FLORA: A Novel Method to Predict Protein Function from Structure in Diverse Superfamilies

Predicting protein function from structure remains an active area of interest, particularly for the structural genomics initiatives where a substantial number of structures are initially solved with little or no functional characterisation. Although global structure comparison methods can be used to transfer functional annotations, the relationship between fold and function is complex, particularly in functionally diverse superfamilies that have evolved through different secondary structure embellishments to a common structural core. The majority of prediction algorithms employ local templates built on known or predicted functional residues. Here, we present a novel method (FLORA) that automatically generates structural motifs associated with different functional sub-families (FSGs) within functionally diverse domain superfamilies. Templates are created purely on the basis of their specificity for a given FSG, and the method makes no prior prediction of functional sites, nor assumes specific physico-chemical properties of residues. FLORA is able to accurately discriminate between homologous domains with different functions and substantially outperforms (a 2–3 fold increase in coverage at low error rates) popular structure comparison methods and a leading function prediction method. We benchmark FLORA on a large data set of enzyme superfamilies from all three major protein classes (α, β, αβ) and demonstrate the functional relevance of the motifs it identifies. We also provide novel predictions of enzymatic activity for a large number of structures solved by the Protein Structure Initiative. Overall, we show that FLORA is able to effectively detect functionally similar protein domain structures by purely using patterns of structural conservation of all residues.     

PASS2: a semi-automated database of Protein Alignments Organised as Structural Superfamilies

PASS2 is a nearly automated version of CAMPASS and contains sequence alignments of proteins grouped at the level of superfamilies. This database has been created to fall in correspondence with SCOP database (1.53 release) and currently consists of 110 multi-member superfamilies and 613 superfamilies corresponding to single members. In multi-member superfamilies, protein chains with no more than 25% sequence identity have been considered for the alignment and hence the database aims to address sequence alignments which represent 26 219 protein domains under the SCOP 1.53 release. Structure-based sequence alignments have been obtained by COMPARER and the initial equivalences are provided automatically from a MALIGN alignment and subsequently augmented using STAMP4.0. The final sequence alignments have been annotated for the structural features using JOY4.0. Several interesting links are provided to other related databases and genome sequence relatives. Availability of reliable sequence alignments of distantly related proteins, despite poor sequence identity and single-member superfamilies, permit better sampling of structures in libraries for fold recognition of new sequences and for the understanding of protein structure–function relationships of individual superfamilies. The database can be queried by keywords and also by sequence search, interfaced by PSI-BLAST methods. Structure-annotated sequence alignments and several structural accessory files can be retrieved for all the superfamilies including the user-input sequence. The database can be accessed from http://www.ncbs.res.in/%7Efaculty/mini/campass/pass.html.     

Assigning genomic sequences to CATH

We report the latest release (version 1.6) of the CATH protein domains database (http://www.biochem.ucl. ac.uk/bsm/cath ). This is a hierarchical classification of 18 577 domains into evolutionary families and structural groupings. We have identified 1028 homo-logous superfamilies in which the proteins have both structural, and sequence or functional similarity. These can be further clustered into 672 fold groups and 35 distinct architectures. Recent developments of the database include the generation of 3D templates for recognising structural relatives in each fold group, which has led to significant improvements in the speed and accuracy of updating the database and also means that less manual validation is required. We also report the establishment of the CATH-PFDB (Protein Family Database), which associates 1D sequences with the 3D homologous superfamilies. Sequences showing identifiable homology to entries in CATH have been extracted from GenBank using PSI-BLAST. A CATH-PSIBLAST server has been established, which allows you to scan a new sequence against the database. The CATH Dictionary of Homologous Superfamilies (DHS), which contains validated multiple structural alignments annotated with consensus functional information for evolutionary protein superfamilies, has been updated to include annotations associated with sequence relatives identified in GenBank. The DHS is a powerful tool for considering the variation of functional properties within a given CATH superfamily and in deciding what functional properties may be reliably inherited by a newly identified relative.     

