The influence of lipid composition on the barrier properties of band 3-containing lipid vesicles

Band 3 protein has been incorporated into lipid vesicles consisting of 94:6 (molar ratio) egg phosphatidylcholine-bovine heart phosphatidylserine or total erythrocyte lipids by means of a Triton X-100 Bio-Beads method, with an additional sonication step prior to the removal of the detergent. This methods results, for both types of band 3 lipid vesicles, in rather homogeneous vesicles with comparable protein content and vesicle trap. Freeze-fracture electron microscopy revealed that band 3-egg phosphatidylcholine-bovine heart phosphatidylserine vesicles have considerably more intramembrane particles as compared to the band 3-erythrocyte lipid vesicles. The dimensions of the nonspecific permeation pathways present in the band 3-lipid vesicles were measured using an influx assay procedure for nonelectrolytes of different size, in which the vesicles were sampled and subsequently freed from nonenclosed labeled permeant by means of gel-filtration. The band 3-egg phosphatidylcholine-bovine heart phosphatidylserine vesicles have nonspecific permeation pathways (pores), with diameters of up to 60 A. In contrast, the band 3-total erythrocyte lipid vesicles are more homogeneous and show much smaller nonspecific permeation pathways, having a diameter of about 12 A. These results suggest that the nonspecific permeability of the band 3-lipid vesicles is strongly lipid-dependent. Increase in specific anion permeability expected as a consequence of the presence of band 3 in the erythrocyte lipid vesicles was found to be very limited. However, stereospecific, phloretin-inhibitable D-glucose permeability could clearly be demonstrated in these vesicles. The difference of the nonspecific permeability of the band 3-egg phosphatidylcholine-bovine heart phosphatidylserine vesicles and band 3-erythrocyte lipid vesicles, is discussed in the light of the presence of defects at the lipid/protein interface and protein aggregation, which may induce formation of pores.     

Preparation of reconstituted cytochrome oxidase vesicles with defined trans-membrane protein orientations employing a cytochrome c affinity column

Reconstituted cytochrome oxidase systems in which the majority of the vesicles contain a single oxidase dimer can be prepared. It is shown that, when these are passed through a cytochrome c affinity column, only those vesicles oriented outwards (such that the active site is available to external cytochrome c) are bound to the support matrix. Protein-free vesicles and vesicles containing an inwardly oriented enzyme are eluted in the void volume. Subsequently, vesicles containing an outwardly oriented enzyme can be eluted from the column at high salt concentrations. This protocol has been used successfully to resolve vesicles of either oxidase orientation when the enzyme is reconstituted with a variety of lipid mixtures. The recovery of oxidase activity from the column ranged between 75 and 94%.     

Studies on the effect of the lipid phase transition on the interaction of glucagon with dimyristoyl glycerophosphocholine

Glucagon is found to interact with dimyristoyl glycerophosphocholine both above and below the phase transition temperature of the lipid. Above the phase transition temperature the interaction is manifested by an increase in the rate of vesicle aggregation and by an increased permeability of unilamellar vesicles to Eu³⁺ and to Fe(CN)₆³⁻. However, no stable lipoprotein complex can be detected by gel filtration. Below the phase transition glucagon can form stable complexes with dimyristoyl glycerophosphocholine vesicles but cannot rapidly rearrange these vesicles to disk-shaped particles until the phase transition temperature is approached. The energy of activation for the dissociation of glucagon from the disk-shaped lipoprotein particle is 29 kcal/mol at temperatures above 36°C but increases markedly at lower temperatures, as the region of the lipid phase transition is approached. This increase in energy of activation at lower temperatures is most probably due to the larger amount of energy required to rearrange gel-state lipid in the transition state and provides an explanation for the unusual kinetic stability of the glucagon-dimyristoyl glycerophosphocholine lipoprotein complex only at temperatures below the phase transition of the lipid.     

