Effects of growth stimulatory factors on mitogenicity and c-myc expression in poorly differentiated and well differentiated human colon carcinoma cells

We demonstrate the differential sensitivity of poorly differentiated and well differentiated human colon carcinoma cells to nutrients alone or to nutrients and polypeptide growth factors under completely serum-free conditions. 3H-Thymidine incorporation into trichloroacetic acid precipitable material and autoradiographic analysis indicated that nutrient replenishment alone was sufficient to initiate DNA synthesis in quiescent poorly differentiated cells, whereas defined polypeptide growth factors produced no additional effect. In contrast, well differentiated cells were mitogenically stimulated to a much greater extent by growth factors (epidermal growth factor + insulin + transferrin), than by nutrient replenishment alone. Expression of the c-myc protooncogene was increased approximately 5-fold after growth factor addition to the well differentiated cells. Maximal expression of c-myc occurred at 4 h post stimulation. In contrast, nutrients resulted in only a slight up-regulation of c-myc (1.8-fold) at approximately 90 min after addition. Addition of nutrients and/or growth factors to the poorly differentiated colon carcinoma cells resulted in an initial decline in c-myc expression (90 min), presumably due to removal of endogenous growth stimulators. Expression of c-myc returned to baseline levels by 24 h after additions. The results indicate that differential sensitivity to polypeptide growth factors is related to differentiation status in this model system and suggest that the insensitivity of poorly differentiated cells to exogenous growth factors may be due to a greater production of autocrine growth stimulators.     

Differential sensitivity of subclasses of human colon carcinoma cell lines to the growth inhibitory effects of transforming growth factor-beta 1

In this study we have employed a model system comprising three groups of colon carcinoma cell lines to examine the growth-inhibitory effects of two molecular forms of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2. Aggressive, poorly differentiated colon carcinoma cells of group I did not respond to growth inhibitory effects of TGF-beta 1 or TGF-beta 2, while less aggressive, well-differentiated cells of group III displayed marked sensitivity to both TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2 in monolayer culture as well as in soft agarose. One moderately well-differentiated cell line from group II which has intermediate growth characteristics failed to respond to TGF-beta 1 or TGF-beta 2, but the growth of two other cell lines in this group was inhibited. TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2 were equally potent, 50% growth inhibition for responsive cell lines being observed at a concentration of 1 ng/ml (40 pM). Antiproliferative effects of TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2 in responsive cell lines of groups II and III were associated with morphological alterations and enhanced, concentration-dependent secretion of carcinoembryonic antigen. Radiolabeled TGF-beta 1 bound to all three groups of colon carcinoma cells with high affinity (Kd between 42 and 64 pM). These data indicate for the first time a strong correlation between the degree of differentiation of colon carcinoma cell lines and sensitivity to the antiproliferative and differentiation-promoting effects of TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2.     

Effects of N,N-dimethylformamide and extracellular matrix on transforming growth factor-beta binding to a human colon carcinoma cell line

Alterations in the binding of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) to the MOSER human colon carcinoma cell line caused by N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) or extracellular matrix (ECM) were examined. DMF induced a more differentiated phenotype in the MOSER cells and resulted in a twofold increase in TGF-beta binding to the cells. This was due to an increase in receptor number with no significant alteration in the KD. The extent of increased TGF-beta binding was dependent on the dose and time of exposure to DMF. Upon removal of DMF, the receptor level returned to that of untreated cells within 6 hr. The binding of TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2 to the cells was increased equally. Despite this increase in TGF-beta binding in the presence of DMF, the sensitivity of the MOSER cells to the growth inhibitory effects of TGF-beta was unaltered. Growth of the MOSER cells on ECM derived from a well-differentiated colon cell line increased the TGF-beta receptor number twofold without altering the KD. No change was observed if the MOSER cells were grown on ECM derived from a poorly differentiated cell line. While no alteration in sensitivity to TGF-beta was observed on cells grown in the presence of DMF, MOSER cells grown on the ECM derived from well-differentiated colon carcinoma cell lines were twofold more sensitive to the growth inhibitory effects of TGF-beta. These results indicated that growth conditions which resulted in a more differentiated phenotype resulted in an increase in the cellular receptors for TGF-beta.     

