Attraction within the membrane. Forces behind transmembrane protein folding and supramolecular complex assembly

Biological membranes are fascinating two-dimensional microenvironments that exhibit unique solvent behaviours due to their varying lipid composition. Although many important bioenergetic and signalling events involve the transient or permanent assembly of membrane protein complexes, the characterization of the thermodynamic and kinetic properties behind this assembly is just beginning. In particular, the molecular forces that govern protein association within these structures remain poorly understood. An understanding of the docking of transmembrane proteins to supramolecular complexes, which will make possible the development of predictive computational tools, will require detailed knowledge of interaction forces at the atomistic or residue level. Here, I review current data on supramolecular complexes in membrane environments and make a tentative comparison between assembly processes in membranes and those driven by the hydrophobic effect in water. This comparison suggests that, in addition to being controlled by specific characteristics of the lipid molecules themselves, molecular assembly in the membrane milieu also depends more generally on the entropy of the lipid fraction.     

Correct folding of the beta-barrel of the human membrane protein VDAC requires a lipid bilayer

Spontaneous membrane insertion and folding of beta-barrel membrane proteins from an unfolded state into lipid bilayers has been shown previously only for few outer membrane proteins of Gram-negative bacteria. Here we investigated membrane insertion and folding of a human membrane protein, the isoform 1 of the voltage-dependent anion-selective channel (hVDAC1) of mitochondrial outer membranes. Two classes of transmembrane proteins with either alpha-helical or beta-barrel membrane domains are known from the solved high-resolution structures. VDAC forms a transmembrane beta-barrel with an additional N-terminal alpha-helix. We demonstrate that similar to bacterial OmpA, urea-unfolded hVDAC1 spontaneously inserts and folds into lipid bilayers upon denaturant dilution in the absence of folding assistants or energy sources like ATP. Recordings of the voltage-dependence of the single channel conductance confirmed folding of hVDAC1 to its active form. hVDAC1 developed first beta-sheet secondary structure in aqueous solution, while the alpha-helical structure was formed in the presence of lipid or detergent. In stark contrast to bacterial beta-barrel membrane proteins, hVDAC1 formed different structures in detergent micelles and phospholipid bilayers, with higher content of beta-sheet and lower content of alpha-helix when inserted and folded into lipid bilayers. Experiments with mixtures of lipid and detergent indicated that the content of beta-sheet secondary structure in hVDAC1 decreased at increased detergent content. Unlike bacterial beta-barrel membrane proteins, hVDAC1 was not stable even in mild detergents such as LDAO or dodecylmaltoside. Spontaneous folding of outer membrane proteins into lipid bilayers indicates that in cells, the main purpose of membrane-inserted or associated assembly factors may be to select and target beta-barrel membrane proteins towards the outer membrane instead of actively assembling them under consumption of energy as described for the translocons of cytoplasmic membranes.     

Quantitative characterization of the lateral distribution of membrane proteins within the lipid bilayer.

The dependence of the lateral distribution of membrane proteins on the size, protein/lipoid molar ratio, and the magnitude of the interaction potentials has been investigated by computer modeling protein-lipid distributions with Monte Carlo calculations. These results have allowed us to develop a quantitative characterization of the distribution of membrane proteins and to correlate these distributions with experimental observables. The topological arrangement of protein domains, protein plus annular lipid domains, and free lipid domains is described in terms of radial distribution, pair connectedness, and cluster distribution functions. The radial distribution functions are used to measure the distribution of intermolecular distances between protein molecules, whereas the pair connectedness functions are used to estimate the physical extension of compositional domains. It is shown that, at characteristic protein/lipid molar ratios, previously isolated domains become connected, forming domain networks that extend over the entire membrane surface. These changes in the lateral connectivity of compositional domains are paralleled by changes in the calculated lateral diffusion coefficients and might have important implications for the regulation of diffusion controlled processes within the membrane.     

