types of recombinants were found. Nucleotide sequences of all the parental plasmids were involved in intermolecular recombination. Nucleotide sequencing of recombinant DNA junctions has revealed that in 8 cases recombination occurred between short homologous regions (9-15 b.p.). One of the recombinants resulted from nonhomologous recombination. The similarity between nucleotide sequences of recombination sites of two types of contegrates and those used for pE194 integration into the B. subtilis chromosome (Bashkirov et al. 1987) was demonstrated. Possible mechanisms of illegitimate recombination are discussed.     

Integration of various plasmids into the Bacillus subtilis chromosome

Some features of integration of temperature-sensitive pE194, pGG10 and pGG20 plasmids into the Bacillus subtilis chromosome were studied. Several auxotrophic mutations were obtained using insertion of these plasmids into the chromosome. The sites of plasmids for illegitimate recombination were determined. It was shown that the integration into the Bac. subtilis chromosome is characteristic not only for the plasmid pE194 but is the property of Staphylococcus aureus plasmid pC194 and Escherichia coli pBR322 plasmid. The influence of different Bac. subtilis rec mutations on the frequency of integration was studied.     

DNA amplification occurs between the core region of replicationori + of the ts plasmid integrated in the chromosome and its analog in the bacterial genome

Integrated in theBacillus subtilis chromosome, hybrid plasmid pGG10 is capable of thermosensitive amplification. One amplification site corresponds to the core region of replicationori ⁺ of pE194, a component of pGG10; the other is a homologous region of theB. subtilis chromosome. A model of illegitimate amplification mediated by pE194 RepF is proposed.     

Plasmid replication stimulates DNA recombination in Bacillus subtilis

The effects of plasmid replication on the frequency of homologous recombination have been investigated. For that purpose Bacillus subtilis strains that carry in their chromosome directly repeated DNA sequences, and an integrated copy of plasmid pE194 either proximal or distal to the repeats, were constructed. The repeat consists either of 3.9 X 10(3) base pBR322 sequences or 2.1 X 10(3) base B. subtilis chromosomal sequences. As plasmid pE194 is naturally thermosensitive for replication, the activity of the replicon could be regulated. Recombination between the repeated sequences was infrequent (about 10(-4) per generation) when the integrated plasmid did not replicate. It was 20 to 450 times higher when the plasmid was allowed to replicate, provided that the repeats were in the proximity of the plasmid. These results show that plasmid replication stimulates DNA recombination.     

Identification of plasmid and Bacillus subtilis chromosomal recombination sites used for pE194 integration.

The plasmid pE194 (3.7 kilobases) is capable of integrating into the genome of the bacterial host Bacillus subtilis in the absence of the major homology-dependent RecE recombination system. Multiple recombination sites have been identified on both the B. subtilis chromosome and pE194 (J. Hofemeister, M. Israeli-Reches, and D. Dubnau, Mol. Gen. Genet. 189:58-68, 1983). The B. subtilis chromosomal recombination sites were recovered by genetic cloning, and these sites were studied by nucleotide sequence analysis. Recombination had occurred between regions of short nucleotide homology (6 to 14 base pairs) as indicated by comparison of the plasmid and the host chromosome recombination sites with the crossover sites of the integration products. Recombination between the homologous sequences of the plasmid and the B. subtilis genome produced an integrated pE194 molecule which was bounded by direct repeats of the short homology. These results suggest a recombination model involving a conservative, reciprocal strand exchange between the two recombination sites. A preferred plasmid recombination site was found to occur within a 70-base-pair region which contains a GC-rich dyad symmetry element. Five of seven pE194-integrated strains analyzed had been produced by recombination at different locations within this 70-base-pair interval, located between positions 860 and 930 in pE194. On the basis of these data, mechanisms are discussed to explain the recombinational integration of pE194.     

Homologous recombination between plasmid and chromosomal DNA in Bacillus subtilis requires approximately 70 bp of homology

Summary To determine the minimal DNA sequence homology required for recombination in Bacillus subtilis, we developed a system capable of distinguishing between homologous and illegitimate recombination events during plasmid integration into the chromosome. In this system the recombination frequencies were measured between is pE194 derivatives carrying segments of the chromosomal -gluconase gene (bglS) of various lengths and the bacterial chromosome, using selection for erythromycin resistance at the non-permissive temperature. Homologous recombination events, resulting in disruption of the bglS gene, were easily detected by a colorimetric assay for -gluconase activity. A linear dependence of recombination frequency on homology length was observed over an interval of 77 bp. It was found that approximately 70 bp of homology is required for detectable homologous recombination. Homologous recombination was not detected when only 25 by of homology between plasmid and chromosome were provided. The data indicate that homology requirements for recombination in B. subtilis differ from those in Escherichia coli.     

