Physiological and metabolic responses of winter wheat to prolonged freezing stress

Survival and cold hardiness declined gradually when cold-hardened Fredrick winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) was maintained at −6°C for several weeks. Moisture content of crown and root tissue did not change significantly during this period. Uptake of O₂ and accumulation of ⁸⁶Rb by root tissue declined abruptly upon exposure to −6°C, whereas a concomitant negative effect of freezing on these metabolic processes was not observed in crown tissue. Electron spin resonance spectroscopic analysis of microsomal membrane preparations from crown tissue revealed no evidence of gross changes in the physical properties of the bulk lipids even when seedlings were killed. The results provide biochemical evidence that seedling damage due to prolonged exposure to a mild freezing stress is due to disruption of key metabolic process in the root while cells within the crown remain viable.     

Freezing injury and root development in winter cereals

Upon exposure to 2°C, the leaves and crowns of rye (Secale cereale L. cv `Puma') and wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv `Norstar' and `Cappelle') increased in cold hardiness, whereas little change in root cold hardiness was observed. Both root and shoot growth were severely reduced in cold-hardened Norstar wheat plants frozen to −11°C or lower and transplanted to soil. In contrast, shoot growth of plants grown in a nutrient agar medium and subjected to the same hardening and freezing conditions was not affected by freezing temperatures of −20°C while root growth was reduced at −15°C. Thus, it was apparent that lack of root development limited the ability of plants to survive freezing under natural conditions.

Generally, the temperatures at which 50% of the plants were killed as determined by the conductivity method were lower than those obtained by regrowth. A simple explanation for this difference is that the majority of cells in the crown are still alive while a small portion of the cells which are critical for regrowth are injured or killed.

Suspension cultures of Norstar wheat grown in B-5 liquid medium supplemented with 3 milligrams per liter of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid could be cold hardened to the same levels as soil growth plants. These cultures produce roots when transferred to the same growth medium supplemented with a low rate of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (<1 milligram per liter). When frozen to −15°C regrowth of cultures was 50% of the control, whereas the percentage of calli with root development was reduced 50% in cultures frozen to −11°C. These results suggest that freezing affects root morphogenesis rather than just killing the cells responsible for root regeneration.

     

Changes in adenine nucleotides and energy charge in isolated winter wheat cells during low temperature stress

Adenylate energy charge (AEC) and adenine nucleotide levels of isolated winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Kharkov 22 MC) cells exposed to various low temperature stresses were determined. During ice encasement at −1°C, nucleotide levels decreased gradually in approximate relation to a decline in cell viability. AEC values remained high even after 5 weeks of icing when cell viability was severely reduced. When isolated cell suspensions were exposed to various cooling and freezing regimes ranging from −10 to −30°C, cell damage was dependent on the minimum temperature imposed and the duration of exposure to the freezing stress. The levels of all three adenine nucleotides declined with increasing severity of the imposed stress, but AEC values remained high even at −30°C when nearly all of the cells were killed. The addition of 10 millimolar Ca²⁺ to cell suspensions enhanced survival during low temperature stresses, but did not influence nucleotide levels other than through its effect on cell viability. These results indicate that impairment of the ion transport system during the early stages of ice encasement prior to a detectable decline in cell viability cannot be attributed to changes in the adenylate energy charge system of the cell.     

Freezing tolerance of citrus, spinach, and petunia leaf tissue : osmotic adjustment and sensitivity to freeze induced cellular dehydration

