Type I collagen triplet duplication mutation in lethal osteogenesis imperfecta shifts register of alpha chains throughout the helix and disrupts incorporation of mutant helices into fibrils and extracellular matrix

The majority of collagen mutations causing osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) are glycine substitutions that disrupt formation of the triple helix. A rare type of collagen mutation consists of a duplication or deletion of one or two Gly-X-Y triplets. These mutations shift the register of collagen chains with respect to each other in the helix but do not interrupt the triplet sequence, yet they have severe clinical consequences. We investigated the effect of shifting the register of the collagen helix by a single Gly-X-Y triplet on collagen assembly, stability, and incorporation into fibrils and matrix. These studies utilized a triplet duplication in COL1A1 exon 44 that occurred in the cDNA and gDNA of two siblings with lethal OI. The normal allele encodes three identical Gly-Ala-Hyp triplets at aa 868-876, whereas the mutant allele encodes four. The register shift delays helix formation, causing overmodification. Differential scanning calorimetry yielded a decrease in T(m) of 2 degrees C for helices with one mutant chain and a 6 degrees C decrease in helices with two mutant chains. An in vitro binary co-processing assay of N-proteinase cleavage demonstrated that procollagen with the triplet duplication has slower N-propeptide cleavage than in normal controls or procollagen with proalpha1(I) G832S, G898S, or G997S substitutions, showing that the register shift persists through the entire helix. The register shift disrupts incorporation of mutant collagen into fibrils and matrix. Proband fibrils formed inefficiently in vitro and contained only normal helices and helices with a single mutant chain. Helices with two mutant chains and a significant portion of helices with one mutant chain did not form fibrils. In matrix deposited by proband fibroblasts, mutant chains were abundant in the immaturely cross-linked fraction but constituted a minor fraction of maturely cross-linked chains. The profound effects of shifting the collagen triplet register on chain interactions in the helix and on fibril formation correlate with the severe clinical consequences.     

Selective retention and degradation of molecules with a single mutant α1(I) chain in the Brtl IV mouse model of OI

We investigated the secretion, matrix incorporation and interactions of molecules with one and two mutant alpha1(I) collagen chains in the Brtl IV murine model for Osteogenesis Imperfecta, carrying a Gly-349 to Cys substitution in one col1a1 allele. We detected a significant deviation from the expected 25 and 50% content of the molecules with no (37-46%) and one (26-40%) mutant chains in skin and bone as well as in fibroblast and osteoblast cell culture media. Steady-state labeling with (35)S-Cys demonstrated incomplete secretion of the mutant collagen in cell culture, particularly molecules containing one mutant chain. Pulse and pulse-chase experiments revealed slower secretion of the latter. An enlargement of endoplasmic reticulum in skin fibroblasts from Brtl IV mice, clearly visible by electron microscopy, supported the abnormal secretion identified by biochemical studies. We observed increased susceptibility of molecules with one mutant chain to proteolytic degradation in vitro, but we did not detect significant selective degradation in cell culture media. Mutant collagen molecules incorporated from the media into newly deposited fibers and into fully crosslinked and mature matrix in the same ratio as they were secreted. Specific labeling of reactive -SH demonstrated that about half of the Cys349-SH groups in the mutant molecules were exposed and potentially available for aberrant interactions with other molecules inside or outside the cells. Based on these and our previous findings, we argue that the outcome in Brtl IV may be significantly affected by cellular stress and malfunction caused by the retention and degradation of newly synthesized mutant collagen.     