Regions of minimal structural variation among members of protein domain superfamilies: application to remote homology detection and modelling using distant relationships

Structurally conserved regions or structural templates have been identified and examined for features such as amino acid content, solvent accessibility, secondary structures, non-polar interaction, residue packing and extent of structural deviations in 179 aligned members of superfamilies involving 1208 pairs of protein domains. An analysis of these structural features shows that the retention of secondary structural conservation and similar hydrogen bonding pattern within the templates is 2.5 and 1.8 times higher, respectively, than full-length alignments suggesting that they form the minimum structural requirement of a superfamily. The identification and availability of structural templates find value in different areas of protein structure prediction and modelling such as in sensitive sequence searches, accurate sequence alignment and three-dimensional modelling on the basis of distant relationships.     

Improving the quality of twilight-zone alignments

Several recent publications illustrated advantages of using sequence profiles in recognizing distant homologies between proteins. At the same time, the practical usefulness of distant homology recognition depends not only on the sensitivity of the algorithm, but also on the quality of the alignment between a prediction target and the template from the database of known proteins. Here, we study this question for several supersensitive protein algorithms that were previously compared in their recognition sensitivity (Rychlewski et al., 2000). A database of protein pairs with similar structures, but low sequence similarity is used to rate the alignments obtained with several different methods, which included sequence-sequence, sequence-profile, and profile-profile alignment methods. We show that incorporation of evolutionary information encoded in sequence profiles into alignment calculation methods significantly increases the alignment accuracy, bringing them closer to the alignments obtained from structure comparison. In general, alignment quality is correlated with recognition and alignment score significance. For every alignment method, alignments with statistically significant scores correlate with both correct structural templates and good quality alignments. At the same time, average alignment lengths differ in various methods, making the comparison between them difficult. For instance, the alignments obtained by FFAS, the profile-profile alignment algorithm developed in our group are always longer that the alignments obtained with the PSI-BLAST algorithms. To address this problem, we develop methods to truncate or extend alignments to cover a specified percentage of protein lengths. In most cases, the elongation of the alignment by profile-profile methods is reasonable, adding fragments of similar structure. The examples of erroneous alignment are examined and it is shown that they can be identified based on the model quality.     

Prediction of functional sites by analysis of sequence and structure conservation

We present a method for prediction of functional sites in a set of aligned protein sequences. The method selects sites which are both well conserved and clustered together in space, as inferred from the 3D structures of proteins included in the alignment. We tested the method using 86 alignments from the NCBI CDD database, where the sites of experimentally determined ligand and/or macromolecular interactions are annotated. In agreement with earlier investigations, we found that functional site predictions are most successful when overall background sequence conservation is low, such that sites under evolutionary constraint become apparent. In addition, we found that averaging of conservation values across spatially clustered sites improves predictions under certain conditions: that is, when overall conservation is relatively high and when the site in question involves a large macromolecular binding interface. Under these conditions it is better to look for clusters of conserved sites than to look for particular conserved sites.     

Fold predictions for bacterial genomes

Fold assignments for newly sequenced genomes belong to the most important and interesting applications of the booming field of protein structure prediction. We present a brief survey and a discussion of such assignments completed to date, using as an example several fold assignment projects for proteins from the Escherichia coli genome. This review focuses on steps that are necessary to go beyond the simple assignment projects and into the development of tools extending our understanding of functions of proteins in newly sequenced genomes. This paper also discusses several problems seldom addressed in the literature, such as the problem of domain prediction and complementary predictions (e.g., transmembrane regions and flexible regions) and cross-correlation of predictions from different servers. The influence of sequence and structure database growth on prediction success is also addressed. Finally, we discuss the perspectives of the field in the context of massive sequence and structure determination projects, as well as the development of novel prediction methods.     

Using the CATH domain database to assign structures and functions to the genome sequences

The CATH database of protein structures contains approximately 18000 domains organized according to their (C)lass, (A)rchitecture, (T)opology and (H)omologous superfamily. Relationships between evolutionary related structures (homologues) within the database have been used to test the sensitivity of various sequence search methods in order to identify relatives in Genbank and other sequence databases. Subsequent application of the most sensitive and efficient algorithms, gapped blast and the profile based method, Position Specific Iterated Basic Local Alignment Tool (PSI-BLAST), could be used to assign structural data to between 22 and 36 % of microbial genomes in order to improve functional annotation and enhance understanding of biological mechanism. However, on a cautionary note, an analysis of functional conservation within fold groups and homologous superfamilies in the CATH database, revealed that whilst function was conserved in nearly 55% of enzyme families, function had diverged considerably, in some highly populated families. In these families, functional properties should be inherited far more cautiously and the probable effects of substitutions in key functional residues carefully assessed.     

