Nitrogen and phosphate mass balance in a sub-surface flow constructed wetland for treating municipal wastewater

This paper reports on the feasibility of using sub-surface horizontal flow constructed wetlands to treat municipal wastewater in Hong Kong. Two different hydraulic retention times (10-day and 5-day) and different types of treatments (with and without vegetation) were investigated. Better performance in the planted treatments was obtained in both hydraulic retention time treatments. Nutrients were better removed in treatments with plants (DOC 68% and 72%; NH₄-N 92% and 95%; TKN 65% and 62%; PO₄-P 79% and 72%; TP 67% and 52% for 10-day HRT; 5-day HRT treatments). In the unplanted treatments, negative values were achieved in the removal of phosphate in wastewater and the presence of plants could further polish the wastewater so phosphate concentrations decreased in the planted treatments. The effluent concentrations in the planted treatments meet the Inland Water A effluent standard, and they can be used in recreation park in Hong Kong (1 mg L⁻¹ of NO_x; 15 mg L⁻¹ of NH₃; 1 mg L⁻¹ of TP).     

Two ways to achieve an anammox influent from real reject water treatment at lab-scale: Partial SBR nitrification and SHARON process

A comparative study to produce the correct influent for Anammox process from anaerobic sludge reject water (700–800 mg NH₄⁺-N L⁻¹) was considered here. The influent for the Anammox process must be composed of NH₄⁺-N and NO₂⁻-N in a ratio 1:1 and therefore only a partial nitrification of ammonium to nitrite is required. The modifications of parameters (temperature, ammonium concentration, pH and solid retention time) allows to achieve this partial nitrification with a final effluent only composed by NH₄⁺-N and NO₂⁻-N at the right stoichiometric ratio. The equal ratio of HCO₃⁻/NH₄⁺ in reject water results in a natural pH decrease when approximately 50% of NH₄⁺ is oxidised. A Sequencing batch reactor (SBR) and a chemostat type of reactor (single-reactor high activity ammonia removal over nitrite (SHARON) process) were studied to obtain the required Anammox influent. At steady state conditions, both systems had a specific conversion rate around 40 mg NH₄⁺-N g⁻¹ volatile suspended solids (VSS) h⁻¹, but in terms of absolute nitrogen removal the SBR conversion was 1.1 kg N day⁻¹ m⁻³, whereas in the SHARON chemostat was 0.35 kg N day⁻¹ m⁻³ due to the different hydraulic retention time (HRT) used. Both systems are compared from operational (including starvation experiments) and kinetic point of view and their advantages/disadvantages are discussed.     

Effect of hydraulic retention time on the treatment of secondary effluent in a subsurface flow constructed wetland

This study evaluates the potential of subsurface flow (SSF) constructed wetlands (CWs) for tertiary treatment of wastewater at four shorter HRTs (1–4 days). The CWs were planted with Typha angustata, which was observed in our earlier study to be more efficient than Phragmites karka and Scirpus littoralis. The CWs comprised four rectangular treatment cells (2.14 m × 0.76 m × 0.61 m) filled with layers of gravel of two different sizes (approximately 2.5 cm and 1.5 cm diameter) to a depth of 0.61 m. The inflow rates of the secondary effluent in the four cells were accordingly fixed at 300 L d^?1, 150 L d^?1, 100 L d^?1 and 75 L d^?1, respectively, for 1, 2, 3 and 4 days HRT. The hydraulic loads ranged between 59.05 mm d^?1 and 236.22 mm d^?1.The wastewater inflow into the CW system as well as the treated effluent were analyzed, using standard methods, at regular intervals for various forms of nitrogen (NH₄-N, NO₃-N and TKN), orthophosphate-P and organic matter (BOD and COD) concentrations over a period of five weeks after the development of a dense stand.The higher HRT of 4 days not only helped maximum removal of all the pollutants but also maintained the stability of the treatment efficiency throughout the monitoring period. For the nutrients (NH₄-N, NO₃-N and TKN), HRT played a more significant role in their removal than in case of organic matter (BOD₃ and COD). More than 90% of NO₃-N and TKN and 100% of NH₄-N were removed from the wastewater at 4 days HRT.At lower HRTs, the mass loading rate was higher with greater fluctuation. However mass reduction efficiency of the T. angustata CW for all forms of nitrogen was >80% with the HRTs of 2, 3 and 4 days.     

