psbA based molecular analysis of cross-feeding experiments suggests that Dinophysis acuta does not harbour permanent plastids

Toxic marine dinoflagellate species of the genus Dinophysis Ehrenberg are obligate mixotrophs that require feeding on the ciliate Mesodinium rubrum and light to achieve growth. It is now well known that they harbour plastids of cryptophyte origin, particularly of the genus Teleaulax, Plagioselmis or Geminigera group (TPG clade). Nevertheless, whether these plastids are permanent, or periodically acquired from M. rubrum prey, need additional studies in different phototrophic Dinophysis species. The origin of plastids from Dinophysis acuta Ehrenberg, one of the main agents of diarrhetic shellfish poisoning (DSP) outbreaks in Western Europe, was investigated here. Cross feeding-starvation experiments were carried out with cultures of D. acuta using M. rubrum as prey, the latter fed with two cryptophyte species, Teleaulax amphioxeia Hill and Teleaulax gracilis, belonging to the TPG clade in addition to Falcomonas sp. and Hemiselmis sp. The fate of cryptophyte plastids transferred to D. acuta through its ciliate prey was investigated using the plastid psbA gene as a tracer.     

Mass entrapment and lysis of Mesodinium rubrum cells in mucus threads observed in cultures with Dinophysis

The entrapment and death of the ciliate Mesodinium rubrum in the mucus threads in cultures with Dinophysis is described and quantified. Feeding experiments with different concentrations and predator–prey ratios of Dinophysis acuta, Dinophysis acuminata and M. rubrum to study the motility loss and aggregate formation of the ciliates and the feeding behaviour of Dinophysis were carried out. In cultures of either Dinophysis species, the ciliates became entrapped in the mucus, which led to the formation of immobile aggregates of M. rubrum and subsequent cell lysis. The proportion of entrapped ciliates was influenced by the concentration of Dinophysis and the ratio of predator and prey in the cultures. At high cell concentrations of prey (136 cells mL⁻¹) and predator (100 cells mL⁻¹), a maximum of 17% of M. rubrum cells became immobile and went through cell lysis. Ciliates were observed trapped in the mucus even when a single D. acuminata cell was present in a 3.4 mL growth medium. Both Dinophysis species were able to detect immobile or partly immobile ciliates at a distance and circled around the prey prior to the capture with a stretched out peduncle. Relatively high entrapment and lysis of M. rubrum cells in the mucus threads indicates that under certain conditions Dinophysis might have a considerable impact on the population of M. rubrum.     

Harmful effects of Dinophysis to the ciliate Mesodinium rubrum: Implications for prey capture

Toxigenic Dinophysis spp. are obligate mixotrophic dinoflagellates that require a constant supply of prey—Mesodinium rubrum—to achieve long-term growth by means of kleptoplasty. Mesodinium rubrum is, however, a fast moving, jumping ciliate exhibiting an effective escape response from suspensivorous predators. In the present study, a series of laboratory experiments evaluating the motility and survival of M. rubrum in the presence of Dinophysis cells and/or substances contained in their culture medium was designed, in order to assess the mechanisms involved in prey capture by Dinophysis spp. Cell abundance of M. rubrum decreased in the presence of Dinophysis cf. ovum cells producing okadaic acid (OA; up to 7.94 ± 2.67 pg cell⁻¹) and smaller amounts of dinophysistoxin-1 (DTX-1) and pectenotoxin-2 (PTX-2). Prey capture was often observed after the ciliate had been attached to adhesive “mucus traps”, which only appeared in the presence of Dinophysis cells. Before being attached to the mucus traps, M. rubrum cells reduced significantly their swimming frequency (from ∼41 to 19 ± 3 jumps min⁻¹) after only 4 h of initial contact with D. cf. ovum cells. M. rubrum survival was not affected in contact with purified OA, DTX-1 and PTX-2 solutions, but decreased significantly when the ciliate was exposed to cell-free or filtered culture medium from both D. cf. ovum and D. caudata, the latter containing moderate concentrations of free eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid. The results thus indicate that Dinophysis combines the release of toxic compounds other than shellfish toxins, possibly free PUFAs, and a “mucus trap” to enhance its prey capture success by immobilizing and subsequently arresting M. rubrum cells.     

