Melanocyte regeneration reveals mechanisms of adult stem cell regulation

Utilization of adult stem cells in regenerative therapies may require a thorough understanding of the mechanisms that establish, recruit and renew the stem cell, promote the differentiation of its daughters, or how the stem cell is repressed by its target tissue. Regeneration of melanocytes in the regenerating zebrafish caudal fin, or following larval melanocyte-specific ablation, or recruitment of new melanocytes during pigment pattern metamorphosis each provides evidence for melanocyte stem cells (MSCs) that support the melanocyte pigment pattern. We discuss the mechanisms of MSC regulation provided from analysis of normal or mutant regeneration in each of these systems, including the implications drawn from evidence that regeneration does not simply recapitulate ontogenetic development. These results suggest that analysis of melanocyte regeneration in zebrafish will provide a fine scale dissection of mechanisms establishing or regulating adult stem cells.     

pyewacket, a new zebrafish fin pigment pattern mutant

Many mutants that disrupt zebrafish embryonic pigment pattern have been isolated, and subsequent cloning of the mutated genes causing these phenotypes has contributed to our understanding of pigment cell development. However, few mutants have been identified that specifically affect development of the adult pigment pattern. Through a mutant screen for adult pigment pattern phenotypes, we identified pyewacket (pye), a novel zebrafish mutant in which development of the adult caudal fin pigment pattern is aberrant. Specifically, pye mutants have fin melanocyte pigment pattern defects and fewer xanthophores than wild-type fins. We mapped pye to an interval where a single gene, the zebrafish ortholog of the human gene DHRSX, is present. pye will be an informative mutant for understanding how xanthophores and melanocytes interact to form the pigment pattern of the adult zebrafish fin.     

Zebrafish sparse corresponds to an orthologue of c-kit and is required for the morphogenesis of a subpopulation of melanocytes, but is not essential for hematopoiesis or primordial germ cell development.

The relative roles of the Kit receptor in promoting the migration and survival of amniote melanocytes are unresolved. We show that, in the zebrafish, Danio rerio, the pigment pattern mutation sparse corresponds to an orthologue of c-kit. This finding allows us to further elucidate morphogenetic roles for this c-kit-related gene in melanocyte morphogenesis. Our analyses of zebrafish melanocyte development demonstrate that the c-kit orthologue identified in this study is required both for normal migration and for survival of embryonic melanocytes. We also find that, in contrast to mouse, the zebrafish c-kit gene that we have identified is not essential for hematopoiesis or primordial germ cell development. These unexpected differences may reflect evolutionary divergence in c-kit functions following gene duplication events in teleosts.     

A requirement for <Emphasis Type="Italic">kit</Emphasis> in embryonic zebrafish melanocyte differentiation is revealed by melanoblast delay

Exploring differences in gene requirements between species can allow us to delineate basic developmental mechanisms, provide insight into patterns of evolution, and explain heterochronic differences in developmental processes. One example of differences in gene requirements between zebrafish and mammals is the requirement of the kit receptor tyrosine kinase in melanocyte development. kit is required for migration, survival and differentiation of all neural crest-derived melanocytes in mammals. In contrast, zebrafish kit is not required for differentiation of embryonic melanocytes during normal development. When melanoblast development in zebrafish embryos is delayed by injecting morpholinos targeted to the mitfa gene, we show that these delayed melanoblasts fail to differentiate in kit mutants. Thus, we show that there is a kit requirement for melanocyte differentiation in zebrafish when melanoblast development is delayed. Furthermore, we show that kit is not involved in maintaining melanocyte precursors through the developmental delay, but instead is required for differentiation of melanocytes after the block on their development is removed. Finally, we suggest there is a heterochronic shift in the onset of melanocyte differentiation between fish and mouse, and developmental delay of melanoblast development in zebrafish removes this heterochronic difference.Edited by D. Tautz     

An orthologue of the kit-related gene fms is required for development of neural crest-derived xanthophores and a subpopulation of adult melanocytes in the zebrafish, Danio rerio

