The role of the pilus in recipient cell recognition during bacterial conjugation mediated by F-like plasmids

The effects of defined mutations In the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and the outer membrane protein OmpA of the recipient cell on mating-pair formation in liquid media by the transfer systems of the F-Iike plasmids pOX38 (F), ColB2 and R100-1 were investigated. Transfer of all three plasmids was affected differently by mutations in the rfa (LPS) locus of the recipient cell, the F plasmid being most sensitive to mutations that affected rfaP gene expression which is responslbie for the addition of pyrophosphorylethanolamine (PPEA) to heptose I of the inner core of the LPS. CoIB2 transfer was more strongly affected by mutations in the heptose II-heptose III region of the LPS (rfaF) whereas R100-1 was not strongly affected by any of the rfa mutations tested. ompA but not rfa mutations further decreased the mating efficiency of an F plasmid carrying a mutation in the mating-pair stabilization protein TraN. An F derivative with a chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) cassette interrupting the traA pilin gene was constructed and pilin genes from F-like plasmids (F, ColB2, R100-1) were used to complement this mutation. Unexpectediy, the results suggested that the differences in the pilin sequences were not responsible for recognizing specific groups in the LPS, OmpA or the TraT surface exclusion protein. Other corroborating evidence is presented suggesting the presence of an adhesin at the F pilus tip.     

The effect of tra mutations on the synthesis of the F-pilin membrane polypeptide

Summary We had previously demonstrated that several F specific polypeptide bands could be detected in the membranes of Flac, but not F^- strains of Escherichia coli K 12, (Moore et al. 1981). One of these polypeptides co-migrated with F-pilin protein on polyacrylamide gels. We have now analyzed ³⁵[S]methionine labelled membrane preparations from a series of strains containing Flac tra mutant plasmids. The F-pilin polypeptide was absent from preparations of strains containing all traA mutants tested, confirming the importance of the traA gene in F-pilin biosynthesis. A polypeptide which migrated in the F-pilin position was still present, however, in membranes prepared from Flac strains carrying mutations in traL, traE, traK, traB, traV, traW, traC, traU, traF, traH or traG despite the inability of these mutants to elaborate F-pili filaments. Thus, all of these gene products may be concerned with F-pilus assembly and outgrowth rather than biosynthesis of the F-pilin subunit. The polar mutation tra-4 did, however, prevent the appearance of pilin polypeptide, indicating that at least one unidentified gene in the region between traE and traG must also be required in F-pilin biosynthesis.Our analysis also permitted the identification of a 100,000 dalton membrane protein as the product of traG. The appearance of an F specific 12,000 dalton protein was prevented by traD amber mutants. As expected, traJ mutants prevented the expression of all the tra operon products detected except the product of traT. The traT product band was reduced only to 50–60% of its normal intensity.     

Localization, cloning, and sequence determination of the conjugative plasmid ColB2 pilin gene.

ColB2 is a colicin-producing, 96-kilobase plasmid which encodes a conjugative system that is similar, but not identical, to F. A restriction map of this plasmid was generated, and DNA homology studies between F and ColB2 plasmids revealed homology only between their transfer operons. The locations of the ColB2 transfer operon and ColB2 pilin gene were localized on this restriction map. The gene encoding ColB2 pilin, traA, was cloned and sequenced. The pilin protein of ColB2 is identical to F, except at the amino terminus, where ala-gln of ColB2 pilin corresponds to Ala-Gly-Ser-Ser of F pilin. This is due to a 6-base-pair deletion in the ColB2 pilin gene. Biochemical studies on tryptic peptides derived from ColB2 pilin demonstrate the location of this gene to be correct. There is a putative signal peptidase cleavage site after the sequence Ala-Met-Ala, giving a signal peptide of 51 amino acids and a mature pilin protein of 68 amino acids (7,000 daltons). The amino terminus is blocked, probably with an acetyl group. A chimera containing the ColB2 pilin gene was able to complement an F traA mutant, demonstrating that the pilus assembly proteins of F can utilize the ColB2 pilin protein to form a pilus.     