Identification of functional subclasses in the DJ-1 superfamily proteins

Genomics has posed the challenge of determination of protein function from sequence and/or 3-D structure. Functional assignment from sequence relationships can be misleading, and structural similarity does not necessarily imply functional similarity. Proteins in the DJ-1 family, many of which are of unknown function, are examples of proteins with both sequence and fold similarity that span multiple functional classes. THEMATICS (theoretical microscopic titration curves), an electrostatics-based computational approach to functional site prediction, is used to sort proteins in the DJ-1 family into different functional classes. Active site residues are predicted for the eight distinct DJ-1 proteins with available 3-D structures. Placement of the predicted residues onto a structural alignment for six of these proteins reveals three distinct types of active sites. Each type overlaps only partially with the others, with only one residue in common across all six sets of predicted residues. Human DJ-1 and YajL from Escherichia coli have very similar predicted active sites and belong to the same probable functional group. Protease I, a known cysteine protease from Pyrococcus horikoshii, and PfpI/YhbO from E. coli, a hypothetical protein of unknown function, belong to a separate class. THEMATICS predicts a set of residues that is typical of a cysteine protease for Protease I; the prediction for PfpI/YhbO bears some similarity. YDR533Cp from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, of unknown function, and the known chaperone Hsp31 from E. coli constitute a third group with nearly identical predicted active sites. While the first four proteins have predicted active sites at dimer interfaces, YDR533Cp and Hsp31 both have predicted sites contained within each subunit. Although YDR533Cp and Hsp31 form different dimers with different orientations between the subunits, the predicted active sites are superimposable within the monomer structures. Thus, the three predicted functional classes form four different types of quaternary structures. The computational prediction of the functional sites for protein structures of unknown function provides valuable clues for functional classification.     

Relationships between functional subclasses and information contained in active‐site and ligand‐binding residues in diverse superfamilies

To investigate the relationships between functional subclasses and sequence and structural information contained in the active‐site and ligand‐binding residues (LBRs), we performed a detailed analysis of seven diverse enzyme superfamilies: aldolase class I, TIM‐barrel glycosidases, α/β‐hydrolases, P‐loop containing nucleotide triphosphate hydrolases, collagenase, Zn peptidases, and glutamine phosphoribosylpyrophosphate, subunit 1, domain 1. These homologous superfamilies, as defined in CATH, were selected from the enzyme catalytic‐mechanism database. We defined active‐site and LBRs based solely on the literature information and complex structures in the Protein Data Bank. From a structure‐based multiple sequence alignment for each CATH homologous superfamily, we extracted subsequences consisting of the aligned positions that were used as an active‐site or a ligand‐binding site by at least one sequence. Using both the subsequences and full‐length alignments, we performed cluster analysis with three sequence distance measures. We showed that the cluster analysis using the subsequences was able to detect functional subclasses more accurately than the clustering using the full‐length alignments. The subsequences determined by only the literature information and complex structures, thus, had sufficient information to detect the functional subclasses. Detailed examination of the clustering results provided new insights into the mechanism of functional diversification for these superfamilies. Proteins 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Confirmation of data mining based predictions of protein function

MOTIVATION: A central problem in bioinformatics is the assignment of function to sequenced open reading frames (ORFs). The most common approach is based on inferred homology using a statistically based sequence similarity (SIM) method, e.g. PSI-BLAST. Alternative non-SIM based bioinformatic methods are becoming popular. One such method is Data Mining Prediction (DMP). This is based on combining evidence from amino-acid attributes, predicted structure and phylogenic patterns; and uses a combination of Inductive Logic Programming data mining, and decision trees to produce prediction rules for functional class. DMP predictions are more general than is possible using homology. In 2000/1, DMP was used to make public predictions of the function of 1309 Escherichia coli ORFs. Since then biological knowledge has advanced allowing us to test our predictions. RESULTS: We examined the updated (20.02.02) Riley group genome annotation, and examined the scientific literature for direct experimental derivations of ORF function. Both tests confirmed the DMP predictions. Accuracy varied between rules, and with the detail of prediction, but they were generally significantly better than random. For voting rules, accuracies of 75-100% were obtained. Twenty-one of these DMP predictions have been confirmed by direct experimentation. The DMP rules also have interesting biological explanations. DMP is, to the best of our knowledge, the first non-SIM based prediction method to have been tested directly on new data. AVAILABILITY: We have designed the "Genepredictions" database for protein functional predictions. This is intended to act as an open repository for predictions for any organism and can be accessed at http://www.genepredictions.org     

