RNA structure and packaging signals in the 5' leader region of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genome

The leader region of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genome has a highly folded structure, comprising at least two RNA stem-loops [the transactivation response (TAR) and poly(A) hairpins] near its 5' end and four others (SL1 to SL4) downstream. Each of these stem-loops contributes to the function of the HIV-1 packaging signal, which efficiently targets genomic RNA into nascent virions. The central 140-base region of the leader, which includes the U5 and primer binding site (PBS) sequences, is also believed to adopt a complex structure, but the nature of this structure and its possible role in RNA packaging have not been extensively explored. Here we report a mutational analysis identifying at least three separate loci within the U5-PBS region which, when mutated, impair both HIV-1 packaging specificity and infectivity in a single-round proviral assay. In common with those of all previously described packaging signals in the leader, the function of one of these loci appeared to depend on secondary structure rather than on sequence alone. By contrast, the activity of the other two loci did not correlate with any predicted conformations. Moreover, unlike SL1 to SL4, the TAR, poly(A), and U5-PBS hairpins were not bound with high affinity by the nucleocapsid portion of the HIV-1 Gag protein in vitro, implying that they contribute to packaging through a mechanism distinct from that of SL1 to SL4. Our findings confirm the existence and importance of secondary structure around the PBS and demonstrate that functional packaging signals are distributed across the entire HIV-1 leader.     

A base-paired structure in the avian sarcoma virus 5' leader is required for efficient encapsidation of RNA.

Selective encapsidation of avian sarcoma-leukosis virus genomic RNA within virions requires recognition of a cis-acting signal (termed psi) located in the 5' leader of the RNA between the primer binding site and the splice donor site. Computer analyses indicate the potential for numerous secondary structure interactions within this region, including alternative conformations with similar free energy levels. We have constructed mutations designed to disrupt and restore potential secondary structure interactions within psi to investigate the role of these structures in RNA packaging. To test for the ability of psi mutants to package a heterologous reporter gene into virions, chimeric constructs bearing avian sarcoma virus 5' sequences fused to lacZ were transiently cotransfected with a nonpackageable helper construct into chicken embryo fibroblasts. lacZ virions produced from cotransfected cells were used to infect new cultures of chicken embryo fibroblasts, and then an in situ assay for individual cells expressing lacZ was done. Results obtained with this assay were confirmed in direct analyses of isolated virion RNA by RNase protection assays. Two mutations, predicted to disrupt a potential stem structure forming between elements located at nucleotides 160 to 167 and 227 to 234, severely inhibited packaging when either element was mutated. A construct in which these mutations were combined to restore potential base pairing between the two elements displayed a partially restored packaging phenotype. These results strongly suggest that the structure, referred to as the O3 stem, is required for efficient encapsidation of avian sarcoma virus RNA. Site-directed mutagenesis of additional sequence elements located in the O3 loop reduced packaging as measured by the indirect assay, suggesting that these sequences may also be components of the encapsidation signal. The possible implications of the O3 stem structure with regard to translation of avian sarcoma-leukosis virus short upstream open reading frames are discussed.     

SHAPE analysis of the FIV Leader RNA reveals a structural switch potentially controlling viral packaging and genome dimerization

Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) infects many species of cat, and is related to HIV, causing a similar pathology. High-throughput selective 2' hydroxyl acylation analysed by primer extension (SHAPE), a technique that allows structural interrogation at each nucleotide, was used to map the secondary structure of the FIV packaging signal RNA. Previous studies of this RNA showed four conserved stem-loops, extensive long-range interactions (LRIs) and a small, palindromic stem-loop (SL5) within the gag open reading frame (ORF) that may act as a dimerization initiation site (DIS), enabling the virus to package two copies of its genome. Our analyses of wild-type (wt) and mutant RNAs suggest that although the four conserved stem-loops are static structures, the 5' and 3' regions previously shown to form LRI also adopt an alternative, yet similarly conserved conformation, in which the putative DIS is occluded, and which may thus favour translational and splicing functions over encapsidation. SHAPE and in vitro dimerization assays were used to examine SL5 mutants. Dimerization contacts appear to be made between palindromic loop sequences in SL5. As this stem-loop is located within the gag ORF, recognition of a dimeric RNA provides a possible mechanism for the specific packaging of genomic over spliced viral RNAs.     

