The systematic relationships of glucosinolate-producing plants and related families: a cladistic investigation based on morphological and molecular characters

A cladistic analysis is performed using 94 morphological and biochemical characters for 42 genera to compare a phylogeny based on morphological data with those obtained using different genes ( rbc L, atp B, 18S RNA, mat K) or their combination with morphological data, and to understand the floral evolution within the expanded Brassicales (Capparales) relative to Sapindales and Malvales. The tree produced with morphological data is congruent with those obtained from macromolecular studies in obtaining a well-supported glucosinolate-producing clade and an expanded Sapindales. The combined analysis of the morphological and molecular characters is generally well resolved with support for many of the relationships. The inclusion of the fossil taxon Dressiantha demonstrates the value of inserting fossil evidence in phylogenetic analyses. However, the fossil appears to be related to the Anacardiaceae and not to the Brassicales. The core Brassicales are well supported by a number of synapomorphies, although the internal position of Tovariaceae and Pentadiplandraceae is not well resolved. Emblingiaceae appears to be related to Bataceae and Salvadoraceae. Several significant morphological characters are mapped on the combined trees and their evolutionary significance is discussed. Within Brassicales and Sapindales several well supported clades can be recognized which merit ordinal or subordinal status, putting the present orders at a higher level; these include: Tropaeolales, Setchellanthales, Batidales, Brassicales (Brassiciflorae), Burserales, Sapindales and Rutales (Sapindiflorae). The present scheme of affinities within the Brassicales corresponds well with a gradual morphological evolution in the order.  © 2006 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2006, 151 , 453–494.     

REEXAMINATION OF PHYLOGENETIC RELATIONSHIPS WITHIN THE COLONIAL VOLVOCALES (CHLOROPHYTA): AN ANALYSIS OF atpB AND rbcL GENE SEQUENCES

The chloroplast-encoded atp B gene was sequenced from 33 strains representing 28 species of the colonial Volvocales (the Volvocaceae and its relatives) to reexamine phylogenetic relationships as previously deduced by morphological data and rbc L gene sequence data.1128 base pairs in the coding regions of the atp B gene were analyzed by MP, NJ, and ML analyses. Although supported with relatively low bootstrap values (75% and 65% in the NJ and ML analyses, respectively), three anisogamous/oogamous volvocacean genera— Eudorina, Pleodorina, and Volvox, excluding the section Volvox (= Euvolvox, illegitimate name), constituted a large monophyletic group (Eudorina group). Outside the Eudorina group, a robust lineage composed of three species of Volvox sect. Volvox was resolved as in the rbc L gene trees, rejecting the hypothesis of the previous cladistic analysis based on morphological data that the genus Volvox is monophyletic. In addition, the NJ and ML trees suggested that Eudorina is a nonmonophyletic genus as inferred from the morphological data and rbc L gene sequences. Although phylogenetic status of the genus Gonium is ambiguous in the rbc L gene trees and the paraphyly of this genus is resolved in the cladistic analysis based on morphological data, the atp B gene sequence data suggest monophyly of Gonium with relatively low bootstrap values (56–61%) in the NJ and ML trees. On the basis of the combined sequence data (2256 base pairs) from atp B and rbc L genes, Gonium was resolved as a robust monophyletic genus in the NJ and ML trees (with 68–86% bootstrap values), and Eudorina elegans Ehrenberg represented a paraphyletic species positioned most basally within the Eudorina group. However, phylogenetic status and relationships of the families of the colonial Volvocales were still almost ambiguous even in the combined analysis.     

A Phylogenetic Analysis of the Plastid matK Gene with Emphasis on Melanthiaceae sensu lato