Differential response to intracellular stress in the skin from osteogenesis imperfecta Brtl mice with lethal and non lethal phenotype: a proteomic approach

Phenotypic variability in the presence of an identical molecular defect is a recurrent feature in heritable disorders and it was also reported in osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). OI is a prototype for skeletal dysplasias mainly caused by mutations in the two genes coding for type I collagen. No definitive cure is available for this disorder, but the understanding of molecular basis in OI phenotypic modulation will have a pivotal role in identifying possible targets to develop novel drug therapy. We used a functional proteomic approach to address the study of phenotypic variability using the skin of the OI murine model Brtl. Brtl mice reproduce the molecular defect, dominant transmission and phenotypic variability of human OI patients. In the presence of a Gly349Cys substitution in α1(I)-collagen Brtl mice can have a lethal or a moderately severe outcome. Differential expression of chaperones, proteasomal subunits, metabolic enzymes, and proteins related to cellular fate demonstrated that a different ability to adapt to cellular stress distinguished mutant from wild-type mice and mutant lethal from surviving mutant animals. Interestingly, class discovery analysis identified clusters of differentially expressed proteins associated with a specific outcome, and functional analysis contributed to a deeper investigation into biochemical and cellular pathways affected by the disease. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Translational Proteomics.     

Heterozygosity for a large deletion in the alpha 2(I) collagen gene has a dramatic effect on type I collagen secretion and produces perinatal lethal osteogenesis imperfecta

We characterized a de novo 4.5 kilobase pair deletion in the paternally derived alpha 2(I) collagen allele (COL1A2) from a patient with perinatal lethal osteogenesis imperfecta. The intron-to-intron deletion removed the seven exons which encode residues 586-765 of the triple helical domain of the chain. Type I procollagen molecules that contain the mutant pro-alpha 2(I) chain have a lower than normal thermal stability, undergo increased post-translational modification amino-terminal to the deletion junction, and are retained within the rough endoplasmic reticulum. The block to secretion appears to result from improper assembly of the triple helix, apparently a consequence of a disruption of charge-charge interactions between the shortened pro-alpha 2(I) chain and normal pro-alpha 1(I) chains. The lethal effect may be due to decreased secretion of normal collagen and secretion of a small amount of abnormal collagen that disrupts matrix formation.     

Homozygosity by descent for a COL1A2 mutation in two sibs with severe osteogenesis imperfecta and mild clinical expression in the heterozygotes

We report two sibs with severe, progressively deforming osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) and homozygosity by descent for a glycine 751 to serine substitution in the α2(I) collagen chain due to a G to A transition in the COL1A2 gene. The parents, who were first cousins, and two elder sibs were heterozygous for the mutation and presented mild clinical manifestations of OI. Collagen studies on cultured fibroblasts from one of the probands and from the father showed that cells from the homozygote produced only mutant, unstable collagen I, whereas cells from the heterozygote produced both normal and mutant collagen I. This family represents an exceptional example of autosomal recessive OI, caused by homozygosity for a missense mutation in collagen I. Received: 22 July 1996     

Defects of type I procollagen metabolism correlated with decrease of prolidase activity in a case of lethal osteogenesis imperfecta.

We have studied the structure and metabolism of type I procollagen in a case of perinatal lethal osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) type II. Cultured skin fibroblasts from the proband synthesized both normal and abnormal forms of type I procollagen. Some abnormal, overmodified molecules were secreted by OI cells, although less efficiently than normal molecules from control cells. The OI fibroblasts accumulated large amounts of abnormal proalpha1(I) and proalpha2(I) chains intracellularly. The extracellular collagenolytic activity was decreased compared to control cells. Furthermore, OI cells produced less type I procollagen and demonstrated lower capacity to synthesize DNA than control cells. We have found that in contrast to prolinase activity, the activity of prolidase (an enzyme essential for collagen synthesis and cell growth) is also significantly reduced in OI cells. No differences were found in the amount of the enzyme protein recovered from both the OI and control cells. However, we found that expressions of beta1 integrin and insulin-like growth factor-I receptor (receptors known to play an important role in up regulation of prolidase activity) were decreased in OI cells compared to control cells. The decrease in prolidase activity may provide an important mechanism of altered cell growth and collagen metabolism involved in producing the perinatal lethal form of the OI phenotype.     

