Meiosis in haploid barley — An interpretation of non-homologous chromosome associations

Detailed meiotic studies were conducted on ten haploid plants representing six different genotypes of barley (Hordeum vulgare, 2n=14). At pachytene stages the non-homologous chromosomes were observed to pair as intimately as homologous chromosomes in many cells. Foldback pairing, involving single chromosomes, and multivalent associations were common. At diplotene, up to 4 chiasmatalike structures were observed in paired chromosomes but it is not likely that they resulted from crossing over. At diakinesis the bivalent frequency mean was from 1 to 1.3 per cell whereas by metaphase I the paired associations were rare with a single rod bivalent being observed in 3 to 5% of the cells. The frequencies of various types of secondary associations at metaphase were also recorded. — The origin and significance of bivalents and secondary associations in haploids is reviewed and discussed. Caution is urged in the interpretation that low levels of chromosome pairing in haploids is evidence of homology. It is concluded that very little chromosome duplication is likely to be found within the haploid set of barley chromosomes and that the basic chromosome number is seven.     

Synaptonemal complex analysis in spermatocytes of diploid and triploid Chinese shrimp Fenneropenaeus chinensis

A modified surface spreading technique for synaptonemal complex (SC) analysis was tested to assess the process of chromosome synapsis in spermatocytes of diploid and induced triploid Fenneropenaeus chinensis. Spermatocytes of diploid shrimp showed typical morphological characteristics of eukaryote SC, with complete synapsis of bivalents. No recognizable bivalent associated with sex chromosomes was observed in spermatocytes of diploid shrimp. However, differences in morphology of SC, including unsynapsed univalents, bivalents, totally paired trivalents with non-homologous synapsis, partner switches and triple synapsis were identified at early pachytene stage of triploid spermatocytes. Triple synapsis was especially common at late pachytene stage in spermatocytes of triploid shrimp. The observed abnormal synapsis behavior of chromosomes in spermatocytes indicated that triploid male shrimp may find it difficult to develop normal haploid sperm.     

美味猕猴桃原生质体再生植株细胞遗传学研究 Ⅲ .母株减数分裂前期Ⅰ染色体配对的光镜观察

首次报道在光镜下观察美味猕猴桃 (品种 :No.2 6原生质体植株的母株 )花粉母细胞( PMC)染色体在减数分裂前期的配对 ,发现其配对和凝缩有明显不同步性。不同细胞间染色体配对形式变化较大 ,一般以二价联会为主 ,其次由其它多种配对方式 (包括有复合配对、重复配对、着丝点或端粒处联合和多价联会 )形成多价体 ,还有少数未配对或发生内配对 (偶见 )的单价体和几条二价体之间的次级配对。粗线期观察到少数染色体有缺失 (或重复 )、倒位、易位和疏松配对等结构性改变。表明该植株是一个复杂的区段异源六位体 ,少数染色体在结构上累积有变异。还认为该植株是研究减数分裂染色体配对和联会机制的好材料。     

The meiotic prophase in Bombyx mori females analyzed by three-dimensional reconstructions of synaptonemal complexes

