Host plant variation in plant-mediated indirect effects: moth boring-induced susceptibility of willows to a specialist leaf beetle

Abstract.  1. We examined the plant-mediated indirect effects of the stem-boring moth Endoclita excrescens (Lepidoptera: Hepialidae) on the leaf beetle Plagiodera versicolora (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) in three willow species, Salix gilgiana , S. eriocarpa , and S. serissaefolia.
2. When the stem-boring moth larvae damaged stems in the previous year, willows were stimulated to produce vigorously growing lateral shoots on these stems. These new lateral shoots were significantly longer and the upper leaves had significantly higher nitrogen and water content than current-year shoots on unbored stems, although the carbon content and leaf dry mass were not different between lateral and current-year shoots.
3. In the field, leaf beetle larvae and adults had significantly greater densities on lateral shoots of bored stems than on current-year shoots of unbored stems. A laboratory experiment showed that female beetles had significantly greater mass and fecundity when fed on leaves of newly-emerged lateral shoots. Thus, the stem-boring moth had a positive effect on the temporally and spatially separated leaf beetle by increasing resource availability by inducing compensatory regrowth.
4. The strength of the indirect effects on the density and performance of the leaf beetle differed among willow species, because there was interspecific variation in host quality and herbivore-induced changes in plant traits. In particular, we suggest that the differences in magnitude of the changes among willow species in shoot length and leaf nitrogen content greatly affected the strength of the plant-regrowth mediated indirect effect, coupled with host-plant preference of the leaf beetle.     

Leaf Production and Morphology in the Artichoke Gall of Yew (Taxus baccata L.)

Comparative leaf production rates and leaf morphology studiesfor galled and normal shoots of yew trees have been obtainedthroughout the life cycle of the causative agent, the gall midge,Taxomyia taxi. Normal and galled shoot leaf numbers have beenrelated to those of their parent shoots. It was found that whereasthe annual leaf production of normal shoots was positively relatedto that of the parent shoots, galled shoot leaf production remainedconstant regardless of parent shoot vigour showing leaf stimulationby the midge to be a special case. The midge larva appears tobe determining the rate of leaf production in galled shoots.In galls leaf production continues throughout the winter monthswith no dormant period. From morphological evidence, alternationof leaves and cataphylls is continued in galled buds.     

Willow regrowth after galling increases bud production through increased shoot survival

Insect herbivory can negatively or positively affect plant performance. We examined how a stem gall midge Rabdophaga rigidae affects the survival, growth, and bud production of current year shoots of the willow Salix eriocarpa. In mid-May, the gall midge initiates stem galls on the apical regions of shoots. The following spring, galled shoots had thicker basal diameters and more lateral shoots than ungalled shoots. Although galled shoots were on average 1.6 times longer than ungalled shoots, there were no significant differences in shoot length or in the numbers of reproductive, vegetative, and dormant buds per shoot. However, the subsequent survival of galled shoots was significantly higher than that of ungalled shoots, probably because of the thicker basal diameter. This increased shoot survival resulted in approximately two times greater reproductive, vegetative, and dormant bud production on galled shoots compared with ungalled shoots in the following spring. These results suggest that the willow regrowth induced by galling can lead to an increase in bud production through increased shoot survival.     

Leaf beetle grazing does not induce willow trichome defence in the coppicing willow Salix viminalis

Abstract 1 Willows are frequently attacked and defoliated by adult leaf beetles (Phratora vulgatissima L.) early in the season and the plants are then attacked again when new larvae emerge. The native willow Salix cinerea has previously been shown to respond to adult grazing by producing new leaves with an increased trichome density. Subsequent larval feeding was reduced on new leaves. This type of induced plant response may reduce insect damage and could potentially be utilized for plant protection in agricultural systems. 2 Here, we investigated if the willow species most commonly used for biomass production in short rotation coppice, Salix viminalis, also responds to adult beetle grazing by increasing trichome density. Larval performance and feeding behaviour on plants previously exposed to adult beetles was compared with that on undefoliated control plants in a greenhouse. 3 We found an overall decrease in trichome density within all the plants (i.e. trichome density was lower on new leaves compared to that for older basal leaves on S. viminalis). However, leaves of beetle defoliated plants had a higher trichome density compared to control plants. Larval growth and feeding was not affected by this difference between treatments. Larvae appeared to remove trichomes when feeding on S. viminalis, a behaviour that might explain the lack of difference between treatments.     