The anion permeability of vesicles reconstituted with intrinsic proteins from the human erythrocyte membrane

Band 3 protein was reconstituted with lipid vesicles consisting of 94:6 (molar ratio) egg phosphatidylcholine-bovine heart phosphatidylserine in a 2500:1 phospholipid:protein molar ratio by means of a Triton X-100/beads method. The SO2-4 permeability of the resulting vesicles was measured using an influx assay procedure in which the vesicles were sampled and subsequently eluted over Sephadex columns at appropriate time intervals. The accuracy of the assay was greatly increased by using an internal standard in order to correct for vesicle recovery. In agreement with previous work, it could be demonstrated that incorporation of band 3 in the vesicles caused an increase in SO2-4 permeability, which could be (partially) inhibited by high concentrations of DIDS or a competitive anion such as thiocyanate. However, the magnitude of the increased SO2-4 permeability was highly variable, even when vesicles were reconstituted using band 3 isolated from one batch of ghosts. In addition, the SO2-4 influx curves showed complex kinetics. These results are related to the existence of vesicle heterogeneity with respect to protein content and vesicle size as revealed by stractan density gradient centrifugation and freeze-fracture electron microscopy. Band 3 incorporation also increased the L-glucose permeability of the vesicles which could also be inhibited by DIDS. Glycophorin, which has no known transport function, reconstituted with lipid vesicles consisting of 94:6 (molar ratio) egg phosphatidylcholine-bovine heart phosphatidylserine in a 400:1 phospholipid:protein molar ration increased the bilayer permeability towards SO2-4 as well as towards L-glucose. Surprisingly, the SO2-4 permeability in the vesicles could also be inhibited by DIDS and thiocyanate. It is concluded that the use of DIDS and a competitive anion, thiocyanate, in order to prove that band 3 is functionally reconstituted, is highly questionable. The increased SO2-4 and L-glucose permeability of band 3-lipid as well as glycophorin-lipid vesicles and the inhibitory action of DIDS are discussed in the light of the presence of defects at the lipid/protein interface and protein aggregation, which may induce the formation of pores. Since the band 3-lipid vesicles are more permeable for SO2-4 than for L-glucose, in contrast to the glycophorin-containing vesicles, it is suggested that some anion specificity of the increased bilayer permeability in the band 3-lipid vesicles is still preserved.     

Permeability behaviour of lipid vesicles prepared from plant plasma membranes--impact of compositional changes

Exposure of oat seedlings to repeated moderate water deficit stress causes a drought acclimation of the seedlings. This acclimation is associated with changes in the lipid composition of the plasma membrane of root cells. Here, plasma membranes from root cells of acclimated and control plants were isolated using the two-phase partitioning method. Membrane vesicles were prepared of total lipids extracted from the plasma membranes. In a series of tests the vesicle permeability for glucose and for protons were analysed and compared with the permeability of model vesicles. Further, the importance of critical components for the permeability properties was analysed by modifying the lipid composition of the vesicles from acclimated and from control plants. The purpose was to add specific lipids to vesicles from acclimated plants to mimic the composition of the vesicles from control plants and vice versa. The plasma membrane lipid vesicles from acclimated plants had a significantly increased permeability for glucose and decreased permeability for protons as compared to control vesicles. The results point to the importance of the ratio phosphatidylcholine (PC)/phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), the levels of cerebrosides and free sterols and the possible interaction of these components for the plasma membrane as a permeability barrier.     

Fluorescent probe study of temperature-induced conformational changes in cytochrome oxidase in lecithin vesicle and solubilized systems

A protein-bound label, N-(1-anilinonaphthyl-4)-maleimide (ANM), was used to investigate conformational changes in bovine heart cytochrome oxidase. The fluidity of cytochrome oxidase vesicles was monitored by a lipophilic probe, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene. The fluroescence intensity and emission anisotropy of these probes were examined between 4 and 60 degrees C in enzyme--dipalmitoyllecithin vesicles, in enzyme--dimyristoyllecithin vesicles, in enzyme--dioleoyllecithin vesicles, and in the soluble enzyme. The temperature-dependent changes in these quantities indicated that there were two types of conformational changes in oxidized cytochrome oxidase: one was attributed to an intrinsic enzyme conformation change which occurred around 20 degrees C, and the other was attributed to a conformational change induced by the lipid phase transition. Although ANM-reactive subunits of cytochrome oxidase in these four lecithin vesicle and solubilized systems were different from each other, subunit I always reacted with ANM in preference to other subunits.     

