Evaluation of a high-throughput fluorescence assay method for HERG potassium channel inhibition

The number of projects in drug development that fail in late phases because of cardiac side effects such as QT prolongation can impede drug discovery and development of projects. The molecular target responsible for QT prolongation by a wide range of pharmaceutical agents is the myocardial hERG potassium channel. It is therefore desirable to screen for compound interactions with the hERG channel at an early stage of drug development. Here, the authors report a cell-based fluorescence assay using membrane potential-sensitive fluorescent dyes and stably transfected hERG channels from CHO cells. The assay allows semiautomated screening of compounds for hERG activity on 384-well plates and is sufficiently rapid for testing a large number of compounds. The assay is robust as indicated by a Z' factor larger than 0.6. The throughput is in the range of 10,000 data points per day, which is significantly higher than any other method presently available for hERG. The data obtained with the fluorescence assay were in qualitative agreement with those from patch-clamp electrophysiological analysis. There were no false-positive hits, and the rate of false-negative compounds is currently 12% but might be further reduced by testing compounds at higher concentration. Quantitative differences between fluorescence and electrophysiological methods may be due to the use- or voltage-dependent activity of the antagonists.     

A new homogeneous high-throughput screening assay for profiling compound activity on the human ether-a-go-go-related gene channel

Long QT syndrome, either inherited or acquired from drug treatments, can result in ventricular arrhythmia (torsade de pointes) and sudden death. Human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG) channel inhibition by drugs is now recognized as a common reason for the acquired form of long QT syndrome. It has been reported that more than 100 known drugs inhibit the activity of the hERG channel. Since 1997, several drugs have been withdrawn from the market due to the long QT syndrome caused by hERG inhibition. Food and Drug Administration regulations now require safety data on hERG channels for investigative new drug (IND) applications. The assessment of compound activity on the hERG channel has now become an important part of the safety evaluation in the process of drug discovery. During the past decade, several in vitro assay methods have been developed and significant resources have been used to characterize hERG channel activities. However, evaluation of compound activities on hERG have not been performed for large compound collections due to technical difficulty, lack of throughput, and/or lack of biological relevance to function. Here we report a modified form of the FluxOR thallium flux assay, capable of measuring hERG activity in a homogeneous 1536-well plate format. To validate the assay, we screened a 7-point dilution series of the LOPAC 1280 library collection and reported rank order potencies of ten common hERG inhibitors. A correlation was also observed for the hERG channel activities of 10 known hERG inhibitors determined in this thallium flux assay and in the patch clamp experiment. Our findings indicate that this thallium flux assay can be used as an alternative method to profile large-volume compound libraries for compound activity on the hERG channel.     

Microfluidic cell culture and its application in high-throughput drug screening: cardiotoxicity assay for hERG channels

Evaluation of drug cardiotoxicity is essential to the safe development of novel pharmaceuticals. Assessing a compound's risk for prolongation of the surface electrocardiographic QT interval and hence risk for life-threatening arrhythmias is mandated before approval of nearly all new pharmaceuticals. QT prolongation has most commonly been associated with loss of current through hERG (human ether-a-go-go related gene) potassium ion channels due to direct block of the ion channel by drugs or occasionally by inhibition of the plasma membrane expression of the channel protein. To develop an efficient, reliable, and cost-effective hERG screening assay for detecting drug-mediated disruption of hERG membrane trafficking, the authors demonstrate the use of microfluidic-based systems to improve throughput and lower cost of current methods. They validate their microfluidics array platform in polystyrene (PS), cyclo-olefin polymer (COP), and polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) microchannels for drug-induced disruption of hERG trafficking by culturing stably transfected HEK cells that overexpressed hERG (WT-hERG) and studying their morphology, proliferation rates, hERG protein expression, and response to drug treatment. Results show that WT-hERG cells readily proliferate in PS, COP, and PDMS microfluidic channels. The authors demonstrated that conventional Western blot analysis was possible using cell lysate extracted from a single microchannel. The Western blot analysis also provided important evidence that WT-hERG cells cultured in microchannels maintained regular (well plate-based) expression of hERG. The authors further show that experimental procedures can be streamlined by using direct in-channel immunofluorescence staining in conjunction with detection using an infrared scanner. Finally, treatment of WT-hERG cells with 5 different drugs suggests that PS (and COP) microchannels were more suitable than PDMS microchannels for drug screening applications, particularly for tests involving hydrophobic drug molecules.     

