Evolution of the bovine lysozyme gene family: Changes in gene expression and reversion of function

Recruitment of lysozyme to a digestive function in ruminant artiodactyls is associated with amplification of the gene. At least four of the approximately ten genes are expressed in the stomach, and several are expressed in nonstomach tissues. Characterization of additional lysozymelike sequences in the bovine genome has identified most, if not all, of the members of this gene family. There are at least six stomachlike lysozyme genes, two of which are pseudogenes. The stomach lysozyme pseudogenes show a pattern of concerted evolution similar to that of the functional stomach genes. At least four nonstomach lysozyme genes exist. The nonstomach lysozyme genes are not monophyletic. A gene encoding a tracheal lysozyme was isolated, and the stomach lysozyme of advanced ruminants was found to be more closely related to the tracheal lysozyme than to the stomach lysozyme of the camel or other nonstomach lysozyme genes of ruminants. The tracheal lysozyme shares with stomach lysozymes of advanced ruminants the deletion of amino acid 103, and several other adaptive sequence characteristics of stomach lysozymes. I suggest here that tracheal lysozyme has reverted from a functional stomach lysozyme. Tracheal lysozyme then represents a second instance of a change in lysozyme gene expression and function within ruminants. Correspondence to: D.M. Irwin     

Amino acid sequences of stomach and nonstomach lysozymes of ruminants

Summary Complete amino acid sequences are presented for lysozymesc from camel and goat stomachs and compared to sequences of other lysozymesc. Tree analysis suggests that the rate of amino acid replacement went up as soon as lysozyme was recruited for the stomach function in early ruminants. The two lysozymes from goat stomach are the products of a gene duplication that probably took place before the divergence of cow, goat, and deer about 25 million years ago. Partial sequences of three lysozymes from goat tears indicated that (a) the goat tear family of lysozymes may have diverged from the stomach lysozyme family by an ancient duplication and (b) later duplications are probably responsible for the multiple forms of tear and milk lysozymes in ruminants.     

Multiple cDNA sequences and the evolution of bovine stomach lysozyme

To investigate the origin of stomach expression of lysozyme in ruminants; we surveyed clones from a cow stomach cDNA library with a lysozyme cDNA probe. Ten percent of the clones in this library were lysozyme-specific. Thirty of the lysozyme clones were sequenced, and seven types of lysozyme mRNA sequence were found. They encode the three previously identified stomach isozymes of lysozyme. The seven sequences are closely related to one another and represent the products of a minimum of 4 of the approximately 10 cow lysozyme genes detected by genomic blotting. The most abundant form of stomach lysozyme (form 2) is encoded by at least two genes, whereas forms 1 and 3 are possibly each encoded by only one gene. The number of genes encoding each isozyme appears to contribute the largest factor in the relative abundance of each isozyme. The multiple lysozyme genes expressed in the cow stomach are the result of gene duplications that occurred during ruminant evolution. The recruitment of lysozyme as a major enzyme in the stomach may thus have involved an early regulatory event and a later 4-7-fold increase in expression allowed by gene amplification. During this period, the amino acid sequences of these lysozymes have been evolving more slowly than those of nonruminant lysozymes.     

Evolutionary genetics of ruminant lysozymes

Comparative studies of mammalian lysozymes and their genes have contributed to knowledge of how new functions arise during evolution. The recruitment of lysozymes for functioning in the stomach fluid of ruminants has occurred in response to selection pressures that are partly known and on a time-scale that is known. A semiquantitative analysis of adaptive evolution is thus made possible by the ruminant lysozyme system. Large-scale production of lysozyme by the stomach lining entailed gene duplication as well as a change in gene expression. Remoulding of the lysozyme for working and lasting in the stomach fluid involved accelerated amino acid replacements, which may have been facilitated by intergenic recombination. The possibility that multigene families can accelerate adaptive evolution, by virtue of their capacity for bringing together functionally coupled substitutions, receives emphasis in this review.     