Seasonal variations in freezing tolerance, water content, water and osmotic potential, and levels of soluble sugars of leaves of field-grown Valencia orange (Citrus sinensis) trees were studied to determine the ability of citrus trees to cold acclimate under natural conditions. Controlled environmental studies of young potted citrus trees, spinach (Spinacia pleracea), and petunia (Petunia hybrids) were carried out to study the water relations during cold acclimation under less variable conditions. During the coolest weeks of the winter, leaf water content and osmotic potential of field-grown trees decreased about 20 to 25%, while soluble sugars increased by 100%. At the same time, freezing tolerance increased from lethal temperature for 50% (LT₅₀) of −2.8 to −3.8°C. In contrast, citrus leaves cold acclimated at a constant 10°C in growth chambers were freezing tolerant to about −6°C. The calculated freezing induced cellular dehydration at the LT₅₀ remained relatively constant for field-grown leaves throughout the year, but increased for leaves of plants cold acclimated at 10°C in a controlled environment. Spinach leaves cold acclimated at 5°C tolerated increased cellular dehydration compared to nonacclimated leaves. Cold acclimated petunia leaves increased in freezing tolerance by decreasing osmotic potential, but had no capacity to change cellular dehydration sensitivity. The result suggest that two cold acclimation mechanisms are involved in both citrus and spinach leaves and only one in petunia leaves. The common mechanism in all three species tested was a minor increase in tolerance (about −1°C) resulting from low temperature induced osmotic adjustment, and the second in citrus and spinach was a noncolligative mechanism that increased the cellular resistance to freeze hydration.     

Effect of a freeze-thaw cycle on properties of microsomal membranes from wheat

A freeze-thaw cycle to −12°C induced several physical and compositional changes in the microsomal membranes isolated from crown tissue of winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Frederick). Exposing 7-day-old, nonacclimated seedlings to a single freeze-thaw cycle prevented regrowth of the crown and resulted in increased membrane semipermeability. The phospholipid and protein content of microsomal membranes isolated from the crowns decreased by 70 and 50%, respectively. Microsomal membranes isolated after the lethal freeze-thaw stress, and liposomes prepared from total membrane lipids, exhibited greater microviscosity, measured by fluorescence polarization of 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene. The number of free thiol groups per milligram membrane protein, measured using the specific fluorescent probe, N-dansylaziridine, decreased after freezing. In contrast, acclimated wheat seedlings which showed increased freezing tolerance, as indicated by survival and ion leakage, suffered almost no effects from the freeze thaw treatment as determined by measurements of membrane microviscosity, phospholipid content, protein content, or danzylaziridine fluorescence. An examination of membranes isolated from frozen tissue showed that most of the changes occurred during the freezing and not during the thawing phase.     

Adaptation of Grapevine Flowers to Cold Involves Different Mechanisms Depending on Stress Intensity

Grapevine flower development and fruit set are influenced by cold nights in the vineyard. To investigate the impact of cold stress on carbon metabolism in the inflorescence, we exposed the inflorescences of fruiting cuttings to chilling and freezing temperatures overnight and measured fluctuations in photosynthesis and sugar content. Whatever the temperature, after the stress treatment photosynthesis was modified in the inflorescence, but the nature of the alteration depended on the intensity of the cold stress. At 4°C, photosynthesis in the inflorescence was impaired through non-stomatal limitations, whereas at 0°C it was affected through stomatal limitations. A freezing night (−3°C) severely deregulated photosynthesis in the inflorescence, acting primarily on photosystem II. Cold nights also induced accumulation of sugars. Soluble carbohydrates increased in inflorescences exposed to −3°C, 0°C and 4°C, but starch accumulated only in inflorescences of plants treated at 0 and −3°C. These results suggest that inflorescences are able to cope with cold temperatures by adapting their carbohydrate metabolism using mechanisms that are differentially induced according to stress intensity.     

Effect of cold acclimation on bulk tissue electrical impedance: I. Measurements with birdsfoot trefoil at subfreezing temperatures

The resistive and reactive components of electrical impedance were measured for birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus L.) stems at freezing temperatures to −8°C. As temperature decreased the specific resistance at frequencies between 49 hertz and 1.11 megahertz of stems from cold acclimated plants increased more rapidly than from nonacclimated plants. This temperature dependence of specific resistance could be characterized by an Arrhenius activation energy; cold acclimated stems had a larger Arrhenius activation energy than nonacclimated stems. The low frequency resistance is believed to characterize the extracellular region of the stems and the high frequency resistance is believed to characterize the intracellular region of the stems. Cold acclimation increased the intracellular but not the extracellular resistance at nonfreezing temperatures. Cold acclimated stems were not injured by freezing to −8°C and thawing, but nonacclimated stems were injured by freezing to temperatures between −2.2 and −5.6°C and thawing. Injury to nonacclimated stems at freezing temperatures below −2.2°C was indicated by a decrease in the ratio of resistance at 49 Hz to that at 1.11 megahertz.     

