Development of a high-throughput screening assay for the discovery of small-molecule SecA inhibitors

A major pathway for bacterial preprotein translocation is provided by the Sec-dependent preprotein translocation pathway. Proteins destined for Sec-dependent translocation are synthesized as preproteins with an N-terminal signal peptide, which targets them to the SecYEG translocase channel. The driving force for the translocation reaction is provided by the peripheral membrane ATPase SecA, which couples the hydrolysis of ATP to the stepwise transport of unfolded preproteins across the bacterial membrane. Since SecA is essential, highly conserved among bacterial species, and has no close human homologues, it represents a promising target for antibacterial chemotherapy. However, high-throughput screening (HTS) campaigns to identify SecA inhibitors are hampered by the low intrinsic ATPase activity of SecA and the requirement of hydrophobic membranes for measuring the membrane or translocation ATPase activity of SecA. To address this issue, we have developed a colorimetric high-throughput screening assay in a 384-well format, employing an Escherichia coli (E. coli) SecA mutant with elevated intrinsic ATPase activity. The assay was applied for screening of a chemical library consisting of ∼27,000 compounds and proved to be highly reliable (average Z′ factor of 0.89). In conclusion, a robust HTS assay has been established that will facilitate the search for novel SecA inhibitors.     

The SecDFyajC domain of preprotein translocase controls preprotein movement by regulating SecA membrane cycling.

Escherichia coli preprotein translocase comprises a membrane-embedded hexameric complex of SecY, SecE, SecG, SecD, SecF and YajC (SecYEGDFyajC) and the peripheral ATPase SecA. The energy of ATP binding and hydrolysis promotes cycles of membrane insertion and deinsertion of SecA and catalyzes the movement of the preprotein across the membrane. The proton motive force (PMF), though not essential, greatly accelerates late stages of translocation. We now report that the SecDFyajC domain of translocase slows the movement of preprotein in transit against both reverse and forward translocation and exerts this control through stabilization of the inserted form of SecA. This mechanism allows the accumulation of specific translocation intermediates which can then complete translocation under the driving force of the PMF. These findings establish a functional relationship between SecA membrane insertion and preprotein translocation and show that SecDFyajC controls SecA membrane cycling to regulate the movement of the translocating preprotein.     

Cross-talk between catalytic and regulatory elements in a DEAD motor domain is essential for SecA function

SecA, the motor subunit of bacterial polypeptide translocase, is an RNA helicase. SecA comprises a dimerization C-terminal domain fused to an ATPase N-terminal domain containing conserved DEAD helicase motifs. We show that the N-terminal domain is organized like the motor core of DEAD proteins, encompassing two subdomains, NBD1 and IRA2. NBD1, a rigid nucleotide-binding domain, contains the minimal ATPase catalytic machinery. IRA2 binds to NBD1 and acts as an intramolecular regulator of ATP hydrolysis by controlling ADP release and optimal ATP catalysis at NBD1. IRA2 is flexible and can undergo changes in its alpha-helical content. The C-terminal domain associates with NBD1 and IRA2 and restricts IRA2 activator function. Thus, cytoplasmic SecA is maintained in the thermally stabilized ADP-bound state and unnecessary ATP hydrolysis cycles are prevented. Two DEAD family motifs in IRA2 are essential for IRA2-NBD1 binding, optimal nucleotide turnover and polypeptide translocation. We propose that translocation ligands alleviate C-terminal domain suppression, allowing IRA2 to stimulate nucleotide turnover at NBD1. DEAD motors may employ similar mechanisms to translocate different enzymes along chemically unrelated biopolymers.     

The ATPase domain of SecA can form a tetramer in solution.

Preprotein translocase is a general and essential system for bacterial protein export, the minimal components of which are SecA and SecYEG. SecA is a peripheral ATPase that associates with nucleotide, preprotein, and the membrane integral SecYEG to form a translocation-competent complex. SecA can be separated into two domains: an N-terminal 68 kDa ATPase domain (N68) that binds preprotein and catalyzes ATP hydrolysis, and a 34 kDa C-terminal domain that regulates the ATPase activity of N68 and mediates dimerization. We have carried out gel filtration chromatography, analytical ultracentrifugation, and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) to demonstrate that isolated N68 self-associates to form a tetramer in solution, indicating that removal of the C-terminal domain facilitates the formation of a higher-order SecA structure. The associative process is best modelled as a monomer-tetramer equilibrium, with a K(D) value of 63 microM(3) (where K(D)=[monomer](4)/[tetramer]) so that at moderate concentrations (10 microM and above), the tetramer is the major species in solution. Hydrodynamic properties of the N68 monomer indicate that it is almost globular in shape, but the N68 tetramer has a more ellipsoidal structure. Analysis of SAXS data indicates that the N68 tetramer is a flattened, bi-lobed structure with dimensions of approximately 13.5 nm x 9.0 nm x 6.5 nm, that appears to contain a central pore.     