Thermotropic behavior of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine in the presence of cytochrome c oxidase

The thermotropic behavior of lipid vesicles prepared from dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine in the presence of cytochrome c oxidase has been studied by highly sensitive differential scanning microcalorimetry. This protein has a remarkable effect on the gel–liquid crystalline transition of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine. In the presence of cytochrome c oxidase, the thermogram of the lipid vesicles exhibits a second endothermic peak, which is adjacent to the main lipid phase-transition peak and appears at a higher temperature. As the concentration of added protein increases, the two endothermic peaks become further separated, and the transition temperatures and the heats of transition corresponding to both endothermic peaks decrease. A greater decrease in the transition temperature at the lower-temperature peak with added protein suggests that the lower-temperature peak is more perturbed than the higher-temperature peak. The higher-temperature peak is not thermally reversible. Treatment of sample well above the transition temperature results in a reduction of the magnitude of the higher-temperature peak. The lipid–protein interaction contributing to the higher-temperature peak is discussed.     

Influence of the growth at high osmolality on the lipid composition, water permeability and osmotic response of Lactobacillus bulgaricus

Changes in water permeability and membrane packing were measured in cells of Lactobacillus bulgaricus and in vesicles prepared with lipids extracted from them. The osmotic response of whole cells and vesicles is compared with the one of bacteria grown in a high osmolal medium. Both bacteria and vesicles, behave as osmometers. This means that the volume decrease is promoted by the outflow of water, driven by the NaCl concentration difference, arguing that neither Na+ nor Cl- permeates the cell or the lipid membrane in these conditions. Therefore, the volume changes can be correlated with the rate of water permeation across the cell or the vesicle membranes. The permeation of water was analyzed as a function of the lipid species by measuring the volume changes and the saturation ratio of the lipids. To put into relevance the membrane processes, the permeation properties of lipid vesicles prepared with lipids extracted from bacteria grown in normal and high osmolality conditions were also analyzed. The permeation response was correlated with the physical properties of the membrane of whole cells and vesicles, by means of fluorescence anisotropy of diphenyl hexatriene (DPH). The modifications in membrane properties are related with the changes in the membrane composition triggered by the growth in a high osmolal medium. The changes appear related to an increase in the sugar content of the whole pool of lipids and in the saturated fatty acid residues.     

Effect of chilling temperatures on osmotic water permeability and aquaporin activity in the plasma membranes from pea roots

The osmotic water permeability of plasma membrane vesicles was examined after isolation from the roots of 7-day-old etiolated pea ( Pisum sativum, cv. Orlovchanin) seedlings grown at optimal temperature and those exposed to 1-day chilling at 8°C in the end of the growth period. The homogenization medium for obtaining plasma membranes was supplemented with either SH-reagents or protein phosphatase inhibitors. The plasmalemma vesicles were purified from the microsome fraction by means of two-phase polymer system. The osmotic water permeability of membrane vesicles was evaluated from the rate of their osmotically induced shrinkage. The lowering of growth temperature was accompanied by the increase in osmotic water permeability of plasmalemma. These changes occurred without the corresponding increase in aquaporin content or permeability of membrane lipid matrix. The membranes from cooled seedlings were markedly depleted in the content of SH-groups. Furthermore, the treatment of membrane samples with a thiol-reducing agent, tributylphosphine did not raise the SH-group content in membranes from chilled plants, unlike such changes in membranes from warm-grown plants. When the homogenization medium contained dithiothreitol and phenylarsine oxide (an inhibitor of tyrosine protein phosphatases), the osmotic permeability of plasmalemma in preparations from warm-grown seedlings also increased. Based on these results, it is supposed that aquaporin-mediated water permeability of membranes is regulated through different pathways under optimal and adverse conditions for plant growth. Direct action of endogenous SH redox regulators on aquaporin activity is likely under optimal growth conditions, while protein phosphatase might mediate changes in aquaporin activity under unfavorable growth conditions.     