Type I procollagen in the severe non-lethal form of osteogenesis imperfecta

Summary We have screened type I procollagen synthesized in vitro by skin fibroblasts from several patients with the severe non-lethal form of osteogenesis imperfecta. Cells from one patient synthesized and secreted both normal and a larger amount of abnormal type I procollagen. The abnormal alpha chains are larger in size due to post-translational overmodifications involving the whole triple helical domain. Abnormal collagen heterotrimers had a melting temperature 2.5°–3°C lower than normal ones or from controls. Chemical analysis of collagen in the medium showed a greater degree of both lysyl hydroxylation and hydroxylysyl glycosylation, the major increase in molecular mass of overmodified alpha chains being due to the higher hydroxylysine-bound hexose content. The proband's cells modify proteoglycan metabolism and mineral proband's cells modify proteoglycan metabolism and mineral crystals form in the dermis, possibly a response to abnormal collagen-proteoglycan interactions. These findings can be explained by a small defect in the product of one allele for pro-1(I) chains: three-quarters of the synthesized type I procollagen molecules are composed of trimers containing one or two chains defective near the C-terminus of the triple helix or in the C-propeptide. The data obtained for this patient confirmed that the severity of clinical manifestations in osteogenesis imperfecta strongly depends on the location and nature of the mutations, and that the phenotype could be a consequence of a collagen defect(s) and its influence on collagen-collagen interactions and collagen interactions with other connective tissue components.     

Two novelCOL1A1 mutations in patients with osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) affect the stability of the collagen type I triple-helix

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a bone dysplasia caused by mutations in theCOL1A1 andCOL1A2 genes. Although the condition has been intensely studied for over 25 years and recently over 800 novel mutations have been published, the relation between the location of mutations and clinical manifestation is poorly understood. Here we report missense mutations inCOL1A1 of several OI patients. Two novel mutations were found in the D1 period. One caused a substitution of glycine 200 by valine at the N-terminus of D1 in OI type I/IV, lowering collagen stability by 50% at 34°C. The other one was a substitution of valine 349 by phenylalanine at the C-terminus of D1 in OI type I, lowering collagen stability at 37.5°C. Two other mutations, reported before, changed amino residues in D4. One was a lethal substitution changing glycine 866 to serine in genetically identical twins with OI type II. That mutated amino acid was near the border of D3 and D4. The second mutation changed glycine 1040 to serine located at the border of D4 and D0.4, in a proband manifesting OI type III, and lowered collagen stability at 39°C (2°C lower than normal). Our results confirm the hypothesis on a critical role of the D1 and D4 regions in stabilization of the collagen triple-helix. The defect in D1 seemed to produce a milder clinical type of OI, whereas the defect in the C-terminal end of collagen type caused the more severe or lethal types of OI.     

Transfer of proalpha2(I) cDNA into cells of a murine model of human Osteogenesis Imperfecta restores synthesis of type I collagen comprised of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) heterotrimers in vitro and in vivo

The oim mouse is a model of human Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) that has deficient synthesis of proalpha2(I) chains. Cells isolated from oim mice synthesize alpha1(I) collagen homotrimers that accumulate in tissues. To explore the feasibility of gene therapy for OI, a murine proalpha2(I) cDNA was inserted into an adenovirus vector and transferred into bone marrow stromal cells isolated from oim mice femurs. The murine cDNA under the control of the cytomegalovirus early promoter was expressed by the transduced cells. Analysis of the collagens synthesized by the transduced cells demonstrated that the cells synthesized stable type I collagen comprised of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) heterotrimers in the correct ratio of 2:1. The collagen was efficiently secreted and also the cells retained the osteogenic potential as indicated by the expression of alkaline phosphatase activity when the transduced cells were treated with recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein 2. Injection of the virus carrying the murine proalpha2(I) cDNA into oim skin demonstrated synthesis of type I collagen comprised of alpha1 and alpha2 chains at the injection site. These preliminary data demonstrate that collagen genes can be transferred into bone marrow stromal cells as well as fibroblasts in vivo and that the genes are efficiently expressed. These data encourage further studies in gene replacement for some forms of OI and use of bone marrow stromal cells as vehicles to deliver therapeutic genes to bone.     