Promiscuous DNA transfer system of Agrobacterium tumefaciens: role of the virB operon in sex pilus assembly and synthesis

Conjugative transfer of DNA that occurs between bacteria also operates between bacteria and higher organisms. The transfer of DNA between Gram-negative bacteria requires initial contact by a sex pilus followed by DNA traversing four membranes (donor plus recipient) using a transmembrane pore. Accumulating evidence suggests that transfer of the T-DNA from Agrobacterium tumefaciens to plants may also occur via a conjugative mechanism. The virB operon of the Ti plasmid exhibits close homologies to genes that are known to encode the pilin subunits and pilin assembly proteins. The proteins encoded by the PilW operon of IncW plasmid R388 share strong similarities (average similarity=50.8%) with VirB proteins. Similarly, the TraA, TraL and TraC proteins of IncF plasmid F have similarities to VirB2, VirB3 and VirB4 respectively (average similarity = 45.3%). VirB2 protein (12.3 kDa) contains a signal peptidase-I cleavage sequence that generates a polypeptide of 7.2 kDa. Likewise, the 12.8 kDa propilin protein TraA of plasmid F also possesses a peptidase-I cleavage site that generates the 7.2 kDa pilin structural protein. Similar amino acid sequences of the conjugative transfer genes of F, R388 as well as plasmid RP4 and the genes of the ptl operon of Bortedella pertussis suggest the existence of a superfamily of transmembrane proteins adapted to the promiscuous transfer of DNA-protein complexes.     

DNA transfer occurs during a cell surface contact stage of F sex factor-mediated bacterial conjugation.

Donor bacteria containing JCFL39, a temperature-sensitive traD mutant of the F sex factor, were used at the nonpermissive temperature to accumulate stable mating pairs with recipient cells. At this stage in conjugation, extracellular F pili were removed by treatment with 0.01% sodium dodecyl sulfate. Upon then shifting to the permissive temperature for JCFL39, transfer of the F plasmid was observed. The mating pairs that were accumulated with JCFL39 at the nonpermissive temperature were readily observed by electron microscopy in wall-to-wall contact with the recipient bacteria. These results demonstrate that the traD product, which is known to be required in transferring DNA to a recipient bacterium, acts after the stage at which extracellular F pili are required. In addition, we concluded that DNA transfer takes place while donor and recipient cells are in surface contact and not necessarily through an extended F pilus as envisioned in some models of bacterial conjugation.     

A new activity in the Ftra operon which is required for F-pilin synthesis

Summary Membrane preparations from a series of Hfr mutant strains of Escherichia coli K12 deleted in the promoter distal end of the F transfer operon were analyzed. Deletions which extended into traG, as expected, had no discernible effect on synthesis of membrane F-pilin. A more extensive deletion in strain KI777 which eliminated traH activity similarly had no effect on F-pilin synthesis. Membranes from three other TraF⁺ TraH^- deletion strains, as well as membranes from all strains carrying deletions extending into traF or further, lacked F-pilin, however. Since traH amber mutations do not affect synthesis of membrane pilin (Moore et al. 1981 b) we conclude that a gene required for F-pilin biosynthesis is located between traF and traH. We have named this gene traQ.Further evidence for traQ and an assay for its activity was obtained by examining the products of a TraM⁺ TraJ⁺ TraA⁺ lambda transducing phage, KI13, in UV irradiated cells. Infection of F^- cells with KI13 does not result in F-pilin synthesis. Membrane pilin is synthesized as a product of the transducing phage if an Flac or Hfr irradiated host is used, however. Mutant analysis demonstrated that this synthesis is independent of host expression of traA, traL, traE, traK, traB, traV, traW, traC, traU, traF, or traH, but dependent on expression of the traF-traH region. We interpret our data to indicate that an activity encoded by traQ is required for the conversion of traA product to F-pilin.     

