Exploring the cytochrome c folding mechanism: cytochrome c552 from thermus thermophilus folds through an on-pathway intermediate

Understanding the role of partially folded intermediate states in the folding mechanism of a protein is a crucial yet very difficult problem. We exploited a kinetic approach to demonstrate that a transient intermediate of a thermostable member of the widely studied cytochrome c family (cytochrome c552 from Thermus thermophilus) is indeed on-pathway. This is the first clear indication of an obligatory intermediate in the folding mechanism of a cytochrome c. The fluorescence properties of this intermediate demonstrate that the relative position of the heme and of the only tryptophan residue cannot correspond to their native orientation. Based on an analysis of the three-dimensional structure of cytochrome c552, we propose an interpretation of the data which explains the residual fluorescence of the intermediate and is consistent with the established role played by some conserved interhelical interactions in the folding of other members of this family. A limited set of topologically conserved contacts may guide the folding of evolutionary distant cytochromes c through the same partially structured state, which, however, can play different kinetic roles, acting either as an intermediate or a transition state.     

An on-pathway intermediate in the folding of a PDZ domain

The folding pathways of some proteins include the population of partially structured species en route to the native state. Identification and characterization of these folding intermediates are particularly difficult as they are often only transiently populated and play different mechanistic roles, being either on-pathway productive species or off-pathway kinetic traps. To define the role of folding intermediates, a quantitative analysis of the folding and unfolding rate constants over a wide range of denaturant concentration is often required. Such a task is further complicated by the reversible nature of the folding reaction, which implies the observed kinetics to be governed by a complex combination of different microscopic rate constants. Here, we tackled this problem by measuring directly the folding rate constant under highly denaturing conditions, namely by inducing the folding of a PDZ domain through a quasi-irreversible binding reaction with a specific peptide. In analogy with previous works based on hydrogen exchange experiments, we present evidence that the folding pathway of the PDZ domain involves the formation of an obligatory on-pathway intermediate. The results presented exemplify a novel type of kinetic test to detect an on-pathway folding intermediate.     

Protein topology affects the appearance of intermediates during the folding of proteins with a flavodoxin-like fold

The topology of a native protein influences the rate with which it is formed, but does topology affect the appearance of folding intermediates and their specific role in kinetic folding as well? This question is addressed by comparing the folding data recently obtained on apoflavodoxin from Azotobacter vinelandii with those available on all three other alpha-beta parallel proteins the kinetic folding mechanism of which has been studied, i.e. Anabaena apoflavodoxin, Fusarium solani pisi cutinase and CheY. Two kinetic folding intermediates, one on-pathway and the other off-pathway, seem to be present during the folding of proteins with an alpha-beta parallel, also called flavodoxin-like, topology. The on-pathway intermediate lies on a direct route from the unfolded to the native state of the protein involved. The off-pathway intermediate needs to unfold to allow the production of native protein. Available simulation data of the folding of CheY show the involvement of two intermediates with characteristics that resemble those of the two intermediates experimentally observed. Apparently, protein topology governs the appearance and kinetic roles of protein folding intermediates during the folding of proteins that have a flavodoxin-like fold.     

A common folding mechanism in the cytochrome c family

Of the globular proteins, cytochrome c (cyt c) has been used extensively as a model system for folding studies. Here we analyse the folding pathway of different cyt c proteins from prokaryotes and eukaryotes, and attempt to single out general correlations between structural determinants and folding mechanisms. Recent studies provide evidence that the folding pathway of several cyt c proteins involves the formation of a partially structured intermediate. Using state-of-the-art kinetic analysis on published data, we show that such a folding intermediate is an obligatory on-pathway species that might represent either a defined local minimum in the reaction coordinate or an unstable high-energy state. Available data also indicate that some essential structural features of the folding intermediate and transition states are highly conserved across this protein family. Thus, cyt c proteins share a consensus folding mechanism in spite of large differences in physico-chemical properties and thermodynamic stability. This novel outlook on the folding of cyt c can shed light on much published data and might offer a general scheme by which to plan new experiments.     

Cytochrome c from a thermophilic bacterium has provided insights into the mechanisms of protein maturation, folding, and stability.