Isosteric replacements for benzothiazoles and optimisation to potent Cathepsin K inhibitors free from hERG channel inhibition

The discovery of nitrile compound 4, a potent inhibitor of Cathepsin K (Cat K) with good bioavailability in dog is described. The compound was used to demonstrate target engagement and inhibition of Cat K in an in vivo dog PD model. The margin to hERG ion channel inhibition was deemed too low for a clinical candidate and an optimisation program to find isosteres or substitutions on benzothiazole group led to the discovery of 20, 24 and 27; all three free from hERG inhibition.     

Estimation of hERG inhibition of drug candidates using multivariate property and pharmacophore SAR

We describe the development of a computational model for the prediction of the inhibition of K(+) flow through the hERG ion channel. Using a collection of 1075 discovery compounds with hERG inhibition measured in our standard patch-clamp electrophysiology assay, molecular features important for drug-induced inhibition were identified using a combination of statistical inference algorithms and manual hypothesis generation and testing. While many of the features used in the model reflect those referenced in the literature, several aspects of the model provide new insight into the role of physicochemical properties, electrostatics, and novel pharmacophores in hERG inhibition. Coefficients for these 10 features were then determined by least median squares regression, resulting in a model with an R(2) approximately 0.66 and RMS error (RMSe) of 0.47 log units for an external test set. Significant additional validation performed using a large collection of subsequent discovery data has been very encouraging with an R(2)=0.54 and an RMSe of 0.63 log units. The performance of the model across several different chemotypes is demonstrated and discussed.     

Role of hERG potassium channel assays in drug development

Numerous structurally and functionally unrelated drugs block the hERG potassium channel. HERG channels are involved in cardiac action potential repolarization, and reduced function of hERG lengthens ventricular action potentials, prolongs the QT interval in an electrocardiogram, and increases the risk for potentially fatal ventricular arrhythmias. In order to reduce the risk of investing resources in a drug candidate that fails preclinical safety studies because of QT prolongation, it is important to screen compounds for activity on hERG channels early in the lead optimization process. A number of hERG assays are available, ranging from high throughput binding assays on stably expressed recombinant channels to very time consuming electrophysiological examinations in cardiac myocytes. Depending on the number of compounds to be tested, binding assays or functional assays measuring membrane potential or Rb(+) flux, combined with electrophysiology on a few compounds, can be used to efficiently develop the structure-function relationship of hERG interactions.     

Role of hERG potassium channel assays in drug development

Numerous structurally and functionally unrelated drugs block the hERG potassium channel. HERG channels are involved in cardiac action potential repolarization, and reduced function of hERG lengthens ventricular action potentials, prolongs the QT interval in an electrocardiogram, and increases the risk for potentially fatal ventricular arrhythmias. In order to reduce the risk of investing resources in a drug candidate that fails preclinical safety studies because of QT prolongation, it is important to screen compounds for activity on hERG channels early in the lead optimization process. A number of hERG assays are available, ranging from high throughput binding assays on stably expressed recombinant channels to very time consuming electrophysiological examinations in cardiac myocytes. Depending on the number of compounds to be tested, binding assays or functional assays measuring membrane potential or Rb+ flux, combined with electrophysiology on a few compounds, can be used to efficiently develop the structure-function relationship of hERG interactions.     

