Differentiation of the O and P cell lines in the embryo of the leech. II. Genealogical relationship of descendant pattern elements in alternative developmental pathways

The p blast cells are a group of embryonic precursors found in the ectodermal cell layer of the leech germinal band. Each p blast cell normally undergoes the same invariant sequence of cell divisions and gives rise to a precisely defined set of uniquely identifiable neuronal and epidermal descendants in the mature leech. In the present paper, various of the p blast cell progeny were injected with a fluorescent lineage tracer in order to characterize the cellular composition of their descendant clones, and the results show that there is a stereotyped segregation of descendant cell fates through the first three p blast cell divisions. Previous work has shown that neurons and epidermal specializations which normally descend from the p blast cell will arise from a different precursor--the o blast cell--in response to ablation of the neighboring P cell line and that if the o blast cell is at a certain stage of differentiation when the ablation is performed it will produce only a subset of the normal P descendants. Comparison with the present findings indicates that under those conditions the o blast cell clone is not simply recapitulating a branch of the normal p blast cell lineage, but rather manifests an alternative lineage in which P descendants exhibit an abnormal genealogical relationship. Thus, even though normal leech development comprises a nearly invariant cell lineage, lineage relationships are open to considerable reorganization under experimental conditions.     

Stepwise commitment of blast cell fates during the positional specification of the O and P cell lines in the leech embryo

The o and p bandlets of the leech embryo are parallel columns of ectodermal blast cells which are identified by their relative positions, and which during normal embryogenesis follow distinct developmental pathways. A previous study showed that o blast cells are initially capable of following either the O or P pathway, and suggested that commitment to the O pathway depends upon interaction with the adjacent p bandlet. To better understand the nature and timing of this interaction we examined the fate of o blast cells whose p blast cell neighbors had been selectively ablated by photoexcitation of a fluorescent lineage tracer. If an o blast cell has not yet begun its secondary divisions, its normal commitment to the O pathway can be effectively prevented by ablation of the adjacent p bandlet. Comparing the outcome of progressively later lesions reveals that the progeny of the o blast cell become committed to the O pathway in a series of three discrete steps, and that these steps occur around the time of the first three blast cell divisions. Each of the three events affects a different subset of elements within the blast cell clone, and apparently commits those elements to either the O or P pathway depending upon the presence or absence of the other bandlet. These changes in blast cell fate are coextensive with the lesion along the bandlet's length, suggesting that the interaction of the two bandlets is localized to neighboring cells.     

Determination of cleavage pattern in embryonic blast cells of the leech

The o blast cells of the leech embryo become committed to one of two alternative cleavage geometries shortly before they divide. Cleavage geometry depends upon the presence or absence of the adjoining p bandlet, and if that bandlet is ablated, the pattern of o blast cell cleavages will undergo an abrupt transition several hours later. Previous work has shown that the oblast cell becomes committed to the formation of a particular complement of postmitotic descendants early in its differentiation, but the present findings suggest that cleavage pattern and descendant fate are determined at separate commitment events.     

Developmental origin of segmental differences in the leech ectoderm: survival and differentiation of the distal tubule cell is determined by the host segment

The body plan of the adult leech is metameric, with each hemisegmental complement of ectodermal and mesodermal tissues being produced from a set of seven serially repeated embryonic blast cells. Previous studies have shown that homologous o blast cells give rise to an almost identical complement of descendant cells in each of the 21 abdominal segments, but that one o blast cell derivative--the distalmost cell of the nephridial tubule--is only present in 15 abdominal segments in the mature leech. Here we show that all o blast cells generate a presumptive distal tubule cell and that this cell migrates to its normal position in all abdominal segments. However, in segments which normally do not contain the mesodermal portion of the nephridium, the distal tubule cell dies before undergoing its terminal morphological differentiation. To ascertain whether the fate of the distal tubule cell is determined by its lineage history or by the segmental environment into which it is born, we utilized a previously described procedure for altering the segmental register between different embryonic cell lines. This procedure allowed us to effectively transplant o blast cells into more posterior segments prior to the cell divisions which generate their descendant clones. The results indicate that the survival or death of the distal tubule cell is determined by the identity of the host segment and that a given distal tubule cell could be effectively murdered or rescued by slipping its blast cell precursor into an appropriate segment. These findings suggest that the segment-specific pattern of distal tubule cell survival is not inherent to the O cell line, but arises from interactions with surrounding tissues.     

