Postmetamorphic development of neuromuscular junctions and muscle fibers in the frog cutaneous pectoris

Synaptic size, synaptic remodelling, polyneuronal innervation, and synaptic efficacy of neuromuscular junctions were studied as a function of growth in cutaneous pectoris muscles of postmetamorphic Rana pipiens. Recently metamorphosed frogs grew rapidly, and this growth was accompanied by hypertrophy of muscle fibers, myogenesis, and increases in the size and complexity of neuromuscular junctions. There were pronounced gradients in pre- and postsynaptic size across the width of the muscle, with neuromuscular junctions and muscle fibers near the medial edge being smaller than in more lateral regions. The incidence of polyneuronal innervation, measured physiologically and histologically, was also higher near the medial edge. Growth-associated declines in all measures of polyneuronal innervation indicated that synapse elimination occurs throughout life. Electrophysiology also demonstrated regional differences in synaptic efficacy and showed that doubly innervated junctions have lower synaptic efficacy than singly innervated junctions. Repeated, in vivo observations revealed extensive growth and remodelling of motor nerve terminals and confirmed that synapse elimination is a slow process. It was concluded that some processes normally associated with embryonic development persist long into adulthood in frog muscles.     

Elevated levels of polyneuronal innervation persist for as long as two years in reinnervated frog neuromuscular junctions

When the nerve to an adult frog sartorius muscle is crushed, and axons are allowed to regenerate, the level of polyneuronal innervation at reinnervated neuromuscular junctions is higher than normal. With time, much of this polyneuronal innervation is reduced by the process of synapse elimination (Werle and Herrera, 1988). Using intracellular recording, we estimated the level of polyneuronal innervation in adult frog (Rana pipiens) sartorius muscles 2 years (range: 1.7-2.4 years) after crushing the sartorius nerve. We found that 27% (S.E. = 1.4%) of the junctions in muscles 2 years after reinnervation were polyneuronally innervated, whereas only 10% (S.E. = 1.2%) of the junctions in normal frog muscles were polyneuronally innervated. Thus, the synapse elimination that occurs following reinnervation does not restore the normal level of polyneuronal innervation. Histological comparisons of junctional structure between muscles 2 years after reinnervation and normal muscles revealed substantial differences. Reinnervated junctions had a greater length of synaptic gutter apposed by nerve terminal processes, more axonal inputs, more empty synaptic gutter, more instances of single synaptic gutters innervated by more than one axon, and longer lengths of nerve terminal processes that connect synaptic gutters within a junction. On the basis of this physiological and anatomical evidence, we conclude that nerve injury causes persistent changes in the pattern of muscle innervation.     

Synaptic competition and the elimination of polyneuronal innervation follwoing reinnervation of adult frog sartorius muscles

The elimination of polyneuronal innervation (synapse elimination) that occurs following reinnervation was studied in sartorius muscles of adult Rana pipiens. The percentage of neuromuscular junctions that were polyneuronally innervated declined from 47% at 40–80 days after nerve crush to 22% at greater than 250 days after nerve crush. We measured the size, synaptic strength, and position of competing nerve terminals at identified dually innervated neuromuscular junctions at these two different periods of synapse elimination. Our goal was to determine if any of these parameters play a role in the competition between nerve terminals that ultimately results in the elimination of polyneuronal innervation. Our data support the hypothesis that polyneuronal innervation will persist if competing nerve terminals are of similar synaptic efficacies but will be eliminated if the competing terminals are of different synaptic efficacies. We also tested, but failed to find any evidence, that the spatial proximity of competing nerve terminals at the same synaptic site influences the elimination of polyneuronal innervation.     

Synaptic competition and the elimination of polyneuronal innervation following reinnervation of adult frog sartorius muscles

The elimination of polyneuronal innervation (synapse elimination) that occurs following reinnervation was studied in sartorius muscles of adult Rana pipiens. The percentage of neuromuscular junctions that were polyneuronally innervated declined from 47% at 40-80 days after nerve crush to 22% at greater than 250 days after nerve crush. We measured the size, synaptic strength, and position of competing nerve terminals at identified dually innervated neuromuscular junctions at these two different periods of synapse elimination. Our goal was to determine if any of these parameters play a role in the competition between nerve terminals that ultimately results in the elimination of polyneuronal innervation. Our data support the hypothesis that polyneuronal innervation will persist if competing nerve terminals are of similar synaptic efficacies but will be eliminated if the competing terminals are of different synaptic efficacies. We also tested, but failed to find any evidence, that the spatial proximity of competing nerve terminals at the same synaptic site influences the elimination of polyneuronal innervation.     