Investigation of polyene macrolide antibiotic-induced permeability changes in vesicles by 31P nuclear magnetic resonance

The permeability of egg yolk lecithin (EYL) vesicles to Pr3+ has been measured by 31P nuclear magnetic resonance (nmr) spectroscopy. Measurable Pr3+ leakage into the internal aqueous compartment of EYL vesicles at ambient (21 degrees C) temperature required the presence of small (7--10 mol%) amounts of dicetyl phosphate (DCP). The permeability of DCP-containing vesicles is decreased by incorporation of sterol (cholesterol greater than ergosterol approximately 5.6-dihydroergosterol greater than zymosterol) into the lipid bilayer. Addition of the polyene macrolide antibiotic, nystatin, to DCP-containing EYL vesicles with and without sterol resulted in increased Pr3+ permeability at the three temperatures studied (21--37.5 degrees C). Permeability changes observed upon addition of nystatin to sterol-impregnated, DCP-containing vesicles varied with sterol structure: ergosterol approximately 5,6-dihydroergosterol greater than cholesterol approximately zymosterol. These results are compared with other polyene macrolide induced permeability changes on model and natural membrane systems. Permeability changes induced by nystatin in sterol-free EYL vesicles were generally greater than for comparable sterol-containing vesicles. This is attributed to a nonspecific interaction of the antibiotic with the latter vesicles.     

Effect of temperature on the formation of liquid phase-separating giant unilamellar vesicles (GUV)

Giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) are widely used as model systems to study both, lipid and membrane protein behavior. During their preparation by the commonly applied electroformation method, a number of issues must be considered to avoid the production of artifacts due to a poor lipid hydration and protein degradation. Here we focus on the effect of preparation temperature on GUVs composed of the most commonly used domain-forming mixture dioleoylelphospatidylcholine/shingomyelin/cholesterol (DOPC/SM/chol) (2/2/1). Lower production temperatures are generally preferable when aiming at a functional reconstitution of proteins into the membrane. On the other hand, lower growth temperature is suspected to alter the lipid composition and the yield of phase-separating vesicles. By confocal imaging, we find that vesicles prepared significantly above and below the melting temperature T(m) have the same overall morphology, similar size distributions of vesicles and a similar area coverage by liquid-ordered (L(o)) domains. However, a large population analysis indeed reveals a different overall yield of phase-separating vesicles. Two-focus scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy measurements did not show any divergence of lipid analog mobility in (L(o)) and (L(d)) phases in vesicles prepared at different temperatures, indicating that the lowered growth temperature did not influence the lipid organization within the two phases. Moreover, the expected advantages of lower preparation temperature for proteo-GUVs could be exemplified by the reconstitution of voltage dependent anion channel (VDAC) into DOPC/SM/chol GUVs, which aggregates at high, but not at low preparation temperatures.     

Monitoring of the Membrane Potential in Proteoliposomes with Incorporated Cytochrome-c Oxidase Using the Fluorescent Dye Indocyanine

A method has been developed to monitor changes of the membrane potential across vesicle membranes in real time. Using the potential-sensitive fluorescent dye indocyanine and on the basis of a water/lipid redistribution model, a calculation procedure has been introduced to estimate the membrane potential in vesicles with incorporated cytochrome-c oxidase. Physical parameters, such as vesicle size distribution and density of the lipid bilayer were estimated and used as calculation parameters. By extrapolation of the transient potential change to zero time, the initial rate of the potential change (dU/dt) could be calculated. It is also shown, that the initial potential change (dU/dt) may be used to study the proton/electron stoichiometry of cytochrome-c oxidase incorporated in the vesicles. Received: 28 September 1995/Revised: 6 February 1996     

Calorimetric studies of cytochrome oxidase-phospholipid interactions

Thermotropic phase transitions in phospholipid vesicles reconstituted with mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase (EC 1.9.3.1) were studied using differential scanning calorimetry. Both dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and mixtures of DMPC and cardiolipin were used at different lipid-to-protein ratios. The incorporated protein reduces the energy absorbed during phase transitions of DMPC vesicles, and causes a small decrease in the transition temperature (tm). delta H depends on the amount of protein in the vesicles. This dependence indicates that about 72 DMPC molecules are influenced per cytochrome alpha alpha 3 monomer. The transition parameters remain unaffected by changes in ionic strength or by reduction of the enzyme. Incorporation of cytochrome oxidase depleted of subunit III into DMPC liposomes resulted in a larger decrease of tm, but the amount of perturbed phospholipids remains similar to that in the case of the intact enzyme. Incorporation of cytochrome oxidase into DMPC/cardiolipin vesicles counteracts the effect of cardiolipin in decreasing the enthalpy of the DMPC transition. Thus cytochrome oxidase segregates the phospholipids by attracting cardiolipin from the bulk lipid. Cytochrome c does not significantly affect this apparent cardiolipin 'shell' around membranous cytochrome oxidase.     

