The receptor-like MLO protein and the RAC/ROP family G-protein RACB modulate actin reorganization in barley attacked by the biotrophic powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei

Cytoskeleton remodelling is a crucial process in determining the polarity of dividing and growing plant cells, as well as during interactions with the environment. Nothing is currently known about the proteins, which regulate actin remodelling during interactions with invading pathogens. The biotrophic powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei (Bgh) invades susceptible barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) by penetrating epidermal cells, which remain intact during fungal development. In contrast, resistant host plants prevent infection by inhibiting penetration through apoplastic mechanisms, which require focusing defence reactions on the site of attack. We stained actin filaments in a susceptible Mlo-genotype and a near-isogenic race-non-specifically resistant barley mlo5-mutant genotype using fluorescence-labelled phalloidin after chemical fixation. This revealed that the actin cytoskeleton is differentially reorganized in susceptible and resistant hosts challenged by Bgh. Actin filaments were polarized towards the sites of attempted penetration in the resistant host, whereas when susceptible hosts were penetrated, a more subtle reorganization took place around fungal haustoria. Strong actin filament focusing towards sites of fungal attack was closely associated with successful prevention of penetration. Actin focusing was less frequent and seemingly delayed in susceptible wild-type barley expressing the susceptibility factor MLO. Additionally, single cell overexpression of a constitutively activated RAC/ROP G-protein, CA RACB, another potential host susceptibility factor and hypothetical actin cytoskeleton regulator, partly inhibited actin reorganization when under attack from Bgh, whereas knockdown of RACB promoted actin focusing. We conclude that RACB and, potentially, MLO are host proteins involved in the modulation of actin reorganization and cell polarity in the interaction of barley with Bgh.     

Constitutively activated barley ROPs modulate epidermal cell size, defense reactions and interactions with fungal leaf pathogens

RHO-like monomeric G-proteins of plants (ROPs, also called RACs), are involved in plant development and interaction with the environment. The barley (Hordeum vulgare) ROP protein HvRACB has been shown to be required for entry of the biotrophic powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei (Bgh) into living host cells. To get a deeper insight into evolutionarily conserved functions of ROPs in cell polarity and pathogen responses, we stably expressed constitutively activated (CA) mutant variants of different barley ROPs (HvRACB, HvRAC1, HvRAC3) in barley. CA HvROPs induced epidermal cell expansion and/or abolished polarity in tip growing root hairs. All three CA HvROPs enhanced susceptibility of barley to penetration by Bgh whereas only CA HvRAC1 supported whole cell H₂O₂ production in non-penetrated cells. Despite increasing penetration by Bgh, CA HvRAC1 promoted callose deposition at sites of fungal attack and resistance to penetration by Magnaporthe oryzae. The data show an involvement of ROPs in polar growth processes of the monocot barley and in responses to fungal pathogens with different life style.     

Ectopic expression of constitutively activated RACB in barley enhances susceptibility to powdery mildew and abiotic stress

Small RAC/ROP-family G proteins regulate development and stress responses in plants. Transient overexpression and RNA interference experiments suggested that the barley (Hordeum vulgare) RAC/ROP protein RACB is involved in susceptibility to the powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei. We created transgenic barley plants expressing the constitutively activated RACB mutant racb-G15V under control of the maize (Zea mays) ubiquitin 1 promoter. Individuals of the T1 generation expressing racb-G15V were significantly more susceptible to B. graminis when compared to segregating individuals that did not express racb-G15V. Additionally, racb-G15V-expressing plants showed delayed shoot development from the third leaf stage on, downward rolled leaves, and stunted roots. Expression of racb-G15V decreased photosynthetic CO(2)-assimilation rates and transpiration of nonstressed leaves. In contrast, racb-G15V-expressing barley leaves, when detached from water supply, showed increased water loss and enhanced transpiration. Water loss was associated with reduced responsiveness to abscisic acid in regard to transpiration when compared to segregants not expressing racb-G15V. Hence, RACB might be a common signaling element in response to both biotic and abiotic stress.     

