Mate availability affects female choice in a fish with paternal care: female counterstrategies against male filial cannibalism

Theory predicts that individuals should adopt counterstrategies against intersexual conflict with their mating partners if the counterstrategies are effective and cost-efficient. In fishes, males with parental care often cannibalize their own offspring, which reduces the female’s fitness and creates intersexual conflicts. Males of the goby Rhinogobius flumineus cannibalize more eggs in the nest when they have access to additional females prior to spawning. Thus, it is predicted that females will strategically avoid spawning with males that have high mate availability. In the present study, we experimentally tested this prediction. When sexual pairs were placed in tanks, most females (control females; 21/22) successfully spawned inside the nest. In contrast, when a gravid female (stimulus female) that was housed in a small transparent cage was shown to the experiment pairs prior to spawning, only about half of the females (experiment females; 16/29) spawned inside the nest; the remaining females released unfertilized eggs outside of the nest. Moreover, experiment females infrequently accepted and followed males into nests, and delayed spawning more often than control females. R. flumineus females prefer males that court frequently. Indeed, experiment females that infrequently received courtship tended to spawn outside of the nest. However, infrequent courtship alone could not explain outside-nest spawning, delay in spawning, or the shorter stay of females in nests. These results imply that the presence of a stimulus female dampens female spawning with males. We suggest that R. flumineus females may strategically reject or hesitate to spawn with males that have high mate availability, and that this spawning avoidance may be a counterstrategy against male filial cannibalism.     

Dummy Egg Production by Female Cardinalfish to Deceive Cannibalistic Males: Oogenesis without Vitellogenesis

Filial cannibalism occurs in a variety of taxa, especially in fish exhibit paternal care. In the Apogonidae, males mouthbrood a cohesive mass of eggs received from a single female, although the males frequently eat the entire brood. It has been recognized that a primary factor concerning entire brood cannibalism is the brood size produced by females, as the parent eats a small egg mass so long as the reproductive return does not exceed the cost of providing care. In Apogon lineatus, approximately 18% of each brood was occupied by abnormal eggs lacking yolk, which were hydrated without the vitellogenesis phase and eventually ovulated with other normal eggs as a single egg mass. By not providing yolk to some eggs within the brood, A. lineatus females may succeed in producing an apparently large brood, reducing the likelihood of entire brood cannibalism by males.     

Intentional multiple mating by females in a species where sneak fertilization circumvents female choice for parental males

This paper describes how individual female ocellated wrasse Symphodus ocellatus distribute their spawning among males and nests in space and time. It is based on previously collected genetic data of larvae from ten different nests (used to reconstruct half and full‐sibling groupings both within and among nests on multiple days) and behavioural data of marked females across the reproductive season. Both the genetic analyses and behavioural observations confirm that female S. ocellatus intentionally engage in multiple mating, by repeatedly spawning at the same nest on different days and at several different nests (up to 12 spawning events over 3 weeks), leading to mixed paternity among her young. The main benefit of such high and intentional multiple mating is probably insurance against brood failure due to nest predation, desertion or poor paternal care by the male. These findings reveal that even in systems where females attempt to avoid male‐controlled mixed paternity, they may still engage in intentional multiple mating due to these potential benefits.     

Filial Cannibalism in the Paternal Mouthbrooding Cardinalfish Apogon lineatus: Egg Production by the Female as the Nutrition Source for the Mouthbrooding Male

We investigated about filial cannibalism by Apogon lineatus based on 25 mouthbrooding males sampled in Tokyo Bay, Japan. Eggs were found in the stomachs of all mouthbrooding males, indicating that Apogon lineatus performs partial brood cannibalism. The number of eggs in the stomachs ranged from 1015 to 9384, corresponding to 30% on average of the entire brood. This study revealed that mouthbrooding males could gain considerable energy by partial brood cannibalism during brood periods, that is, females would produce surplus eggs as the nutrition sources for starving males.     

