In vitro analysis of the relationship between endonuclease and maturase activities in the bi-functional group I intron-encoded protein, I-AniI.

The AnCOB group I intron from Aspergillus nidulans encodes a homing DNA endonuclease called I-AniI which also functions as a maturase, assisting in AnCOB intron RNA splicing. In this investigation we biochemically characterized the endonuclease activity of I-AniI in vitro and utilized competition assays to probe the relationship between the RNA- and DNA-binding sites. Despite functioning as an RNA maturase, I-AniI still retains several characteristic properties of homing endonucleases including relaxed substrate specificity, DNA cleavage product retention and instability in the reaction buffer, which suggest that the protein has not undergone dramatic structural adaptations to function as an RNA-binding protein. Nitrocellulose filter binding and kinetic burst assays showed that both nucleic acids bind I-AniI with the same 1 : 1 stoichiometry. Furthermore, in vitro competition activity assays revealed that the RNA substrate, when prebound to I-AniI, stoichiometrically inhibits DNA cleavage activity, yet in reciprocal experiments, saturating amounts of prebound DNA substrate fails to inhibit RNA splicing activity. The data suggest therefore that both nucleic acids do not bind the same single binding site, rather that I-AniI appears to contain two binding sites.     

Functionally distinct nucleic acid binding sites for a group I intron encoded RNA maturase/DNA homing endonuclease

A large number of group I introns encode a family of homologous proteins that either promote intron splicing (maturases) or are site-specific DNA endonucleases that function in intron mobility (a process called "homing"). Genetic studies have shown that some of these proteins have both activities, yet how a single protein carries out both functions remains obscure. The similarity between respective DNA-binding sites and the RNA structure near the 5' and 3' splice sites has fueled speculation that such proteins may use analogous interactions to perform both functions. The Aspergillus nidulans mitochondrial COB group I intron encodes a bi-functional protein, I-AniI, that has both RNA maturase and site-specific DNA endonuclease activities in vitro. Here, we show that I-AniI shows distinctive features of the endonuclease family to which it belongs, including highly specific, tight binding and sequential DNA strand cleavage. Competition experiments demonstrate that I-AniI binds the COB intron RNA even in saturating concentrations of its DNA target site substrate, suggesting that the protein has a separate binding site for RNA. In addition, we provide evidence that two different DNA-binding site mutants of I-AniI have little effect on the protein's RNA maturation activity. Since RNA splicing is likely a secondary adaptation of the protein, these observations support a model in which homing endonucleases may have developed maturase function by utilizing a hitherto "non-functional" protein surface.     

A C-terminal fragment of an intron-encoded maturase is sufficient for promoting group I intron splicing

Group I introns often encode proteins that catalyze site-specific DNA hydrolysis. Some of these proteins have acquired the ability to promote splicing of their cognate intron, but whether these two activities reside in different regions of the protein remains obscure. A crystal structure of I-AniI, a dual function intron-encoded protein, has shown that the protein has two pseudo-symmetric domains of equal size. Each domain contacts its DNA substrate on either side of two cleavage sites. As a first step to identify the RNA binding surface, the N- and C-terminal domains of I-AniI were separately expressed and tested for promoting the splicing of the mitochondrial (mt) COB pre-RNA. The N-terminal protein showed no splicing activation or RNA binding, suggesting that this domain plays a minimal role in activity or is improperly folded. Remarkably, the 16-kDa C-terminal half facilitates intron splicing with a rate similar to that of the full-length protein. Both the C-terminal fragment and full-length proteins bind tightly to the COB intron. RNase footprinting shows that the C-terminal and full-length proteins bind to the same regions and induce the same conformational changes in the COB intron. Together, these results show that the C-terminal fragment of I-AniI is necessary and sufficient for maturase activity and suggests that I-AniI acquired splicing function by utilizing a relatively small protein surface that likely represents a novel RNA binding motif. This fragment of I-AniI represents the smallest group I intron splicing cofactor described to date.     

Degeneration of a homing endonuclease and its target sequence in a wild yeast strain

Mobile introns and inteins self-propagate by ‘homing’, a gene conversion process initiated by site-specific homing endonucleases. The VMA intein, which encodes the PI-SceI endonuclease in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is present in several different yeast strains. Surprisingly, a wild wine yeast (DH1-1A) contains not only the intein⁺ allele, but also an inteinless allele that has not undergone gene conversion. To elucidate how these two alleles co-exist, we characterized the endonuclease encoded by the DH1-1A intein⁺ allele and the target site in the intein^– allele. Sequence analysis reveals seven mutations in the 31 bp recognition sequence, none of which occurs at positions that are individually critical for activity. However, binding and cleavage of the sequence by PI-SceI is reduced 10-fold compared to the S.cerevisiae target. The PI-SceI analog encoded by the DH1-1A intein⁺ allele contains 11 mutations at residues in the endonuclease and protein splicing domains. None affects protein splicing, but one, a R417Q substitution, accounts for most of the decrease in DNA cleavage and DNA binding activity of the DH1-1A protein. Loss of activity in the DH1-1A endonuclease and target site provides one explanation for co-existence of the intein⁺ and intein^– alleles.     

