Chromatin Accessibility Data Sets Show Bias Due to Sequence Specificity of the DNase I Enzyme

Background

DNase I is an enzyme which cuts duplex DNA at a rate that depends strongly upon its chromatin environment. In combination with high-throughput sequencing (HTS) technology, it can be used to infer genome-wide landscapes of open chromatin regions. Using this technology, systematic identification of hundreds of thousands of DNase I hypersensitive sites (DHS) per cell type has been possible, and this in turn has helped to precisely delineate genomic regulatory compartments. However, to date there has been relatively little investigation into possible biases affecting this data.

Results

We report a significant degree of sequence preference spanning sites cut by DNase I in a number of published data sets. The two major protocols in current use each show a different pattern, but for a given protocol the pattern of sequence specificity seems to be quite consistent. The patterns are substantially different from biases seen in other types of HTS data sets, and in some cases the most constrained position lies outside the sequenced fragment, implying that this constraint must relate to the digestion process rather than events occurring during library preparation or sequencing.

Conclusions

DNase I is a sequence-specific enzyme, with a specificity that may depend on experimental conditions. This sequence specificity is not taken into account by existing pipelines for identifying open chromatin regions. Care must be taken when interpreting DNase I results, especially when looking at the precise locations of the reads. Future studies may be able to improve the sensitivity and precision of chromatin state measurement by compensating for sequence bias.     

Analysis of Chromatin Structure in the Control Regions of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Chlamydomonas HSP70A</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">RBCS2</Emphasis> Genes

We have used DNaseI and micrococcal nuclease sensitivity assays to determine the chromatin structures in the control regions of the Chlamydomonas reinhardtii HSP70A and RBCS2 genes. Both genes appear to be organized into nucleosome arrays, which exhibit shorter nucleosome repeat lengths than bulk chromatin. In HSP70A we have identified up to four confined DNaseI hypersensitive sites, three of them localize to the promoter region, a fourth one to the fourth intron. Three hypersensitive sites map close to putative heat shock elements, one close to a CCAAT-box. All hypersensitive sites are located to internucleosomal linkers. Alternative nucleosome positions at half-nucleosomal phasing were constitutively detected in the HSP70A promoter region, indicating local chromatin remodelling. Upon heat shock, dramatic changes in the nucleosome structure of HSP70A were detected that particularly affected the promoter, but also a region within the fourth intron. In contrast, light induction entailed no change in HSP70A chromatin. In the RBCS2 control region we identified a strong DNaseI hypersensitive site that maps close to a CCAAT-box. This site forms the boundary of a nucleosome array with a region of ~700 bp apparently devoid of nucleosomes. This study demonstrates that chromatin structure may be determined readily at fairly high resolution in Chlamydomonas, suggesting this organism as a well-suited model for studying the role of chromatin structure on gene expression in photosynthetic eukaryotes.     

A simple and efficient procedure for isolating plant chromatin which is suitable for studies of DNase I-sensitive domains and hypersensitive sites

Summary A simple and rapid procedure has been developed for the isolation of chromatin from plant leaves. The molecular weight of the DNA extracted from these chromatin preparations is comparable to that of DNA isolated by a conventional purification procedure (CTAB-CsCl-method). These results suggest that almost no degradation occurs during the isolation procedure. The effect of DNase I on three different groups of genes was studied; one of them, encoding the NADPH-protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (PCR), represents a gene which is actively transcribed in etiolated leaf tissue. The other genes examined encode the hordein seed storage protein and 26S ribosomal RNA. The hordein genes are known to be inactive in leaves.The hordein and rDNA genes were found to be resistant to low levels of DNase I, while the gene for the PCR was highly sensitive to DNase I. During the course of digestion of the PCR gene, discrete cleavage products are generated. These indicate the presence of DNase I hypersensitive sites in the vicinity of the PCR gene in etiolated leaves. As a control naked DNA has been digested with DNase I. No differences in sensitivity between the PCR gene and the hordein genes can be detected.     