Processed VirB2 Is the Major Subunit of the Promiscuous Pilus of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Previous studies have implicated the obligatory requirement for the vir regulon (or “virulon”) of the Ti plasmid for the transfer of oncogenes from Agrobacterium tumefaciens to plant cells. The machinery used in this horizontal gene transfer has been long thought to be a transformation or conjugative delivery system. Based on recent protein sequence comparisons, the proteins encoded by the virB operon are strikingly similar to proteins involved in the synthesis and assembly of conjugative pili such as the conjugative pilus of F plasmid in Escherichia coli. The F pilus is composed of TraA pilin subunits derived from TraA propilin. In the present study, evidence is provided showing that the counterpart of TraA is VirB2, which like TraA propilin is processed into a 7.2-kDa product that comprises the pilus subunit as demonstrated by biochemical and electron microscopic analyses. The processed VirB2 protein is present exocellularly on medium on which induced A. tumefaciens had grown and appears as thin filaments of 10 nm that react specifically to VirB2 antibody. Exocellular VirB2 is produced abundantly at 19°C as compared with 28°C, an observation that parallels the effect of low temperature on the production of vir gene-specific pili observed previously (K. J. Fullner, L. C. Lara, and E. W. Nester, Science 273:1107–1109, 1996). Export of the processed VirB2 requires other virB genes since mutations in these genes cause the loss of VirB2 pilus formation and result in processed VirB2 accumulation in the cell. The presence of exocellular processed VirB2 is directly correlated with the formation of pili, and it appears as the major protein in the purified pilus preparation. The evidence provides a compelling argument for VirB2 as the propilin whose 7.2-kDa processed product is the pilin subunit of the promiscuous conjugative pilus, hereafter called the “T pilus” of A. tumefaciens.     

Partitioning of the F plasmid: Overproduction of an essential protein for partition inhibits plasmid maintenance

Summary Multicopy plasmids carrying the sopB gene of the F plasmid inhibit stable inheritance of a coexisting mini-F plasmid. This incompatibility, termed IncG, is found to be caused by excess amounts of the SopB protein, which is essential for accuratepartitioning of plasmid DNA molecules into daughter cells. A sopB-carrying multicopy plasmid that shows the IncG⁺ phenotype was mutagenized in vitro and IncG negative mutant plasmids were isolated. Among these amber and missense mutants of sopB, mutants with a low plasmid copy number and a mutant in the Shine-Dalgarno sequence for translation of the SopB protein were obtained. These results demonstrate that the IncG phenotype is caused by the SopB protein, and that the incompatibility is expressed only when the protein is overproduced. This suggests that the protein must be kept at appropriate concentrations to ensure stable maintenance of the plasmid.     

The pilE gene product of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, required for pilus biogenesis, shares amino acid sequence identity with the N-termini of type 4 prepilin proteins

A new locus required for type 4 pilus biogenesis by Pseudomonas aeruginosa has been identified. A pilE mutant, designated MJ-6, was broadly resistant to pili-specific phages and unable to translocate across solid surfaces by the pilus-dependent mechanism of twitching motility (Twt⁻). Immunoblot analysis demonstrated that MJ-6 was devoid of pili (Pil⁻) but was unaffected in the production of unassembled pilin pools. Genetic studies aimed at localizing the pilE mutation on the P. aeruginosa PAO chromosome demonstrated a strong co-linkage between MJ-6 phage resistance and the proB marker located at 71 min. Cloning of the pilE gene was facilitated by the isolation and identification of a proB⁺-containing plasmid from a PAO1 cosmid library. Upon introduction of the PA01 proB⁺ cosmid clone into MJ-6, sensitivity to pili-specific phage, twitching motility and pilus production were restored. The nucleotide sequence of a 1 kb Eco RV-Clal fragment containing the pilE region revealed a single complete open reading frame with characteristic P. aeruginosa codon bias. PilE, a protein with a molecular weight of 15278, showed significant sequence identity to the pilin precursors of P. aeruginosa and to other type 4 prepilin proteins. The region of highest homology was localized to the N-terminal 40 amino acid residues. The putative PilE N-terminus contained a seven-residue basic leader sequence followed by a consensus cleavage site for prepilin pep-tidase and a largely hydrophobic region which contained tyrosine residues (Tyr-24 and Tyr-27) previously implicated in maintaining pilin subunit-subunit interactions. The requirement of PilE in pilus biogenesis was confirmed by demonstrating that chromosomal pilE insertion mutants were pilus- and twitching-motility deficient.     