Continuous maintenance of transformed fibroblasts under reduced serum conditions: utility as a model system for investigating growth factor-specific effects in nonquiescent cells

We report the continuous growth maintenance of untransformed and chemically transformed fibroblasts (AKR-2B, AKR-MCA cells) in low concentrations of serum (0.1% FBS). The cell lines established (AKR-0.1F, MCA-0.1F) proliferated at rates comparable to cells maintained under high serum conditions (10% FBS). Complete removal of serum from the cells did not induce quiescence. The MCA-0.1F cells were more similar to the untransformed AKR-2B fibroblasts in their morphology, saturation density, inability to form colonies under anchorage-independent conditions, steady-state level of c-myc expression, and kinetics of induction of c-myc in response to specific growth factors. This report demonstrates the utility of this cell line as a nonquiescent model system for investigating growth factor-specific effects in serum-free, cycling cells. Addition of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) (5 ng/ml) to proliferating MCA-0.1F cells, in the absence of any serum, induced a multilayered growth pattern at confluency, similar to that of AKR-MCA cells maintained in 10% FBS. Other growth factors tested did not elicit this effect. The induction of this growth pattern by TGF-beta was associated with a sustained induction of the c-myc proto-oncogene at confluency, but not with a restoration of anchorage-independent growth. The data suggest that TGF-beta may play a role in the up-regulation of c-myc at confluency previously described for AKR-MCA cells maintained in 10% serum.     

TGF-beta inhibits growth factor-induced DNA synthesis in hamster fibroblasts without affecting the early mitogenic events

Transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) was found to inhibit (IC50 = 0.1 ng/ml) alpha-thrombin or FGF-induced mitogenicity in G0-arrested Chinese hamster lung fibroblasts. Growth factor-stimulated cells became rapidly insensitive to TGF-beta addition during their progression through G0/G1 suggesting that an early step of the mitogenic response was the target of TGF-beta action. Surprisingly, none of the well characterized early mitogenic events commonly triggered by growth factors was found to be affected by TGF-beta addition. These responses included: phosphoinositide breakdown, activation of protein kinase C as determined by EGF receptor down-modulation, subsequent rises in pHi, c-fos, and c-myc mRNA levels, ribosomal protein S6 phosphorylation, the increase in RNA and protein synthesis, induction of ornithine decarboxylase. Only the induction of thymidine kinase, a marker of entry in the S phase, was found to be repressed by TGF-beta, with maximal inhibition when TGF-beta was added early in G1. These results indicate that the inhibitory action of TGF-beta does not affect the growth factors signalling pathways but touches an early event different from those so far analyzed.     

Phenotype alteration in colon carcinoma cells: Effect of in vivo passage?

Summary A panel of rat colon adenocarcinoma cell lines (the Per series) were used to investigate the phenotype and karyotype changes induced by in vivo passage in the subcutis of athymic nude mice. One poorly and one well-differentiated tumor cell line were serially passaged through the athymic nude mouse and then back to the syngeneic rat host. Each of the primary and xenograft cell lines expressed fetal crypt cell (“CaCo”) antigens. The well differentiated primary and xenograft lines (Per305, Per305N1, and Per305N2a) were different in each of their growth factor reponsiveness in vitro [i.e. epidermal growth factor (EGF), bombesin, vasoactive intestinal peptide], their EGF receptor expression, their secretion of transforming growth factor-α, and their exhibition of anchorage independent (A-I) growth capabilities. The poorly differentiated primary and xenograft cell lines were also different but were all capable of A-I growth; their responsiveness to exogenous growth factor stimulation decreased with progressive in vivo passage, as did their basal unstimulated proliferation rate. Cytogenetic alterations detected were those associated with clinical specimens from various stages of malignancy, i. e. aneuploidy, structural aberrations, and marker chromosomes. Genetic and mitogenic individuality of each line demonstrated the diversity of the growth control mechanisms in neoplasms at different stages of progression. Financial support was provided from the Richard Walter Gibbon Fund of the Faculty of Medicine, the University of Western Australia; and from the Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital Research Foundation.     