The catalytic cycle of the escherichia coli SecA ATPase comprises two distinct preprotein translocation events.

SecA is the ATP-dependent force generator in the Escherichia coli precursor protein translocation cascade, and is bound at the membrane surface to the integral membrane domain of the preprotein translocase. Preproteins are thought to be translocated in a stepwise manner by nucleotide-dependent cycles of SecA membrane insertion and de-insertion, or as large polypeptide segments by the protonmotive force (Deltap) in the absence of SecA. To determine the step size of a complete ATP- and SecA-dependent catalytic cycle, translocation intermediates of the preprotein proOmpA were generated at limiting SecA translocation ATPase activity. Distinct intermediates were formed, spaced by intervals of approximately 5 kDa. Inhibition of the SecA ATPase by azide trapped SecA in a membrane-inserted state and shifted the step size to 2-2.5 kDa. The latter corresponds to the translocation elicited by binding of non-hydrolysable ATP analogues to SecA, or by the re-binding of partially translocated polypeptide chains by SecA. Therefore, a complete catalytic cycle of the preprotein translocase permits the stepwise translocation of 5 kDa polypeptide segments by two consecutive events, i.e. approximately 2.5 kDa upon binding of the polypeptide by SecA, and another 2.5 kDa upon binding of ATP to SecA.     

Disorder-order folding transitions underlie catalysis in the helicase motor of SecA

SecA is a helicase-like motor that couples ATP hydrolysis with the translocation of extracytoplasmic protein substrates. As in most helicases, this process is thought to occur through nucleotide-regulated rigid-body movement of the motor domains. NMR, thermodynamic and biochemical data show that SecA uses a novel mechanism wherein conserved regions lining the nucleotide cleft undergo cycles of disorder-order transitions while switching among functional catalytic states. The transitions are regulated by interdomain interactions mediated by crucial 'arginine finger' residues located on helicase motifs. Furthermore, we show that the nucleotide cleft allosterically communicates with the preprotein substrate-binding domain and the regulatory, membrane-inserting C domain, thereby allowing for the coupling of the ATPase cycle to the translocation activity. The intrinsic plasticity and functional disorder-order folding transitions coupled to ligand binding seem to provide a precise control of the catalytic activation process and simple regulation of allosteric mechanisms.     

The role of the mature domain of proOmpA in the translocation ATPase reaction.

The export of proOmpA, the precursor of outer membrane protein A from Escherichia coli, requires preprotein translocase, which is comprised of SecA, SecY/E, and acidic phospholipids. Previous studies of proOmpA translocation intermediates (Schiebel, E., Driessen, A. J. M., Hartl, F.-U., and Wickner, W. (1991) Cell 64, 927-939) suggested that the "slippage" of the translocating polypeptide chain and the high level of ATP hydrolysis, characteristic of the "translocation ATPase," were part of a futile cycle. To examine the role of the mature domain of proOmpA in its translocation-dependent ATP hydrolysis, we used chemical cleavage to generate NH2-terminal fragments of this preprotein. Each fragment contained the 21-residue leader region and either 53 or 228 residues of the mature domain (preproteins P74 and P249, respectively). As observed with full-length proOmpA, the translocation of each fragment requires ATP and both the SecA and SecY/E domains of translocase and is stimulated by the transmembrane proton electrochemical gradient. The apparent maximal velocities of P74 and proOmpA translocation are similar. While the translocation of P74 and of proOmpA show the same apparent Km for ATP, far less ATP is hydrolyzed during the translocation of P74. Thus, the mature carboxyl-terminal domain of proOmpA has a major role in supporting the translocation ATPase.     

SecA protein: autoregulated ATPase catalysing preprotein insertion and translocation across the Escherichia coli inner membrane

Recent insight into the biochemical mechanism of protein translocation in Escherichia coli indicates that SecA ATPase is required both for the initial binding of preproteins to the inner membrane as well as subsequent translocation across this structure. SecA appears to promote these events by direct recognition of the preprotein or preprotein-SecB complex, binding to inner-membrane anionic phospholipids, insertion into the membrane biiayer and association with the preprotein translocator, SecY/SecE. ATP binding appears to control the affinity of SecA for the various components of the system and ATP hydrolysis promotes cycling between its different biochemical states. As a component likely to catalyse a rate-determining step in protein secretion, SecA synthesis is co-ordinated with the activity of the protein export pathway. This form of negative reguiation appears to rely on SecA protein binding to its mRNA and repressing translation if conditions of rapid protein secretion prevail within the cell. A precise biochemical scheme for SecA-dependent catalysis of protein export and the details of secA regulation appear to be close at hand. The evolutionary conservation of SecA protein among eubacteria as well as the general requirement for translocation ATPases in other protein secretion systems argues for a mechanistic commonality of all prokaryotic protein export pathways.     