Developmental mechanisms underlying traits expressed in larval and adult vertebrates remain largely unknown. Pigment patterns of fishes provide an opportunity to identify genes and cell behaviors required for postembryonic morphogenesis and differentiation. In the zebrafish, Danio rerio, pigment patterns reflect the spatial arrangements of three classes of neural crest-derived pigment cells: black melanocytes, yellow xanthophores and silver iridophores. We show that the D. rerio pigment pattern mutant panther ablates xanthophores in embryos and adults and has defects in the development of the adult pattern of melanocyte stripes. We find that panther corresponds to an orthologue of the c-fms gene, which encodes a type III receptor tyrosine kinase and is the closest known homologue of the previously identified pigment pattern gene, kit. In mouse, fms is essential for the development of macrophage and osteoclast lineages and has not been implicated in neural crest or pigment cell development. In contrast, our analyses demonstrate that fms is expressed and required by D. rerio xanthophore precursors and that fms promotes the normal patterning of melanocyte death and migration during adult stripe formation. Finally, we show that fms is required for the appearance of a late developing, kit-independent subpopulation of adult melanocytes. These findings reveal an unexpected role for fms in pigment pattern development and demonstrate that parallel neural crest-derived pigment cell populations depend on the activities of two essentially paralogous genes, kit and fms.     

EDNRB/EDN3 and Hirschsprung Disease Type II

The study of vertebrate pigmentary anomalies has greatly improved our understanding of melanocyte biology. One such disorder, Waardenburg syndrome (WS), is a mendelian trait characterized by hypopigmentation and sensorineural deafness. It is commonly subdivided into four types (WS1–4), defined by the presence or absence of additional symptoms. WS type 4 (WS4), or Shah‐Waardenburg syndrome, is also known as Hirschsprung disease Type II (HSCR II) and is characterized by an absence of epidermal melanocytes and enteric ganglia. Mutations in the genes encoding the endothelin type‐B receptor (EDNRB) and its physiological ligand endothelin 3 (EDN3) are now known to account for the majority of HSCR II patients. Null mutations in the mouse genes Ednrb and Edn3 have identified a key role for this pathway in the normal development of melanocytes and other neural crest‐derived lineages. The pleiotropic effects of genes in this pathway, on melanocyte and enteric neuron development, have been clarified by the embryologic identification of their common neural crest (NC) ancestry. EDNRB and EDN3 are transiently expressed in crest‐derived melanoblast and neuroblast precursors, and in the surrounding mesenchymal cells, respectively. The influence of EDNRB‐mediated signaling on the emigration, migration, proliferation, and differentiation of melanocyte and enteric neuron precursors, in vivo and in vitro has recently been the subject of great scrutiny. A major emergent theme is that EDN3‐induced signaling prevents the premature differentiation of melanocyte and enteric nervous system precursors and is essential between 10 and 12.5 days post‐coitum. We review the present understanding of pigment cell development in the context of EDNRB/EDN3 – a receptor‐mediated pathway with pleiotropic effects.     

Lineage relationship of direct-developing melanocytes and melanocyte stem cells in the zebrafish

Previous research in zebrafish has demonstrated that embryonic and larval regeneration melanocytes are derived from separate lineages. The embryonic melanocytes that establish the larval pigment pattern do not require regulative melanocyte stem cell (MSC) precursors, and are termed direct-developing melanocytes. In contrast, the larval regeneration melanocytes that restore the pigment pattern after ablation develop from MSC precursors. Here, we explore whether embryonic melanocytes and MSCs share bipotent progenitors. Furthermore, we explore when fate segregation of embryonic melanocytes and MSCs occurs in zebrafish development. In order to achieve this, we develop and apply a novel lineage tracing method. We first demonstrate that Tol2-mediated genomic integration of reporter constructs from plasmids injected at the 1-2 cell stage occurs most frequently after the midblastula transition but prior to shield stage, between 3 and 6 hours post-fertilization. This previously uncharacterized timing of Tol2-mediated genomic integration establishes Tol2-mediated transposition as a means for conducting lineage tracing in zebrafish. Combining the Tol2-mediated lineage tracing strategy with a melanocyte regeneration assay previously developed in our lab, we find that embryonic melanocytes and larval regeneration melanocytes are derived from progenitors that contribute to both lineages. We estimate 50-60 such bipotent melanogenic progenitors to be present in the shield-stage embryo. Furthermore, our examination of direct-developing and MSC-restricted lineages suggests that these are segregated from bipotent precursors after the shield stage, but prior to the end of convergence and extension. Following this early fate segregation, we estimate approximately 100 embryonic melanocyte and 90 MSC-restricted lineages are generated to establish or regenerate the zebrafish larval pigment pattern, respectively. Thus, the dual strategies of direct-development and MSC-derived development are established in the early gastrula, via fate segregation of the two lineages.     

