Increasing canopy photosynthesis in rice can be achieved without a large increase in water use—A model based on free‐air CO2 enrichment

Achieving higher canopy photosynthesis rates is one of the keys to increasing future crop production; however, this typically requires additional water inputs because of increased water loss through the stomata. Lowland rice canopies presently consume a large amount of water, and any further increase in water usage may significantly impact local water resources. This situation is further complicated by changing the environmental conditions such as rising atmospheric CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]). Here, we modeled and compared evapotranspiration of fully developed rice canopies of a high‐yielding rice cultivar (Oryza sativa L. cv. Takanari) with a common cultivar (cv. Koshihikari) under ambient and elevated [CO₂] (A‐CO₂ and E‐CO₂, respectively) via leaf ecophysiological parameters derived from a free‐air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment. Takanari had 4%–5% higher evapotranspiration than Koshihikari under both A‐CO₂ and E‐CO₂, and E‐CO₂ decreased evapotranspiration of both varieties by 4%–6%. Therefore, if Takanari was cultivated under future [CO₂] conditions, the cost for water could be maintained at the same level as for cultivating Koshihikari at current [CO₂] with an increase in canopy photosynthesis by 36%. Sensitivity analyses determined that stomatal conductance was a significant physiological factor responsible for the greater canopy photosynthesis in Takanari over Koshihikari. Takanari had 30%–40% higher stomatal conductance than Koshihikari; however, the presence of high aerodynamic resistance in the natural field and lower canopy temperature of Takanari than Koshihikari resulted in the small difference in evapotranspiration. Despite the small difference in evapotranspiration between varieties, the model simulations showed that Takanari clearly decreased canopy and air temperatures within the planetary boundary layer compared to Koshihikari. Our results indicate that lowland rice varieties characterized by high‐stomatal conductance can play a key role in enhancing productivity and moderating heat‐induced damage to grain quality in the coming decades, without significantly increasing crop water use.     

Comparison of Palaeobotanical Observations with Experimental Data on the Leaf Anatomy of Durmast Oak [Quercus petraea(Fagaceae)] in Response to Environmental Change

To test whether stomatal density measurements on oak leaf remainsare reliable tools for assessing palaeoatmospheric carbon dioxideconcentration [CO₂], under changing Late Miocene palaeoenvironmentalconditions, young seedings of oak (Quercus petraea,Liebl.) weregrown at elevatedvs.ambient atmospheric [CO₂] and at high humiditycombined with an increased air temperature. The leaf anatomyof the young oaks was compared with that of fossil leaves ofthe same species. In the experiments, stomatal density and stomatalindex were significantly decreased at elevated [CO₂] in comparisonto ambient [CO₂]. Elevated [CO₂] induced leaf cell expansionand reduced the intercellular air space by 35%. Leaf cell sizeor length were also stimulated at high air humidity and temperature.Regardless of a temperate or subtropical palaeoclimate, leafcell size in fossil oak was not enhanced, since neither epidermalcell density nor length of the stomatal apparatus changed. Theabsence of these effects may be attributed to the phenologicalresponse of trees to climatic changes that balanced temporalchanges in environmental variables to maintain leaf growth underoptimal and stable conditions.Quercus petraea,which evolvedunder recurring depletions in the palaeoatmospheric [CO₂], maypossess sufficient phenotypic plasticity to alter stomatal frequencyin hypostomatous leaves allowing high maximum stomatal conductanceand high assimilation rates during these phases of low [CO₂].Copyright1998 Annals of Botany Company Atmospheric CO₂, high humidity, elevated temperature,Quercus petraea,durmast oak, Late Miocene, palaeoclimates, leaf anatomy, stomatal density, stomatal index     

Responses of stomatal conductance to light, humidity and temperature in winter wheat and barley grown at three concentrations of carbon dioxide in the field