Nitrogen removal enhanced by shunt distributing wastewater in a subsurface wastewater infiltration system

Three pilot subsurface wastewater infiltration systems filled with the same mixed matrix made of 80% brown soil and cinder at a weight of 20% were constructed in the laboratory. All systems worked successfully in the intermittent feeding mode with total hydraulic loading of 4 m³/(m² d) for over 2 months, with the optimal parameters of shunt ratio of 1:1 and shunt position at the depth of 0.7 m was achieved on the basis of large amounts of experimental data. The experiment results showed that shunt distributing wastewater could significantly improve the nitrogen removal in the subsurface infiltration system and the average removal rates of TN and NH₄-N increased by 10% and 5.67%, respectively. Shunt distributing wastewater had little influence on the removal rates of COD and TP. The results suggested that shunt distributing wastewater was simple and effective for nitrogen removal.     

NH3 gas absorption and bio-oxidation in a single bioscrubber system

A combined ammonia gas absorption and nitrification was conducted in a single bioscrubber. The reactor was consisted of a bubble column (gas absorption) and a packed bed (nitrification) which contained poly-urethane foams with immobilized nitrifying activated sludge. The entering gas and scrubbing liquid were contacted countercurrently. The bubble column elimination capacity (EC) was 26.74 g NH₃/m³ h at >99% ammonia gas removal and effluent gas concentration lower than 2 ppm_v. Without ammonium supplement, EC can reach 35.66 g NH₃/m³ h which is equivalently the highest tolerable ammonia loading rate of 700 g N/m³ day (1650 mg N/L) at the packed bed. At this level, 593 g N/m³-day ammonia removal rate was achieved via nitrification, dominated by ammonia oxidation. Partial recycling (R/Q = 0.5) of scrubbing solution reduced the secondary wastewater volume by producing 233% more concentrated nitrified products. Hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 24 h was found optimal for both processes (gas absorption and nitrification).     

Removal of total nitrogen by Cyperus alternifolius from wastewaters in simulated vertical-flow constructed wetlands

The vertical-flow constructed wetland (VFCW) is a promising engineering technique for removal of excess nutrients and certain pollutants from wastewaters. This study investigated the uptake and removal of total nitrogen (TN) by Cyperus alternifolius from domestic wastewaters in simulated VFCWs. A total of eight simulated VFCW treatments, including two different substrates, two different wet-to-dry ratios, and with and without C. alternifolius species (2 × 2 × 2 = 8), were employed for an operation period of 2 years in this study. Results show that more TN was removed from the influent with the presence of C. alternifolius compared to without this plant species. A linear correlation existed between the aboveground biomass and its TN content. An increase in total biomass by 100 g resulted in an increase in TN accumulation in the aboveground biomass by 2.4 g. Large amounts of TN were removed by the aboveground biomass compared to those by substrate adsorption. Results suggest that C. alternifolius played a discernable role in removal of TN from wastewaters in the simulated VFCWs.     

Efficient nitrogen removal in a pilot system based on upflow multi-layer bioreactor for treatment of strong nitrogenous swine wastewater

In order to prevent the toxic effect caused by high strength ammonium in a swine wastewater treatment system, a patented upflow multi-layer bioreactor (UMBR) as a pre-anoxic tank was applied to a pilot-scale plant with a treatment capacity of 5 m³/d. This plant was operated for 4 months at a high IR ratio in the range of 10–17, in order to alleviate the toxic effects caused by high strength ammonium. A computational fluid dynamic (CFD) analysis was also conducted to design and configure the rotating distributors in the UMBR. At an IR ratio of about 17, the influent NH₄⁺-N (1169 mg N/L) was diluted to less than 80 mg N/L at the head of the UMBR, and then was completely nitrified (about 98.3%) in the aeration tank, without any inhibition caused by high strength ammonium. The nitrate at a concentration of about 58.2 mg N/L recycled from the aeration tank was completely denitrified in UMBR #1, which was operated at an actual hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 3.5 h.     