A distinct patterning mechanism of O and P cell fates in the development of the rostral segments of the leech Helobdella robusta: implications for the evolutionary dissociation of developmental pathway and morphological outcome

Despite a high degree of homonomy in the segmental organization of the ectoderm, the body plan of the leech is divided into two zones based on the distinct cell lineage patterns that give rise to the O/P portion of the segmental ectoderm. In the midbody and caudal segments, each segmental repeat of ectoderm arises in part from one 'o' blast cell and one 'p' blast cell. These two blast cells are positionally specified to distinct O and P fates, and give rise to differentiated descendant cells called O and P pattern elements, respectively. In the rostral segments, each segmental repeat of O and P pattern elements arises from a single 'op' blast cell. Based on their developmental fates and their responses to the ablation of neighboring cells, the granddaughters of the primary op blast cell are categorized into two O-type cells and two P-type cells. The O-type cells do not require the presence of the rest of the op blast cell clone for their normal development. By contrast, normal development of the P-type cells depends upon interactions with the other OP sublineages. Additional experiments showed that the O-type cells are the source of a repressive signal involved in the normal fate specification of the P-type cells. Our data suggest that the cell interactions involved in fate specification differ substantially in the rostral and midbody segments, even though the set of differentiated descendants produced by the rostral OP pathway and the midbody O and P pathways are very similar.     

Establishment of segment polarity in the ectoderm of the leech Helobdella

The segmented ectoderm and mesoderm of the leech arise via a stereotyped cell lineage from embryonic stem cells called teloblasts. Each teloblast gives rise to a column of primary blast cell daughters, and the blast cells generate descendant clones that serve as the segmental repeats of their particular teloblast lineage. We have examined the mechanism by which the leech primary blast cell clones acquire segment polarity - i.e. a fixed sequence of positional values ordered along the anteroposterior axis of the segmental repeat. In the O and P teloblast lineages, the earliest divisions of the primary blast cell segregate anterior and posterior cell fates along the anteroposterior axis. Using a laser microbeam, we ablated single cells from both o and p blast cell clones at stages when the clone was two to four cells in length. The developmental fate of the remaining cells was characterized with rhodamine-dextran lineage tracer. Twelve different progeny cells were ablated, and in every case the ablation eliminated the normal descendants of the ablated cell while having little or no detectable effect on the developmental fate of the remaining cells. This included experiments in which we specifically ablated those blast cell progeny that are known to express the engrailed gene, or their lineal precursors. These findings confirm and extend a previous study by showing that the establishment of segment polarity in the leech ectoderm is largely independent of cell interactions conveyed along the anteroposterior axis. Both intercellular signaling and engrailed expression play an important role in the segment polarity specification of the Drosophila embryo, and our findings suggest that there may be little or no conservation of this developmental mechanism between those two organisms.     

Epidermal cell lineage.

The epidermis is a stratified squamous epithelium, which is under a constant state of proliferation, commitment, differentiation, and elimination so that the functional integrity of the tissue is maintained. The intact epidermis has the ability to respond to diverse environmental stimuli by continuous turnover to maintain its normal homeostasis throughout an organism's life. This is achieved by a tightly regulated balance between stem cell self-renewal and the generation of a population of cells that undergo a limited number of more rapid (amplifying) transit divisions before giving rise to nonproliferative, terminally differentiating cells. This process makes it an excellent model system to study lineage, commitment, and differentiation, although neither the identity of epidermal stem cells nor the precise steps and regulators that lead to mature epidermal cells have yet been determined. Furthermore, the identities of genes that initiate epidermal progenitor commitment to the epidermal lineage, from putative epidermal stem cells, are unknown. This is mainly due to the lack of an in vitro model system, as well as the lack of specific reagents, to study the early events in epidermal lineage. Our recent development of a differentiating embryonic stem cell model for epidermal lineage now offers the opportunity to analyze the factors that regulate epidermal lineage. These studies will provide new insight into epidermal lineage and lead to a better understanding of various hyperproliferative skin diseases such as psoriasis and cancer.     