Integration of repeated sequences (pBR322) in the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome without affecting the genome structure

The Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322 sequence (4363 bp) was integrated at the met, pro, or leuB locus of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome without duplication of the flanking chromosomal regions. The integrated pBR322 was stably maintained as part of the chromosome regardless of its orientation or location. It was found that a DNA segment as large as 17 kb cloned in pBR322 can be readily transferred to the B. subtilis chromosome by transformation. It was demonstrated that a second pBR322 sequence could be effectively introduced at different regions of the chromosome by sequential transformation using chromosomal DNA isolated from a strain that had already acquired a pBR322 sequence at a different locus. Similarly, a third pBR322 sequence could be introduced. By this method, two or three pBR322 sequences can be incorporated at unlinked loci without affecting the overall structure of the B. subtilis genome.     

A novel method for the rapid cloning in Escherichia coli of Bacillus subtilis chromosomal DNA adjacent to Tn917 insertions

Summary A rapid and general procedure has been devised for the pBR322-mediated cloning in Escherichia coli of Bacillus subtilis chromosomal DNA extending in a specified direction from any Tn917 insertion. Derivatives of Tn917 have been constructed that contain a pBR322-derived replicon, together with a chloramphenicol-resistance (Cm^r) gene of Gram-positive origin (selectable in B. subtilis), inserted by ligation in two orientations into a SalI restriction site located near the center of the transposon. When linearized plasmid DNA carrying such derivatives was used to transform to Cm^r B. subtilis bacteria already containing a chromosomal insertion of Tn917, the pBR322 sequences efficiently became integrated into the chromosomal copy of the transposon by homologous recombination. It was then possible to clone chromosomal sequences adjacent to either transposon insertion junction into E. coli, using a selection for ampicillin-resistance, by transforming CaCl₂-treated cells with small amounts of insert-containing DNA that had been digested with various restriction enzymes and then ligated at a dilute concentration. Because pBR322 sequences may be inserted by recombination in either orientation with respect to the transposon arms, a single restriction enzyme (such as EcoRi or SphI) that has a unique recognition site in pBR322 DNA may be used to separately clone chromosomal DNA extending in either direction from the site of any transposon insertion. A family of clones generated from the region of an insertional spo mutation (spoIIH::Tn917) was used in Southern hybridization experiments to verify that cloned material isolated with this procedure accurately reflected the arrangement of sequences present in the chromosome. Strategies are discussed for taking advantage of certain properties inherent in the structure of clones generated in this way to facilitate the identification and study of promoters of insertionally mutated genes.     

Expression in Escherichia coli of a staphylococcal gene for resistance to macrolide, lincosamide, and streptogramin type B antibiotics.

Plasmid pBD9, which comprises two plasmids from Staphylococcus aureus, pE194 and pUB110, was joined to plasmid pBR322 by in vitro recombination to form plasmid pKH80. The ermC gene of plasmid pE194 confers inducible resistance to macrolide, lincosamide, and streptogramin type B antibiotics. When pKH80 was transferred to Escherichia coli K-12, the bacteria became resistant to several of these antibodies.     

Generation of deletions through a cis-acting mutation in plasmid pC194

Summary When plasmid pC194-1 is ligated to pBR322 to generate plasmid pHV15-1, deletions occur with high frequency within the joined pBR322 DNA. Generation of deletions is recE4 independent, and occurs in B. subtilis with a 1,000-fold higher frequency than in Escherichia coli. In the hybrid plasmid pVH15-1, deletion end-points are not at random, but at defined locations within pBR322. We propose that the base alteration, characterizing pC194-1, has stabilized within the plasmid a stem/loop structure, which acts as a deletion generator.     

Construction of a recombinant plasmid composed of B. subtilis leucine genes and a B. subtilis (natto) plasmid: its use as cloning vehicle in B. subtilis 168.

