Contrasting ‘Top-Down’ Effects of Crustacean Zooplankton Grazing on Bacteria and Phytoflagellates

The combined effects of grazing and nutrient regeneration by Daphnia and Eudiaptomus on the growth of Rhodomonas and heterotrophic bacteria was assessed experimentally. The responses of Rhodomonas and bacteria to the grazers were measured as net specific growth rate over the entire experimental periods, as well as production and specific production at the end of the experiments. Both zooplankton species had a negative effect on Rhodomonas net specific growth rate due to grazing and a positive effect on specific primary production due to nutrient regeneration. Daphnia had no effect on bacterial net specific growth rate, bacterial production or specific bacterial production in one of two experiments. In the other experiment, however, both bacterial growth rate and production decreased as a result of grazing. Furthermore, Daphnia had a negative effect on specific bacterial production, but Eudiaptomus had a positive effect on all bacterial parameters due to nutrient regeneration, probably of phosphorus. Positive effects of copepods on bacterial growth has previously been attributed to trophic cascades via protozoa. However, the present experiments show that regeneration of nutrients, especially phosphorus, may account for a large part of the stimulation of bacterial growth.     

The role of food quality for zooplankton: remarks on the state-of-the-art, perspectives and priorities

1. This paper summarizes the salient features of the contributions to the workshop on The Role of Food Quality for Zooplankton. In this paper we attempt critically to evaluate our present knowledge in the light of new studies. 2. For the growth and reproduction of zooplankton, the existing literature considers two main limiting factors in the diet, i.e. phosphorus (homeostasis theory) and fatty acids. Nevertheless, interpretations and opinions regarding the importance of these two factors are the subject of controversy in the literature. No attempts have been made to link these two potentially limiting factors, let alone give a coherent view based on the mechanisms behind limitation. Aquaculture studies provide some direct evidence of the importance of the long-chained poly unsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) for zooplankton. The presence of PUFA in phytoplankton is reported to affect the growth rates of zooplankton significantly. 3. Field data on carbon and phosphorus indicate a greater constancy of the C : P ratios of zooplankton than of their food. Empirical data and modelling studies suggest that zooplankton, especially Daphnia spp., may maintain nutrient homeostasis by incorporating a greater proportion of the limiting nutrients ingested and releasing more of nutrients in excess supply. The need for conserving nutrients in short supply increases with the increase in growth rates. 4. Phosphorus certainly influences zooplankton food directly. Direct supplementation of the P-insufficient algal diet with PO₄-P alone discernibly improves the growth in daphnids. It is highly plausible that P limitation and fatty acid limitation are not mutually exclusive alternatives. The two, separately or in conjunction, can control growth of at least some lake zooplankters, especially daphnids. 5. Besides a shortage of nutrient (P), other environmental factors (irradiance, UV-radiation, temperature) can also adversely affect the zooplankton diet, including its digestibility and assimilation efficiency. 6. It is not yet clear if PUFA deficiency in the diet is in some way related to or caused by P deficiency. It is, however, now known that the EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid, 20 : 5ω3) content of certain algae is markedly reduced under P-limitation and that it differs significantly among the different taxonomic groups of phytoplankton. Diatoms and flagellates are generally considered as good-quality foods because of their high EPA content. On the contrary, cyanobacteria are low-quality food, having both low EPA and P content. 7. Recent experiments reveal that the relative importance of fatty acids for daphnids increases with a decreasing C : P ratio in the food, i.e. if P is no longer limiting, and vice versa. For daphnids, there is possibly a switch between P-limitation and PUFA limitation at intermediate C : P ratios. At higher C : P ratios, P is more important but at lower ratios PUFA are more crucial for growth and reproduction. 8. Lastly, the accumulating evidence for P limitation is stronger than that for fatty acid limitation.     