The open-access dataset for insilico cardiotoxicity prediction system

Drug cardiotoxicity is one of the main reasons of fatal drug related problem events and the subsequent withdrawals. Therefore, its early assessment is a crucial element of the drug development process. For the drug driven hERG inhibition assessment, which is assumed to be the main reason for toxicity, in vitro techniques are used. Gold standards are based on the Patch Clamp method with the use of various cell models but due to its low throughput, insilico models have become more appreciated. To develop a reliable empirical QSAR model, wide dataset containing a variety of cases has to be available. In this article, a freely available for download, set of data is described. It is based on literature peer-reviewed reports and contains hERG inhibition information expressed as IC50 value for 263 molecules described in 642 records. All studies were done with the use of three cell models (XO, CHO, HEK) and other elements describe the electrophysiological settings of the in vitro study. The above mentioned set was used for the successful development of the predictive models.     

Development and application of an automated solution stability assay for drug discovery

Screening of solution stability provides an early alert on potential liabilities of drug candidates so that strategies can be developed to overcome the challenges. A fully automated solution stability assay has been developed to accelerate traditional manual operation. The assay uses the advanced capabilities of a high-performance liquid chromatography instrument that is present in many pharmaceutical research laboratories. The samples are prepared automatically by a temperature-controlled autosampler. The samples are delivered to the stability matrices, mixed, incubated, and injected at selected time points during the reaction time course. This automated process occurs without operator intervention, thus allowing 96 experiments to be run with 0.5 h of a scientist's time compared to 8 h for the same study when performed manually. Automation not only eliminates the manual operation but also improves accuracy and throughput. The assay protocol has been optimized to achieve homogenous mixing and eliminate carryover. The assay is robust, flexible, and high throughput. It can be used to study stability for a large number of samples under multiple incubation conditions and has a wide range of applications in drug discovery and development, such as screening compound stability in biological assay media, obtaining a stability-pH profile, surveying compound stability in physiological fluids, and performing development forced degradation and excipient compatibility.     

Evaluation of cellular dielectric spectroscopy, a whole-cell, label-free technology for drug discovery on Gi-coupled GPCRs

Cellular dielectric spectroscopy (CDS) is an emerging technology capable of detecting a range of whole-cell responses in a label-free manner. A new CDS-based instrument, CellKey, has been developed that is optimized for G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) detection and has automated liquid handling in microplate format, thereby making CDS accessible to lead generation/optimization drug discovery. In addition to having sufficient throughput, new assay technologies must pass rigorous standards for assay development, signal window, dynamic range, and reproducibility to effectively support drug discovery SAR studies. Here, the authors evaluated CellKey with 3 different G(i)-coupled GPCRs for suitability in supporting SAR studies. Optimized assay conditions compatible with the precision, reproducibility, and throughput required for routine screening were quickly achieved for each target. Across a 1000-fold range in compound potencies, CellKey results correlated with agonist and antagonist data obtained using classical methods ([(35)S]GTPgammaS binding and cAMP production). For partial agonists, relative efficacy measurements also correlated with GTPgammaS data. CellKey detection of positive allosteric modulators appeared superior to GTPgammaS methodology. Agonist and antagonist activity could be accurately quantified under conditions of low receptor expression. CellKey is a new technology platform that uses label-free detection in a homogeneous assay that is unaffected by color quenching and is easily integrated into existing microtiter-based compound testing and data analysis procedures for drug discovery.     

Identification and Characterization of a Compound That Protects Cardiac Tissue from Human Ether-à-go-go-related Gene (hERG)-related Drug-induced Arrhythmias

The human Ether-à-go-go-related gene (hERG)-encoded K⁺ current, I_Kr is essential for cardiac repolarization but is also a source of cardiotoxicity because unintended hERG inhibition by diverse pharmaceuticals can cause arrhythmias and sudden cardiac death. We hypothesized that a small molecule that diminishes I_Kr block by a known hERG antagonist would constitute a first step toward preventing hERG-related arrhythmias and facilitating drug discovery. Using a high-throughput assay, we screened a library of compounds for agents that increase the IC₇₀ of dofetilide, a well characterized hERG blocker. One compound, VU0405601, with the desired activity was further characterized. In isolated, Langendorff-perfused rabbit hearts, optical mapping revealed that dofetilide-induced arrhythmias were reduced after pretreatment with VU0405601. Patch clamp analysis in stable hERG-HEK cells showed effects on current amplitude, inactivation, and deactivation. VU0405601 increased the IC₅₀ of dofetilide from 38.7 to 76.3 nm. VU0405601 mitigates the effects of hERG blockers from the extracellular aspect primarily by reducing inactivation, whereas most clinically relevant hERG inhibitors act at an inner pore site. Structure-activity relationships surrounding VU0405601 identified a 3-pyridiyl and a naphthyridine ring system as key structural components important for preventing hERG inhibition by multiple inhibitors. These findings indicate that small molecules can be designed to reduce the sensitivity of hERG to inhibitors.     