Concerted evolution of ruminant stomach lysozymes. Characterization of lysozyme cDNA clones from sheep and deer

Contradictory evolutionary histories of ruminant lysozymes have been predicted by analysis of genomic blots (Irwin, D.M., Sidow, A., White, R., and Wilson, A.C. (1989) in The Immune Response to Structurally Defined Proteins: The Lysozyme Model (Smith-Gill, S.J., and Sercarz, E.E., eds) pp. 73-85, Adenine Press, Guilderland, NY) and sequences of cow stomach lysozyme cDNAs (Irwin, D.M., and Wilson, A.C. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 11387-11393). Genomic blots indicate that the amplification of the lysozyme gene family occurred 40-50 million years ago, while the cDNA sequences imply that the stomach genes began diverging from one another after the splitting of the deer and cow lineages, 25 million years ago. To resolve this contradiction, we characterized 111 stomach lysozyme cDNAs from two additional ruminant species: domestic sheep and axis deer. The cDNA sequences of the coding region of mature lysozyme together with the 3'-untranslated region were obtained from abomasum (true stomach) mRNA with the use of the polymerase chain reaction. The two primers for amplifying the cDNA were a lysozyme-specific primer, encoding a conserved sequence at the amino terminus of mature stomach lysozyme, and oligo(dT) as a general mRNA primer. Comparison of the cDNA sequences from these species to one another and to those of the cow revealed that different parts of the ruminant stomach lysozyme genes have had different evolutionary histories. The 3'-untranslated region has evolved in a divergent fashion since the original duplications 40-50 million years ago, supporting the genomic blot interpretation; by contrast, the coding region has evolved in a concerted fashion, that is, the multiple sequences within a species have evolved in unison. The 3'-untranslated portion of the lysozyme genes appears to have escaped from concerted evolution due to inability to initiate concerted evolution, rather than due to reduced sequence similarity. The process of concerted evolution in stomach lysozymes may have had roles both in adapting lysozyme to the stomach environment in early ruminants as well as in retarding amino acid sequence evolution in the well adapted lysozyme of modern ruminants.     

Parallel functional changes in the digestive RNases of ruminants and colobines by divergent amino acid substitutions

A morphological or physiological trait may appear multiple times in evolution. At the molecular level, similar protein functions may emerge independently in different lineages. Whether these parallel functional changes are due to parallel amino acid substitutions has been a subject of debate. Here, I address this question using digestive ribonucleases (RNases) of two groups of foregut-fermenting mammals: ruminant artiodactyls and colobine monkeys. The RNase1 gene was duplicated twice in ancestral ruminants at least 40 MYA, and it was also duplicated in the douc langur, an Asian colobine, approximately 4 MYA. After duplication, similar functional changes occurred in the ruminant and monkey enzymes. Interestingly, five amino acid substitutions in ruminant RNases that are known to affect its catalytic activity against double-stranded (ds) RNA did not occur in the monkey enzyme. Rather, a similar functional change in the monkey was caused by a different set of nine substitutions. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to make three of the five ruminant-specific substitutions in the monkey enzyme. Functional assays of these mutants showed that one of the three substitutions has a similar effect in monkeys, the second has a stronger effect, and the third has an opposite effect. These results suggest that (1) an evolutionary problem can have multiple solutions, (2) the same amino acid substitution may have opposite functional effects in homologous proteins, (3) the stochastic processes of mutation and drift play an important role even at functionally important sites, and (4) protein sequences may diverge even when their functions converge.     

Evolution of cow nonstomach lysozyme genes.

Expansion of the lysozyme gene family is associated with the evolution of the ruminant lifestyle in ruminant artiodactyls such as the cow. Gene duplications allowed recombination between stomach lysozyme genes that may have assisted in the evolution of an enzyme adapted to survive and function in the stomach environment. Despite amplification of lysozyme genes, cow tears, milk, and blood are considered to be lysozyme deficient. Here we have identified 2 new cow lysozyme cDNA sequences and show that at least 4 different lysozymes are expressed in cows in nonstomach tissues and probably function as antibacterial defence enzymes. These 4 lysozyme genes are in addition to the 4 digestive lysozyme genes expressed in the stomach, yielding a number of expressed lysozyme genes in the cow larger than that found in most nonlysozyme-deficient mammals. In contrast to expectations, evidence for recombination between stomach and nonstomach lysozyme genes was found. Recombination, through concerted evolution, may have allowed some lysozymes to acquire the ability to survive in occasional acidic environments.     