Responses of leaf stomatal conductance to light, humidity and temperature were characterized for winter wheat and barely grown at ambient (about 350 μmol mol^?1 in the daytime), ambient + 175 and ambient + 350 μmol mol^?1 concentrations of carbon dioxide in open‐topped chambers in field plots over a three year period. Stomatal responses to environment were determined by direct manipulation of single environmental factors, and those results were compared with responses derived from natural day to day variation in mid‐day stomatal conductance. The purpose of these experiments was to determine the magnitude of reduction in stomatal conductance at elevated [CO₂], and to assess whether the relative response of conductance to elevated [CO₂] was constant across light, humidity and temperature conditions. The results indicated that light, humidity and temperature all significantly affected the relative decrease in stomatal conductance at elevated [CO₂]. The relative decrease in conductance with elevated [CO₂] was greater at low light, low water vapour pressure difference, and high temperature in both species. For measurements made at saturating light near mid‐day, the ratio of mid‐day stomatal conductances at doubled [CO₂] to that at ambient [CO₂] ranged from 0.42 to 0.86, with a mean of 0.66 in barley, and from 0.33 to 0.80, with a mean of 0.56 in wheat. Day‐to‐day variation in the relative effect of elevated [CO₂] on conductance was correlated with the relative stimulation of [CO₂] assimilation rate and with temperature. Some limitations of multiple linear regression, multiplicative, and ‘Ball–Berry' models as summaries of the data are discussed. In barley, a better fit to the models occurred in individual years than for the combined data, and in wheat a better fit to the models occurred when data from near the end of the season were removed.     

Acclimation of peanut (Arachis hypogaea L.) leaf photosynthesis to elevated growth CO2 and temperature

Peanut (Arachis hypogaea L. cv. Florunner) was grown from seed sowing to plant maturity under two daytime CO₂ concentrations ([CO₂]) of 360 μmol mol⁻¹ (ambient) and 720 μmol mol⁻¹ (elevated) and at two temperatures of 1.5 and 6.0 °C above ambient temperature. The objectives were to characterize peanut leaf photosynthesis responses to long-term elevated growth [CO₂] and temperature, and to assess whether elevated [CO₂] regulated peanut leaf photosynthetic capacity, in terms of activity and protein content of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase (Rubisco), Rubisco photosynthetic efficiency, and carbohydrate metabolism. At both growth temperatures, leaves of plants grown under elevated [CO₂] had higher midday photosynthetic CO₂ exchange rate (CER), lower transpiration and stomatal conductance and higher water-use efficiency, compared to those of plants grown at ambient [CO₂]. Both activity and protein content of Rubisco, expressed on a leaf area basis, were reduced at elevated growth [CO₂]. Declines in Rubisco under elevated growth [CO₂] were 27–30% for initial activity, 5–12% for total activity, and 9–20% for protein content. Although Rubisco protein content and activity were down-regulated by elevated [CO₂], Rubisco photosynthetic efficiency, the ratio of midday light-saturated CER to Rubisco initial or total activity, of the elevated-[CO₂] plants was 1.3- to 1.9-fold greater than that of the ambient-[CO₂] plants at both growth temperatures. Leaf soluble sugars and starch of plants grown at elevated [CO₂] were 1.3- and 2-fold higher, respectively, than those of plants grown at ambient [CO₂]. Under elevated [CO₂], leaf soluble sugars and starch, however, were not affected by high growth temperature. In contrast, high temperature reduced leaf soluble sugars and starch of the ambient-[CO₂] plants. Activity of sucrose-P synthase, but not adenosine 5′-diphosphoglucose pyrophosphorylase, was up-regulated under elevated growth [CO₂]. Thus, in the absence of other environmental stresses, peanut leaf photosynthesis would perform well under rising atmospheric [CO₂] and temperature as predicted for this century.     

Asymmetric responses of adaxial and abaxial stomata to elevated CO2: impacts on the control of gas exchange by leaves

The response of adaxial and abaxial stomatal conductance in Rumex obtusifolius to growth at elevated atmospheric concentrations of CO₂ (250 μmol mol^?1 above ambient) was investigated over two growing seasons. The conductance of both the adaxial and abaxial leaf surfaces was found to be reduced by elevated concentrations of CO₂. Elevated CO₂ caused a much greater reduction in conductance for the adaxial surface than for the abaxial surface. The absence of effects upon stomatal density indicated that the reductions were probably the result of changes in stomatal aperture. Partitioning of gas exchange between the leaf surfaces revealed that increased concentrations of CO₂ caused increased rates of photosynthesis only via the abaxial surface. Additionally, leaf thickness was found to increase during growth at elevated concentrations of CO₂. The tendency for these amphistomatous leaves to develop a distribution of conductance approaching that of hypostomatous leaves clearly reduced their maximum photosynthetic potential. This conclusion was supported by measurements of stomatal limitation, which showed greater values for the adaxial surfaces, and greater values at elevated CO₂. This reduction in photosynthesis may in part be caused by higher diffusive limitations imposed because of increased leaf thickness. In an uncoupled canopy, asymmetrical stomatal responses of the kind identified here may appreciably reduce transpiration. Species which show symmetrical responses are less likely to show reduced transpirational rates, and a redistribution of water loss between species may occur. The implications of asymmetrical stomatal responses for photosynthesis and canopy transpiration are discussed.     