Dislocation of a type I membrane protein requires interactions between membrane-spanning segments within the lipid bilayer

The human cytomegalovirus gene product US11 causes rapid degradation of class I major histocompatibility complex (MHCI) heavy chains by inducing their dislocation from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and subsequent degradation by the proteasome. This set of reactions resembles the endogenous cellular quality control pathway that removes misfolded or unassembled proteins from the ER. We show that the transmembrane domain (TMD) of US11 is essential for MHCI heavy chain dislocation, but dispensable for MHCI binding. A Gln residue at position 192 in the US11 TMD is crucial for the ubiquitination and degradation of MHCI heavy chains. Cells that express US11 TMD mutants allow formation of MHCI-beta2m complexes, but their rate of egress from the ER is significantly impaired. Further mutagenesis data are consistent with the presence of an alpha-helical structure in the US11 TMD essential for MHCI heavy chain dislocation. The failure of US11 TMD mutants to catalyze dislocation is a unique instance in which a polar residue in the TMD of a type I membrane protein is required for that protein's function. Targeting of MHCI heavy chains for dislocation by US11 thus requires the formation of interhelical hydrogen bonds within the ER membrane.     

Photogenerated reagents for membrane labeling. 2. Phenylcarbene and adamantylidene formed within the lipid bilayer

Phenylcarbene and adamantylidene have been generated photochemically from the corresponding diazirines within lipid bilayers. Reasonable yields of labeled fatty acid side chains have been observed. The products have been characterized by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and derive both from the insertion of the carbene into carbon-hydrogen bonds of saturated fatty acids and from the addition of the carbene to the carbon-carbon double bonds of unsaturated fatty acids. In contrast to the results found using phenylnitrene, the lipid labeling by carbene is not reduced by the water-soluble scavenger glutath ione. Carbenes generated from diazirines are evidently superior reagents for the photolabeling of lipids and should be useful for identifying the intrinsic hydrophobic sections of membrane proteins.     

The final stages of folding of the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin occur by kinetically indistinguishable parallel folding paths that are mediated by pH

The folding of the transmembrane protein bacteriorhodopsin that occurs during the binding of its retinal cofactor is investigated in a membrane-like environment. Changes in the retinal absorption band reveal two transient retinal-protein intermediate states, with apparent absorption maxima at 380 nm and 440 nm, respectively. Studies on a bacteriorhodopsin mutant of Lys216, which cannot bind retinal covalently, add to evidence that retinal is non-covalently bound in these intermediate states. The two retinal-protein intermediates are genuine intermediate states that form in parallel, each with an observed rate constant of 1.1 s-1. Meanwhile no formation of the folded state is detected. Folded bacteriorhodopsin, with all trans retinal covalently bound, forms from both retinal-bound intermediates with the same apparent rate constant of 0.0070 s-1 that is independent of retinal concentration. Retinal isomerisation then occurs with a rate constant of 0.00033 s-1 to give bacteriorhodopsin containing all trans and 13 cis-retinal. These results provide experimental evidence for multiple folding routes for a membrane protein that are pH dependent, with pH conditions determining the apparent folding route. These observed parallel folding paths are kinetically indistinguishable, which contrasts with most other observations of parallel folding pathways where only pathways with different kinetics have been reported. Furthermore, together with previous work, this study shows that bacteriorhodopsin has to populate at least two folding intermediates, during folding in the mixed lipid micelles investigated here, before the final fold is attained.     

A study of chemoreception based on membrane fluidity and circular dichroism of a membrane assembly model--role of protein penetrating into the lipid bilayer

We attempted to reconstitute a chemical sensing assembly by mimicking the natural constituents of cell membranes. This liposomal arrangement is able to recognize chemical stimulants by detecting perturbation of the ordered lipid bilayer due to penetration by protein molecules. It was ascertained by measuring membrane fluidity using ESR that this assembly may be able to detect individually added chemical stimulants such as short-chain-bearing odorants (isovaleric acid, isovaleraldehyde, and isoamyl alcohol etc) at a concentration of 3 x 10(-4) parts to 1 part water. This recognition mechanism may clarify both the affinity of chemical stimulants for the liposomal arrangement and the trigger action of conformational changes in poly-L-lysine (PLL) due to the penetration of the bilayer of the PLL and sodium octylsulfate complex.     