A barley ROP GTPase ACTIVATING PROTEIN associates with microtubules and regulates entry of the barley powdery mildew fungus into leaf epidermal cells

Little is known about the function of host factors involved in disease susceptibility. The barley (Hordeum vulgare) ROP (RHO of plants) G-protein RACB is required for full susceptibility of the leaf epidermis to invasion by the biotrophic fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp hordei. Stable transgenic knockdown of RACB reduced the ability of barley to accommodate haustoria of B. graminis in intact epidermal leaf cells and to form hairs on the root epidermis, suggesting that RACB is a common element of root hair outgrowth and ingrowth of haustoria in leaf epidermal cells. We further identified a barley MICROTUBULE-ASSOCIATED ROP-GTPASE ACTIVATING PROTEIN (MAGAP1) interacting with RACB in yeast and in planta. Fluorescent MAGAP1 decorated cortical microtubules and was recruited by activated RACB to the cell periphery. Under fungal attack, MAGAP1-labeled microtubules built a polarized network at sites of successful defense. By contrast, microtubules loosened where the fungus succeeded in penetration. Genetic evidence suggests a function of MAGAP1 in limiting susceptibility to penetration by B. graminis. Additionally, MAGAP1 influenced the polar organization of cortical microtubules. These results add to our understanding of how intact plant cells accommodate fungal infection structures and suggest that RACB and MAGAP1 might be antagonistic players in cytoskeleton organization for fungal entry.     

Functional analysis of barley RAC/ROP G-protein family members in susceptibility to the powdery mildew fungus

Small monomeric G-proteins of the plant ras (rat sarcome oncogene product) related C3 botulinum toxin substrate (RAC)/Rho of plants (ROP) family are molecular switches in signal transduction of many cellular processes. RAC/ROPs regulate hormone effects, subcellular gradients of Ca2+, the organisation of the actin cytoskeleton and the production of reactive oxygen intermediates. Therefore, we followed a genetic bottom-up strategy to study the role of these proteins during the interaction of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) with the fungal biotrophic pathogen Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei (Bgh). We identified six barley RAC/ROP proteins and studied their gene expression. Five out of six Rac/Rop genes were expressed constitutively in the leaf epidermis, which is the site of interaction with Bgh. None of the genes showed enhancement of mRNA abundance after inoculation with Bgh. After microprojectile mediated transformation of single barley epidermal cells with constitutively activated mutant RAC/ROP proteins, we found an RAC/ROP-specific enhancement of pathogen accessibility, tagging HvRACB, HvRAC3 and HvROP6 as host proteins potentially involved in the establishment of susceptibility to Bgh. Confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) of green fluorescent protein (GFP):HvRAC/ROP-transformed cells revealed varying strengths of plasma membrane association of barley RAC/ROPs. The C-terminal CAAX motif for presumable prenylation or the C-terminal hypervariable region (HVR), respectively, were required for membrane association of the RAC/ROPs. Proper intracellular localisation was essential for HvRACB and HvRAC3 function. Together, our data support the view that different paths of host signal transduction via RAC/ROP G-proteins are involved in processes supporting parasitic entry into epidermal host cells.     

A barley SKP1‐like protein controls abundance of the susceptibility factor RACB and influences the interaction of barley with the barley powdery mildew fungus

In an increasing number of plant–microbe interactions, it has become evident that the abundance of immunity‐related proteins is controlled by the ubiquitin–26S proteasome system. In the interaction of barley with the biotrophic barley powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei (Bgh), the RAC/ROP [RAT SARCOMA‐related C3 botulinum toxin substrate/RAT SARCOMA HOMOLOGUE (RHO) of plants] guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase) HvRACB supports the fungus in a compatible interaction. By contrast, barley HvRBK1, a ROP‐binding receptor‐like cytoplasmic kinase that interacts with and can be activated by constitutively activated HvRACB, limits fungal infection success. We have identified a barley type II S‐phase kinase 1‐associated (SKP1)‐like protein (HvSKP1‐like) as a molecular interactor of HvRBK1. SKP1 proteins are subunits of the SKP1‐cullin 1‐F‐box (SCF)–E3 ubiquitin ligase complex that acts in the specific recognition and ubiquitination of protein substrates for subsequent proteasomal degradation. Transient induced gene silencing of either HvSKP1‐like or HvRBK1 increased protein abundance of constitutively activated HvRACB in barley epidermal cells, whereas abundance of dominant negative RACB only weakly increased. In addition, silencing of HvSKP1‐like enhanced the susceptibility of barley to haustorium establishment by Bgh. In summary, our results suggest that HvSKP1‐like, together with HvRBK1, controls the abundance of HvRACB and, at the same time, modulates the outcome of the barley–Bgh interaction. A possible feedback mechanism from RAC/ROP‐activated HvRBK1 on the susceptibility factor HvRACB is discussed.     