Characterisation of Fmrp in zebrafish: evolutionary dynamics of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">fmr1</Emphasis> gene

Fragile X syndrome is the most common inherited form of mental retardation. It is caused by the lack of the Fragile X Mental Retardation Protein (FMRP), which is encoded by the FMR1 gene. Although Fmr1 knockout mice display some characteristics also found in fragile X patients, it is a complex animal model to study brain abnormalities, especially during early embryonic development. Interestingly, the ortholog of the FMR1 gene has been identified not only in mouse, but also in zebrafish (Danio rerio). In this study, an amino acid sequence comparison of FMRP orthologs was performed to determine the similar regions of FMRP between several species, including human, mouse, frog, fruitfly and zebrafish. Further characterisation of Fmrp has been performed in both adults and embryos of zebrafish using immunohistochemistry and western blotting with specific antibodies raised against zebrafish Fmrp. We have demonstrated a strong Fmrp expression in neurons of the brain and only a very weak expression in the testis. In brain tissue, a different distribution of the isoforms of Fmrp, compared to human and mouse brain tissue, was shown using western blot analysis. Due to the high similarity between zebrafish Fmrp and human FMRP and their similar expression pattern, the zebrafish has great potential as a complementary animal model to study the pathogenesis of the fragile X syndrome, especially during embryonic development.Edited by D. Tautz     

Functional genomics tools for the analysis of zebrafish pigment

Genetic model organisms are increasingly valuable in the post-genomics era to provide a basis for comparative analysis of the human genome. For higher order processes of vertebrate pigment cell biology and development, the mouse has historically been the model of choice. A complementary organism, the zebrafish (Danio rerio), shares many of the signaling and biological processes of vertebrates, e.g. neural crest development. The zebrafish has a number of characteristics that make it an especially valuable model for the study of pigment cell biology and disease. Large-scale genetic screens have identified a collection of pigmentation mutants that have already made valuable contributions to pigment research. An increasing repertoire of genomic resources such as an expressed sequence tag-based Gene Index (The Institute for Genomic Research) and improving methods of mutagenesis, transgenesis, and gene targeting make zebrafish a particularly attractive model. Morpholino phosphorodiamidate oligonucleotide (MO) 'knockdown' of pigment gene expression provides a non-conventional antisense tool for the analysis of genes involved in pigment cell biology and disease. In addition, an ongoing, reverse-genetic, MO-based screen for the rapid identification of gene function promises to be a valuable complement to other high-throughput microarray and proteomic approaches for understanding pigment cell biology. Novel reagents for zebrafish transgenesis, such as the Sleeping Beauty transposon system, continue to improve the capacity for genetic analysis in this system and ensure that the zebrafish will be a valuable genetic model for understanding a variety of biological processes and human diseases for years to come.     

Small molecule screening identifies targetable zebrafish pigmentation pathways

Small molecules complement genetic mutants and can be used to probe pigment cell biology by inhibiting specific proteins or pathways. Here, we present the results of a screen of active compounds for those that affect the processes of melanocyte and iridophore development in zebrafish and investigate the effects of a few of these compounds in further detail. We identified and confirmed 57 compounds that altered pigment cell patterning, number, survival, or differentiation. Additional tissue targets and toxicity of small molecules are also discussed. Given that the majority of cell types, including pigment cells, are conserved between zebrafish and other vertebrates, we present these chemicals as molecular tools to study developmental processes of pigment cells in living animals and emphasize the value of zebrafish as an in vivo system for testing the on- and off-target activities of clinically active drugs.     

A new transgenic mouse line for tetracycline inducible transgene expression in mature melanocytes and the melanocyte stem cells using the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Dopachrome tautomerase</Emphasis> promoter

We have generated a novel transgenic mouse to direct inducible and reversible transgene expression in the melanocytic compartment. The Dopachrome tautomerase (Dct) control sequences we used are active early in the development of melanocytes and so this system was designed to enable the manipulation of transgene expression during development in utero and in the melanocyte stem cells as well as mature melanocytes. We observed inducible lacZ and GFP reporter transgene activity specifically in melanocytes and melanocyte stem cells in mouse skin. This mouse model will be a useful tool for the pigment cell community to investigate the contribution of candidate genes to normal melanocyte and/or melanoma development in vivo. Deregulated expression of the proto-oncogene MYC has been observed in melanoma, however whether MYC is involved in tumorigenesis in pigment cells has yet to be directly investigated in vivo. We have used our system to over-express MYC in the melanocytic compartment and show for the first time that increased MYC expression can indeed promote melanocytic tumor formation.     

