Partial medial meniscectomy and rotational differences at the knee during walking

Loss of meniscal function due to injury or partial meniscectomy is common and represents a significant risk factor for premature osteoarthritis. The menisci can influence the transverse plane movements (anterior–posterior (AP) translation and internal–external (IE) rotation) of the knee during walking. While walking is the most frequent activity of daily living, the kinematic differences at the knee during walking associated with the meniscal injury are not well understood. This study examined the influence of partial medial meniscectomy (PMM) on the kinematics and kinetics of the knee during the stance phase of gait by testing the differences in anterior–posterior translation, internal–external rotation, knee flexion range of movement, peak flexion/extension moments, and adduction moments between the PMM and healthy contralateral limbs. Ten patients (45±9 years old, height 1.75±0.06 m, weight 76.7±13.5 kg) who had undergone partial medial meniscectomy (33±100 months post-op) in one limb with a healthy contralateral limb were tested during normal walking. The contralateral limb was compared to a matched control group and no differences were found. The primary kinematic difference was a significantly greater external rotation (3.2°) of the tibia that existed through stance phase, with 8 of 10 subjects demonstrating the same pattern. The PMM subjects also exhibited significantly lower peak flexion and extension moments in their PMM limbs. The altered rotational position found likely results in changes of tibio-femoral contact during walking and could cause the type of degenerative changes found in the articular cartilage following meniscal injury.     

Knee joint kinematics during walking influences the spatial cartilage thickness distribution in the knee

The regional adaptation of knee cartilage morphology to the kinematics of walking has been suggested as an important factor in the evaluation of the consequences of alteration in normal gait leading to osteoarthritis. The purpose of this study was to investigate the association of spatial cartilage thickness distributions of the femur and tibia in the knee to the knee kinematics during walking. Gait data and knee MR images were obtained from 17 healthy volunteers (age 33.2 ± 9.8 years). Cartilage thickness maps were created for the femoral and tibial cartilage. Locations of thickest cartilage in the medial and lateral compartments in the femur and tibia were identified using a numerical method. The flexion-extension (FE) angle associated with the cartilage contact regions on the femur, and the anterior-posterior (AP) translation and internal-external (IE) rotation associated with the cartilage contact regions on the tibia at the heel strike of walking were tested for correlation with the locations of thickest cartilage. The locations of the thickest cartilage had relatively large variation (SD, 8.9°) and was significantly associated with the FE angle at heel strike only in the medial femoral condyle (R(2)=0.41, p<0.01). The natural knee kinematics and contact surface shapes seem to affect the functional adaptation of knee articular cartilage morphology. The sensitivity of cartilage morphology to kinematics at the knee during walking suggests that regional cartilage thickness variations are influenced by both loading and the number of loading cycles. Thus walking is an important consideration in the analysis of the morphological variations of articular cartilage, since it is the dominant cyclic activity of daily living. The sensitivity of cartilage morphology to gait kinematics is also important in understanding the etiology and pathomechanics of osteoarthritis.     

Changes in knee function associated with treadmill ambulation

A comparison of level walking, on a walkway and on a treadmill, was performed using ten normal subjects. Motion about the knee was measured using a triaxial electrogoniometer, and foot-floor contact patterns were recorded by means of four foot switches attached to the sole of each shoe. On the walkway, the data were collected with the subject moving at a comfortable walking speed. The treadmill was then set at the average velocity obtained on the walkway. Knee joint rotation in the coronal and transverse planes did not change significantly between the walkway and the treadmill. In the sagittal plane, significant differences were found for total motion (p less than 0.01), swing phase motion (p less than 0.01), knee position at heel strike (p less than 0.05), and maximum swing phase extension (p less than 0.01). A comparison of the foot-floor contact patterns between walkway and treadmill ambulation revealed reduced heel contact time, with an increase in toe contact while on the treadmill. It was concluded that sagittal plane knee kinematics during level treadmill walking differ significantly from level overground walking.     