Seasonal seston stoichiometry: effects on zooplankton in cyanobacteria-dominated lakes

Seasonal dynamics in elemental composition [carbon (C), nitrogenand phosphorus (P)] of seston and zooplankton were studied overseveral years in three hypereutrophic Dutch lakes with persistentdominance and high biomass of cyanobacteria. In all three lakes,there was a strong pattern with decreased P-content and increasedC:P ratio in seston (<150 µm) coinciding with the increasein water temperature. The seston C:P ratios (at:at) were morethan doubled with the rising temperature, i.e. from 200 (at:at)in winter to 500 in summer. Sestonic C:P ratios increased overthe growing season, suggesting that seasonal dynamics amongautotrophs with high P-uptake in winter and support of subsequentphytoplankton growth by consumption of internal cellular P (P-quota)was the main cause of low sestonic P contents in late summer.This could, however, occur in concert with a physiologicallydriven decrease in cell-specific P at higher temperatures insummer. In contrast, the annual variation of C:P ratios of thezooplankton fraction was only 10% of that of seston. The variationsof C:P ratios of the zooplankton were, nevertheless, stronglycorrelated with those of seston. For most of the summer, sestonC:P ratios were far above the threshold ratio for P-limitationin Daphnia and other P-demanding species. This will pose furtherconstraints on growth performance of Daphnia in these lakes,thus adding to the fish predation pressure and the poor foodquality of cyanobacteria per se. The low grazing pressure causesa high biomass of low-quality autotrophs, promoting a stablestate with low trophic transfer efficiency.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Daphnia</Emphasis> distribution in Andean Patagonian lakes: effect of low food quality and fish predation

Food quality in terms of carbon (C):phosphorus (P) ratio can constrain the success of highly demanding P herbivores as Daphnia. North Andean Patagonian lakes are ultraoligotrophic with low nutrient concentrations and well-developed euphotic zones. We investigated the distribution of the large Daphnia commutata in relation with food quality (sestonic C:P ratio) and predation risk in these lakes. The predation risk was estimated based on the fish species present and their relative eye diameter and transparency of the lake. The C:P ratios in the lakes were high, varying from 350 to >1,200. The lakes with D. commutata had significantly lower C:P ratio than those without these daphnids. On the other hand, those lakes where Daphnia is present have the lower predation risk than those were Daphnia is absent. In addition, we carried out growth experiments with neonates and natural seston of three lakes with different C:P ratio. The growth rates were inversely related with C:P of the food. Food quality and predation risk together determined the success or failure of large Daphnia populations in these Andean clear ultraoligotrophic lakes.     

Response of phytoplankton and bacteria to nutrients and zooplankton: a mesocosm experiment

Although both nutrient inputs and zooplankton grazing are importantto phytoplankton and bacteria in lakes, controversy surroundsthe relative importance of grazing pressure for these two groupsof organisms. For phytoplankton, the controversy revolves aroundwhether zooplankton grazers, especially large cladocerans likeDaphnia, can effectively reduce phytoplankton populations regardlessof nutrient conditions. For bacteria, little is known aboutthe balance between possible direct and indirect effects ofboth nutrients and zooplankton grazing. However, there is evidencethat bacteria may affect phytoplankton responses to nutrientsor zooplankton grazing through direct or apparent competition.We performed a mesocosm experiment to evaluate the relativeimportance of the effects of nutrients and zooplankton grazingfor phytoplankton and bacteria, and to determine whether bacteriamediate phytoplankton responses to these factors. The factorialdesign crossed two zooplankton treatments (unsieved and sieved)with four nutrient treatments (0, 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 µgphosphorus (P) l^–1 day^–1 together with nitrogen(N) at a N:P ratio of 20:1 by weight). Weekly sieving with 300µm mesh reduced the average size of crustacean zooplanktonin the mesocosms, decreased the numbers and biomass of Daphnia,and increased the biomass of adult copepods. Nutrient enrichmentcaused significant increases in phytoplankton chlorophyll a(4–5x), bacterial abundance and production (1.3x and 1.6x,respectively), Daphnia (3x) and total zooplankton biomass (2x).Although both total phytoplankton chlorophyll a and chlorophylla in the <35 µm size fraction were significantly lowerin unsieved mesocosms than in sieved mesocosms, sieving hadno significant effect on bacterial abundance or production.There was no statistical interaction between nutrient and zooplanktontreatments for total phytoplankton biomass or bacterial abundance,although there were marginally significant interactions forphytoplankton biomass <35 µm and bacterial production.Our results do not support the hypothesis that large cladoceransbecome less effective grazers with enrichment; rather, the differencebetween phytoplankton biomass in sieved versus unsieved zooplanktontreatments increased across the gradient of nutrient additions.Furthermore, there was no evidence that bacteria buffered phytoplanktonresponses to enrichment by either sequestering P or affectingthe growth of zooplankton.     