Abstract: The presented mat K tree primarily agrees well with the previously presented rbc L tree and combined rbc L + atp B + 18SrDNA tree. According to the mat K tree, the monocotyledons are monophyletic with 100 % bootstrap support. Acorus diverges first from all other monocotyledons (90 % bootstrap support) in which two major clades are recognized: one (89 %) consisting of Alismatanae and Tofieldia (Nartheciaceae), and the other (< 50 %) comprising Lilianae, Commelinanae and Nartheciaceae other than Tofieldia. Within the latter major clade, Petrosavia and Japonolirion (Nartheciaceae) (82 %) diverge first from the remaining taxa (< 50 %) in which two clades are formed: one (81 %) consisting of Pandanales, Dioscoreales and Nartheciaceae-Narthecioideae, and the other (< 50 %) comprising Liliales, Asparagales and Commelinanae. In the former clade, Dioscoreales and Narthecioideae are grouped together (88 %). In the latter clade, Asparagales and Commelinanae are grouped together (< 50 %). Differences between the mat K and rbc L tree topologies appear in the positions of Tricyrtis (Calochortaceae) and Dracaenaceae. Differences between the mat K and combined rbc L + atp B + 18SrDNA tree topologies exist in the positions of the Petrosavia-Japonolirion pair (Nartheciaceae) and Pandanales. The stop codon position of the mat K gene appears to be highly variable among the monocotyledons, especially in the Liliales.     

Isolation of precise plastid deletion mutants by homology-based excision: a resource for site-directed mutagenesis, multi-gene changes and high-throughput plastid transformation

We describe a simple and efficient homology-based excision method to delete plastid genes. The procedure allows one or more adjacent plastid genes to be deleted without the retention of a marker gene. We used aad A-based transformation to duplicate a 649 bp region of plastid DNA corresponding to the atp B promoter region. Efficient recombination between atp B repeats deletes the intervening foreign genes and 1984 bp of plastid DNA (co-ordinates 57 424–59 317) containing the rbc L gene. Only five foreign bases are present in Δ rbc L plants illustrating the precision of homology-based excision. Sequence analysis of non-functional rbc L-related sequences in Δ rbc L plants indicated an extra-plastidic origin. Mutant Δ rbc L plants were heterotrophic, pale-green and contained round plastids with reduced amounts of thylakoids. Restoration of autotrophy and leaf pigmentation following aad A-based transformation with the wild-type rbc L gene ruled out mutations in other genes. Excision and re-use of aadA shows that, despite the multiplicity of plastid genomes, homology-based excision ensures complete removal of functional aad A genes. Rescue of the Δ rbc L mutation and autotrophic growth stabilizes transgenic plastids in heteroplasmic transformants following antibiotic withdrawal, enhancing the overall efficiency of plastid transformation. Unlike the available set of homoplasmic knockout mutants in 25 plastid genes, the rbc L deletion mutant isolated here is readily transformed with the efficient aad A marker gene. This improvement in deletion design facilitates advanced studies that require the isolation of double mutants in distant plastid genes and the replacement of the deleted locus with site-directed mutant alleles and is not easily achieved using other methods.     

Molecular dating of the 'Gondwanan' plant family Proteaceae is only partially congruent with the timing of the break-up of Gondwana

Aim  The flowering plant family Proteaceae is putatively of Gondwanan age, with modern and fossil lineages found on all southern continents. Here we test whether the present distribution of Proteaceae can be explained by vicariance caused by the break-up of Gondwana.
Location  Africa, especially southern Africa, Australia, New Zealand, South America, New Caledonia, New Guinea, Southeast Asia, Sulawesi, Tasmania.
Methods  We obtained chloroplast DNA sequence data from the rbc L gene, the rbc L- atp B spacer, and the atp B gene from leaf samples of forty-five genera collected from the field and from living collections. We analysed these data using Bayesian phylogenetic and molecular dating methods, with five carefully selected fossil calibration points to obtain age estimates for the nodes within the family.
Results  Four of eight trans-continental disjunctions of sister groups within our sample of the Proteaceae post-date the break-up of Gondwana. These involve independent lineages, two with an Africa-Australia disjunction, one with an Africa–South America disjunction, and one with a New Zealand–Australasia disjunction. The date of the radiation of the bird-pollinated Embothriinae corresponds approximately to the hypothesized date of origin of nectar-feeding birds in Australia.
Main conclusions  The findings suggest that disjunct distributions in Proteaceae result from both Gondwanan vicariance and transoceanic dispersal. Our results imply that ancestors of some taxa dispersed across oceans rather than rafting with Gondwanan fragments as previously thought. This finding agrees with other studies of Gondwanan plants in dating the divergence of Australian, New Zealand and New Caledonian taxa in the Eocene, consistent with the existence of a shared, ancestral Eocene flora but contrary to a vicariance scenario based on accepted geological knowledge.     