Negative impact of leaf gallers on arctic-alpine dwarf willow, Salix herbacea

According to available evidence, leaf gallers have only minor impacts on their plant hosts. We hypothesised that the relatively large leaf gallers formed by Eupontania sawflies on small, creeping arctic-alpine willows have a strong influence on their host plants. In this study, we specifically tested the effects of leaf galler (Eupontania aquilonis) on the survival and growth of dwarf willow (Salix herbacea) in a mountain snow-bed in northern Finland. We marked galled, leaves-removed and untreated ramets in experimental blocks. In the following year, we measured the growth and survival of the ramets. The mortality of galled shoots was approx. 40% higher, and the mortality of galled ramets approx. 25% higher than in the control ramets and in the leaf-removal treatment. The leaf biomass of galled ramets and the number of leaves were significantly less in galled ramets than in untreated or leaves-removed ramets. It is possible that galling causes fatal resource depletion of shoots in its host plant. The results show that leaf gallers are ecologically more influential than previously thought.     

Size class structure and tree dispersion patterns in old-growth cedar-hemlock forests of the northern Rocky Mountains (USA)

Summary The relationship between the food selection of four leaf beetle species (Phratora vitellinae, Plagiodera versicolora, Lochmaea capreae, Galerucella lineola) and the phenolic glycosides of willow (Salix spp.) leaves was tested in laboratory food choice experiments. Four willow species native to the study area (Eastern Finland) and four introduced, cultivated willows were tested.The willow species exhibited profound differences in their phenolic glycoside composition and total concentration. The food selection patterns of the leaf beetles followed closely the phenolic glycoside spectra of the willow species. Both the total amount and the composition of phenolic glycosides affected the feeding by the beetles. Phenolic glycosides apparently have both stimulatory and inhibitory influences on leaf beetle feeding depending on the degree of adaptation of a particular insect. Very rare glycosides or exceptional combination of several glycoside types seem to provide certain willow species with high level of resistance against most herbivorous insects. Analogously the average absolute amount of leaf beetle feeding was lower on the introduced willows than on the native species to which the local herbivores have a good opportunity to become adapted.     

Host‐plant quality adaptively affects the diapause threshold: evidence from leaf beetles in willow plantations

1. Voltinism of herbivorous insects can vary depending on environmental conditions. The leaf beetle Phratora vulgatissima L. is univoltine in Sweden but will sometimes initiate a second generation in short‐rotation coppice (SRC) willow plantations. 2. The study investigated whether increased voltinism by P. vulgatissima in plantations can be explained by (i) rapid life‐cycle development allowing two generations, or (ii) postponed diapause induction on coppiced willows. 3. In the field, no difference was found in the phenology or development of first‐generation broods between plantations (S. viminalis) and natural willow habitats (S. cinerea). However, the induction of diapause occurred 1–2 weeks later in SRC willow plantations. 4. Laboratory experiments indicated no genetic difference in the critical day‐length for diapause induction between beetles originating from plantations and natural habitats. Development time was unaffected by host‐plant quality but critical day‐length was prolonged by almost an hour when the beetles were reared on a non‐preferred willow species (S. phylicifolia). When reared on new leaves from re‐sprouting shoots of recently coppiced willow plants, diapause incidence was significantly less than when the beetles were reared on mature leaves from uncoppiced plants. 5. The study suggests that P. vulgatissima has a plastic diapause threshold influenced by host‐plant quality. The use of host‐plant quality as a diapause‐inducing stimulus is likely to be adaptive in cases where food resources are unpredictable, such as when new host‐plant tissue is produced after a disturbance. SRC willows may allow two beetle generations due to longer growing seasons of coppiced plants that grow vigorously.     