Sequence and structure continuity of evolutionary importance improves protein functional site discovery and annotation

Protein functional sites control most biological processes and are important targets for drug design and protein engineering. To characterize them, the evolutionary trace (ET) ranks the relative importance of residues according to their evolutionary variations. Generally, top‐ranked residues cluster spatially to define evolutionary hotspots that predict functional sites in structures. Here, various functions that measure the physical continuity of ET ranks among neighboring residues in the structure, or in the sequence, are shown to inform sequence selection and to improve functional site resolution. This is shown first, in 110 proteins, for which the overlap between top‐ranked residues and actual functional sites rose by 8% in significance. Then, on a structural proteomic scale, optimized ET led to better 3D structure‐function motifs (3D templates) and, in turn, to enzyme function prediction by the Evolutionary Trace Annotation (ETA) method with better sensitivity of (40% to 53%) and positive predictive value (93% to 94%). This suggests that the similarity of evolutionary importance among neighboring residues in the sequence and in the structure is a universal feature of protein evolution. In practice, this yields a tool for optimizing sequence selections for comparative analysis and, via ET, for better predictions of functional site and function. This should prove useful for the efficient mutational redesign of protein function and for pharmaceutical targeting.     

Improved secondary structure predictions for a nicotinic receptor subunit: incorporation of solvent accessibility and experimental data into a two-dimensional representation

Abstract A refined prediction of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) subunits' secondary structure was computed with third-generation algorithms. The four selected programs, PHD, Predator, DSC, and NNSSP, based on different prediction approaches, were applied to each sequence of an alignment of nAChR and 5-HT3 receptor subunits, as well as a larger alignment with related subunit sequences from glycine and GABA receptors. A consensus prediction was computed for the nAChR subunits through a "winner takes all" method. By integrating the probabilities obtained with PHD, DSC, and NNSSP, this prediction was filtered in order to eliminate the singletons and to more precisely establish the structure limits (only 4% of the residues were modified). The final consensus secondary structure includes nine alpha-helices (24.2% of the residues, with an average length of 13.9 residues) and 17 beta-strands (22.5% of the residues, with an average length of 6.6 residues). The large extracellular domain is predicted to be mainly composed of beta-strands, with only two helices at the amino-terminal end. The transmembrane segments are predicted to be in a mixed alpha/beta topology (with a predominance of alpha-helices), with no known equivalent in the current protein database. The cytoplasmic domain is predicted to consist of two well-conserved amphipathic helices joined together by an unfolded stretch of variable length and sequence. In general, the segments predicted to occur in a periodic structure correspond to the more conserved regions, as defined by an analysis of sequence conservation per position performed on 152 superfamily members. The solvent accessibility of each residue was predicted from the multiple alignments with PHDacc. Each segment with more than three exposed residues was assumed to be external to the core protein. Overall, these data constitute an envelope of structural constraints. In a subsequent step, experimental data relative to the extracellular portion of the complete receptor were incorporated into the model. This led to a proposed two-dimensional representation of the secondary structure in which the peptide chain of the extracellular domain winds alternatively between the two interfaces of the subunit. Although this representation is not a tertiary structure and does not lead to predictions of specific beta-beta interaction, it should provide a basic framework for further mutagenesis investigations and for fold recognition (threading) searches.     

Three-dimensional cluster analysis identifies interfaces and functional residue clusters in proteins