Synaptic competition and the persistence of polyneuronal innervation at frog neuromuscular junctions

Mechanisms governing the elimination of polyneuronal innervation were examined by correlating the morphology and physiology of competing nerve terminals at identified dually innervated neuromuscular junctions in sartorius muscles of adult frogs (Rana pipiens). Synaptic efficacy (endplate potential amplitude per unit nerve terminal length) was presumed to reflect the ability of a terminal to compete for synaptic space. The synaptic efficacies of two terminals at the same synaptic site were found to be surprisingly equal, with a median difference of 33%. Much more variation would be expected if dually innervated junctions were randomly innervated by pairs of terminals having the same range of synaptic efficacy as that found at singly innervated junctions in the same muscle. This finding supports the hypothesis that the weaker input is eliminated from dually innervated junctions when there is a large discrepancy in competitive efficacy, and that both inputs may persist if competitive efficacies are relatively equal. We also tested but failed to find support for the hypothesis that spatial proximity between competing terminals intensifies competition for synaptic space during synapse elimination.     

Effects of evoked and spontaneous motoneuronal firing on synapse competition and elimination in skeletal muscle

Synapse elimination is a general feature of the development of neural connections, including the connections of motoneurons to skeletal muscle fibers. Our work addressed two questions: (1) how the action potentials generated in the set of motoneurons innervating an individual muscle (i.e., in a motor pool) are correlated in time during development in vivo; (2) what influence different firing patterns exert on the processes of polyneuronal innervation and synapse elimination which characterize the establishment of muscle innervation. We recorded the spontaneous electromyographic activity of the tibialis anterior and soleus muscles of late embryonic and neonatal rats, identifying the firing of at least two single motor unit signals in each record. We found that a striking switch occurs a few days after birth from a highly synchronous type of firing to an asynchronous one, the first thus characterizing embryonic while the second one adult motoneurons. We also investigated the effects of an evoked synchronous type of discharge on neuromuscular synapse formation, measuring polyneuronal innervation and synapse elimination. This was done in an adult in vivo model of de novo synapse formation, while a chronic TTX nerve conduction block, placed centrally with respect to the stimulating electrodes, eliminated the natural activity of motoneurons. We found that the imposed synchronous activity greatly inhibits synapse elimination, causing polyneuronal innervation to persist. We conclude that the early synchronous firing, favors the establishment of polyneuronal innervation while the subsequent switch to an asynchronous one promotes synapse elimination.     

Age-associated synapse elimination in mouse parasympathetic ganglia

Little is known about the effects of aging on synapses in the mammalian nervous system. We examined the innervation of individual mouse submandibular ganglion (SMG) neurons for evidence of age-related changes in synapse efficacy and number. For approximately 85% of adult life expectancy (30 months) the efficacy of synaptic transmission, as determined by excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP) amplitudes, remains constant. Similarly, the number of synapses contacting individual SMG neurons is also unchanged. After 30 months of age, however, some neurons (23%) dramatically lose synaptic input exhibiting both smaller EPSP amplitude and fewer synaptic boutons. Attenuation of both the amplitude and frequency of miniature EPSPs was also observed in neurons from aged animals. Electron micrographs revealed that, although there were many vesicle-laden preganglionic axonal processes in the vicinity of the postsynaptic membrane, the number of synaptic contacts was significantly lower in old animals. These results demonstrate primary, age-associated synapse elimination with functional consequences that cannot be explained by pre- or postsynaptic cell death.     