Profiles of isoprene emission and photosynthetic parameters in hybrid poplars exposed to free‐air CO2 enrichment†

Poplar (Populus × euroamericana) saplings were grown in the field to study the changes of photosynthesis and isoprene emission with leaf ontogeny in response to free air carbon dioxide enrichment (FACE) and soil nutrient availability. Plants growing in elevated [CO₂] produced more leaves than those in ambient [CO₂]. The rate of leaf expansion was measured by comparing leaves along the plant profile. Leaf expansion and nitrogen concentration per unit of leaf area was similar between nutrient treatment, and this led to similar source–sink functional balance. Consequently, soil nutrient availability did not cause downward acclimation of photosynthetic capacity in elevated [CO₂] and did not affect isoprene synthesis. Photosynthesis assessed in growth [CO₂] was higher in plants growing in elevated than in ambient [CO₂]. After normalizing for the different number of leaves over the profile, maximal photosynthesis was reached and started to decline earlier in elevated than in ambient [CO₂]. This may indicate a [CO₂]‐driven acceleration of leaf maturity and senescence. Isoprene emission was adversely affected by elevated [CO₂]. When measured on the different leaves of the profile, isoprene peak emission was higher and was reached earlier in ambient than in elevated [CO₂]. However, a larger number of leaves was emitting isoprene in plant growing in elevated [CO₂]. When integrating over the plant profile, emissions in the two [CO₂] levels were not different. Normalization as for photosynthesis showed that profiles of isoprene emission were remarkably similar in the two [CO₂] levels, with peak emissions at the centre of the profile. Only the rate of increase of the emission of young leaves may have been faster in elevated than in ambient [CO₂]. Our results indicate that elevated [CO₂] may overall have a limited effect on isoprene emission from young seedlings and that plants generally regulate the emission to reach the maximum at the centre of the leaf profile, irrespective of the total leaf number. In comparison with leaf expansion and photosynthesis, isoprene showed marked and repeatable differences among leaves of the profile and may therefore be a useful trait to accurately monitor changes of leaf ontogeny as a consequence of elevated [CO₂].     

Elevated CO2 increases water use efficiency by sustaining photosynthesis of water-limited maize and sorghum

Maize and grain sorghum seeds were sown in pots and grown for 39 days in sunlit controlled-environment chambers at 360 (ambient) and 720 (double-ambient, elevated) μmol mol⁻¹ carbon dioxide concentrations [CO₂]. Canopy net photosynthesis (PS) and evapotranspiration (TR) was measured throughout and summarized daily from 08:00 to 17:00 h Eastern Standard Time. Irrigation was withheld from matched pairs of treatments starting on 26 days after sowing (DAS). By 35 DAS, cumulative PS of drought-stress maize, compared to well-watered plants, was 41% lower under ambient [CO₂] but only 13% lower under elevated [CO₂]. In contrast, by 35 DAS, cumulative PS of drought-stress grain sorghum, compared to well-watered plants, was only 9% lower under ambient [CO₂] and 7% lower under elevated [CO₂]. During the 27-35 DAS drought period, water use efficiency (WUE, mol CO₂ Kmol⁻¹ H₂O), was 3.99, 3.88, 5.50, and 8.65 for maize and 3.75, 4.43, 5.26, and 9.94 for grain sorghum, for ambient-[CO₂] well-watered, ambient-[CO₂] stressed, elevated-[CO₂] well-watered and elevated-[CO₂] stressed plants, respectively. Young plants of maize and sorghum used water more efficiently at elevated [CO₂] than at ambient [CO₂], especially under drought. Reductions in biomass by drought for young maize and grain sorghum plants were 42 and 36% at ambient [CO₂], compared to 18 and 14% at elevated [CO₂], respectively. Results of our water stress experiment demonstrated that maintenance of relatively high canopy photosynthetic rates in the face of decreased transpiration rates enhanced WUE in plants grown at elevated [CO₂]. This confirms experimental evidence and conceptual models that suggest that an increase of intercellular [CO₂] (or a sustained intercellular [CO₂]) in the face of decreased stomatal conductance results in relative increases of growth of C₄ plants. In short, drought stress in C₄ crop plants can be ameliorated at elevated [CO₂] as a result of lower stomatal conductance and sustaining intercellular [CO₂]. Furthermore, less water might be required for C₄ crops in future higher CO₂ atmospheres, assuming weather and climate similar to present conditions.     

