Fine needle cytology--is aspiration suction necessary? A study of 100 masses in various sites

One hundred consecutive superficial mass lesions in various body sites were sampled by both conventional fine needle aspiration (FNA) and by a fine needle without the application of syringe suction. The latter technique is based on the principle of capillarity and may be termed "fine needle capillary" (FNC) sampling. The two sampling techniques were compared using five objective parameters: (1) the amount of diagnostic cellular material present, (2) the retention of appropriate architecture and cellular arrangement, (3) the degree of cellular degeneration, (4) the cellular trauma and (5) the volume of obscuring background blood and clots. There was no statistically significant difference between the efficacies of the two sampling techniques for any of the parameters studied. FNA sampling was diagnostic in a greater number of cases than was FNC sampling, but this difference was not statistically significant at a level of P = .05. When FNC sampling was diagnostic, it more frequently produced superior-quality material; conventional FNA, although diagnostic in a greater number of cases, mostly produced adequate, rather than superior-quality, material. This trend was not, however, statistically significant at a level of P = .05. These findings differ from those of previous studies (which have shown overall superiority of FNC sampling over conventional FNA sampling) and suggest that the technique of fine needle sampling employed for cytodiagnosis can be left to the personal preference of the operator.     

Comparative study of fine needle aspiration and fine needle capillary sampling of thyroid lesions

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether fine needle capillary (FNC) sampling gives quantitatively and qualitatively superior cytologic material as compared to the conventional technique of fine needle aspiration (FNA) when performed by a single aspirator. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional diagnostic test evaluation study. FNA and FNC were performed by a single operator on 200 diffuse and nodular thyroid lesions. RESULTS: A statistically significant difference in favor of FNC was observed for the parameter amount of cellular material. For the rest of the parameters--background blood or clot, degree of cellular degeneration, degree of cellular trauma and retention of architecture--the average score favored FNC but was not statistically significant--i.e., smears prepared from FNC displayed cellular material that was more concentrated, less damaged and less likely to be obscured by blood. CONCLUSION: Although FNC sampling was diagnostic in a greater number of cases than FNA sampling, this study did not prove a clear superiority of FNC over FNA. Until greater experience shows clear sampling superiority of FNC alone, rather than performing only FNA in diffuse or nodular thyroid lesions, incorporating FNC into the second puncture will definitely improve the quality and quantity of material at the patient's first visit.     

Making Mock-FNA Smears from Fresh Surgical Pathology Specimens to Improve Smear Preparation Technique and to Create Cytohistological Correlation Series

Background

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology is a well-established diagnostic method based on the microscopic interpretation of often scant cytological material; therefore, experience, good technique and smear quality are equally important in obtaining satisfactory results.

Aims of Study

We studied the use of fresh surgical pathology specimens for making so-called mock-FNA smears with the potential of cytohistological correlation. Additionally, we studied how this process aids the improvement of preparation technique and smear quality.

Methods

Cytological aspirates from 32 fresh biopsy specimens from various sites: lung (20), lymph nodes (6), and breast (6) were obtained, all with a clinical diagnosis of tumor. Aspiration was performed from grossly palpable tumors. 25G needle and Cameco-type syringe holder was used with minimal or no suction.

Results

Unfixed surgical specimens provided sufficient cytological material that resulted in good quality smears. After standard processing of specimens into microscopic sections from paraffin embedded tissues, cytohistological case-series were created. No significant alteration was reported in tissue architecture on hematoxylin-eosin stained sections after the aspiration procedure. A gradual, but steady improvement was observed in smear quality just after a few preparations.

Discussions and Conclusions

Our study proved that surgical specimens may be used as a source of cytological material to create cytohistological correlation studies and also to improve FNA cytology skills. The use of very fine gauge needle (25G, 0,6 mm diameter) during the sampling process does not alter tissue architecture therefore the final histopathological diagnosis is not compromised. We conclude that by using fresh surgical specimens useful cytohistological collections can be created both as a teaching resource and as improving experience.     

Cytologic diagnosis by transthoracic fine needle sampling without aspiration

The cytologic findings of transthoracic fine needle sampling without aspiration (fine needle capillary [FNC] sampling) are reported. Eleven patients were examined by FNC sampling while four were examined by the classic fine needle aspiration (FNA) method. In contrast to FNA sampling, FNC sampling produced less patient trauma and admixture of the sample with blood, while giving a better perception of the tumor and its consistency. The quality of the samples obtained by the FNC technique was equal to that of the FNA samples. The results demonstrate that fine needle sampling without aspiration may be used in the study of deep-seated as well as of superficial organs.     