Stripes and belly-spots -- a review of pigment cell morphogenesis in vertebrates

Pigment patterns in the integument have long-attracted attention from both scientists and non-scientists alike since their natural attractiveness combines with their excellence as models for the general problem of pattern formation. Pigment cells are formed from the neural crest and must migrate to reach their final locations. In this review, we focus on our current understanding of mechanisms underlying the control of pigment cell migration and patterning in diverse vertebrates. The model systems discussed here - chick, mouse, and zebrafish - each provide unique insights into the major morphogenetic events driving pigment pattern formation. In birds and mammals, melanoblasts must be specified before they can migrate on the dorsolateral pathway. Transmembrane receptors involved in guiding them onto this route include EphB2 and Ednrb2 in chick, and Kit in mouse. Terminal migration depends, in part, upon extracellular matrix reorganization by ADAMTS20. Invasion of the ectoderm, especially into the feather germ and hair follicles, requires specific signals that are beginning to be characterized. We summarize our current understanding of the mechanisms regulating melanoblast number and organization in the epidermis. We note the apparent differences in pigment pattern formation in poikilothermic vertebrates when compared with birds and mammals. With more pigment cell types, migration pathways are more complex and largely unexplored; nevertheless, a role for Kit signaling in melanophore migration is clear and indicates that at least some patterning mechanisms may be highly conserved. We summarize the multiple factors thought to contribute to zebrafish embryonic pigment pattern formation, highlighting a recent study identifying Sdf1a as one factor crucial for regulation of melanophore positioning. Finally, we discuss the mechanisms generating a second, metamorphic pigment pattern in adult fish, emphasizing recent studies strengthening the evidence that undifferentiated progenitor cells play a major role in generating adult pigment cells.     

Genetics and evolution of pigment patterns in fish

Vertebrate pigment patterns are both beautiful and fascinating. In mammals and birds, pigment patterns are likely to reflect the spatial regulation of melanocyte physiology, via alteration of the colour-type of the melanin synthesized. In fish, however, pigment patterns predominantly result from positioning of differently coloured chromatophores. Theoretically, pigment cell patterning might result from long-range patterning mechanisms, from local environmental cues, or from interactions between neighbouring chromatophores. Recent studies in two fish genetic model systems have made progress in understanding pigment pattern formation. In embryos, the limited evidence to date implicates local cues and chromatophore interactions in pigment patterning. In adults, de novo generation of chromatophores and cell-cell interactions between chromatophore types play critical roles in generating striped patterns; orientation of the stripes may well depend upon environmental cues mediated by underlying tissues. Further genetic screens, coupled with the routine characterization of critical gene products, promises a quantitative understanding of how striped patterns are generated in the zebrafish system. Initial 'evo-devo' studies indicate how fish pigment patterns may evolve and will become more complete as the developmental genetics is integrated with theoretical modelling.     

GABA‐A receptor and mitochondrial TSPO signaling act in parallel to regulate melanocyte stem cell quiescence in larval zebrafish

Tissue regeneration and homeostasis often require recruitment of undifferentiated precursors (adult stem cells; ASCs). While many ASCs continuously proliferate throughout the lifetime of an organism, others are recruited from a quiescent state to replenish their target tissue. A long‐standing question in stem cell biology concerns how long‐lived, non‐dividing ASCs regulate the transition between quiescence and proliferation. We study the melanocyte stem cell (MSC) to investigate the molecular pathways that regulate ASC quiescence. Our prior work indicated that GABA‐A receptor activation promotes MSC quiescence in larval zebrafish. Here, through pharmacological and genetic approaches we show that GABA‐A acts through calcium signaling to maintain MSC quiescence. Unexpectedly, we identified translocator protein (TSPO), a mitochondrial membrane‐associated protein that regulates mitochondrial function and metabolic homeostasis, as a parallel regulator of MSC quiescence. We found that both TSPO‐specific ligands and induction of gluconeogenesis likely act in the same pathway to promote MSC activation and melanocyte production in larval zebrafish. In contrast, TSPO and gluconeogenesis appear to act in parallel to GABA‐A receptor signaling to regulate MSC quiescence and vertebrate pigment patterning.     