Cytochrome c is widely distributed in bacterial species, from mesophiles to thermophiles, and is one of the best-characterized redox proteins in terms of biogenesis, folding, structure, function, and evolution. Experimental molecular biology techniques (gene cloning and expression) have become applicable to cytochrome c, enabling its engineering and manipulation. Heterologous expression systems for cytochromes c in bacteria, for use in mutagenesis studies, have been established by extensive investigation of the biological process by which the functional structure is formed. Mutagenesis and structure analyses based on comparative studies using a thermophile Hydrogenobacter thermophilus cytochrome c-552 and its mesophilic counterpart have provided substantial clues to the mechanism underlying protein stability at the amino-acid level. The molecular mechanisms underlying protein maturation, folding, and stability in bacterial cytochromes c are beginning to be understood.     

Protein folding: matching theory and experiment.

The impact of folding funnels and folding simulations on the way experimentalists interpret results is examined. The image of the transition state has changed from a unique species that has a strained configuration, with a correspondingly high free energy, to a more ordinary folding intermediate, whose balance between limited conformational entropy and stabilizing contacts places it at the top of the free energy barrier. Evidence for a broad transition barrier comes from studies showing that mutations can change the position of the barrier. The main controversial issue now is whether populated folding intermediates are productive on-pathway intermediates or dead-end traps. Direct experimental evidence is needed. Theories suggesting that populated intermediates are trapped in a glasslike state are usually based on mechanisms which imply that trapping would only be extremely short-lived (e.g., nanoseconds) in water at 25 degrees C. There seems to be little experimental evidence for long-lived trapping in monomers, if folding aggregates are excluded. On the other hand, there is good evidence for kinetic trapping in dimers. alpha-Helix formation is currently the fastest known process in protein folding, and incipient helices are present at the start of folding. Fast helix formation has the effect of narrowing drastically the choice of folding routes. Thus helix formation can direct folding. It changes the folding metaphor from pouring liquid down a folding funnel to a train leaving a switchyard with only a few choices of exit tracks.     

Studies on cytochrome c oxidase activity of the cytochrome c1aa3 complex from Thermus thermophilus

Cytochrome oxidase from T. thermophilus is isolated as a noncovalent complex of cytochromes c1 and aa3 in which the four redox components of aa3 appear to be associated with a single approximately 55,000-D subunit while the heme C is associated with a approximately 33,000-D peptide (Yoshida, T., Lorence, R. M., Choc, M. G., Tarr, G. E., Findling, K. L., and Fee, J. A. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 112-123). We have examined the steady state transfer of electrons from ascorbate to oxygen by cytochrome c1aa3 as mediated by horse heart, Candida krusei, and T. thermophilus (c552) cytochromes c as well as tetramethylphenylenediamine (TMPD). These mediators exhibit simple Michaelis-Menten kinetic behavior yielding Vmax and KM values characteristic of the experimental conditions. Three classes of kinetic behavior were observed and are qualitatively discussed in terms of a reaction scheme. The data show that tetramethylphenyldiamine and cytochromes c react with the enzyme at independent sites; it is suggested that cytochrome c1 may efficiently transfer electrons to cytochrome aa3. When incorporated into phospholipid vesicles, the highly purified cytochrome c1aa3 was found to translocate one proton into the exterior medium for each molecule of cytochrome c552 oxidized. The combined results suggest that this bacterial enzyme functions in a manner generally identical with the more complex eucaryotic enzyme.     

Electron transfer kinetics of soluble fragments indicate a direct interaction between complex III and the caa3 oxidase in Thermus thermophilus

The extremely thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus expresses an aerobic respiratory chain resembling that of mitochondria and many mesophilic prokaryotes. Yet, interaction modes between redox partners differ between the thermophilic and mesophilic electron transport chains. While electron transfer in mesophilic organisms such as Paracoccus denitrificans follows a two-step mechanism mostly governed by long-range electrostatic interactions, the electron transfer in thermophiles is mediated mainly by apolar interactions. The terminal branch of the electron path from the bc-complex via the soluble cytochrome c(552) to the ba(3) oxidase has extensively been characterized, whereas contradicting evidence has been put forward on the nature of the physiological substrate(s) of the caa(3) oxidase. We have cloned and expressed a soluble fragment of the hydrophilic cytochrome c domain derived from subunit IIc of the caa(3) oxidase (c(caa)(3)) and characterized its kinetic behaviour in terms of substrate specificity and ionic strength dependency using pre-steady state stopped-flow techniques. The kinetics revealed fast electron transfer between the caa(3) fragment and both, the cytochrome c(552) and the soluble cytochrome c(bc) fragment of the bc-complex, showing only a weak ionic strength dependence. These data suggest a direct intercomplex electron transfer between the bc-complex and the caa(3) oxidase without requirement for a soluble electron shuttle.     

