Genetic resistance to rhabdovirus infection in teleost fish is paralleled to the derived cell resistance status

Genetic factors of resistance and predisposition to viral diseases explain a significant part of the clinical variability observed within host populations. Predisposition to viral diseases has been associated to MHC haplotypes and T cell immunity, but a growing repertoire of innate/intrinsic factors are implicated in the genetic determinism of the host susceptibility to viruses. In a long-term study of the genetics of host resistance to fish rhabdoviruses, we produced a collection of double-haploid rainbow trout clones showing a wide range of susceptibility to Viral Hemorrhagic Septicemia Virus (VHSV) waterborne infection. The susceptibility of fibroblastic cell lines derived from these clonal fish was fully consistent with the susceptibility of the parental fish clones. The mechanisms determining the host resistance therefore did not associate with specific host immunity, but rather with innate or intrinsic factors. One cell line was resistant to rhabdovirus infection due to the combination of an early interferon IFN induction--that was not observed in the susceptible cells--and of yet unknown factors that hamper the first steps of the viral cycle. The implication of IFN was well consistent with the wide range of resistance of this genetic background to VSHV and IHNV, to the birnavirus IPNV and the orthomyxovirus ISAV. Another cell line was even more refractory to the VHSV infection through different antiviral mechanisms. This collection of clonal fish and isogenic cell lines provides an interesting model to analyze the relative contribution of antiviral pathways to the resistance to different viruses.     

Viral susceptibility of newly established cell lines from the Hawaiian monk seal Monachus schauinslandi

Ten of 11 cell lines, recently established from the snout (MS-SN), periorbital soft tissue (MS-EY), liver (MS-LV), kidney (MS-KD), lung (MS-LG), spleen (MS-SP), heart (MS-HT), thyroid (MS-TY), brain (MS-BR) and urinary bladder (MS-UB) of a juvenile Hawaiian monk seal Monachus schauinslandi, were evaluated in vitro for their susceptibility to 5 mammalian viruses: herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1), vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), reovirus type 3 (Reo-3), poliovirus type 1 (Polio-1) and vaccinia virus (Vac); 5 fish viruses: channel catfish herpesvirus (CCV), infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV), infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV), fish rhabdovirus carpio (RC) and viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV); and 2 marine mammal morbilliviruses: phocine distemper virus (PDV) and dolphin distemper virus (DMV). Four well-established continuous cell-lines of nonhuman primate (Vero) and fish (EPC, CHSE-214 and BB) origin served as controls to standardize the virus infectivity assays. Virus yields were quantified as 50% tissue culture infectious dose (TCID50) ml(-1) on Day 7 post-inoculation. Results of the viral challenge assays revealed that the monk seal cell lines shared a similar pattern of susceptibility to the mammalian viruses. Despite their different tissue origins, all monk seal cells were sensitive to HSV-1, Vac, VSV and Reo-3, but were refractory to Polio-1. A characteristic viral-induced cytopathic effect was noted with VSV and Reo-3, and distinct plaques were observed for HSV-1 and Vac. Monk seal cell lines were also susceptible to PDV and DMV, 2 morbilliviruses isolated from seals and dolphins, respectively. By contrast, these cell lines were generally resistant to VHSV, IHNV and IPNV, with varying susceptibility to RC and CCV. The wide range of viral susceptibility of these monk seal cell lines suggests their potential value in studying viruses of monk seals and other marine mammals.     

In vitro viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus replication in excised fins of rainbow trout: correlation with resistance to waterborne challenge and genetic variation

In vitro viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus replication in excised fin tissue (VREFT) was investigated as a possible criterion to predict the resistance of groups or individuals to viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV) in rainbow trout. Adipose and rayed fins were compared for VREFT response, and a statistically significant correlation was found. Correlation between VREFT and survival after waterborne viral challenge was estimated on a set of 27 groups of trout, and was highly significant (R = 0.72). A further experiment with fish individually tagged and challenged some time after fin clipping for determination of VREFT confirmed that the mean value of resistant (surviving) fish was significantly lower than the mean value of susceptible (dead) ones, but there was a wide variation within each of these groups. In particular, a large proportion of fish expected to be resistant based on VREFT values died all the same. Using clones, we showed that the correlation between VREFT and survival was dramatically high (R = 0.96). Genetic analyses of the data from the different groups available in the experiment consistently indicated a large amount of genetic determination of VREFT, an encouraging result for selection purposes. Though these results were obtained in experimentally controlled conditions not identical to those in the field, they shed new light on the analysis of defence mechanisms against the virus and on the possibility of performing indirect selection for resistance, using VREFT as the secondary character.     