Serial sectioning followed by three dimensional reconstruction of lateral components of the synaptonemal complex have been used to follow chromosome pairing during the prophase of the achiasmatic meiotic division in the silkworm, Bombyx mori. During leptotene and early zygotene, the lateral components become attached to the nuclear envelope at a specific region, thus forming a chromosome bouquet. The attachment of lateral components to the nuclear envelope precedes the completion of the components between their attachment points. Synapsis and synaptonemal complex formation start during the period of lateral component organization in the individual nucleus. Telomeric movements on the nuclear envelope occur at two stages of the prophase: the chromosome pairing appears to be initiated by an association of unpaired ends of homologous chromosomes, the nature of this primary attraction and recognition being unknown. Secondly, the paired chromosomes become dispersed in the nucleus by shifting of attachment sites of completed synaptonemal complexes at the end of zygotene. This movement is possibly related to a membrane flow occurring during this stage. Membrane material is synthesized at the region of synaptonemal complex attachment. Later, the excess membrane material is shifted to the opposite pole where it protrudes into the lumen of the nuclei thus forming vacuoles. — Two previously undescribed features of chromosome pairing were revealed. In late zygotene, chromosome pairing and synaptonemal complex formation were frequently observed to be delayed or even prevented over a short distance by interlocking of two bivalents, both being attached to the nuclear envelope. Such interlocking of bivalents was not found in pachytene. Secondly, one nucleus was found in which two homologous chromosomes were totally unpaired while the remaining 27 bivalents were completed or in a progressed state of pairing. The lateral components of the two unpaired chromosomes had the same length and were located several microns apart, thus eliminating the possibility of a permanent association of homologous chromosomes before the onset of meiosis in Bombyx mori females. — During pachytene, one of the 8 cells belonging to the syncytial cell cluster characteristic of oogenesis continues the meiotic prophase whereas the remaining 7 cells, the nurse cells, enter a different developmental sequence, finally resulting in their degeneration. The synaptonemal complex of the oocyte develops into a sausage-like structure after pachytene by a deposition of dense material onto the lateral components, thus filling out most of the central region. The diameter of this modified synaptonemal complex reaches at least 300 nm, as compaired to a pachytene width of approximately 130 nm. Also, the length of synaptonemal complexes increases from 212 at zygotene/pachytene to at least 300 at the modified pachytene stage. In nurse cells, synaptonemal complexes are shed from the bivalents shortly after pachytene simultaneously with a condensation of the chromatin. These free synaptonemal complex fragments associate and form various aggregates, either more or less normal looking polycomplexes or various complex figures formed by reorganized synaptonemal complex subunits. Later stages have not been included in the present investigation.     

Synaptic adjustment,non-homologous pairing,and non-pairing of homologous segments in sex chromosome mutants of Ephestia kuehniella (Insecta,Lepidoptera)

Microspread pachytene nuclei of wild-type and W chromosome mutants of the mealmoth Ephestia kuehniella were used to study synaptonemal complex (SC) formation. In structurally heterozygous bivalents, axial elements of considerable length differences were brought to the same length by synaptic adjustment. The adjustment length was a compromise between the mutant and the wildtype homologue length in a structural heterozygote of a W chromosome-autosome translocation, T(A; W). The translocated non-homologous W segment really participated in SC formation as could be seen from the W chromosomal heterochromatin, used as a cytogenetic marker. Pachytene pairing of the wild-type W-Z bivalent extended from about two-thirds to the full length of the W chromosome, though from cytogenetic and genetic evidence W and Z are largely — if not completely — non-homologous. Nonhomologous pairing was even more conspicuous in sex chromosome bivalents containing a deleted W chromosome, Df(W). In one of the pairing configurations the halves of the Z chromosome were synapsed to either side of the Df(W). Thus, one side was pairing with the Df(W) in reversed order. The pairing behavior of the W with homologous chromosome segments was tested by introducing supernumerary W segments via the T(A; W) translocation. Pairing between the W and the translocated homologous W segment never occurred, whereas the Z frequently synapsed with it. Even in T(A; W) homozygotes, pairing between the two translocated W segments was not regularly found while the autosomal parts of the translocation chromosomes were always completely paired. Homologous chromosomes and the ability to form an SC are not sufficient for pairing initiation. Specific loci or sequences are postulated for this function. They are either absent from the W chromosome or are present in only low concentrations.     