Testicular fine needle aspiration cytology in male infertility

OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of testicular fine needle aspiration and biopsy for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. STUDY DESIGN: A comparison of testicular fine needle aspiration and biopsy was performed on 34 infertile men over a 2-year period. RESULTS: Concordance of the 2 tests was evident in 88% of cases. In discordant cases fine needle aspiration yielded more than biopsy, considering the existence of secondary spermatocytes and spermatids. Charcot-Bottcher crystalloids were frequently seen in the cytoplasm of Sertoli cells in normal and abnormal spermatogenesis. CONCLUSION: Testicular fine needle aspiration is a simple and cost-effective method of evaluating testicular pathology in male factor infertility. It may yield more diagnostic and therapeutic material than does biopsy.     

Telediagnosis of transbronchial fine needle aspirations--a feasibility study.

AIM: To analyze the diagnostic accuracy of telediagnostic procedures for transbronchial fine needle aspirations. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A double blind study was performed on cytological slides of 54 randomly selected cases with transbronchial fine needle aspirations. The slides were digitized using a Leica digital camera DC100 mounted on a microscope Leica Laborlux S, and analyzed by an experienced pathologist without knowing the definite diagnosis or any additional clinical data. The diagnoses stated by analyzing the digital images were compared to the final conventional diagnoses. In addition, the duration of the digital diagnosis, used magnifications, and difficulties for correct sampling were documented. RESULTS: The "digital" diagnoses of the 54 cases were all in general agreement with the definite diagnoses. No wrong positive or wrong negative case in respect to malignant/non-malignant (31/23) or to small cell/non-small cell (9/22) occurred. The performance of a digital diagnosis lasted for 115 s at average (15-260 s), and is significantly longer compared to that of conventional fine needle aspiration judgement (20 s). The screening magnification was commonly set to x2.5, that for definite diagnostic analysis x40. Benign diseases (2 tuberculosis and 3 sarcoidosis cases) were correctly classified. CONCLUSIONS: Telepathology systems can probably be used for fine needle aspiration analysis without major diagnostic errors. Their use can improve the endoscopic sampling and avoid second anesthesia when missing the lesion of request during the first examination.     

Randomized study comparing endoscopic ultrasound-guided Trucut biopsy and fine needle aspiration with high suction

H. Gerke, M. K. Rizk, A. D. Vanderheyden and C. S. Jensen
Randomized study comparing endoscopic ultrasound-guided Trucut biopsy and fine needle aspiration with high suction
Objectives:  Endoscopic ultrasound (EUS)-guided Trucut biopsy (TCB) enables acquisition of tissue cores for histological assessment. Because of the rigid needle and the spring mechanism, tissue acquisition can be difficult from regions that require sharp angulation of the echoendoscope. Fine needle aspiration with high suction (FNAHS) has been proposed as a method to obtain histological tissue cores while affording the flexibility to obtain specimens even with extreme endoscope angulation. The objective was to compare prospectively these two methods in their ability to obtain specimens for histological assessment and in their diagnostic accuracy, including cytological diagnosis when achieved.
Methods:  Eighty lesions in 77 patients were amenable to transoesophageal, transgastric or transrectal biopsy and were randomized to TCB ( n  = 44) or FNAHS ( n  = 36). Each specimen was assessed for adequacy (scoring system where a score of 0 was no material, 1–2 was considered cytological, and 3–5 was considered histological). Follow-up information was obtained to establish a gold standard final diagnosis.
Results:  The median histological scores for FNAHS and TCB were 2 and 5, respectively. Histological cores were obtained in 95.3% of TCB, as opposed to 27.8% in the FNAHS group ( P  < 0.0001). Although the diagnostic accuracy for TCB was greater than that for FNAHS (88.3% and 77.8%, respectively), this was not statistically significant ( P  = 0.24).
Conclusion:  If histological information is required, TCB is superior to FNAHS. The difference in diagnostic accuracy did not reach statistical significance due to low numbers and the fact that FNAHS often enabled a cytological diagnosis.     