Tank spawning of first generation domestic green sturgeon

Green sturgeon Acipenser medirostris from hatchery spawned wild‐caught broodfish matured under aquaculture conditions. The first females (three out of four) matured at age 8 years, were successfully induced to ovulate by hormonal injections, and their eggs collected by caesarean surgery for fertilization. While the incision healed completely, unknown complications resulted in mortalities 5–12 months later. To minimize handling stress and to eliminate mortalities associated with surgery, a semi‐natural tank spawning technique was used in subsequent years. A female was placed into a 3.7 m diameter flat‐bottom circular fiberglass tank, depth 0.7 m, with two or three males, and the fish were injected with gonadotropin‐releasing hormone analog (GnRHa) and white sturgeon pituitary extracts to induce spawning. Fuller’s Earth was continually added to the spawning tank using a belt feeder to minimize egg adhesion to other eggs and to the tank surfaces. The tank was checked hourly for oviposition, and the eggs collected using a fine mesh dip net, every 1–3 h. Spawning lasted 15–21 h, and 53–80 000 eggs were collected from individual spawning females. Direct observation of spawning activity was not possible because of the high turbidity caused by Fuller’s Earth. However, the female and males occasionally breached at the water surface and appeared to be interacting. After oviposition was completed, viable milt was collected from all males, and fertilization success ranged from 7% to 83% in five spawning events. Over three consecutive years (2009–2011) all five females and 11 males used in semi‐natural tank spawning ovulated or spermiated, and were not subject to post‐spawning mortality. The relatively slow deposition of eggs and the continuous addition of Fuller’s Earth minimized the adhesion of eggs into large clumps. While the egg fertility and hatchability varied greatly among individual females, the tank spawning technique presented a feasible alternative to other more invasive methods for obtaining fertilized eggs of green sturgeon, and may be applicable for other sturgeons, particularly endangered species.     

Male Isaza (Gymnogobius isaza, Gobiidae) prefer large mates: a counterstrategy against brood parasitism by conspecific females

Like many other gobies, male Isaza (Gymnogobius isaza) which are endemic to Lake Biwa, Japan, exclusively care for broods in nests. This goby may have an optimal range of brood size (i.e., an average clutch size of about 2000–3000 eggs) within which they may produce larger numbers of hatching young because much larger broods may be destroyed by fungal infection before hatching. This optimal brood size hypothesis (Takahashi et al. in J Ethol 22:153–159, 2004) predicts that (1) after spawning, both males and females will refuse additional spawning by other gravid females (second females) to keep brood sizes within optimal ranges, (2) larger fish will repel second females more successfully than will smaller fish, and thus, (3) both sexes prefer larger mates. To examine these predictions, we first observed Isaza’s aggressive behaviors in aquaria and investigated whether fish attacked and repelled second females that were introduced after spawning, and, if so, what were the sizes of fish that did so. Large fish, regardless of sex, aggressively prevented second females from entering the nest, but second females larger than the pairs displaced the pair females forcibly and spawned eggs into their clutches. Mate choice experiments showed that males preferred large females. Although females’ choice of large mates was not confirmed, many results may largely coincide with the predictions of the optimal brood size hypothesis. Thus, Isaza males’ choice of large mates will be advantageous for defending against brood parasitism by conspecific females and for achieving optimal clutch size.     

The evolution of filial cannibalism and female mate choice strategies as resolutions to sexual conflict in fishes