Parallel pathways in cytochrome c(551) folding

The folding of cytochrome c(551) from Pseudomonas aeruginosa was previously thought to follow a simple sequential mechanism, consistent with the lack of histidine residues, other than the native His16 heme ligand, that can give rise to mis-coordinated species. However, further kinetic analysis reveals complexities indicative of a folding mechanism involving parallel pathways. Double-jump interrupted refolding experiments at low pH indicate that approximately 50% of the unfolded cytochrome c(551) population can reach the native state via a fast (10 ms) folding track, while the rest follows a slower folding path with populated intermediates. Stopped-flow experiments using absorbance at 695 nm to monitor refolding confirm the presence of a rapidly folding species containing the native methionine-iron bond while measurements on carboxymethylated cytochrome c(551) (which lacks the Met-Fe coordination bond) indicate that methionine ligation occurs late during folding along the fast folding track, which appears to be dominant at physiological pH. Continuous-flow measurements of tryptophan-heme energy transfer, using a capillary mixer with a dead time of about 60 micros, show evidence for a rapid chain collapse within 100 micros preceding the rate-limiting folding phase on the milliseconds time scale. A third process with a time constant in the 10-50 ms time range is consistent with a minor population of molecules folding along a parallel channel, as confirmed by quantitative kinetic modeling. These findings indicate the presence of two or more slowly inter-converting ensembles of denatured states that give rise to pH-dependent partitioning among fast and slow-folding pathways.     

Unveiling a hidden folding intermediate in c-type cytochromes by protein engineering

Several investigators have highlighted a correlation between the basic features of the folding process of a protein and its topology, which dictates the folding pathway. Within this conceptual framework we proposed that different members of the cytochrome c (cyt c) family share the same folding mechanism, involving a consensus partially structured state. Pseudomonas aeruginosa cyt c(551) (Pa cyt c(551)) folds via an apparent two-state mechanism through a high energy intermediate. Here we present kinetic evidence demonstrating that it is possible to switch its folding mechanism from two to three state, stabilizing the high energy intermediate by rational mutagenesis. Characterization of the folding kinetics of one single-site mutant of the Pa cyt c(551) (Phe(7) to Ala) indeed reveals an additional refolding phase and a fast unfolding process which are explained by the accumulation of a partially folded species. Further kinetic analysis highlights the presence of two parallel processes both leading to the native state, suggesting that the above mentioned species is a non obligatory on-pathway intermediate. Determination of the crystallographic structure of F7A shows the presence of an extended internal cavity, which hosts three "bound" water molecules and a H-bond in the N-terminal helix, which is shorter than in the wild type protein. These two features allow us to propose a detailed structural interpretation for the stabilization of the native and especially the intermediate states induced by a single crucial mutation. These results show how protein engineering, x-ray crystallography and state-of-the-art kinetics concur to unveil a folding intermediate and the structural determinants of its stability.     

Specificity of the interaction between the Paracoccus denitrificans oxidase and its substrate cytochrome c: comparing the mitochondrial to the homologous bacterial cytochrome c(552), and its truncated and site-directed mutants

Under in vitro conditions, bacterial cytochrome c oxidases may accept several nonhomologous c-type electron donors, including the evolutionarily related mitochondrial cytochrome c. Several lines of evidence suggest that in intact membranes the heme aa(3) oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans receives its electrons from the membrane-bound cytochrome c(552). Both the structures of the oxidase and of a heterologously expressed, soluble fragment of the c(552) have been determined recently, but no direct structural information about a static cocomplex is available. Here, we analyze the kinetic properties of the isolated oxidase with the full-size c(552), with two truncated soluble forms, and with a set of site-specific mutants within the presumed docking site of the cytochrome, all heterologously expressed in Escherichia coli. Our data indicate that all three forms, the wild type and both truncations, are fully competent kinetically and exhibit biphasic kinetic behavior, however, under widely different ionic strength conditions. When mutations in lysine residues clustered around the interaction domain were introduced into the smallest fragment of c(552), both kinetic parameters, K(M) and k(cat), were drastically influenced. On the other hand, when the nonmutated truncated form was used to donate electrons to a set of oxidase mutants with replacements clustered along the docking site on subunit II, we observe distinct differences when comparing the kinetic properties of the widely used horse heart cytochrome c with those of the bacterial c(552). We conclude that the specific docking sites for the two types of cytochromes differ to some extent.     