Nutrient recycling and shifts in N:P ratio by different zooplankton structures in a South Andes lake

In South Andes lakes, zooplankton succession is characterizedby a change in the dominance from the calanoid copepod Boeckellagracilipes in winter and spring, to the cladoceran Bosmina longirostrisin midsummer, and the rotifer Polyarthra vulgaris in late summer.We performed three series of field experiments at differenttimes (late spring, summer and late summer) to examine the roleof zooplankton constitution in the released nitrogen:phosphorus(N:P) ratio. We observed that changes in the zooplankton constitutionover the annual cycle may change the nutrient supply ratio.In South Andes lakes, Boeckella gracilipes would decrease theP limitation, lowering the N:P ratio, whereas Bosmina longirostristends to increase the N:P ratio and therefore increase the Plimitation during summer.     

Survival,growth and reproduction of Daphnia galeata feeding on single and mixed Pseudomonas and Rhodomonas diets

1. Bacteria can be an important resource for zooplankton production in aquatic food webs, although the degree to which bacteria sustain zooplankton growth and reproduction is not clear. We performed a growth experiment with Daphnia galeata feeding on different ratios of P‐replete Pseudomonas and Rhodomonas, ranging from a 100% bacterial to a 100% algal diet. 2. A pure bacterial diet did not support survival, growth or reproduction of D. galeata. While a 20% share of Rhodomonas in the food allowed survival of daphniids, the occurrence of offspring on a 50% algal diet indicated that the threshold for successful reproduction was between those two proportions of algal food. Increasing the proportion of the alga further increased growth and reproductive output, indicating that Rhodomonas was a higher‐quality food than Pseudomonas. 3. A subsequent labelling experiment demonstrated that D. galeata incorporated phosphorus from Pseudomonas and Rhodomonas with similar efficiency, whereas carbon was incorporated more efficiently from Pseudomonas than from Rhodomonas. 4. we hypothesise that inadequate levels of essential biochemicals in pure bacterial diets led to decreased Daphnia performance. Concentrations of fatty acids in general, and especially of polyunsaturated fatty acids, were much lower in Pseudomonas than in Rhodomonas. This difference could explain the different growth and reproduction responses, although limitation by other essential biochemicals (e.g. sterols) cannot be ruled out. 5. Hence, where they dominate, bacteria may provide a significant part of the elemental flux to species feeding higher in the food web on the short term. However, the performance of consumers may be constrained by essential biochemicals.     

Grazing and nutrient influences of Daphnia and Eudiaptomus on phytoplankton in laboratory microcosms

In two experiments, top-down and bottom-up influences of theherbivorous crustaceans Daphnia pulicaria and Eudiaptomus grac$$$loideson phytoplankton were compared in laboratory microcosms. Ina long-term experiment (63 days), both grazers were able toestablish populations. The Daphnia population exerted strongergrazing pressure, whereas Eudiaptomus fed more selectively.Daphnia retained relatively more phosphorus (P) and thus causedalgal P limitation; with Eudiaptomus as a grazer, both nitrogen(N) and P remained limiting. In a short-term experiment (1 day),N and P release rates and algal-specific grazing rates by bothconsumers were measured. In this experiment, the increase inconcentrations of soluble mineral nutrients (     

Does excess carbon affect respiration of the rotifer Brachionus calyciflorus Pallas?

1. Herbivorous zooplankton maintain a rather constant elemental composition in their body mass as compared with the variability commonly encountered in their food. Furthermore, their high phosphorus (P) and nitrogen (N) content means that they often face an excess of carbon (C) in their diet. Regulation of this surplus of energy may occur via modulation of assimilation efficiency, or postassimilation by increased respiration (CO₂) and/or excretion dissolved organic carbon, DOC. Whereas several studies have examined the effect of elemental imbalance in the genus Daphnia, few have examined other zooplankton taxa. 2. We investigated whether the rotifer Brachionus calyciflorus uses increased respiration as a means of stoichiometrically regulating excess dietary C. Growth rate and respiration were measured under different food qualities (C : N and C : P ratios). 3. Both C : N and C : P ratios in food had strong effects on growth rate, demonstrating strong nutrient limitation of rotifer growth when nutrient elements were depleted in the diet and indicating the need for stoichiometric regulation of excess ingested C. 4. Respiration measurements, supported by a stoichiometric model, indicated that excess C was not released as CO₂ in B. calyciflorus and that nutrient balance must therefore be maintained by other means such as excretion of DOC or egestion in faecal material.     