Crystal structure and assembly of the functional Nanoarchaeum equitans tRNA splicing endonuclease

The RNA splicing and processing endonuclease from Nanoarchaeum equitans (NEQ) belongs to the recently identified (αβ)₂ family of splicing endonucleases that require two different subunits for splicing activity. N. equitans splicing endonuclease comprises the catalytic subunit (NEQ205) and the structural subunit (NEQ261). Here, we report the crystal structure of the functional NEQ enzyme at 2.1 Å containing both subunits, as well as that of the NEQ261 subunit alone at 2.2 Å. The functional enzyme resembles previously known α₂ and α₄ endonucleases but forms a heterotetramer: a dimer of two heterodimers of the catalytic subunit (NEQ205) and the structural subunit (NEQ261). Surprisingly, NEQ261 alone forms a homodimer, similar to the previously known homodimer of the catalytic subunit. The homodimers of isolated subunits are inhibitory to heterodimerization as illustrated by a covalently linked catalytic homodimer that had no RNA cleavage activity upon mixing with the structural subunit. Detailed structural comparison reveals a more favorable hetero- than homodimerization interface, thereby suggesting a possible regulation mechanism of enzyme assembly through available subunits. Finally, the uniquely flexible active site of the NEQ endonuclease provides a possible explanation for its broader substrate specificity.     

Achieving specific RNA cleavage activity by an inactive splicing endonuclease subunit through engineered oligomerization

Protein-protein interaction is a common strategy exploited by enzymes to control substrate specificity and catalytic activities. RNA endonucleases, which are involved in many RNA processing and regulation processes, are prime examples of this. How the activities of RNA endonucleases are tightly controlled such that they act on specific RNA is of general interest. We demonstrate here that an inactive RNA splicing endonuclease subunit can be switched "on" solely by oligomerization. Furthermore, we show that the mode of assembly correlates with different RNA specificities. The recently identified splicing endonuclease homolog from Sulfolobus solfataricus, despite possessing all of the putatively catalytic residues, has no detectable RNA cleavage activity on its own but is active upon mixing with its structural subunit. Guided by the previously determined three-dimensional structure of the catalytic subunit, we altered its sequence such that it could potentially self-assemble thereby enabling its catalytic activity. We present the evidence for the specific RNA cleavage activity of the engineered catalytic subunit and for its formation of a functional tetramer. We also identify a higher order oligomer species that possesses distinct RNA cleavage specificity from that of previously characterized RNA splicing endonucleases.     

Active site electrostatics protect genome integrity by blocking abortive hydrolysis during DNA recombination

Water, acting as a rogue nucleophile, can disrupt transesterification steps of important phosphoryl transfer reactions in DNA and RNA. We have unveiled this risk, and identified safeguards instituted against it, during strand cleavage and joining by the tyrosine site‐specific recombinase Flp. Strand joining is threatened by a latent Flp endonuclease activity (type I) towards the 3′‐phosphotyrosyl intermediate resulting from strand cleavage. This risk is not alleviated by phosphate electrostatics; neutralizing the negative charge on the scissile phosphate through methylphosphonate (MeP) substitution does not stimulate type I endonuclease. Rather, protection derives from the architecture of the recombination synapse and conformational dynamics within it. Strand cleavage is protected against water by active site electrostatics. Replacement of the catalytic Arg‐308 of Flp by alanine, along with MeP substitution, elicits a second Flp endonuclease activity (type II) that directly targets the scissile phosphodiester bond in DNA. MeP substitution, combined with appropriate active site mutations, will be useful in revealing anti‐hydrolytic mechanisms engendered by systems that mediate DNA relaxation, DNA transposition, site‐specific recombination, telomere resolution, RNA splicing and retrohoming of mobile introns.     

Evolution from DNA to RNA recognition by the bI3 LAGLIDADG maturase

LAGLIDADG endonucleases bind across adjacent major grooves via a saddle-shaped surface and catalyze DNA cleavage. Some LAGLIDADG proteins, called maturases, facilitate splicing by group I introns, raising the issue of how a DNA-binding protein and an RNA have evolved to function together. In this report, crystallographic analysis shows that the global architecture of the bI3 maturase is unchanged from its DNA-binding homologs; in contrast, the endonuclease active site, dispensable for splicing facilitation, is efficiently compromised by a lysine residue replacing essential catalytic groups. Biochemical experiments show that the maturase binds a peripheral RNA domain 50 A from the splicing active site, exemplifying long-distance structural communication in a ribonucleoprotein complex. The bI3 maturase nucleic acid recognition saddle interacts at the RNA minor groove; thus, evolution from DNA to RNA function has been mediated by a switch from major to minor groove interaction.     