Summary Recombinant plasmids composed of Bacillus subtilis 168 leucine genes and a B. subtilis (natto) plasmid have been constructed in a recombination deficient (recE4) mutant of Bacillus subtilis 168. The process involved EcoRI fragmentation and ligation of a B. subtilis (natto) plasmid and a composite plasmid RSF2124-B · leu in which B. subtilis 168 leucine genes are linked to the R-factor RSF2124. A constructed plasmid (pLS102) was found to be composed of an EcoRI fragment derived from the vector plasmid and two tandemly repeated EcoRI fragments carrying the leucine genes. A derivative plasmid (pLS101 or pLS103) consisting of one molecule each of the EcoRI fragments was obtained by in vivo intramolecular recombination between the repeated leucine gene fragments in pLS102. pLS103 was cleaved once with BamNI, SmaI and HpaI. Insertion of foreign DNA (Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322) into the BamNI site inactivated leuA but not the leuC function which thus can serve as selective marker if the plasmid is used as vector in molecular cloning. The penicillin resistance carried in pBR322 was not functionally expressed in B. subtilis cells. By partial digestion of pLS103 with HindIII followed by ligation with T4-induced ligase, pLS107 was obtained which contained only one EcoRI site. However, insertion of exogenous DNA (pBR322) into this EcoRI site inactivated both leuA and leuC functions.     

Integration of repeated sequences (pBR322) in the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome without affecting the genome structure

The Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322 sequence (4363 bp) was integrated at the met, pro, or leuB locus of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome without duplication of the flanking chromosomal regions. The integrated pBR322 was stably maintained as part of the chromosome regardless of its orientation or location. It was found that a DNA segment as large as 17 kb cloned in pBR322 can be readily transferred to the B. subtilis chromosome by transformation. It was demonstrated that a second pBR322 sequence could be effectively introduced at different regions of the chromosome by sequential transformation using chromosomal DNA isolated from a strain that had already acquired a pBR322 sequence at a different locus. Similarly, a third pBR322 sequence could be introduced. By this method, two or three pBR322 sequences can be incorporated at unlinked loci without affecting the overall structure of the B. subtilis genome.     

Nucleotide sequence and functional map of pC194, a plasmid that specifies inducible chloramphenicol resistance.

The nucleotide sequence of pC194, a small plasmid from Staphylococcus aureus which is capable of replication in Bacillus subtilis, has been determined. The genetic determinant of chloramphenicol (CAM) resistance, which includes the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) structural gene, the putative promoter and controlling element of this determinant, have been mapped functionally by subcloning a 1,035-nucleotide fragment which specifies the resistance phenotype using plasmid pBR322 as vector. Expression of CAM resistance is autogenously regulated since the 1,035-nucleotide fragment containing the CAT gene sequence and its promoter cloned into pBR322 expresses resistance inducibly in the Escherichia coli host. A presumed controlling element of CAT expression consists of a 37-nucleotide inverted complementary repeat sequence that is located between the -10 and ribosome-loading sequences of the CAT structural gene. Whereas the composite plasmid containing the minimal CAT determinant cloned in pBR322 could not replicate in B. subtilis, ability to replicate in B. subtilis was seen if the fragment cloned included an extension consisting of an additional 300 nucleotides beyond the 5' end of the single pC194 MspI site associated with replication. This 5' extension contained a 120-nucleotide inverted complementary repeat sequence similar to that found in pE194 TaqI fragment B which contains replication sequences of that plasmid. pC194 was found to contain four opening reading frames theoretically capable of coding for proteins with maximum molecular masses, as follows: A, 27,800 daltons; B, 26,200 daltons; C, 15,000 daltons; and D, 9,600 daltons. Interruption or deletion of either frame A or D does not entail loss of ability to replicate or to express CAM resistance, whereas frame B contains the CAT structural gene and frame C contains sequences associated with plasmid replication.     

Recombination between repeated DNA sequences occurs more often in plasmids than in the chromosome of Bacillus subtilis

Summary Directly repeated pBR322 sequences 3.7–3.8 kb long recombine with a frequency of about 10% per generation when carried on plasmids related to pC194 and 0.01% per generation when carried on the Bacillus subtilis chromosome. Recombination is therefore 1,000 times more efficient in plasmids than in the chromosome of this organism.     

Nucleotide sequence and functional map of pE194, a plasmid that specifies inducible resistance to macrolide, lincosamide, and streptogramin type B antibodies.