Stabilization mechanism of cytochrome c552 from a moderately thermophilic bacterium, Hydrogenophilus thermoluteolus

Cytochrome c(552) (PH c(552)) from moderately thermophilic Hydrogenophilus thermoluteolus exhibits stability intermediate between those of cytochrome c(552) (HT c(552)) from thermophilic Hydrogenobacter thermophilus and cytochrome c(551) (PA c(551)) from mesophilic Pseudomonas aeruginosa. To understand the mechanism of stabilization of PH c(552), we introduced mutations into PH c(552) at five sites, which, in HT c(552), are occupied by the amino acids responsible for stability higher than the less stable PA c(551). When PH c(552) Val-78 was mutated to Ile, as found in HT c(552), the resulting variant showed increased stability. Mutation of Ala-7, Met-13, and Tyr-34 to the corresponding residues in PA c(551) (Phe, Val, and Phe, respectively) resulted in destabilization. We also found that PH c(552) Lys-43 contributed to stability through the formation of an attractive electrostatic interaction with Asp-39. These results suggest that the intermediate stability of PH c(552) is due to the amino acids at these five sites.     

Kinetic studies on redox reactions of hemoproteins. I. Reduction of thermoresistant cytochrome c-552 and horse heart cytochrome c by ferrocyanide.

The oxidation-reduction reaction of horse heart cytochrome c and cytochrome c (552, Thermus thermophilus), which is highly thermoresistant, was studied by temperature-jump method. Ferrohexacyanide was used as reductant. (Formula: see text.) Thermodynamic and activation parameters of the reaction obtained for both cytochromes were compared with each other. The results of this showed that (1) the redox potential of cytochrome c-552, + 0.19 V, is markedly less than that of horse heart cytochrome c. (2) deltaHox of cytochrome c-552 is considerably lower than that of horse heart cytochrome c. (3) deltaSox and deltaSred of cytochrome c-552 are more negative than those of horse heart cytochrome c. (4) kred of cytochrome c-552 is much lower than that of horse heart cytochrome c at room temperature.     

Amino acid sequence of cytochrome c-552 from a thermophilic hydrogen-oxidizing bacterium, Hydrogenobacter thermophilus.

The complete amino acid sequence of cytochrome c-552 from an extremely thermophilic hydrogen bacterium, Hydrogenobacter thermophilus TK-6 (IAM 12695), was determined. It is a single polypeptide chain of 80 residues, and its molecular weight, including heme, was calculated to be 7,599. The sequence of cytochrome c-552 from H. thermophilus TK-6 closely resembles that of cytochromes c-551 from Pseudomonas species. Moreover, the tertiary structure of Hydrogenobacter cytochrome c-552 is suggested to be similar to that of cytochrome c-551 from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The sequence similarity between Hydrogenobacter cytochrome c-552 and that of other bacteria physiologically related to H. thermophilus is not high.     

Folding kinetics of the cooperatively folded subdomain of the IκBα ankyrin repeat domain

The ankyrin repeat (AR) domain of IκBα consists of a cooperative folding unit of roughly four ARs (AR1-AR4) and of two weakly folded repeats (AR5 and AR6). The kinetic folding mechanism of the cooperative subdomain, IκBα_67-206, was analyzed using rapid mixing techniques. Despite its apparent architectural simplicity, IκBα_67-206 displays complex folding kinetics, with two sequential on-pathway high-energy intermediates. The effect of mutations to or away from the consensus sequences of ARs on folding behavior was analyzed, particularly the GXTPLHLA motif, which have not been examined in detail previously. Mutations toward the consensus generally resulted in an increase in folding stability, whereas mutations away from the consensus resulted in decreased overall stability. We determined the free energy change upon mutation for three sequential transition state ensembles along the folding route for 16 mutants. We show that folding initiates with the formation of the interface of the outer helices of AR3 and AR4, and then proceeds to consolidate structure in these repeats. Subsequently, AR1 and AR2 fold in a concerted way in a single kinetic step. We show that this mechanism is robust to the presence of AR5 and AR6 as they do not strongly affect the folding kinetics. Overall, the protein appears to fold on a rather smooth energy landscape, where the folding mechanism conforms a one-dimensional approximation. However, we note that the AR does not necessarily act as a single folding element.     