Essential role of the NV protein of Novirhabdovirus for pathogenicity in rainbow trout

Novirhabdovirus, infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV), and viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV) are fish rhabdoviruses that, in comparison to the other rhabdoviruses, contain an additional gene coding for a small nonvirion (NV) protein of unassigned function. A recombinant IHNV with the NV gene deleted but expressing the green fluorescent protein (rIHNV-Delta NV) has previously been shown to be efficiently recovered by reverse genetics (S. Biacchesi et al., J. Virol. 74:11247-11253, 2000). However, preliminary experiments suggested that the growth in cell culture of rIHNV-Delta NV was affected by the NV deletion. In the present study, we show that the growth in cell culture of rIHNV-Delta NV is indeed severely impaired but that a normal growth of rIHNV-Delta NV can be restored when NV is provided in trans by using fish cell clones constitutively expressing the NV protein. These results indicate that NV is a protein that has a crucial biological role for optimal replication of IHNV in cell culture. Although IHNV and VHSV NV proteins do not share any significant identity, we show here that both NV proteins play a similar role since a recombinant IHNV virus, rIHNV-NV(VHSV), in which the IHNV NV open reading frame has been replaced by that of VHSV, was shown to replicate as well as the wild-type (wt) IHNV into fish cells. Finally, data provided by experimental fish infections with the various recombinant viruses strongly suggest an essential role of the NV protein for the pathogenicity of IHNV. Furthermore, we show that juvenile trout immunized with NV-knockout IHNV were protected against challenge with wt IHNV. That opens a new perspective for the development of IHNV attenuated live vaccines.     

Histological, serological and virulence studies on rainbow trout experimentally infected with recombinant infectious hematopoietic necrosis viruses

Several recombinant infectious hematopoietic necrosis viruses (IHNV) were produced by reverse genetics and their pathogenicity in trout was evaluated and compared to that of the wild type (wt) viruses IHNV and viral haemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV). Recombinant IHNVs used in this study were: rIHNV, identical to the wtIHNV; rIHNV-Gvhsv, a recombinant virus expressing the VHSV G gene instead of the IHNV G gene; rIHNV-Gmut, which possesses 2 targeted mutations in the glycoprotein; and rIHNVmut-Gmut, which is similar to the rIHNV-Gmut, but exhibits additional mutations along the genome. Results obtained in experimental infections showed that the rIHNV and rIHNV-Gmut were the most virulent recombinant viruses. Severity of the lesions induced by the different recombinant viruses was in agreement with mortality data. The kidney and the liver were the organs most affected by the most pathogenic viruses, and the lesions observed resembled those produced by wtIHNV. The introduction of mutations did not alter the tissue tropism of the virus. The recombinant viruses were able to replicate in fish, as shown by immunoperoxidase assay and RT-PCR. Antibodies against IHNV were detected in the fish inoculated with IHNV, rIHNV, rIHNV-Gmut and rIHNVmut-Gmut, and antibodies against VHSV were also found in fish infected with rIHNV-Gvhsv. Finally, antibody production was highest in fish infected with the rIHNVmut-Gmut even though this virus was the least virulent.     

Virus susceptibility of the fish cell line SAF-1 derived from gilt-head seabream

The recently reported SAF-1 cell line from fins of gilt-head seabream was evaluated for susceptibility to lymphocystis disease virus (LDV) and to several salmonid fish viruses, such as infectious haematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV), viral haemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV) and several strains of infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV). LDV, VHSV and IHNV replicated well in the cultured fin cells as demonstrated by cell lysis and increases in viral titer. The potential use of this cell line to detect viruses from fish marine species is discussed.     

Comparison of two birnavirus-rhabdovirus coinfections in fish cell lines

Aquabirnaviruses, such as the infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV), Novirhabdoviruses, such as the infectious hematopoiteic necrosis virus (IHNV) and the viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV), cause considerable losses to the salmonid industry worldwide. Coinfections of 2 viruses have been described, but the interactions between rhabdoviruses and birnaviruses have not been examined closely. Using virus titration, flow cytometry and RT-PCR assays, we compared the effect of IPNV on the replication of IHNV and VHSV in tissue culture cells. RT-PCR assays indicated that simultaneous infection of IPNV with VHSV does not affect the replication of the rhabdovirus either in the first or successive passages; the infective titers were similar in single and double infections. In contrast, coinfection of IPNV with IHNV induced a fall in infectivity, with reduced expression of IHNV viral antigens in BF-2 cells from Lepomis macrochirus and a loss of 4.5 log10 units of the infective titer after 3 successive passages. It was possible to stimulate BF-2 cells to produce significant interferon-like activity against IHNV but not against VHSV.     