Filial cannibalism (the consumption of one's own viable offspring) is common among fish with paternal care. In this study, I use a computer simulation to study simultaneous evolution of male filial cannibalism and female mate choice. Under certain conditions, selection on parental males favors filial cannibalism. When filial cannibalism increases a male's probability to raise the current brood successfully, filial cannibalism also benefits the female. However, when egg eating is a male investment into future reproduction, a conflict between female and male interests emerges. Here I investigate how female discrimination against filial cannibals affects evolution of filial cannibalism and how different female choice criteria perform against filial cannibalism. The introduction of discriminating females makes the fixation of filial cannibalism less likely. I introduced three different female choice criteria: (1) females who could discern a male's genotype, that is, whether the male was going to eat eggs as an investment in future reproductive events; (2) energy-choosing females that preferred to mate with males who had enough energy reserves to live through the current brood cycle without consuming eggs; and (3) females that preferred to mate with already mated males, that is, males with eggs in their nest. Genotype choice never coexisted with filial cannibals at fixation and filial cannibals were unable to invade a population with genotype-choosing females. Energy choice was successful only when males had high energy reserves and were less dependent on filial cannibalism as an alternative energy source. The egg choosers frequently coexisted with the cannibals at fixation. When the female strategies were entered simultaneously, the most frequent outcome for low mate sampling costs was that both the cannibals and the egg choice was fixed and all other strategies went extinct. These results suggest that sexual conflicts may not always evolve toward a resolution of the conflict, but sometimes the stable state retains the conflict. In the present case, this was because the egg-preference strategy had a higher fitness than the other female strategies. The outcome of this simulation is similar to empirical findings. In fish with paternal care, male filial cannibalism and female preference for mates with eggs commonly co-occur.     

Mating patterns of female Leon Springs pupfish Cyprinodon bovinus

In a field study of Leon Springs pupfish Cyprinodon bovinus, two questions about female promiscuity were investigated. First, were females selective in the males with whom they spawned or were they unselective, spawning randomly among males? Second, how promiscuous were the females, i.e. with how many males did they spawn? If simply spawning with many males maximized a female's reproductive success, then females might be expected to spawn randomly with as many males as possible. Alternatively, if females were selective but engaged in multiple mating, they would limit their spawning to preferred males. In the only wild population of this endangered fish, breeding males defend closely associated territories in the shallow margins of a single desert pool. No territories were observed elsewhere in the pool. Therefore, all territorial males were present simultaneously and females could survey all of them, depositing any number of eggs with one, a few or many males. Rather than spawning randomly, females surveyed many males first, visited relatively few males and ultimately spawned with a small fraction of those available males. With increasing numbers of spawns, however, females increased the number of different mates with whom they spawned. Thus, females showed a bet‐hedging tactic of having a narrow mate preference while also laying eggs in the territories of other males, possibly to reduce egg predation and to avoid inbreeding.     

Hurry-up and hatch: selective filial cannibalism of slower developing eggs

Filial cannibalism (the consumption of one's own offspring) is thought to represent an adaptive strategy in many animals. However, little is known about the details of which offspring are consumed when a parent cannibalizes. Here, we examined patterns of within-brood filial cannibalism in the sand goby (Pomatoschistus minutus). Males spawned sequentially with two females, and we asked whether males cannibalized selectively with regard to egg size or the order in which eggs were received. Males preferentially consumed the larger eggs of the second female they spawned with. Because larger eggs took longer to hatch, and because female 2's eggs were up to 1 day behind those of female 1, such preferential cannibalism might allow males to decrease the time spent caring for the current brood and re-enter the mating pool sooner. More work is needed to understand the fitness consequences of such selective cannibalism.     

Seasonal pattern of filial cannibalism by Apogon doederleini mouthbrooding males

In temperate waters of southern Japan, mouthbrooding males of the cardinal fish Apogon doederleini sometimes ate their entire brood within a day of spawning. In spite of annual variation in age structure and length of the breeding season, however, the annual cannibalism rate (broods cannibalized to total broods spawned) was nearly constant, 12–16%. Fish 1 year old frequently cannibalized early broods of the season, especially the first brood, whereas the cannibalism rate by 2 year-old fish did not vary within the season. In contrast, the cannibalism by older males increased late in the season. This tendency was attributed to their different allocation patterns to growth and reproduction. For 1 year-old fish, which can enhance future reproductive success by growth and cannibalizing on early broods instead of mouthbrooding (at relatively low temperatures), this may be a tactic for investing energy in growth. For fish 3 years, which have more breeding cycles and grow little, cannibalizing late broods may be energetic compensation for their poor somatic condition. No seasonal variation of cannibalism by 2 year-old fish can be explained by their intermediate nature of growth and reproduction. Multiple mate availability is one factor facilitating the cannibalism by 2 and 3 + year-old fish whose operational sex ratio is female-biased.     