The effects on Arbutus unedo L. of long-term exposure to elevated CO2

Arbutus unedo is a sclerophyllous evergreen, characteristic of Mediterranean coastal scrub vegetation. In Italy, trees of A. unedo have been found close to natural CO₂ vents where the mean atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration is about 2200 μmol mol^?1. Comparisons were made between trees growing in elevated and ambient CO₂ concentrations to test for evidence of adaptation to long-term exposure to elevated CO₂. Leaves formed at elevated CO₂ have a lower stomatal density and stomatal index and higher specific leaf area than those formed at ambient CO₂, but there was no change in carbon to nitrogen ratios of the leaf tissue. Stomatal conductance was lower at elevated CO₂ during rapid growth in the spring. In mid-summer, under drought stress, stomatal closure of all leaves occurred and in the autumn, when stress was relieved, the conductance of leaves at both elevated and ambient CO₂ increased. In the spring, the stomatal conductance of the new flush of leaves at ambient CO₂ was higher than the leaves at elevated CO₂, increasing instantaneous water use efficiency at elevated CO₂. Chlorophyll fluorescence measurements suggested that elevated CO₂ provided some protection against photoinhibition in mid-summer. Analysis of A/C_i curves showed that there was no evidence of either upward or downward regulation of photosynthesis at elevated CO₂. It is therefore anticipated that A. unedo will have higher growth rates as the ambient CO₂ concentrations increase.     

Will photosynthesis of maize (Zea mays) in the US Corn Belt increase in future [CO2] rich atmospheres? An analysis of diurnal courses of CO2 uptake under free‐air concentration enrichment (FACE)

The C₄ grass Zea mays (maize or corn) is the third most important food crop globally in terms of production and demand is predicted to increase 45% from 1997 to 2020. However, the effects of rising [CO₂] upon C₄ plants, and Z. mays specifically, are not sufficiently understood to allow accurate predictions of future crop production. A rainfed, field experiment utilizing free‐air concentration enrichment (FACE) technology in the primary area of global corn production (US Corn Belt) was undertaken to determine the effects of elevated [CO₂] on corn. FACE technology allows experimental treatments to be imposed upon a complete soil–plant–atmosphere continuum with none of the effects of experimental enclosures on plant microclimate. Crop performance was compared at ambient [CO₂] (354 μ mol mol^?1) and the elevated [CO₂] (549 μmol mol^?1) predicted for 2050. Previous laboratory studies suggest that under favorable growing conditions C₄ photosynthesis is not typically enhanced by elevated [CO₂]. However, stomatal conductance and transpiration are decreased, which can indirectly increase photosynthesis in dry climates. Given the deep soils and relatively high rainfall of the US Corn Belt, it was predicted that photosynthesis would not be enhanced by elevated [CO₂]. The diurnal course of gas exchange of upper canopy leaves was measured in situ across the growing season of 2002. Contrary to the prediction, growth at elevated [CO₂] significantly increased leaf photosynthetic CO₂ uptake rate (A) by up to 41%, and 10% on average. Greater A was associated with greater intercellular [CO₂], lower stomatal conductance and lower transpiration. Summer rainfall during 2002 was very close to the 50‐year average for this site, indicating that the year was not atypical or a drought year. The results call for a reassessment of the established view that C₄ photosynthesis is insensitive to elevated [CO₂] under favorable growing conditions and that the production potential of corn in the US Corn Belt will not be affected by the global rise in [CO₂].     

How is the relationship between the C4 cereal Sorghum bicolor and the C3 root hemi-parasites Striga hermonthica and Striga asiatica affected by elevated CO2?

The C₄ cereal Sorghum bicolor was grown under either ambient (350 μmol mol^?1) or elevated (700 μmol mol^?1) [CO₂] in either the presence or absence of the C₃ obligate root hemi-parasites Striga hermonthica or S. asiatica. Both uninfected and infected sorghum plants were taller and had greater biomass, photosynthetic rates, water-use efficiencies and leaf areas under elevated compared with ambient [CO₂]. There was no evidence of any downregula-tion of photosynthesis in sorghum grown at elevated [CO₂]. Biomass of infected sorghum was lower under both ambient and elevated [CO₂], and although infected plants were larger under elevated [CO₂] the relative impact of infection on host biomass was either the same (S. asiatica) or only slightly less (S. hermonthica) than under ambient [CO₂]. In contrast, biomass of S. hermonthica and S. asiatica per host was lower under elevated than ambient [CO₂], although rates of photosynthesis were higher at elevated [CO₂] and parasite stomatal conductance was not responsive to [CO₂]. Parasites emerged above-ground and flowered earlier under ambient compared with elevated [CO₂]. It appears that the mechanism(s) by which the parasites affect host growth is (are) relatively insensitive to increased atmospheric [CO₂], although the parasites themselves were adversely affected by growth at elevated [CO₂].     