The role of the alpha2 chain in the stabilization of the collagen type I heterotrimer: a study of the type I homotrimer in oim mouse tissues

We have previously reported that the fragility of skin, tendon and bone from the oim mouse is related to a significant reduction in the intermolecular cross-linking. The oim mutation is unlikely to affect the efficacy of the lysyl oxidase, suggesting that the defect is in the molecule and fibre. We have therefore investigated the integrity of both the oim collagen molecules and the fibre by differential scanning calorimetry.The denaturation temperature of the oim molecule in solution and the fibre from tail tendon were found to be higher than the wild-type by 2.6deg.C and 1.9deg.C, respectively. With the loss of the alpha2 chain, the hydroxyproline content of the homotrimer is higher than the heterotrimer, which may account for the increase.There is a small decrease in the enthalpy of the oim fibres but it is not significant, suggesting that the amount of disorder of the triple-helical molecules and of the fibres is small and involves only a small part of the total bond energy holding the helical structure together. The difference in denaturation temperature of the skin collagen molecules (t(m)) and fibres (t(d)) is significantly lower for the oim tissues, 19.9deg.C against 23.1deg.C, indicating reduced molecular interactions and hence packing of the molecules in the fibre. Computation of the volume fraction of the water revealed that the interaxial separation of the oim fibres was indeed greater, increasing from 19.6A to 21.0A. This difference of 1.4A, equivalent to a C-C bond, would certainly decrease the ability of the telopeptide aldehyde to interact with the epsilon -amino group from an adjacent molecule and form a cross-link. We suggest, therefore, that the reduction of the cross-linking is due to increased water content of the fibre rather than a distortion of the molecular structure.The higher hydrophobicity of the alpha2 chain appears to play a role in the stabilisation of heterotrimeric type I collagen, possibly by increasing the hydrophobic interactions between the heterotrimeric molecules, thereby reducing the water content and increasing the binding of the molecules in the fibre.     

Variable expression of osteogenesis imperfecta in a nuclear family is explained by somatic mosaicism for a lethal point mutation in the alpha 1(I) gene (COL1A1) of type I collagen in a parent.

Fibroblasts from a man with a mild form of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) and from his son with perinatal lethal OI (OI type II) produced normal and abnormal type I procollagen molecules. The abnormal molecules synthesized by both cell strains contained one or two pro alpha 1(I) chains in which the glycine at position 550 of the triple-helical domain was substituted by arginine as the result of a G-to-A transition in the first base of the glycine codon. Cells from the mother produced only normal type I procollagen molecules. By allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization to amplified genomic sequences from paternal tissues we determined that the mutant allele accounted for approximately 50% of the COL1A1 alleles in fibroblasts, 27% of those in blood, and 37% of those in sperm. These findings demonstrate that the father is mosaic for the potentially lethal mutation and suggest that the OI phenotype is determined by the nature of the mutation and the relative abundance of the normal and mutant alleles in different tissues. Furthermore, the findings make it clear that some individuals with mild to moderate forms of OI are mosaic for mutations that will be lethal in their offspring.     

Studies on type I collagen in skin fibroblasts cultured from twins with lethal osteogenesis imperfecta

Studies on type I procollagen produced by skin fibroblasts cultured from twins with lethal type II of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) showed that biosynthesis of collagen (measured by L-[5-(3)H]proline incorporation into proteins susceptible to the action of bacterial collagenase) was slightly increased as compared to the control healthy infant. SDS/PAGE showed that the fibroblasts synthesized and secreted only normal type I procollagen. Electrophoretic analysis of collagen chains and CNBr peptides showed the same pattern of electrophoretic migration as in the controls. The lack of posttranslational overmodification of the collagen molecule suggested a molecular defect near the amino terminus of the collagen helix. Digestion of OI type I collagen with trypsin at 30 degrees C for 5 min generated a shorter than normal alpha2 chain which melted at 36 degrees C. Direct sequencing of an asymmetric PCR product revealed a heterozygous single nucleotide change C-->G causing a substitution of histidine by aspartic acid in the alpha2 chain at position 92. Pericellular processing of type I procollagen by the twin's fibroblasts yielded a later appearance of the intermediate pC-alpha1(I) form as compared with control cells.     