Mutational analysis of endothelin receptor b1 (rose) during neural crest and pigment pattern development in the zebrafish Danio rerio

Pigment patterns of fishes are a tractable system for studying the genetic and cellular bases for postembryonic phenotypes. In the zebrafish Danio rerio, neural crest-derived pigment cells generate different pigment patterns during different phases of the life cycle. Whereas early larvae exhibit simple stripes of melanocytes and silver iridophores in a background of yellow xanthophores, this pigment pattern is transformed at metamorphosis into that of the adult, comprising a series of dark melanocyte and iridophore stripes, alternating with light stripes of iridophores and xanthophores. Although several genes have been identified in D. rerio that contribute to the development of both early larval and adult pigment patterns, comparatively little is known about genes that are essential for pattern formation during just one or the other life cycle phase. In this study, we identify the gene responsible for the rose mutant phenotype in D. rerio. rose mutants have wild-type early larval pigment patterns, but fail to develop normal numbers of melanocytes and iridophores during pigment pattern metamorphosis and exhibit a disrupted pattern of these cells. We show that rose corresponds to endothelin receptor b1 (ednrb1), an orthologue of amniote Ednrb genes that have long been studied for their roles in neural crest and pigment cell development. Furthermore, we demonstrate that D. rerio ednrb1 is expressed both during pigment pattern metamorphosis and during embryogenesis, and cells of melanocyte, iridophore, and xanthophore lineages all express this gene. These analyses suggest a phylogenetic conservation of roles for Ednrb signaling in the development of amniote and teleost pigment cell precursors. As murine Ednrb is essential for the development of all neural crest derived melanocytes, and D. rerio ednrb1 is required only by a subset of adult melanocytes and iridophores, these analyses also reveal variation among vertebrates in the cellular requirements for Ednrb signaling, and suggest alternative models for the cellular and genetic bases of pigment pattern metamorphosis in D. rerio.     

EDNRB/EDN3 and Hirschsprung disease type II.

The study of vertebrate pigmentary anomalies has greatly improved our understanding of melanocyte biology. One such disorder, Waardenburg syndrome (WS), is a mendelian trait characterized by hypopigmentation and sensorineural deafness. It is commonly subdivided into four types (WS1-4), defined by the presence or absence of additional symptoms. WS type 4 (WS4), or Shah-Waardenburg syndrome, is also known as Hirschsprung disease Type II (HSCR II) and is characterized by an absence of epidermal melanocytes and enteric ganglia. Mutations in the genes encoding the endothelin type-B receptor (EDNRB) and its physiological ligand endothelin 3 (EDN3) are now known to account for the majority of HSCR II patients. Null mutations in the mouse genes Ednrb and Edn3 have identified a key role for this pathway in the normal development of melanocytes and other neural crest-derived lineages. The pleiotropic effects of genes in this pathway, on melanocyte and enteric neuron development, have been clarified by the embryologic identification of their common neural crest (NC) ancestry. EDNRB and EDN3 are transiently expressed in crest-derived melanoblast and neuroblast precursors, and in the surrounding mesenchymal cells, respectively. The influence of EDNRB-mediated signaling on the emigration, migration, proliferation, and differentiation of melanocyte and enteric neuron precursors, in vivo and in vitro has recently been the subject of great scrutiny. A major emergent theme is that EDN3-induced signaling prevents the premature differentiation of melanocyte and enteric nervous system precursors and is essential between 10 and 12.5 days post-coitum. We review the present understanding of pigment cell development in the context of EDNRB/EDN3--a receptor-mediated pathway with pleiotropic effects.     