Functionally significant mobile regions of Escherichia coli SecA ATPase identified by NMR

SecA, a 204-kDa homodimeric protein, is a major component of the cellular machinery that mediates the translocation of proteins across the Escherichia coli plasma membrane. SecA promotes translocation by nucleotide-modulated insertion and deinsertion into the cytoplasmic membrane once bound to both the signal sequence and portions of the mature domain of the preprotein. SecA is proposed to undergo major conformational changes during translocation. These conformational changes are accompanied by major rearrangements of SecA structural domains. To understand the interdomain rearrangements, we have examined SecA by NMR and identified regions that display narrow resonances indicating high mobility. The mobile regions of SecA have been assigned to a sequence from the second of two domains with nucleotide-binding folds (NBF-II; residues 564-579) and to the extreme C-terminal segment of SecA (residues 864-901), both of which are essential for preprotein translocation activity. Interactions with ligands suggest that the mobile regions are involved in functionally critical regulatory steps in SecA.     

SecY and SecA interact to allow SecA insertion and protein translocation across the Escherichia coli plasma membrane.

SecA, the preprotein-driving ATPase in Escherichia coli, was shown previously to insert deeply into the plasma membrane in the presence of ATP and a preprotein; this movement of SecA was proposed to be mechanistically coupled with preprotein translocation. We now address the role played by SecY, the central subunit of the membrane-embedded heterotrimeric complex, in the SecA insertion reaction. We identified a secY mutation (secY205), affecting the most carboxyterminal cytoplasmic domain, that did not allow ATP and preprotein-dependent productive SecA insertion, while allowing idling insertion without the preprotein. Thus, the secY205 mutation might affect the SecYEG 'channel' structure in accepting the preprotein-SecA complex or its opening by the complex. We isolated secA mutations that allele-specifically suppressed the secY205 translocation defect in vivo. One mutant protein, SecA36, with an amino acid alteration near the high-affinity ATP-binding site, was purified and suppressed the in vitro translocation defect of the inverted membrane vesicles carrying the SecY205 protein. The SecA36 protein could also insert into the mutant membrane vesicles in vitro. These results provide genetic evidence that SecA and SecY specifically interact, and show that SecY plays an essential role in insertion of SecA in response to a preprotein and ATP and suggest that SecA drives protein translocation by inserting into the membrane in vivo.     

Escherichia coli SecA truncated at its termini is functional and dimeric

Terminal residues in SecA, the dimeric ATPase motor of bacterial preprotein translocase, were proposed to be required for function and dimerization. To test this, we generated truncation mutants of the 901aa long SecA of Escherichia coli. We now show that deletions of carboxy-terminal domain (CTD), the extreme CTD of 70 residues, or of the N-terminal nonapeptide or of both, do not compromise protein translocation or viability. Deletion of additional C-terminal residues upstream of CTD compromised function. Functional truncation mutants like SecA9-861 are dimeric, conformationally similar to SecA, fully competent for nucleotide and SecYEG binding and for ATP catalysis. Our data demonstrate that extreme terminal SecA residues are not essential for SecA catalysis and dimerization.     

A single amino acid substitution in SecY stabilizes the interaction with SecA.

The SecYEG complex constitutes a protein conducting channel across the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane. It binds the peripheral ATPase SecA to form the translocase. When isoleucine 278 in transmembrane segment 7 of the SecY subunit was replaced by a unique cysteine, SecYEG supported an increased preprotein translocation and SecA translocation ATPase activity, and allowed translocation of a preprotein with a defective signal sequence. SecY(I278C)EG binds SecA with a higher affinity than normal SecYEG, in particular in the presence of ATP. The increased translocation activity of SecY(I278C)EG was confirmed in a purified system consisting of SecYEG proteoliposomes, while immunoprecipitation in detergent solution reveal that translocase-preprotein complexes are more stable with SecY(I278C) than with normal SecY. These data imply an important role for SecY transmembrane segment 7 in SecA binding. As improved SecA binding to SecY was also observed with the prlA4 suppressor mutation, it may be a general mechanism underlying signal sequence suppression.     