Chlorogenic acid as an antiherbivore defence of willows against leaf beetles

In the leaves of 13 Finnish willow species, the content of a phenolic, chlorogenic acid, was found to vary from 0 up to 18 mg g^–1 D.W. Effects of pure chlorogenic acid on insect feeding behaviour were tested using four common leaf beetle species which are in the field mainly found on willows with low-chlorogenic acid leaves. One species, Lochmaea capreae L., was invariably deterred by pure chlorogenic acid applied in naturally occurring concentrations on the willow leaves. Accordingly, in 2-choice laboratory feeding trials L. capreae was found to prefer low-chlorogenic acid leaves of four willow species over high-chlorogenic acid leaves of Salix pentandra L. and S. myrsinifolia Salisb. When presented on the leaves of S. phylicifolia L, pure chlorogenic acid inhibited also the feeding by Phratora polaris Sp.-Schn. Instead, chlorogenic acid had no significant effect on Ph. polaris when it was presented on the leaves of another willow S. cinerea L. In laboratory, Ph. polaris did not show general preference for willow species with low chlorogenic acid content in their leaves. Thus, the response of Ph. polaris to chlorogenic acid seems to depend on the plant species. Apparently variation in other traits such as leaf hairyness may easily override the potential effect of chlorogenic acid content on Ph. polaris. To two other leaf beetle species, Galerucella lineola F. and Plagiodera versicolora Laich., chlorogenic acid is an ineffective deterrent even at unnaturally high concentrations. In laboratory, G. lineola and P. versicolora did not prefer willows with low chlorogenic acid content in their leaves. Thus, among four studied leaf beetle species, only L. capreae seems to be clearly affected by this phenolic. Therefore, overall importance of chlorogenic acid as a defence against willow-feeding leaf beetles appears to be very limited.     

Beetle community responses to grey willow (Salix cinerea) invasion within three New Zealand wetlands

Abstract

We investigated the effects of invasion by introduced grey willow (Salix cinerea) on beetle communities within four wetland vegetation types: native vegetation, native vegetation following grey willow removal, native vegetation undergoing grey willow invasion and dense grey willow-dominated vegetation. In total, 1505 beetles from 90 species were collected using modified Malaise traps. Native wetland vegetation had significantly lower beetle species richness than willow-dominated vegetation and was dominated by herbivores, whereas detritivores characterised willow-dominated vegetation. Beetle abundance was highest in the willow-dominated vegetation and mostly comprised detritivores. In contrast, beetle abundance was lowest in native wetland vegetation, but had even proportions of herbivores and detritivores. Native wetland vegetation had a high proportion of native beetles present. As grey willows invaded, introduced beetles became more common. The beetle community composition differed significantly between grey willow-dominated vegetation and native wetland vegetation. These compositional differences were mainly due to the increasing complexity of vegetation structure following grey willow invasion. The beetle communities within restored native wetland vegetation were most similar to those within the native wetland vegetation. From a conservation perspective, these results are encouraging and suggest that, although grey willows dramatically alter the composition of beetle communities present, these communities can be restored to a beetle fauna that is similar to those found within native wetland through the removal of the willows.     

Bottom-up cascade in a tri-trophic system: different impacts of host-plant regeneration on performance of a willow leaf beetle and its natural enemy

Abstract.  1. Plant quality can directly and indirectly affect the third trophic level. However, little attention has been paid to how changes in plant quality affect the performance of predators through trophic levels, and which herbivores or predators are affected more strongly by host-plant quality. The present study examined the effects of artificial cutting of willows on the performance of a willow leaf beetle ( Plagiodera versicolora Laicharting) and its predatory ladybird beetle ( Aiolocaria hexaspilota Hope).
2. Laboratory experiments showed that performance (survival rate, developmental time, and adult mass) of the willow leaf beetle was higher when fed with leaves of cut willows than when fed with leaves of uncut willows. Performance (developmental time and adult mass) of the predatory ladybird was also improved when it was fed on the leaf beetle larvae that had been fed on leaves of cut willows, compared with those that had been fed on leaves of uncut willows. This indicates that a bottom-up cascade occurs in the tri-trophic system.
3. In a comparison of improved performance parameters between the leaf beetle and the ladybird, regenerated willows shortened the developmental time of the willow leaf beetle more than that of the ladybird. This indicates that the impacts of willow cutting on insect performance differ between the second and third trophic levels.     

Does Rust Infection of Willow Affect Feeding and Oviposition Behavior of Willow Leaf Beetles?

Willows are often attacked by both herbivorous insects and rust fungi. Little is known about interactions between these two willow enemies. We studied whether feeding and oviposition behavior of the willow leaf beetle Plagiodera versicolora upon the willow hybrid Salix x cuspidata is affected when the rust fungus Melampsora allii-fragilis has attacked the plant. Laboratory bioassays revealed that adult willow leaf beetles significantly avoided feeding and oviposition on rust-infected leaves when compared to healthy leaves. Further bioassays aimed to elucidate the temporal and spatial scale of effects of rust infection on feeding behavior of adults. While infected parts of leaves were avoided at all times past infection tested (8, 12, and 16 days), symptom-free parts of infected leaves were only avoided 16 days past infection. Systemic effects extended only one leaf position up and two leaf positions down from the infection site.     

