The problems of eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA packaging and in vivo conformation posed by superhelix density heterogeneity

Systems for gel electrophoresis in the presence of one of the intercalative unwinding ligands, ethidium or chloroquine, have been developed which permit the resolution of highly supercoiled closed circular DNA molecules differing by unit values of the topological winding number, alpha. All native closed circular DNAs examined, including the viral and intracellular forms of SV40 and polyoma DNA, bacterial plasmid DNAs, and the double stranded closed circular DNA genome of the marine bacteriophage, PM2, are more heterogeneous with respect to the number of superhelical turns present than are the thermal distributions observed in the limit products of the action of nicking-closing (N-C) enzyme on the respective DNAs. In the cases of SV40 and polyoma, where it has been shown that the supercoiling is a combined consequence of the binding of the four nucleosomal histones, H2a, H2b, H3 and H4, and the action of N-C enzyme, the breadth of the distributions within the form I DNAs poses specific problems since the work of other laboratories indicates that the number of nucleosomes on the respective minichromosomes falls within a narrow distribution of 21. If it is assumed that all nucleosomes have identical structures, and that the DNA within a nucleosome is not free to rotate, the native DNA would be anticipated to be less heterogeneous than the thermal equilibrium mixtures present in N-C enzyme relaxed SV40 and polyoma DNAs.The absolute number of superhelical turns (at 37 degrees C in 0.2 M NaCl) in virion polyoma DNA has been determined to be 26 +/- 1, which is the same value obtained for virion SV40 DNA. This is consistent with the observations that polyoma DNA has a higher molecular weight, a lower superhelix density, but the same number of nucleosomes as SV40 DNA. In addition, the distributions within the virion and intracellular form I DNAs of both SV40 and polyoma were found to be indistinguishable.Images     

Electrophoretic analysis of covalently closed SV40 DNA: Boltzmann distributions of DNA species.

Covalently closed relaxed SV40 DNA [SV40(I')] generated by polynucleotide ligase closure of nicked circular SV40 DNA was analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis. The DNA can be resolved into a series of bands differing in superhelical density whose intensities are approximately symmetrical about a central most intense band. Densitometric analysis of the gel pattern has revealed that the distribution of DNA species conforms to a Boltzmann distribution and has enabled us to derive an equation for the free energy of superhelix formation for SV40 DNA. We believe the observed bands reflect the time-averaged distribution of thermally induced fluctuations in DNA chain conformation in solution at the time of ligase catalyzed phosphodiester bond formation. Densitometric analysis of native supercoiled SV40 DNA, partially unwound in the presence of ethidium bromide, demonstrates that the separation between adjacent bands is approximately half that seen with SV40(I'). Agarose gel electrophoresis was also used to measure the change in average base rotation angle as a function of temperature by a procedure independent of ethidium dye binding.     

E. coli DNA binding protein HU forms nucleosomelike structure with circular double-stranded DNA.

The incubation of the E coli DNA binding protein HU with relaxed circular SV40 DNA in the presence of pure nicking-closing enzyme introduces up to 18 negative superhelical turns in the DNA molecules as measured by agarose gel electrophoresis. The maximal density of supercoiling is obtained at a HU-DNA mass ratio of 1. Reconstituted DNA-HU complexes prefixed with glutaraldehyde appear as condensed circular structures having an average of 14 "beads" per circular SV40 DNA molecule, with a "bead" diameter of 180 +/- 23 A. The circular SV40 DNA is condensed by a ratio of 2.0-2.5 relative to naked DNA. This is similar to the ratio (2.4) measured for chromatin formed by reassociation of relaxed SV40 DNA with the four core histones.     

Electron microscopy of SV40 DNA cross-linked by anti-Z DNA IgG.

Electron microscopy has revealed the specific binding of bivalent anti-Z DNA immunoglobulin G (IgG) to different sites on supercoiled Form I SV40 DNA. The anti-Z IgG links together left-handed regions located within individual or on multiple SV40 DNA molecules at the superhelix density obtained upon extraction. Velocity sedimentation, electrophoresis, and electron microscopy all show that two or more Z DNA sites in the SV40 genome can be intermolecularly cross-linked with bivalent IgG into high mol. wt. complexes. The formation and stability of the intermolecular antibody-DNA complexes are dependent on DNA superhelix density, as judged by three criteria: (1) relaxed circular (Form II) DNA does not react; (2) release of torsional stress by intercalation of 0.25 microM ethidium bromide removes the antibody; and (3) linearization with specific restriction endonucleases reverses antibody binding and DNA cross-linking. Non-immune IgG does not bind to negatively supercoiled SV40 Form I DNA, nor are complexes observed in the presence of competitive synthetic polynucleotides constitutively in the left-handed Z conformation; B DNA has no effect. Using various restriction endonucleases, three major sites of anti-Z IgG binding have been mapped by electron microscopy to the 300-bp region containing nucleotide sequences controlling SV40 gene expression. A limited number of minor sites may also exist (at the extracted superhelix density).     