Activity and synapse elimination at the neuromuscular junction

The neuromuscular junction undergoes a loss of synaptic connections during early development. This loss converts the innervation of each muscle fiber from polyneuronal to single. During this change the number of motor neurons remains constant but the number of muscle fibers innervated by each motor neuron is reduced. Evidence indicates that a local competition among the inputs on each muscle fiber determines which inputs are eliminated. The role of synapse elimination in the development of neuromuscular circuits, other than ensuring a single innervation of each fiber, is unclear. Most evidence suggests that the elimination plays little or no role in correcting for errant connections. Rather, it seems that connections are initially highly specific, in terms of both which motor neurons connect to which muscles and which neurons connect to which particular fibers within these muscles. A number of attempts have been made to determine the importance of neuromuscular activity during early development for this rearrangement of synaptic connections. Experiments reducing neuromuscular activity by muscle tenotomy, deafferentation and spinal cord section, block of nerve impulse conduction with tetrodotoxin, and the use of postsynaptic and presynaptic blocking agents have all shown that normal activity is required for normal synapse elimination. Most experiments in which complete muscle paralysis has been achieved show that activity may be essential for the occurrence of synapse elimination. Furthermore, experiments in which neuromuscular activity has been augmented by external stimulation show that synapse elimination is accelerated. A plausible hypothesis to explain the activity dependence of neuromuscular synapse elimination is that a neuromuscular trophic agent is produced by the muscle fibers and that this production is controlled by muscle-fiber activity. The terminals on each fiber compete for the substance produced by that fiber. Inactive fibers produce large quantities of this substance; on the other hand, muscle activity suppresses the level of synthesis of this agent to the point where only a single synaptic terminal can be maintained. Inactive muscle fibers would be expected to be able to maintain more nerve terminals. The attractiveness of this scheme is that it provides a simple feedback mechanism to ensure that each fiber retains a single effective input.     

Increases in pericellular proteolysis at developing neuromuscular junctions in culture.

To determine whether localized changes in pericellular proteolysis contribute to synapse formation, we examined the degradative actions of developing Xenopus laevis nerve and muscle cells on films of extracellular matrix proteins adsorbed to the glass surface of a tissue culture chamber. Skeletal myocytes, growing neurites, and fibroblasts all removed fluorescent fibronectin and laminin from the culture substratum at regions of close cell-surface contact. In addition, however, motor neurites also displayed a particularly enhanced rate of gelatin elimination at developing neuromuscular junctions. It has already been shown (a) that there is a similar remodeling of organized muscle basal lamina proteoglycan accumulations along the path of nerve-muscle contact and (b) that this is the earliest detectable biochemical change specific to developing neuromuscular junctions. Our observations thus suggest that the establishment of motoneuron-muscle contact leads to a further activation of pericellular proteinases along both the pre- and the postsynaptic surfaces of the developing junction. We therefore consider whether site-specific proteinase-activation cascades could contribute to the inductive signals that direct synaptic differentiation.     

Intrinsic Neuronal Determinants Locally Regulate Extrasynaptic and Synaptic Growth at the Adult Neuromuscular Junction

Long-term functional plasticity in the nervous system can involve structural changes in terminal arborization and synaptic connections. To determine whether the differential expression of intrinsic neuronal determinants affects structural plasticity, we produced and analyzed transgenic mice overexpressing the cytosolic proteins cortical cytoskeleton–associated protein 23 (CAP-23) and growth-associated protein 43 (GAP-43) in adult neurons.

Like GAP-43, CAP-23 was downregulated in mouse motor nerves and neuromuscular junctions during the second postnatal week and reexpressed during regeneration. In transgenic mice, the expression of either protein in adult motoneurons induced spontaneous and greatly potentiated stimulus-induced nerve sprouting at the neuromuscular junction. This sprouting had transgene-specific features, with CAP-23 inducing longer, but less numerous sprouts than GAP-43. Crossing of the transgenic mice led to dramatic potentiation of the sprout-inducing activities of GAP-43 and CAP-23, indicating that these related proteins have complementary and synergistic activities. In addition to ultraterminal sprouting, substantial growth of synaptic structures was induced. Experiments with pre- and postsynaptic toxins revealed that in the presence of GAP-43 or CAP-23, sprouting was stimulated by a mechanism that responds to reduced transmitter release and may be independent of postsynaptic activation.

These results demonstrate the importance of intrinsic determinants in structural plasticity and provide an experimental approach to study its role in nervous system function.