Genotypic differences in phosphorus use physiology in producers (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Chlamydomonas reinhardtii</Emphasis>) and consumers (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Daphnia pulex</Emphasis>) interact to alter primary and secondary production

By considering the relative abundance of elements in trophic interactions, ecological stoichiometry makes predictions about key ecological processes such as biomass production and consumer-driven nutrient recycling. Theoretical and empirical work has focused on interspecific variation in elemental composition, and stoichiometric imbalances between resources and consumers in determining productivity, particularly at the base of foodwebs. Recent work has found considerable intraspecific variation in elemental composition. We know little about the ecological relevance of such variation, and whether predictions of stoichiometric theory hold at the intraspecific level. Here, we used two genotypes of a primary producer Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, and two genotypes of a primary consumer Daphnia pulex, which are already known to vary considerably in their phosphorus (P) use physiology, under conditions of P abundance and limitation, to explore whether such intraspecific differences alter primary as well as secondary production. Specifically, we tested whether there are intraspecific differences in the carbon: phosphorus (C:P) stoichiometry of Chlamydomonas genotypes, whether such differences affect growth and abundance of the two Daphnia genotypes, and whether the two Daphnia genotypes had distinct effects on primary production and growth of the two Chlamydomonas genotypes. We found significant differences in C:P stoichiometry between the two Chlamydomonas genotypes in both P supply conditions. Such intraspecific differences altered the growth of Daphnia genotypes, and affected the outcome of genotypic competition. Finally, Daphnia genotype affected primary production, and interacted with P supply to distinctly affect the growth of the two Chlamydomonas genotypes. Together, our results highlight the potential ecological relevance of intraspecific differences in nutrient use physiology and elemental composition, and the utility of ecological stoichiometry in understanding such consequences.     

Interaction of Nutrient Limitation and Protozoan Grazing Determines the Phenotypic Structure of a Bacterial Community

We examined the impact of nutrient conditions (carbon and phosphorus limitation) and grazing by protozoans on the phenotypic community structure of freshwater bacteria in continuous culture systems. Lakewater bacteria were grown on mineral medium, which was supplemented with glucose and amino acids and adjusted by different phosphorus concentrations to achieve either carbon or phosphorus limitation. Each nutrient treatment was inoculated with the same bacterial community and consisted of a nongrazing and a grazing treatment, to which the heterotrophic nanoflagellates Spumella sp. and Ochromonas sp. were added. We found that nutrient conditions alone resulted in differences in the phenotypic structure of the bacterial community: small and motile bacteria dominated under C limitation while large, elongated, and capsulated bacteria were characteristic for P limitation. The genotypic community composition as measured by T-RFLP (terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism) was not severely influenced by the two nutrient treatments. In the presence of flagellate predators, grazing-resistant bacteria developed under both nutrient conditions, but with different survival mechanisms: highly motile bacteria prevailed under C limitation, whereas the P-limited grazing treatment was dominated by filamentous forms. T-RFLP analysis revealed only moderate changes in bacterial community composition due to grazing, which were most pronounced under P limitation. Analysis by video microscopy revealed that high swimming speed is an efficient nonmorphological survival mechanism for bacteria to reduce the capture success of the flagellate predator. The rejection of optimal-sized, nonmotile bacteria under P limitation suggests the importance of other nonmorphological, surface-located cell properties. Our results illustrate that the realized mechanisms of grazing resistance are linked to the actual limitation conditions, and that the combined effects of nutrient limitation and grazing are major determinants of bacterial community structure.     

Field evidence for stoichiometric relationships between zooplankton and N and P availability in a shallow calcareous lake