Polytopic membrane protein folding and assembly in vitro and in vivo

The insertion and folding of proteins in biological membranes during protein synthesis in vivo is fundamental to membrane biogenesis. At present, however, certain molecular aspects of this process can only be understood by complementary studies in vitro. We bring together in vitro and in vivo results, highlighting how the studies inform each other and increase our knowledge of the folding and assembly of polytopic membrane proteins. A notable recent advance is the high-resolution crystal structure of the protein machinery responsible for membrane protein insertion into the endoplasmic reticulum. This provides an opportunity to combine in vitro and in vivo studies at a more sophisticated level and address mechanistic aspects of polytopic protein insertion and folding. Quality control is another important aspect of membrane biogenesis, and we give an overview of the current understanding of this process, focusing on cystic fibrosis as a well-studied paradigm. Mutations in the associated membrane protein, the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), can cause the quality control mechanisms to prevent the mutant protein reaching its normal site of action, the cell surface. In vitro studies of CFTR shed light on the possible origins of other clinically relevant folding mutants and highlight the potential synergy between in vitro and in vivo approaches.     

Modulation of erythrocyte membrane proteins by membrane cholesterol and lipid fluidity.

Human erythrocyte membranes were enriched or depleted of cholesterol and effects on membrane proteins assessed with a membrane-impermeant sulfhydryl reagent, [35S]glutathione-maleimide. Reaction of the probe with intact cells quantifies exofacial sulfhydryl groups and reaction with leaky ghost membranes permits quantification of endofacial sulfhydryl groups. The mean endofacial sulfhydryl titer of cholesterol-enriched membranes exceeded that of cholesterol-depleted membrane by approximately 45 nmol/mg of protein or 64%. The corresponding exofacial titer of cholesterol-enriched cells was less than that of cholesterol-depleted cells by approximately 0.4 nmol/mg of protein, or 14%. Labeled membranes were examined by autoradiography of sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electropherograms to determine the labeling patterns of individual protein bands. Cholesterol enrichment enhanced the surface labeling of Coomassie brilliant blue stained bands 1,2,3, and 5, decreased the labeling of band 6, and did not change significantly that of band 4. The results demonstrate that changes in membrane cholesterol which influence lipid fluidity can alter the surface labeling of both intrinsic and extrinsic membrane proteins.     

Mechanism of generation and regulation of photopotential by bacteriorhodopsin in bimolecular lipid membrane.

Photoelectric properties of bacteriorhodopsin incorporated into a bimolecular lipid membrane were investigated with special regard to the mechanism of photoelectric field generation. It was shown that besides its proton pump and electric generator functions bacteriorhodopsin works as a possible molecular regulator of the light-induced membrane potential. When a bimolecular lipid membrane containing bacteriorhodopsin is continuously illuminated in its main visible absorption band, and afterwards by superimposed blue light matching the absorption band of the long-living photobleached bacteriorhodopsin (M412) as well, the latter either enhances or decreases the steady-state photoresponse, depending upon the intensity of the green light. Thus, the additional blue-light illumination tends to cause the resultant photoelectric membrane potential to become stabilized. Two alternative schemes are tentatively proposed for the photochemical cycle of bacteriorhodopsin whereby blue light can control photovoltage generation. A kinetic model of the proton pump and the regulation of the photoelectric membrane potential is presented. This model fits all the experimental findings, even quantitatively. From the model some kinetic and physical parameters of this light-driven pump could be determined.     