Beetle assemblages on willow trees: do phenolic glycosides matter?

Herbivorous beetles were sampled in central Slovakia and in the Tatra Mountains of northern Slovakia from seven different Salix species which are partly characterized by smooth leaves containing phenolic glycosides and partly by hairy leaves containing tannins. The collection included about 8000 individuals representing 129 species. Of the 129 species, 77 species are able to use the willows as hosts; the remaining 52 ‘tourist’ species comprise less than 3% of the collected individuals. The data on species richness and abundance did not generally support the ‘feeding specialization’ hypothesis. The proportion of specialized (= monophagous and oligophagous) beetles feeding on willows of both morphological and biochemical groups was in the same range. Host plants of the two groups could support high diversity and high evenness values, even when leaf characteristics and plant chemicals largely influenced species assemblage. The region in which the willow trees grow had a considerable impact on host plant use. Generalist beetle species predominated in central Slovakia. By contrast, in the Tatra Mountains, specialist feeders which are able to use phenolic glycosides to their advantage were predominant. The number of species and the total density of individuals collected from willows containing phenolic glycosides (S. fragilis and S. purpurea) did not usually vary between the two regions. In contrast, fewer species and individuals were found in the Tatra Mountains when they settled on willow species containing tannins (S. caprea and S. cinerea). Also, the phylogenetic status of host plants affected species assemblages. In central Slovakia willow species of the subgenus Vetrix (S. purpurea, S. caprea and S. cinerea) generally showed a higher beetle diversity (H_s) than species of the subgenus Salix (S. fragilis, S. alba and S. triandra), although both subgenera comprise species of both morphological and biochemical groups. Furthermore, when the analysis was restricted to beetles of central Slovakia, which should be most adapted to their host plants (i.e. catkin feeders and phyllophages in the adult and larval stage), the phylogenetic status was found to be more important than any single leaf character measured.     

Mortality factors and resource use of the bud-galling sawfly, Euura mucronata (Hartig), on willows (Salix spp.) in arctic Eurasia

We studied egg and larval mortality factors in arctic populations of the bud-galling sawfly, Euura mucronata (Hartig) on three willow species (Salix glauca L., S. phylicifolia L., and S. lapponum L.) and the quality of resources (shoot length of willows) required for egg-laying. The survival was independent of latitude. There was a positive correlation in survival on different willow species among sampling sites, indicating that similar, locally operating factors affected survival. Host plant-based mortality factors were dominant and caused 17.9–48.0% mortality in eggs and 6.6–44.1% mortality in larvae. Parasitoids and inquilines caused relatively low and variable rates of mortality. Parasitoids were absent from several of the northernmost populations, but caused up to 11.0% mortality at southern sites. Mortality caused by inquilines was minor in other areas except in some sites in the Taymyr Peninsula, where it varied from 0 to 23.1%. E. mucronata laid eggs on the longest shoots available. Plant vigour as measured by shoot length decreased toward the north, and densities of galls were positively correlated with plant vigour. The difference in length between galled and ungalled shoots was 2.0- to 4.6-fold. Absence of E. mucronata in the most northern populations of willows was apparently caused by insufficient shoot growth. Short shoots failed to provide sufficient resources for successful development of galls. Our results suggest that the quality of host plants is the main factor determining abundance and distribution of E. mucronata in arctic areas. Received: 10 February 1997 / Accepted: 2 May 1997     

Spatio-temporal abundance of flushing leaves shapes host selection in the willow leaf beetle, Plagiodera versicolora