Survival of Ice Nucleation-Active and Genetically Engineered Non-Ice-Nucleating Pseudomonas syringae Strains after Freezing

The survival after freezing of ice nucleation-active (INA) and genetically engineered non-INA strains of Pseudomonas syringae was compared. Each strain was applied to oat seedlings and allowed to colonize for 3 days, and the plants were subjected to various freezing temperatures. Plant leaves were harvested before and after freezing on two consecutive days, and bacterial populations were determined. Populations of the INA wild-type strain increased 15-fold in the 18 h after the oat plants incurred frost damage at −5 and −12°C. Plants colonized by the non-INA strain were undamaged at −5°C and exhibited no changes in population size after two freeze trials. As freezing temperatures were lowered (−7, −9, and −12°C), oat plants colonized by the non-INA strain suffered increased frost damage concomitant with bacterial population increases following 18 h. At −12°C, both strains behaved identically. The data show a relationship between frost damage to plants and increased bacterial population size during the following 18 h, indicating a potential competitive advantage of INA strains of P. syringae over non-INA strains in mild freezing environments.     

Apoplastic Sugars, Fructans, Fructan Exohydrolase, and Invertase in Winter Oat: Responses to Second-Phase Cold Hardening

Changes in apoplastic carbohydrate concentrations and activities of carbohydrate-degrading enzymes were determined in crown tissues of oat (Avena sativa L., cv Wintok) during cold hardening. During second-phase hardening (−3°C for 3 d) levels of fructan, sucrose, glucose, and fructose in the apoplast increased significantly above that in nonhardened and first-phase-hardened plants. The extent of the increase in apoplastic fructan during second-phase hardening varied with the degree of fructan polymerization (DP) (e.g. DP3 and DP4 increased to a greater extent than DP7 and DP > 7). Activities of invertase and fructan exohydrolase in the crown apoplast increased approximately 4-fold over nonhardened and first-phase-hardened plants. Apoplastic fluid extracted from nonhardened, first-phase-hardened, and second-phase-hardened crown tissues had low levels, of symplastic contamination, as determined by malate dehydrogenase activity. The significance of these results in relation to increases in freezing tolerance from second-phase hardening is discussed.     

Induction of Freezing Tolerance in Spinach during Cold Acclimation

Spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) seedlings, grown in soil or on an agar medium in vitro, became cold acclimated when exposed to a constant 5°C. Plants subjected to cold acclimation, beginning 1 week postgermination, attained freezing tolerance levels similar to that achieved by seedlings that were cold acclimated beginning 3 weeks after sowing. Seedlings at 1 week of age had only cotyledonary leaves, while 3-week-old seedlings had developed true leaves. Plants grown in vitro were able to increase in freezing tolerance, but were slightly less hardy than soil-grown plants. These results suggest that spinach, a cool-season crop that begins growth in early spring when subzero temperatures are likely, can undergo cold acclimation at the earliest stages of development following germination. Axenic seedlings, grown in vitro, were used to develop a noninjurious radiolabeling technique. Leaf proteins were radiolabeled to specific activities of 10⁵ counts per minute per microgram at 25°C or 5 × 10⁴ counts per minute per microgram at 5°C over a 24 hour period. The ability to radiolabel leaf proteins of in vitro grown plants to high specific activities at low temperature, without injury or microbial contamination, will facilitate studies of cold acclimation.     

Effect of cold acclimation on the incidence of two forms of freezing injury in protoplasts isolated from rye leaves

The freezing tolerance and incidence of two forms of freezing injury (expansion-induced lysis and loss of osmotic responsiveness) were determined for protoplasts isolated from rye leaves (Secale cereale L. cv Puma) at various times during cold acclimation. During the first 4 weeks of the cold acclimation period, the LT₅₀ (i.e. the minimum temperature at which 50% of the protoplasts survived) decreased from −5°C to −25°C. In protoplasts isolated from nonacclimated leaves (NA protoplasts), expansion-induced lysis (EIL) was the predominant form of injury at the LT₅₀. However, after only 1 week of cold acclimation, the incidence of EIL was reduced to less than 10% at any subzero temperature; and loss of osmotic responsiveness was the predominant form of injury, regardless of the freezing temperature. Fusion of either NA protoplasts or protoplasts isolated from leaves of seedlings cold acclimated for 1 week (1-week ACC protoplasts) with liposomes of dilinoleoylphosphatidylcholine also decreased the incidence of EIL to less than 10%. Fusion of protoplasts with dilinoleoylphosphatidylcholine diminished the incidence of loss of osmotic responsiveness, but only in NA protoplasts or 1-week ACC protoplasts that were frozen to temperatures over the range of -5 to -10°C. These results suggest that the cold acclimation process, which results in a quantitative increase in freezing resistance, involves several different qualitative changes in the cryobehavior of the plasma membrane.     