The fate of cryptophyte cell organelles in the ciliate Mesodinium cf. rubrum subjected to starvation

Mesodinium rubrum Lohmann is a mixotrophic ciliate and one of the best studied species exhibiting acquired phototrophy. To investigate the fate of cryptophyte organelles in the ciliate subjected to starvation, we conducted ultrastructural studies of a Korean strain of M. cf. rubrum during a 10 week starvation experiments. Ingested cells of the cryptophyte Teleaulax amphioxeia were first enveloped by ciliate membrane, and then prey organelles, including ejectisomes, flagella, basal bodies and flagellar roots, were digested. Over time, prey nuclei protruded into the cytoplasm of the ciliate, their size and volume increased, and their number decreased, suggesting that the cryptophyte nuclei likely fused with each other in the ciliate cytoplasm. At 4 weeks of starvation, M. cf. rubrum cells without cryptophyte nuclei started to appear. At 10 weeks of starvation, only two M. cf. rubrum cells still possessing a cryptophyte nucleus had relatively intact chloroplast-mitochondria complexes (CMCs), while M. cf. rubrum cells without cryptophyte nuclei had a few damaged CMCs. This is the first ultrastructural study demonstrating that cryptophyte nuclei undergo a dramatic change inside M. cf. rubrum in terms of size, shape, and number following their acquisition.     

Fate of green plastids in Dinophysis caudata following ingestion of the benthic ciliate Mesodinium coatsi: Ultrastructure and psbA gene

Phototrophic Dinophysis species are known to acquire plastids of the cryptophyte Teleaulax amphioxeia through feeding on the ciliate Mesodinium rubrum or M. cf. rubrum. In addition, several molecular studies have detected plastid encoding genes of various algal taxa within field populations of Dinophysis species. The trophic pathway by which Dinophysis species acquire plastids from algae other than the cryptophyte genus Teleaulax, however, is unknown. In this study, we examined the fate of prey organelles and plastid genes obtained by Dinophysis caudata through ingestion of Mesodinium coatsi, a benthic ciliate that retains green plastids of Chroomonas sp. Transmission electron microscopy and molecular analysis revealed relatively rapid digestion of prey-derived plastids. Following digestion of M. coatsi, however, photodamaged D. caudata cells having olive-green rather than reddish-brown plastids were able to recover some of their original reddish-brown pigmentation. Results further suggest that plastid genes of various algal taxa detected in field populations of Dinophysis species may reflect prey diversity rather than sequestration of multiple plastid types. Ingestion and digestion of prey other than M. rubrum or M. cf. rubrum may also provide nutritional requirements needed to repair and perhaps maintain sequestered T. amphioxeia plastids.     

Production and excretion of okadaic acid,pectenotoxin-2 and a novel dinophysistoxin from the DSP-causing marine dinoflagellate Dinophysis acuta – Effects of light,food availability and growth phase

Diarrhetic shellfish poisoning (DSP) toxins constitute a severe economic threat to shellfish industries and a major food safety issue for shellfish consumers. The prime producers of the DSP toxins that end up in filter feeding shellfish are species of the marine mixotrophic dinoflagellate genus Dinophysis. Intraspecific toxin contents of Dinophysis spp. vary a lot, but the regulating factors of toxin content are still poorly understood. Dinophysis spp. have been shown to sequester and use chloroplasts from their ciliate prey, and with this rare mode of nutrition, irradiance and food availability could play a key role in the regulation of toxins contents and production. We investigated toxin contents, production and excretion of a Dinophysis acuta culture under different irradiances, food availabilities and growth phases. The newly isolated strain of D. acuta contained okadaic acid (OA), pectenotoxins-2 (PTX-2) and a novel dinophysistoxin (DTX) that we tentatively describe as DTX-1b isomer. We found that all three toxins were excreted to the surrounding seawater, and for OA and DTX-1b as much as 90% could be found in extracellular toxin pools. For PTX-2 somewhat less was excreted, but often >50% was found extracellularly. This was the case both in steady-state exponential growth and in food limited, stationary growth, and we emphasize the need to include extracellular toxins in future studies of DSP toxins. Cellular toxin contents were largely unaffected by irradiance, but toxins accumulated both intra- and extracellularly when starvation reduced growth rates of D. acuta. Toxin production rates were highest during exponential growth, but continued at decreased rates when cell division ceased, indicating that toxin production is not directly associated with ingestion of prey. Finally, we explore the potential of these new discoveries to shed light on the ecological role of DSP toxins.     