Ultrastructural analysis of maize pachytene karyotypes by three dimensional reconstruction of the synaptonemal complexes

Aldehyde fixation followed by staining with phosphotungstic acid produces differential contrast between the synaptonemal complex and the chromatin of maize pachytene bivalents. Centromeres, heterochromatic knobs and large chromomeres are easily recognised. With this and other staining techniques the nucleolus organizer region can be differentiated into two components. — Microsporocyte nuclei at pachytene were serially sectioned and all ten bivalents reconstructed in five nuclei. An idiogram was derived from the mean chromosome (= synaptonemal complex) lengths, the arm ratios, positions of knobs and the nucleolus organizer region. The idiogram agrees well with that published from light microscopic analyses. However, bivalent lengths are only two thirds of those observed by light microscopy of squash preparations. Many telomeres of the bivalents are connected via chromatin to the nuclear envelope, but a varying number of free bivalent ends are observed in all five reconstructed nuclei. — Bivalents heterozygous for inversion 3b were reconstructed. In the presence of abnormal chromosome 10 (K10) the lateral components of the synaptonemal complex of chromosome 3 formed a typical inversion loop, while in one of the nuclei having no K10 the two lateral components of the long arms of chromosome 3 remained unpaired in the region of inversion heterozygosity. The presence of K10, which increases crossing-over frequencies and promotes intimate pairing at the light microscopic level, was thus found to permit formation of complete synaptonemal complexes in the inverted region. The extra terminal portion of the K10 chromosome folded back on itself and formed a morphologically normal synaptonemal complex in this — possibly non-homologously paired — region. The chromatin of centromeres and knobs from different bivalents were sometimes found to fuse, but the synaptonemal complexes transversing the fused centromeres or knobs retained their individuality.     

Chromosome pairing in a Lolium temulentum X Lolium perenne diploid hybrid with a low chiasma frequency

Summary Despite an average difference of about 50% in DNA amount, homoeologous chromosomes pair effectively at first metaphase in the diploid interspecific hybrid between Lolium temulentum and Lolium perenne. However, in the presence of accessory B chromosomes and diploidising genes pairing at metaphase I is severely reduced. Reconstruction of serial electron micrographs through pollen mother cell nuclei show that synaptonemal complexes are formed at pachytene between not only homoeologous but also non-homologous chromosome segments resulting in multivalent formation. These associations are largely ineffective in terms of chiasma formation and degenerate at late pachytene. It is highly probable that the pairing determinants exercise their control on chromosome pairing largely by prohibiting the siting of crossovers in homoeologously paired chromosome segments.     

Synaptonemal complex formation in hybrids of Lolium temulentum x Lolium perenne (L.)

Comparisons were made between two kinds of tetraploids derived from the hybrid Lolium temulentum x L. perenne. One hybrid behaves like an autotetraploid with multivalents at first metaphase of meiosis in pollen mother cells. The other behaves like an allotetraploid, in which pairing at first metaphase is restricted to bivalents comprised of strictly homologous chromosomes. The diploidisation of the latter form is controlled by determinants located on both the normal, A chromosomes and on supernumary B chromosomes. Reconstruction of synaptonemal complexes and their elements, from serial sections through pollen mother cell nuclei examined under the electron microscope, reveals that at zygotene pairing in both forms results in multivalent formation involving non-homologous as well as homologous chromosomes. The mechanism responsible for the diploidisation is, therefore, not based on a restriction of pairing at early meiosis to homologous chromosomes but on a correction or transformation of the multivalent chromosome associations to bivalents subsequent to zygotene. The transformation is not completed until late pachytene. In the multivalent-forming tetraploid a maximum of four chromosomes are associated at first metaphase. Yet configurations of a higher valency are found at zygotene. There is, therefore, a partial transformation of multivalents even in this autotetraploid form which restricts configurations at metaphase I to homologous and homoeologous chromosomes only. In both hybrids some homologous bivalents are not the product of resolution of multivalents but result from two-by-two pairing from the beginning of zygotene.     

Synaptonemal complex formation in hybrids of Lolium temulentum × Lolium perenne (L.)