A REASSESSMENT OF PHYLOGENETIC RELATIONSHIPS WITHIN THE PHAEOPHYCEAE BASED ON RUBISCO LARGE SUBUNIT AND RIBOSOMAL DNA SEQUENCES

To better assess the current state of phaeophycean phylogeny, we compiled all currently available rbc L, 18S, and 26S rDNA sequences from the EMBL/GenBank database and added 21 new rbc L sequences of our own. We then developed three new alignments designed to maximize taxon sampling while minimizing information loss due to partial sequences. Phylogenetic analyses were performed on separate and combined data sets (with and without taxa from the sister classes Tribophyceae and Phaeothamniophyceae as outgroups) using a variety of assumption sets, tree-drawing algorithms (parsimony, neighbor joining, and likelihood), and resampling methods (bootstrap, decay, jackknife). Partition homogeneity testing (PHT) by codon position within rbc L showed that all positions could be used despite mild third position saturation. PHT by gene and domain within rDNA showed that the 26S D1 and D2 regions do not enhance phylogenetic signal even when combined with the 18S. The rbc L and rDNA (excluding the 26S D1 and D2) could be combined under PHT. The topology of the combined tree was the same as that of the rbc L tree alone, but bootstrap support was consistently higher in the combined analysis, applied to more branches, and enabled the establishment of sister group relationships among six orders. Although the taxon sampling for the combination tree was lower ( n = 22) than for individual gene analyses ( n = 58 for rbc L and n = 59 for rDNA), results show that the Laminariales (previously reported) and Sphacelariales (new) are both paraphyletic. Choristocarpus tenellus (Kützing) Zanardini is the most basal phaeophyte and the Dictyotales the most basal order. In contrast, the Laminariales sensu stricto ( s.s. ) and Ectocarpales sensu lato ( s.l. ) are the most derived. For phylogenetic studies in the Phaeophyceae, rbc L has more resolving power than rDNA, though the reason for this is unclear based on the fact that both genes are highly conserved.     

DNA序列在植物系统学研究中的应用

植物DNA序列由于进化速率上的差异而适用于不同分类阶元的系统发育研究,因此,针对某一特定的系统学问题选择相应合适的分子片段是分子系统学研究中最为关键的一步。在前人研究的基础上,主要讨论了目前分子系统发育和进化研究中一些常用的DNA序列的适用范围,包括nrDNA的18S基因及ITS等非编码区,cpDNA的编码基因（rbcI、matK、ndhF、atpB）及非编码区序列（rpL16、rpoC1、rps16、trnL-F和trnT-L）和应用较少的mtDNA。研究表明,18S、rbcI等编码基因及mtDNA一般适用于较高分类阶元甚至整个种子植物谱系间的系统发育的探讨,而ITS及cpDNA的非编码区序列等因其较快的进化速率多用于较低分类阶元的系统关系研究。     

Phylogenetic Analyses of Aurantioideae (Rutaceae) Based on Non-Coding Plastid DNA Sequences and Phytochemical Features

Abstract: Sequences of the plastid DNA atp B/ rbc L intergenic spacer and rps16 intron from 23 genera and 47 species of Rutaceae were used to resolve phylogenetic relationships in subfamily Aurantioideae. According to these, the subfamily is monophyletic, but its classical subdivision into tribes Clauseneae and Citreae is only justified if the genus Murraya s.s. (exclusive of the species segregated as Bergera , e.g., Murraya koenigii and M. siamensis ) and Merrillia are transferred to Citreae s.l. This conclusion is also well supported by phytochemistry, demonstrating accumulation of carbazoles in Bergera and Clausena , and of 8-prenylated coumarins and polyoxygenated flavonoids in Murraya s.s. and Merrillia. Formation of both carbazoles, as well as 8-prenylated coumarins, and polyoxygenated flavonoids in Micromelum suggests relationships between Clauseneae s.s. and Citreae s.l. The monophyly of several larger genera in both tribes is supported by relatively high bootstrap percentages and specific chemical profiles for e.g., Clausena, Micromelum, Glycosmis and Atalantia. In contrast, molecular, chemical, and other data show that none of the subtribes recognized within Aurantioideae reflect phylogenetic relationships. Only the clades with Clausena + Bergera, Murraya s.s. + Merrillia, and Citrus + Clymenia + Eremocitrus + Fortunella + Poncirus ("true Citrus fruit trees") are well supported by such data. Among the outgroup genera, Zanthoxylum (Rutoideae) and Toddalia (Toddalioideae) are much closer to each other than to Ruta (Rutoideae).     

