Investigation of the recognition of an important uridine in an internal loop of a hairpin ribozyme prepared using post-synthetically modified oligonucleotides.

We introduced 4-thio- ((4S)U), 2-thio- ((2S)U), 4- O -methyluridine ((4Me)U) and cytidine substitutions for U+2, which is an important base for cleavage in a substrate RNA. Oligonucleotides containing 4-thio- and 4- O -methyluridine were prepared by a new convenient post-synthetic modification method using a 4- O - p -nitrophenyl-uridine derivative. A hairpin ribozyme cleaved the substrate RNA with either C+2, (4S)U+2 or (4Me)U+2 at approximately 14-, 6- and 4-fold lower rates, respectively, than that of the natural substrate. In contrast, the substrate with a (2S)U+2 was cleaved with the same activity as the natural substrate. These results suggest that the O4 of U+2 is involved in hydrogen bonding at loop A, but the O2 of U+2 is not recognized by the active residues. Circular dichroism data of the ribozymes containing (4S)U+2 and (2S)U+2, as well as the susceptibility of the thiocarbonyl group to hydrogen peroxide, suggest that a conformational change of U+2 occurs during the domain docking in the cleavage reaction. We propose here the conformational change of U+2 from the ground state to the active molecule during the reaction.     

The hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme is a member of a family of small RNA endonucleases, which includes hammer-head, human hepatitis delta virus, Neurospora VS, and the lead-dependent catalytic RNAs. All these catalytic RNAs reversibly cleave the phosphodiester bond of substrate RNA to generate 5'-hydroxyl and 2',3'-cyclic phosphate termini. Whereas the reaction products from family members are similar, large structural and mechanistic differences exist. Structurally the hairpin ribozyme has two principal domains that interact to facilitate catalysis. The hairpin ribozyme uses a catalytic mechanism that does not require metals for cleavage or ligation of substrate RNA. In this regard it is presently unique among RNA catalysts. Targeting rules for cleavage of substrate have been determined and required bases for catalysis have been identified. The hairpin ribozyme has been developed and used for gene therapy and was the first ribozyme to be approved for human clinical trials.     

Nucleotide analog interference mapping of the hairpin ribozyme: implications for secondary and tertiary structure formation.

The hairpin ribozyme is a small, naturally occurring RNA capable of folding into a distinct three-dimensional structure and catalyzing a specific phosphodiester transfer reaction. We have adapted a high throughput screening procedure entitled nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) to identify functional groups important for proper folding and catalysis of this ribozyme. A total of 18 phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs were used to determine the contribution made by individual ribose 2'-OH and purine functional groups to the hairpin ribozyme ligation reaction. Substitution with 2'-deoxy-nucleotide analogs disrupted activity at six sites within the ribozyme, and a unique interference pattern was observed at each of the 11 conserved purine nucleotides. In most cases where such information is available, the NAIM data agree with the previously reported single-site substitution results. The interference patterns are interpreted in comparison to the isolated loop A and loop B NMR structures and a model of the intact ribozyme. These data provide biochemical evidence in support of many, but not all, of the non-canonical base-pairs observed by NMR in each loop, and identify the functional groups most likely to participate in the tertiary interface between loop A and loop B. These groups include the 2'-OH groups of A10, G11, U12, C25, and A38, the exocyclic amine of G11, and the minor groove edge of A9 and A24. The data also predict non-A form sugar pucker geometry at U39 and U41. Based upon these results, a revised model for the loop A tertiary interaction with loop B is proposed. This work defines the chemical basis of purine nucleotide conservation in the hairpin ribozyme, and provides a basis for the design and interpretation of interference suppression experiments.     

Base and sugar requirements for RNA cleavage of essential nucleoside residues in internal loop B of the hairpin ribozyme: implications for secondary structure.

The hairpin ribozyme is a small self-cleaving RNA that can be engineered for RNA cleavage in trans and has potential as a therapeutic agent. We have used a chemical synthesis approach to study the requirements of hairpin RNA cleavage for sugar and base moieties in residues of internal loop B, an essential region in one of the two ribozyme domains. Individual nucleosides were substituted by either a 2'-deoxy-nucleoside, an abasic residue, or a C3-spacer (propyl linker) and the abilities of the modified ribozymes to cleave an RNA substrate were studied in comparison with the wild-type ribozyme. From these results, together with previous studies, we propose a new model for the potential secondary structure of internal loop B of the hairpin ribozyme.     

The structure of the L3 loop from the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme: a syn cytidine.