Structural heterogeneity of type I collagen triple helix and its role in osteogenesis imperfecta

We investigated regions of different helical stability within human type I collagen and discussed their role in intermolecular interactions and osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). By differential scanning calorimetry and circular dichroism, we measured and mapped changes in the collagen melting temperature (DeltaTm) for 41 different Gly substitutions from 47 OI patients. In contrast to peptides, we found no correlations of DeltaTm with the identity of the substituting residue. Instead, we observed regular variations in DeltaTm with the substitution location in different triple helix regions. To relate the DeltaTm map to peptide-based stability predictions, we extracted the activation energy of local helix unfolding (DeltaG) from the reported peptide data. We constructed the DeltaG map and tested it by measuring the H-D exchange rate for glycine NH residues involved in interchain hydrogen bonds. Based on the DeltaTm and DeltaG maps, we delineated regional variations in the collagen triple helix stability. Two large, flexible regions deduced from the DeltaTm map aligned with the regions important for collagen fibril assembly and ligand binding. One of these regions also aligned with a lethal region for Gly substitutions in the alpha1(I) chain.     

A frameshift mutation results in a truncated nonfunctional carboxyl-terminal pro alpha 1(I) propeptide of type I collagen in osteogenesis imperfecta

A codon frameshift mutation caused by a single base (U) insertion after base pair 4088 of prepro alpha 1(I) mRNA of type I procollagen was identified in a baby with lethal perinatal osteogenesis imperfecta. The mutation was identified in fibroblast RNA by a new method that allows the direct detection of mismatched bases by chemical modification and cleavage in heteroduplexes formed between mRNA and control cDNA probes. The region of mismatches was specifically amplified by the polymerase chain reaction and sequenced. The heterozygous mutation in the amplified cDNA most likely resulted from a T insertion in exon 49 of COL1A1. The frameshift resulted in a truncated pro alpha 1(I) carboxyl-terminal propeptide in which the amino acid sequence was abnormal from Val1146 to the carboxyl terminus. The propeptide lacked Asn1187, which normally carries an N-linked oligosaccharide unit, and was more basic than the normal propeptide. The distribution of cysteines was altered and the mutant propeptide was unable to form normal interchain disulfide bonds. Some of the mutant pro alpha 1(I)' chains were incorporated into type I procollagen molecules but resulted in abnormal helix formation with over-hydroxylation of lysine residues, increased degradation, and poor secretion. Only normal type I collagen was incorporated into the extracellular matrix in vivo resulting in a tissue type I collagen content approximately 20% of that of control (Bateman, J. F., Chan, D., Mascara, T., Rogers, J. G., and Cole, W. G. (1986) Biochem. J. 240, 699-708).     

Changes in thermal stability and microunfolding pattern of collagen helix resulting from the loss of alpha2(I) chain in osteogenesis imperfecta murine

Homozygous mutations resulting in formation of alpha1(I)(3) homotrimers instead of normal type I collagen cause mild to severe osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) in humans and mice. Limited studies of changes in thermal stability of type I homotrimers were reported previously, but the results were not fully consistent. We revisited this question in more detail using purified tendon collagen from wild-type (alpha1(I)(2)alpha2(I) heterotrimers) and oim (alpha1(I)(3)) mice as well as artificial alpha1(I)(3) homotrimers obtained by refolding of rat-tail-tendon collagen. We found that at the same heating rate oim homotrimers completely denature at approximately 2.5deg.C higher temperature than wild-type heterotrimers, as determined by differential scanning calorimetry. At the same, constant temperature, homotrimers denature approximately 100 times slower than heterotrimers, as determined by circular dichroism. Detailed analysis of proteolytic cleavage at different temperatures revealed that microunfolding of oim homotrimers and wild-type heterotrimers occurs at similar rate but within a number of different sites. In particular, the weakest spot on the oim triple helix is located approximately 100 amino acid residues from the C-terminal end within the cyanogen bromide peptide CB6. The same microunfolding site is also present in wild-type collagen, but the weakest spot of the latter is located close to the N-terminal end of CB8. Amino acid analysis and differential gel electrophoresis showed virtually no posttranslational overmodification of oim mouse tendon collagen. Moreover, thermal stability and microunfolding of artificial rat-tail-tendon homotrimers were similar to oim homotrimers. Thus, the observed changes are associated with difference in the amino acid composition of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) chains rather than posttranslational overmodification.     