Comparison of the treatment performances of blast furnace slag-based and gravel-based vertical flow wetlands operated identically for domestic wastewater treatment in Turkey

In 2001, to foster the practical development of constructed wetlands (CWs) used for domestic wastewater treatment in Turkey, vertical subsurface flow constructed wetlands (30 m² of each) were implemented on the campus of the METU, Ankara, Turkey. The main objective of the research was to quantify the effect of different filter media on the treatment performance of vertical flow wetlands in the prevailing climate of Ankara. Thus, a gravel-filled wetland and a blast furnace granulated iron slag-filled wetland were operated identically with primarily treated domestic wastewater (3 m³ d⁻¹) at a hydraulic loading rate of 0.100 m d⁻¹, intermittently. Both of the wetland cells were planted with Phragmites australis. According to the first year results, average removal efficiencies for the slag and gravel wetland cells were as follows: total suspended solids (TSS) (63% and 59%), chemical oxygen demand (COD) (47% and 44%), NH₄⁺–N (88% and 53%), total nitrogen (TN) (44% and 39%), PO₄³⁻-P (44% and 1%) and total phosphorus (TP) (45% and 4%). The treatment performances of the slag-filled wetland were better than that of the gravel-filled wetland in terms of removal of phosphorus and production of nitrate. Since this study was a pioneer for implementation of subsurface constructed wetlands in Turkey using local sources, it has proved that this eco-technology could also be used effectively for water quality enhancement in Turkey.     

Wastewater treatment performance of a vermifilter enhancement by a converter slag–coal cinder filter

The study aimed at investigating rural domestic wastewater treatment performance through vermifilter enhancement by a converter slag–coal cinder filter. The research was carried out by column experiments in a lab scale. Results showed the average removal rate of TCOD, BOD, ammonia nitrogen (NH₄⁺-N) and phosphorus removal by the system were 78.0%, 98.4%, 90.3%, 62.4%, respectively at a hydraulic loading rate of 4 m³ m^?2 day^?1. Vermifiltration was effective for insoluble organic matter and suspended solid removal, and the converter slag–coal cinder filter played an important role in phosphorus removal. The molecular weight of particles in the influent and effluents from every unit of the system were distributed in a wide range between 0.1 kDa and 10,000 kDa with predominance of values between 10 kDa and 300 kDa; the major portion of soluble material are high MW compounds. In addition, the optimal design parameters for vermifiltration and converter slag and coal cinder filters, respectively, were studied in the experiments.     

Kinetics of pollutant removal from domestic wastewater in a tropical horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetland system: Effects of hydraulic loading rate

The treatment capacity of constructed wetlands is expected to be high in tropical areas because of the warm temperatures and the associated higher rates of microbial activity. A pilot scale horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetland system filled with river sand and planted with Phragmites vallatoria (L.) Veldkamp was set up in the southern part of Vietnam to assess the treatment capacity and the removal rate kinetics under tropical conditions. The system received municipal wastewater at four hydraulic loading rates (HLRs) of 31, 62, 104 and 146 mm day^?1. Removals of TSS, BOD₅ and COD were efficient at all HLRs with mean removal rates of 86–95%, 65–83% and 57–84%, respectively. Removals of N and P decreased with HLRs and were: NH₄-N 0–91%; TN 16–84% and TP 72–99%. First-order area-based removal rate constants (k, m year^?1) estimated from sampling along the length of the wetland from inlet to outlet at the four HLRs were in the range of 25–95 (BOD₅), 22–30 (COD), 31–115 (TSS), 5–24 (TN and TKN) and 41–84 (TP) at background concentrations (C*) of 5, 10, 0, 1.5 and 0 mg L^?1, respectively. The estimated k-values should not be used for design purposes, as site-specific differences and stochastic variability can be high. However, the study shows that domestic wastewater can be treated in horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetland systems to meet even the most stringent Vietnamese standards for discharge into surface waters.     

The role of plants in the removal of nutrients at a constructed wetland treating agricultural (dairy) wastewater,Ontario, Canada

The South Nation River Watershed, in eastern Ontario, Canada, is an agricultural watershed impacted by excess nutrient loading primarily from agricultural activities. A constructed wetland for the treatment of agricultural wastewater from a 150-cow dairy operation in this watershed was monitored in its eighth operating season to evaluate the proportion of total nitrogen (TN) (approximated by total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN) due to low NO₃⁻) and total phosphorus (TP) removal that could be attributed to storage in Typha latifolia L. and Typha angustifolia L., which dominate this system. Nutrient loading rates were high, with 16.2 kg ha⁻¹ d⁻¹ N and 3.4 kg ha⁻¹ d⁻¹ P entering the wetland and loading the first wetland cell. Plant uptake accounted for 0.7% of TKN removal when the vegetated free water surface cells were considered together. However, separately, in the second wetland cell with lower N and P loading rates, plants accounted for 9% of TKN, 21% of NH₄⁺ and 5% of TP removal. Plant uptake was significant to overall removal given wetland age and nutrient loading. Nutrient storage during the growing season at this constructed wetland helped reduce the nutrient load entering the watershed, already stressed by intensive local agriculture.     