Nonvirion protein of novirhabdovirus suppresses apoptosis at the early stage of virus infection

Viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV) and infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) are members of the genus Novirhabdovirus within the Rhabdoviridae family, which can cause severe hemorrhagic disease in fresh- and saltwater fish worldwide. These viruses carry an additional nonvirion (NV) gene, which codes for the nonstructural NV protein that has been implicated to play a role in viral pathogenesis. To determine the precise biological function of this NV gene and its gene product, we generated NV-deficient and NV knockout recombinant VHSVs, using reverse genetics. Comparisons of the replication kinetics and markers for virus-induced apoptosis indicated that the NV-deficient and NV knockout mutant viruses induce apoptosis earlier in cell culture than the wild-type recombinant VHSV. These results suggest that the NV protein has an antiapoptotic function at the early stage of virus infection. Furthermore, we created a chimeric VHSV, in which the NV gene of VHSV was replaced by the IHNV NV gene, which was capable of suppressing apoptosis in cell culture. These results show that the NV protein of other members of Novirhabdovirus can restore the NV protein function. In this study, we also investigated the kinetics of VHSV replication during a single round of viral replication and examined the mechanism of VHSV-induced apoptosis. Our results show that VHSV infection induced caspases 3, 8 and 9 in cell culture.     

Inter-laboratory comparison of cell lines for susceptibility to three viruses: VHSV, IHNV and IPNV.

Eleven European National Reference Laboratories participated in an inter-laboratory comparison of the susceptibility of 5 selected cell lines to 3 fish pathogenic viruses. The test included viral hemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV); infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) and infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV), and the cell lines derived from bluegill fry (BF-2), chinook salmon embryo (CHSE-214), epithelioma papulosum cyprini (EPC), fathead minnow (FHM) and rainbow trout gonad (RTG-2). The results showed that for isolation of VHSV, BF-2 and RTG-2 cells performed equally well and had higher sensitivity compared to the other cell lines. For IHNV, EPC and FHM cells gave the best results, and for IPNV it was BF-2 and CHSE-214 cells. FHM cells showed the largest variability among laboratories, whereas EPC was the cell line showing the smallest variability.     

Recombinant infectious hematopoietic necrosis viruses induce protection for rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss

Infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) and viral hemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV) are rhabdoviruses that infect salmonids, producing serious economic losses. Two recombinant IHN viruses were generated by reverse genetics. For one (rIHNV GFP) the IHNV NV gene was replaced with the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene. In the other (rIHNV-Gvhsv GFP) the G gene was also exchanged for that of VHSV. No mortalities, external signs or histological lesions were observed in experimental infections conducted with the recombinant viruses. Neither the rIHNV GFP nor rIHNV-Gvhsv GFP was detected by RT-PCR in any of the examined tissues from experimentally infected fish. In order to assess their potential as vaccines against the wild type viruses, rainbow trout were vaccinated with the recombinant viruses by intraperitoneal injection and challenged 30 d later with virulent IHNV or VHSV. The GFP viruses provided protection against both wild type viruses. None of the recombinant viruses induced antibody production, and the expression of interferon (IFNalpha4) and interferon induced genes such as Mx protein and ISG-15 was not different to that of controls. The rIHNV-Gvhsv GFP did not inhibit cellular apoptosis as it was observed in an IHNV inoculated fish cell line. These studies suggest that the recombinant rIHNV-Gvhsv GFP is a promising candidate as a live recombinant vaccine and also provides a good model to further study viral pathogenicity and the molecular basis of protection against these viral infections.     

Heterologous exchanges of the glycoprotein and the matrix protein in a Novirhabdovirus

Infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) and viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV) are two salmonid rhabdoviruses replicating at low temperatures (14 to 20 degrees C). Both viruses belong to the Novirhabdovirus genus, but they are only distantly related and do not cross antigenically. By using a recently developed reverse-genetic system based on IHNV (S. Biacchesi et al., J. Virol. 74:11247-11253, 2000), we investigated the ability to exchange IHNV glycoprotein G with that of VHSV. Thus, the IHNV genome was modified so that the VHSV G gene replaced the complete IHNV G gene. A recombinant virus expressing VHSV G instead of IHNV G, rIHNV-Gvhsv, was generated and was shown to replicate as well as the wild-type rIHNV in cell culture. This study was extended by exchanging IHNV G with that of a fish vesiculovirus able to replicate at high temperatures (up to 28 degrees C), the spring viremia of carp virus (SVCV). rIHNV-Gsvcv was successfully recovered; however, its growth was restricted to 14 to 20 degrees C. These results show the nonspecific sequence requirement for the insertion of heterologous glycoproteins into IHNV virions and also demonstrate that an IHNV protein other than the G protein is responsible for the low-temperature restriction on growth. To determine to what extent the matrix (M) protein interacts with G, a series of chimeric pIHNV constructs in which all or part of the M gene was replaced with the VHSV counterpart was engineered and used to recover the respective recombinant viruses. Despite the very low percentage (38%) of amino acid identity between the IHNV and VHSV matrix proteins, viable chimeric IHNVs, harboring either the matrix protein or both the glycoprotein and the matrix protein from VHSV, were recovered and propagated. Altogether, these data show the extreme flexibility of IHNV to accommodate heterologous structural proteins.     

Study of the viral interference between infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV) and infectious haematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

The resistance of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) to an infectious haematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) challenge following a preceding non-lethal infection with infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV) was investigated through experimental dual infections. Trout initially infected with IPNV were inoculated 14 days later with IHNV. Single infections of trout with 1 of the 2 viruses or with cell culture supernatant were also carried out and constituted control groups. No mortality was noted in fish after a single infection with IPNV. This virus had no influence on the head kidney leucocyte phagocytic activity and plasma haemolytic complement activity. IHNV induced a high mortality (72%) and reduced the macrophage phagocytic activity and complement haemolytic activity. It also induced a late production of anti-IHNV antibodies which occurred after clearance of the virus in the fish. In trout co-infected with both viruses, a mortality rate of 2% occurred and the immune parameters were similar to those observed in the fish infected with IPNV only, demonstrating that in co-infected trout IPNV inhibits the effects of IHNV. The studied parameters did not allow us to define the mechanism of interference occurring between these 2 viruses, but some hypothesis are put forward to explain the interference between the 2 viruses.     

Effect of Cecropin B and a Synthetic Analogue on Propagation of Fish Viruses In Vitro

Abstract Cecropins and other natural antimicrobial peptides are widely distributed in animals from insects to mammals. These proteins have been shown to be major constituents of the innate immune systems of animals for nonspecific defense of the host against various bacteria and parasites. Therefore, exploitation of this natural innate defense system may lead to the development of effective methods for protecting fish from invasion by microbial pathogens. Recently, we have demonstrated that the introduction of cecropin transgenes into Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes) conferred resistance to infection by fish bacterial pathogens. Aside from a few reports documenting the antiviral effect of antimicrobial peptides including cecropins against mammalian viruses, there is no evidence for the effect of these peptides against fish viruses. In this article we present results of in vitro characterization of native cecropin B and a synthetic analogue, CF17, against several important fish viral pathogens—namely, infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV), viral hemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV), snakehead rhabdovirus (SHRV), and infectious pancreatic necrosis virus (IPNV). Upon coincubation of these peptides and viruses, the viral titers yielded in fish cells were reduced from several fold to 104-fold. Direct disruption of the viral envelope and disintegration of the viral capsids may be involved in the inhibition of viral replication by the peptides. Results of our studies demonstrate the potential of manipulating antimicrobial peptide genes by transgenesis to combat viral infection in fish.     

In vitro assay to select rainbow trout with variable resistance/susceptibility to viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus

The merit of a candidate criterion of resistance to viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV) was tested with the view of producing experimental trout progeny with a predictable level of resistance. The criterion, the measure of in vitro viral replication in excised fin tissue (VREFT) was previously developed. Three experiments were performed, using both ordinary and homozygous doubled-haploid breeders. A set of 48 progeny was tested. Breeders were individually scored for repeated measures of VREFT, and the progeny were tested against VHSV (strain 07-71, serotype 1) through a waterborne challenge (5 x 10(4) pfu ml(-1) during 2 h). Analysis of repeated measures of VREFT revealed the risk of identifying 'false' resistant individuals. The highest value should be considered the most predictive of the resistance status. Survival of progeny ranged from 0 to 100% according to the group and the experiment. The survival was correlated to the mean VREFT value of the breeders in Expts 1 and 2 (R = 0.96 and 0.61 respectively), but not in Expt 3 (R = 0.36, ns) where all tested progeny were highly susceptible. Results thus indicate that viral growth in fin tissue is genetically correlated to resistance to waterborne disease and may be used to produce selected progeny, at least at the experimental scale. Possible implications of the relationship between VREFT and resistance for the study of resistance mechanisms are discussed.     