The structure of the L3 central hairpin loop isolated from the antigenomic sequence of the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme with the P2 and P3 stems from the ribozyme stacked on top of the loop has been determined by NMR spectroscopy. The 26 nt stem-loop structure contains nine base pairs and a 7 nt loop (5'-UCCUCGC-3'). This hairpin loop is critical for efficient catalysis in the intact ribozyme. The structure was determined using homonuclear and heteronuclear NMR techniques on non-labeled and15N-labeled RNA oligonucleotides. The overall root mean square deviation for the structure was 1.15 A (+/- 0.28 A) for the loop and the closing C.G base pair and 0.90 A (+/- 0.18 A) for the loop and the closing C.G base pair but without the lone purine in the loop, which is not well defined in the structure. The structure indicates a U.C base pair between the nucleotides on the 5'- and 3'-ends of the loop. This base pair is formed with a single hydrogen bond involving the cytosine exocyclic amino proton and the carbonyl O4 of the uracil. The most unexpected finding in the loop is a syn cytidine. While not unprecedented, syn pyrimidines are highly unusual. This one can be confidently established by intranucleotide distances between the ribose and the base determined by NMR spectroscopy. A similar study of the structure of this loop showed a somewhat different three-dimensional structure. A discussion of differences in the two structures, as well as possible sites of interaction with the cleavage site, will be presented.     

A conformational change in the "loop E-like" motif of the hairpin ribozyme is coincidental with domain docking and is essential for catalysis

The catalysis of site-specific RNA cleavage and ligation by the hairpin ribozyme requires the formation of a tertiary interaction between two independently folded internal loop domains, A and B. Within the B domain, a tertiary structure has been identified, known as the loop E motif, that has been observed in many naturally occurring RNAs. One characteristic of this motif is a partial cross-strand stack of a G residue on a U residue. In a few cases, including loop B of the hairpin ribozyme, this unusual arrangement gives rise to photoreactivity. In the hairpin, G21 and U42 can be UV cross-linked. Here we show that docking of the two domains correlates very strongly with a loss of UV reactivity of these bases. The rate of the loss of photoreactivity during folding is in close agreement with the kinetics of interdomain docking as determined by hydroxyl-radical footprinting and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). Fixing the structure of the complex in the cross-linked form results in an inability of the two domains to dock and catalyze the cleavage reaction, suggesting that the conformational change is essential for catalysis.     

Investigation of adenosine base ionization in the hairpin ribozyme by nucleotide analog interference mapping.

Tertiary structure in globular RNA folds can create local environments that lead to pKa perturbation of specific nucleotide functional groups. To assess the prevalence of functionally relevant adenosine-specific pKa perturbation in RNA structure, we have altered the nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) approach to include a series of a phosphorothioate-tagged adenosine analogs with shifted N1 pKa values. We have used these analogs to analyze the hairpin ribozyme, a small self-cleaving/ligating RNA catalyst that is proposed to employ a general acid-base reaction mechanism. A single adenosine (A10) within the ribozyme active site displayed an interference pattern consistent with a functionally significant base ionization. The exocyclic amino group of a second adenosine (A38) contributes substantially to hairpin catalysis, but ionization of the nucleotide does not appear to be important for activity. Within the hairpin ribozyme crystal structure, A10 and A38 line opposite edges of a solvent-excluded cavity adjacent to the 5'-OH nucleophile. The results are inconsistent with the model of ribozyme chemistry in which A38 acts as a general acid-base catalyst, and suggest that the hairpin ribozyme uses an alternative mechanism to achieve catalytic rate enhancement that utilizes functional groups within a solvent-excluded cleft in the ribozyme active site.     

Conformational heterogeneity at position U37 of an all-RNA hairpin ribozyme with implications for metal binding and the catalytic structure of the S-turn