THE PINGUIOPHYCEAE CLASSIS NOVA, CHROMOPHYTE ALGAE PRODUCING LARGE AMOUNTS OF OMEGA-3 FATTY ACIDS

The streptophytes comprise the Charophyceae sensu Mattox and Stewart (a morphologically diverse group of fresh-water green algae) and the embryophytes (land plants). Several charophycean groups are currently recognized. These include the Charales, Coleochaetales, Chlorokybales, Klebsormidiales and Zygnemophyceae (Desmidiales and Zygnematales). Recently, SSU rRNA gene sequence data allied Mesostigma viride (Prasinophyceae) with the Streptophyta. Complete chloroplast sequence data, however, placed Mesostigma sister to all green algae, not with the streptophytes. Several morphological, ultrastructural and biochemical features unite these lineages into a monophyletic group including embryophytes, but evolutionary relationships among the basal streptophytes remain ambiguous. To date, numerous studies using SSU rRNA gene sequences have yielded differing phylogenies with varying degrees of support dependent upon taxon sampling and choice of phylogenetic method. Like SSU data, chloroplast DNA sequence data have been used to examine relationships within the Charales, Coleochaetales, Zygnemophyceae and embryophytes. Representatives of all basal streptophyte lineages have not been examined using chloroplast data in a single analysis. Phylogenetic analyses were performed using DNA sequences of rbc L (the genes encoding the large subunit of rubisco) and atp B (the beta-subunit of ATPase) to examine relationships of basal streptophyte lineages. Preliminary analyses placed the branch leading to Mesostigma as the basal lineage in the Streptophyta with Chlorokybus , the sole representative of the Chlorokybales, branching next. Klebsormidiales and the enigmatic genus Entransia were sister taxa. Sister to these, the Charales, Coleochaetales, embryophytes and Zygnemophyceae formed a monophyletic group with Charales and Coleochaetales sister to each other and this clade sister to the embryophytes.     

基于叶绿体TrnL- F序列和联合数据分析木通科的分子系统发育(英文)

基于叶绿体trnL_F序列单独分析以及trnL_F和rbcL序列联合分析重建了木通科的分子系统发育。本研究的系统发育拓扑结构与覃海宁和塔赫他间的族划分系统非常一致。猫儿屎族和串果藤族在系统发育树上位于本科的基部。由分布于南美的勃奎拉藤属和拉氏藤属组成的拉氏藤族得到了trnL_F序列分析 (10 0 % )和联合序列分析 (99% )的很好支持。木通族在两个分析里都得到了 10 0 %的靴带支持率。新建立的长萼木通属在trnL_F树上嵌套在木通属内 ;然而 ,在联合分析的树上 ,它与木通属形成姐妹群并得到很高的支持率。在系统发育上关系密切的 3个属 :牛藤果属、八月瓜属和野木瓜属之间的关系仍未解决。牛藤果与八月瓜在两个分析里都形成姐妹群 ,但支持率低。小花鹰爪枫嵌套在野木瓜属内 ,并与西南野木瓜形成姐妹群。木通族内这 3个属可能都不是单系 ,它们的属间界限和属的界定需要更多的分子和形态数据的进一步研究。     

MODULATION OF VERY-LONG CHAIN (C28) HIGHLY UNSATURATED FATTY ACIDS IN PROROCENTRUM MININUM (DINOPHYCEAE) BY SELENIUM

Sargassum is one of the most species-rich genera in the brown algae with over 400 described species worldwide. The bulk of these species occurs in Pacific-Indian ocean waters with only a small portion found on the Atlantic side of the Isthmus of Panama. Sargassum also has one of the most subdivided and complex taxonomic systems used within the algae. Systematic distinctions within the genus are further complicated by high rates of phenotypic variability in several key morphological characters. Molecular analyses in such systems should allow testing of systematic concepts while providing insights into speciation and evolutionary patterns. Global molecular phylogenetic analyses using both conserved and variable regions of the Rubisco operon ( rbc L and rbc L-IGS-rbcS) were performed with species from the Gulf of Mexico, Caribbean, and Pacific basin. Results confirm earlier analyses based on rbc L-IGS- rbc S from Pacific species at the subgeneric and sectional level while providing additional insights into the systematics and phylogenetics on a global scale. For example, species east of the Isthmus of Panama form a distinct well-resolved clade within the tropical subgenus. This result in sharp contrast to traditional systematic treatments but provides a window into the evolutionary history of this genus in the Pacific and Atlantic Ocean basins and a possible means to time speciation events.     