     

Dynactin is necessary for synapse stabilization

We present evidence that synapse retraction occurs during normal synaptic growth at the Drosophila neuromuscular junction (NMJ). An RNAi-based screen to identify the molecular mechanisms that regulate synapse retraction identified Arp-1/centractin, a subunit of the dynactin complex. Arp-1 dsRNA enhances synapse retraction, and this effect is phenocopied by a mutation in P150/Glued, also a dynactin component. The Glued protein is enriched within the presynaptic nerve terminal, and presynaptic expression of a dominant-negative Glued transgene enhances retraction. Retraction is associated with a local disruption of the synaptic microtubule cytoskeleton. Electrophysiological, ultrastructural, and immunohistochemical data support a model in which presynaptic retraction precedes disassembly of the postsynaptic apparatus. Our data suggests that dynactin functions locally within the presynaptic arbor to promote synapse stability.     

Neuromuscular synapses can form in vivo by incorporation of initially aneural postsynaptic specializations

Synapse formation requires the coordination of pre- and postsynaptic differentiation. An unresolved question is which steps in the process require interactions between pre- and postsynaptic cells, and which proceed cell-autonomously. One current model is that factors released from presynaptic axons organize postsynaptic differentiation directly beneath the nerve terminal. Here, we used neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) of the zebrafish primary motor system to test this model. Clusters of neurotransmitter (acetylcholine) receptors (AChRs) formed in the central region of the myotome, destined to be synapse-rich, before axons extended and even when axon extension was prevented. Time-lapse imaging revealed that pre-existing clusters on early-born slow (adaxial) muscle fibers were incorporated into NMJs as axons advanced. Axons were, however, required for the subsequent remodeling and selective stabilization of synaptic clusters that precisely appose post- to presynaptic elements. Thus, motor axons are dispensable for the initial stages of postsynaptic differentiation but are required for later stages. Moreover, many AChR clusters on later-born fast muscle fibers formed at sites that had already been contacted by axons, suggesting heterogeneity in the signaling mechanisms leading to synapse formation by a single axon.     

Synapse elimination occurs late in the hormone-sensitive levator ani muscle of the rat

Using tetranitroblue tetrazolium (TNBT) to stain neuromuscular synapses, we compared the development of the adult pattern of innervation in two fast-twitch muscles in the rat: the androgen-sensitive levator ani (LA) and the extensor digitorum longus (EDL), which is not thought to be androgen sensitive. We found that about 18% of adult LA muscle fibers, but only about 2% of adult EDL fibers, are multiply innervated. Moreover, synapse elimination occurs substantially later in the LA compared with the EDL. At 2 weeks after birth, the EDL is already predominantly singly innervated, whereas the LA is still predominantly multiply innervated. The apparent delay in the normal time course of synapse elimination in the LA corresponds to a similar delay in other aspects of neuromuscular development (the time course of appearance of axonal retraction bulbs, the growth of fibers, and the development of adult motor terminal morphology). Finally, motor terminals change during synapse elimination from morphologies resembling growth cones to the adult form of neuromuscular synapses. Because the period of synapse elimination is significantly different for muscles that differ in their androgen sensitivity, hormonal sensitivity may represent an important property of motoneurons or muscle fibers influencing the normal time course of neuromuscular synapse elimination in rats. Thus, androgen might regulate the normal ontogenetic process of synapse elimination.     

Assembly,plasticity and selective vulnerability to disease of mouse neuromuscular junctions