Differential sensitivity of subclasses of human colon carcinoma cell lines to the growth inhibitory effects of transforming growth factor-β1

In this study we have employed a model system comprising three groups of colon carcinoma cell lines to examine the growth-inhibitory effects of two molecular forms of transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β), TGF-β1 and TGF-β2. Aggressive, poorly differentiated colon carcinoma cells of group I did not respond to growth inhibitory effects of TGF-β1 or TGF-β2, while less aggressive, well-differentiated cells of group III displayed marked sensitivity to both TGF-β1 and TGF-β2 in monolayer culture as well as in soft agarose. One moderately well-differentiated cell line from group II which has intermediate growth characteristics failed to respond to TGF-β1 or TGF-β2, but the growth of two other cell lines in this group was inhibited. TGF-β1 and TGF-β2 were equally potent, 50% growth inhibition for responsive cell lines being observed at a concentration of 1 ng/ml (40 pM). Antiproliferative effects of TGF-β1 and TGF-β2 in responsive cell lines of groups II and III were associated with morphological alterations and enhanced, concentration-dependent secretion of carcinoembryonic antigen. Radiolabeled TGF-β1 bound to all three groups of colon carcinoma cells with high affinity (K_d between 42 and 64 pM). These data indicate for the first time a strong correlation between the degree of differentiation of colon carcinoma cell lines and sensitivity to the antiproliferative and differentiation-promoting effects of TGF-β1 and TGF-β2.     

Transforming growth factor beta 1 is a powerful modulator of platelet-derived growth factor action in vascular smooth muscle cells.

We have studied the effect of transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF-beta 1) on vascular smooth muscle cell (SMC) mitogenesis and expression of thrombospondin and other growth related genes. We found that TGF-beta 1 treatment of vascular SMC induced a prolonged increase in steady-state mRNA levels of thrombospondin as well as alpha 1 (IV) collagen. The increase began at approximately 2 h, peaked by 24 h, and remained considerably elevated 48 h after growth factor addition. There was a corresponding increase in thrombospondin protein as well as increased expression of several other secreted polypeptides. The increase in thrombospondin contrasted sharply with that observed for platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) which induced a rapid and transient increase in thrombospondin mRNA level. Although TGF-beta 1 was able to directly enhance expression of thrombospondin as well as the growth-related genes c-fos and c-myc, and induced c-fos expression with identical kinetics as PDGF, it was unable to elicit [3H]thymidine incorporation into DNA in three independent smooth muscle cell strains. However, TGF-beta 1 was able to strongly increase the mitogenic response of SMC to PDGF. Addition of both TGF-beta 1 and PDGF to SMC also caused a synergistic increase in the expression of thrombospondin as well as c-myc. Interestingly, in one other smooth muscle cell strain, a weak and delayed mitogenic response to TGF-beta 1 alone was observed. Our results strongly suggest that induction of thrombospondin expression by TGF-beta 1 and by PDGF occurs by distinct mechanisms. In addition, that TGF-beta 1 can enhance PDGF-induced mitogenesis may be due to the ability of TGF-beta 1 to directly induce the expression of thrombospondin, c-fos, c-myc, and the PDGF beta-receptor.     

Identification of basic fibroblast growth factor sensitivity and receptor and ligand expression in human colon tumor cell lines.

Basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) has been shown to be mitogenic to many different eukaryotic cell lines of mesodermal and neuroectodermal origin. Addition of exogenous bFGF to the chemically defined media of five characterized human colon tumor cell lines, cultured in the absence of epidermal growth factor (EGF), resulted in stimulation of growth from 24% to 146% in four of five cell lines, as measured by a colorimetric MTT assay. A positive dose-response relationship was observed when colon cells were treated with bFGF concentrations from 1 pM to 1 nM. bFGF showed a cumulative effect with EGF in stimulating the proliferation of colon tumor cells. The growth-inhibitory effect of exogenous transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) on these cells was abolished by bFGF. When colon tumor cells were examined on immunoblots with a fibroblast growth factor (FGF) receptor-specific antibody, bands were detected at apparent molecular weights of 131 and 145 kDa. Conditioned media and cell lysates from the same human colon tumor cell lines were immunoprecipitated with a bFGF-specific antibody. An immunoreactive band was detected that comigrated with authentic human recombinant bFGF (16 kDa). Furthermore, preabsorption of anti-bFGF antibody with authentic ligand blocked immunodetection of the 16 kDa band on immunoblots. Documentation of a bFGF response, receptor, and ligand expression in human colon tumor cell lines is novel, and may represent a more widespread role for FGF that extends to epithelial cells and tumors of endodermal germ layer origin. The expression of both ligand and receptors by these cells indicates that bFGF could be involved in their growth regulation at the autocrine level.     