Analysis of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">pilU</Emphasis> gene for the prepilin peptidase involved in the biogenesis of type IV pili encoded by plasmid R64

In many type IV pili, the N-terminal amino acid of the pilin subunit is N-methylated phenylalanine. A prepilin peptidase removes the leader peptide from the precursor and methylates the amino group of the newly formed phenylalanine. PilS, the precursor of the pilin encoded by plasmid R64, is processed by the prepilin peptidase PilU, but the N-terminal amino acid of the mature pilin is a non-methylated tryptophan that is otherwise modified. To study the relationship between the structure and function of PilU, 42 missense pilU mutations were constructed by PCR and site-directed mutagenesis, and the ability of these pilU mutants to complement a pilU null mutant for mating in liquid culture was analyzed. Although practically no conjugation was noted for 21 of the mutants, the remaining 21 supported varying levels of residual plasmid transfer activity. Two mutants with aspartic acid replacements in conserved motifs exhibited no PilU activity, suggesting that the product of the pilU gene is an aspartic acid peptidase, like TcpJ, the prepilin peptidare of Vibrio cholerae. No PilS processing was detected in 21 of the mutants, but the remaining 21 exhibited varying levels of residual PilS processing. A close correlation was noted between residual PilS processing activity and conjugative transfer, suggesting that the pilU gene product possesses prepilin peptidase activity, but is unable to methylate the N-terminal tryptophan. Based on the activity of pilU-phoA and pilU-lacZ fusion genes encoding different segments of PilU, a model for the membrane topology of the protein is also proposed. Furthermore, some amino acid substitutions in the pilU portion of the pilU-phoA and pilU-lacZ fusion genes were found to alter the membrane topology of the product.     

Analysis of the transfer region of the Streptomyces plasmid SCP2*

plJ903, a bifunctional derivative of the 31.4 kb low-copy number, conjugative Streptomyces plasmid SCP², was mutagenized in Streptomyces lividans using Tn4560. Mutant plasmids differing in their transfer frequencies, chromosome mobilization abilities, pock formation, and complementation properties were isolated. The mutations defined five transfer-related genes, traA, traB, traC, traD and spd, clustered in a region of 9 kb. The deduced sequences of the putative TraA and TraB proteins showed no overall similarity to known protein sequences, but the phenotype of traA mutant plasmids and sequence motifs in the putative TraA protein suggested that it might be a DNA helicase.     

Three dimensional structure of bacterial pili

Crystallographic and associated biochemical and structural studies are in progress on the fiber-forming pilin proteins of the gonococcal pilus. Preparative scale purification procedures have been developed for the gonococcal pilin protein, which appear generally applicable to bacterial pilins. For three gonococcal pilin protein strains, we have obtained both reassembled pilus fibers and three-dimensional crystals. One needle-shaped crystal form of gonococcal C30 pilin diffracts beyond 3 Å resolution using synchrotron x-ray radiation. A diffraction data set to 3.5 Å resolution has been collected on these needle-shaped crystals (lattice spacings a=125.4(3) b=120.4(3), c=26.61(4) Å) in which the packing arrangement of the pilin subunits appears to resemble that seen in the pilus fibers using electron microscopy. X-ray diffraction data confirm our proposed model for the overall polypeptide fold of a pilin subunit, which is an antiparallel 4- helix bundle similar to tobacco mosaic virus coat protein and myohemerythrin.     

Investigations of the F conjugation gene traI:traI mutants and lambdatraI transducing phages.

Summary A series of traI point and deletion mutants of Flac, and a traM mutant, were characterised. Complementation tests with an amber Flac traI mutant confirmed their genotypes, and in addition all the traI mutants, but not the traM mutant, were complemented by pRS31 (pSC101 traDI) and ED109 (traI). Judging from the efficiencies of plating of F-specific phages, none of the mutations affected pilus formation. The traI products of F and of the F-like plasmid R1 were interchangeable with each other but not with that of R100, while the traM product of F could not be replaced by those of R1 or of R100. Neither traI nor traM were needed for conjugal transfer of ColE1.Three transducing phages carrying traI were isolated by in vivo or in vitro techniques, and characterised by genetic complementation tests, by analysis of the fragments produced by restriction endonucleases, and by measurement of heteroduplex molecules. The genetic structures together with the sizes and F coordinates, of the transfer regions carried by the phages were thereby determined.Comparison of the proteins synthesised in UV-irradiated cells by one of the raI phages with those made by a derivative carrying an amber traImutation, allowed the traI product to be identified as a protein of molecular weight 174,000. In addition, the molecular weights of the traD (84,000), traS (18,000), and traT (25,000) products made by the traSTDI phage ED107 were measured.The possible roles of the traI and traM products in conjugation are discussed.     