1. According to stoichiometric theory, zooplankters have a species‐specific elemental composition. Daphniids have a relatively high phosphorus concentration in their tissues and copepods high nitrogen. Daphniids should, therefore, be more sensitive to phosphorus limitation and copepods more sensitive to nitrogen. A 2‐year study of a shallow marl lake in the west of Ireland investigated whether population fluctuations of the two dominant taxa, Daphnia spp. and the calanoid Eudiaptomus gracilis, were associated with the availability of phosphorus and nitrogen. 2. In accordance with stoichiometric predictions, Daphnia and Eudiaptomus reproduction had contrasting relationships with dietary phosphorus and nitrogen availability. Egg production by Daphnia was negatively associated with the ratio of dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) : total phosphorus (TP) and the ratio of light to TP which was used as an indirect index for seston carbon (C) : phosphorus (P). Conversely calanoid egg production had a positive relationship with the DIN : TP ratio and was unrelated to the estimated C : P (light : TP) ratio. 3. Daphnia biomass was not, however, correlated with phosphorus availability, and neither was calanoid biomass correlated with nitrogen. The high ratio of DIN : TP when Daphnia dominated the zooplankton biomass and the low ratio when calanoids dominated, is consistent with Daphnia acting as a sink for phosphorus and calanoids as a sink for nitrogen and suggests consumer‐driven nutrient recycling.     

Contrasting effects of a cladoceran (Daphnia galeata) and a calanoid copepod (Eodiaptomus japonicus) on algal and microbial plankton in a Japanese lake, Lake Biwa

Macrozooplankton may affect algal and microbial plankton directly through grazing or predation and indirectly through nutrient regeneration. They may also affect potential prey positively by removing alternative predators. Here, we examined the effects of a cladoceran (Daphnia) and a calanoid copepod (Eodiaptomus) on algal and microbial plankton in a Japanese lake using in situ experiments in which we manipulated the nutrient supply and biomass of these macrozooplankton. The response of algal and microbial plankton to macrozooplankton was diverse and varied depending on the level of nutrient supply. Eodiaptomus seemed to feed mainly on large algae (>20 µm) and microzooplankton, while direct grazing by Daphnia on algae, bacteria, heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF), and microzooplankton (ciliates, heliozoa, and rotifers) was pronounced. Trophic linkages within these microbial plankton was also suggested; bacteria were grazed by HNF and these in turn were grazed by microzooplankton. When the nutrient supply was high, both HNF and microzooplankton were exposed to higher amounts of algae and lower bacterial abundance. Moreover, nutrient regeneration by daphnids and Eodiaptomus copepods seemed to differentially stimulate the growth of algae and bacteria. The results suggest that the relationship between macrozooplankton and microbial plankton cannot be fully understood without taking into consideration not only the feeding characteristics of the macrozooplankton, but also the food web structure, the subsidized algal resource, and nutrient regeneration from the macrozooplankton.     

Nutrient content of seagrasses and epiphytes in the northern Gulf of Mexico: Evidence of phosphorus and nitrogen limitation

We examined C:N:P ratios of seagrass leaves and epiphytic algae from the eastern shoreline of Grand Bay (Alabama, USA) and the entire shoreline of Big Lagoon (Florida, USA) during the summer of 2001 and March 2003, and used contour plotting of N:P ratios in both locations to examine spatial trends in our data. Results indicated phosphorus limitation for seagrass and epiphytes in each bay. In addition, C:N, C:P, and N:P ratios in both locations showed differences between summer and wintertime values for seagrasses; however, the only epiphytic elemental ratios to differ were C:P and N:P ratios in Grand Bay. Within Grand Bay, phosphorus limitation was stronger in epiphytes than seagrasses, with the largest amount of variation in N:P ratios occurring adjacent to the only developed land on the shoreline. In Big Lagoon, two distinct areas were present in N:P contour plots: the eastern end of the bay that was influenced by water from the Gulf of Mexico and Santa Rosa Sound, and the western end of the bay that was most influenced by Perdido Bay and a developed area along the northern shoreline. Detection of phosphorus limitation within Big Lagoon was not surprising, as both input sources to Big Lagoon are known to be low in phosphorus. However, phosphorus limitation in Grand Bay was unexpected, as both “feeder systems” (Mobile Bay and the Mississippi Sound) have high ambient phosphorus levels. As a result, C:N:P ratios from seagrasses and epiphytes may not accurately reflect ambient nutrient levels in Grand Bay due to decreased availability of some forms of phosphorus or increased competition for the uptake of phosphorus. Overall, our C:N:P analysis suggested that not only was P limitation greater than N limitation in Grand Bay and Big Lagoon, but patterns of nutrient limitation varied both temporally and geographically for inter- and intra-bay comparisons.     