Diurnal and seasonal variations in stomatal conductance of rice at elevated atmospheric CO2 under fully open‐air conditions

Understanding of leaf stomatal responses to the atmospheric CO₂ concentration, [CO₂], is essential for accurate prediction of plant water use under future climates. However, limited information is available for the diurnal and seasonal changes in stomatal conductance (g_s) under elevated [CO₂]. We examined the factors responsible for variations in g_s under elevated [CO₂] with three rice cultivars grown in an open‐field environment under flooded conditions during two growing seasons (a total of 2140 individual measurements). Conductance of all cultivars was generally higher in the morning and around noon than in the afternoon, and elevated [CO₂] decreased g_s by up to 64% over the 2 years (significantly on 26 out of 38 measurement days), with a mean g_s decrease of 23%. We plotted the g_s variations against three parameters from the Ball‐Berry model and two revised versions of the model, and all parameters explained the g_s variations well at each [CO₂] in the morning and around noon (R² > 0.68), but could not explain these variations in the afternoon (R² < 0.33). The present results provide an important basis for modelling future water use in rice production.     

Atmospheric carbon dioxide and fertilizer nitrogen effects on radiation interception by rice 1

In order to predict the potential impacts of global change, it is important to understand the impact of increasing global atmospheric [CO₂] on the growth and yield of crop plants. The objectives of this study were to determine the interaction of N fertilization rates and atmospheric [CO₂] on radiation interception and radiation-use efficiency of rice (Oryza sativa L. cv. IR72) grown under tropical field conditions. Rice plants were grown inside open top chambers in a lowland rice field at the International Rice Research Institute in the Philippines at ambient (about 350 μmol mol^-1) or elevated (about 600 μmol mol^-1 during the 1993 wet season and 700 μmol mol^-1 during the 1994 dry season) in combination with three levels of applied N (0, 50 or 100 kg N ha^-1 in the wet season; 0, 90 or 200 kg N ha-1 in the dry season). Light interception was not directly affected by [CO₂], but elevated [CO₂] indirectly increased light interception through increasing total absorbed N. Plant N requirement for radiation interception was similar for rice grown under ambient [CO₂] or elevated [CO₂] treatments. The conversion efficiency of intercepted radiation to dry matter, radiation-use efficiency (RUE), was about 35% greater at elevated [CO₂] than at ambient [CO₂]. The relationship between leaf N and RUE was curvilinear. At ambient [CO₂], RUE was fairly stable across levels of leaf N, but leaf N less than about 2.5% resulted in lower RUE for plants grown with elevated [CO₂] than for plant grown at ambient [CO₂]. Decreased leaf N with increased [CO₂], therefore decreased RUE of rice plants grown at elevated [CO₂]. When predicting responses of rice to elevated [CO₂], RUE should be adjusted with a decrease in leaf N. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Guard cell photosynthesis is critical for stomatal turgor production,yet does not directly mediate CO2‐ and ABA‐induced stomatal closing

Stomata mediate gas exchange between the inter‐cellular spaces of leaves and the atmosphere. CO₂ levels in leaves (Ci) are determined by respiration, photosynthesis, stomatal conductance and atmospheric [CO₂]. [CO₂] in leaves mediates stomatal movements. The role of guard cell photosynthesis in stomatal conductance responses is a matter of debate, and genetic approaches are needed. We have generated transgenic Arabidopsis plants that are chlorophyll‐deficient in guard cells only, expressing a constitutively active chlorophyllase in a guard cell specific enhancer trap line. Our data show that more than 90% of guard cells were chlorophyll‐deficient. Interestingly, approximately 45% of stomata had an unusual, previously not‐described, morphology of thin‐shaped chlorophyll‐less stomata. Nevertheless, stomatal size, stomatal index, plant morphology, and whole‐leaf photosynthetic parameters (PSII, qP, qN, F_V′/F_M′) were comparable with wild‐type plants. Time‐resolved intact leaf gas‐exchange analyses showed a reduction in stomatal conductance and CO₂‐assimilation rates of the transgenic plants. Normalization of CO₂ responses showed that stomata of transgenic plants respond to [CO₂] shifts. Detailed stomatal aperture measurements of normal kidney‐shaped stomata, which lack chlorophyll, showed stomatal closing responses to [CO₂] elevation and abscisic acid (ABA), while thin‐shaped stomata were continuously closed. Our present findings show that stomatal movement responses to [CO₂] and ABA are functional in guard cells that lack chlorophyll. These data suggest that guard cell CO₂ and ABA signal transduction are not directly modulated by guard cell photosynthesis/electron transport. Moreover, the finding that chlorophyll‐less stomata cause a ‘deflated’ thin‐shaped phenotype, suggests that photosynthesis in guard cells is critical for energization and guard cell turgor production.     