The chromosomes of Lolium temulentum are longer and contain on average 50% more nuclear DNA than the chromosomes of L. perenne. In the hybrid, despite the difference in length and DNA content, pairing between the homoeologous chromosomes at pachytene is effective and the chiasma frequency at first metaphase in pollen mother cells is high, about 1.6 per bivalent, comparable to that in the L. perenne parent. Electron microscopic observations from reconstructed nuclei at pachytene show that synaptonemal complex (SC) formation in 40% of bivalents is perfect, complete and continuous from telomere to telomere. In others, SCs extend from telomere to telomere but incorporate lateral component loops in interstitial chromosome segments. Even in these bivalents, however, pairing is effective in the sense of chiasma formation. The capacity to form perfect SCs is achieved by an adjustment of chromosome length differences both before and during synapsis. Perfect pairing and SC formation is commoner within the larger bivalents of the complement. At zygotene, in contrast to pachytene, pairing is not confined to homoeologous chromosomes. On the contrary there is illegitimate pairing between non-homologous chromsomes resulting in multivalent formation. There must, therefore, be a mechanism operative between zygotene and pachytene that corrects and modifies associations in such a way as to restrict the pairing to bivalents comprised of strictly homoeologous chromosomes. Such a correction bears comparison with that known to apply in allopolyploids. In the hybrid and in the L. perenne parent also, certain specific nucleolar organisers are inactivated at meiosis.     

Synaptonemal complexes in insects

The synaptonemal complex (SC) is the key nuclear element formed in meiotic prophase I to join 2 homologous chromosomes at the pachytene bivalent. It is a highly conserved structure that is universally present in eukaryotes. The SC is presented as a tripartite protein structure, which consists of 2 lateral elements and a central region. In insects, the central region is particularly distinct and highly ordered. This made it possible to describe the fine structure of the central region and propose a model of its architecture. Chromatid DNA is arranged in chromatin loops extending radially from the SC. The loops appear to consist of a basic chromatin fiber with a diameter of 20–30 nm. In many insect species, synaptonemal polycomplexes occur in postpachytene cells. They represent one of the possible ways of SC degradation. Another process, which occurs beyond pachytene, is the formation of proteinaceous chromatid axis, the silver-stained chromatid core. Based on results in insect models, the chromatid cores have been related to the structure and formation of the SC. Research on insect models significantly contributed to understanding individual steps of the SC formation and temporal sequence of chromosome pairing. These include the formation of lateral elements of the SC, pairing initiation, interlocking of chromosomes, and synapsis of homologous chromosomes. Attention is also given to non-homologous pairing, including synaptic adjustment, correction of pairing, and pairing of sex chromosomes. In the next section, chiasmatic and achiasmatic modes of meiosis are compared with respect to the SC formation. In the chiasmatic mode, the SCs display recombination nodules that are believed to mediate the process of recombination. These nodules were discovered in insects, and indirect evidence for their role comes from insects. Two different examples of achiasmatic meiosis, occurring in the heterogametic sex of several insect orders, are given: one involves the SC formation, whereas in the other, SCs are absent. Finally, the potential of SC karyotyping for analysis of the insect genome is discussed.     

The nature and extent of synaptonemal complex formation in haploid barley

Normal synaptonemal complexes have been found in haploid barley meiotic prophase at stages equivalent to pachytene in diploids. Reconstructions of serially sectioned nuclei have shown that up to 60% of the haploid chromosomes may pair in either intra- or interchromosomal associations. The extent and nature of the synaptonemal complex formation suggest that the chromosome pairing is non-homologous. From the virtual absence of chiasmata in metaphase I stages of the haploids it is inferred that crossing over requires a more precise DNA alignment than is provided by synaptonemal complex formation alone.     

Chromosome pairing in the allotetraploid Aegilops biuncialis and a triploid intergeneric hybrid.

Chromosome pairing behaviour of the natural allotetraploid Aegilops biuncialis (genome UUMM) and a triploid hybrid Ae. biuncialis x Secale cereale (genome UMR) was analyzed by electron microscopy in surface-spread prophase I nuclei. Synaptonemal-complex analysis at zygotene and pachytene revealed that synapsis in the allotetraploid was mostly between homologous chromosomes, although a few quadrivalents were also formed. Only homologous bivalents were observed at metaphase I. In contrast, homoeologous and heterologous chromosome associations were common at prophase I and metaphase I of the triploid hybrid. It is concluded that the mechanism controlling bivalent formation in Ae. biuncialis acts mainly at zygotene by restricting pairing to homologous chromosomes, but also acts at pachytene by preventing chiasma formation in the homoeologous associations. In the hybrid the mechanism fails at both stages. Key words : Aegilops biuncialis, allotetraploid, intergeneric hybrid, pairing control, synaptonemal complex.     