Cotton block method: one-step method of cell block preparation after fine needle aspiration

OBJECTIVE: To describe the cotton block method, an easy, inexpensive, 1-step method of obtaining a cell block after fine needle aspiration biopsy. STUDY DESIGN: Before connection to a 10-mL syringe, the plastic hub of a 22-23-gauge needle is filled with the 3-4-mm, woolly tip of a cotton bud. Aspiration is performed as described elsewhere. After smear preparation, the material remaining in the needle and the material retained in the cotton wool mesh are immediately fixed by aspiration ofa fixative fluid (70% alcoholic formaldehyde-acetic acid). After fixation, the cotton tip is removed and routinely processed for paraffin embedding, and the sections are stained by routine methods used in cytopathology. RESULTS: The results demonstrate that the amount and quality of material obtained in the cotton wool tip is similar to that in the traditional cell block obtained from the pellet after centrifugation of aspirated fluid. CONCLUSION: The method is easy to perform and cost effective and is a rapid way to prepare cell blocks of high quality, allowing special staining techniques and improving cytohistologic correlation.     

Histologic analysis and comparison of techniques in fine needle aspiration-induced alterations in thyroid

OBJECTIVE: To assess histologic alterations following fine needle aspiration (FNA) of the thyroid and differentiate these from ominous lesions, such as papillary carcinoma thyroid, as well as assess and compare the degree of tissue trauma from the techniques: needle only vs. needle with syringe, size of needle and number of aspirations. STUDY DESIGN: Thyroidectomy specimens of 100 cases with prior FNA biopsy were selected. The changes called "worrisome histologic alteration following fine needle aspiration of the thyroid" (WHAFFT) were studied. Number of FNAs, needle size and technique were tabulated for 73 of 100 cases. RESULTS: Worrisome changes were confined to areas near the needle tract and hence could be differentiated from ominous lesions. Control cases did not show WHAFFT lesions. Non-aspiration FNA cytology (FNAC) technique results in fewer, less frequent WHAFFT changes. The increasing number of FNAs leads to statistically significant increase in infarction, necrosis and vascular changes. A gradation in the WHAFFT changes, directly proportional to the increasing diameter of the needle, was observed. CONCLUSION: The pathologist should be aware of WHAFFT to avoid misinterpretation. The technique of non-aspiration FNAC is significantly less traumatic. An increase in FNAs or size of needle results in more severe WHAFFT changes.     

A new specially designed needle significantly increases sample yield during fine needle aspiration of breast lesions

A large and increasing number of women in the western world will at some point during their life be investigated morphologically for breast cancer. Fine needle aspiration (FNA) is one morphological method which is considered to be the fastest, cheapest and the most patient-friendly approach. Nevertheless, the technique has not gained major clinical success outside of Scandinavia, mainly because of a high frequency of insufficient samples. With this in mind it is quite peculiar that standard needles which are mainly configured for blood sampling and infusion therapy, comprising large quantities of residual spaces, are used. In this study we have developed and tested a new needle dedicated for FNA, which is intended to abate this drawback by increasing the sampling yield by changing the tip angle, the cannula wall-thickness and the storage compartment. In total, 499 consecutive aspiration procedures of palpable breast lesions were performed to compare the new needle (outer diameter 0.6 mm) with standard needles (outer diameters 0.6 mm and 0.7 mm). The new needle provided three times more material than did standard needles of the same diameter. Surprisingly, the new needle also provided more material than the standard 0.7 mm needle, which increased up to almost twice the material in cases with no material in the syringe. The frequency of tests with sparse harvested material (<4 mg) was less with the new needle (9%) compared to its standard counterpart (35%). The presented results were obtained by a very skilled sampling operator. Thus for the average sampling operator who probably obtains more samples in the spare range, the new dedicated FNA needle should have even more added value.     

Aspiration cytology of the conjunctival surface

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate a method of obtaining conjunctival cells that utilizes aspiration of the conjunctival surface. STUDY DESIGN: Eighteen eyes from 16 patients with epibulbar lesions underwent aspiration of the conjunctival surface using a tuberculin syringe without a needle. The aspirated cells were prepared by the cytocentrifuge or Millipore filter technique. The lesions were subsequently biopsied, and the cytologic and histologic diagnoses were compared. RESULTS: Diagnoses of the conjunctival lesions, in decreasing order of frequency, were conjunctival intraepithelial neoplasia (dysplasia, carcinoma in situ), squamous cell carcinoma, squamous metaplasia, nevus, lymphoma and inflammation. In this feasibility study, the cytologic diagnosis accurately correlated with the histologic diagnosis in most cases. There were two cases in which the cytologic diagnosis led to the correct histologic diagnosis. CONCLUSION: Aspiration cytology of the conjunctival surface is useful in obtaining diagnostic material and may be used as a guide to where a biopsy should be performed. Limitations include inadequate samples and lack of observer experience.     