Direct and acclimatory responses of stomatal conductance to elevated carbon dioxide in four herbaceous crop species in the field

In order to separate the net effect of growth at elevated [CO₂] on stomatal conductance (g_s) into direct and acclimatory responses, mid‐day values of g_s were measured for plants grown in field plots in open‐topped chambers at the current ambient [CO₂], which averaged 350 μmol mol^?1 in the daytime, and at ambient + 350 μmol mol^?1[CO₂] for winter wheat, winter barley, potato and sorghum. The acclimatory response was determined by comparing g_s measured at 700 μmol mol^?1[CO₂] for plants grown at the two [CO₂]. The direct effect of increasing [CO₂] from 350 to 700 μmol mol^?1 was determined for plants grown at the lower concentration. Photosynthetic rates were measured concurrently with g_s. For all species, growth at the higher [CO₂] significantly reduced g_s measured at 700 μmol mol^?1[CO₂]. The reduction in g_s caused by growth at the higher [CO₂] was larger for all species on days with low leaf to air water vapour pressure difference for a given temperature, which coincided with highest conductances and also the smallest direct effects of increased [CO₂] on conductance. For barley, there was no other evidence for stomatal acclimation, despite consistent down‐regulation of photosynthetic rate in plants grown at the higher [CO₂]. In wheat and potato, in addition to the vapour pressure difference interaction, the magnitude of stomatal acclimation varied directly in proportion to the magnitude of down‐regulation of photosynthetic rate through the season. In sorghum, g_s consistently exhibited acclimation, but there was no down‐regulation of photosynthetic rate. In none of the species except barley was the direct effect the larger component of the net reduction in g_s when averaged over measurement dates. The net effect of growth at elevated [CO₂] on mid‐day g_s resulted from unique combinations of direct and acclimatory responses in the various species.     

The stomatal CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> proxy does not saturate at high atmospheric CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> concentrations: evidence from stomatal index responses of Araucariaceae conifers

The inverse relationship between the number of stomata on a leaf surface and the atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration ([CO₂]) in which the leaf developed allows plants to optimise water-use efficiency (WUE), but it also permits the use of fossil plants as proxies of palaeoatmospheric [CO₂]. The ancient conifer family Araucariaceae is often represented in fossil floras and may act as a suitable proxy of palaeo-[CO₂], yet little is known regarding the stomatal index (SI) responses of extant Araucariaceae to [CO₂]. Four Araucaria species (Araucaria columnaris, A. heterophylla, A. angustifolia and A. bidwillii) and Agathis australis displayed no significant relationship in SI to [CO₂] below current ambient levels (~380 ppm). However, representatives of the three extant genera within the Araucariaceae (A. bidwillii, A. australis and Wollemia nobilis) all exhibited significant reductions in SI when grown in atmospheres of elevated [CO₂] (1,500 ppm). Stomatal conductance was reduced and WUE increased when grown under elevated [CO₂]. Stomatal pore length did not increase alongside reduced stomatal density (SD) and SI in the three araucariacean conifers when grown at elevated [CO₂]. These pronounced SD and SI reductions occur at higher [CO₂] levels than in other species with more recent evolutionary origins, and may reflect an evolutionary legacy of the Araucariaceae in the high [CO₂] world of the Mesozoic Era. Araucariacean conifers may therefore be suitable stomatal proxies of palaeo-[CO₂] during periods of “greenhouse” climates and high [CO₂] in the Earth’s history.     

Gas exchange acclimation to elevated CO2 in upper-sunlit and lower-shaded canopy leaves in relation to nitrogen acquisition and partitioning in wheat grown in field chambers