Driving efficiency in a high-throughput metabolic stability assay through a generic high-resolution accurate mass method and automated data mining

Improving analytical throughput is the focus of many quantitative workflows being developed for early drug discovery. For drug candidate screening, it is common practice to use ultra-high performance liquid chromatography (U-HPLC) coupled with triple quadrupole mass spectrometry. This approach certainly results in short analytical run time; however, in assessing the true throughput, all aspects of the workflow needs to be considered, including instrument optimization and the necessity to re-run samples when information is missed. Here we describe a high-throughput metabolic stability assay with a simplified instrument set-up which significantly improves the overall assay efficiency. In addition, as the data is acquired in a non-biased manner, high information content of both the parent compound and metabolites is gathered at the same time to facilitate the decision of which compounds to proceed through the drug discovery pipeline.     

Addressing hERG activity while maintaining favorable potency,selectivity and pharmacokinetic properties of PPARδ modulators

One of the most commonly used strategies to reduce hERG (human ether-a-go-go) activity in the drug candidates is introduction of a carboxylic acid group. During the optimization of PPARδ modulators, some of the compounds containing a carboxylic acid were found to inhibit the hERG channel in a patch clamp assay. By modifying the basicity of the imidazole core, potent and selective PPARδ modulators that do not inhibit hERG channel were identified. Some of the modulators have excellent pharmacokinetic profiles in mice.     

Staurosporine-based binding assay for testing the affinity of compounds to protein kinases

Staurosporine is a broad-spectrum inhibitor of both tyrosine and serine/threonine protein kinases. Excitation of staurosporine and its analogues at 296 nm results in major emission bands centered at 378 and 396 nm. The intensity of the emission bands is enhanced on binding to the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) site of many protein kinases. This property was used to develop a competitive displacement assay for evaluating the binding affinity of small molecules to protein kinases. The assay was validated in both cuvette and plate formats for several phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated protein kinases. The throughput of the assay is high enough to be used in drug discovery for screening as well as lead optimization.     

Identifying modulators of hERG channel activity using the PatchXpress planar patch clamp

The authors used the PatchXpress 7000A system to measure compound activity at the hERG channel using procedures that mimicked the "gold-standard" conventional whole-cell patch clamp. A set of 70 compounds, including hERG antagonists with potencies spanning 3 orders of magnitude, were tested on hERG302-HEK cells using protocols aimed at either identifying compound activity at a single concentration or obtaining compound potency from a cumulative concentration dependence paradigm. After exposure to compounds and subsequent washout of the wells to determine reversibility of the block, blockade by a reference compound served as a quality control. Electrical parameters and voltage dependence were similar to those obtained using a conventional whole-cell patch clamp. Rank order of compound potency was also comparable to that determined by conventional methods. One exception was flunarizine, a particularly lipophilic compound. The PatchXpress accurately identified the activity of 29 moderately potent antagonists, which only weakly displace radiolabeled astemizole and are false negatives in the binding assay. Finally, no false hits were observed from a collection of relatively inactive compounds. High-quality data acquisition by PatchXpress should help accelerate secondary screening for ion channel modulators and the drug discovery process.     