In the willow leaf beetle, Plagiodera versicolora (Laicharting) (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), food resources available for adults are severely restricted by leaf toughness, which increases with age. Nevertheless, females require their own food almost all their life in order to produce eggs. In this paper, we have focused our attention on the spatio-temporal abundance of flushing leaves and have examined its effect on host-plant selection by adults among four co-occurring willow species ( Salix chaenomeloides , Salix eriocarpa , Salix integra , and Salix serissaefolia ) (Salicaceae) by field observations and experiments at two spatial scales. Among the various factors associated with this, the amount of new leaf production contributed maximally to variation in adult abundance. By conducting two experiments, we confirmed that the adults preferentially flew towards willow trees with abundant flushing leaves. Furthermore, we detected substantial seasonal changes in new leaf abundance and realized fecundity in the field, and a strong positive correlation was observed between them. Availability of adult food resources limited the reproductive performance of adults, particularly in mid-summer when only S. serissaefolia produced a few new leaves. These results supported the substantial effect of new leaf abundance on adult abundance in the field. Thus, we concluded that adult feeding is a critical factor that shapes the host-plant selection of P. versicolora and determines its seasonal occurrence through the dispersal and settlement of adults.     

Release of phylogenetic constraints through low resource heterogeneity: the case of gall-inducing sawflies

Abstract. 1. A group of six unusual sawfly species, which do not conform to the phylogenetic constraints hypothesis as it has been applied to sawflies, was examined in natural populations. All species were in the genus Pontania (Hymenoptera: Tenthredinidae), which induce galls on leaves of willow species (Salicaceae). An understanding of these non‐conformist species was important as a test of the validity of the general hypothesis. 2. The six species of sawfly, Pontania mandshurica, P. cf. arcticornis, P. aestiva, P. arcticornis, P. pacifica, and P. nr. pacifica, showed no oviposition preference for long, vigorous shoots, in contrast to 37 documented tenthredinid species that have demonstrated such a preference. Rather, the non‐conformist species attacked the shortest shoot length classes more frequently and larval establishment in galls was successful. 3. The evident escape from the phylogenetic constraint, which commonly limits sawfly attack to the most vigorous shoots in a willow population, resulted from low apparent heterogeneity of the resources exploited by these Pontania species. At the time of female oviposition, shoots and leaves were too uniform to allow discrimination by females among shoot length classes, resulting in random, or near random attack of shoots. 4. The unusual relative uniformity of resources to which sawflies were exposed resulted from several characteristics. (1) Females emerged early relative to shoot growth phenology, making discrimination among shoot length and vigour difficult or impossible. (2) Low heterogeneity in leaf length resulted in resource similarity independent of shoot length. (3) Abscission of leaves occurred after emergence of larvae from leaf galls so that differential abscission of leaves in relation to shoot length became irrelevant. (4) In some cases, low variance in shoot lengths was evident in old ramets lacking long, vigorous shoots. Probably as a result of low resource heterogeneity, larvae survived well across all shoot length classes, revealing no ovipositional preference and larval performance linkage related to the exploitation of the longest shoot length classes in a population of willows, as in the conformist species. Therefore, larval survival did not provide positive feedback on female preferential behaviour for long shoots, as in the conformist species studied.     

Patterns of gall-forming in Ossaea confertiflora (Melastomataceae) by Lopesia brasiliensis (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) in an area of Atlantic Rainforest in southeastern Brazil

Patterns of galling by the gall midge Lopesia brasiliensis (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) were studied in Ossaea confertiflora (Melastomataceae) in an Atlantic forest site at Ilha Grande, RJ. Out of the 81 plants surveyed, 55 (67.9%) bore galls. The number of galls per galled individual ranged from 1 to 261 and 94.4% of the galls were in leaves. The number of galls per galled leaf varied from 1 to 25. Total gall number was positively correlated with plant height. Larger and more ramified plants tended to have a smaller percentage of their leaves with galls and a lower density of galls per leaf than smaller plants. Plants that were close to other individuals of the same species tended to have more galls per leaf than relatively isolated plants. The observed patterns may be linked to strategies of optimization in the use of resources (i.e. oviposition sites) and predation avoidance by the gall midges.     

Interactions between the willow beetle Phratora vulgatissima and different genotypes of Salix viminalis