Growth at elevated CO₂ often decreases photosynthetic capacity (acclimation) and leaf N concentrations. Lower-shaded canopy leaves may undergo both CO₂ and shade acclimation. The relationship of acclimatory responses of flag and lower-shaded canopy leaves of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) to the N content, and possible factors affecting N gain and distribution within the plant were investigated in a wheat crop growing in field chambers set at ambient (360 μmol mol⁻¹) and elevated (700 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂, and with two amounts of N fertilizer (none and 70 kg ha⁻¹ applied on 30 April). Photosynthesis, stomatal conductance and transpiration at a common measurement CO₂, chlorophyll and Rubisco levels of upper-sunlit (flag) and lower-shaded canopy leaves were significantly lower in elevated relative to ambient CO₂-grown plants. Both whole shoot N and leaf N per unit area decreased at elevated CO₂, and leaf N declined with canopy position. Acclimatory responses to elevated CO₂ were enhanced in N-deficient plants. With N supply, the acclimatory responses were less pronounced in lower canopy leaves relative to the flag leaf. Additional N did not increase the fraction of shoot N allocated to the flag and penultimate leaves. The decrease in photosynthetic capacity in both upper-sunlit and lower-shaded leaves in elevated CO₂ was associated with a decrease in N contents in above-ground organs and with lower N partitioning to leaves. A single relationship of N per unit leaf area to the transpiration rate accounted for a significant fraction of the variation among sun-lit and shaded leaves, growth CO₂ level and N supply. We conclude that reduced stomatal conductance and transpiration can decrease plant N, leading to acclimation to CO₂ enrichment.     

Acclimation of photosynthesis to elevated CO2 and temperature in five British native species of contrasting functional type

Acclimation of photosynthesis to growth at elevated CO₂ concentration varies markedly between species. Species functionally classified as stress-tolerators (S) and ruderals (R), are thought to be incapable, or the least capable, of responding positively in terms of growth to elevated [CO₂]. Is this pattern of response also apparent in leaf photosynthesis of wild S- and R-strategists? Acclimatory loss of a photosynthetic and growth response to elevated [CO₂] is assumed to reflect limitation on capacity to utilize additional photosynthate. The doubling of pre-industrial global [CO₂] is expected to coincide with a 3 °C increase in mean temperature which could stimulate growth; will photosynthetic capacity at elevated [CO₂] be greater when the concurrent temperature increase is simulated? Five species from natural grassland of NW Europe and of contrasting ecological strategy were grown in hemispherical greenhouses, environmentally controlled to track the external microclimate. Within a replicated design, plants were grown at (i) current ambient [CO₂] and temperature, (ii) elevated [CO₂] (ambient + 340 μmol mol^–1) and ambient temperature, (iii) ambient [CO₂] and elevated temperature (ambient + 3 °C), or (iv) elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature. After 75–104 days, the CO₂ response of light-saturated rates of photosynthesis (A_sat) was analysed in controlled-environment cuvettes in a field laboratory. There was no acclimatory loss of photosynthetic capacity with growth in elevated [CO₂] or elevated temperature over this period in Poa alpina (S), Bellis perennis (R) or Plantago lanceolata (mixed C-S-R strategist), and a significant (P ? ? bl 0.05) increase in capacity in Helianthemum nummularium (S) and Poa annua (R). Photosynthetic rates of leaves grown and measured in elevated [CO₂] were therefore significantly higher than rates for leaves grown and measured in ambient [CO₂], for all species. With the exception of Poa alpina, stomatal conductance and stomatal limitation on A_sat showed no acclimatory response to growth in elevated [CO₂]. Carboxylation efficiency, determined from the initial slope of the response of A_sat to intercellular CO₂ concentration was significantly increased by elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature in H.nummularium, implying a possible increase in in vivo RubisCO activity. Increased carboxylation efficiency of this species was also reflected by an increase in the CO₂- and light-saturated rates of photosynthesis, indicating an increased capacity for regeneration of the primary CO₂ acceptor in photosynthesis. The results show that R-strategists and slow-growing S-strategists, are inherently capable of large increases in leaf photosynthetic capacity with growth in elevated [CO₂] in contrast to expectations from growth studies. With the exception of P.annua, where there was a significant negative interaction between CO₂ and temperature, concurrent increase in growth temperature had little effect on this pattern of response.     

Leaf dynamics of a deciduous forest canopy: no response to elevated CO<Subscript>2</Subscript>