Chromosome structure and pairing preferences in autotetraploid rye (Secale cereale).

The influence of chromosome structure upon pairing behaviour during meiosis was investigated by comparing four autotetraploid genotypes of rye (Secale cereale) containing homologous chromosome sets with different degrees of structural similarity. The series provided a range of genotypes that, at one extreme, contained structurally identical chromosome sets and, at the other extreme, sets that are certainly more heterozygous in the genic sense and probably also more diverse from a purely structural viewpoint. Relative frequencies of pairing configurations at meiotic prophase and metaphase I were compared by electron microscopy of whole-mount surface-spread synaptonemal complex complements and light microscopy of squash preparations. Despite unexpectedly low quadrivalent frequencies over all four genotypes, higher mean bivalent frequencies appeared to be associated with greater homologue diversity. In other words, greater structural divergence between chromosome sets appears to facilitate more efficient discrimination between homologous and identical chromosomes that drives the formation of bivalents. Statistical comparisons were not able to confirm in some cases the significance of the observed pattern of pairing behaviour.     

OsSPO11-1 is essential for both homologous chromosome pairing and crossover formation in rice

Spo11 is a homolog of a subunit of archaebacterial topoisomerase, which catalyzes DNA double-strand breaks and initiates homologous chromosome recombination. In the present study, we silenced the SPO11-1 gene in rice (Oryza sativa) using RNAi. Rice plants with loss-of-function of OsSPO11-1 have no apparent growth defects during vegetative development, but homologous chromosome pairing and recombination are significantly obstructed. Telomeres can be assembled as bouquet during the zygotene stage of the OsSPO11-1-deficient plants, just as that in wild type. Although the two axial-associated proteins, REC8 and PAIR2, are loaded onto the chromosomes, the depletion of PAIR2 from the chromosomes is much later than in wild type. The central element of the synaptonemal complex (SC), ZEP1, does not load onto the chromosomes normally, implying that SC formation is disturbed severely. The crossover protein, MER3, isn't efficiently assembled onto chromosomes and the lack of bivalent suggests that crossovers are also affected in the absence of OsSPO11-1. Thus, OsSPO11-1 is essential for both homologous chromosomes pairing and crossover formation during meiosis in rice.     

Complete meiotic pairing of crested newt chromosomes.

The longest chromosome (number 1) of Trituturus cristatus carries a heteromorphic segment, a heterozygosity perpetuated by a balanced lethal system. The heteromorphic segment is regarded as achiasmate and has been claimed to be asynaptic. Direct observations of chromosome pairing in spermatocytes and oocytes yield some cases where all homologous chromosomes appear to be completely paired, but the individual bivalents could not be identified as pachytene is not particularly clear in this species. The long arms of bivalent 1 usually remain attached by a terminal chiasma in spermatocytes of T. c. cristatus but the corresponding chiasma is only rarely present in T. c. carnifex spermatocytes. Synaptonemal complexes have been measured in both spermatocytes and oocytes of T. c. cristatus. A karyotype constructed from these measurements matches the main features of somatic and lampbrush chromosome karyotypes, indicating that all chromosomes must be completely paired and proportionately represented as synaptonemal complex. The total length of synaptonemal complex is much the same in spermatocytes and oocytes and is similar to the length in spermatocytes of Xenopus laevis. These two amphibian examples supplement a recent survey of other vertebrate classes to reinforce its conclusion that synaptonemal complex length is not related to genome size in vertebrates.     

Meiotic chromosome interactions in inbred autotetraploid rye (Secale cereale).