Unravelling the folding of bacteriorhodopsin

The folding mechanism of integral membrane proteins has eluded detailed study, largely as a result of the inherent difficulties in folding these proteins in vitro. The seven-transmembrane helical protein bacteriorhodopsin has, however, allowed major advances to be made, not just on the folding of this particular protein, but also on the factors governing folding of transmembrane alpha-helical proteins in general. This review focusses on kinetic and equilibrium studies of bacteriorhodopsin folding in vitro. It covers what is currently known about secondary and tertiary structure formation as well as the events accompanying retinal binding, for protein in detergent and lipid systems, including native membrane samples.     

FCS study of the thermodynamics of membrane protein insertion into the lipid bilayer chaperoned by fluorinated surfactants

Experimental determination of the free energy (ΔG) stabilizing the structure of membrane proteins (MPs) in their native environment has been hampered by the aggregation and precipitation of MPs outside the lipid bilayer. We recently demonstrated that the latter process can be prevented by the use of fluorinated surfactants, FTACs, that act as chaperones for MP insertion without partitioning in the membrane themselves. Here we combine the advantages of the chaperone-like ability of FTACs with the sensitivity of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy measurements to determine ΔG of bilayer insertion of model MPs. First, we calibrate our approach by examining the effects of chaperoned insertion on ΔG of transmembrane insertion of Annexin B12. We find that a shorter-chained surfactant, FTAC-C6, for which the working concentration range of 0.05-0.2 mM falls below CMC = 0.33 mM, has a mild effect on an apparent ΔG. In contrast, additions of a longer-chained FTAC-C8 (CMC = 0.03 mM) result in a steep and nonlinear concentration dependence of ΔG. We then apply the same methodology to the pH-triggered insertion of diphtheria toxin T-domain, which is known to be affected by nonproductive aggregation in solution. We find that the correction of the ΔG value needed to compensate for unchaperoned insertion of the T-domain exceeds 3 kcal/mole. A relatively shallow and linear dependence of the ΔG for Annexin B12 and T-domain insertion on FTAC-C6 concentration is encouraging for future applications of this surfactant in thermodynamic studies of the stability of other MPs.     

Comparison of intramolecular and intermolecular reactions in protein folding

The intrinsic component of the standard free energy change for the formation of a disulfide bond in a protein molecule is compared to that for an analogous chemical reaction. The former reaction, which represents theintramolecular formation of a disulfide bond in a protein molecule from a cysteine group containing a mixed disulfide bond with glutathione, and a free cysteine residue, is a unimolecular reaction. In contrast, its chemical analogue is a bimolecular reaction, and corresponds to theintermolecular disulfide interchange between a mixed disulfide-bonded compound between a cysteine residue and glutathione, and a free cysteine molecule. The difference in the intrinsic free energy of the above two reactions is estimated by two different approaches. First, a theoretical estimate of the magnitude of the difference in free energy of the two reactions (for a standard state of 1 M) is obtained using a gas-phase statistical thermodynamic approach, which indicates that the intramolecular reaction is energetically favored over its intermolecular counterpart by as much as 15.6 kcal/mole. For comparison, an experimentally derived value is also obtained, using experimental data from a study by Konishi et al. of the regeneration of the protein ribonuclease A (RNase A) from its reduced form by reduced and oxidized glutathiones. The intrinsic component of the free energy change of the intramolecular reaction, as it occurs in the protein molecule, is obtained from such experimental data by accounting explicitly for the free energy change (assumed to be solely an entropy change) pertaining to the conformational changes (ring closure) that the protein molecule undergoes in the course of the reaction. On the basis of the value derived from such an experimental approach, the intramolecular reaction is also energetically more favorable as compared to its intermolecular analogue, but only by a difference of 2.3 kcal/mole (for a standard state of 1 M). The large apparent discrepancy between the two values estimated from the theoretical and experimental approaches is rationalized by the postulation of several additional factors not inherent in the gas-phase theoretical estimate, such as dehydration and intramolecular hydrogen-bonding effects, which can largely compensate for the otherwise favorable energetics of the intramolecular reaction.