Type IV Pilus Assembly Proficiency and Dynamics Influence Pilin Subunit Phospho-Form Macro- and Microheterogeneity in Neisseria gonorrhoeae

The PilE pilin subunit protein of the gonococcal Type IV pilus (Tfp) colonization factor undergoes multisite, covalent modification with the zwitterionic phospho-form modification phosphoethanolamine (PE). In a mutant lacking the pilin-like PilV protein however, PilE is modified with a mixture of PE and phosphocholine (PC). Moreover, intrastrain variation of PilE PC modification levels have been observed in backgrounds that constitutively express PptA (the protein phospho-form transferase A) required for both PE and PC modification. The molecular basis underlying phospho-form microheterogeneity in these instances remains poorly defined. Here, we examined the effects of mutations at numerous loci that disrupt or perturb Tfp assembly and observed that these mutants phenocopy the pilV mutant vis a vis phospho-form modification status. Thus, PC modification appears to be directly or indirectly responsive to the efficacy of pilin subunit interactions. Despite the complexity of contributing factors identified here, the data favor a model in which increased retention in the inner membrane may act as a key signal in altering phospho-form modification. These results also provide an alternative explanation for the variation in PilE PC levels observed previously and that has been assumed to be due to phase variation of pptA. Moreover, mass spectrometry revealed evidence for mono- and di-methylated forms of PE attached to PilE in mutants deficient in pilus assembly, directly implicating a methyltransferase-based pathway for PC synthesis in N. gonorrhoeae.     

Variant pili produced by mutants of the Flac plasmid

Transfer-proficient Flac mutants with reduced abilities to plate various F-specific phages were isolated, either by selection after mutagenesis, or as revertants of Flac traA mutants. In many of the mutants pilus-related properties were altered, including physical adsorption of R17 phage, the number of pili per cell and the outgrowth/retraction equilibrium. Complementation studies showed that the mutations were in traA, suggesting that specific alterations in the amino-acid sequence of the pilin subunit protein were responsible for the altered pilus properties. Complementation between the Flac traA mutants and the derepressed plasmid R100-1 restored phage sensitivity in some cases, suggesting that the incorporation of both mutant and R100-1 subunits into the pilus structure may result in conformational changes which increase the capacity of the pilus to interact with phages.     

Molecular principles of antigenic variation in Neisseria gonorrhoeae

The genome of Neisseria gonorrhoeae harbours many gene loci for the production of variant pili. Strain MS11 has two expression genes (pilE) with promoter and complete coding sequences. The remaining genes are silent (pilS) lacking the promoter and the conservative amino terminals coding sequences of pilin. The pilus genes consist of six variable minicassettes (mc's), that are flancked by strictly conserved sequences. Upon phase (P⁺ to P⁺) and antigenic (P⁺ to P^–, or vice versa) transitions minicassettes from silent loci are transferred from silent pilus gene copies to the expression gene by gene conversion. P^– variants resulting from such rearrangements still produce pilin mRNA as well as pilin, but only a few are found on the surface of those gonococci.     

Cloning and characterization of the bundle-forming pilin gene of enteropathogenic Escherichia coli and its distribution in Salmonella serotypes

bfp, the structural gene of the major repeating bundle-forming pilus (BFP) subunit, was cloned from the enteroadherent factor (EAF) plasmid of enteropathogenic Escherichia coli (EPEC) strain B171 (0111:NM). The bfp open reading frame encoded a 193-amlno-acid protein; comparison of this sequence with the biochemically determined N-terminal amino acid sequence showed that the mature pilin protein is comprised of 180 amino acids, that this sequence is similar to other members of the type IV pilin family, and that it is preceded by a 13-amino-acid signal peptide. Expression of the cloned bfp structural gene in an EPEC strain that had been cured of the EAF plasmid yielded a 21000 dalton protein that co-migrated with the BFP precursor protein. Thus, other genes, probably carried by the EAF plasmid, are required for the maturation of the bfp product and for the production of extracellular pilus filaments. Use of bfp as a hybridization probe showed that homologous sequences are present in all tested EPEC strains and in 13 of 16 tested Salmonelia serotypes. Fifty per cent of these bfp probe-sensitive salmonellae exhibited the localized-adherence (LA) phenotype when incubated with tissue culture cell monolayers, a trait previously associated with EAF plasmid-containing EPEC strains. Scanning electron micrographs of a bfp probe-positive, LA-positive Salmonella dublin strain showed that it grows as adherent colonies on infected monolayers and that within these colonies, BFP-like fibres form inter-bacterial linkages. For EAF plasmid-containing EPEC strains and for severai Salmonella serotypes, BFP expression may lead to the development of adherent colonies on epithelial surfaces early in the infective process.     