In vitro measurement of the restraining role of the anterior cruciate ligament during walking and stair ascent

The study aimed to test the hypothesis that the restraining role of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) of the knee is significant during the activities of normal walking and stair ascent. The role of the ACL was determined from the effect of ACL excision on tibiofemoral displacement patterns measured in vitro for fresh-frozen knee specimens subjected to simulated knee kinetics of walking (n = 12) and stair ascent (n = 7). The knee kinetics were simulated using a newly developed dynamic simulator able to replicate the sagittal-plane knee kinetics with reasonable accuracy while ensuring unconstrained tibiofemoral kinematics. The displacements were measured using a calibrated six degree-of-freedom electromechanical goniometer. For the simulation of the walking cycle, two types of knee flexion/extension moment patterns were used: the more common "biphasic" pattern, and an extensor muscle force intensive pattern. For both of these patterns, the restraining role of the ACL to tibial anterior translation was found to be significant throughout the stance phase and in the terminal swing phase, when the knee angle was in the range of 4 degrees to 30 degrees. The effect of ACL excision was an increase in tibial anterior translation by 4 mm to 5 mm. For the stair ascent cycle, however, the restraining role of the ACL was significant only during the terminal stance phase, and not during the initial and middle segments of the phase. Although, in these segments, the knee moments were comparable to that in walking, the knee angle was in the range of 60 degrees to 70 degrees. These results have been shown to be consistent with available data on knee mechanics and ACL function measured under static loading conditions.     

Effect of ACL deficiency on MCL strains and joint kinematics

The knee joint is partially stabilized by the interaction of multiple ligament structures. This study tested the interdependent functions of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and the medial collateral ligament (MCL) by evaluating the effects of ACL deficiency on local MCL strain while simultaneously measuring joint kinematics under specific loading scenarios. A structural testing machine applied anterior translation and valgus rotation (limits 100 N and 10 N m, respectively) to the tibia of ten human cadaveric knees with the ACL intact or severed. A three-dimensional motion analysis system measured joint kinematics and MCL tissue strain in 18 regions of the superficial MCL. ACL deficiency significantly increased MCL strains by 1.8% (p<0.05) during anterior translation, bringing ligament fibers to strain levels characteristic of microtrauma. In contrast, ACL transection had no effect on MCL strains during valgus rotation (increase of only 0.1%). Therefore, isolated valgus rotation in the ACL-deficient knee was nondetrimental to the MCL. The ACL was also found to promote internal tibial rotation during anterior translation, which in turn decreased strains near the femoral insertion of the MCL. These data advance the basic structure-function understanding of the MCL, and may benefit the treatment of ACL injuries by improving the knowledge of ACL function and clarifying motions that are potentially harmful to secondary stabilizers.     

Effect of arm swinging on lumbar spine and hip joint forces

During level walking, arm swing plays a key role in improving dynamic stability. In vivo investigations with a telemeterized vertebral body replacement showed that spinal loads can be affected by differences in arm positions during sitting and standing. However, little is known about how arm swing could influence the lumbar spine and hip joint forces and motions during walking. The present study aims to provide better understanding of the contribution of the upper limbs to human gait, investigating ranges of motion and joint reaction forces.A three-dimensional motion analysis was carried out via a motion capturing system on six healthy males and five patients with hip instrumented implant. Each subject performed walking with different arm swing amplitudes (small, normal, and large) and arm positions (bound to the body, and folded across the chest). The motion data were imported in a commercial musculoskeletal analysis software for kinematic and inverse dynamic investigation.The range of motion of the thorax with respect to the pelvis and of the pelvis with respect to the ground in the transversal plane were significantly associated with arm position and swing amplitude during gait. The hip external-internal rotation range of motion statistically varied only for non-dominant limb. Unlike hip joint reaction forces, predicted peak spinal loads at T12-L1 and L5-S1 showed significant differences at approximately the time of contralateral toe off and contralateral heel strike.Therefore, arm position and swing amplitude have a relevant effect on kinematic variables and spinal loads, but not on hip loads during walking.     