Abstract 1 Planting of species mixtures is a strategy for the non‐chemical management of willow beetles in short‐rotation coppice willows. However, the relatively susceptible Salix viminalis genotypes and their hybrids dominate current high‐yielding willows. Interactions between Phratora vulgatissima and different genotypes of S. viminalis were examined under laboratory conditions to determine if these genotypes exhibit genetic differences in susceptibility to willow beetle damage. 2 Seven S. viminalis genotypes and four hybrids were tested for the feeding preference of adult P. vulgatissima, larval performance and within‐season plant response to manual defoliation (50% and 75%). 3 The feeding preference of adult beetles, the growth rate of larvae, and the weight at 33 days of larvae and pupae differed significantly between genotypes. Genotypes also differed significantly in their height and weight responses to mechanical defoliation. Two genotypes were taller, with longer internodes, after defoliation than were undamaged plants. Two hybrids and their S. viminalis parent showed no significant reduction in final dry weight between 0% and 50% defoliation treatments. 4 Susceptibility of genotypes to adult feeding was not correlated with their tolerance to defoliation in terms of weight or height responses; however, larval growth rate on genotypes was negatively correlated both with final height and number of leaves after 75% defoliation and with the susceptibility of genotype to adult feeding. 5 Salix viminalis showed genetic differences for all parameters tested. This suggests that the planting of a mixture of these genotypes would contain genetic differences with respect to host susceptibility to P. vulgatissima. Some parameters showed similarities between a hybrid and its parent, whereas others showed differences between siblings. This offers potential for effective breeding of desirable traits.     

Rapid gall midge adaptation to a resistant willow genotype

Abstract 1 We conducted two experiments to investigate why a basket willow Salix viminalis L. genotype, known to be highly resistant to the leaf-roller gall midge Dasineura marginemtorquens (Bremi), should support very high gall densities in a field plantation at Tälle, south Sweden.
2 The first experiment was a field test of the hypothesis of fine-scale host adaptation in the gall midge/willow system. Support for the hypothesis would be established if midges originating from resistant willows and those originating from nearby susceptible willows differed in their abilities to initiate galls and complete development on resistant plants.
3 The objective of the second experiment was to explore whether there was a genetic basis to the trait for virulence in the midge population and to investigate any potential trade-offs this trait may entail.
4 Our results indicate that there was a fine-scaled microgeographic genetic structure to the midge population at Tälle. Midges originating from resistant plants had a heritable trait that enabled them to establish galls on resistant plants.
5 Midges able to initiate galls on the resistant genotype had longer developmental time on the susceptible genotype. This suggests that there is a physiological cost associated with being adapted to the resistant willow genotype.
6 We suggest that driving forces behind the observed host adaptation are selection imposed on the midge population by very strong willow resistance and restricted gene flow in the midge populations due to the special life history features of D. marginemtorquens .     

Multiple effects of precipitation onSalix lasiolepis and populations of the stem-galling sawfly,Euura lasiolepis

Relatively low winter precipitation (e.g., 18–28 cm from October to May compared to 45 to 65 cm) caused reduced growth of the arroyo willow,Salix lasiolepis, with number of shoots per stem initiated and shoot length reduced. Resources were reduced for the stem-galling sawfly,Euura lasiolepis, which declined in numbers after the relatively dry winter of 1980–81. Sawfly phenology was advanced relative to willow phenology in the 1981 generation, causing an additional reduction in resource availability. These direct effects of precipitation on the sawfly were increased by indirect effects on survivorship of the 1981 generation. Egg death in galls increased on water-stressed willow plants, forming the major mortality in the generation. This resulted in very low survival in the generation and an even lower population in the 1982 generation, even though resources recovered after high precipitation during the 1981–82 winter (46.7 cm). An experiment using high, medium, and low water treatments on potted willow plants demonstrated that the effects on willows and sawflies could be reproduced using only water as a variable.     

Carbon–nitrogen stoichiometry in the tritrophic food chain willow, leaf beetle, and predatory ladybird beetle

Although plant quality can indirectly increase the performance of the third trophic level by bottom-up cascading effects, the mechanisms of this indirect effect are still unclear. In this study the carbon–nitrogen stoichiometry in a tri-trophic system consisting of the willow, a leaf beetle, and a predatory ladybird beetle were examined to determine the mechanisms of the bottom-up cascading effect. The bottom-up cascade is initiated by increasing leaf nitrogen, because of artificial cutting of willow trees. The relative growth rate (RGR) of the leaf beetle increased when fed on cut willow leaves, because of the high leaf nitrogen in the cut willows. Ladybird beetle RGR also increased when fed on leaf beetles fed on cut willow leaves. The increased RGR of the ladybirds cannot be explained by the quality of the prey, however, because leaf beetle nitrogen was not affected by host plant quality. Thus, the carbon–nitrogen stoichiometry could not be a mechanism of the bottom-up cascade through multiple trophic levels.