Isolation,characterization, and structure of the folded interphase genome of Drosophila melanogaster

The intact interphase genome of Drosophila melanogaster has been isolated by sucrose gradient centrifugation after gentle lysis of tissue culture cells in 0.9 M NaCl-0.4% Nonidet P40. The nonviscous folded DNA sediments as a single broad 5000S peak in a complex with RNA (a fraction of the nuclear nascent RNA) and protein (all of the four intranucleosome histones: H2A, H2B, H3, and H4).The folded DNA is supercoiled and can be relaxed to slower sedimenting forms either by intercalating ethidium or by nicking with DNAase I. Incomplete DNAase treatment gives partially relaxed complexes, indicating that each nick relaxes only a stretch of DNA (defined as a supercoiled DNA loop) without affecting the superhelical content of the rest of the genome. The concentration of superhelices in the Drosophila folded DNA is the same as in the E. coli and SV40 closed circular DNAs—that is, about one negative turn every 200 base pairs (bp) in 0.15 M NaCl at 26°C. The estimated average size of the supercoiled DNA loops, about 85,000 bp, equals the size of the larger Drosophila chromomeres.Ethidium intercalation in 0.9 M NaCl both removes the negative superhelical turns and dissociates the four histones from the DNA. The four histones are dissociated in equimolar concentrations, and the relative proportion of histones displaced from the DNA is a function of ethidium concentration. The histones are completely dissociated from the folded DNA at the ethidium concentration which removes all of the negative superhelices. Thus the data strongly suggest that the rotation of the Watson Crick helix which accompanies ethidium intercalation causes the loss of nucleosomes from the DNA.The results are interpreted in terms of a model for the folded Drosophila genome which has the DNA constrained (by both protein-DNA and RNA-DNA interactions) into independent supercoiled loops containing on the average 400 nucleosomes per loop. Each nucleosome is composed of a histone core with the DNA wound around it in a 360° left-handed toroidal supercoil; each nucleosome toroidal supercoil plus its relaxed internucleosome DNA contains, on the average, 200 bp.     

Interaction between SV40 DNA and camptothecin, an antitumor alkaloid

Camptothecin specifically interacted with closed superhelical circular SV40 DNA during incubation in 1.0 M NaCl at 37 degrees C and induced an alkali-labile linkage in the E strand. No interaction occurred in the reaction mixture containing 0.1 M NaCl, or at 4 degrees C. As camptothecin did not affect linear SV40 DNA, the superhelical structure of DNA appeared to be essential. The site of the alkali-labile linkage induced in SV40 DNA I through interaction with camptothecin was near the origin of replication on the basis of the results of experiments with restriction enzymes. Neither sulfhydryl reagents nor EDTA affected the interaction between camptothecin and SV40 DNA I, so the action of camptothecin is different from those of antitumor antibiotics, bleomycin or neocarzinostatin. Analysis of the s20,0w value of SV40 DNA I after the interaction with camptothecin and the sedimentation profiles of DNA after heating in the reaction mixture indicated that the interaction between camptothecin and SV40 DNA I was different from those of intercalating or alkylating agents such as ethidium bromide and methylmethanesulfonate. Replacement of the OH group at C-20 in the E ring of camptothecin by H-, CH3-, and Cl- resulted in the reduction, in this order, of the potency for interaction with SV40 DNA I to induce an alkali-labile linkage.     

The use of Haemophilus gallinarum DNA-relaxing enzyme to investigate the relationship between the number of superhelical turns and the molecular weight in a negatively twisted DNA.

Covalently closed-circular, superhelical DNAs, including viral DNAs, bacterial plasmid DNAs, and bacteriophage replicative-form DNA, were treated with a small amount of Haemophilus gallinarum DNA-relaxing enzyme to generate incompletely relaxed DNA molecules. Each sample consisted of a set of closed-circular DNA molecules differing by one turn in their number of superhelical turns. The DNA samples were analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis under conditions such that the electrophoretic mobility was a function of the number of turns. The numbers of superhelical turns (at 37 degrees C in 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.5)-5 mM MgCl2) in the DNAs of pSC101 (5.8 megadaltons), Colicin E1 (4.2 megadaltons), pMR4 (4.0 megadaltons; recombinant between pBR322 and lambda DNA fragment), phi X174 replicative-form (RF) I, Simian virus 40 (SV40), and polyoma virus (3.4--3.6 megadaltons each), and lambda dv021 (2.05 megadaltons) were estimated to be 36, 27, 23--24, 20--21, 20--21, 20--21, and 11--13, respectively. It appears that the number of superhelical turns is mainly a function of the molecular weight of the DNA, at least in the substrates tested here.     