Mutations in type I collagen genes resulting in osteogenesis imperfecta in humans

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), commonly known as "brittle bone disease", is a dominant autosomal disorder characterized by bone fragility and abnormalities of connective tissue. Biochemical and molecular genetic studies have shown that the vast majority of affected individuals have mutations in either the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes that encode the chains of type I procollagen. OI is associated with a wide spectrum of phenotypes varying from mild to severe and lethal conditions. The mild forms are usually caused by mutations which inactivate one allele of COL1A1 gene and result in a reduced amount of normal type I collagen, while the severe and lethal forms result from dominant negative mutations in COL1A1 or COL1A2 which produce structural defects in the collagen molecule. The most common mutations are substitutions of glycine residues, which are crucial to formation and function of the collagen triple helix, by larger amino acids. Although type I collagen is the major structural protein of both bone and skin, the mutations in type I collagen genes cause a bone disease. Some reports showed that the mutant collagen can be expressed differently in bone and in skin. Since most mutations identified in OI are dominant negative, the gene therapy requires a fundamentally different approach from that used for genetic-recessive disorders. The antisense therapy, by reducing the expression of mutant genes, is able to change a structural mutation into a null mutation, and thus convert severe forms of the disease into mild OI type I.     

Effect of rapamycin on bone mass and strength in the α2(I)‐G610C mouse model of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is commonly caused by heterozygous type I collagen structural mutations that disturb triple helix folding and integrity. This mutant‐containing misfolded collagen accumulates in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and induces a form of ER stress associated with negative effects on osteoblast differentiation and maturation. Therapeutic induction of autophagy to degrade the mutant collagens could therefore be useful in ameliorating the ER stress and deleterious downstream consequences. To test this, we treated a mouse model of mild to moderate OI (α2(I) G610C) with dietary rapamycin from 3 to 8 weeks of age and effects on bone mass and mechanical properties were determined. OI bone mass and mechanics were, as previously reported, compromised compared to WT. While rapamycin treatment improved the trabecular parameters of WT and OI bones, the biomechanical deficits of OI bones were not rescued. Importantly, we show that rapamycin treatment suppressed the longitudinal and transverse growth of OI, but not WT, long bones. Our work demonstrates that dietary rapamycin offers no clinical benefit in this OI model and furthermore, the impact of rapamycin on OI bone growth could exacerbate the clinical consequences during periods of active bone growth in patients with OI caused by collagen misfolding mutations.     

Immunofluorescent localization of type III collagen and the N-terminal propeptide of type III procollagen in dentin matrix in osteogenesis imperfecta

Demineralized deciduous and permanent teeth from seven patients with six different types of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) and from four unaffected controls were stained for type III collagen and for the N-terminal propeptide of type III procollagen using indirect immunofluorescence. Sillence types IA, IB and III OI were each represented by one patient. Two patients had type IVB and two had unclassifiable OI. After enzymatic treatment, the dentin matrix of one patient each with type IB OI, type IVB, and unclassifiable OI reacted with the specific antibodies against both type III collagen and the N-terminal propeptide. Positive staining was observed around the pathological canal-like structures and as delicate strands traversing the matrix. The similar patterns of immunofluorescence for both antigens in dentin in OI are suggestive of retention of the N-terminal propeptide in association with type III collagen identical to that in normal nonmineralized connective tissues. The abnormal presence of type III collagen in dentin in OI may be secondary to the aberrant structure of type I collagen. The failure of dentin matrix of all patients with OI to immunostain for type III collagen and the N-terminal propeptide may reflect heterogeneity or additional secondary changes in matrix macromolecule interactions.