Interaction of intestinal brush border membrane vesicles with small unilamellar phospholipid vesicles. Exchange of lipids between membranes is mediated by collisional contact

The kinetics of lipid transfer from small unilamellar vesicles as the donor to brush border vesicles as the acceptor have been investigated by following the transfer of radiolabeled or spin-labeled lipid molecules in the absence of exchange protein. The labeled lipid molecules studied were various radiolabeled and spin-labeled phosphatidylcholines, radiolabeled cholesteryl oleate, and a spin-labeled cholestane. At a given temperature and brush border vesicle concentration similar pseudo-first-order rate constants (half-lifetimes) were observed for different lipid labels used. The lipid transfer is shown to be an exchange reaction leading to an equal distribution of label in donor and acceptor vesicles at equilibrium (time t----infinity). The lipid exchange is a second-order reaction with rate constants being directly proportional to the brush border vesicle concentration. The results are only consistent with a collision-induced exchange of lipid molecules between small unilamellar phospholipid vesicles and brush border vesicles. Other mechanisms such as collision-induced fusion or diffusion of lipid monomers through the aqueous phase are negligible at least under our experimental conditions.     

Changes in plasma-membrane lipid composition: a strategy for acclimation to copper stress

Wheat seedlings were grown hydroponically in the presence of 50 microM Cu2+. The copper stress resulted in plasma-membrane (PM) changes of the root cells as altered lipid composition, a decreased phosphatidylcholine (PC)/phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) ratio from 0.7 to 0.3, a decreased fatty acyl unsaturation and a decrease in the lipid/protein ratio. Membrane vesicles made from total lipid extracts of isolated PMs of wheat grown under copper excess showed a remarkably low permeability to polar molecules like glucose, as compared with the control, and no difference in proton permeability. Permeability studies of vesicles of plasma-membrane lipids, which were selectively modified by addition of specific lipids such as PC and PE, were also performed. The results are discussed with emphasis on the role of the increased PE proportion.     

The fusogenic effect of synthetic polycations on negatively charged lipid bilayers

The effect of synthetic polycations, polyallylamine, and polyethylenimine, on liposomes containing phosphatidylserine was investigated along with that of polylysine and divalent cations. The addition of polycations caused aggregation of sonicated vesicles composed of phosphatidylserine and phosphatidylcholine (molar ratio 1:4) as determined by measuring the turbidity changes. Liposomal turbidity increased 10 times compared with that of control liposomes at charge ratios of polymer/vesicle from 0.23 (polylysine) to 2.5 (linear polyethylenimine), while the turbidity was unchanged by the addition of Ca2+ or Mg2+ at charge ratios up to 500. These polycations also induced intermixing of liposomal membranes as indicated by resonance energy transfer between fluorescent lipids incorporated in lipid bilayers, without inducing drastic permeability changes as determined from the calcein release. Fifty percent intermixing of liposomes (0.05 mM as lipid concentration) was induced by these polycations at charge ratios of around 1.0. However, the highest resonance energy transfer was produced by the addition of polyallylamine, which caused multicycles of membrane intermixing between vesicles. Polycation-induced membrane intermixing and permeability changes of phosphatidylserine liposomes were also investigated. At charge ratios of around 1.0, these polymers caused resonance energy transfer of fluorescent lipids incorporated in separate vesicles; however, polyallylamine and branched polyethylenimine also caused permeability increases of liposomal membranes. Membrane intermixing and permeability changes of phosphatidylserine vesicles induced by polyallylamine were dependent on the polymer/vesicle charge ratio, and were different from those induced by Ca2+ since the latter caused half-maximal membrane intermixing or permeability change of phosphatidylserine vesicles at about 1 mM at the liposomal concentrations investigated.     