Environmental control of harmful dinoflagellates and diatoms in a fjordic system

Fjordic coastlines provide an ideal protected environment for both finfish and shellfish aquaculture operations. This study reports the results of a cruise to the Scottish Clyde Sea, and associated fjordic sea lochs, that coincided with blooms of the diarrhetic shellfish toxin producing dinoflagellate Dinophysis acuta and the diatom genus Chaetoceros, that can generate finfish mortalities. Unusually, D. acuta reached one order of magnitude higher cell abundance in the water column (2840 cells L⁻¹) than the more common Dinophysis acuminata (200 cells L⁻¹) and was linked with elevated shellfish toxicity (maximum 601 ± 237 μg OA eq/kg shellfish flesh) which caused shellfish harvesting closures in the region. Significant correlations between D. acuta abundance and that of Mesodinium rubrum were also observed across the cruise transect potentially supporting bloom formation of the mixotrophic D. acuta. Significant spatial variability in phytoplankton that was related to physical characteristics of the water column was observed, with a temperature-driven frontal region at the mouth of Loch Fyne being important in the development of the D. acuta, but not the Chaetoceros bloom. The front also provided important protection to the aquaculture located within the loch, with neither of the blooms encroaching within it. Analysis based on a particle-tracking model confirms the importance of the front to cell transport and shows significant inter-annual differences in advection within the region, that are important to the harmful algal bloom risk therein.     

Overwintering populations of Mesodinium rubrum (Ciliophora: Haptorida) in lakes of the Vestfold Hills, East Antarctica

 The autotrophic ciliate Mesodinium rubrum Lohmann was observed during winter and spring in saline lakes ranging in salinity from 2 to 78‰ in the Vestfold Hills, Antarctica. The ciliate remained active during winter, and contained chlorophyll even though the level of light available for photosynthesis was minimal. No evidence of encystment as a means of survival during winter was observed. A seasonal study in one of the lakes, Ace Lake, revealed that M. rubrum was present throughout the year at abundances ranging from 1×10⁴ to 3.5×10⁵ cells l^-1. During the winter period, when little light penetrated the lake’s ice cover, cells were most common immediately under the ice at 2 m, where cell numbers were typically 8×10⁴ cells l^-1. Received: 3 January 1996/Accepted: 21 April 1996     

Feeding characteristics and molecular phylogeny of the thecate mixotrophic dinoflagellate Fragilidium mexicanum

Prey spectrum and feeding process of the mixotrophic thecate dinoflagellate Fragilidium mexicanum strain Fm-LOHABE01 were examined using a culture isolated from Masan Bay, Korea in 2011 during a summer bloom of the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium pacificum. The novel 18S and 28S rDNA sequences for F. mexicanum were also used to explore inter-species relationships within the genus Fragilidium. The F. mexicanum fed on species belonging to four dinoflagellate genera (i.e., Alexandrium, Ceratium, Heterocapsa, and Scrippsiella) when separately offered a variety of prey, including dinoflagellates, raphidophytes, cryptophytes, and a ciliate. In addition, F. mexicanum displayed different levels of feeding frequency for prey species of Alexandrium. While F. mexicanum consistently fed on A. catenella and A. pacificum, feeding on A. affine was rarely observed. The F. mexicanum ingested prey by direct engulfment through the sulcus, after capturing the prey by a tow filament. Phylogenetic analyses of 18S and 28S rDNA datasets demonstrated that Fragilidium sequences formed a monophyletic group with high statistical supports and diverged into four distinct clades. The F. mexicanum formed a separate clade with Fragilidium sp. EUSK D from Angola and Korean isolate of F. fissile with very strong supports.     

Acquired phototrophy in Mesodinium and Dinophysis – A review of cellular organization,prey selectivity,nutrient uptake and bioenergetics