Single-strand nicks induce homologous recombination with less toxicity than double-strand breaks using an AAV vector template

Gene targeting by homologous recombination (HR) can be induced by double-strand breaks (DSBs), however these breaks can be toxic and potentially mutagenic. We investigated the I-AniI homing endonuclease engineered to produce only nicks, and found that nicks induce HR with both plasmid and adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector templates. The rates of nick-induced HR were lower than with DSBs (24-fold lower for plasmid transfection and 4- to 6-fold lower for AAV vector infection), but they still represented a significant increase over background (240- and 30-fold, respectively). We observed severe toxicity with the I-AniI ‘cleavase’, but no evidence of toxicity with the I-AniI ‘nickase.’ Additionally, the frequency of nickase-induced mutations at the I-AniI site was at least 150-fold lower than that induced by the cleavase. These results, and the observation that the surrounding sequence context of a target site affects nick-induced HR but not DSB-induced HR, strongly argue that nicks induce HR through a different mechanism than DSBs, allowing for gene correction without the toxicity and mutagenic activity of DSBs.     

Characterization of PA-N terminal domain of Influenza A polymerase reveals sequence specific RNA cleavage

Influenza virus uses a unique cap-snatching mechanism characterized by hijacking and cleavage of host capped pre-mRNAs, resulting in short capped RNAs, which are used as primers for viral mRNA synthesis. The PA subunit of influenza polymerase carries the endonuclease activity that catalyzes the host mRNA cleavage reaction. Here, we show that PA is a sequence selective endonuclease with distinct preference to cleave at the 3′ end of a guanine (G) base in RNA. The G specificity is exhibited by the native influenza polymerase complex associated with viral ribonucleoprotein particles and is conferred by an intrinsic G specificity of the isolated PA endonuclease domain PA-Nter. In addition, RNA cleavage site choice by the full polymerase is also guided by cap binding to the PB2 subunit, from which RNA cleavage preferentially occurs at the 12th nt downstream of the cap. However, if a G residue is present in the region of 10–13 nucleotides from the cap, cleavage preferentially occurs at G. This is the first biochemical evidence of influenza polymerase PA showing intrinsic sequence selective endonuclease activity.     

Massively parallel characterization of restriction endonucleases

Restriction endonucleases are highly specific in recognizing the particular DNA sequence they act on. However, their activity is affected by sequence context, enzyme concentration and buffer composition. Changes in these factors may lead to either ineffective cleavage at the cognate restriction site or relaxed specificity allowing cleavage of degenerate ‘star’ sites. Additionally, uncharacterized restriction endonucleases and engineered variants present novel activities. Traditionally, restriction endonuclease activity is assayed on simple substrates such as plasmids and synthesized oligonucleotides. We present and use high-throughput Illumina sequencing-based strategies to assay the sequence specificity and flanking sequence preference of restriction endonucleases. The techniques use fragmented DNA from sequenced genomes to quantify restriction endonuclease cleavage on a complex genomic DNA substrate in a single reaction. By mapping millions of restriction site–flanking reads back to the Escherichia coli and Drosophila melanogaster genomes we were able to quantitatively characterize the cognate and star site activity of EcoRI and MfeI and demonstrate genome-wide decreases in star activity with engineered high-fidelity variants EcoRI-HF and MfeI-HF, as well as quantify the influence on MfeI cleavage conferred by flanking nucleotides. The methods presented are readily applicable to all type II restriction endonucleases that cleave both strands of double-stranded DNA.     

The C-terminal loop of the homing endonuclease I-CreI is essential for site recognition, DNA binding and cleavage

Meganucleases are sequence-specific endonucleases with large cleavage sites that can be used to induce efficient homologous gene targeting in cultured cells and plants. These enzymes open novel perspectives for genome engineering in a wide range of fields, including gene therapy. A new crystal structure of the I-CreI dimer without DNA has allowed the comparison with the DNA-bound protein. The C-terminal loop displays a different conformation, which suggests its implication in DNA binding. A site-directed mutagenesis study in this region demonstrates that whereas the C-terminal helix is negligible for DNA binding, the final C-terminal loop is essential in DNA binding and cleavage. We have identified two regions that comprise the Ser138–Lys139 and Lys142–Thr143 pairs whose double mutation affect DNA binding in vitro and abolish cleavage in vivo. However, the mutation of only one residue in these sites allows DNA binding in vitro and cleavage in vivo. These findings demonstrate that the C-terminal loop of I-CreI endonuclease plays a fundamental role in its catalytic mechanism and suggest this novel site as a region to take into account for engineering new endonucleases with tailored specificity.     