Sapindales: molecular delimitation and infraordinal groups

An analysis of rbcL sequence data for representatives of families of putative sapindalean/rutalean affinity identified a robust clade of core “sapindalean” taxa that is sister to representatives of Malvales. The constitution of this clade approximates the broad concept of Sapindales (sensu Cronquist). Five lineages within the order are recognized: a “rutaceae” clade (Rutaceae, Cneoraceae, Ptaeroxylaceae, Simaroubaceae sensu stricto, and Meliaceae); a “sapindaceae” clade (Sapindaceae, Aceraceae, and Hippocastenaceae); Anacardiaceae plus Burseraceae; Kirkiaceae; and Zygophyllaceae pro parte. Relationships among these groups were only weakly resolved, but there was no support for the recognition of the two more narrowly defined orders, Rutales and Sapindales sensu stricto. Several families that have previously been allied to Sapindales or Rutales show no affinity to the core sapindalean taxa identified with the molecular data, and are excluded from the order: viz. Akaniaceae, Bretschneideraceae, Conneraceae, Coriariaceae, Melianthaceae, Meliosmaceae, Physenaceae, Rhabdodrendraceae, Sabiaceae, Staphyleaceae, Stylobasiaceae, Surianaceae, and Zygophyllaceae sensu stricto.     

Phylogenetic Relationships between Asplenium bourgaei (Boiss.) Milde and A. jahandiezii (Litard.) Rouy Inferred from Morphological Characters and rbcL Sequences

Abstract: Micromorphological analysis reveals that A. jahandiezii, which occurs as a local endemic taxon in the Grand Canyon du Verdon in southern France, shows substantial differences to A. bourgaei, from the eastern Mediterranean region, in the surface structure of perispores, sporangial indehiscence and the size of stomatal subsidiary cells. Nucleotide sequences and genetic distances (0.9 % nucleotide substitutions) of the rbc L gene support the view that both taxa are related but distinct sibling species. Both species form a monophyletic group together with Asplenium fontanum and A. majoricum.     

PHYLOGENETIC RELATIONSHIPS OF GELIDIALES SPECIES IN COSTA RICA

Despite a general paucity of studies on marine algae in Costa Rica, within the red algal order Gelidiales, 9 species are reported from the Caribbean, and 6 species from the Pacific. In this study 5 species from the southeast Caribbean coast and 2 species from the northwest Pacific coast of Costa Rica were collected for DNA sequence and morphological analyses. At the time of this writing, morphological observations of four Caribbean taxa have identified them as Gelidium microdonticum , Pterocladiella capillacea , P. melanoidea , and Gelidiella acerosa. In rbc L sequence analyses, Gelidium microdonticum is resolved within a clade of small Gelidium species predominantly found in the south Atlantic. Two collections representing different forms of Pterocladiella melanoidea sensu Dawson were found to have identical rbc L sequences. These samples were resolved in rbc L trees with a taxon from Texas identified as P. bartlettii and not P. melanoidea from Europe. Comparisons with type material are being made to verify these identifications so that the status of P. melanoidea in the Caribbean may be determined. The unidentified Caribbean taxon is resolved as a distinct species within the Pterocladiella clade as well. Gelidiella acerosa from Caribbean Costa Rica is closely allied with other Caribbean G. acerosa samples in rbc L trees. The two pacific taxa are small intertidal turf species and have not yet been identified. Sequence analyses resolve these taxa within a large clade of Indo-Pacific and Caribbean Gelidium species.     