Applications of mRNA injections for analyzing cell lineage and asymmetric cell divisions during segmentation in the leech Helobdella robusta

Synthetic mRNAs can be injected to achieve transient gene expression even for 'non-model' organisms in which genetic approaches are not feasible. Here, we have used this technique to express proteins that can serve as lineage tracers or reporters of cellular events in embryos of the glossiphoniid leech Helobdella robusta (phylum Annelida). As representatives of the proposed super-phylum Lophotrochozoa, glossiphoniid leeches are of interest for developmental and evolutionary comparisons. Their embryos are suitable for microinjection, but no genetic approaches are currently available. We have injected segmentation stem cells (teloblasts) with mRNAs encoding nuclear localized green fluorescent protein (nGFP) and its spectral variants, and have used tandem injections of nGFP mRNA followed by antisense morpholino oligomer (AS MO), to label single blast cell clones. These techniques permit high resolution cell lineage tracing in living embryos. We have applied them to the primary neurogenic (N) lineage, in which alternate segmental founder cells (nf and ns blast cells) contribute distinct sets of progeny to the segmental ganglia. The nf and ns blast cell clones exhibit strikingly different cell division patterns: the increase in cell number within the nf clone is roughly linear, while that in the ns clone is almost exponential. To analyze spindle dynamics in the asymmetric divisions of individual blast cells, we have injected teloblasts with mRNA encoding a tau::GFP fusion protein. Our results show that the asymmetric divisions of n blast cells result from a posterior shift of both the spindle within the cell and the midbody within the mitotic spindle, with differential regulation of these processes between nf and ns.     

Cell lineage,cell-cell interaction,and segment formation in the ectoderm of a glossiphoniid leech embryo

Cell division patterns and cell-cell interactions in the germinal bands of the glossiphoniid leech Helobdella triserialis were studied with the aid of a cell lineage tracer dye. Each germinal band of the Helobdella embryo consists of five columns, or bandlets, of primary blast cells, designated as the mesodermal m bandlet and ectodermal n, o, p, and q bandlets. Primary blast cells of each ectodermal bandlet appear to undergo stereotyped, lineage-specific cell divisions. The metameric segmentation pattern of the leech thus appears to arise through a series of segmentally iterated, stereotyped cell divisions of serially homologous primary blast cell clones. Cell-cell interactions were studied by means of cell ablations. With one exception, blast cells underwent their stereotyped divisions without regard to the presence or absence of their normal neighbors. In the one exceptional case, o blast cells underwent divisions normally characteristic of p blast cells when their normal neighboring p bandlet was deleted. However, both o and p blast cells underwent their normal stereotyped divisions when their neighboring m, n, and q bandlets were deleted. It is proposed that the differential choice of pathway by the o and p blast cells depends upon their relative position with respect to each other and to a polarity cue external to the germinal band.     

Myogenic stem cell commitment probability remains constant as a function of organismal and mitotic age

Chicken myogenic stem cells can undergo symmetric and asymmetric cell divisions. Symmetric divisions produce two stem cells or two cells committed to terminal muscle differentiation. Asymmetric divisions produce one stem cell and one committed cell. Committed cells undergo four divisions, and their progeny differentiate into postmitotic, biochemically distinct muscle cells, which can be identified immunocytochemically. The control of stem cell commitment was investigated in vitro by means of cell cloning and subcloning experiments, and computer modeling. We found that stem cell commitment is a process which can be modeled as a stochastic event, with a central tendency or probability of 0.2 +/- 0.1. This value is independent of organismal or mitotic age of the stem cells, cell density, or growth in a mitogen-poor environment. Myogenic stem cells stop dividing after approximately 30 divisions in vitro. Since the probability of commitment to terminal differentiation remains below 0.5, clonal senescence and terminal differentiation are separate processes in this system.     