Sec-dependent preprotein translocation in bacteria

Translocation of precursor proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane in bacteria is mediated by a multi-subunit protein complex termed translocase, which consists of the integral membrane heterotrimer SecYEG and the peripheral homodimeric ATPase SecA. Preproteins are bound by the cytosolic molecular chaperone SecB and targeted in a complex with SecA to the translocation site at the cytoplasmic membrane. This interaction with SecYEG allows the SecA/preprotein complex to insert into the membrane by binding of ATP to the high affinity nucleotide binding site of SecA. At that stage, presumably recognition and proofreading of the signal sequence occurs. Hydrolysis of ATP causes the release of the preprotein in the translocation channel and drives the withdrawal of SecA from the membrane-integrated state. Hydrolysis of ATP at the low-affinity nucleotide binding site of SecA converts the protein into a compact conformational state and releases it from the membrane. In the absence of the proton motive force, SecA is able to complete the translocation stepwise by multiple nucleotide modulated cycles. Received: 4 August 1995 / Accepted: 9 October 1995     

Cysteine-directed cross-linking demonstrates that helix 3 of SecE is close to helix 2 of SecY and helix 3 of a neighboring SecE.

Preprotein translocation in Escherichia coli is mediated by translocase, a multimeric membrane protein complex with SecA as the peripheral ATPase and SecYEG as the translocation pore. Unique cysteines were introduced into transmembrane segment (TMS) 2 of SecY and TMS 3 of SecE to probe possible sites of interaction between the integral membrane subunits. The SecY and SecE single-Cys mutants were cloned individually and in pairs into a secYEG expression vector and functionally overexpressed. Oxidation of the single-Cys pairs revealed periodic contacts between SecY and SecE that are confined to a specific alpha-helical face of TMS 2 and 3, respectively. A Cys at the opposite alpha-helical face of TMS 3 of SecE was found to interact with a neighboring SecE molecule. Formation of this SecE dimer did not affect the high-affinity binding of SecA to SecYEG and ATP hydrolysis, but blocked preprotein translocation and thus uncouples the SecA ATPase activity from translocation. Conditions that prevent membrane deinsertion of SecA markedly stimulated the interhelical contact between the SecE molecules. The latter demonstrates a SecA-mediated modulation of the protein translocation channel that is sensed by SecE.     

SecA supports a constant rate of preprotein translocation

In Escherichia coli, secretory proteins (preproteins) are translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane by the Sec system composed of a protein-conducting channel, SecYEG, and an ATP-dependent motor protein, SecA. After binding of the preprotein to SecYEG-bound SecA, cycles of ATP binding and hydrolysis by SecA are thought to drive the stepwise translocation of the preprotein across the membrane. To address how the length of a preprotein substrate affects the SecA-driven translocation process, we constructed derivatives of the precursor of the outer membrane protein A (proOmpA) with 2, 4, 6, and 8 in-tandem repeats of the periplasmic domain. With increasing polypeptide length, an increasing delay in the time before full-length translocation was observed, but the translocation rate expressed as amino acid translocation per minute remained constant. These data indicate that in the ATP-dependent reaction, SecA drives a constant rate of preprotein translocation consistent with a stepping mechanism of translocation.     

Identification of the preprotein binding domain of SecA

SecA, the preprotein translocase ATPase, has a helicase DEAD motor. To catalyze protein translocation, SecA possesses two additional flexible domains absent from other helicases. Here we demonstrate that one of these "specificity domains" is a preprotein binding domain (PBD). PBD is essential for viability and protein translocation. PBD mutations do not abrogate the basal enzymatic properties of SecA (nucleotide binding and hydrolysis), nor do they prevent SecA binding to the SecYEG protein conducting channel. However, SecA PBD mutants fail to load preproteins onto SecYEG, and their translocation ATPase activity does not become stimulated by preproteins. Bulb and Stem, the two sterically proximal PBD substructures, are physically separable and have distinct roles. Stem binds signal peptides, whereas the Bulb binds mature preprotein regions as short as 25 amino acids. Binding of signal or mature region peptides or full-length preproteins causes distinct conformational changes to PBD and to the DEAD motor. We propose that (a) PBD is a preprotein receptor and a physical bridge connecting bound preproteins to the DEAD motor, and (b) preproteins control the ATPase cycle via PBD.     

