Insights into the quality of DnaA boxes and their cooperativity

Plasmids carrying the mioC promoter region with its two DnaA boxes are as efficient in titration of DnaA protein as plasmids carrying a replication-inactivated oriC region with its five DnaA boxes. The two DnaA boxes upstream of the mioC promoter were mutated in various ways to study the cooperativity between the DnaA boxes, and to study in vivo the in vitro-defined 9mer DnaA box consensus sequence (TT(A)/(T)TNCACA). The quality and cooperativity of the DnaA boxes were determined in two complementary ways: as titration of DnaA protein leading to derepression of the dnaA promoter, and as repression of the mioC promoter caused by the DnaA protein binding to the DnaA boxes. Titration of DnaA protein correlated with repression of the mioC promoter. The level of titration and repression with the normal promoter-proximal box (TTTTCCACA) depends strongly on the presence and the quality of a DnaA box in the promoter-distal position, whereas a promoter-proximal DnaA box with the sequence TTATCCACA titrated DnaA protein and caused significant repression of the mioC promoter without a promoter-distal DnaA box. The quality of the eight different consensus DnaA boxes located in the promoter-proximal position was determined: TTATCCACA had the highest affinity for DnaA protein. In the third position, A was better than T, and the four possibilities in the fifth position could be ranked as C >A >or=G >T. Parallel in vitro experiments using a purified DNA-binding domain of DnaA protein gave the same ranking of the binding affinities of the eight DnaA boxes.     

DnaA protein binding to individual DnaA boxes in the Escherichia coli replication origin, oriC.

The formation of nucleoprotein complexes between the Escherichia coli initiator protein DnaA and the replication origin oriC was analysed in vitro by band-shift assays and electron microscopy. DnaA protein binds equally well to linear and supercoiled oriC substrates as revealed by analysis of the binding preference to individual DnaA boxes (9-mer repeats) in oriC, and by a competition band-shift assay. DnaA box R4 (oriC positions 260-268) binds DnaA preferentially and in the oriC context with higher affinity than expected from its binding constant. This effect depends on oriC positions 249 to 274, is enhanced by the wild-type sequence in the DnaA box R3 region, but is not dependent on Dam methylation or the curved DNA segment to the right of oriC. DnaA binds randomly to the DnaA boxes R1, M, R2 and R3 in oriC with no apparent cooperativity: the binding preference of DnaA to these sites was not altered for templates with mutated DnaA box R4. In the oriC context, DnaA box R1 binds DnaA with lower affinity than expected from its binding constant, i.e. the affinity is reduced to approximately that of DnaA box R2. Higher protein concentrations were required to observe binding to DnaA box M, making this low-affinity site a novel candidate for a regulatory dnaA box.     

Structural basis of replication origin recognition by the DnaA protein

Escherichia coli DnaA binds to 9 bp sequences (DnaA boxes) in the replication origin, oriC, to form a complex initiating chromosomal DNA replication. In the present study, we determined the crystal structure of its DNA-binding domain (domain IV) complexed with a DnaA box at 2.1 Å resolution. DnaA domain IV contains a helix–turn–helix motif for DNA binding. One helix and a loop of the helix– turn–helix motif are inserted into the major groove and 5 bp (3′ two-thirds of the DnaA box sequence) are recognized through base-specific hydrogen bonds and van der Waals contacts with the C5-methyl groups of thymines. In the minor groove, Arg399, located in the loop adjacent to the motif, recognizes three more base pairs (5′ one-third of the DnaA box sequence) by base-specific hydrogen bonds. DNA bending by ~28° was also observed in the complex. These base-specific interactions explain how DnaA exhibits higher affinity for the strong DnaA boxes (R1, R2 and R4) than the weak DnaA boxes (R3 and M) in the replication origin.     