Molecular genetics and evolution of stomach and nonstomach lysozymes in the hoatzin

Multiple genes of the hoatzin encoding stomach lysozyme c and closely related members of this calcium-binding lysozyme c group were cloned from a genomic DNA library and sequenced. There are a minimum of five genes represented among these sequences that encode two distinct groups of protein sequences. One group of three genes corresponds to the stomach lysozyme amino acid sequences, and the remaining genes encode predicted proteins that are more basic in character and share several sequence identities with the pigeon egg-white lysozyme rather than with the hoatzin stomach lysozymes. Despite these structural similarities between some of the hoatzin gene products and the pigeon lysozyme, phylogenetic analyses indicate that all of the hoatzin sequences are closely related to one another. This is borne out by the relatively small genetic distances even in the intronic regions, which are not subject to the selective pressures operating on the coding regions of the stomach lysozymes. These results suggest that multiple gene duplication events have occurred during the evolution of hoatzin lysozymes.     

Mosaic evolution of ruminant stomach lysozyme genes

The genomes of ruminant artiodactyls, such as cow and sheep, have approximately 10 lysozyme genes, 4 of which are expressed in the stomach. Most of the duplications of the lysozyme genes occurred 40-50 million years ago, before the divergence of cow and sheep. Despite this, the coding regions of stomach lysozyme genes within a species (e.g., cow, sheep, or deer) are more similar to each other than to lysozyme genes in other ruminants. This observation suggests that the coding regions of the stomach lysozyme genes have evolved in a concerted fashion. Our previous characterization of 3 cow stomach lysozyme genes suggested that it was only the coding exons that had participated in concerted evolution. To determine whether the introns and flanking regions of ruminant stomach lysozyme genes are evolving in a concerted or a divergent fashion, we have isolated and characterized 2 sheep stomach lysozyme genes. Comparison of the sequences of the sheep and cow stomach lysozyme genes clearly shows that the introns and flanking regions have evolved, like the 3' untranslated region of the mRNAs, in a divergent manner. Thus, if the four coding exons are evolving by concerted evolution, then a mosaic pattern of concerted and divergent evolution is occurring in these genes. The independent concerted evolution of coding exons of the ruminant stomach lysozyme gene may have assisted in the accelerated adaptive evolution of the lysozyme to new function in the early ruminant.     

Physical mapping of the lysozyme gene family in cattle

Amplification of an ancestral lysozyme gene in artiodactyls is associated with the evolution of foregut fermetation in the ruminant lineage and has resulted in about ten lysozyme genes in true ruminants. Hybridization of a cow stomach lysozyme 2 cDNA clone to restricted DNAs of a panel of cowxhamster hybrid cell lines revealed that all but one of the multiple bovine-specific bands segregate concordantly with the marker for bovine syntenic group U3 [Chromosome (Chr) 5]. The anomalous band was subsequently mapped to bovine syntenic group U22 (Chr 7) with a second panel of hybrids representing all 31 bovine syntenic groups. By two-dimensional pulsed-field gel electrophoresis the lysozyme genes on cattle Chr 5 were shown to be clustered on a 2- to 3-Mb DNA fragment, while the lactalbumin gene and pseudogenes that are paralogous and syntenic with the lysozymes were outside the lysozyme gene cluster. Chromosomal fluorescence in situ hybridization of a cocktail of lysozyme genomic clones localized the lysozyme gene cluster to cattle Chr 5 band 23, corroborating the somatic cell assignment.     

Molecular adaptation of a leaf-eating bird: stomach lysozyme of the hoatzin

This report describes a lysozyme expressed at high levels in the stomach of the hoatzin, the only known foregut-fermenting bird. Evolutionary comparison places it among the calcium-binding lysozymes rather than among the conventional types. Conventional lysozymes were recruited as digestive enzymes twice in the evolution of mammalian foregut fermenters, and these independently recruited lysozymes share convergent structural changes attributed to selective pressures in the stomach. Biochemical convergence and parallel amino acid replacements are observed in the hoatzin stomach lysozyme even though it has a different genetic origin from the mammalian examples and has undergone more than 300 million years of independent evolution.      