C. elegans POP-1/TCF functions in a canonical Wnt pathway that controls cell migration and in a noncanonical Wnt pathway that controls cell polarity

In Caenorhabditis elegans, Wnt signaling pathways are important in controlling cell polarity and cell migrations. In the embryo, a novel Wnt pathway functions through a (beta)-catenin homolog, WRM-1, to downregulate the levels of POP-1/Tcf in the posterior daughter of the EMS blastomere. The level of POP-1 is also lower in the posterior daughters of many anteroposterior asymmetric cell divisions during development. I have found that this is the case for of a pair of postembryonic blast cells in the tail. In wild-type animals, the level of POP-1 is lower in the posterior daughters of the two T cells, TL and TR. Furthermore, in lin-44/Wnt mutants, in which the polarities of the T cell divisions are frequently reversed, the level of POP-1 is frequently lower in the anterior daughters of the T cells. I have used a novel RNA-mediated interference technique to interfere specifically with pop-1 zygotic function and have determined that pop-1 is required for wild-type T cell polarity. Surprisingly, none of the three C. elegans (beta)-catenin homologs appeared to function with POP-1 to control T cell polarity. Wnt signaling by EGL-20/Wnt controls the migration of the descendants of the QL neuroblast by regulating the expression the Hox gene mab-5. Interfering with pop-1 zygotic function caused defects in the migration of the QL descendants that mimicked the defects in egl-20/Wnt mutants and blocked the expression of mab-5. This suggests that POP-1 functions in the canonical Wnt pathway to control QL descendant migration and in novel Wnt pathways to control EMS and T cell polarities.     

The role of cell lineage in development

Studies of the role of cell lineage in development began in the latter part of the 19th century, fell into decline in the early part of the 20th, and were revived about 20 years ago. This recent revival was accompanied by the introduction of new and powerful analytical techniques. Concepts of importance for cell lineage studies include the principal division modes by which a cell may give rise to its descendant clone (proliferative, stem cell and diversifying); developmental determinacy, or indeterminacy, which refer to the degree to which the normal cleavage pattern of the early embryo and the developmental fate of its individual cells is, or is not, the same in specimen after specimen; commitment, which refers to the restriction of the developmental potential of a pluripotent embryonic cell; and equivalence group, which refers to two or more equivalently pluripotent cell clones that normally take on different fates but of which under abnormal conditions one clone can take on the fate of another. Cell lineage can be inferred to have a causative role in developmental cell fate in embryos in which induced changes in cell division patterns lead to changes in cell fate. Moreover, such a causative role of cell lineage is suggested by cases where homologous cell types characteristic of a symmetrical and longitudinally metameric body plan arise via homologous cell lineages. The developmental pathways of commitment to particular cell fates proceed according to a mixed typologic and topographic hierarchy, which appears to reflect an evolutionary compromise between maximizing the ease of ordering the spatial distribution of the determinants of commitment and minimizing the need for migration of differentially committed embryonic cells. Comparison of the developmental cell lineages in leeches and insects indicates that the early course of embryogenesis is radically different in these phyletically related taxa. This evolutionary divergence of the course of early embryogenesis appears to be attributable to an increasing prevalence of polyclonal rather than monoclonal commitment in the phylogenetic line leading from an annelid-like ancestor to insects.     

Cell lineage analysis of pattern formation in the Tubifex embryo. I. Segmentation in the mesoderm.