Acquired phototrophy, i.e. the use of chloroplasts from ingested prey, can be found among some species of dinoflagellates and ciliates. The best studied examples of this phenomenon in these groups are within the ciliate genus Mesodinium and the dinoflagellate genus Dinophysis, both ecologically important genera with a worldwide distribution. Mesodinium species differ considerably in their carbon metabolism. Some species rely almost exclusively on food uptake, while other species rely mostly on photosynthesis. In Mesodinium with acquired phototrophy, a number of prey organelles in addition to chloroplasts may be retained, and the host ciliate has considerable control over the acquired chloroplasts; Mesodinium rubrum is capable of dividing its acquired chloroplasts and can also photoacclimate. In Dinophysis spp., the contents of ciliate prey are sucked out, but only the chloroplasts are retained from the ingested prey. Some chloroplast house-keeping genes have been found in the nucleus of Dinophysis and some preliminary evidence suggests that Dinophysis may be capable for photoacclimation. Both genera have been claimed to take up inorganic nutrients, including NO₃⁻, indicating that processes beyond photosynthesis have been acquired. M. rubrum seems to depend upon prey species within the Teleaulax/Plagioselmis/Geminigera clade of marine cryptophytes. Up until now, Dinophysis species have only been maintained cultured on M. rubrum as food, but other ciliates may also be ingested. Dinophysis spp. and M. rubrum are obligate mixotrophs, depending upon both prey and light for sustained growth. However, while M. rubrum only needs to ingest 1–2% of its carbon demand per day to attain maximum growth, Dinophysis spp. need to obtain about half of their carbon demand from ingestion for maximum growth. Both Mesodinium and Dinophysis spp. can survive for months in the light without food. The potential role for modeling in exploring the complex balance of phototrophy and phago-heterotrophy, and its ecological implications for the mixotroph and their prey, is discussed.     

A Dinoflagellate Amylax triacantha with Plastids of the Cryptophyte Origin: Phylogeny,Feeding Mechanism,and Growth and Grazing Responses

The gonyaulacalean dinoflagellates Amylax spp. were recently found to contain plastids of the cryptophyte origin, more specifically of Teleaulax amphioxeia. However, not only how the dinoflagellates get the plastids of the cryptophyte origin is unknown but also their ecophysiology, including growth and feeding responses as functions of both light and prey concentration, remain unknown. Here, we report the establishment of Amylax triacantha in culture, its feeding mechanism, and its growth rate using the ciliate prey Mesodinium rubrum (= Myrionecta rubra) in light and dark, and growth and grazing responses to prey concentration and light intensity. The strain established in culture in this study was assigned to A. triacantha, based on morphological characteristics (particularly, a prominent apical horn and three antapical spines) and nuclear SSU and LSU rDNA sequences. Amylax triacantha grew well in laboratory culture when supplied with the marine mixotrophic ciliate M. rubrum as prey, reaching densities of over 7.5 × 10³ cells/ml. Amylax triacantha captured its prey using a tow filament, and then ingested the whole prey by direct engulfment through the sulcus. The dinoflagellate was able to grow heterotrophically in the dark, but the growth rate was approximately two times lower than in the light. Although mixotrophic growth rates of A. triacantha increased sharply with mean prey concentrations, with maximum growth rate being 0.68/d, phototrophic growth (i.e. growth in the absence of prey) was ?0.08/d. The maximum ingestion rate was 2.54 ng C/Amylax/d (5.9 cells/Amylax/d). Growth rate also increased with increasing light intensity, but the effect was evident only when prey was supplied. Increased growth with increasing light intensity was accompanied by a corresponding increase in ingestion. In mixed cultures of two predators, A. triacantha and Dinophysis acuminata, with M. rubrum as prey, A. triacantha outgrew D. acuminata due to its approximately three times higher growth rate, suggesting that it can outcompete D. acuminata. Our results would help better understand the ecophysiology of dinoflagellates retaining foreign plastids.     

Toxic mucus traps: A novel mechanism that mediates prey uptake in the mixotrophic dinoflagellate Alexandrium pseudogonyaulax

The functional role of harmful substances (i.e. toxins) produced by marine planktonic algae is still, in many cases, unknown. This study describes a novel mechanism by which the phototrophic dinoflagellate Alexandrium pseudogonyaulax secretes a toxic mucus trap where prey items are caught and immobilized prior to ingestion. Prey cells remain entrapped and immobile in the mucus trap, but most stay intact, readily available as whole-cell prey. It is shown that food uptake by A. pseudogonyaulax increases its growth rate considerably even in nutrient-replete, high-light conditions. The increase in growth rate was more enhanced in light-limited treatments and A. pseudogonyaulax grew significantly faster when fed Heterocapsa rotundata, than when fed Teleaulax acuta under both light conditions. For comparison, strains of Alexandrium catenella and Alexandrium minutum were studied for their mixotrophic capabilities. None of these strains were mixotrophic under the conditions provided. In addition, the toxic effects on various protistan targets of these Alexandrium strains as well as Alexandrium tamarense and Alexandrium ostenfeldii were compared to that of A. pseudogonyaulax. A. tamarense and A. catenella did immobilize and lyse target cells through substances leaked directly into the water, differing from all the strains of A. pseudogonyaulax studied. Results show that the toxic effect of A. pseudogonyaulax is non-specific causing nearly 100% immobilization of a variety of protistan targets at relatively low cell concentrations (500 cells ml⁻¹ of donor cell). A critical donor cell density was not required as only one A. pseudogonyaulax cell was able to cause immobilization of target cells. For the first time, the connection between excreted toxins and phagotrophy is evident in an Alexandrium species and this particular strategy has the potential to severely impact competing phytoplankton communities.     