Sound production and associated behavior in a cichlid fish,Cichlasoma centrarchus. II. Breeding pairs

Synopsis Pairs of Cichlasoma centrarchus were observed daily in the laboratory. Both males and females made sounds during a breeding cycle but all sounds were aggressive in context; no sounds were heard to accompany courtship. Males made more sounds before spawning than afterwards and these were associated with territorial defense and with establishment of dominance over the female. Females produced more sounds after spawning than before, most in the context of brood defense but some toward the male during pre-spawning nest preparation. Prior to spawning, the number of sounds made by the males toward their mates increased but the aggressive actions accompanying them became less intense. No such inverse correlation of agonistic intensity with number of sounds made was found for the females. From this study and earlier ones by the author it was concluded that sound in this species is a threat display which 1) provides an expression for agonism alternative to the performance of actions which could injure the female or drive her away, and 2) lessens the risk of injury to male or female during territory or brood defense.     

Intensive genetic assessment of the mating system and reproductive success in a semi-closed population of the mottled sculpin,Cottus bairdi

Most genetic surveys of parentage in nature sample only a small fraction of the breeding population. Here we apply microsatellite markers to deduce the genetic mating system and assess the reproductive success of females and males in an extensively collected, semi-closed stream population of the mottled sculpin fish, Cottus bairdi. In this species, males guard nest rocks where females deposit the eggs for fertilization. The potential exists for both males and females to mate with multiple partners and for males to provide parental care to genetically unrelated offspring. Four hundred and fifty-five adults and subadults, as well as 1,259 offspring from 23 nests, were genotyped at five polymorphic microsatellite loci. Multilocus maternal genotypes, deduced via genetic analyses of embryos, were reconstructed for more than 90% of the analysed nests, thus allowing both male and female reproductive success to be estimated accurately. There was no genetic evidence for cuckoldry, but one nest probably represents a takeover event. Successful males spawned with a mean of 2.8 partners, whereas each female apparently deposited her entire clutch of eggs in a single nest (mean fecundity = 66 eggs/female). On average, genetically deduced sires and dams were captured 1.6 and 9.3 metres from their respective nests, indicating little movement by breeders during the spawning season. Based on a 'genetic mark-recapture' estimate, the total number of potentially breeding adults (c. 570) was an order-of-magnitude larger than genetically based estimates of the effective number of breeders (c. 54). In addition, significantly fewer eggs per female were deposited in single than in multidam nests. Not only were perceived high-quality males spawning with multiple partners, but they were receiving more eggs from each female.     

Filial cannibalism by mouthbrooding males of the cardinal fish,Apogon doederleini, in relation to their physical condition

Synopsis Paternal brood cannibalism was observed in a population ofApogon doederleini in Shikoku Island, Japan. Of 361 egg masses mouthbrooded by males, 47 disappeared within a day of spawning. A stomach check with a syringe ascertained that they had been consumed by the males. The frequency of this cannibalism increased as the breeding season advanced. As males completed 4–7 breeding cycles in a breeding season and spent 80% of the time mouthbrooding without taking ordinary food, their physical condition deteriorated greatly late in the breeding season. We concluded that parental physical condition is an important factor in the occurrence of brood cannibalism.     

Paternal inheritance of growth in fish pursuing alternative reproductive tactics

In species with indeterminate growth, age‐related size variation of reproductive competitors within each sex is often high. This selects for divergence in reproductive tactics of same‐sex competitors, particularly in males. Where alternative tactics are fixed for life, the causality of tactic choice is often unclear. In the African cichlid Lamprologus callipterus, large nest males collect and present empty snail shells to females that use these shells for egg deposition and brood care. Small dwarf males attempt to fertilize eggs by entering shells in which females are spawning. The bourgeois nest males exceed parasitic dwarf males in size by nearly two orders of magnitude, which is likely to result from greatly diverging growth patterns. Here, we ask whether growth patterns are heritable in this species, or whether and to which extent they are determined by environmental factors. Standardized breeding experiments using unrelated offspring and maternal half‐sibs revealed highly divergent growth patterns of male young sired by nest or dwarf males, whereas the growth of female offspring of both male types did not differ. As expected, food had a significant modifying effect on growth, but neither the quantity of breeding substrate in the environment nor ambient temperature affected growth. None of the environmental factors tested influenced the choice of male life histories. We conclude that in L. callipterus growth rates of bourgeois and parasitic males are paternally inherited, and that male and female growth is phenotypically plastic to only a small degree.     