Annelids are strongly segmented animals that display a high degree of metamerism in their body plan. The embryonic origin of metameric segmentation was examined in an oligochaete annelid Tubifex using lineage tracers. Segmental organization arises sequentially in the anterior-to-posterior direction along the longitudinal axis of the mesodermal germ band, a coherent column of primary blast cells that are produced from the mesodermal teloblast. Shortly after its birth, each primary blast cell undergoes a spatiotemporally stereotyped sequence of cell divisions to generate three classes of cells (in terms of cell size), which together give rise to a distinct cell cluster. Each cluster is composed of descendants of a single primary blast cell; there is no intermingling of cells between adjacent clusters. Relatively small-sized cells in each cluster become localized at its periphery, and they form coelomic walls including an intersegmental septum to establish individuality of segments. A set of cell ablation experiments showed that these features of mesodermal segmentation are not affected by the absence of the overlying ectodermal germ band. These results suggest that each primary blast cell serves as a founder cell of each mesodermal segment and that the boundary between segments is determined autonomously. It is concluded that the metameric body plan of Tubifex arises from an initially simple organization (i.e., a linear series) of segmental founder cells.     

Stochastic branching model for hemopoietic progenitor cell differentiation

We present algebraic expressions describing the predictions of a stochastic branching model for differentiation of hemopoietic progenitor cells. The model assumes that there is a fixed probability, p (0 less than or equal to p less than or equal to 1), that commitment to a differentiative event occurs per progenitor cell division for each daughter cell. The model describes properties of in vitro hemopoietic cell differentiation including the population structure at the time the first progenitor cell becomes committed, the number of committed progenitor cells engendered by a single progenitor cell, and the probability of eventual commitment of all daughter cells derived from a single progenitor or stem cell. Application of the model to experimental data obtained from erythroid cultures suggests that the observed data can be explained by the stochastic branching model alone without making the deterministic assumption that there is a differentiative hierarchy in the lineage of the progenitors of erythropoiesis (BFU-E). The qualitative and quantitative aspects of the proposed stochastic model are discussed in conjunction with other analogous stochastic branching models.     

Nanos is required in somatic blast cell lineages in the posterior of a mollusk embryo

During animal development, blast cell lineages are generated by repeated divisions of a mother cell into a series of daughter cells, often with a specific series of distinct fates. Nanos is a translational regulator that is involved in germline development in diverse animals and also involved in somatic patterning in insects. Recently, Nanos was found to be required for maintenance of stem cell divisions in the Drosophila germline. We have found that in the mollusk Ilyanassa, Nanos messenger RNA and protein are specifically localized in the mesendodermal blast cell lineage derived from the strongly conserved 4d cell. Nanos activity is required for differentiation of multiple tissues that are derived from the 4d cell, showing that IoNanos is required for somatic development in this embryo. At the cellular level, we show that IoNanos activity is required for the highly stereotyped cleavage pattern of the 4d lineage, the proliferative capacity of the blast cells, and the marked asymmetry of the blast cell divisions. These results suggest that IoNanos is involved in regulating blast cell behaviors in the 4d lineage.     

Grandparental stem cells in leech segmentation: Differences in CDC42 expression are correlated with an alternating pattern of blast cell fates

Embryonic segmentation in clitellate annelids (oligochaetes and leeches) is a cell lineage-driven process. Embryos of these worms generate a posterior growth zone consisting of 5 bilateral pairs of identified segmentation stem cells (teloblasts), each of which produces a column of segmental founder cells (blast cells). Each blast cell generates a lineage-specific clone via a stereotyped sequence of cell divisions, which are typically unequal both in terms of the relative size of the sister cells and in the progeny to which they give rise. In two of the five teloblast lineages, including the ventralmost, primary neurogenic (N) lineage, the blast cells adopt two different fates, designated nf and ns, in exact alternation within the blast cell column; this is termed a grandparental stem cell lineage. To lay groundwork for investigating unequal divisions in the leech Helobdella, we have surveyed the Helobdella robusta genome for genes encoding orthologs of the Rho family GTPases, including the rho, rac and cdc42 sub-families, which are known to be involved in multiple processes involving cell polarization in other systems. We find that, in contrast to most other known systems the Helobdella genome contains two cdc42 orthologs, one of which is expressed at higher levels in the ns blast cells than in nf blast cells. We also demonstrate that the asymmetric divisions of the primary nf and ns blast cells are regulated by the polarized distribution of the activated form of the Cdc42 protein, rather than by the overall level of expression. Our results provide the first molecular insights into the mechanisms of the grandparental stem cell lineages, a novel, yet evolutionarily ancient stem cell division pattern. Our results also provide an example in which asymmetries in the distribution of Cdc42 activity, rather than in the overall levels of Cdc42 protein, are important regulating unequal divisions in animal cells.     