The Effect of Starvation on Plastid Number and Photosynthetic Performance in the Kleptoplastidic Dinoflagellate Amylax triacantha

The dinoflagellate Amylax triacantha is known to retain plastids of cryptophyte origin by engulfing the mixotrophic ciliate Mesodinium rubrum, itself a consumer of cryptophytes. However, there is no information on the fate of the prey's organelles and the photosynthetic performance of the newly retained plastids in A. triacantha. In this study, we conducted a starvation experiment to observe the intracellular organization of the prey's organelles and temporal changes in the photosynthetic efficiency of acquired plastids in A. triacantha. The ultrastructural observations revealed that while the chloroplast‐mitochondria complexes and nucleus of cryptophyte were retained by A. triacantha, other ciliate organelles were digested in food vacuoles. Acquired plastids were retained in A. triacantha for about 1 mo and showed photosynthetic activities for about 18 d when measured by a pulse‐amplitude modulation fluorometer.     

Effects of small-scale turbulence on two species of Dinophysis

Dinoflagellate species of Dinophysis, in particular D. acuminata and D. acuta, produce lipophilic toxins that pose a threat to human health when concentrated in shellfish and jeopardize shellfish exploitations in western Europe. In northwestern Iberia, D. acuminata has a long growing season, from spring to early autumn, and populations develop as soon as shallow stratification forms when the upwelling season begins. In contrast, D. acuta blooms in late summer, when the depth of the pycnocline is maximal and upwelling pulses are moderate. In situ observations on the hydrodynamic regimes during the two windows of opportunity for Dinophysis species led us to hypothesize that D. acuta should be more sensitive to turbulence than D. acuminata.To test this hypothesis, we studied the response of D. acuminata and D. acuta to three realistic turbulence levels low (LT), ε ≈ 10⁻⁶ m² s^-3; medium (MT), ε ≈ 10^-5 m² s^-3 and high (HT), ε ≈ 10^-4 m² s^-3 generated by Turbogen, a highly reproducible, computer-controlled system. Cells of both species exposed to LT and MT grew at rates similar to the controls. Marked differences were found in the response to HT: D. acuminata grew slowly after an initial lag phase, whereas D. acuta cell numbers declined. Results from this study support the hypothesis that turbulence may play a role in shaping the spatio-temporal distribution of individual species of Dinophysis. We also hypothesize that, in addition to cell disturbance affecting division, sustained high shear generated by microturbulence may cause a decline in Dinophysis numbers due to decreased densities of ciliate prey.     

Characterization of azaspiracids in plankton size-fractions and isolation of an azaspiracid-producing dinoflagellate from the North Sea