The hairpin ribozyme is an RNA enzyme that performs site-specific phosphodiester bond cleavage between nucleotides A-1 and G+1 within its cognate substrate. Previous functional studies revealed that the minimal hairpin ribozyme exhibited "gain-of-function" cleavage properties resulting from U39C or U39 to propyl linker (C3) modifications. Furthermore, each "mutant" displayed different magnesium-dependence in its activity. To investigate the molecular basis for these gain-of-function variants, crystal structures of minimal, junctionless hairpin ribozymes were solved in native (U39), and mutant U39C and U39(C3) forms. The results revealed an overall molecular architecture comprising two docked internal loop domains folded into a wishbone shape, whose tertiary interface forms a sequestered active site. All three minimal hairpin ribozymes bound Co(NH(3))(6)(3+) at G21/A40, the E-loop/S-turn boundary. The native structure also showed that U37 of the S-turn adopts both sequestered and exposed conformations that differ by a maximum displacement of 13 A. In the sequestered form, the U37 base packs against G36, and its 2'-hydroxyl group forms a water mediated hydrogen bond to O4' of G+1. These interactions were not observed in previous four-way-junction hairpin ribozyme structures due to crystal contacts with the U1A splicing protein. Interestingly, the U39C and U39(C3) mutations shifted the equilibrium conformation of U37 into the sequestered form through formation of new hydrogen bonds in the S-turn, proximal to the essential nucleotide A38. A comparison of all three new structures has implications for the catalytically relevant conformation of the S-turn and suggests a rationale for the distinctive metal dependence of each mutant.     

In vitro selection of second site revertants analysis of the hairpin ribozyme active site

We have used in vitro genetics to evaluate the function and interactions of the conserved base G8 in the hairpin ribozyme catalytic RNA. Second site revertant selection for a G8X mutant, where X is any of the other three natural nucleobases, yielded a family of second site suppressors of the G8U mutant, but not of G8C or G8A, indicating that only G and U can be tolerated at position 8 of the ribozyme. This result is consistent with recent observations that point to the functional importance of G8 N-1 in the chemistry of catalysis by this ribozyme reaction. Suppression of the G8U mutation was observed when changes were made directly across loop A from the mutated base at substrate position +2 or positions +2 and +3 in combination. The same changes made in the context of the natural G8 sequence resulted in a very large drop in activity. Thus, the G8U mutation results in a change in specificity of the ribozyme from 5'-N / GUC-3' to 5'-N / GCU-3'. The results presented imply that G8 interacts directly with U+2 during catalysis. We propose that this interaction favors the correct positioning of the catalytic determinants of G8. The implications for the folding of the ribozyme and the catalytic mechanism are discussed.     

The catalytic mechanism of hairpin ribozyme studied by hydrostatic pressure

The discovery of ribozymes strengthened the RNA world hypothesis, which assumes that these precursors of modern life both stored information and acted as catalysts. For the first time among extensive studies on ribozymes, we have investigated the influence of hydrostatic pressure on the hairpin ribozyme catalytic activity. High pressures are of interest when studying life under extreme conditions and may help to understand the behavior of macromolecules at the origins of life. Kinetic studies of the hairpin ribozyme self-cleavage were performed under high hydrostatic pressure. The activation volume of the reaction (34 ± 5 ml/mol) calculated from these experiments is of the same order of magnitude as those of common protein enzymes, and reflects an important compaction of the RNA molecule during catalysis, associated to a water release. Kinetic studies were also carried out under osmotic pressure and confirmed this interpretation and the involvement of water movements (78 ± 4 water molecules per RNA molecule). Taken together, these results are consistent with structural studies indicating that loops A and B of the ribozyme come into close contact during the formation of the transition state. While validating baro-biochemistry as an efficient tool for investigating dynamics at work during RNA catalysis, these results provide a complementary view of ribozyme catalytic mechanisms.     

Mechanistic considerations for general acid-base catalysis by RNA: revisiting the mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme

Several small ribozymes carry out self-cleavage at a specific phosphodiester bond to yield 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. Prior mechanistic and structural studies on the HDV ribozymes led to the proposal that the pK(a) of C75 is shifted toward neutrality, making it an effective general acid. Recent mechanistic studies on the hairpin ribozyme have led to models in which protonation of G8 is required for phosphodiester cleavage, either for general acid catalysis or for electrostatic stabilization. Inspection of recent crystal structures of the hairpin ribozyme, including a complex with a vanadate transition state mimic, suggests an alternative model involving general acid-base catalysis with G8 serving as the general base and A38 as the general acid. This model is consistent with the literature on the hairpin ribozyme, including pH-rate profiles of wild-type and mutant ribozymes and solvent isotope effects. General mechanistic considerations for RNA catalysis suggest that the penalty for having general acids and bases with pK(a)s removed from neutrality is not as severe as expected. These considerations suggest that general acid-base catalysis may be a common mechanistic strategy of RNA enzymes.     