Probing the structure of gal operator-repressor complexes. Conformation change in DNA

The gal operon is regulated by binding of Gal repressor to two operator loci, OE and OI, which are separated by 114 base pairs (bp). We have probed the actual operator DNA segments with and without Gal repressor occupation by characterizing the regions protected by repressor from DNase I digestion and dimethyl sulfate methylation. The segments which are protected from DNase I digestion in both OE and OI are about 22 bp long and seem to include 2-3 extra bp on either side of a 16-bp similar sequence containing an approximate dyad symmetry, with a consensus half-symmetry sequence GTG(G/T)AA-C. Repressor occupation hinders the reactivity of the consensus guanines in the four half-symmetry sequences, as shown by retardation of methylation at the N-7 positions by dimethyl sulfate owing to repressor binding. The protected guanines are symmetrically located. Since a dimeric Gal repressor affects symmetrically located bases, it is consistent with the notion that each half-operator is occupied by a repressor subunit. Because the N-7 positions of methylation of guanines lie in the major grooves and the protected guanines are located at positions 1, 3, 8 and the rotational 1', 3', and 8' in the 16-bp dyad symmetry, we suggest that Gal repressor establishes direct contacts with bases at 1, 3, 1', and 3' through two major grooves lying on one face of an operator helix and prevents reactivity of the guanines at 8 and 8' of a third major groove on the opposite face by changing the DNA helical structure at this position. Contacts at other positions are also discussed.     

Mechanism of origin unwinding: sequential binding of DnaA to double- and single-stranded DNA

The initiator protein DnaA of Escherichia coli binds to a 9mer consensus sequence, the DnaA box (5'-TT(A/T)TNCACA). If complexed with ATP it adopts a new binding specificity for a 6mer consensus sequence, the ATP-DnaA box (5'-AGatct). Using DNase footprinting and surface plasmon resonance we show that binding to ATP-DnaA boxes in the AT-rich region of oriC of E.coli requires binding to the 9mer DnaA box R1. Cooperative binding of ATP-DnaA to the AT-rich region results in its unwinding. ATP-DnaA subsequently binds to the single-stranded region, thereby stabilizing it. This demonstrates an additional binding specificity of DnaA protein to single-stranded ATP-DnaA boxes. Binding affinities, as judged by the DnaA concentrations required for site protection in footprinting, were approximately 1 nM for DnaA box R1, 400 nM for double-stranded ATP-DnaA boxes and 40 nM for single-stranded ATP-DnaA boxes, respectively. We propose that sequential recognition of high- and low-affinity sites, and binding to single-stranded origin DNA may be general properties of initiator proteins in initiation complexes.     

Structural and thermodynamic signatures of DNA recognition by Mycobacterium tuberculosis DnaA

An essential protein, DnaA, binds to 9-bp DNA sites within the origin of replication oriC. These binding events are prerequisite to forming an enigmatic nucleoprotein scaffold that initiates replication. The number, sequences, positions, and orientations of these short DNA sites, or DnaA boxes, within the oriCs of different bacteria vary considerably. To investigate features of DnaA boxes that are important for binding Mycobacterium tuberculosis DnaA (MtDnaA), we have determined the crystal structures of the DNA binding domain (DBD) of MtDnaA bound to a cognate MtDnaA-box (at 2.0 Å resolution) and to a consensus Escherichia coli DnaA-box (at 2.3 Å). These structures, complemented by calorimetric equilibrium binding studies of MtDnaA DBD in a series of DnaA-box variants, reveal the main determinants of DNA recognition and establish the [T/C][T/A][G/A]TCCACA sequence as a high-affinity MtDnaA-box. Bioinformatic and calorimetric analyses indicate that DnaA-box sequences in mycobacterial oriCs generally differ from the optimal binding sequence. This sequence variation occurs commonly at the first 2 bp, making an in vivo mycobacterial DnaA-box effectively a 7-mer and not a 9-mer. We demonstrate that the decrease in the affinity of these MtDnaA-box variants for MtDnaA DBD relative to that of the highest-affinity box TTGTCCACA is less than 10-fold. The understanding of DnaA-box recognition by MtDnaA and E. coli DnaA enables one to map DnaA-box sequences in the genomes of M. tuberculosis and other eubacteria.     

A critical DnaA box directs the cooperative binding of the Escherichia coli DnaA protein to the plasmid RK2 replication origin.