The binding of Pseudomonas aeruginosa pili to glycosphingolipids is a tip-associated event involving the C-terminal region of the structural pilin subunit

Pili are one of the adhesins of Pseudomonas aeruginosa that mediate adherence to epithelial cell-surface receptors. The pili of P. aeruginosa strains PAK and PAO were examined and found to bind gangliotetraosyl ceramide (asialo-GM₁) and, to a lesser extend, ll³N-acetylneuraminosylgangliotetraosyl ceramide (GM₁) in solid-phase binding assays. Asialo-GM₁, but not GM₁, inhibited both PAK and PAK pili binding to immobilized asialo-GM₁ on the microtitre plate. PAO pili competitively inhibited PAK pili binding to asialo-GM₁, suggesting the presence of a structurally similar receptor-binding domain in both pilus types. The interaction between asialo-GM₁ and pili occurs at the pilus tip as asialo-GM₁ coated colloidal gold only decorates the tip of purified pili. Three sets of evidence suggest that the C-terminal disulphide-bonded region of the Pseudomonas pilin is exposed at the tip of the pilus: (i) immunocytochemical studies indicate that P. aeruginosa pili have a basal-tip structural differentiation where the monoclonal antibody (mAb) PK3B recognizes an antigenic epitope displayed only on the basal ends of pili (produced by shearing) while the mAb PK99H, whose antigenic epitope resides in residues 134–140 (Wong et al., 1992), binds only to the tip of PAK pili; (ii) synthetic peptides, PAK(128–144)^ox-OH and PAO(128–144)^ox-OH, which correspond to the C-terminal disulphide-bonded region of Pseudomonas pilin are able to bind to asialo-GM₁ and inhibit the binding of pili to the glycolipid; (iii) PK99H was shown to block PAK pilus binding to asialo-GM₁ Monoclonal antibody PK3B had no effect on PAK pili binding to asialo-GM₁ Thus, the adherence of the Pseudomonas pilus to glycosphingolipid receptors is a tip-associated phenomenon Involving a tip-exposed C-terminal region of the pilin structural subunit.     

Characterization of the F-plasmid conjugative transfer gene traU.

We characterized the traU gene of the Escherichia coli K-12 conjugative plasmid F. Plasmids carrying segments of the F transfer operon were tested for their capacity to complement F lac traU526. The protein products of TraU+ clones were identified, and the nucleotide sequence of traU was determined. traU mapped between traW and trbC. It encodes a 330-amino-acid, Mr36,786 polypeptide that is processed. Ethanol caused accumulation of a precursor polypeptide; removal of ethanol permitted processing of the protein to occur. Because F lac traU526 strains appear to be resistant to F-pilus-specific phages, traU has been considered an F-pilus assembly gene. However, electron microscopic analysis indicated that the traU526 amber mutation caused only a 50% reduction in F-piliation. Since F lac traU526 strains also retain considerable transfer proficiency, new traU mutations were constructed by replacing a segment of traU with a kanamycin resistance gene. Introduction of these mutations into a transfer-proficient plasmid caused a drastic reduction in transfer proficiency, but pilus filaments remained visible at approximately 20% of the wild-type frequency. Like traU526 strains, such mutants were unable to plaque F-pilus-specific phages but exhibited a slight sensitivity on spot tests. Complementation with a TraU+ plasmid restored the wild-type transfer and phage sensitivity phenotypes. Thus, an intact traU product appears to be more essential to conjugal DNA transfer than to assembly of pilus filaments.