Barley ROP binding kinase1 is involved in microtubule organization and in basal penetration resistance to the barley powdery mildew fungus

Certain plant receptor-like cytoplasmic kinases were reported to interact with small monomeric G-proteins of the RHO of plant (ROP; also called RAC) family in planta and to be activated by this interaction in vitro. We identified a barley (Hordeum vulgare) partial cDNA of a ROP binding protein kinase (HvRBK1) in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) two-hybrid screenings with barley HvROP bait proteins. Protein interaction of the constitutively activated (CA) barley HvROPs CA HvRACB and CA HvRAC1 with full-length HvRBK1 was verified in yeast and in planta. Green fluorescent protein-tagged HvRBK1 appears in the cytoplasm and nucleoplasm, but CA HvRACB or CA HvRAC1 can recruit green fluorescent protein-HvRBK1 to the cell periphery. Barley HvRBK1 is an active kinase in vitro, and activity is enhanced by CA HvRACB or GTP-loaded HvRAC1. Hence, HvRBK1 might act downstream of active HvROPs. Transient-induced gene silencing of barley HvRBK1 supported penetration by the parasitic fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei, suggesting a function of the protein in basal disease resistance. Transient knockdown of HvRBK1 also influenced the stability of cortical microtubules in barley epidermal cells. Hence, HvRBK1 might function in basal resistance to powdery mildew by influencing microtubule organization.     

A class III peroxidase specifically expressed in pathogen-attacked barley epidermis contributes to basal resistance

Higher plants possess large multigene families encoding secreted class III peroxidase (Prx) proteins. In barley, two Prx cDNAs encoding HvPrx07 and HvPrx08 have been isolated and characterized to some extent with respect to a resistance-mediating function upon attack by the powdery-mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei ( Bgh ). Here we present evidence for the tissue-specific accumulation of a new Prx mRNA, HvPrx40 , in Bgh -attacked epidermis of barley ( Hordeum vulgare ). The encoded protein is predicted to be secreted into the apoplastic space of epidermal cells due to the absence of a C-terminal extension, which distinguishes it from other Prx proteins reported to accumulate in leaf epidermis. Transient overexpression of HvPrx40 enhanced the resistance of wheat ( Triticum aestivum ) and barley against Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici (wheat powdery mildew) and Bgh , respectively. These findings were complemented by transient-induced gene silencing showing hypersusceptibility of barley leaf epidermal cells to Bgh . The local accumulation of oxidized 3,3-diaminobenzidine that reflects H₂O₂ production at sites of attempted fungal penetration was not reduced in HvPrx40 -silenced cells, suggesting a role of this peroxidase other than the production of reactive oxygen species.     

A barley Engulfment and Motility domain containing protein modulates Rho GTPase activating protein HvMAGAP1 function in the barley powdery mildew interaction

Engulfment and Motility (ELMO) proteins are involved in the regulation of small GTPase activity in eukaryotic organisms, but little is known about ELMO proteins in plants. We isolated the barley ELMO Domain Containing Protein, HvELMOD_C, in a yeast two hybrid screen for proteins interacting with HvMAGAP1 (Microtubule Associated ROP-GTPase Activating Protein 1). HvMAGAP1 is considered as an antagonist of barley RACB, a member of the RHO of plant (ROP) family GTPases, which functions as a susceptibility factor in the interaction of barley with the barley powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei. HvELMOD_C interacts with the central RHO-GAP domain of HvMAGAP1. Cytoplasmic HvELMOD_C translocates to microtubules on co-expression of HvMAGAP1 but not on co-expression of HvMAGAP1-R185G, a mutant of the catalytically active arginine R185 in the RHO-GAP domain. HvELMOD_C, when simultaneously expressed with HvMAGAP1, abolished the resistance-inducing effect of HvMAGAP1 to B. graminis f.sp. hordei. Therefore, HvELMOD_C might function as a new modulator of HvMAGAP1 and thus ROP activity in barley.     