Female mate choice through spawning parade formed by male-male competition in filefishRudarius ercodes

In the small filefishRudarius ercodes inhabiting temperatre seaweed beds, 2–10 males follow a gravid female, in a line until spawning early in the morning. Formation of the spawning parade and change of male order were investigated in a large aquarium. Males competed for the position nearest to the female during the parade, while the female controlled the parade by her swimming speed and course. During the parade, male members and their order changed frequently. The male order in the parade was related with the intensity of nuptial coloration, which changed according to the social rank. The female sometimes tried to take a spawning posture but rejected spawning when male positioning was not good for her, for example, far different from parading order. The female spawned with 2–5 males on each side. The nearest mating positions to the female were usually occupied by two males that had been staying at an anterior position in the parade for a long time. During the spawning parade over a long distance and time, females ofR. ercodes can choose multiple suitable males in a variable environment like a temperate seaweed bed.     

Mate Choice and Mating Pattern in a Stream Goby of the Genus Rhinogobius

The mate choice and mating pattern of a benthic goby Rhinogobius sp. CB (cross band type) were investigated in the Kamo River, Shikoku, Japan. During the breeding season, gravid females assumed a nuptial color and either males or females initiated a courtship display. Males preferentially courted a female of similar size to lead her to his nest, whereas females courted more frequently when they encountered a large male. Eggs in any one nest were always at the same developmental stage. Sampling data of nesting males and females indicated that, in more than half the nests, males gathered more than one female before spawning. In some nests with eggs, two or three females had spent ovaries, indicating that the eggs were laid by multiple females within a short span of time. However, a comparison between the total number of eggs which females would spawn in one nest and the number of eggs actually deposited suggested that eggs were contributed by one female in most nests. This low level of polygyny in spite of multiple female availability is attributed to a limited available spawning area of the nest.     

Mate Choice and Spawning Success in the Fighting Fish Betta splendens: the Importance of Body Size, Display Behavior and Nest Size

Courtship displays should be exaggerated enough to attract mates and yet tempered so as not to deter them. We tested this hypothesis in the fighting fish Betta splendens by studying courtship displays and body size and their relationships with male parental quality and female fecundity, as well as the effects of display behavior and body size on mate choice decisions and spawning success. Because of their high degree of parental investment, males are expected to be discriminating in their choice of mates. Males who displayed more frequently built larger nests, a measure of parental quality, but larger males did not. When females were paired with males with high display rates, however, the pair had fewer eggs in their nest, even when accounting for female body mass. In a mate choice test using computer‐generated male stimuli that differed only in display behavior, females showed no preferences for displaying males vs. non‐displaying males, or for males with higher display rates vs. lower display rates. In similar tests in which the computer‐generated males differed only in size, females preferred larger males, but also preferred males that differed with respect to body size (negative assortative mating). Males preferred computer‐generated females that performed courtship displays over non‐displaying females, but showed no preferences for female body size. Neither a female's body size nor her display behavior was a significant predictor of her fecundity as estimated by the number of eggs released during spawning. Thus, our results suggest that female B. splendens must balance male parental quality (nest size) with the risk of potentially disruptive or dangerous behavior during spawning, and that females may minimize these risks through negative size‐assortative mating. Female display behavior, while unrelated to fecundity in our study, may attract males because it indicates reproductive readiness or serves a species‐recognition function.     