A molecular switch in SecA protein couples ATP hydrolysis to protein translocation

SecA, the dimeric ATPase subunit of bacterial protein translocase, catalyses translocation during ATP-driven membrane cycling at SecYEG. We now show that the SecA protomer comprises two structural modules: the ATPase N-domain, containing the nucleotide binding sites NBD1 and NBD2, and the regulatory C-domain. The C-domain binds to the N-domain in each protomer and to the C-domain of another protomer to form SecA dimers. NBD1 is sufficient for single rounds of SecA ATP hydrolysis. Multiple ATP turnovers at NBD1 require both the NBD2 site acting in cis and a conserved C-domain sequence operating in trans. This intramolecular regulator of ATP hydrolysis (IRA) mediates N-/C-domain binding and acts as a molecular switch: it suppresses ATP hydrolysis in cytoplasmic SecA while it releases hydrolysis in SecY-bound SecA during translocation. We propose that the IRA switch couples ATP binding and hydrolysis to SecA membrane insertion/deinsertion and substrate translocation by controlling nucleotide-regulated relative motions between the N-domain and the C-domain. The IRA switch is a novel essential component of the protein translocation catalytic pathway.     

SecA protein hydrolyzes ATP and is an essential component of the protein translocation ATPase of Escherichia coli.

Bacterial protein export requires two forms of energy input, ATP and the membrane electrochemical potential. Using an in vitro reaction reconstituted with purified soluble and peripheral membrane components, we can now directly measure the translocation-coupled hydrolysis of ATP. This translocation ATPase requires inner membrane vesicles, SecA protein and translocation-competent proOmpA. The stimulatory activity of membrane vesicles can be blocked by either antibody to the SecY protein or by preparing the membranes from a secY-thermosensitive strain which had been incubated at the non-permissive temperature in vivo. The SecA protein itself has more than one ATP binding site. 8-azido-ATP inactivates SecA for proOmpA translocation and for translocation ATPase, yet does not inhibit a low level of ATP hydrolysis inherent in the isolated SecA protein. These data show that the SecA protein has a central role in coupling the hydrolysis of ATP to the transfer of pre-secretory proteins across the membrane.     

Preprotein transfer to the Escherichia coli translocase requires the co-operative binding of SecB and the signal sequence to SecA

In Escherichia coli , precursor proteins are targeted to the membrane-bound translocase by the cytosolic chaperone SecB. SecB binds to the extreme carboxy-terminus of the SecA ATPase translocase subunit, and this interaction is promoted by preproteins. The mutant SecB proteins, L75Q and E77K, which interfere with preprotein translocation in vivo , are unable to stimulate in vitro translocation. Both mutants bind proOmpA but fail to support the SecA-dependent membrane binding of proOmpA because of a marked reduction in their binding affinities for SecA. The stimulatory effect of preproteins on the interaction between SecB and SecA exclusively involves the signal sequence domain of the preprotein, as it can be mimicked by a synthetic signal peptide and is not observed with a mutant preprotein (Δ8proOmpA) bearing a non-functional signal sequence. Δ8proOmpA is not translocated across wild-type membranes, but the translocation defect is suppressed in inner membrane vesicles derived from a prlA4 strain. SecB reduces the translocation of Δ8proOmpA into these vesicles and almost completely prevents translocation when, in addition, the SecB binding site on SecA is removed. These data demonstrate that efficient targeting of preproteins by SecB requires both a functional signal sequence and a SecB binding domain on SecA. It is concluded that the SecB–SecA interaction is needed to dissociate the mature preprotein domain from SecB and that binding of the signal sequence domain to SecA is required to ensure efficient transfer of the preprotein to the translocase.     

Delta mu H+ and ATP function at different steps of the catalytic cycle of preprotein translocase.

Preprotein translocation in E. coli requires ATP, the membrane electrochemical potential delta mu H+, and translocase, an enzyme with an ATPase domain (SecA) and the membrane-embedded SecY/E. Studies of translocase and proOmpA binds to the SecA domain. Second, SecA binds ATP. Third, ATP-binding energy permits translocation of approximately 20 residues of proOmpA. Fourth, ATP hydrolysis releases proOmpA. ProOmpA may then rebind to SecA and reenter this cycle, allowing progress through a series of transmembrane intermediates. In the absence of delta mu H+ or association with SecA, proOmpA passes backward through the membrane, but moves forward when either ATP and SecA or a membrane electrochemical potential is supplied. However, in the presence of delta mu H+ (fifth step), proOmpA rapidly completes translocation. delta mu H(+)-driven translocation is blocked by SecA plus nonhydrolyzable ATP analogs, indicating that delta mu H+ drives translocation when ATP and proOmpA are not bound to SecA.