pE194 is a small plasmid (isolated originally in Staphylococcus aureus) which confers erythromycin-inducible resistance to macrolide, lincosamide, and streptogramin type B (MLS) antibiotics. The nucleotide sequence of pE194 contains 3,728 base pairs (bp), corresponding to a molecular mass of 2.4 million daltons. By means of site-specific cleavage with restriction endonucleases and cloning resultant fragments, determinants of the two major biological functions of p E194, i.e., inducible MLS resistance and replication, could be localized and assigned to specific sequences in the plasmid. Restriction endonuclease TaqI cut pE194 at three sites. TaqI fragment A (1,443 bp) contained the determinant for inducible MLS resistance, whereas TaqI fragment B (1,354 bp) contained a determinant necessary for plasmid replication. Regulatory mutations resulting in constitutive expression of MLS resistance mapped in TaqI fragment A, whereas a mutation associated with elevated plasmid copy number was mapped in TaqI fragment B. Also mapping in TaqI fragment B was a plasmid replication determinant comprising two sets of inverted complementary repeat sequences, one of which spanned 124 bp and was adjacent to a second smaller set which was rich in guanine and cytosine residues. pE194 contained six open reading frames which were theoretically capable of coding for proteins with maximum molecular masses as follows (in daltons): A, 48,300; B, 29,200; C, 14,000; D, 13,900; E, 12,600; and F, 2,700. Insertion of plasmid pBR322 into the single PstI site located in frame A of pE194 resulted in a composite plasmid which could replicate in both Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli, suggesting that an intact polypeptide A is dispensable for both replication of pE194 and for MLS resistance. Frame B specified inducible MLS resistance, whereas frame F specified the putative peptide associated with the proposed B determinant translational attenuator. The extent to which frames C, D, and E, all contained in TaqI fragment B, were translated into polypeptide products is not known; however, a base change in frame E was found in a comparison between the high-copy-number mutant, cop-6, and the wild-type strains.     

Sequence specificity of Bacillus subtilis DNA gyrase in vivo

Linearization of pBG0 (a hydrid between Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322 and Staphylococcus aureus plasmid pUB110) was performed by lysis of the oxolinic acid treated Bacillus subtilis protoplasts with sodium dodecyl sulfate. This plasmid DNA linearization was used both for a detailed mapping of DNA gyrase cleavage sites of various strength and for the nucleotide sequence determinations at the points of gyrase-mediated scission by introducing the XhoI linker DNA. A total of 40 plasmids carrying inserted XhoI linker were sequenced by labeling 3' termini of XhoI sites; 38 of them were found to contain a duplication of four base-pairs of the plasmid sequence flanking the linker, which were characteristic of the oxolinic acid-induced DNA cleavage by E. coli DNA gyrase in vitro and in vivo. The relative strength of these sequenced sites was established by comparing their positions to the sites mapped on the appropriate plasmid genome. This allowed us to propose a consensus sequence of B. subtilis DNA gyrase in vivo cleavage site:GNAT GATCATNC% MathType!MTEF!2!1!+-% feaafeart1ev1aaatCvAUfeBSjuyZL2yd9gzLbvyNv2CaerbuLwBLn% hiov2DGi1BTfMBaeXafv3ySLgzGmvETj2BSbqefm0B1jxALjhiov2D% aebbfv3ySLgzGueE0jxyaibaiiYdd9qrFfea0dXdf9vqai-hEir8Ve% ea0de9qq-hbrpepeea0db9q8as0-LqLs-Jirpepeea0-as0Fb9pgea% 0lrP0xe9Fve9Fve9qapdbaqaaeGacaGaaiaabeqaamaabaabcaGcba% GaaeikaiaabsfacaqGPaGaaeiiaiaabccacaqGGaGaaeiiaiaabcca% caqGOaGaae4raiaabMcacaqGGaGaaeiiaiaabccacaqGGaGaaeiiai% aabccacaqGGaGaaeiiaiaabccacaqGGaGaaeiiaiaabccacaqGGaGa% aeiiaiaabccacaqGOaGaaeyqaiaabMcaaaa!4E92!\[{\rm{(T) (G) (A)}}\]where N is any nucleotide. The bases in parentheses were preferred secondarily. The involvement of DNA gyrase in illegitimate recombination events in Bacillus subtilis is discussed.     

Site-specific and illegitimate recombination in the oriV1 region of the F factor. DNA sequences involved in recombination and resolution

We have defined some of the sequences involved in high frequency recA-independent recombination at the oriV1 region of the F factor. Using a mobilization assay, we determined that plasmid pMB080, a pBR322 derivative bearing the PvuII-BamHI (F factor co-ordinates 45.43 to 46.0) fragment from the oriV1 region of F, contained all sequences necessary to undergo efficient site-specific recombination with the F derivative pOX38, which retains the oriV1 region. We constructed a series of pMB080 deletions in vitro using exonucleases S1 and Bal31. Deletions removing a ten base-pair sequence, which forms part of an inverted repeat segment located 62 base-pairs to the left of the NcoI site (45.87) within the cloned fragment, totally eliminated the recA-independent recombination reaction. Other deletions differentially affected both the frequency and stability of cointegrate molecules formed by the site-specific recombination system. The F factor oriV1 region is involved also in low-frequency recombination with several sites on pBR322 and related plasmids. We have determined the precise location of these recombination sites within oriV1 by DNA sequencing. These studies revealed that recombination always took place within an eight base-pair spacer region between the ten base-pair inverted repeats found to be important for oriV1-oriV1 interactions. We propose that the low-efficiency recombination between pBR322 and pOX38 results from the ability of the F site-specific recombination apparatus to weakly recognize and interact with sequences that bear some resemblance to the normal oriV1 recognition elements. Furthermore, we suggest, by analogy with the lambda paradigm, that the nucleotide sequences at the junctions of secondary site recombinants define at least one crossover site used during the normal site-specific recombination process.     