Spermine supports catalysis of hairpin ribozyme variants to differing extents

Because of the ability to cleave RNA substrates in trans, the hairpin ribozyme has great potential for therapeutic application. Activity of a three-stranded version of the minimal truncated form is enhanced by the presence of the polyamine spermine. Since spermine is the most abundant polyamine in eucariots, improved prospects for the hairpin ribozyme as therapeutic agent were predicted. We have found that not all hairpin ribozyme variants accept spermine equally well as counter-ion. Particularly the two-stranded versions commonly used for therapeutic studies show rather decreased activity when spermine is present. We have investigated a number of hairpin ribozyme derivatives regarding their ability to carry out spermine supported catalysis. Among the studied structures a two-stranded reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme displayed the highest cleavage rates in a synergistic mixture of magnesium ions and spermine. The specific features of this ribozyme along with its potential for in vivo application are discussed.     

The hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme is a naturally occurring RNA that catalyzes sequence-specific cleavage and ligation of RNA. It has been the subject of extensive biochemical and structural studies, perhaps the most detailed for any catalytic RNA to date. Comparison of the structures of its constituent domains free and fully assembled demonstrates that the RNA undergoes extensive structural rearrangement. This rearrangement results in a distortion of the substrate RNA that primes it for cleavage. This ribozyme is known to achieve catalysis employing exclusively RNA functional groups. Metal ions or other catalytic cofactors are not used. Current experimental evidence points to a combination of at least four mechanistic strategies by this RNA: (1) precise substrate orientation, (2) preferential transition state binding, (3) electrostatic catalysis, and (4) general acid base catalysis.     

Design of hairpin ribozyme variants with improved activity for poorly processed substrates

Application of ribozymes for knockdown of RNA targets requires the identification of suitable target sites according to the consensus sequence. For the hairpin ribozyme, this was originally defined as Y?2 N?1 *G+1 U+2 Y+3 B+?, with Y = U or C, and B = U, C or G, and C being the preferred nucleobase at positions -2 and +4. In the context of development of ribozymes for destruction of an oncogenic mRNA, we have designed ribozyme variants that efficiently process RNA substrates at U?2 G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 A+? sites. Substrates with G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 sites were previously shown to be processed by the wild-type hairpin ribozyme. However, our study demonstrates that, in the specific sequence context of the substrate studied herein, compensatory base changes in the ribozyme improve activity for cleavage (eight-fold) and ligation (100-fold). In particular, we show that A+3 and A+? are well tolerated if compensatory mutations are made at positions 6 and 7 of the ribozyme strand. Adenine at position +4 is neutralized by G? →U, owing to restoration of a Watson-Crick base pair in helix 1. In this ribozyme-substrate complex, adenine at position +3 is also tolerated, with a slightly decreased cleavage rate. Additional substitution of A? with uracil doubled the cleavage rate and restored ligation, which was lost in variants with A?, C? and G?. The ability to cleave, in conjunction with the inability to ligate RNA, makes these ribozyme variants particularly suitable candidates for RNA destruction.     

Nucleobase catalysis in the hairpin ribozyme

RNA catalysis is important in the processing and translation of RNA molecules, yet the mechanisms of catalysis are still unclear in most cases. We have studied the role of nucleobase catalysis in the hairpin ribozyme, where the scissile phosphate is juxtaposed between guanine and adenine bases. We show that a modified ribozyme in which guanine 8 has been substituted by an imidazole base is active in both cleavage and ligation, with ligation rates 10-fold faster than cleavage. The rates of both reactions exhibit bell-shaped dependence on pH, with pK(a) values of 5.7 +/- 0.1 and 7.7 +/- 0.1 for cleavage and 6.1 +/- 0.3 and 6.9 +/- 0.3 for ligation. The data provide good evidence for general acid-base catalysis by the nucleobases.     

Comparative analysis of hairpin ribozyme structures and interference data

Great strides in understanding the molecular underpinnings of RNA catalysis have been achieved with advances in RNA structure determination by NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography. Despite these successes the functional relevance of a given structure can only be assessed upon comparison with biochemical studies performed on functioning RNA molecules. The hairpin ribozyme presents an excellent case study for such a comparison. The active site is comprised of two stems each with an internal loop that forms a series of non-canonical base pairs. These loops dock into each other to create an active site for catalysis. Recently, three independent structures have been determined for this catalytic RNA, including two NMR structures of the isolated loop A and loop B stems and a high-resolution crystal structure of both loops in a docked conformation. These structures differ significantly both in their tertiary fold and the nature of the non-canonical base pairs formed within each loop. Several of the chemical groups required to achieve a functioning hairpin ribozyme have been determined by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM). Here we compare the three hairpin structures with previously published NAIM data to assess the convergence between the structural and functional data. While there is significant disparity between the interference data and the individual NMR loop structures, there is almost complete congruity with the X-ray structure. The only significant differences cluster around an occluded pocket adjacent to the scissile phosphate. These local differences may suggest a role for these atoms in the transition state, either directly in chemistry or via a local structural rearrangement.     