The interaction of epithelial Ihha and mesenchymal Fgf10 in zebrafish esophageal and swimbladder development

Developmental patterning and growth of the vertebrate digestive and respiratory tracts requires interactions between the epithelial endoderm and adjacent mesoderm. The esophagus is a specialized structure that connects the digestive and respiratory systems and its normal development is critical for both. Shh signaling from the epithelium regulates related aspects of mammalian and zebrafish digestive organ development and has a prominent effect on esophageal morphogenesis. The mechanisms underlying esophageal malformations, however, are poorly understood. Here, we show that zebrafish Ihha signaling from the epithelium acting in parallel, but independently of Shh, controls epithelial and mesenchymal cell proliferation and differentiation of smooth muscles and neurons in the gut and swimbladder. In zebrafish ihha mutants, the esophageal and swimbladder epithelium is dysmorphic, and expression of fgf10 in adjacent mesenchymal cells is affected. Analysis of the development of the esophagus and swimbladder in fgf10 mutant daedalus (dae) and compound dae/ihha mutants shows that the Ihha–Fgf10 regulatory interaction is realized through a signaling feedback loop between the Ihha-expressing epithelium and Fgf10-expressing mesenchyme. Disruption of this loop further affects the esophageal and swimbladder epithelium in ihha mutants, and Ihha acts in parallel to but independently of Shha in this process. These findings contribute to the understanding of epithelial–mesenchymal interactions and highlight an interaction between Hh and Fgf signaling pathways during esophagus and swimbladder development.     

Differential contribution of direct-developing and stem cell-derived melanocytes to the zebrafish larval pigment pattern

The extent of adult stem cell involvement in embryonic growth is often unclear, as reliable markers or assays for whether a cell is derived from an adult stem cell, such as the melanocyte stem cell (MSC), are typically not available. We have previously shown that two lineages of melanocytes can contribute to the larval zebrafish pigment pattern. The embryo first develops an ontogenetic pattern that is largely composed of ErbB-independent, direct-developing melanocytes. This population can be replaced during regeneration by an ErbB-dependent MSC-derived population following melanocyte ablation. In this study, we developed a melanocyte differentiation assay used together with drugs that ablate the MSC to investigate whether MSC-derived melanocytes contribute to the ontogenetic pattern. We found that essentially all melanocytes that develop before 3 dpf arise from the ErbB-independent, direct-developing population. Similarly, late-developing (after 3 dpf) melanocytes of the head are also ErbB independent. In contrast, the melanocytes that develop after 3 days postfertilization in the lateral and dorsal stripe are sensitive to ErbB inhibitor, indicating that they are derived from the MSC. We show that melanocyte regeneration mutants kit^j1e99 and skiv2l2^j24e1 that are grossly normal for the overall ontogenetic pattern also lack the MSC-derived contribution to the lateral stripe. This result suggests that the underlying regeneration defect of these mutations is a defect in MSC regulation. We suggest that the regulative functions of the MSC may serve quality control roles during larval development, in addition to its established roles in larval regeneration and growth and homeostasis in the adult.     

Rhythmic patterns in phagocytosis and the production of reactive oxygen species by zebrafish leukocytes

Multiple components of vertebrate immune systems have been shown to exhibit circadian fluctuations. While the zebrafish is currently generating a wealth of information on the molecular pacemakers that may control circadian rhythms, there have been no reports of rhythmic activity in zebrafish leukocytes. In this study, we found that phagocytosis and the production of reactive oxygen species by zebrafish leukocytes varied significantly throughout twenty-four hour periods. A distinct peak in cellular ROS levels occurred before dawn, while the kinetics of respiratory burst responses were least rapid at this time of day. Phagocytosis of E. coli peaked late in the day, whereas there was no daily variation in phagocytosis of S. aureus. As seen in other species, the number of bacteria ingested per cell peaked during the night. These data provide direct evidence of rhythmic immune system activity, and demonstrate that zebrafish can be a valuable model in which to study the relationships between circadian gene expression, systemic pacemakers, and the activity of vertebrate immune system cells.     

Developmental stage‐dependent switching in the neuromodulation of vertebrate locomotor central pattern generator networks

Neuromodulation plays important and stage‐dependent roles in regulating locomotor central pattern (CPG) outputs during vertebrate motor system development. Dopamine, serotonin and nitric oxide are three neuromodulators that potently influence CPG outputs in the development of Xenopus frog tadpole locomotion. However, their roles switch from predominantly inhibitory early in development to mainly excitatory at later stages. In this review, we compare the stage‐dependent switching in neuromodulation in Xenopus with other vertebrate systems, notably the mouse and the zebrafish, and highlight features that appear to be phylogenetically conserved.