ANALYSIS OF CLONAL CULTURES OF THE BROWN TIDE ALGAE AUREOCOCCUS AND AUREOUMBRA (PELAGOPHYCEAE) USING 18S rRNA, rbcL, AND RUBISCO SPACER SEQUENCES

Variability among clonal cultures of the brown tide algae Aureococcus anophagefferens Hargraves et Sieburth and Aureoumbra lagunensis Stockwell, DeYoe, Hargraves et Johnson was examined by DNA sequence comparisons. Nuclear-encoded 18S rRNA and plastid-encoded rbc L gene sequences were determined for six Aureococcus strains. RUBISCO spacer sequences were determined for 14 strains of Aureococcus. No differences among Aureococcus strains were found in the DNA regions examined. The rbc L and RUBISCO spacer sequences for three Aureoumbra strains were identical but differed from those of Aureococcus. These data indicate that blooms of these species are comprised of cells that are very similar and also imply that Aureococcus and Aureoumbra do not contain varieties or cryptic species. Separate and combined phylogenetic analyses of the 18S rRNA and rbc L gene sequences were performed. Results confirm that the brown-tide-causing algae of Long Island Sound, New York ( Aureococcus ), and Laguna Madre, Texas ( Aureoumbra ), are best classified in separate genera within the Pelagophyceae. Phylogenetic trees place Aureococcus and Aureoumbra within the Pelagomonadales and Sarcinochrysidales, respectively.     

Parasitization of Lacanobia oleracea (Lepidoptera) by the ectoparasitic wasp,Eulophus pennicornis,suppresses haemocyte-mediated recognition of non-self and phagocytosis

Although many endoparasitic wasps suppress the haemocyte-mediated immune defences of their insect hosts, the effects of ectoparasitoids are virtually unknown. In view of this, a study has been made of the ectoparasitic wasp, Eulophus pennicornis, and its host, the tomato moth, Lacanobia oleracea. For unparasitized insects, in vitro assays indicated that less than 3.0% of L. oleracea haemocytes on a monolayer formed rosettes with yeast cells or fresh rabbit erythrocytes (rbc), and virtually no phagocytosis of these particles occurred. In addition, although fixed rbc formed rosettes with 51.21% of haemocytes, only about 3.0% of the haemocytes ingested one or more of these particles. In contrast to this, B. cereus and E. coli were readily phagocytosed by 14.75% and 53.70% of haemocytes, respectively. These results indicate that L. oleracea haemocytes can recognise different types of non-self particles and demonstrate that ingestion does not necessarily follow attachment. When rosetting and phagocytosis assays were performed with fixed rbc and FITC-labelled E. coli, and haemocytes from starved L. oleracea, PBS injected L. oleracea, and experimentally envenomated insects on day five of treatment, there was no significant difference in the percentage of rosetting or phagocytosis occurring. When haemocytes from parasitized insects on day five of treatment were utilised, however, rosetting and phagocytosis were reduced by 31.41% and 34.94%, respectively. Thus, the effects of parasitization and experimental envenomation are not the same. In addition, suppression of host haemocyte-mediated recognition and phagocytosis was not a secondary effect of nutritional deprivation and was not due to ectoparasitoid venom components, rather it was a direct result of parasitization of L. oleracea by E. pennicornis. The putative nature and source of the immunosuppressive factor(s) involved is discussed with reference to those produced by endoparasitic wasps.     

Origin and relationships of the myco-heterotrophic liverwort Cryptothallus mirabilis Malmb. (Metzgeriales, Marchantiophyta)

Heterotrophic life histories have evolved independently numerous times in the angiosperms. In non-vascular embryophytes, heterotrophy is known only in the genus Cryptothallus . Cryptothallus mirabilis obtains photosynthates indirectly from a host tree via a basidiomycete that is simultaneously ectomycorrhizal on the host, a strategy known as myco-heterotrophism. This simple thalloid liverwort was initially described as an albino variant of Aneura pinguis , and the literature varies on whether it should be considered as such, as a distinct species of Aneura , or as a separate genus. Here, the relationships of C. mirabilis within the family Aneuraceae are reconstructed using DNA sequence data from the chloroplast ( rps 4, rps 14, atp B- rbc L spacer, trn G), mitochondrial ( trn S), and nuclear (26S and ITS) genomes. Several allopatric populations of C. mirabilis and of both sympatric species of Aneura (i.e. A. pinguis and A. maxima ) were included. Cryptothallus mirabilis is resolved as having a single origin from within Aneura , and hence the myco-heterotrophic liverwort should be considered as a distinct species of Aneura , rather than an autonomous genus. The fungal symbiont of the photosynthetic A. pinguis is of the same genus, Tulasnella , as that of C. mirabilis , suggesting that the heterotrophic life strategy might have evolved from a pre-existing symbiosis.  © 2008 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2008, 156 , 1–12.