Evaluation of fine needle aspiration vs. fine needle capillary sampling on specimen quality and diagnostic accuracy in endoscopic ultrasound-guided biopsy

OBJECTIVE: To compare percutaneous and endoscopic ultrasound (EUS)-guided biopsy techniques. Study DESIGN: From July 2005 to February 2006, all patients referred for EUS-guided fine needle aspiration (FNA) were considered. If inclusion criteria were met, the first 2 biopsy passes were performed without suction (fine needle capillary [FNC] sampling). Two additional passes were performed using the same needle with 10 mL of applied suction (FNA). A single blinded pathologist later retrospectively evaluated each set of slides. Fifty-three patients met inclusion criteria. The study group comprised pancreatic masses (23), lymph nodes (26), subepithelial masses (3) and liver lesion (1). There were 38 malignant and 15 benign lesions. RESULTS: No statistically significant differences were found with the scoring systems considered in the study. In the subgroups of patients with pancreatic masses, lymph nodes, benign disease and malignant disease, no statistically significant outcomes were noted. CONCLUSIONS: No difference exists between quality and diagnostic accuracy of specimens obtained from EUS-guided tissue acquisition via FNC and FNA. The decision to use FNC or FNA should be left to the discretion of the individual endosonographer.     

Comparison of Fine Needle Sampling By Capillary Action and Fine Needle Aspiration

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) and non-suction fine needle sampling (FNS) were performed consecutively in 107 lesions from 100 patients. the quality of diagnostic material was assessed using a scoring system based on the cellularity and amount of blood in the smear. the total score in the FNS group was significantly higher (P < 0.05) than that of FNA technique. the FNS procedure is less traumatic and equally cost effective and can be safely undertaken in liver, orbital and thyroid lesions. In lymph nodes, especially in children, FNS gives an excellent cellular yield. However, this procedure can not be advocated in cystic, bony and fibrous lesions.     

Lymph node examination by fine needle aspiration in patients with known or suspected malignancy

In a series of more than 2,500 fine needle aspirates from multiple body sites, over 200 were clinically identified as lymph nodes from patients with known or suspected malignancy. The material was obtained using the easily manipulated Aspir-Gun with a 21-gauge or 22-gauge needle and syringe. Of the 200 lymph node specimens, 100 (50%) were cytologically reported as positive for malignancy. Ninety cases had surgical pathology specimens available for comparison with the fine needle aspiration (FNA) specimens. For the 88 of these cases with satisfactory FNA specimens, evaluation of the FNA results showed a predictive value of a positive result of 96.8%. These results compare favorably with those of surgical biopsy. The malignancies present in the lymph nodes included numerous adenocarcinomas from the breast, melanoma and pulmonary small-cell carcinoma. Six cases are briefly presented in which the FNA diagnosis was more problematic. While histologic examination of tissues or organs remains the desirable benchmark of comparison, the appropriate utilization of FNA cytology to guide therapy, particularly in a patient with previously diagnosed malignancy, may obviate the need for an open biopsy. The technique is convenient for patient and physician, useful for outpatients, relatively painless and provides good correlation between cytologic morphology and histopathology.     

Pulmonary hamartomas: cytologic appearances of fine needle aspiration biopsy.

The cytologic findings in specimens obtained from pulmonary hamartomas by fine needle aspiration biopsy are presented. The following are the main characteristics: 1. In spite of the fact that the lesions are usually hard and cartilaginous, find needle aspiration is possible and can obtain diagnostic material. 2. The material obtained usually has few cells. 3. The cells aspirated include columnar ciliated cells, lymphocytes, histiocytes as well as fragments of cartilage which are quite characteristic. 4. The differential diagnosis is discussed.     

Extramedullary plasmacytoma, a report of five cases diagnosed by FNAC

Objective:  To review cytological findings and diagnostic challenges in the use of fine needle aspiration in the diagnosis of extramedullary plasmacytoma.
Methods:  Five cases of extramedullary plasmacytoma that were initially diagnosed on fine needle aspiration cytology over a period of two years in Sir Ganga Ram Hospital were reviewed.
Results:  The cytological findings were similar in all five cases. The smears were cellular and composed of plasmacytoid cells arranged singly and in clusters, with varying pleomorphism, bi- and multinucleation and mitotic figures. Presence of anaplasia, increased plasmablasts, numerous naked nuclei and unusual location of the tumour were some of the challenges faced during the cytological evaluation.
Conclusions:  Extramedullary plasmacytoma may occur either as an initial presentation or as a secondary involvement by multiple myeloma. Fine needle aspiration is a reliable technique for its rapid diagnosis.     