A place for high-throughput electrophysiology in cardiac safety: screening hERG cell lines and novel compounds with the ion works HTTM system

Several commercially available pharmaceutical compounds have been shown to block the IKr current of the cardiac action potential. This effect can cause a prolongation of the electrocardiogram QT interval and a delay in ventricular repolarization. The Food and Drug Administration recommends that all new potential drug candidates be assessed for IKr block to avoid a potentially lethal cardiac arrhythmia known as torsades de pointes. Direct compound interaction with the human ether-a-go-go- related gene (hERG) product, a delayed rectifier potassium channel, has been identified as a molecular mechanism of IKr block. One strategy to identify compounds with hERG liability is to monitor hERG current inhibition using electrophysiology techniques. The authors describe the Ion Works HT instrument as a tool for screening cell lines expressing hERG channels. Based on current amplitude and stability criteria, a cell line was selected and used to perform a 300-compound screen. The screen was able to identify compounds with hERG activity within projects that spanned different therapeutic areas. The cell line selection and optimization, as well as the screening abilities of the Ion Works HT system, provide a powerful means of assessing hERGactive compounds early in the drug discovery pipeline.     

Structure Driven Design of Novel Human Ether-A-Go-Go-Related-Gene Channel (hERG1) Activators

One of the main culprits in modern drug discovery is apparent cardiotoxicity of many lead-candidates via inadvertent pharmacologic blockade of K⁺, Ca²⁺ and Na⁺ currents. Many drugs inadvertently block hERG1 leading to an acquired form of the Long QT syndrome and potentially lethal polymorphic ventricular tachycardia. An emerging strategy is to rely on interventions with a drug that may proactively activate hERG1 channels reducing cardiovascular risks. Small molecules-activators have a great potential for co-therapies where the risk of hERG-related QT prolongation is significant and rehabilitation of the drug is impractical. Although a number of hERG1 activators have been identified in the last decade, their binding sites, functional moieties responsible for channel activation and thus mechanism of action, have yet to be established. Here, we present a proof-of-principle study that combines de-novo drug design, molecular modeling, chemical synthesis with whole cell electrophysiology and Action Potential (AP) recordings in fetal mouse ventricular myocytes to establish basic chemical principles required for efficient activator of hERG1 channel. In order to minimize the likelihood that these molecules would also block the hERG1 channel they were computationally engineered to minimize interactions with known intra-cavitary drug binding sites. The combination of experimental and theoretical studies led to identification of functional elements (functional groups, flexibility) underlying efficiency of hERG1 activators targeting binding pocket located in the S4–S5 linker, as well as identified potential side-effects in this promising line of drugs, which was associated with multi-channel targeting of the developed drugs.     

A novel and simple method of screening compounds for interaction with DNA: A validation study

We report the development of a simple, cost-effective assay for detecting compounds that have the ability to interact with and modify DNA. Potential uses for the assay lie in the areas of early genotoxicity testing of drug candidates, anticancer and antibiotic drug discovery, environmental monitoring and testing in the food, beverage and cosmetics industries. At present the assay has been used to assess direct-acting compounds only and it is yet to be established whether the assay is compatible with bio-activation. The methodology is based on the oxidative reaction of potassium permanganate with pyrimidine bases, which have become perturbed and more reactive by the agent under test. Results are recorded by use of UV/vis spectroscopy. The adaptation to a multi-well plate format provides the capacity for high throughput utilizing small amounts of compounds. Over 100 compounds, comprising different classes of DNA-binding chemicals as well as non-binding controls, have been put through the assay and the results compared with existing genotoxicity testing data from other methods. The assay has shown to be predictive of the results of other genotoxicity testing methods. We have found that the method is overall predictive of 71% of Ames bacterial reverse-mutation test results (where data are given) encompassing both negative and positive results.     

Small Molecule Screening in Human Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell-derived Terminal Cell Types

A need for better clinical outcomes has heightened interest in the use of physiologically relevant human cells in the drug discovery process. Patient-specific human induced pluripotent stem cells may offer a relevant, robust, scalable, and cost-effective model of human disease physiology. Small molecule high throughput screening in human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cells with the intent of identifying novel therapeutic compounds is starting to influence the drug discovery process; however, the use of these cells presents many high throughput screening development challenges. This technology has the potential to transform the way drug discovery is performed.