Azaspiracids (AZAs) are a group of lipophilic polyether toxins implicated in incidents of shellfish poisoning in humans, particularly in northern Europe. In an attempt to establish the biogeographical distribution of AZA toxins, their association with plankton size-fractions, and to confirm the identity of the causative species responsible for human poisoning, a month-long oceanographic study was undertaken in coastal North Sea waters. The occurrence and abundance of AZA analogues was measured by on board triple quadrupole mass spectrometry coupled to liquid chromatography (LC-MS/MS). In size-fractionated plankton samples collected by net tows (20 μm mesh-size), by pumping from discrete depths and from Niskin entrapment bottle casts to fixed depths, AZA-1 was consistently the major azaspiracid component. In eastern Scottish coastal waters, the highest amounts of AZA-1 in net tow samples were in the 50–200 μm fractions, with lesser amounts detected in the >200 μm and 50–20 μm fractions. At these stations, the 50–200 μm fractions were rich in the ciliate Favella ehrenbergii. Cells of F. ehrenbergii isolated by microcapillary indeed contained AZA-1, but isolated cells grown and fed the non-toxic dinoflagellate Scrippsiella trochoidea for one week failed to contain any detectable AZA-1—evidence that F. ehrenbergii is merely a vector for AZA. Detailed analysis of plankton from Niskin bottle samples from around the North Sea typically showed highest amounts of AZA in the 3–20 μm fraction. From this fraction, a large number of crude cultures were established and subsequently screened for the presence of AZAs. A small photosynthetic thecate dinoflagellate, provisionally designated as strain 3D9, was isolated by microcapillary and brought into pure culture. This dinoflagellate strain was found to produce AZA-1, AZA-2 and an isomer of AZA-2. Sequence comparisons by molecular genetic techniques also indicated that this genotype was present in field samples rich in AZA. This discovery of a novel causative dinoflagellate for AZA toxicity essentially explains the lack of correlation of AZA with the abundance and distribution of the previously postulated culprit species Protoperidinium crassipes. We instead propose that such large phagotrophic dinoflagellates can act as an AZA vector following grazing upon a proximal source, such as the dinoflagellate 3D9 strain.     

Effects of marine ciliates on survivability of the first-feeding larval surgeonfish,Paracanthurus hepatus: laboratory rearing experiments

The contribution of ciliates as a food source to survival of first-feeding surgeonfish larvae, Paracanthurus hepatus, was examined in rearing experiments. The larvae were exposed to eight treatments; i.e. a tintinnid, Amphorellopsis acuta (1.0 × 10⁴, 5.1 × 10³ and 2.2 × 10³ cells l^–1) and a naked ciliate, Euplotes sp. (1.3 × 10⁴, 8.0 × 10³ and 5.0 × 10³ cells l^–1), plus two controls without ciliates. Highest survival of the larvae over the first 4–8 days was observed in the highest density of A. acuta. Rearing experiments also showed that the survivals of larvae fed with A. acuta were higher than those fed with Euplotes sp. Gut content analyses revealed loricae of A. acuta in the larvae. Although Euplotes sp. (lacking loricae) was never recognized in those larval guts, feeding on Euplotes sp. by larvae was confirmed using the ciliate labeled with fluorescent microspheres, implying that the feeding on naked ciliates by fish larvae has been overlooked. The results strongly suggested that both tintinnid and naked ciliates play important roles as alternative food sources to copepod nauplii by enhancing the survivability of fish larvae, especially those with a smaller mouth.     

Climate variability and Dinophysis acuta blooms in an upwelling system

Dinophysis acuta is a frequent seasonal lipophilic toxin producer in European Atlantic coastal waters associated with thermal stratification. In the Galician Rías, populations of D. acuta with their epicentre located off Aveiro (northern Portugal), typically co-occur with and follow those of Dinophysis acuminata during the upwelling transition (early autumn) as a result of longshore transport. During hotter than average summers, D. acuta blooms also occur in August in the Rías, when they replace D. acuminata. Here we examined a 30-year (1985–2014) time series of D. acuta from samples collected by the same method in the Galician Rías. Our main objective was to identify patterns of distribution and their relation with climate variability, and to explain the exceptional summer blooms of D. acuta in 1989–1990. A dome-shaped relationship was found between summer upwelling intensity and D. acuta blooms; cell maxima were associated with conditions where the balance between upwelling intensity and heating, leading to deepened thermoclines, combined with tidal phase (3 days after neap tides) created windows of opportunity for this species. The application of a generalized additive model based on biological (D. acuta inoculum) and environmental predictors (Cumulative June–August upwelling CUI_JJA, average June–August SST_JJA and tidal range) explained more than 70% of the deviance for the exceptional summer blooms of D. acuta, through a combination of moderate (35,000–50,000 m³ s⁻¹ km⁻¹) summer upwelling (CUI_JJA), thermal stratification (SST_JJA > 17 °C) and moderate tidal range (∼2.5 m), provided D. acuta cells (inoculum) were present in July. There was no evidence of increasing trends in D. acuta bloom frequency/intensity nor a clear relationship with NAO or other long-term climatic cycles. Instead, the exceptional summer blooms of 1989–1990 appeared linked to extreme hydroclimatic anomalies (high positive anomalies in SST and NAO index), which affected most of the European Atlantic coast.