Although physiological differences among neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) have long been known, NMJs have usually been considered as one type of synapse, restricting their potential value as model systems to investigate mechanisms controlling synapse assembly and plasticity. Here we discuss recent evidence that skeletal muscles in the mouse can be subdivided into two previously unrecognized subtypes, designated FaSyn and DeSyn muscles. These muscles differ in the pattern of neuromuscular synaptogenesis during embryonic development. Differences between classes are intrinsic to the muscles, and manifest in the absence of innervation or agrin. The distinct rates of synaptogenesis in the periphery may influence processes of circuit maturation through retrograde signals. While NMJs on FaSyn and DeSyn muscles exhibit a comparable anatomical organization in postnatal mice, treatments that challenge synaptic stability result in nerve sprouting, NMJ remodeling, and ectopic synaptogenesis selectively on DeSyn muscles. This anatomical plasticity of NMJs diminishes greatly between 2 and 6 months postnatally. NMJs lacking this plasticity are lost selectively and very early on in mouse models of motoneuron disease, suggesting that disease-associated motoneuron dysfunction may fail to initiate maintenance processes at “non-plastic” NMJs. Transgenic mice overexpressing growth-promoting proteins in motoneurons exhibit greatly enhanced stimulus-induced sprouting restricted to DeSyn muscles, supporting the notion that anatomical plasticity at the NMJ is primarily controlled by processes in the postsynaptic muscle. The discovery that entire muscles in the mouse differ substantially in the anatomical plasticity of their synapses establishes NMJs as a uniquely advantageous experimental system to investigate mechanisms controlling synaptic rearrangements at defined synapses in vivo.     

The rat brain postsynaptic density fraction contains a homolog of the Drosophila discs-large tumor suppressor protein.

In CNS synapses, the synaptic junctional complex with associated postsynaptic density is presumed to contain proteins responsible for adhesion between pre- and postsynaptic membranes and for postsynaptic signal transduction. We have found that a prominent, brain-specific protein (PSD-95) enriched in the postsynaptic density fraction from rat brain is highly similar to the Drosophila lethal(1)discs-large-1 (dlg) tumor suppressor protein. The dlg protein is associated with septate junctions in developing flies and contains a guanylate kinase domain that is required for normal control of cell division. The sequence similarity between dlg and PSD-95 suggests that molecular mechanisms critical for growth control in developing organisms may also regulate synapse formation, stabilization, or function in the adult brain.     

Molecules involved in the formation of synaptic connections in muscle and brain.

Synapses are highly specialized structures designed to guarantee precise and efficient communication between neurons and their target cells. Molecules of the extracellular matrix have an instructive role in the formation of the neuromuscular junction, the best-characterized synapse. In this review, the molecular mechanisms underlying these instructive signals will be discussed with particular emphasis on the receptors involved. Additionally, recent evidence for the involvement of specific adhesion complexes in the formation and modulation of synapses in the central nervous system will be reviewed. Synapses are specialized junctions between neurons and their target cells where information is transferred from the pre- to the postsynaptic cell. At most vertebrate synapses, this transfer is accomplished by the release of a specific neurotransmitter from the presynaptic nerve terminal. The release of neurotransmitter is initiated by the action potential and the subsequent influx of Ca(2+) into the presynaptic nerve terminal. This results in the rapid fusion of vesicles with the nerve membrane and the release of the neurotransmitter into the synaptic cleft. The neurotransmitter then diffuses across the cleft and binds to specific postsynaptic receptors, resulting in a change in the membrane potential of the postsynaptic cell. This can result in the generation of an action potential. The high precision of synaptic transmission requires that pre- and postsynaptic structures are both highly organized and in juxtaposition to each other. In addition, alterations in synaptic transmission are the basis of learning and memory and are likely to be accompanied by the remodeling of synaptic structures (Toni et al., 1999). Thus, the study of how synapses are formed during development is also of relevance for the understanding of the cellular and molecular processes involved in learning and memory. This review focuses on the molecular mechanisms involved in the formation and the function of synapses.     

Age‐associated synapse elimination in mouse parasympathetic ganglia

Little is known about the effects of aging on synapses in the mammalian nervous system. We examined the innervation of individual mouse submandibular ganglion (SMG) neurons for evidence of age‐related changes in synapse efficacy and number. For approximately 85% of adult life expectancy (30 months) the efficacy of synaptic transmission, as determined by excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP) amplitudes, remains constant. Similarly, the number of synapses contacting individual SMG neurons is also unchanged. After 30 months of age, however, some neurons (23%) dramatically lose synaptic input exhibiting both smaller EPSP amplitude and fewer synaptic boutons. Attenuation of both the amplitude and frequency of miniature EPSPs was also observed in neurons from aged animals. Electron micrographs revealed that, although there were many vesicle‐laden preganglionic axonal processes in the vicinity of the postsynaptic membrane, the number of synaptic contacts was significantly lower in old animals. These results demonstrate primary, age‐associated synapse elimination with functional consequences that cannot be explained by pre‐ or postsynaptic cell death. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Neurobiol 60: 214–226, 2004     