Electrostatic forces control the penetration of membranes by charged solutes

Using fluorescent, anionic dyes such as carboxyfluorescein as model solutes, it is shown that the forces allowing such solutes to be retained within sealed lipid vesicles, against a large concentration gradient, can be primarily electrostatic in nature. At temperatures distant from that of the ordered-fluid lipid phase transition a small number of the anionic dye molecules trapped within lipid vesicles are capable of traversing the lipid bilayer and establishing an electrical diffusion potential across the membrane. Further solute movement can then only occur with the concomitant permeation of ions which restore electrical balance. A significant flux of dye can be triggered by (a) increasing the permeability of the membrane to ions (for example by the addition of ionophores such as gramicidin, or by allowing the lipid to approach a phase transition) or by (b) adding lipophilic counterions such as tetraphenylborate or dinitrophenol to the system.     

Electrostatic forces control the penetration of membranes by charged solutes

Using fluorescent, anionic dyes such as carboxyfluorescein as model solutes, it is shown that the forces allowing such solutes to be retained within sealed lipid vesicles, against a large concentration gradient, can be primarily electrostatic in nature. At temperatures distant from that of the ordered-fluid lipid phase transition a small number of the anionic dye molecules trapped within lipid vesicles are capable of traversing the lipid bilayer and establishing an electrical diffusion potential across the membrane. Further solute movement can then only occur with the concomitant permeation of ions which restore electrical balance. A significant flux of dye can be triggered by (a) increasing the permeability of the membrane to ions (for example by the addition of ionophores such as gramicidin, or by allowing the lipid to approach a phase transition) or by (b) adding lipophilic counterions such as tetraphenylborate or dinitrophenol to the system.     

Shear stress induced lipid order and permeability changes of giant unilamellar vesicles

BackgroundThe permeability of a lipid bilayer is a function of its phase state and depends non-linearly on thermodynamic variables such as temperature, pressure or pH. We investigated how shear forces influence the phase state of giant unilamellar vesicles and their membrane permeability.MethodsWe determined the permeability of giant unilamellar vesicles composed of different phospholipid species under shear flow in a tube at various temperatures around and far off the melting point by analyzing the release of fluorescently labelled dextran. Furthermore, we quantified phase state changes of these vesicles under shear forces using spectral decomposition of the membrane embedded fluorescent dye Laurdan.ResultsWe observed that the membrane permeability follows a step function with increasing permeability at the transition from the gel to the fluid phase and vice versa. Second, there was an all-or-nothing permeabilization near the main phase transition temperature and a gradual dye release far off the melting transition. Third, the Laurdan phase state analysis suggests that shear forces induce a reversible melting temperature shift in giant unilamellar vesicle membranes.Major conclusionsThe observed effects can be explained best in a scenario in which shear forces directly induce membrane pores that possess relatively long pore lifetimes in proximity to the phase transition.General significanceOur study elucidates the release mechanism of thermo-responsive drug carriers as we found that liposome permeabilization is not continuous but quantized. Furthermore, the shear force induced melting temperature shift must be taken into consideration when thermo-responsive liposomes are designed.     

A quantitative characterisation of H+ translocation by cytochrome c oxidase vesicles

A quantitative analysis of H+ extrusion by reconstituted cytochrome c oxidase vesicles is presented with particular regard to the decay kinetics of the extruded proton pulse and to the structural heterogeneity of the vesicle preparation. The decay of the extruded H+ pulse under conditions typical of those used for its measurement is much slower than expected from the passive proton permeability of the vesicle membranes. It is shown that this apparent anomaly results from insufficient transmembrane charge equilibration via valinomycin and K+ during oxidase turnover. This situation can be remedied by increasing the valinomycin concentration or by replacing this counterion system with 1 mM tetraphenylphosphonium. Under these latter conditions, the decay kinetics can be described as the sum of two exponential terms. To facilitate interpretation of the proton pump decay kinetics, a structural analysis of the oxidase vesicle preparation is presented. The bulk of the reconstituted vesicles (i.e., those representing approx. 80% of the total oxidase and lipid) are 30-62 nm in diameter. At least 70% of the reconstituted oxidase molecules are contained individually in separate vesicles, indicating that the enzyme monomer is competent in H+ translocation.