A specific DNA unwinding activity associated with SV40 large T antigen

The incubation of highly purified large T antigen with relaxed, circular SV40 DNA in the presence of topoisomerase I (nicking closing enzyme) resulted in the introduction of negative superhelical turns in the DNA. ATP was not required for this reaction. A similar introduction of superhelical turns could also be obtained when a recombinant plasmid DNA (Y182), which contains sequences from both SV40 DNA and pBR322, was used. However, no effect was observed when relaxed pBR322 DNA, which does not contain SV40 DNA sequences, was incubated with T antigen in the presence of topoisomerase. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that large T antigen can recognize and unwind specific sequences on SV40 DNA.     

Unwinding of Parental Strands During Simian Virus 40 DNA Replication

Pools of young (less than 60% replicated) and mature (60-90% replicated) replicating molecules of simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA have been treated at pH 12.2 in order to dissociate growing chains from the parental strands. The molecules are neutralized so that the parental strands can reassociate and they have then been isolated. They are covalently closed structures which sediment rapidly in alkaline sucrose gradients; however, the sedimentation rates are less than the sedimentation rate of SV40 DNA I. Isopycnic banding in CsCl-ethidium bromide and sedimentation velocity studies in the presence of various amounts of ethidium bromide indicate that these structures contain negative superhelical turns and several-fold-higher superhelix densities than SV40 DNA I (the covalently closed DNA molecule). These structures are those that would be predicted if nicking, unwinding, and sealing of the parental strands occurred as replication proceeded. These experiments provide a direct demonstration that there is a progressive decrease in the topological winding number which accompanies SV40 DNA replication.     

Isolation of Z-DNA binding proteins from SV40 minichromosomes: evidence for binding to the viral control region

Proteins dissociated from SV40 minichromosomes by increasing NaCl concentration were tested for their binding to Z-DNA [Br-poly(dG-dC)] and B-DNA [poly (dG-dC)]. Z-DNA binding proteins are largely released in 0.2 M NaCl whereas most B-DNA binding proteins are not released until 0.6 M NaCl. Incubation of SV40 minichromosomes with Z-DNA-Sephadex in low salt solution results in proteins with Z-DNA binding activity (PZ proteins). These proteins bind to negatively supercoiled DNAs containing left-handed Z-DNA but not to relaxed DNAs. They compete with anti-Z-DNA antibodies in binding to negatively supercoiled DNAs. The binding is tighter to negatively supercoiled SV40 DNA than to other plasmids, suggesting sequence-specific Z-DNA binding. PZ proteins binding to negatively supercoiled SV40 DNA interfere with cleavage at the Sph I sites, within the 72 bp repeat sequences of the viral control region, but not with cleavage at the Bgl I site, at the origin of replication. Removal of PZ proteins also exposes the Sph I sites in the SV40 minichromosomes while addition of PZ proteins makes the sites inaccessible.     

Conformational and thermodynamic properties of supercoiled DNA.

We used Monte Carlo simulations to investigate the conformational and thermodynamic properties of DNA molecules with physiological levels of supercoiling. Three parameters determine the properties of DNA in this model: Kuhn statistical length, torsional rigidity and effective double-helix diameter. The chains in the simulation resemble strongly those observed by electron microscopy and have the conformation of an interwound superhelix whose axis is often branched. We compared the geometry of simulated chains with that determined experimentally by electron microscopy and by topological methods. We found a very close agreement between the Monte Carlo and experimental values for writhe, superhelix axis length and the number of superhelical turns. The computed number of superhelix branches was found to be dependent on superhelix density, DNA chain length and double-helix diameter. We investigated the thermodynamics of supercoiling and found that at low superhelix density the entropic contribution to superhelix free energy is negligible, whereas at high superhelix density, the entropic and enthalpic contributions are nearly equal. We calculated the effect of supercoiling on the spatial distribution of DNA segments. The probability that a pair of DNA sites separated along the chain contour by at least 50 nm are juxtaposed is about two orders of magnitude greater in supercoiled DNA than in relaxed DNA. This increase in the effective local concentration of DNA is not strongly dependent on the contour separation between the sites. We discuss the implications of this enhancement of site juxtaposition by supercoiling in the context of protein-DNA interactions involving multiple DNA-binding sites.     