Expression of a dominant-negative mutant TGF-beta type II receptor in transgenic mice reveals essential roles for TGF-beta in regulation of growth and differentiation in the exocrine pancreas.

Using a dominant-negative mutant receptor (DNR) approach in transgenic mice, we have functionally inactivated transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) signaling in select epithelial cells. The dominant-negative mutant type II TGF-beta receptor blocked signaling by all three TGF-beta isoforms in primary hepatocyte and pancreatic acinar cell cultures generated from transgenic mice, as demonstrated by the loss of growth inhibitory and gene induction responses. However, it had no effect on signaling by activin, the closest TGF-beta family member. DNR transgenic mice showed increased proliferation of pancreatic acinar cells and severely perturbed acinar differentiation. These results indicate that TGF-beta negatively controls growth of acinar cells and is essential for the maintenance of a differentiated acinar phenotype in the exocrine pancreas in vivo. In contrast, such abnormalities were not observed in the liver. Additional abnormalities in the pancreas included fibrosis, neoangiogenesis and mild macrophage infiltration, and these were associated with a marked up-regulation of TGF-beta expression in transgenic acinar cells. This transgenic model of targeted functional inactivation of TGF-beta signaling provides insights into mechanisms whereby loss of TGF-beta responsiveness might promote the carcinogenic process, both through direct effects on cell proliferation, and indirectly through up-regulation of TGF-betas with associated paracrine effects on stromal compartments.     

Production and significance of TGF-beta in AT-3 metastatic cell line established from the Dunning rat prostatic adenocarcinoma

A colony formation assay using NRK-49F cells revealed that a metastatic cell line, AT-3, established from the Dunning prostatic carcinoma could produce TGF-beta in a latent form. TGF-beta at a concentration as low as 0.05 ng/ml either stimulated the attachment or detachment of AT-3 cells depending on the kind of culture media. Acid extracts from conditioned medium (5 micrograms/ml) showed the activity comparable to that of TGF-beta (5 ng/ml). The detached cells were able to grow in suspension. TGF-beta (0.1 ng/ml) could also stimulate the growth of MC3T3-El osteoblasts established from mouse calvaria. These results suggest that TGF-beta is a key growth factor for osteoblastic bony metastasis of prostate cancer.     

Transforming growth factor beta1 regulates follistatin mRNA expression during in vitro bovine granulosa cell differentiation

In order to test the hypothesis that transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) acts by FS regulation on bovine granulosa cells in in vitro differentiation, we analyzed the effect of TGF-beta1 on follistatin mRNA expression in three differentiation states of bovine granulosa cells. We showed a positive regulation of FS mRNA after TGF-beta1 (1 ng/ml) treatment of freshly isolated granulosa cells from small-medium antral follicles (2-8 mm). This effect was abolished by the addition of exogenous follistatin (100 ng/ml), suggesting that this effect could be mediated by activin. Although these cells showed a similar effect on FS mRNA expression after treatment with activin-A, a soluble form of activin receptor type IIA was unable to inactivate the TGF-beta effect. When we tested the TGF-beta effect on FS mRNA in different granulosa cell states, TGF-beta1 regulation was associated with progesterone production only in freshly isolated cells. The amount of total activin-A produced by first passage cells (dedifferentiated cells), was ten times smaller than the one measured in a conditioned medium from freshly isolated cells (mature cells). The TGF-beta1-dependent FS mRNA expression persisted in first passage cells without changes with FS addition. On the other hand, the BGC-1 granulosa cell line (immature cells) produced large amounts of activin-A regulated by TGF-beta1 and an invariable steady state of FS mRNAs. In summary, our results showed that FS mRNA expression is regulated by TGF-beta1 independently of activin effects in differentiated granulosa cells.     

Gastrin-releasing peptide is a mitogen and a morphogen in murine colon cancer.