Interference of plasmid pCM194 with lysogeny of bacteriophage SP02 in Bacillus subtilis.

Three observations indicated that the 2-megadalton chloramphenicol resistance plasmid pCM194 interferes with SP02 lysogeny of Bacillus subtilis. SP02 plaques formed on B. subtilis(pCM194) appeared almost clear, whereas plaques produced on plasmid-free or pUB110-containing cells contained large turbid centers. The number of phages spontaneously liberated by B. subtilis(SP02) was increased 10-fold or more when pCM194 was also present in the lysogens. Lastly, growth of B. subtilis(SP02, pCM194) for approximately 20 to 25 generations resulted in essentially complete loss of the prophage. This interference was not observed with pUB110 or pE194, and the pCM194 interference was not directed against B. subtilis temperate phage phi 105, which is unrelated to SP02. Lytic replication of SP02 appeared to be unaffected by pCM194. pCM194 interference with SP02 lysogeny was demonstrable in recombination-proficient strains and a recE mutant of B. subtilis. SP02 prophage which were noninducible due to the phage ind mutation were resistant to pCM194 interference. pCM194 interference was lost when the entire pCM194 molecule was joined at its unique HpaII site or at one of the two MboI sites to pUB110 or pUB110 derivatives. pBR322 joined to pCM194 at the same MboI site or at the HindIII site produced chimeras that retained the ability to interfere with SP02 lysogeny. A three-part plasmid constructed by joining pBR322 to pCM194 (at HindIII sites) and to pE194 (at PstI sites) was compatible with the SP02 prophage and showed a temperature-sensitive replication phenotype characteristic of the pE194 replicon. One explanation for the interference involves competition for a host component between an SP02 genome attempting to establish lysogeny and plasmids whose replication is directed by the pCM194 replicon.     

A bifunctional plasmid carrying the recA gene of E. coli

Summary To investigate the effect of an active, plasmid-carried recA gene on the stability and/or the expression of plasmid genes in different genetic backgrounds, we have constructed a bifunctional plasmid (able to replicate in Escherichia coli and in Bacillus subtilis). Chimeric plasmids were obtained by inserting pC194 (Ehrlich 1977) into pDR1453 (Sancar and Rupp 1979). pDR1453 is a 12.9 Kbp plasmid constructed by inserting an E. coli chromosome fragment carrying the recA gene into pBR322. The expected bifunctional recombinant (pMR22/1) (15.7 Kbp) was easily obtained but surprisingly the Cm resistance was expressed only at a very low level in E. coli (as compared, for example, to pHV14, pHV15). We attribute this effect to the presence of multiple recA genes in the cell. On the contrary, Cm^r E. coli transformants bear a recombinant plasmid (pMR22/n) containing tandemly repeated copies of pC194 in equilibrium with excised free pC194. Such amplification has never been observed in a Rec^- background and is therefore mediated by the recA genes. Growth of these clones in the absence of Cm causes the loss of the extra copies, yielding a plasmid with a single copy of pC194, indistingishable from pMR22/1. Interestingly, we have observed that deletions occur at high frequency in pC194, which drastically increase Cm^r in E. coli containing plasmids with a single copy of pC194. Two types of such deletions were detected: (a) large 1050 bp deletions covering about onethird of pC194 and (b) small 120–150 bp deletions (near the MspI site) in the region containing the replicative functions of pC194 (Horinouchi and Weisblum 1982). Both types of deletion render the recombinant plasmid unable to replicate in B. subtilis. pM22/1 replicates, although with a low copy-number, and is stable in B. subtilis wild type; the recA gene of E. coli does not complement any of the rec ^- mutations of B. subtilis. A strong instability, mainly of the E. coli and pBR322 sequences, was observed in many dna and rec mutants of B. subtilis yielding smaller plasmid with a much higher copy-number.