Leaf area index (LAI) and its seasonal dynamics are key determinants of terrestrial productivity and, therefore, of the response of ecosystems to a rising atmospheric CO₂ concentration. Despite the central importance of LAI, there is very little evidence from which to assess how forest LAI will respond to increasing [CO₂]. We assessed LAI and related leaf indices of a closed-canopy deciduous forest for 4 years in 25-m-diameter plots that were exposed to ambient or elevated CO₂ (542 ppm) in a free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment. LAI of this Liquidambar styraciflua (sweetgum) stand was about 6 and was relatively constant year-to-year, including the 2 years prior to the onset of CO₂ treatment. LAI throughout the 1999–2002 growing seasons was assessed through a combination of data on photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) transmittance, mass of litter collected in traps, and leaf mass per unit area (LMA). There was no effect of [CO₂] on any expression of leaf area, including peak LAI, average LAI, or leaf area duration. Canopy mass and LMA, however, were significantly increased by CO₂ enrichment. The hypothesized connection between light compensation point (LCP) and LAI was rejected because LCP was reduced by [CO₂] enrichment only in leaves under full sun, but not in shaded leaves. Data on PAR interception also permitted calculation of absorbed PAR (APAR) and light use efficiency (LUE), which are key parameters connecting satellite assessments of terrestrial productivity with ecosystem models of future productivity. There was no effect of [CO₂] on APAR, and the observed increase in net primary productivity in elevated [CO₂] was ascribed to an increase in LUE, which ranged from 1.4 to 2.4 g MJ^–1. The current evidence seems convincing that LAI of non-expanding forest stands will not be different in a future CO₂-enriched atmosphere and that increases in LUE and productivity in elevated [CO₂] are driven primarily by functional responses rather than by structural changes. Ecosystem or regional models that incorporate feedbacks on resource use through LAI should not assume that LAI will increase with CO₂ enrichment of the atmosphere.     

Stomatal conductance and not stomatal density determines the long-term reduction in leaf transpiration of poplar in elevated CO<Subscript>2</Subscript>

Using a free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment, poplar trees (Populus × euramericana clone I214) were exposed to either ambient or elevated [CO₂] from planting, for a 5-year period during canopy development, closure, coppice and re-growth. In each year, measurements were taken of stomatal density (SD, number mm⁻²) and stomatal index (SI, the proportion of epidermal cells forming stomata). In year 5, measurements were also taken of leaf stomatal conductance (g _s, μmol m⁻² s⁻¹), photosynthetic CO₂ fixation (A, mmol m⁻² s⁻¹), instantaneous water-use efficiency (A/E) and the ratio of intercellular to atmospheric CO₂ (C_i:C_a). Elevated [CO₂] caused reductions in SI in the first year, and in SD in the first 2 years, when the canopy was largely open. In following years, when the canopy had closed, elevated [CO₂] had no detectable effects on stomatal numbers or index. In contrast, even after 5 years of exposure to elevated [CO₂], g _s was reduced, A/E was stimulated, and C_i:C_a was reduced relative to ambient [CO₂]. These outcomes from the long-term realistic field conditions of this forest FACE experiment suggest that stomatal numbers (SD and SI) had no role in determining the improved instantaneous leaf-level efficiency of water use under elevated [CO₂]. We propose that altered cuticular development during canopy closure may partially explain the changing response of stomata to elevated [CO₂], although the mechanism for this remains obscure.     

Seasonal patterns of photosynthetic response and acclimation to elevated carbon dioxide in field-grown strawberry

Strawberry (Fragaria × ananassa) plants were grown in field plots at the current ambient [CO₂], and at ambient + 300 and ambient + 600 μmol mol⁻¹ [CO₂]. Approximately weekly measurements were made of single leaf gas exchange of upper canopy leaves from early spring through fall of two years, in order to determine the temperature dependence of the stimulation of photosynthesis by elevated [CO₂], whether growth at elevated [CO₂] resulted in acclimation of photosynthesis, and whether any photosynthetic acclimation was reduced when fruiting created additional demand for the products of photosynthesis. Stimulation of photosynthetic CO₂ assimilation by short-term increases in [CO₂] increased strongly with measurement temperature. The stimulation exceeded that predicted from the kinetic characteristics of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase at all temperatures. Acclimation of photosynthesis to growth at elevated [CO₂] was evident from early spring through summer, including the fruiting period in early summer, with lower rates under standard measurement conditions in plants grown at elevated [CO₂]. The degree of acclimation increased with growth [CO₂]. However, there were no significant differences between [CO₂] treatments in total nitrogen per leaf area, and photosynthetic acclimation was reversed one day after switching the [CO₂] treatments. Tests showed that acclimation did not result from a limitation of photosynthesis by triose phosphate utilization rate at elevated [CO₂]. Photosynthetic acclimation was not evident during dry periods in midsummer, when the elevated [CO₂] treatments conserved soil water and photosynthesis declined more at ambient than at elevated [CO₂]. Acclimation was also not evident during the fall, when plants were vegetative, despite wet conditions and continued higher leaf starch content at elevated [CO₂]. Stomatal conductance responded little to short-term changes in [CO₂] except during drought, and changed in parallel with photosynthetic acclimation through the seasons in response to the long-term [CO₂] treatments. The data do not support the hypothesis that source-sink balance controls the seasonal occurrence of photosynthetic acclimation to elevated [CO₂] in this species. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.