Chilling- and Freezing- Induced Alterations in Cytosine Methylation and Its Association with the Cold Tolerance of an Alpine Subnival Plant,Chorispora bungeana

Chilling (0–18°C) and freezing (<0°C) are two distinct types of cold stresses. Epigenetic regulation can play an important role in plant adaptation to abiotic stresses. However, it is not yet clear whether and how epigenetic modification (i.e., DNA methylation) mediates the adaptation to cold stresses in nature (e.g., in alpine regions). Especially, whether the adaptation to chilling and freezing is involved in differential epigenetic regulations in plants is largely unknown. Chorispora bungeana is an alpine subnival plant that is distributed in the freeze-thaw tundra in Asia, where chilling and freezing frequently fluctuate daily (24 h). To disentangle how C. bungeana copes with these intricate cold stresses through epigenetic modifications, plants of C. bungeana were treated at 4°C (chilling) and -4°C (freezing) over five periods of time (0–24 h). Methylation-sensitive amplified fragment-length polymorphism markers were used to investigate the variation in DNA methylation of C. bungeana in response to chilling and freezing. It was found that the alterations in DNA methylation of C. bungeana largely occurred over the period of chilling and freezing. Moreover, chilling and freezing appeared to gradually induce distinct DNA methylation variations, as the treatment went on (e.g., after 12 h). Forty-three cold-induced polymorphic fragments were randomly selected and further analyzed, and three of the cloned fragments were homologous to genes encoding alcohol dehydrogenase, UDP-glucosyltransferase and polygalacturonase-inhibiting protein. These candidate genes verified the existence of different expressive patterns between chilling and freezing. Our results showed that C. bungeana responded to cold stresses rapidly through the alterations of DNA methylation, and that chilling and freezing induced different DNA methylation changes. Therefore, we conclude that epigenetic modifications can potentially serve as a rapid and flexible mechanism for C. bungeana to adapt to the intricate cold stresses in the alpine areas.     

Cold Acclimation in Arabidopsis thaliana

The abilities of two races of Arabidopsis thaliana L. (Heyn), Landsberg erecta and Columbia, to cold harden were examined. Landsberg, grown at 22 to 24°C, increased in freezing tolerance from an initial 50% lethal temperature (LT₅₀) of about −3°C to an LT₅₀ of about −6°C after 24 hours at 4°C; LT₅₀ values of −8 to −10°C were achieved after 8 to 9 days at 4°C. Similar increases in freezing tolerance were obtained with Columbia. In vitro translation of poly(A⁺) RNA isolated from control and cold-treated Columbia showed that low temperature induced changes in the population of translatable mRNAs. An mRNA encoding a polypeptide of about 160 kilodaltons (isoelectric point about 4.5) increased markedly after 12 to 24 h at 4°C, as did mRNAs encoding four polypeptides of about 47 kilodaltons (isoelectric points ranging from 5-5.5). Incubation of Columbia callus tissue at 4°C also resulted in increased levels of the mRNAs encoding the 160 kilodalton polypeptide and at least two of the 47 kilodalton polypeptides. In vivo labeling experiments using Columbia plants and callus tissue indicated that the 160 kilodalton polypeptide was synthesized in the cold and suggested that at least two of the 47 kilodalton polypeptides were produced. Other differences in polypeptide composition were also observed in the in vivo labeling experiments, some of which may be the result of posttranslational modifications of the 160 and 47 kilodalton polypeptides.     