Chromatin structure of a 3-methylcholanthrene-induced cytochrome P-450 gene

Plasmids carrying fragments of a cytochrome P-450 gene, inducible by 3-methylcholanthrene, were used to study the chromatin structure of this gene in the liver of normal and carcinogen-treated rats. Digestion with micrococcal nuclease revealed that the gene is not present in the typical 200 base pair nucleosomal structure. By use of indirect end-label hybridization, four DNase I hypersensitive sites were mapped in the 5'-terminal region of the gene. An S1 nuclease sensitive site is located close to a DNase I site. Gene induction by treatment with 3-methylcholanthrene does not result in detectable changes in the DNase I hypersensitive sites. Rat thymus chromatin does not contain DNase I hypersensitive sites in the P-450 gene, suggesting that in the liver the chromatin structure is altered so as to allow tissue-specific expression of the gene. This paper is the first study on the chromatin structure of a gene coding for a member of the cytochrome P-450 family of enzymes. The implications of our results to the understanding of gene regulation of the P-450 genes are discussed.     

Multiple interactions between nuclear proteins of Zea mays and the promoter of the Shrunken gene

Summary Nuclear proteins were extracted from isolated nuclei of immature maize kernels. The promoter region (1.5 kb) of the Shrunken gene, which is highly transcribed in the developing endosperm of the kernel, was scanned for protein-DNA interactions. Several promoter fragments showed protein-DNA complex formation in gel retardation experiments. Two different nucleo-protein complexes (MNP1 and MNP2) have been distinguished in competition and DNase I footprinting experiments. Both nuclear DNA-binding activities are able to recognize multiple sites distributed over a 1.5 kb upstream region of the Shrunken gene. Some of the binding sites established in the in vitro reconstitution experiments are located near to DNase I hypersensitive sites found in the promoter of the Shrunken gene (Frommer and Starlinger 1988).     

Organization of the GAL1-GAL10 intergenic control region chromatin.

A defined, "far upstream" promoter element, the Upstream Activator Sequence (UAS), which mediates the galactose dependent induction of expression of the GAL10 gene in yeast, is the locus of an anomalous, mainly expression independent chromatin structure. The UAS chromatin shows three symmetrical DNase I hypersensitive sites in brief digests, a loss of the 10 bp DNase I ladder pattern in more extensive digests and an enhanced staphylococcal nuclease sensitivity. This anomalous structure is confined to a small region of the UAS. The surrounding chromatin, including the TATA box regions shows a more typical, but expression dependent nucleoprotein, probably nucleosomal, organization. Such an arrangement may be a common feature of eukaryotic genes.     

Tissue-specific and light-dependent changes of chromatin organization in barley (Hordeum vulgare)

The DNase I sensitivity of the nuclear genes encoding the NADPH-protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase, the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein (LHCP), the hordeins and a 15-kDa protein of unknown function was assayed in chromatin of etiolated and green leaves and endosperm tissue of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.). A tissue-specific differentiation of chromatin structure was found for the LHCP, hordein and 15-kDa protein genes. The genes for the LHCP and the 15-kDa protein, which are expressed in leaf tissue, display DNase I sensitivity in leaves but not in endosperm. Hordein genes which are expressed solely in endosperm, were insensitive to low levels of digestion with DNase I in leaves but sensitive in endosperm. The effect of light on chromatin structure was determined by comparing leaves of etiolated plants and plants which had been grown under a day/night cycle. Only in the case of the 15-kDa protein is there a remarkable change from a DNAse-I-sensitive configuration in etiolated leaves to a more resistant one in leaves from illuminated plants. The gene for the NADPH-protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase was found to be equally sensitive to DNase I in leaves and endosperm.     

Constitutive and light-induced DNAseI hypersensitive sites in the rbcS genes of pea (Pisum sativum)

The chromatin structure of pea (Pisum sativum) rbcS genes in inactive (root), potentially active (dark-grown leaf), and active states (light-grown leaf) was analysed using (a) pancreatic DNAseI to detect general DNAseI sensitivity and DNAseI-hypersensitive sites, and (b) methyl-sensitive restriction endonucleases to probe for cytosine methylation within the promoter region. We showed that within the same organ individual members of the pea rbcS multigene family are differentially sensitive to DNAseI suggesting differential protection in nuclei. During light activation general DNAseI sensitivity increases in some genes, especially their 5 upstream regulatory sequences. DNAseI-hypersensitive sites are constitutively present in 5 upstream regulatory sequences around positions –335, –465, –650, and –945 (5 constitutive domain) and in the coding region around position +340, +450, +530, +640, and +810 (3 constitutive domain). One additional hypersensitive site appears after light induction (inducible site). This region is centred around position –190 and flanked by light-responsive elements (LREs). In spite of changes in the chromatin structure of rbcS genes during their transition from an inactive to an active state, their cytosine methylation at Alu I, Fnu 4HI, Hae III, Sau 3AI and Sau 96I sites in the promoter region remains uniform.