The simian immunodeficiency virus 5' untranslated leader sequence plays a role in intracellular viral protein accumulation and in RNA packaging

We investigated the role of 5' untranslated leader sequences of simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV(mac239)) in RNA encapsidation and protein expression. A series of progressively longer deletion mutants was constructed with a common endpoint six nucleotides upstream of the gag initiation codon and another endpoint at the 3' end of the primer binding site (PBS). We found that efficient intracellular Gag-Pol protein accumulation required the region between the PBS and splice donor (SD) site. Marked reduction of genomic RNA packaging was observed with all the deletion mutants that involved sequences at both the 5' and at the 3' ends of the major SD site, and increased nonspecific RNA incorporation could be detected in these mutants. RNA encapsidation was affected only modestly by a deletion of 54 nucleotides at the 3' end of the SD site when the mutant construct pDelta54 was transfected alone. In contrast, the amount of pDelta54 genomic RNA incorporated into particles was reduced more than 10-fold when this mutant was cotransfected with a construct specifying an RNA molecule with a wild-type packaging signal. Therefore, we conclude that the 175 nucleotides located 5' of the gag initiation codon are critical for efficient and selective incorporation of genomic RNA into virions. This location of the SIV Psi element provides the means for efficient discrimination between viral genomic and spliced RNAs.     

Identification of the in vitro HIV-2/SIV RNA dimerization site reveals striking differences with HIV-1

Although their genomes cannot be aligned at the nucleotide level, the HIV-1/SIVcpz and the HIV-2/SIVsm viruses are closely related lentiviruses that contain homologous functional and structural RNA elements in their 5'-untranslated regions. In both groups, the domains containing the trans-activating region, the 5'-copy of the polyadenylation signal, and the primer binding site (PBS) are followed by a short stem-loop (SL1) containing a six-nucleotide self-complementary sequence in the loop, flanked by unpaired purines. In HIV-1, SL1 is involved in the dimerization of the viral RNA, in vitro and in vivo. Here, we tested whether SL1 has the same function in HIV-2 and SIVsm RNA. Surprisingly, we found that SL1 is neither required nor involved in the dimerization of HIV-2 and SIV RNA. We identified the NarI sequence located in the PBS as the main site of HIV-2 RNA dimerization. cis and trans complementation of point mutations indicated that this self-complementary sequence forms symmetrical intermolecular interactions in the RNA dimer and suggested that HIV-2 and SIV RNA dimerization proceeds through a kissing loop mechanism, as previously shown for HIV-1. Furthermore, annealing of tRNA(3)(Lys) to the PBS strongly inhibited in vitro RNA dimerization, indicating that, in vivo, the intermolecular interaction involving the NarI sequence must be dissociated to allow annealing of the primer tRNA.     

Bovine leukemia virus RNA sequences involved in dimerization and specific gag protein binding: close relation to the packaging sites of avian, murine, and human retroviruses.

In vitro detection of a specific complex of the bovine leukemia virus (BLV) MA(p15) protein and the 5'-terminal RNA dimer led to the hypothesis that the NH2-terminal domain of retrovirus gag protein precursor is involved in the selective viral RNA packaging mechanism. Here we describe mapping of the BLV RNA for dimer-forming and MA(p15)-binding abilities by a simple cDNA probing method followed by mutation analyses with the reactive U5-5' gag RNA. The RNA dimerization is mediated by the region harboring U5, the primer binding site (PBS), and the 30 bases immediately downstream of PBS. This conclusion is supported by computer-assisted RNA secondary-structure analysis which predicted a multibranched stem-loop folding throughout the dimer region determined. Another region from PBS to the 5'-terminal 60 residues of the gag gene, partially overlapping the dimer region, likely provides essential elements for the MA(p15) binding reaction, although the presence of either the 3' or 5' neighboring sequences increases the complex-forming efficiency significantly, and each of the substructures predicted within the core region has, if any, only very weak affinity to MA(p15). These in vitro characterizations of the BLV RNA may reflect general features of the specific protein-RNA interaction in the packaging events of various retroviruses. 5'-terminal folded structures of retroviral RNA molecules and their biological activities are discussed.     