Overwintering Strategy and Mechanisms of Cold Tolerance in the Codling Moth (Cydia pomonella)

Background

The codling moth (Cydia pomonella) is a major insect pest of apples worldwide. Fully grown last instar larvae overwinter in diapause state. Their overwintering strategies and physiological principles of cold tolerance have been insufficiently studied. No elaborate analysis of overwintering physiology is available for European populations.

Principal Findings

We observed that codling moth larvae of a Central European population prefer to overwinter in the microhabitat of litter layer near the base of trees. Reliance on extensive supercooling, or freeze-avoidance, appears as their major strategy for survival of the winter cold. The supercooling point decreases from approximately −15.3°C during summer to −26.3°C during winter. Seasonal extension of supercooling capacity is assisted by partial dehydration, increasing osmolality of body fluids, and the accumulation of a complex mixture of winter specific metabolites. Glycogen and glutamine reserves are depleted, while fructose, alanine and some other sugars, polyols and free amino acids are accumulated during winter. The concentrations of trehalose and proline remain high and relatively constant throughout the season, and may contribute to the stabilization of proteins and membranes at subzero temperatures. In addition to supercooling, overwintering larvae acquire considerable capacity to survive at subzero temperatures, down to −15°C, even in partially frozen state.

Conclusion

Our detailed laboratory analysis of cold tolerance, and whole-winter survival assays in semi-natural conditions, suggest that the average winter cold does not represent a major threat for codling moth populations. More than 83% of larvae survived over winter in the field and pupated in spring irrespective of the overwintering microhabitat (cold-exposed tree trunk or temperature-buffered litter layer).     

Relationship between Freezing Tolerance of Root-Tip Cells and Cold Stability of Microtubules in Rye (Secale cereale L. cv Puma)

The response of cortical microtubules to low temperature and freezing was assessed for root tips of cold-acclimated and non-acclimated winter rye (Secale cereale L. cv Puma) seedlings using indirect immunofluorescence microscopy with antitubulin antibodies. Roots cooled to 0 or −3°C were fixed for immunofluorescence microscopy at these temperatures or after an additional hour at 4°C. Typical arrays of cortical microtubules were present in root-tip cells of seedlings exposed to the cold-acclimation treatment of 4°C for 2 days. Microtubules in these cold-acclimated cells were more easily depolymerized by a 0°C treatment than microtubules in root-tip cells of nonacclimated, 22°C-grown seedlings. Microtubules were still present in some cells of both nonacclimated and cold-acclimated roots at 0 and −3°C; however, the number of microtubules in these cells was lower than in controls. Microtubules remaining during the −3°C freeze were shorter than microtubules in unfrozen control cells. Repolymerization of microtubules after both the 0 and −3°C treatments occurred within 1 h. Root tips of nonacclimated seedlings had an LT-50 of −9°C. Cold acclimation lowered this value to −14°C. Treatment of 22°C-grown seedlings for 24 h with the microtubule-stabilizing drug taxol caused a decrease in the freezing tolerance of root tips, indicated by a LT-50 of −3°C. Treatment with D-secotaxol, an analog of taxol that was less effective in stabilizing microtubules, did not alter the freezing tolerance. We interpret these data to indicate that a degree of depolymerization of microtubules is necessary for realization of maximum freezing tolerance in root-tip cells of rye.     

Sucrose Synthase Expression during Cold Acclimation in Wheat

When wheat (Triticum aestivum) seedlings are exposed to a cold temperature (2-4°C) above 0°C, sucrose accumulates and sucrose synthase activity increases. The effect of a cold period on the level of sucrose synthase (SS) was investigated. Using antibodies against wheat germ SS, Western blots studies showed that the amount of the SS peptide increased during 14 days in the cold, when plants were moved from 23°C to 4°C. The level of SS diminished when plants were moved back to 23°C. Northern blots of poly(A)⁺ RNA, confirmed a five- to sixfold induction of SS in wheat leaves during cold acclimation. These results indicate that SS is involved in the plant response to a chilling stress.     

A Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Study of Water in Cold-acclimating Cereals

Continuous wave nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies indicated that the line width of the water absorption peak (Δv½) from crowns of winter and spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) increased during cold acclimation. There was a negative correlation between Δv½ and crown water content, and both of these parameters were correlated with the lowest survival temperature at which 50% or more of the crowns were not killed by freezing (LT₅₀). Regression analyses indicated that Δv½ and water content account for similar variability in LT₅₀. Slow dehydration of unacclimated winter wheat crowns by artificial means resulted in similarly correlated changes in water content and Δv½. Rapid dehydration of unacclimated crowns reduced water content but did not influence Δv½. The incubation of unacclimated winter wheat crowns in a sucrose medium reduced water content and increased Δv½. The increase in Δv½ appears to be dependent in part on a reduction in water content and an increase in solutes.     

Effect of low temperature and calcium on survival and membrane properties of isolated winter wheat cells

Isolated cells obtained by enzymic digestion of young primary leaves of cold-hardened, dark-grown Kharkov winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) were exposed to various low temperature stresses. The initial uptake of ⁸⁶Rb was generally decreased by increasing concentrations of Ca²⁺, but after longer periods of incubation, the inhibiting effect of high Ca²⁺ levels diminished. Viability of isolated cells suspended in water declined rapidly when ice encased at −1°C, while in the presence of 10 millimolar Ca²⁺ viability declined only gradually over a 5-week period. Ice encasement markedly reduced ⁸⁶Rb uptake prior to a significant decline in cell viability or increased ion efflux. Cell damage increased progressively when the icing temperature was reduced from −1 to −2 and −3°C, but the presence of Ca²⁺ in the suspending medium reduced injury. Cell viability and ion uptake were reduced to a greater extent following slow cooling than after rapid cooling to subfreezing temperatures ranging from −10 to −30°C. The results from this study support the view that an early change in cellular properties due to prolonged ice encasement at −1°C involves the ion transport system, whereas cooling to lower subfreezing temperatures for only a few hours results in more general membrane damage, including loss of semipermeability of the plasma membrane.     

High Survivability of Cheese Whey-Grown Rhizobium meliloti Cells upon Exposure to Physical Stress

Whey, a by-product of the dairy industry, has been found to protect the rhizobia cells during freezing and thawing. Cells of rhizobia grown on whey sustained freezing better at −18°C than did cells grown on mannitol or sucrose. Suspensions of cells grown on whey or mannitol that were suspended in whey performed equally well at −18 and −80°C, with 94 and 100% survival, respectively. Whey-grown rhizobia in pellets withstood desiccation better than did their mannitol-grown equivalents. Rhizobia that were grown on whey and then inoculated onto commercial peat showed a survival rate of 100% after 23 weeks at −4°C. Whey-grown cells in peat performed better at various temperatures during storage, even when they were exposed to desiccation, than did mannitol-grown cells in peat. Whey, therefore, offers interesting possibilities as a Rhizobium protectant for the inoculum industry.     

Survival of plant tissue at super-low temperatures v. An electron microscope study of ice in cortical cells cooled rapidly

Experiments were carried out with cortical cells in twig bark of mulberry trees in winter in order to clarify the mechanism of survival at super-low temperatures with rapid cooling and rewarming. Attention was given to the relation between the existence of intracellular ice crystals and survival.

Cortical cells were cooled rapidly by direct immersion into liquid nitrogen or isopentane cooled at various temperatures. After immersion, they were freeze-substituted with absolute ethanol at −78°. They were then embedded, sectioned and examined under the electron microscope for the presence and distribution of cavities left after ice removal.

Cells were found to remain alive and contain no ice cavities when immersed rapidly into isopentane baths kept below −60°. Those cells at intermediate temperatures from −20° to −45°, were almost all destroyed. It was also observed that many ice cavities were contained in the cells immersed rapidly into isopentane baths at −30°. The data seem to indicate that no ice crystals were formed when cooled rapidly by direct immersion into isopentane baths below −60° or into liquid nitrogen.

The tissue sections immersed in liquid nitrogen were rapidly transferred to isopentane baths at temperatures ranging from −70° to −10° before rapid rewarming. There was little damage when samples were held at temperatures below −50° for 10 minutes or below −60° for 16 hours. No cavities were found in these cells. Above −45°, and especially at −30°, however, all cells were completely destroyed even when exposed only for 1 minute. Many ice cavities were observed throughout these cells. The results obtained may be explained in terms of the growth rate of intracellular ice crystals.