Little is known about the factors involved in regulating the appearance, or differentiation, of solid tumors including those arising from the colon. We herein demonstrate that the mitogen gastrin-releasing peptide (GRP) is a morphogen, critically important in regulating the differentiation of murine colon cancer. Although epithelial cells lining the mouse colon do not normally express GRP and its receptor (GRP-R), both are aberrantly expressed by all better differentiated cancers in wild-type C57BL/6J mice treated with the carcinogen azoxymethane. Whereas small tumors in both wild-type and GRP-R-deficient (i.e., GRP-R-/-) mice are histologically similar, larger tumors become better differentiated in the former but degenerate into more poorly differentiated mucinous adenocarcinomas in the latter. This alteration in phenotype is attributable to GRP increasing focal adhesion kinase expression in GRP-R-expressing tumors. Consistent with GRP acting as a mitogen, GRP/GRP-R coexpressing tumors in wild-type animals also contain more proliferating cells than those occurring in GRP-R-/- mice. Yet tumors are similarly sized in animals of either genotype receiving azoxymethane for identical times, a finding attributable to the significantly higher number of apoptotic cells detected in GRP/GRP-R coexpressing cancers. Thus, these findings indicate that although GRP is a mitogen, aberrant expression does not result in increased tumor growth. Rather, the mitogenic properties of GRP are subordinate to it acting as a morphogen, where it and its receptor are critically involved in regulating colon cancer histological progression by promoting a well-differentiated phenotype.     

Somatomedins (insulin-like growth factors), but not growth hormone, are mitogenic for chicken heart mesenchymal cells and act synergistically with epidermal growth factor and brain fibroblast growth factor

Chicken, ovine or human growth hormones have no mitogenic effect on chicken heart mesenchymal cells, which are proliferatively quiescent at low culture densities in medium containing heparinized, heat-defibrinogenated rooster plasma at 10%. Sm-C/IGF-I (15 ng/ml; 2 nM), MSA/rIGF-II (50 ng/ml; 7 nM), insulin (10,000 ng/ml; 1750 nM) or proinsulin (16,000 ng/ml; 1750 nM), however, cause these cells to increase threefold in number during four days of incubation. While EGF alone at 100 ng/ml causes threefold multiplication at four days and brain FGF causes a sixfold increase, EGF acts synergistically with Sm-C/IGF-I, MSA/rIGF-II, insulin or proinsulin to cause 18-fold multiplication, and brain FGF acts synergistically with IGFs to cause 20-fold multiplication. EGF and brain FGF, however, show no mitogenic synergy. Addition to the plasma-containing culture medium of a monoclonal antibody to Sm-C/IGF-I nearly abolishes the mitogenic effect of added EGF or brain FGF but does not affect the autonomous (mitogenic hormone-independent) proliferation of RSV-infected chicken heart mesenchymal cells. These findings support the somatomedin hypothesis for growth hormone action and suggest that potentiation of the activity of other mitogenic hormones, like EGF and FGF, makes a significant contribution to control of cell proliferation by the GH/IGF axis.     

Enhancement of DNA synthesis of human epithelial carcinoma cells by acidic fibroblast growth factor

Human epithelial cells that had grown out from a maxillary carcinoma were examined for their responsiveness to putative growth-controlling factors in a serum-free medium. Among the factors examined, bovine brain acidic fibroblast growth factor (FGF) at 1 to 10 ng/ml significantly promoted DNA synthesis of the cells in the presence of 5 U/ml heparin, whereas type beta transforming growth factor inhibited it in a dose-dependent manner. Fetal bovine serum at 0.6% inhibited DNA synthesis of the cells by approximately 15%, but no significant influence was observed at higher concentrations up to 10%. Epidermal growth factor, bovine pituitary gland FGF and basic FGF exhibited no significant effect on DNA synthesis of the cells. The present result suggests that acidic FGF, a known mitogen for endothelial cells, is also mitogenic for human epithelial cells derived from maxillary carcinoma.     