Characteristics of simultaneous organic and nutrient removal in a pilot-scale vertical submerged membrane bioreactor (VSMBR) treating municipal wastewater at various temperatures

A pilot-scale vertical submerged membrane bioreactor (VSMBR) with anoxic and oxic zones in one reactor was operated in an attempt to reduce the problems concerning effective removal of organic matter and nutrients from municipal wastewater. Source water with total chemical oxygen demand (TCOD)/total nitrogen (TN) ratio of 5.5 was treated at various temperatures (13–25 °C) over an interval of about 1 year. As a result, total suspended solid (TSS) and TCOD were removed by 100% and higher than 98%, respectively. Moreover, the average removal efficiencies of TN and total phosphorus (TP) were found to be 74% and 78% at 8 h-hydraulic retention time (HRT) and 60-days sludge retention time (SRT). Under these conditions, the specific removal rates (SRR) of TN and TP were found to be 0.093 kg N m⁻³ day⁻¹ and 0.008 kg P m⁻³ day⁻¹, and the daily production of excess sludge (DPES), 0.058 kg TSS day⁻¹.     

Application of struvite precipitation as a pretreatment in treating swine wastewater

In this study, the effect of the pretreatment of NH₄-N by struvite precipitation on biological nitrogen removal was investigated in treating swine wastewater. Evaluation was mainly focused on nitrification which occurred in the activated sludge system after struvite precipitation. Laboratory experiments were performed at four different hydraulic retention times (HRT), i.e., 48, 32, 24 and 16 h. Results of the long-term operation of systems showed that the struvite precipitation used as the pretreatment of raw swine wastewater enhanced the nitrification performance in activated sludge system by reducing the applied loading rates of NH₄-N and TCOD in all operating conditions. The reduction of the applied NH₄-N loading rate kept the levels of free ammonia (FA) concentration in biological reactors low and it prevented nitrite accumulation. In addition, the struvite precipitation elicited the biological denitrification reaction and PO₄-P removal by increasing the ratios of carbon-to-nitrogen and carbon-to-phosphorus of wastewater after struvite precipitation. The struvite precipitation also enhanced the biological TCOD removal performance by reducing the toxic effect of FA. Triplicate INT-dehydrogenase tests clearly showed that FA inhibited the degradation of organic matter in activated sludge system. Finally, the struvite precipitation contributed to high TCOD, T-N and PO₄-P removals of 83, 90, and 97% by facilitating biological reaction at a short HRT of 16 h.     

Removal of carbon and nutrients from low strength domestic wastewater by expanded granular sludge bed-zeolite bed filtration (EGSB-ZBF) integrated treatment concept

The performance of an expanded granular sludge bed (EGSB) reactor coupled with zeolite bed filtration (ZBF) for treating low strength domestic wastewater was monitored at 35 °C for 7 months. The whole operation period of EGSB system was divided into five phases. Each phase ran at up-flow velocity (m/h) of 0.51, 1.02, 3.57, 2.05, 9.69, and hydraulic retention time (HRT) (h) of 6, 3, 0.87, 1.5, 0.32, respectively. The influent chemical oxygen demand (COD) was kept approximate at 150 ± 100 mg/L. Under these conditions, the COD removal efficiency of using EGSB system in five phases reached to 81.08, 57.94, 82.79, 56.58 and 79.52%, respectively. Moreover, since nutrients such as NH₄⁺ and PO₄³⁻ were only removed to a limited extent by EGSB, additional treatment is required. The ZBF was employed in phase 2 as a post-treatment following EGSB. NH₄⁺ and PO₄³⁻ concentrations were decreased by 100%, respectively, in the first 2 or 3 d using fresh zeolite. The simple design and excellent treatment performance indicated that this system could be used as a novel Sewage Integrated Treatment System (SITS) for developing country especially in a tropical area.     