Human RNA 5'-kinase (hClp1) can function as a tRNA splicing enzyme in vivo

Yeast and human Clp1 proteins are homologous components of the mRNA 3′-cleavage-polyadenylation machinery. Recent studies highlighting an association of human Clp1 (hClp1) with tRNA splicing endonuclease and an intrinsic RNA-specific 5′-OH polynucleotide kinase activity of hClp1 have prompted speculation that Clp1 might play a catalytic role in tRNA splicing in animal cells. Here, we show that expression of hClp1 in budding yeast can complement conditional and lethal mutations in the essential 5′-OH RNA kinase module of yeast or plant tRNA ligases. The tRNA splicing activity of hClp1 in yeast is abolished by mutations in the kinase active site. In contrast, overexpression of yeast Clp1 (yClp1) cannot rescue kinase-defective tRNA ligase mutants, and, unlike hClp1, the purified recombinant yClp1 protein has no detectable RNA kinase activity in vitro. Mutations of the yClp1 ATP-binding site do not affect yeast viability. These findings, and the fact that hClp1 cannot complement growth of a yeast clp1Δ strain, indicate that yeast and human Clp1 proteins are not functional orthologs, despite their structural similarity. Although hClp1 can perform the 5′-end-healing step of a yeast-type tRNA splicing pathway in vivo, it is uncertain whether its kinase activity is necessary for tRNA splicing in human cells, given that other mammalian counterparts of yeast-type tRNA repair enzymes are nonessential in vivo.     

Coevolution of a homing endonuclease and its host target sequence

We have determined the specificity profile of the homing endonuclease I-AniI and compared it to the conservation of its host gene. Homing endonucleases are encoded within intervening sequences such as group I introns. They initiate the transfer of such elements by cleaving cognate alleles lacking the intron, leading to their transfer via homologous recombination. Each structural homing endonuclease family has arrived at an appropriate balance of specificity and fidelity that avoids toxicity while maximizing target recognition and invasiveness. I-AniI recognizes a strongly conserved target sequence in a host gene encoding apocytochrome B and has fine-tuned its specificity to correlate with wobble versus nonwobble positions across that sequence and to the amount of degeneracy inherent in individual codons. The physiological target site in the host gene is not the optimal substrate for recognition and cleavage: at least one target variant identified during a screen is bound more tightly and cleaved more rapidly. This is a result of the periodic cycle of intron homing, which at any time can present nonoptimal combinations of endonuclease specificity and insertion site sequences in a biological host.     

Structural insights into the substrate specificity of the endonuclease activity of the influenza virus cap-snatching mechanism

The endonuclease activity within the influenza virus cap-snatching process is a proven therapeutic target. The anti-influenza drug baloxavir is highly effective, but is associated with resistance mutations that threaten its clinical efficacy. The endonuclease resides within the N-terminal domain of the PA subunit (PA_N) of the influenza RNA dependent RNA polymerase, and we report here complexes of PA_N with RNA and DNA oligonucleotides to understand its specificity and the structural basis of baloxavir resistance mutations. The RNA and DNA oligonucleotides bind within the substrate binding groove of PA_N in a similar fashion, explaining the ability of the enzyme to cleave both substrates. The individual nucleotides occupy adjacent conserved pockets that flank the two-metal active site. However, the 2′ OH of the RNA ribose moieties engage in additional interactions that appear to optimize the binding and cleavage efficiency for the natural substrate. The major baloxavir resistance mutation at position 38 is at the core of the substrate binding site, but structural studies and modeling suggest that it maintains the necessary virus fitness via compensating interactions with RNA. These studies will facilitate the development of new influenza therapeutics that spatially match the substrate and are less likely to elicit resistance mutations.     

A novel mechanism for protein-assisted group I intron splicing

Previously it was shown that the Aspergillus nidulans (A.n.) mitochondrial COB intron maturase, I-AniI, facilitates splicing of the COB intron in vitro. In this study, we apply kinetic analysis of binding and splicing along with RNA deletion analysis to gain insight into the mechanism of I-AniI facilitated splicing. Our results are consistent with I-AniI and A.n. COB pre-RNA forming a specific but labile encounter complex that is resolved into the native, splicing-competent complex. Significantly, kinetic analysis of splicing shows that the resolution step is rate limiting for splicing. RNA deletion studies show that I-AniI requires most of the A.n. COB intron for binding suggesting that the integrity of the I-AniI-binding site depends on overall RNA tertiary structure. These results, taken together with the observation that A.n. COB intron lacks significant stable tertiary structure in the absence of protein, support a model in which I-AniI preassociates with an unfolded COB intron via a "labile" interaction that facilitates correct folding of the intron catalytic core, perhaps by resolving misfolded RNAs or narrowing the number of conformations sampled by the intron during its search for native structure. The active intron conformation is then "locked in" by specific binding of I-Anil to its intron interaction site.