Demography of a natural population of Daphnia retrocurva in a lake with low food quality

The hypothesis was tested that Daphnia exhibit low populationrecruitment in a lake with phosphorus (P)-deficient food, whereDaphnia populations failed to increase in response to greatlylowered minnow density. Egg ratio analysis was performed onDaphnia retrocurva from L110 of the Experimental Lakes Area,Ontario, in 1994. L110 has high food abundance (seston carbon(C) 100 µM C), but the seston is P deficient (C:P atomic- 600). Chrysophytes dominated the algal community. The fishcommunity in this lake was manipulated in 1993 and 1994 by theaddition of northern pike, Esox lucius. Zooplanktivorous minnowswere greatly reduced after the piscivore addition, but the expectedincrease in abundance of the Daphnia to this altered predationregime was not observed, If food quality constrains the responseof the Daphnia to changed predation, there should be low recruitment in the relatively sparse Daphnia population in this lake.Birth rates estimated by standard egg ratio analysis were <0.1day^–1 for most of the sample period. In comparison toannual averages from the literature, recruitment in L110 wasmoderately, but not dramatically, low. Daphnia exhibited pronounced‘normal’ vertical migration (up at night, down duringthe day) all year, and a strongly declining size at first reproductionthrough the season. Population density and birth rates seemedto show much less short-term change than previously observedin other lakes. Although the demo graphic predictions for foodquality constraints seemed clear, in situ demography unfortunatelyneither supported nor strongly rejected the overall hypothesisof food quality limitation in this lake with very high C:P ratios.Possibly, direct demographic effects of low food quality willbe difficult to observe in nature.     

Seasonal changes of C:P ratios of seston, bacteria, phytoplankton and zooplankton in a deep, mesotrophic lake

• 1 The C:P ratios of seston, bacteria, phytoplankton and zooplankton were measured twice a week in situ in mesotrophic, large and deep Lake Constance from April to December 1995. Except for zooplankton, a strong seasonality was exhibited with low C:P ratios during P‐enriched early spring conditions and high values during P‐depleted summer conditions.
• 2 Molar C:P ratios of seston varied between 180:1 and 460:1 demonstrating moderate phosphorus limitation in spring and during the clear‐water phase, and strong limitation for the rest of the season. The sestonic C:P ratio increased significantly during two decades of re‐oligotrophication of Lake Constance, reflecting an enhanced phosphorus limitation of the plankton community in summer. Molar C:P ratios of bacteria and phytoplankton varied seasonally between 50:1 and 130:1 and 180:1 and 500:1, respectively, and indicate carbon or light limitation in winter and phosphorus limitation in summer. Zooplankton had a molar C:P ratio of about 124:115 which was nearly constant throughout the seasons.
• 3 These differences in the C:P ratios of planktonic organisms have direct implications for phosphorus recycling within the food web as C:P ratios of excreta should be highly variable.

     

Estimation of phosphorus metabolic rates of Daphnia galeata using a three-compartment model

A compartment model to estimate the different phosphorus metabolicrates in Daphnia galeata is presented. The model has three compartments:gut, metabolic pool and structural pool. Existing two-compartmentmodels used for carbon and phosphorus turnover in Daphnia donot allow estimation of ingestion and egestion rates. We extendedexisting two-compartment models with one more compartment, thegut, which allowed us to estimate both the ingestion and theegestion rates. Parameters of the model are estimated from asingle experiment of feeding unlabelled Daphnia with ³²P-labelledScenedesmus obliquus. Separate experiments with juvenile andadult daphnids were carried out in order to compare their metabolisms.This model permits a reliable estimation of the different metabolicrates of Daphrna in a single experiment and discriminates clearlybetween animals of different sizes.     

Seasonal pattern in nutrient limitation and grazing control of the phytoplankton community in a non-stratified lake