Growth modulatory effects of a liver-derived growth inhibitor, transforming growth factor beta 1, and recombinant tumor necrosis factor alpha, in normal and neoplastic cells

The growth modulatory effects of a rat liver-derived growth inhibitor (LDGI), transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF-beta 1), and recombinant tumor necrosis factor (rTNF-alpha) were examined in a variety of liver-derived and nonliver-derived normal and neoplastic cell culture systems. Normal rat liver epithelial (RLE) cells were highly sensitive to the growth inhibitory effects of LDGI (ID50 = 0.2 ng/ml) and TGF-beta 1 (ID50 = 0.25 ng/ml) but were less sensitive to rTNF-alpha (ID40 = 5000 Units/ml). Aflatoxin B1-transformed RLE cells showed sensitivity to the cytostatic effects of LDGI (ID50 = 1.5 ng/ml); however, these cells were completely resistant to the antiproliferative effects of TGF-beta 1 and rTNF-alpha. Clones isolated from these transformed cells, exhibited a wide range of sensitivities to LDGI but all of the clones were resistant to the growth inhibitory effects of both TGF-beta 1 and rTNF-alpha. Rat hepatoma Reuber cells were extremely sensitive to the antiproliferative effects of rTNF-alpha (ID50 = 10 Units/ml) but exhibited sensitivity to LDGI only at concentrations above 1.5 ng/ml and were resistant to the antiproliferative effects of TGF-beta 1. Rat hepatoma UVM 7777 cells and human hepatoma HepG2 cells, however, were insensitive to the growth inhibitory effects of all three factors. Among the nonliver-derived cells, human breast carcinoma (MCF-7) cells were extremely sensitive to rTNF-alpha (ID50 = 20 Units/ml, exhibited some sensitivity to LDGI (ID50 = 1 ng/ml), and were resistant to the antiproliferative effects of TGF-beta 1. In contrast, the rate of DNA synthesis is rat kidney fibroblasts and human foreskin fibroblasts was significantly stimulated in response to TGF-beta 1, LDGI, and rTNF-alpha. These data demonstrate that LDGI, TGF-beta 1, and rTNF-alpha exert positive and negative modulations of growth in different cell systems and that the growth regulatory effects of LDGI differ from those of TGF-beta 1 and rTNF-alpha in some cell types.     

Tumor angiogenesis factors produced by cancer cells.

Tumor angiogenic activity from tumor angiogenesis factors (TAFs) produced by 25 cell lines was assayed onto chorioallantoic membranes (CAMs). Neovascularization occurred prominently in such cell lines, as HTBOA (poorly differentiated ovarian carcinoma), HUOCA-II (poorly differentiated clear cell adenocarcinoma), HWUA (poorly differentiated endometrial adenocarcinoma), HKUS (uterine cervical small cell carcinoma), and in HOTHC (anaplastic thyroid carcinoma). The cell lines which secreted TAF showed high heterotransplantability in nude mice and produced rapidly growing tumors which were rich in blood vessels. The TAFs polypeptides of 14,000 and 78,000 molecular weight, were extracted and purified from the conditioned medium of HUOCA-II or W3UF (sub-line of HUOCA-II) lines, respectively. TAFs at concentrations of 10 ng/ml and 100 ng/ml promoted proliferation of the endothelial cells and induced tube formation. Microsequencing analysis revealed that TAF of 78,000 molecular weight has sequence identity with human hepatocyte growth factor (hHGF).     

Perichondrial-mediated TGF-beta regulation of cartilage growth in avian long bone development

We previously observed using cultured tibiotarsal long-bone rudiments from which the perichondrium (PC) and periosteum (PO) was removed that the PC regulates cartilage growth by the secretion of soluble negative regulatory factors. This regulation is "precise" in that it compensates exactly for removal of the endogenous PC and is mediated through at least three independent mechanisms, one of which involves a response to TGF-beta. PC cell cultures treated with 2 ng/ml TGF-beta1 produced a conditioned medium which when added to PC/PO-free organ cultures effected precise regulation of cartilage growth. In the present study, we have investigated the possibility that TGF-beta itself might be the negative regulator which is produced by the PC cells in response to their treatment with TGF-beta1. Using a TGF-beta responsive reporter assay, we determined that PC cell cultures, when treated with 2 ng/ml or greater exogenous TGF-beta1, produce 300 pg/ml of active TGF-beta. Then we observed that this concentration (300 pg/ml) of active TGF-beta1, when added to PC/PO-free tibiotarsal organ cultures, effected precise regulation of cartilage growth, whereas concentrations of TGF-beta1 either greater or less than 300 pg/ml produced abnormally small cartilages. These results suggest that one mechanism by which the PC effects normal cartilage growth is through the production of a precisely regulated amount of TGF-beta which the PC produces in response to treatment with exogenous TGF-beta itself.