Isolation and characterization of a cDNA encoding for a lysozyme from the gut of the reduviid bug Triatoma infestans

We have isolated and characterised a Triatoma infestans cDNA encoding a lysozyme. A 174-bp fragment was amplified by PCR using degenerate oligodeoxyribonucleotide primers derived from the known amino acid sequences of lysozyme from other insects. This PCR fragment was used to screen a cDNA gut library of T. infestans. A clone containing the 3'-end of the lysozyme cDNA (219 bp) was isolated and sequenced. RACE was used to amplify the 5'-end of the lysozyme cDNA. After sequencing the complete lysozyme cDNA, the deduced 417 amino acid sequence showed high identity (40-50%) with other chicken-type lysozymes. The amino acid residues responsible for the catalytic activity and the binding of the substrate were essentially conserved. The expression pattern of the lysozyme gene in bugs at different molting and feeding states showed that this gene was upregulated in the digestive tract directly after the molt and after feeding. Additionally, this lysozyme gene was expressed differently in the different regions of the digestive tract, strongly in the cardia and stomach, the anterior regions of the midgut, and only traces of lysozyme mRNA could be detected in the small intestine, the posterior region of the midgut.     

Lysozymes in insects: what role do they play in nitrogen metabolism?

Abstract. Lysozymes are widely distributed in many organisms as one of the components of defence mechanisms. In herbivores, when nitrogen is not contained in sufficient amounts in the diet, bacteria lysed by stomach lysozymes are used as sources of nitrogen. In ruminants, lysozymes function as digestive enzymes in the true stomach. A convergence of amino acid sequence has been shown between the stomach lysozymes of different ruminants, and similar lysozymes have recently been reported in the gut or salivary gland of insects. In this mini review, the enzymatic and ecological functions of lysozymes in insects, particularly in termites, are introduced, together with future studies that are needed in this field.     

Cloning of cDNAs and hybridization analysis of lysozymes from two oyster species, Crassostrea gigas and Ostrea edulis

In bivalve molluscs including oysters, lysozymes play an important role in the host defense mechanisms against invading microbes. However, it remains unclear in which sites/cells the lysozyme genes are expressed and which subsequently produced the enzyme. This study cloned lysozyme cDNAs from the digestive organs of Pacific oyster Crassostrea gigas and European flat oyster Ostrea edulis. Both complete sequences of two oysters' lysozymes were composed of 137 amino acids. Two translated proteins present a high content in cysteine residues. Phylogenetic analyses showed that these oysters' lysozymes clustered with the invertebrate-type lysozymes of other bivalve species. In the Pacific oyster, lysozyme mRNA was expressed in all tissues except for those of the adductor muscle. In situ hybridization analyses revealed that lysozyme mRNA was expressed strongly in basophil cells in the digestive gland tubule of C. gigas, but not in digestive cells. Results indicated that the basophil cells of the oyster digestive gland are the sites of lysozyme synthesis.     

Calcium-binding and structural stability of echidna and canine milk lysozymes.

For echidna and canine milk lysozymes, which were presumed to be the calcium-binding lysozymes by their amino acid sequences, we have quantitated their calcium-binding strength and examined their guanidine unfolding profiles. The calcium-binding constants of echidna and canine lysozymes were determined to be 8.6 x 10(6) M(-1) and 8.9 x 10(6) M(-1) in 0.1 M KCl at pH 7.1 and 20 C, respectively. The unfolding of decalcified canine lysozyme proceeds in the same manner as that of alpha-lactalbumin, through a stable molten globule intermediate. However, neither calcium-bound nor decalcified echidna lysozyme shows a stable molten globule intermediate. This unfolding profile of echidna lysozyme is identical to that of conventional lysozymes and pigeon egg-white lysozyme, avian calcium-binding lysozyme. This result supports the suggestion of Prager and Jolles (Prager EM, Jolles P. 1996. Animal lysozymes c and g: An overview. In: Jolles P, ed. Lysozymes: Model enzymes in biochemistry and biology. Basel-Boston-Berlin: Birkhauzer Verlag. pp 9-31) that the lineage of avian and echidna calcium-binding lysozymes and that of eutherian calcium-binding lysozymes diverged separately from that of conventional lysozymes.     

cDNA and amino acid sequences of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) lysozymes and their implications for the evolution of lysozyme and lactalbumin