Plant small monomeric G-proteins (RAC/ROPs) of barley are common elements of susceptibility to fungal leaf pathogens,cell expansion and stomata development

Small monomeric RAC/ROP GTPases act as molecular switches in signal transduction processes of plant development and stress responses. They emerged as crucial players in plant-pathogen interactions either by supporting susceptibility or resistance. In a recent publication, we showed that constitutively activated (CA) mutants of different barley (Hordeum vulgare) RAC/ROPs regulate susceptibility to barley fungal leaf pathogens of different life style in a contrasting way. This illustrates the distinctive signalling roles of RAC/ROPs for different plant-pathogen combinations. We also reported the involvement of RAC/ROPs in plant epidermis development in a monocotyledonous plant. Here we further discuss a failure of CA HvRAC/ROP-expressing barley to normally develop stomata.Key words: Hordeum vulgare, G-proteins, RAC, ROP, cell expansion, stomata, transpirationMembers of the RHO family of small G-proteins in plants (RAC/ROPs) regulate signal transduction processes at the plasma membrane.¹ They act as multifunctional signalling switches in plant development and a variety of stress responses. RAC/ROP GTPases play regulatory roles in polar growth and cell morphogenesis in several cell systems including pollen tubes, developing root hairs and leaf pavement cells.²In a recent publication,³ we showed that constitutively activated (CA) mutants of different barley (Hordeum vulgare) RAC/ROPs support susceptibility to the barley powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei (Bgh). CA HvRAC1 supported susceptibility to biotrophic Bgh but resistance to hemibiotrophic Magnaporthe oryzae in barley at the penetration level in both cases. Additionally, CA HvRAC1 supported local callose deposition at sites of attack from Bgh and a secondary H₂O₂ burst in whole non-penetrated epidermal cells. This supports a regulatory function of RAC/ROPs in plant defence¹ and the potential corruption of defence pathways in susceptibility to Bgh. Because the rice ortholog of HvRAC1, OsRAC1, can regulate an H₂O₂ burst via activation of the plasma membrane NADPH oxidase OsRBOHB,⁴ one can speculate that the secondary H₂O₂ burst in CA HvRAC1 barley could also be caused by over-activation of an NADPH oxidase. However, CA HvRAC1 barley was also more susceptible to fungal penetration, and penetrated cells did not show an H₂O₂ burst. Hence, CA HvRAC1 did not contribute to penetration resistance, and the H₂O₂ burst might have been suppressed by Bgh after successful penetration. Interestingly, Bgh secretes a catalase during interaction with the plant.⁵The involvement of RAC/ROPs in plant development has been widely studied in the dicots Arabidopsis and tobacco. In Arabidopsis, CA AtRAC/ROPs disturb root hair tip growth and epidermal cell morphogenesis.^6,7 We showed similar developmental aberrations as a result of CA HvRAC/ROP expression in monocotyledonous barley. Root hair polarity disruption and enhanced leaf epidermal cell expansion was observed in CA HvRAC/ROP expressing barley. Here, we further report on reduced or abnormal development of stomata as an effect of CA HvRAC/ROP expression.In barley, stomata and short epidermal cells alternate in a row of leaf epidermal cells (Fig. 1A). The number of stomata number was significantly reduced in three CA HvRAC/ROP (CA HvRACB, CAHvRAC3, CA HvRAC1) expressing barley genotypes when compared to azygous controls (barley siblings that lost the transgene due to segregation) (Fig. 1E). In part, this could be explained by enhanced length of epidermal cells intercalated between stomata (Fig. 1B). The presence of longer epidermal cells in all CA HvRAC/ROP-barleys further supports that RAC/ROPs are operating in epidermal cell expansion.³Open in a separate windowFigure 1Stomatal abnormalities observed in CA HvROPexpressing transgenic barley leaves. (A) Wild type leaf adaxial epidermis with alternating stomata complexes (arrows) and short epidermal cells (asterisk). (B) Presence of more than one short epidermal cell in between two stomata. Arrows point the stomata. Double headed arrows highlight intercalated cells with enhanced cell length (C) Two stomata lacking an intercalated short epidermal cell. (D) Stoma failed to develop and left an abnormal blank cell. (E) Average number of stomata present in 5 cm of a stomatal row in transgenic plants expressing distinct CA barley CA HvRAC/ROPs. For all samples, stomatal rows present on either side of the mid rib were counted in the leaf upper epidermis. Fully expanded leaves of 3-weeks-old barley plants were used for counting stomata. Error bars show 95% confidence intervals. Repetition of the experiment led to similar results. Scale bars = 50 µm.Previously, we carried out porometry experiments to measure stomata conductivity in CA HvRACB expressing barley leaves.⁸ The CA HvRACB leaves showed up to 50% less transpiration than azygous controls without any treatment. Additionally, CA HvRACB leaves were less responsive to abscisic acid (ABA) and subsequently they could not effectively reduce transpiration when treated with ABA or when cut-off from water supply.⁸ Our data on numbers of stomata per leaf segment could now explain the lower rates of transpiration in non-stressed CA HvRACB barley when compared to wild type.Apart from the stomata number, developmental abnormalities were observed in the arrangement of epidermal cells. Generally, the shape of epidermal cells was less regular in CA HvRAC/ROP barley.³ We also observed the presence of more than one short epidermal cell in between two stomata (Fig. 1B) or two stomata lacking an intercalated short epidermal cell (Fig. 1C), or stomata failed to develop, which ended up in an abnormally short epidermal cell (Fig. 1D). Although such abnormalities were also rarely observed in wild type plants, all three CA HvRAC/ROP-barley leaves exhibited a clearly higher frequency of abnormalities in a given length of a stomata row. Together, CA HvRAC/ROPs had an effect on both the number and development of stomata. These observations suggest that RAC/ROPs are not only operating in cell expansion but also in barley cell differentiation for stomata development.     