Cell lineage analysis of pattern formation in the Tubifex embryo. II. Segmentation in the ectoderm

Ectodermal segmentation in the oligochaete annelid Tubifex is a process of separation of 50-microm-wide blocks of cells from the initially continuous ectodermal germ band (GB), a cell sheet consisting of four bandlets of blast cells derived from ectoteloblasts (N, O, P and Q). In this study, using intracellular lineage tracers, we characterized the morphogenetic processes that give rise to formation of these ectodermal segments. The formation of ectodermal segments began with formation of fissures, first on the ventral side and then on the dorsal side of the GB; the unification of these fissures gave rise to separation of a 50-microm-wide block of approximately 30 cells from the ectodermal GB. A set of experiments in which individual ectoteloblasts were labeled showed that as development proceeded, an initially linear array of blast cells in each ectodermal bandlet gradually changed its shape and that its contour became indented in a lineage-specific manner. These morphogenetic changes resulted in the formation of distinct cell clumps, which were separated from the bandlet to serve as segmental elements (SEs). SEs in the N and Q lineages were each comprised of clones of two consecutive primary blast cells. In contrast, in the O and P lineages, individual blast cell clones were distributed across SE boundaries; each SE was a mixture of a part of a more anterior clone and a part of the next more posterior clone. Morphogenetic events, including segmentation, in an ectodermal bandlet proceeded normally in the absence of neighboring ectodermal bandlets. Without the underlying mesoderm, separated SEs failed to space themselves at regular intervals along the anteroposterior axis. We suggest that ectodermal segmentation in Tubifex consists of two stages, autonomous morphogenesis of each bandlet leading to generation of SEs and the ensuing mesoderm-dependent alignment of separated SEs.     

Postembryonic nongonadal cell lineages of the nematode Panagrellus redivivus: Description and comparison with those of Caenorhabditis elegans

The postembryonic nongonadal cell lineages of the nematode Panagrellus redivivus are described and compared with those of Caenorhabditis elegans. The newly hatched larvae of P. redivivus females and males and C. elegans hermaphrodites and males are very similar. An almost identical set of blast cells divides postembryonically in P. redivivus and C. elegans to produce similar changes in the neuronal, muscular, hypodermal, and digestive systems. Most of these cell lineages are invariant; however, there is substantial variability in the number of cell divisions in the relatively extensive lineages of the lateral hypodermis of P. redivivus. Typically, in P. redivivus females, 55 blast cells generate 635 surviving progeny and 29 cell deaths; in P. redivivus males, 59 blast cells generate 758 surviving progeny and 35 cell deaths. The lineages generating the cells of the male tails of P. redivivus and C. elegans are almost identical; thus, the grossly different characteristics of these structures must reflect differences in the morphogenesis of cells equivalent in lineage history. Laser ablation experiments demonstrate that the gonad induces vulva development and that cell-cell interactions are important in specifying the fates of hypodermal precursor cells. The lateral hypodermal lineages provide striking examples of the apparent construction of complex lineages from modular sublineages; one simple pattern of cell divisions and cell fates occurs 70 times in the P. redivivus female. The differences in cell lineage between P. redivivus and C. elegans are relatively minor, and many appear to have involved two types of evolutionary change: the replacement of sublineages, and the modification of sublineages by the four classes of lineage transformations previously proposed based on a comparison of P. redivivus and C. elegans gonadal cell lineages (Sternberg and Horvitz, 1981). These types of differences suggest that the genetic programming of cell lineage includes instructions specifying where and when a particular sublineage is utilized, and other instructions specifying the nature of that sublineage.