Summary The complete 129-amino-acid sequences of two rainbow trout lysozymes (I and II) isolated from kidney were established using protein chemistry microtechniques. The two sequences differ only at position 86, I having aspartic acid and II having alanine. A cDNA clone coding for rainbow trout lysozyme was isolated from a cDNA library made from liver mRNA. Sequencing of the cloned cDNA insert, which was 1 kb in length, revealed a 432-bp open reading frame encoding an amino-terminal peptide of 15 amino acids and a mature enzyme of 129 amino acids identical in sequence to II. Forms I and II from kidney and liver were also analyzed using enzymatic amplification via PCR and direct sequencing; both organs contain mRNA encoding the two lysozymes. Evolutionary trees relating DNA sequences coding for lysozymesc and α-lactalbumins provide evidence that the gene duplication giving rise to conventional vertebrate lysozymesc and to lactalbumin preceded the divergence of fishes and tetrapods about 400 Myr ago. Evolutionary analysis also suggests that amino acid replacements may have accumulated more slowly on the lineage leading to fish lysozyme than on those leading to mammal and bird lysozymes.     

Cloning and expression analysis of c-type and g-type lysozymes in yellow catfish (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Pelteobagrus fulvidraco</Emphasis>)

Lysozymes have important roles in innate immune system. Here, a c-type and a g-type lysozyme were identified from yellow catfish (Pelteobagrus fulvidraco). The deduced amino acid sequences of both lysozymes were conserved in catalytic sites and structural features as compared to their counterparts from other species. It was interesting that the g-type lysozyme possessed a signal peptide. The c-type and g-type lysozymes had the highest identity 89.4 and 76.2 % with that from channel catfish respectively. Phylogenetic analysis showed that the two lysozymes had a closely relationship with that from channel catfish and Astyanax mexicanus. Lysozymes from one order could form more than one clade in the phylogenetic tree, which indicated the gene duplications in evolution. Expression analysis with real time quantitative PCR revealed that the two lysozyme genes were constitutively expressed in all the tested tissues. The highest expression of c-type lysozyme was observed in liver, followed by spleen, head kidney, and trunk kidney, while the g-type lysozyme had highest expression in intestine, followed by spleen, head kidney, and trunk kidney. The mRNA levels of both genes were all up-regulated after challenging with Aeromonas hydrophila. However, there were differences in tissues and time points when the mRNA levels reached its peak between the two lysozymes. It indicated the diversity in regulation mechanisms and detailed functions among lysozymes. Taking together, these results will benefit the understanding of yellow catfish lysozymes.     

Yak (Bos Grunniens) Stomach Lysozyme: Molecular Cloning,Expression and its Antibacterial Activities

The cDNA coding for stomach lysozyme in yak was cloned. The cloned cDNA contains a 432 bp open reading frame and encodes 143 amino acids (16.24 KDa) with a signal peptide of 18 amino acids. Further analysis revealed that its amino acid sequence shares many common properties with cow milk lysozyme. Expression of this gene was also detected in mammary gland tissue by RT-PCR. Phylogenetic relationships among yak stomach lysozyme and 8 cow lysozymes indicated that the yak enzyme is more closely related to both cow milk lysozyme and the pseudogene ΨNS4 than cow stomach lysozyme. Recombinant yak lysozyme purified by Ni²⁺-column showed a molecular weight of 33.78 kDa and exhibited lytic activity against Staphylococcus aureus, providing evidence of its antibacterial activities.     

Stomach lysozymes of ruminants. II. Amino acid sequence of cow lysozyme 2 and immunological comparisons with other lysozymes

The complete sequence of 129 amino acids has been determined for one of three closely related lysozymes c purified from cow stomach mucosa. The sequence differs from those known for 17 other lysozymes c at 39-60 positions, at one of which there has been a deletion of 1 amino acid. The glutamate replacement at position 101 and the deletion of proline at position 102 eliminate the aspartyl-prolyl bond that is present between these positions in all other mammalian lysozymes c tested. This bond appears to be the most acid-sensitive one in such lysozymes at physiological temperature. Of the 40 positions previously found to be invariant among lysozymes c, only one has undergone substitution in the cow lineage. This modest number of changes at novel positions is consistent with the inference, based on tree analysis and antigenic comparisons, that the tempo of evolutionary change in the cow lysozyme lineage has not been radically different from that in other lysozyme c lineages. The mutations responsible for the distinctive catalytic properties and stability of cow lysozyme c could be a minor fraction of the total that have been fixed in the cow lineage.