Double brooding and offspring desertion in the barn owl Tyto alba

Many bird species produce two annual broods during a single breeding season. However, not all individuals reproduce twice in the same year suggesting that double brooding is condition‐dependent. In contrast to most raptors and owls, the barn owl Tyto alba produces two annual clutches in most worldwide distributed populations. Nevertheless, the determinants of double brooding are still poorly studied. We performed such a study in a Swiss barn owl population monitored between 1990 and 2014. The annual frequency of double brooding varied from 0 to 14% for males and 0 to 59% for females. The likelihood of double brooding was higher when individuals initiated their first clutch early rather than late in the season and when males had few rather than many offspring at the first nest. Despite the reproductive benefits of double brooding (single‐ and double‐brooded individuals produced 3.97 ± 0.11 and 7.07 ± 0.24 fledglings, respectively), double brooding appears to be traded off against offspring quality because at the first nest double‐brooded males produced poorer quality offspring than single‐brooded males. This might explain why females desert their first mate to produce a second brood with another male without jeopardizing reproductive success at the first nest. Furthermore, the reproductive cycle being very long in the barn owl (120 d from start of laying to offspring independence), selection may have favoured behaviours that accelerate the initiation of a second annual brood. Accordingly, half of the double‐brooded females abandoned their young offspring to look for a new partner in order to initiate the second breeding attempt, 9.48 d earlier than when producing the second brood with the same partner. We conclude that male and female barn owls adopt different reproductive strategies. Females have more opportunities to reproduce twice in a single season than males because mothers are not strictly required during the entire rearing period in contrast to fathers. A high proportion of male floaters may also encourage females to desert their first brood to re‐nest with a new male who is free of parental care duties.     

Parental investment of male two-spotted goby, Gobiusculus flavescens (Fabricius)

The trade-off between parental care and feeding was studied in the male two-spotted goby (Gobiusculus flavescens F.). Two temperatures, 8.5 degrees C and 13.0 degrees C, were used, with five replicates at each temperature, in order to determine whether temperature influenced parental behaviour. In each replicate, two males and four females were introduced to an aquarium, where the males chose between two nests and courted the females. In each replicate, one male spawned. After spawning, the males guarded the eggs until hatching. The guarding males' behaviour was recorded with a video camera twice a day (15 min each time), once before and once after they were fed. The male's condition (c-factor) was calculated at the start of the experiment and after egg hatching. The eggs were spawned in an artificial nest (half of a PVC tube), and attached to the nest in a single layer. The areas with eggs (representing brood size) were marked after spawning and the fry counted after hatching (which was used to calculate area hatched). Numbers of prey eaten (plankton) and number of aggressive encounters between the guarding male and the other fishes were recorded. Time spent in the nest and time used on fertilisation, fanning and cleaning were estimated and related to egg age, brood size, hatching success, temperature and food availability (no food or food).The results showed that feeding (expected to influence future reproduction) decreased and parental expenditure (current reproduction) increased, as the eggs developed (became closer to independence). Parental expenditure was significantly higher at 13.0 degrees C than at 8.5 degrees C, presumably due to higher oxygen demands by the eggs, and a greater risk of egg-infections. The c-factor of the males guarding eggs decreased over time, in contrast to the non-guarding males' c-factor. Guarding males' aggressiveness decreased as the eggs got older, but increased just before hatching. A possible explanation for this could be the decreasing intrusion by the non-guarding male and females caused by high aggressive behaviour by the guarding male early in the brood cycle. The exploitation of the nest (percentage of total nest area covered by eggs) seemed to determine the amount of parental expenditure and loss of condition, while brood size (area of eggs) had no effect.     

Cannibalism on eggs by dark chub, Zacco temmincki (Temminck & Schlegel) (Cyprinidae)

During spawning male dark chub, Zacco temmincki (Temminck & Schlegel), buried eggs by stirring up the river bed with their anal fins. No parental care was shown for eggs after spawning. Many satellites (both males and females) preyed upon eggs at the instant of spawning. The number of eggs produced is a function of body length [log₁₀ E =−0.273+3.519log₁₀ S , where E is the number of eggs and S is standard length (cm)]. From the size distribution of females that spawned during a reproductive season, the total number of spawning sites used and mean number of eggs per spawning site, at least 97.1% eggs were estimated to be consumed by cannibalism. This marked cannibalism resulted from a lack of parental care and the presence of many satellites produced by the polygynous mating system.