Biological treatment of oilfield-produced water: A field pilot study

A field test was conducted on a hydrolysis acidification/bio-contact oxidation system (HA/BCO) to treat oilfield-produced water with high salinity. By operating the biodegradation system for three months with a hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 32 h and a volumetric load of 0.28 kg COD m³ d^?1, the treatment process achieved mean removal efficiencies of 63.5% for chemical oxygen demand (COD), 45% for NH₃-N, 79.5% for total suspended solid (TSS), and 68.0% for total petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH). GC/MS was used to analyze relative changes of components of main organic waste in a process indicating that the influent wastewater contained organic compounds from C₁₂H₂₆ to C₃₅H₇₂, which could be degraded effectively with the coordinated action of hydrolysis acidification and aerobic treatment. The use of maize powder can enhance environmental adaptability of microorganisms and biodegradation ability and is recommended as a nutrient supplement to maintain good treatment performance.     

Growth and nutrient removal properties of a freshwater microalga Scenedesmus sp. LX1 under different kinds of nitrogen sources

Microalgae have received much attention for the inorganic nutrient removal in tertiary treatment of domestic wastewater. Effect of different kinds of nitrogen sources on the growth and nitrogen/phosphorus removal properties of a newly isolated freshwater microalga, Scenedesmus sp. LX1, from a low-nutrient environment condition was studied and reported in this paper. The order of specific growth rate of the microalga with different nitrogen sources was NH₄-N > urea-N > NO₃-N. With nitrate or urea as nitrogen source, the microalga could grow well and remove both nitrogen and phosphorus efficiently (90% nitrogen and nearly 100% phosphorus were removed). However, with ammonium as the nitrogen source, the maximum algal density was relatively low, and the nitrogen and phosphorus removal efficiencies were as low as 31.1% and 76.4%, respectively. This was caused by the inhibitory effect of algal culture's acid pH due to H⁺ releasing from NH₄⁺ during algal cultivation process.     

Combined industrial and domestic wastewater treatment by periodic allocating water hybrid hydrolysis acidification reactor followed by SBR

A pilot-scale hybrid hydrolysis acidification reactor (HHAR) with periodic water allocation mode operation followed by sequencing batch reactor (SBR) in anoxic and aerobic metabolic function was evaluated for the treatment of low-biodegradable combined industrial and domestic wastewater. The HHAR combines the advantages of both the UASB reactor and AF, omitting the three-phase separator. Furthermore, it has lower average up-flow velocity (0.38–0.92 m/h) and higher periodic up-flow velocity (6 m/h), which made the reactor keep higher MLSS concentration (more than 10,000 mg/L) and sludge-bed is in periodic “expansion-sedimentation-expansion” state. When HRT less than 10 h, the B/C variation was positive and reached the maximum value of 0.07 at 8 h. SBR with a total cycle period of 4.5 h was applied as the post-treatment process to remove residual COD, NH₃-N and TN. At steady stage, the pilot-scale SBR effluent COD, NH₃-N and TN concentration was 65, 0.75 and 17.71 mg/L, corresponding in this case to full-scale SBR plant effluent was 93, 16.4 and 34 mg/L. Comparison results indicated that the application of HHAR–SBR system to treat combined industrial and domestic wastewater can improve effluent quality significantly.     

Effect of operational and design parameters on removal efficiency of pilot-scale FWS constructed wetlands and comparison with HSF systems