DNA gyrase can supercoil DNA circles as small as 174 base pairs.

DNA gyrase introduces negative supercoils into closed-circular DNA using the free energy of ATP hydrolysis. Consideration of steric and thermodynamic aspects of the supercoiling reaction indicates that there should be a lower limit to the size of DNA circle which can be supercoiled by gyrase. We have investigated the supercoiling reaction of circles from 116-427 base pairs (bp) in size and have determined that gyrase can supercoil certain relaxed isomers of circles as small as 174 bp, dependent on the final superhelix density of the supercoiled product. Furthermore, this limiting superhelical density (-0.11) is the same as that determined for the supercoiling of plasmid pBR322. We also find that although circles in the range 116-152 bp cannot be supercoiled, they can nevertheless be relaxed by gyrase when positively supercoiled. These data suggest that the conformational changes associated with the supercoiling reaction can be carried out by gyrase in a circle as small as 116 bp. We discuss these results with respect to the thermodynamics of DNA supercoiling and steric aspects of the gyrase mechanism.     

Dye titrations of covalently closed supercoiled DNA analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis.

We have developed a rapid electrophoretic technique for performing ethidium bromide dye titrations in cylindrical 0.7% agarose gels. The technique was used to analyze the extent of supercoiling in circular covalently closed SV40, Co1E1, and pSC101 DNA. We have estimated the superhelical densities of SV40, Co1E1, and pSC101 DNA to be ?0.050, ?0.078, and ?0.085 respectively. The results obtained for native SV40 DNA correlate well with previously published values for the superhelical density of this DNA when these values are corrected to reflect a 26° duplex unwinding angle for ethidium bromide. Ethidium bromide concentrations sufficient to partially relax a supercoiled DNA allow the DNA to be resolved into a series of discrete bands in agarose gels. The distribution of bands represents a natural heterogeneity in the superhelical densities of the DNA molecules in the population.     

Salt-dependent DNA superhelix diameter studied by small angle neutron scattering measurements and Monte Carlo simulations.

Using small angle neutron scattering we have measured the static form factor of two different superhelical DNAs, p1868 (1868 bp) and pUC18 (2686 bp), in dilute aqueous solution at salt concentrations between 0 and 1.5 M Na+ in 10 mM Tris at 0% and 100% D2O. For both DNA molecules, the theoretical static form factor was also calculated from an ensemble of Monte Carlo configurations generated by a previously described model. Simulated and measured form factors of both DNAs showed the same behavior between 10 and 100 mM salt concentration: An undulation in the scattering curve at a momentum transfer q = 0.5 nm-1 present at lower concentration disappears above 100 mM. The position of the undulation corresponds to a distance of approximately 10-20 nm. This indicated a change in the DNA superhelix diameter, as the undulation is not present in the scattering curve of the relaxed DNA. From the measured scattering curves of superhelical DNA we estimated the superhelix diameter as a function of Na+ concentration by a quantitative comparison with the scattering curve of relaxed DNA. The ratio of the scattering curves of superhelical and relaxed DNA is very similar to the form factor of a pair of point scatterers. We concluded that the distance of this pair corresponds to the interstrand separation in the superhelix. The computed superhelix diameter of 16.0 +/- 0.9 nm at 10 mM decreased to 9.0 +/- 0.7 nm at 100 mM salt concentration. Measured and simulated scattering curves agreed almost quantitatively, therefore we also calculated the superhelix diameter from the simulated conformations. It decreased from 18.0 +/- 1.5 nm at 10 mM to 9.4 +/- 1.5 nm at 100 mM salt concentration. This value did not significantly change to lower values at higher Na+ concentration, in agreement with results obtained by electron microscopy, scanning force microscopy imaging in aqueous solution, and recent MC simulations, but in contrast to the observation of a lateral collapse of the DNA superhelix as indicated by cryo-electron microscopy studies.     

The three-dimensional structure of supercoiled deoxyribonucleic acid in solution. Evidence obtained from the angular distribution of scattered light

1. The size and shape of superhelical double-stranded circular DNA from bacteriophage ØX174 were investigated by light-scattering. The molecular weight of the DNA is 3.17×10⁶ and the root-mean-square radius is 103.5nm. 2. The light-scattering envelopes of various theoretical three-dimensional models for such DNA molecules were calculated by repetitive computational techniques, and the results were compared with the experimental findings. 3. It is concluded that the structure of supercoiled DNA containing −12 superhelical turns in buffer of I0.2 corresponds best to one of the more compact models for superhelix structure such as the branched model, and the commonly employed straight interwound superhelix model is incompatible with the experimental results, at the superhelix density found.     