Electron microscopy of whole-mount surface-spread synaptonemal complex complements and conventional light microscopy of chromosomes at first metaphase of meiosis were used to compare the relative frequencies of pairing configurations at the two stages in inbred autotetraploid rye (Secale cereale L.). Statistical tests showed significantly fewer multivalents at first metaphase than expectations based on random initiation of synapsis at each telomeric site within each group of four homologues. Direct observations of synaptic behaviour of chromosomes showed that this deviation is due primarily to a preponderance of bivalents during zygotene and pachytene. It is also the result of a significant drop in multivalent frequency from meiotic prophase to metaphase I, which is attributable both to a lack of chiasmata with which to consolidate multivalents and inhibition of chiasma formation in synaptonemal complex segments of multivalents that are nonhomologous.     

Synaptonemal complexes in a subfertile man with a pericentric inversion in chromosome 21. Heterosynapsis without previous homosynapsis

Analysis of surface-spread synaptonemal complexes of zygotene and pachytene spermatocytes was carried out on a human male carrier of a pericentric inversion of chromosome 21 ascertained after four miscarriages. The synaptic behavior of the bivalent, which could be unambiguously identified by its nonaligned kinetochores, was analyzed. All zygotene and pachytene spermatocytes had 22 linearly paired autosomal bivalents, with apparently normal synaptonemal complexes, and no evidence of a loop configuration in the 50 cells analyzed. According to the XY type (classification of Solari), the cells were distributed across zygotene and pachytene stages, not exclusively in the late pachytene to which adjustment is conventionally thought to be confined. It is suggested that inverted segments heterosynapse at early pachytene, without previous homosynapsis. It is expected that this meiotic process leads to failure of crossing-over, reduces the production of unbalanced gametes, and the risk of recombinant offspring, but can increase the incidence of aneuploidy as a result of nondisjunction during meiosis I (a frequent cause of pregnancy wastage).     

The synaptic behaviour of the wild forms of Triticum turgidum and T. timopheevii.

Different wild allopolyploid species of Triticeae show extensive bivalent formation at zygotene while a considerable number of multivalents is present in cultivated polyploid wheats. To study the chromosome behaviour at early meiotic stages in wild forms of tetraploid wheats Triticum turgidum and T timopheevii (2n = 4x = 28) we have analysed the synaptic pattern in fully traced spread nuclei at mid- and late zygotene and at pachytene of wild accessions of these species. The mean number of synaptonemal complex (SC) bivalents at mid-zygotene ranged from 12.22 to 13.14 among the accessions studied indicating a strong restriction of synapsis initiation to homologous chromosomes. The mean of bivalents increased at pachytene because of the transformation of multivalents into bivalents. Ring bivalents observed at metaphase I support that SC bivalents were formed by homologous chromosomes. The average values of SC bivalents at mid-zygotene in the wild forms are much higher than the average values observed in the cultivated tetraploid wheats but similar to that of a mutant line of T turgidum with a duplication that includes Ph1, the major homoeologous pairing suppressor locus. These results suggest that the efficiency of the mechanism operating in the homologous recognition for synapsis is higher in wild wheat populations than in cultivated varieties. Apparently, a relatively detrimental modification of the pairing regulating genetic system accompanied the domestication of the wild wheat forms.     

Synaptonemal complex formation in hybrids of Lolium temulentum × Lolium perenne (L.)

Chromosome pairing and synaptonemal complex formation at zygotene and pachytene are described from serial section reconstructions of pollen mother cell nuclei in a triploid hybrid containing two haploid sets of Lolium perenne chromosomes, one of L. temulentum and two acces-sory B chromosomes. At pachytene the homologous L. perenne chromosomes form complete and continuous synaptonemal complexes while the L. temulentum chromosomes show extensive nonhomologous pairing both within and between themselves. At zygotene however, homoeologous pairing in the form of a trivalent and very little non-homologous pairing is observed. Evidently, there exists a mechanism that eliminates homoeologous association during zygotene to ensure strict bivalent formation between homologous chromosomes at pachytene. In Lolium this mechanism is under the influence of the B chromosomes and bears close similarity with that in allohexaploid wheat controlled by the Ph locus.