The barley apoptosis suppressor homologue BAX inhibitor-1 compromises nonhost penetration resistance of barley to the inappropriate pathogen Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici

BAX inhibitor-1 (BI-1) proteins have been characterized as suppressors of programmed cell death in mammals and plants. The barley BI-1 is a suppressor of nonspecific background resistance and mlo-mediated penetration resistance to the biotrophic fungal pathogen Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei when overexpressed in epidermal cells of barley. We report here that BI-1 expression is also slightly up-regulated during interaction with the inappropriate wheat pathogen Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici. Significantly, overexpression of BI-1 in single epidermal cells of barley by microprojectile-mediated transformation rendered cells susceptible to penetration by inappropriate B. graminis f. sp. tritici. The degree of transgene-induced accessibility to B. graminis f. sp. tritici was thereby similar to the effect achieved by overexpression of the defense suppressor gene Mlo and could not be further enhanced by double expression of both BI-1 and Mlo. Confocal laser scanning microscopy was used to locate a functional green fluorescing GFP:BI-1 fusion protein in endomembranes and the nuclear envelope of barley epidermal cells. Together, enhanced expression of barley BI-1 suppresses penetration resistance to B. graminis f. sp. tritici, linking barley nonhost resistance with cell death regulation.     

Respiratory burst oxidase homologue A of barley contributes to penetration by the powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei

Reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI) are closely related to defence reactions of plants against pathogens. A prominent role in the production of ROI has been attributed to the plant respiratory burst oxidase homologues (RBOH) of the human phagocyte GP91(phox). A barley RBOH, which encodes a putative superoxide (O2*-)) producing NADPH oxidase, is described here. Histochemical analysis of the barley-Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei (Bgh) interaction showed that O(2*-) is produced locally at the site of penetration. In contrast, hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is produced in non-penetrated cell wall appositions. A barley RBOHA cDNA was isolated and a minor induction of expression of RBOHA was observed during the interactions of barley with Bgh. Transient RNA interference-mediated gene silencing of HvRBOHA during the penetration process of Bgh led to an increase of basal penetration resistance. The results support a potential role of HvRBOHA in cellular accessibility to Blumeria graminis.     