Selective binding of tumor suppressor p53 protein to topologically constrained DNA: Modulation by intercalative drugs

Selective binding of the wild type tumor suppressor protein p53 to negatively and positively supercoiled (sc) DNA was studied using intercalative drugs chloroquine (CQ), ethidium bromide, acridine derivatives and doxorubicin as a modulators of the level of DNA supercoiling. The p53 was found to lose gradually its preferential binding to negatively scDNA with increasing concentrations of intercalators until the DNA negative superhelix turns were relaxed. Formation of positive superhelices (due to further increasing intercalator concentrations) rendered the circular duplex DNA to be preferentially bound by the p53 again. CQ at concentrations modulating the closed circular DNA topology did not prevent the p53 from recognizing a specific target sequence within topologically unconstrained linear DNA. Experiments with DNA topoisomer distributions differing in their superhelix densities revealed the p53 to bind selectively DNA molecules possessing higher number of negative or positive superturns. Possible modes of the p53 binding to the negatively or positively supercoiled DNA and tentative biological consequences are discussed.     

Joint molecule formation following conjugation in wild type and mutant Escherichia coli recipients

The sedimentation coefficients of closed circular Simian virus (SV40) DNA, phage PM2 DNA and animal mitochondrial DNAs in alkaline NaCl and alkaline CsCl were found to decrease by about 5% as the initial superhelix densities decreased from 0.0 to ?0.10, corresponding to a decrease in the degree of strand interwinding from 1.0 to 0.9 net turns per ten base pairs. The small dependence of the appropriately normalized sedimentation coefficients on the degree of strand interwinding is taken to indicate that fully titrated and denatured closed circular DNA is highly supercoiled in a positive sense. This supercoiling results from the spontaneous decrease in the number of secondary turns in the no longer ordered pairs of polynucleotide strands.The measured sedimentation coefficients form a smoothly connected monotonie curve when plotted along with the sedimentation coefficients in alkali (Sebring et al., 1971) of parental closed circles derived from closed circular SV40 DNA replicating intermediates. These DNAs have degrees of strand interwinding that range from 0.6 to 0.15.The possibility raised by Paoletti &; LePecq (1971) that closed circular duplex DNAs contain positive supercoils, i.e. have degrees of strand interwinding greater than 1.0, has been ruled out in a series of ethidium bromide titrations of partially replicated mitochondrial DNA before and after removal of the progeny strand. More ethidium bromide was required in the latter case for relaxation, a result which shows that intercalated ethidium and a displacing strand act on the duplex in the same way, and that both unwind the duplex. This result requires the supercoils of naturally closed circular DNAs to be negative.     

Light-scattering studies on supercoil unwinding

It has been shown previously that supercoiled [unk]X174 bacteriophage intracellular DNA (mol.wt. 3.2x10(6)) with superhelix density, sigma=-0.025 (-12 superhelical turns) at 25 degrees C is best represented as a Y shape. In this work two techniques have been used to unwind the supercoil and study the changes in tertiary structure which result from changes in the secondary structure. The molecular weights from all experiments were in the range 3.2x10(6)+/-0.12x10(6). In experiments involving temperature change little change in the Y shape was observed between sigma=-0.027 (-13 superhelical turns, 14.9 degrees C) and sigma=-0.021 (-10 superhelical turns, 53.4 degrees C) as evidenced by the root-mean-square radius and the particle-scattering factor P(theta). However, at sigma=-0.0176 (-8 superhelical turns, 74.5 degrees C) the root-mean-square radius fell to between 60 and 70nm from 90nm indicating a large structural change, as did alterations in the P(theta) function. In experiments with the intercalating dye proflavine from values of bound proflavine of 0-0.06mol of dye/mol equiv. of nucleotide which correspond to values of sigma from -0.025 to -0.0004 (-12 to 0 superhelical turns) a similar transition was found when the superhelix density was changed by the same amount, and the molecule was shown to go through a further structural change as the unwinding of the duplex proceeded. At sigma=-0.018 (-9 superhelical turns) the structure was compatible with a toroid, and at sigma=-0.0004 it was compatible with a circle but at no point in the sequence of structure transitions was the structure compatible with the conventional straight interwound model normally visualized as the shape of supercoiled DNA.