Different interaction modes of two cytochrome-c oxidase soluble CuA fragments with their substrates

Cytochrome-c oxidase is the terminal enzyme in the respiratory chains of mitochondria and many bacteria and catalyzes the formation of water by reduction of dioxygen. The first step in the cytochrome oxidase reaction is the bimolecular electron transfer from cytochrome c to the homobinuclear mixed-valence CuA center of subunit II. In Thermus thermophilus a soluble cytochrome c552 acts as the electron donor to ba3 cytochrome-c oxidase, an interaction believed to be mainly hydrophobic. In Paracoccus denitrificans, electrostatic interactions appear to play a major role in the electron transfer process from the membrane-spanning cytochrome c552. In the present study, soluble fragments of the CuA domains and their respective cytochrome c electron donors were analyzed by stopped-flow spectroscopy to further characterize the interaction modes. The forward and the reverse electron transfer reactions were studied as a function of ionic strength and temperature, in all cases yielding monoexponential time-dependent reaction profiles in either direction. From the apparent second-order rate constants, equilibrium constants were calculated, with values of 4.8 and of 0.19, for the T. thermophilus and P. denitrificans c552 and CuA couples, respectively. Ionic strength strongly affects the electron transfer reaction in P. denitrificans indicating that about five charges on the protein interfaces control the interaction, when analyzed according to the Br?nsted equation, whereas in the T. thermophilus only 0.5 charges are involved. Overall the results indicate that the soluble CuA domains are excellent models for the initial electron transfer processes in cytochrome-c oxidases.     

Characterization and redox properties of cytochrome c552 from Thermus thermophilus adsorbed on different self-assembled thiol monolayers, used to model the chemical environment of the redox partner

The structure of cytochrome c552 (Cyt-c552) from Thermus thermophilus shows many differences to other c-type cytochromes. The rich lysine domain close to the heme does not exist in this cytochrome, allowing us to postulate that the interaction with its redox partner must be different to the cytochrome c/cytochrome c oxidase interaction. We report a study of Cyt-c552 adsorbed on self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of functionalized alkanethiols used to mimic the chemical properties of its redox partner (ba3-oxydase). Hydrophilic (-COOH), polar (-OH), hydrophobic (-CH3), and mixed (-OH/-CH3) SAMs grafted on roughened silver electrodes were characterized by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Surface enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy (SERRS) was employed to determine the structure and the redox properties (E degrees and number of transferred electron) of the heme of Cyt-c552 adsorbed on roughened silver electrodes coated by the different SAMs. The surface that most closely models the environment of the ba3-oxidase is a mixed SAM formed by 50% polar [Ag-(CH2)5-CH2OH] and 50% hydrophobic [Ag-(CH2)5-CH3] alkanethiols. Only the native form B1(6cLS) of Cyt-c552 is detected by SERRS when the protein is adsorbed on such a surface that promotes a protein orientation favorable for the electron transfer (number of transferred electron = 1). We shall discuss the differences and similarities of the electron-transfer mechanism of Cyt-c552 compared to cyt-c.     

Alkaline isomerization of thermoresistant cytochrome c-552 and horse heart cytochrome c studied by absorption and resonance Raman spectroscopy.

The structure of the thermoresistant cytochrome c (552, Thermus thermophilus) has been investigated at neutral and alkaline pH by absorption and resonance Raman spectroscopy and compared with that of horse heart cytochrome c. The ligands of the ferricytochrome c-552 at neutral pH are considered to be histidine and methionine, whereas the ligands of ferrocytochrome c-552 are histidine and another nitrogen base, histidine or lysine. Ferric cytochrome c-552 undergoes an alkaline isomerization with a pK of 12.3 (25 degrees C), accompanied by a ligand exchange. Horse heart cytochrome c has at least three isomerization states at alkaline pH (pK 9.3, 12.9 and greater than 13.5 at 25 degrees C). The replacement of the sixth ligand may not be involved in the second isomerization. The thermodynamic parameters for the isomerization were also estimated. The entropy change upon isomerization of cytochrome c-552 is negative, whereas for that of horse heart cytochrome c the entropy change is positive.