Functional Analysis of the Core Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Packaging Signal in a Permissive Cell Line

Packaging of type C retrovirus genomic RNAs into budding virions requires a highly specific interaction between the viral Gag precursor and unique cis-acting packaging signals on the full-length RNA genome, allowing the selection of this RNA species from among a pool of spliced viral RNAs and similar cellular RNAs. This process is thought to involve RNA secondary and tertiary structural motifs since there is little conservation of the primary sequence of this region between retroviruses. To confirm RNA secondary structures, which we and others have predicted for this region, disruptive, compensatory, and deletion mutations were introduced into proviral constructs, which were then assayed in a permissive cell line. Disruption of either of two predicted stem-loops was found to greatly reduce RNA encapsidation and replication, whereas compensatory mutations restoring base pairing to these stem-loops had a wild-type phenotype. A GGNGR motif was identified in the loops of three hairpins in this region. Results were consistent with the hypothesis that the process of efficient RNA encapsidation is linked to dimerization. Replication and encapsidation were shown to occur at a reduced rate in the absence of the previously described kissing hairpin motif.     

The Determination of Importance of Sequences Neighboring the Psi Sequence in Lentiviral Vector Transduction and Packaging Efficiency

A number of lentiviral vector systems have been developed for gene delivery and therapy by eliminating and/or modifying viral genetic elements. However, all lentiviral vector systems derived from HIV-1 must have a viral packaging signal sequence, Psi (Ψ), which is placed downstream of 5′ long terminal repeat in a transgene plasmid to effectively package and deliver transgene mRNA. In this study, we examined feasible regions or sequences around Psi that could be manipulated to further modify the packaging sequence. Surprisingly, we found that the sequences immediately upstream of the Psi are highly refractory to any modification and resulted in transgene vectors with very poor gene transduction efficiency. Analysis around the Psi region revealed that there are a few sites that can be used for manipulation of the Psi sequence without disturbing the virus production as well as the efficiency of transgene RNA packaging and gene transduction. By exploiting this new vector system, we investigated the requirement of each of four individual stem-loops of the Psi sequence by deletion mapping analysis and found that all stem-loops, including the SL4 region, are needed for efficient transgene RNA packaging and gene delivery. These results suggest a possible frame of the lentiviral vector that might be useful for further modifying the region/sequence around the packaging sequence as well as directly on the Psi sequence without destroying transduction efficiency.     

A novel role for gag as a cis-acting element regulating RNA structure,dimerization and packaging in HIV-1 lentiviral vectors

Clinical usage of lentiviral vectors is now established and increasing but remains constrained by vector titer with RNA packaging being a limiting factor. Lentiviral vector RNA is packaged through specific recognition of the packaging signal on the RNA by the viral structural protein Gag. We investigated structurally informed modifications of the 5′ leader and gag RNA sequences in which the extended packaging signal lies, to attempt to enhance the packaging process by facilitating vector RNA dimerization, a process closely linked to packaging. We used in-gel SHAPE to study the structures of these mutants in an attempt to derive structure-function correlations that could inform optimized vector RNA design. In-gel SHAPE of both dimeric and monomeric species of RNA revealed a previously unreported direct interaction between the U5 region of the HIV-1 leader and the downstream gag sequences. Our data suggest a structural equilibrium exists in the dimeric viral RNA between a metastable structure that includes a U5–gag interaction and a more stable structure with a U5–AUG duplex. Our data provide clarification for the previously unexplained requirement for the 5′ region of gag in enhancing genomic RNA packaging and provide a basis for design of optimized HIV-1 based vectors.