The requirement of DnaA protein binding for plasmid RK2 replication initiation the Escherichia coli was investigated by constructing mutations in the plasmid replication origin that scrambled or deleted each of the four upstream DnaA boxes. Altered origins were analyzed for replication activity in vivo and in vitro and for binding to the E. coli DnaA protein using a gel mobility shift assay and DNase I footprinting. Most strikingly, a mutation in one of the boxes, box 4, abolished replication activity and eliminated stable DnaA protein binding to all four boxes. Unlike DnaA binding to the E. coli origin, oriC, DnaA binding to two of the boxes (boxes 4 and 3) in the RK2 origin, oriV, is cooperative with box 4 acting as the "organizer" for the formation of the DnaA-oriV nucleoprotein complex. Interestingly, the inversion of box 4 also abolished replication activity, but did not result in a loss of binding to the other boxes. However, DnaA binding to this mutant origin was no longer cooperative. These results demonstrate that the sequence, position, and orientation of box 4 are crucial for cooperative DnaA binding and the formation of a nucleoprotein structure that is functional for the initiation of replication.     

Analysis of the DNA-binding sequence specificity of the archaeal transcriptional regulator Ss-LrpB from Sulfolobus solfataricus by systematic mutagenesis and high resolution contact probing

To determine the sequence specificity of dimeric Ss-LrpB, a high resolution contact map was constructed and a saturation mutagenesis conducted on one half of the palindromic consensus box. Premodification binding interference indicates that Ss-LrpB establishes most of its tightest contacts with a single strand of two major groove segments and interacts with the minor groove at the center of the box. The requirement for bending is reflected in the preference for an A+T rich center and confirmed with C.G and C.I substitutions. The saturation mutagenesis indicates that major groove contacts with C.G at position 5 and its symmetrical counterpart are most critical for the specificity and strength of the interaction. Conservation at the remaining positions improved the binding. Hydrogen bonding to the O6 and N7 acceptor atoms of the G5' residue play a major role in complex formation. Unlike many other DNA-binding proteins Ss-LrpB does not establish hydrophobic interactions with the methyls of thymine residues. The binding energies determined from the saturation mutagenesis were used to construct a sequence logo, which pin-points the overwhelming importance of C.G at position 5. The knowledge of the DNA-binding specificity will constitute a precious tool for the search of new physiologically relevant binding sites for Ss-LrpB in the genome.     

Escherichia coli DnaA protein: specific biochemical defects of mutant DnaAs reduce initiation frequency to suppress a temperature-sensitive dnaX mutation

The Escherichia coli dnaA73, dnaA721, and dnaA71 alleles, which encode A213D, R432L, T435K substitutions, respectively, were originally isolated as extragenic suppressors of a temperature-sensitive dnaX mutant. As the A213D substitution resides in a domain that functions in ATP binding and the R432L and T435K substitutions affect residues that recognize the DnaA box motif, they might be expected to reduce ATP and specific DNA binding, respectively. Therefore, a major objective was to quantify the biochemical defects of the mutant DnaAs to understand how the altered proteins suppress the temperature-sensitive phenotype of a dnaX mutant. A second purpose was to address the paradox that mutant proteins with substitutions of amino acids essential for recognition of the DnaA box motifs within the E. coli replication origin (oriC) may well be inactive in initiation, yet chromosomal dnaA mutants expressing DnaA proteins with the R432L and T435K substitutions are viable at temperatures from 30 to 39 degrees C. We show biochemically that mutant DnaAs carrying R432L and T435K substitutions fail to bind to the DnaA box sequence. The A213D mutant is sevenfold reduced in its affinity for ATP compared to wild-type DnaA, and its affinity for the DnaA box sequence is also reduced. However, the reduced activity of the A213D mutant in oriC plasmid replication appears to arise from a defect in DnaA oligomerization. Although the T435K mutant fails to bind to the DnaA box sequence, other results suggest that DnaA oligomerization stabilizes the binding of the mutant DnaA to oriC to support its partial activity in initiation in vitro. These results support a model that suppression of dnaX occurs by reducing the frequency of initiation to a manageable level for the mutant DnaX so that viability is maintained.     

DnaA dependent replication of plasmid R1 occurs in the presence of point mutations that disrupt the dnaA box of oriR.