1. The relative importance of zooplankton grazing and nutrient limitation in regulating the phytoplankton community in the non-stratified Lake Kvie, Denmark, were measured nine times during the growing season.
2. Natural phytoplankton assemblage bioassays showed increasing importance of nutrient limitation during summer. Growth rates at ambient nutrient concentrations were continually below 0.12 per day, while co-enrichment with nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) to above concentration-saturated conditions enhanced growth rates from May to the end of July.
3. Stoichiometric ratios of important elements in seston (C : N, C : P, N : P), in lake water (TN : TP), in external loading (TN : TP) and in internal loading (DIN : DIP) were measured to determine whether N or P could be the limiting nutrient. TN : TP molar ratio of both lake water, benthic fluxes and external loading suggested P limitation throughout the growing season. However, seston molar ratios suggested moderate P-deficiency only during mid-summer.
4. Abundance and community structure of the zooplankton varied considerably through the season and proved to be important in determining the responses of algal assemblages to grazing. High abundance of cladocerans and rotifers resulted in significant grazing impact, while cyclopoid copepods had no significant effect on the phytoplankton biomass.
5. Regeneration of ammonium and phosphate by zooplankton were periodically important for phytoplankton growth. A comparison of nutrient regeneration by zooplankton with nutrient inputs from sediment and external sources indicated that zooplankton may contribute significantly in supplying N and P for the growth of phytoplankton.     

Relative importance of competition with Daphnia (Cladocera) and nutrient limitation on Anuraeopsis (Rotifera) population dynamics in a laboratory study

• 1 In the laboratory, the growth and reproduction of Anuraeopsis fissa were measured when fed on Scenedesmus species grown in nutrient‐sufficient, nitrogen‐limited and phosphorus‐limited media and in the presence or absence of one adult Daphnia longispina per vial.
• 2 Poor food quality may reduce the effect of competition on rotifers. Competition from Daphnia was stronger with nutrient sufficient algae than with nutrient limited algae. P‐limitation significantly reduced Anuraeopsis population growth rate and fecundity. The effect of nutrient limitation on Anuraeopsis was stronger than that of competition with Daphnia. The Anuraeopsis population declined with P‐limited food in both the presence and absence of Daphnia.
• 3 Exploitative competition by Daphnia on Anuraeopsis was stronger in the nutrient‐sufficient treatment than in the N‐limited one. Density, fecundity and population growth rate of Anuraeopsis were negatively affected by Daphnia in the nutrient‐sufficient treatment, while only fecundity was reduced by Daphnia in the N‐limited treatment. Consequently, in the N‐limited treatment, mortality should be lower in the presence of Daphnia. This result could suggest that Anuraeopsis lives longer when short of nitrogen.
• 4 Nutrient limitation may affect to the competitive interactions between zooplankton species. P‐limitation decreased the quality of algae as food for Anuraeopsis while N‐limitation decreased the susceptibility of this rotifer species to exploitative competition by Daphnia.

     

Does the Redfield ratio infer nutrient limitation in the macroalga Spirogyra fluviatilis?

1. The cellular nutrient contents of microalgae, when growing at or approaching maximum rates, approximate the Redfield C : N : P (molar) ratio of 106 : 16 : 1. Deviations from this optimal ratio can be used to infer nutrient limitation of microalgal growth. However, this ratio may not be applicable to macroalgae, which are distinguished from microalgae by forming a thallus that is a discrete structure visible to the naked eye. The utility of the Redfield ratio to infer nutrient limitation of the growth of macroalgae was tested for Spirogyra fluviatilis in a field experiment conducted in tropical Australia. 2. The optimal cellular C : N : P ratio for S. fluvialitis was estimated by means of in situ nutrient addition. This was compared with S. fluvialitis cellular ratios determined from eight sites with a wide range of soluble N concentrations (<1–90 μg L^?1), a smaller range of soluble P concentrations (5–12 μg L^?1), and soluble molar N : P ratios of 0.11– 27. 3. Spirogyra fluviatilis had an optimal molar C : N : P ratio of 1800 : 87 : 1 which differs substantially from the Redfield ratio, and suggests that the latter ratio is not applicable to this macroalga. Concentrations of N and P in the river deviated from the optimal N : P ratio of 87 : 1, inferring nutrient limitation of growth. 4. C : P and C : N ratios of S. fluviatilis varied in accordance with general stoichiometric relationships for autotrophs under nutrient limitation of growth. Ratios of C : P and C : N increased, respectively, with increased severity of P‐ and N‐limitation. Additionally, C : P ratios increased with increased N : P ratios, whilst the C : N ratio increased with decreased N : P ratios. The C : N molar ratio however was an insensitive indicator of nutrient depletion compared with the C : P ratio. Under N‐limitation of growth, luxury amounts of P were stored by S. fluviatilis. 5. In aquatic environments where macroalgae are sufficiently abundant to be sampled, their cellular carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus stoichiometry can be used to infer nutrient limitation of growth when their optimal C : N : P ratio is known.