Three-dimensional cluster analysis offers a method for the prediction of functional residue clusters in proteins. This method requires a representative structure and a multiple sequence alignment as input data. Individual residues are represented in terms of regional alignments that reflect both their structural environment and their evolutionary variation, as defined by the alignment of homologous sequences. From the overall (global) and the residue-specific (regional) alignments, we calculate the global and regional similarity matrices, containing scores for all pairwise sequence comparisons in the respective alignments. Comparing the matrices yields two scores for each residue. The regional conservation score (C(R)(x)) defines the conservation of each residue x and its neighbors in 3D space relative to the protein as a whole. The similarity deviation score (S(x)) detects residue clusters with sequence similarities that deviate from the similarities suggested by the full-length sequences. We evaluated 3D cluster analysis on a set of 35 families of proteins with available cocrystal structures, showing small ligand interfaces, nucleic acid interfaces and two types of protein-protein interfaces (transient and stable). We present two examples in detail: fructose-1,6-bisphosphate aldolase and the mitogen-activated protein kinase ERK2. We found that the regional conservation score (C(R)(x)) identifies functional residue clusters better than a scoring scheme that does not take 3D information into account. C(R)(x) is particularly useful for the prediction of poorly conserved, transient protein-protein interfaces. Many of the proteins studied contained residue clusters with elevated similarity deviation scores. These residue clusters correlate with specificity-conferring regions: 3D cluster analysis therefore represents an easily applied method for the prediction of functionally relevant spatial clusters of residues in proteins.     

Structural similarity to link sequence space: new potential superfamilies and implications for structural genomics

The current pace of structural biology now means that protein three-dimensional structure can be known before protein function, making methods for assigning homology via structure comparison of growing importance. Previous research has suggested that sequence similarity after structure-based alignment is one of the best discriminators of homology and often functional similarity. Here, we exploit this observation, together with a merger of protein structure and sequence databases, to predict distant homologous relationships. We use the Structural Classification of Proteins (SCOP) database to link sequence alignments from the SMART and Pfam databases. We thus provide new alignments that could not be constructed easily in the absence of known three-dimensional structures. We then extend the method of Murzin (1993b) to assign statistical significance to sequence identities found after structural alignment and thus suggest the best link between diverse sequence families. We find that several distantly related protein sequence families can be linked with confidence, showing the approach to be a means for inferring homologous relationships and thus possible functions when proteins are of known structure but of unknown function. The analysis also finds several new potential superfamilies, where inspection of the associated alignments and superimpositions reveals conservation of unusual structural features or co-location of conserved amino acids and bound substrates. We discuss implications for Structural Genomics initiatives and for improvements to sequence comparison methods.     

Superfamily active site templates

We show that three-dimensional signatures consisting of only a few functionally important residues can be diagnostic of membership in superfamilies of enzymes. Using the enolase superfamily as a model system, we demonstrate that such a signature, or template, can identify superfamily members in structural databases with high sensitivity and specificity. This is remarkable because superfamilies can be highly diverse, with members catalyzing many different overall reactions; the unifying principle can be a conserved partial reaction or chemical capability. Our definition of a superfamily thus hinges on the disposition of residues involved in a conserved function, rather than on fold similarity alone. A clear advantage of basing structure searches on such active site templates rather than on fold similarity is the specificity with which superfamilies with distinct functional characteristics can be identified within a large set of proteins with the same fold, such as the (beta/alpha)8 barrels. Preliminary results are presented for an additional group of enzymes with a different fold, the haloacid dehalogenase superfamily, suggesting that this approach may be generally useful for assigning reading frames of unknown function to specific superfamilies and thereby allowing inference of some of their functional properties.     

Functional insights from structural predictions: analysis of the Escherichia coli genome

Fold assignments for proteins from the Escherichia coli genome are carried out using BASIC, a profile-profile alignment algorithm, recently tested on fold recognition benchmarks and on the Mycoplasma genitalium genome and PSI BLAST, the newest generation of the de facto standard in homology search algorithms. The fold assignments are followed by automated modeling and the resulting three-dimensional models are analyzed for possible function prediction. Close to 30% of the proteins encoded in the E. coli genome can be recognized as homologous to a protein family with known structure. Most of these homologies (23% of the entire genome) can be recognized both by PSI BLAST and BASIC algorithms, but the latter recognizes an additional 260 homologies. Previous estimates suggested that only 10-15% of E. coli proteins can be characterized this way. This dramatic increase in the number of recognized homologies between E. coli proteins and structurally characterized protein families is partly due to the rapid increase of the database of known protein structures, but mostly it is due to the significant improvement in prediction algorithms. Knowing protein structure adds a new dimension to our understanding of its function and the predictions presented here can be used to predict function for uncharacterized proteins. Several examples, analyzed in more detail in this paper, include the DPS protein protecting DNA from oxidative damage (predicted to be homologous to ferritin with iron ion acting as a reducing agent) and the ahpC/tsa family of proteins, which provides resistance to various oxidating agents (predicted to be homologous to glutathione peroxidase).