Multiple avirulence paralogues in cereal powdery mildew fungi may contribute to parasite fitness and defeat of plant resistance

Powdery mildews, obligate biotrophic fungal parasites on a wide range of important crops, can be controlled by plant resistance (R) genes, but these are rapidly overcome by parasite mutants evading recognition. It is unknown how this rapid evolution occurs without apparent loss of parasite fitness. R proteins recognize avirulence (AVR) molecules from parasites in a gene-for-gene manner and trigger defense responses. We identify AVR(a10) and AVR(k1) of barley powdery mildew fungus, Blumeria graminis f sp hordei (Bgh), and show that they induce both cell death and inaccessibility when transiently expressed in Mla10 and Mlk1 barley (Hordeum vulgare) varieties, respectively. In contrast with other reported fungal AVR genes, AVR(a10) and AVR(k1) encode proteins that lack secretion signal peptides and enhance infection success on susceptible host plant cells. AVR(a10) and AVR(k1) belong to a large family with >30 paralogues in the genome of Bgh, and homologous sequences are present in other formae speciales of the fungus infecting other grasses. Our findings imply that the mildew fungus has a repertoire of AVR genes, which may function as effectors and contribute to parasite virulence. Multiple copies of related but distinct AVR effector paralogues might enable populations of Bgh to rapidly overcome host R genes while maintaining virulence.     

Rho-GTPase-dependent filamentous actin dynamics coordinate vesicle targeting and exocytosis during tip growth

The dynamic activity of tip-localized filamentous actin (F-actin) in pollen tubes is controlled by counteracting RIC4 and RIC3 pathways downstream of the ROP1 guanosine triphosphatase promoting actin assembly and disassembly, respectively. We show here that ROP1 activation is required for both the polar accumulation and the exocytosis of vesicles at the plasma membrane apex. The apical accumulation of exocytic vesicles oscillated in phase with, but slightly behind, apical actin assembly and was enhanced by overexpression of RIC4. However, RIC4 overexpression inhibited exocytosis, and this inhibition could be suppressed by latrunculin B treatment or RIC3 overexpression. We conclude that RIC4-dependent actin assembly is required for polar vesicle accumulation, whereas RIC3-mediated actin disassembly is required for exocytosis. Thus ROP1-dependent F-actin dynamics control tip growth through spatiotemporal coordination of vesicle targeting and exocytosis.     

Multivesicular bodies participate in a cell wall-associated defence response in barley leaves attacked by the pathogenic powdery mildew fungus

Localized cell wall modification and accumulation of antimicrobial compounds beneath sites of fungal attack are common mechanisms for plant resistance to fungal penetration. In barley (Hordeum vulgare) leaves, light-microscopically visible vesicle-like bodies (VLBs) containing H(2)O(2) or phenolics frequently accumulate around cell wall appositions (syn. papillae), in which the penetration attempt of the biotrophic powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei (Bgh) is halted. By ultrastructural analyses, we demonstrated that the Bgh-induced VLBs represent different structures. VLBs intensively stained by H(2)O(2)-reactive dyes were actually small papillae instead of cytoplasmic vesicles. Other VLBs were identified as osmiophilic bodies or multivesicular compartments, designated paramural bodies (PMBs) and multivesicular bodies (MVBs). MVBs seemingly followed two distinct pathways: either they were engulfed by the tonoplast for degradation in the vacuole or they fused with the plasma membrane to release their internal vesicles into the paramural space and hence could be the origin of PMBs. MVBs and PMBs appeared to be multicomponent kits possibly containing building blocks to be readily assembled into papilla and antimicrobial compounds to be discharged against fungal penetration. Finally, we propose that released paramural vesicles might be similar to exosomes in animal cells.