A multi-generation analysis of the stability of transgenic virus resistance in doubled-haploid tobacco lines

Plants can be genetically engineered for virus resistance by transformation with a viral gene. We transformed tobacco with the tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) nucleocapsid gene from the Hawaiian L isolate in order to obtain TSWV resistant breeding lines. Doubled-haploid lines were produced from primary transgenic plants that were selected for resistance to the virus. Several of these lines showed very high levels of resistance and were symptomless after inoculation with the Hawaiian L isolate of TSWV. The accumulation of only low levels of full-length transgene RNA and protein observed in these lines is consistent with an RNA-mediated mechanism of resistance. The lines that were highly resistant to the Hawaiian L isolate of TSWV were also found to be highly resistant to several other isolates of TSWV, while lines that were only moderately resistant to the Hawaiian L isolate were often susceptible to the other isolates. The highly resistant lines were advanced over several generations by self-pollination. Although these lines were fully homozygous, several lines lost resistance in later generations, indicating that the resistance was unstable. Selection for resistance in these unstable lines did not prevent the occurrence of susceptible progeny in subsequent generations. Therefore, testing over several generations is required to determine the stability of resistance when breeding crops with transgenic virus resistance.     

Microarray-Based Identification of Differentially Expressed Genes in Families of Turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) After Infection with Viral Haemorrhagic Septicaemia Virus (VHSV)

Viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV) is one of the major threats to the development of the aquaculture industry worldwide. The present study was aimed to identify genes differentially expressed in several turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) families showing different mortality rates after VHSV. The expression analysis was conducted through genome-wide expression profiling with an oligo-microarray in the head kidney. A significant proportion of the variation in the gene expression profiles seemed to be explained by the genetic background, indicating that the mechanisms by which particular species and/or populations can resist a pathogen(s) are complex and multifactorial. Before the experimental infections, fish from resistant families (low mortality rates after VHSV infection) showed high expression of different antimicrobial peptides, suggesting that their pre-immune state may be stronger than fish of susceptible families (high mortality rates after VHSV infection). After infection, fish from both high- and low-mortality families showed an up-modulation of the interferon-induced Mx2 gene, the IL-8 gene and the VHSV-induced protein 5 gene compared with control groups. Low levels of several molecules secreted in the mucus were observed in high-mortality families, but different genes involved in viral entrance into target cells were down-regulated in low-mortality families. Moreover, these families also showed a strong down-modulation of marker genes related to VHSV target organs, including biochemical markers of renal dysfunction and myocardial injury. In general, the expression of different genes involved in the metabolism of sugars, lipids and proteins were decreased in both low- and high-mortality families after infection. The present study serves as an initial screen for genes of interest and provides an extensive overview of the genetic basis underlying the differences between families that are resistant or susceptible to VHSV infection.     

Bioluminescence imaging of live infected salmonids reveals that the fin bases are the major portal of entry for Novirhabdovirus

Although Novirhabdovirus viruses, like the Infectious hematopietic necrosis virus (IHNV), have been extensively studied, limited knowledge exists on the route of IHNV entry during natural infection. A recombinant IHNV (rIHNV) expressing the Renilla luciferase gene was generated and used to infect trout. A noninvasive bioluminescence assay was developed so that virus replication in live fish could be followed hours after infection. We provide here evidence that the fin bases are the portal of entry into the fish. Confirmation was brought by the use of a nonpathogenic rIHNV, which was shown to persist in fins for 3 weeks postinfection.     

Susceptibility of juvenile Atlantic cod Gadus morhua to viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus isolated from wild-caught Atlantic cod

A European strain of viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV) isolated from wild-caught cod Gadus morhua (H16/7/95) was shown to cause clinical disease and mortality in excess of 80% in juvenile Atlantic cod when administered by the intra-peritoneal (i.p.) route. No virus was recovered from cod cohabiting with experimentally infected fish at a ratio of 1:1, and no VHSV-associated mortality was demonstrated following immersion infection. External signs of disease in cod were the presence of exophthalmia and ascites. Virus was identified as VHSV by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and was recovered from both brain and organ pools (kidney, liver and spleen) of 100% of i.p. infected cod mortalities. Virus was also detected using an indirect immunofluorescence test on tissue imprints of kidney, liver, spleen and brain taken from moribund fish. The fact that cod were not susceptible to VHSV following waterborne exposure raises important questions surrounding the propagation, maintenance and impact of a naturally occurring reservoir of virus in the marine environment.