We have found that DnaA dependent replication of R1 still occurred when 5 of the 9 bases in the dnaA box present in oriR were changed by site directed mutagenesis although the replication efficiency decreased to 20% and 70% of the wild-type origin in vitro and in vivo respectively. Additional mutation of a second dnaA box, 28 bp upstream oriR, that differs in only one base from the consensus sequence, did not affect the level of replication whereas polyclonal antibodies against DnaA totally abolished in vitro replication in the absence of the dnaA box. Wild-type RepA as well as a RepA mutant, RepA2623, that binds to oriR but that is inactive in promoting in vitro replication of plasmid R1, induce efficient binding of DnaA to the dnaA box. However, specific binding of DnaA to oriR was not detected by DNase I protection experiments in the absence of the dnaA box. These results suggest that the entrance of the DnaA protein in oriR is promoted initially by interactions with a RepA-oriR pre-initiation complex and that, in the absence of the dnaA box, these interactions can support, with reduced efficiency, DnaA dependent replication of plasmid R1.     

Sequence recognition, cooperative interaction, and dimerization of the initiator protein DnaA of Streptomyces

Using a combined PCR-gel retardation assay, the preferred recognition sequence of the Streptomyces initiator protein DnaA was determined. The protein showed a preference toward DNA containing two Escherichia coli-like DnaA boxes in a head-to-head arrangement (consensus sequence TTATCCACA, whereas the consensus sequence of the DnaA boxes found in the Streptomyces oriC region is TTGTCCACA). In quantitative band shift experiments, the kinetics of the Streptomyces DnaA-DnaA box interaction was characterized. The DnaA protein can form dimers while binding to a single DnaA box; dimer formation is mediated by the domain III of the protein, and the dissociation constant of this process was between 35 and 115 nm. Streptomyces initiator protein DnaA interacts in a cooperative manner with DNA containing multiple binding sites. For the cooperativity effect, which seems to be independent of the distance separating the DnaA boxes, domain I (or I and II) is responsible. The cooperativity constant is moderate and is in the range of 20-110.     

DnaA box sequences as the site for helicase delivery during plasmid RK2 replication initiation in Escherichia coli

DnaA box sequences are a common motif present within the replication origin region of a diverse group of bacteria and prokaryotic extrachromosomal genetic elements. Although the origin opening caused by binding of the host DnaA protein has been shown to be critical for the loading of the DnaB helicase, to date there has been no direct evidence presented for the formation of the DnaB complex at the DnaA box site. For these studies, we used the replication origin of plasmid RK2 (oriV), containing a cluster of four DnaA boxes that bind DnaA proteins isolated from different bacterial species (Caspi, R., Helinski, D. R., Pacek, M., and Konieczny, I. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 18454-18461). Size exclusion chromatography, surface plasmon resonance, and electron microscopy experiments demonstrated that the DnaB helicase is delivered to the DnaA box region, which is localized approximately 200 base pairs upstream from the region of origin opening and a potential site for helicase entry. The DnaABC complex was formed on both double-stranded superhelical and linear RK2 templates. A strict DnaA box sequence requirement for stable formation of that nucleoprotein structure was confirmed. In addition, our experiments provide evidence for interaction between the plasmid initiation protein TrfA and the DnaABC prepriming complex, formed at DnaA box region. This interaction is facilitated via direct contact between TrfA and DnaB proteins.     

DNA binding specificity of the replication initiator protein, DnaA from Helicobacter pylori

The key protein in the initiation of Helicobacter pylori chromosome replication, DnaA, has been characterized. The amount of the DnaA protein was estimated to be approximately 3000 molecules per single cell; a large part of the protein was found in the inner membrane. The H.pylori DnaA protein has been analysed using in vitro (gel retardation assay and surface plasmon resonance (SPR)) as well as in silico (comparative computer modeling) studies. DnaA binds a single DnaA box as a monomer, while binding to the fragment containing several DnaA box motifs, the oriC region, leads to the formation of high molecular mass nucleoprotein complexes. In comparison with the Escherichia coli DnaA, the H.pylori DnaA protein exhibits lower DNA-binding specificity; however, it prefers oriC over non-box DNA fragments. As determined by gel retardation techniques, the H.pylori DnaA binds with a moderate level of affinity to its origin of replication (4nM). Comparative computer modelling showed that there are nine residues within the binding domain which are possible determinants of the reduced H.pylori DnaA specificity. Of these, the most interesting is probably the triad PTL; all three residues show significant divergence from the consensus, and Thr398 is the most divergent residue of all.