Imaging of single hairpin ribozymes in solution by atomic force microscopy.

The hairpin ribozyme is a short endonucleolytic RNA motif isolated from a family of related plant virus satellite RNAs. It consists of two independently folding domains, each comprising two Watson-Crick helices flanking a conserved internal loop. The domains need to physically interact (dock) for catalysis of site-specific cleavage and ligation reactions. Using tapping-mode atomic force microscopy in aqueous buffer solution, we were able to produce high quality images of individual hairpin ribozyme molecules with extended terminal helices. Three RNA constructs with either the essential cleavage site guanosine or a detrimental adenosine substitution and with or without a 6-nt insertion to confer flexibility to the interdomain hinge show structural differences that correlate with their ability to form the active docked conformation. The observed contour lengths and shapes are consistent with previous bulk-solution measurements of the transient electric dichroism decays for the same RNA constructs. The active docked construct appears as an asymmetrically docked conformation that might be an indication of a more complicated docking event than a simple collapse around the interdomain hinge.     

Structure and function of the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme belongs to the family of small catalytic RNAs that cleave RNA substrates in a reversible reaction that generates 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. The hairpin catalytic motif was discovered in the negative strand of the tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA, where hairpin ribozyme-mediated self-cleavage and ligation reactions participate in processing RNA replication intermediates. The self-cleaving hairpin, hammerhead, hepatitis delta and Neurospora VS RNAs each adopt unique structures and exploit distinct kinetic and catalytic mechanisms despite catalyzing the same chemical reactions. Mechanistic studies of hairpin ribozyme reactions provided early evidence that, like protein enzymes, RNA enzymes are able to exploit a variety of catalytic strategies. In contrast to the hammerhead and Tetrahymena ribozyme reactions, hairpin-mediated cleavage and ligation proceed through a catalytic mechanism that does not require direct coordination of metal cations to phosphate or water oxygens. The hairpin ribozyme is a better ligase than it is a nuclease while the hammerhead reaction favors cleavage over ligation of bound products by nearly 200-fold. Recent structure-function studies have begun to yield insights into the molecular bases of these unique features of the hairpin ribozyme.     

Essential nucleotide sequences and secondary structure elements of the hairpin ribozyme.

In vitro selection experiments have been used to isolate active variants of the 50 nt hairpin catalytic RNA motif following randomization of individual ribozyme domains and intensive mutagenesis of the ribozyme-substrate complex. Active and inactive variants were characterized by sequencing, analysis of RNA cleavage activity in cis and in trans, and by substrate binding studies. Results precisely define base-pairing requirements for ribozyme helices 3 and 4, and identify eight essential nucleotides (G8, A9, A10, G21, A22, A23, A24 and C25) within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Activity and substrate binding assays show that point mutations at these eight sites eliminate cleavage activity but do not significantly decrease substrate binding, demonstrating that these bases contribute to catalytic function. The mutation U39C has been isolated from different selection experiments as a second-site suppressor of the down mutants G21U and A43G. Assays of the U39C mutation in the wild-type ribozyme and in a variety of mutant backgrounds show that this variant is a general up mutation. Results from selection experiments involving populations totaling more than 10(10) variants are summarized, and consensus sequences including 16 essential nucleotides and a secondary structure model of four short helices, encompassing 18 bp for the ribozyme-substrate complex are derived.     

Ribozyme mediated trans insertion-splicing of modified oligonucleotides into RNA

The trans insertion-splicing reaction, catalyzed by a group I intron-derived from Pneumocystis carinii, was recently developed for the site-specific insertion of a segment of RNA into a separate RNA substrate. The molecular determinants of this reaction for binding and catalysis are reasonably well understood, making them easily and highly modifiable for altering substrate specificity. To demonstrate proof-of-concept, we now report that the P. carinii ribozyme can except modified oligonucleotides as substrates for catalyzing the trans insertion-splicing reaction. Oligonucleotides that contain one or more sugar modifications (deoxy or methoxy substitution), a backbone modification (phosphorothioate substitution), or a base modification (2-aminopurine or 4-thiouridine) are effective substrates in this reaction. Apparently, trans insertion-splicing is a unique and viable reaction for the site-specific incorporation of modified oligonucleotides into RNAs. This is the first report of a group I intron-derived ribozyme being capable of catalyzing the insertion of a modified oligonucleotide into RNA.