Fine needle capillary sampling of eyelid masses. A study of 70 cases

OBJECTIVE: To study the cytomorphology of eyelid tumors, correlate it with histopathology and determine the diagnostic accuracy of fine needle capillary (FNC) sampling (nonaspiration) in the evaluation of lid tumors. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective study of 70 cases of eyelid masses carried out using FNC, with confirmation by histology in 66 cases and peripheral blood smear and bone marrow examination in 3. Histology was not done in 1 case, and 11 cases were inadequate on cytology. The diagnostic accuracy of cytology was 94.73%, and false negativity was 5.17%. RESULTS: The ages of the patients ranged from 3 to 75 years, with a mean of 40.4. The male/female ratio was nearly equal (37:33). The upper eyelid was affected in 45 cases and lower lid in 25 cases. The right eye was affected in 35 cases, left eye in 34 cases and both eyes in 1 case. Fifteen benign, 35 malignant and 9 infectious/inflammatory lesions were encountered, with 11 inadequate smears. CONCLUSION: FNC sampling is an effective method of sampling eyelid tumors because it causes little discomfort to the patient and allows the operator to maintain better control over the procedure. A distinction between inflammatory, benign and malignant lesions and between the types of malignant tumors can be made.     

Liquid-based vs. conventional smears in fine needle aspiration of bone and soft tissue tumors

OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology of bone and soft tissue tumors utilizing ThinPrep (TP) (Cytyc Corporation, Boxborough, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) vs. conventional smears (CS). STUDY DESIGN: Fine needle aspiration cytology from bone and soft tissue tumors was processed and assessed for cellularity, nuclear and cytoplasmic preservation, cellular architecture and stromal background with both the TP liquid-based smear technique and conventional methods. RESULTS: An accurate diagnosis was made in 13% of TP cases as compared to 64% in CS cases. CONCLUSION: CS of fine needle aspiration sample is far superior to TP in diagnosing tumors of bone and soft tissues. Preservation of cytoplasmic features and cellular architecture was superior in conventionally prepared smears.     

Comparative validation of c-kit exon 11 mutation analysis on cytology samples and corresponding surgical resections of gastrointestinal stromal tumours

Objective:  Studies have shown that c-kit mutation analysis of gastrointestinal stromal tumours (GISTs) obtained by endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration (EUS-FNA) can be routinely performed. We validated c-kit exon 11 mutational analysis on cell block material obtained from fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) for diagnostic purposes and compared it with the same analysis in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded full sections of the corresponding resection specimens.
Methods:  c-kit mutation analysis was done on cell block material obtained from ten cases encountered in our department from 1999 to 2008 on which FNAC was attempted pre-operatively. The findings were compared with analysis on full paraffin section of the corresponding resected tumours in seven cases where patients opted for resection. c-kit exon 11 was examined via bidirectional nucleic acid sequencing.
Results:  Our results showed 100% concordance for the presence and type of exon 11 mutation in the resected and aspirated tumours in all seven cases. These mutations had diagnostic value when compared with other neoplasms that are part of the cytomorphological differential diagnosis, such as leiomyosarcoma or gastric adenocarcinomas.
Conclusion:  Molecular cytopathology is a powerful tool that can complement morphology and immunohistochemical assessment of cytological material in routine practice for the diagnosis and prognostication of GISTs. We briefly discuss the advantages and limitations of the fine needle method of obtaining tissue for the diagnosis and prognostication of GISTs, and its current therapeutic strategies.     

Transcutaneous fine needle aspiration biopsy of the preepiglottic space

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate transcutaneous fine needle aspiration biopsy of the preepiglottic space for staging supraglottic squamous cell carcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: We studied 28 patients who underwent total or horizontal supraglottic laryngectomy as their main therapy modality due to supraglottic squamous cell carcinoma, followed in some cases by adjuvant radiation therapy. All the patients underwent transcutaneous fine needle aspiration. RESULTS: The cytopathologic examination of the material obtained by aspiration was compared to the histopathologic analysis of the laryngectomy specimens; the efficiency was 96.4%. The method did not cause any morbidity. CONCLUSION: Transcutaneous fine needle aspiration biopsy of the preepiglottic space is useful for preepiglottic space evaluation, with a high correlation with histopathologic results and no morbidity.