In order to investigate the effect of temperature, hydraulic residence time (HRT), vegetation type, substrate material and wetland shape on the performance of free-water surface (FWS) constructed wetlands treating wastewater, 5 pilot-scale units were constructed and operated continuously from December 2004 until March 2007 in parallel experiments. Four of the units (A, B, C, D) were rectangular in plan view with dimensions 3.40 m in length and 0.85 m in width, and contained substrate material at a thickness of 0.45 m. The fifth unit (E) had a trapezoidal plan view shape, with a width at the inlet of 1.15 m and at the outlet of 0.55 m, while the length and the thickness of the substrate were the same as in the other four. All units operated at a water depth of 0.10 m. Units B–E contained clay substrate and unit A contained sand. The four units with clay were planted as follows: two with cattails (B and E), one with common reeds (C), and one with giant reeds (D). Unit A, containing sand, was planted with cattails. Planting and substrate material combinations were appropriate for comparison of the effect of vegetation and material type on the function of the system. Synthetic wastewater was introduced in the units. During the operation period four HRTs (i.e., 6 days, 8 days, 14 days and 20 days) were used, while wastewater temperatures varied from about 0.0 °C to 29.1 °C. The removal performance of the five constructed wetland units was good, since it reached on the average 77.5%, 67.9%, 60.4%, 53.9%, 56.0% and 51.7% for BOD, COD, TKN, ammonia (NH₄-N), ortho-phosphate (PO₄-P) and total phosphorus (TP), respectively. BOD and phosphorus removal efficiencies showed dependence on temperature in most units. The 14-day HRT was found adequate for acceptable removal of organic matter, nitrogen and phosphorus for most temperatures. A 20-day HRT is recommended for acceptable removal of BOD and PO₄-P in the cold season. The unit with the trapezoidal plan view shape showed the best performance, with mean removals of 80.1%, 73.5%, 70.4%, 68.6%, 64.7% and 63.5% for BOD, COD, TKN, NH₄-N, PO₄-P and TP, respectively. The cattail was found statistically more efficient than the other two plants in COD and PO₄-P removal. The unit that contained the clay substrate was found statistically more efficient in phosphorus removal than the unit containing sand. HSF CW units were found more efficient than FWS units in removal of most pollutant.     

Degradation of synthetic reactive azo dyes and treatment of textile wastewater by a fungi consortium reactor

In this paper, two microbial cultures with high decolorization efficiencies of reactive dyes were obtained and were proved to be dominant with fungi consortium in which 21 fungal strains were isolated and 8 of them showed significant decolorization effect to reactive red M-3BE. A 4.5 l continuous biofilm reactor was established using the mixed cultures to investigate the decolorization performance and the system stability under the conditions of simulated and real textile wastewater as influents. The optimal nutrient feed to this bioreactor was 0.5 g l⁻¹ glucose and 0.1 g l⁻¹ (NH₄)₂SO₄ when 30 mg l⁻¹ reactive black 5 was used as initial dye concentrations. Dye mineralization rates of 50–75% and color removal efficiencies of 70–80% were obtained at 12 h hydraulic retention time (HRT) in this case. Higher glucose concentrations in the influents could significantly improve color removal, but was not helpful for dye mineralization. Besides reactive black 5, the bioreactor could effectively decolorize reactive red M-3BE, acid red 249 and real textile wastewater with efficiency of 65%, 94% and 89%, respectively. In addition, the microbial community on the biofilm was monitored in the whole running process. The results indicated fungi as a dominant population in the decolorization system with the ratio of fungi to bacteria 6.8:1 to 51.8:1 under all the tested influent conditions. Analysis of molecular biological detection indicated that yeasts of genus Candida occupied 70% in the fungal clone library based on 26S rRNA gene sequences.     

A comparative study of surface and subsurface flow constructed wetlands for treatment of combined sewer overflows: A greenhouse experiment

The use of surface flow (SFCWs) and subsurface flow constructed wetlands (SFCWs) for the treatment of combined sewer overflows was assessed at pilot scale. Synthetic wastewater was applied in three batches with decreasing concentrations to mimic concentration profiles that are obtained in the field during overflow events. Three simulated combined sewer overflows were applied on each wetland. Composite water samples (60 in total) were taken for a period of 8 days to study the removal of total nitrogen (Ntot), NH₄–N, NO₃–N, total COD (CODtot) and total phosphorus. Redox potential, which was monitored at various locations along the wetlands, was more negative in the SSFCWs. In general, removal occurred faster in the SSFCWs and the final concentrations were lower. The removal of Ntot was only 36.6 ± 3.3% in the SFCWs due to nitrification-limiting conditions. The conditions in the SSFCWs, in contrast, seemed to promote Ntot removal (removal efficiency 96.7 ± 1.9%). The removal of P was hampered in both wetland types by reducing conditions. P that was initially removed was released again from the substrates later on. First-order removal rate constants were derived for the removal of both CODtot (SSFCWs: 1.1 ± 0.3 m d^?1; SFCWs: 0.17 ± 0.06 m d^?1) and Ntot (SSFCWs: 0.4 ± 0.1 m d^?1; SFCWs: 1.7 ± 0.5 m d^?1).