Polysialic acid and activity-dependent synapse remodeling

Polysialic acid (PSA) is a large carbohydrate added post-translationally to the extracellular domain of the Neural Cell Adhesion Molecule (NCAM) that influences its adhesive and other functional properties. PSA-NCAM is widely distributed in the developing nervous system where it promotes dynamic cell interactions, like those responsible for axonal growth, terminal sprouting and target innervation. Its expression becomes restricted in the adult nervous system where it is thought to contribute to various forms of neuronal and glial plasticity. We here review evidence, obtained mainly from hypothalamic neuroendocrine centers and the olfactory system, that it intervenes in structural synaptic plasticity and accompanying neuronal-glial transformations, making possible the formation and elimination of synapses that occur under particular physiological conditions. While the mechanism of action of this complex sugar is unknown, it is now clear that it is a necessary molecular component of various cell transformations, including those responsible for activity-dependent synaptic remodeling.Key words: adhesion, synaptic plasticity, astrocytes, central nervous system, hypothalamus, olfactory system     

Morphological effects of ciliary neurotrophic factor treatment during neuromuscular synapse elimination

In adult skeletal muscles, exogenous ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) induces axons and their nerve terminals to sprout. CNTF also regulates the amount of multiple innervation in developing skeletal muscles during synapse elimination, maintaining multiple innervation of muscle fibers. While CNTF may maintain multiple innervation by regulating developmental synapse elimination, it is also possible that CNTF induces the formation of new multiple innervation through a sprouting response. In this study I examined morphologically the effects of CNTF during synapse elimination in the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscle. Rat pups received injections of CNTF in one leg and vehicle in the other either early [postnatal day 7 (P7)-P13] or late (P14–P20) in development. The early treatment period corresponds to that time when the pattern of innervation in the EDL is converted from predominantly multiple to single innervation. The late treatment period is at the end of synapse elimination for the EDL but corresponds to the major period of synapse elimination in the levator ani (LA), allowing a comparison of effects on these two muscles from the same animals. On the day after the final injection, EDL muscles were dissected and stained with tetranitroblue tetrazolium and the resulting pattern of innervation was assessed. The present findings indicate that only the early CNTF treatment regulates the level of multiple innervation in the EDL. Moreover, the effect of early CNTF treatment was local, affecting multiple innervation only in the EDL from the CNTF-treated leg. CNTF injected during the late treatment period had no apparent effects on the EDL but had a potent effect on the pattern of innervation in the LA, significantly increasing the level of multiple innervation in this muscle. Thus, CNTF affected multiple innervation in these two muscles only if provided during the period when single innervation normally develops. There was no evidence to indicate that CNTF induced axons or their terminals to sprout during either treatment period. In conclusion, CNTF increases the level of multiple innervation, probably by regulating synapse elimination, and skeletal muscles themselves may be an important target site for CNTF action. Presumably, the sprouting response to CNTF found in adult muscle develops sometime after P21. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Presynaptic spectrin is essential for synapse stabilization

BACKGROUND: Precise neural circuitry is established and maintained through a regulated balance of synapse stabilization and disassembly. Currently, little is known about the molecular mechanisms that specify synapse stability versus disassembly. RESULTS: Here, we demonstrate that presynaptic spectrin is an essential scaffold that is required to maintain synapse stability at the Drosophila neuromuscular junction (NMJ). Loss of presynaptic spectrin leads to synapse disassembly and ultimately to the elimination of the NMJ. Synapse elimination is documented through light-level, ultrastructural, and electrophysiological assays. These combined assays reveal that impaired neurotransmission is secondary to synapse retraction. We demonstrate that loss of presynaptic, but not postsynaptic, spectrin leads to the disorganization and elimination of essential synaptic cell-adhesion molecules. In addition, we provide evidence of altered axonal transport and disrupted synaptic microtubules as events that contribute to synapse retraction in animals lacking presynaptic spectrin. CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that presynaptic spectrin functions as an essential presynaptic scaffold that may link synaptic cell adhesion with the stabilization of the underlying microtubule cytoskeleton.