The coupled motion of the femur and patella during in vivo weightbearing knee flexion

The movement of the knee joint consists of a coupled motion between the tibiofemoral and patellofemoral articulations. This study measured the six degrees-of-freedom kinematics of the tibia, femur, and patella using dual-orthogonal fluoroscopy and magnetic resonance imaging. Ten normal knees from ten living subjects were investigated during weightbearing flexion from full extension to maximum flexion. The femoral and the patellar motions were measured relative to the tibia. The femur externally rotated by 12.9 deg and the patella tilted laterally by 16.3 deg during the full range of knee flexion. Knee flexion was strongly correlated with patellar flexion (R(2)=0.91), posterior femoral translation was strongly correlated to the posterior patellar translation (R(2)=0.87), and internal-external rotation of the femur was correlated to patellar tilt (R(2)=0.73) and medial-lateral patellar translation (R(2)=0.63). These data quantitatively indicate a kinematic coupling between the tibia, femur, and patella, and provide base line information on normal knee joint kinematics throughout the full range of weightbearing flexion. The data also suggest that the kinematic coupling of tibia, femur, and patella should be considered when investigating patellar pathologies and when developing surgical techniques to treat knee joint diseases.     

Kinematic evaluation of cruciate-retaining total knee replacement patients during level walking: A comparison with the displacement-controlled ISO standard

Differences between wear-scar features of simulator-tested and retrieved tibial total knee replacement (TKR) liners have been reported. This disagreement may result from differences between in vivo kinematic profiles and those defined by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). The purpose of this study was to determine the knee kinematics of a TKR subject group during level walking and compare them with the motion profiles defined by the ISO standard for a displacement-controlled knee wear testing simulator. Twenty-nine patients with a posterior cruciate ligament-retaining TKR design were gait tested using the point cluster technique to obtain flexion–extension (FE) rotation, anterior–posterior (AP) translation and internal–external (IE) rotation knee motions during a complete cycle of level walking. Relative ranges of motion and timing of key points within the in vivo motion data were compared against the same ranges and same key points from the input profiles of the displacement-controlled wear testing standard ISO14243-3. The subjects exhibited a FE pattern similar to ISO, with an insignificant difference in range of FE rotation from midstance to terminal stance. However, the subjects had a significantly higher range of knee flexion from terminal stance into swing. The subjects also exhibited a phase delay for the entire gait cycle. For AP translation, the standard profile had statistically significant lower magnitudes than seen in vivo. Opposite pattern of AP motion was also apparent from midstance and swing. Similarly, ISO specified a smaller IE total range of rotation with a motion pattern in complete opposition to that seen in vivo. In conclusion, significant differences were found in both the magnitudes and pattern of in vivo motion compared with ISO.     

Manipulating post-stroke gait: Exploiting aberrant kinematics

Post-stroke individuals often exhibit abnormal kinematics, including increased pelvic obliquity and hip abduction coupled with reduced knee flexion. Prior examinations suggest these behaviors are expressions of abnormal cross-planar coupling of muscle activity. However, few studies have detailed the impact of gait-retraining paradigms on three-dimensional joint kinematics. In this study, a cross-tilt walking surface was examined as a novel gait-retraining construct. We hypothesized that relative to baseline walking kinematics, exposure to cross-tilt would generate significant changes in subsequent flat-walking joint kinematics during affected limb swing. Twelve post-stroke participants walked on a motorized treadmill platform during a flat-walking condition and during a 10-degree cross-tilt with affected limb up-slope, increasing toe clearance demand. Individuals completed 15 min of cross-tilt walking with intermittent flat-walking catch trials and a final washout period (5 min). For flat-walking conditions, we examined changes in pelvic obliquity, hip abduction/adduction and knee flexion kinematics at the spatiotemporal events of swing initiation and toe-off, and the kinematic event of maximum angle during swing. Pelvic obliquity significantly reduced at swing initiation and maximum obliquity in the final catch trial and late washout. Knee flexion significantly increased at swing initiation, toe-off, and maximum flexion across catch trials and late washout. Hip abduction/adduction was not significantly influenced following cross-tilt walking. Significant decrease in the rectus femoris and medial hamstrings muscle activity across catch trials and late washout was observed. Exploiting the abnormal features of post-stroke gait during retraining yielded desirable changes in muscular and kinematic patterns post-training.     

Differences in tibial rotation during walking in ACL reconstructed and healthy contralateral knees

This study tested the hypotheses that in patients with a successful anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, the internal–external rotation, varus–valgus, and knee flexion position of reconstructed knees would be different from uninjured contralateral knees during walking. Twenty-six subjects with unilateral ACL reconstructions (avg 31 years, 1.7 m, 68 kg, 15 female, 24 months past reconstruction) and no other history of serious lower limb injury walked at a self-selected speed in the gait laboratory, with the uninjured contralateral knee as a matched control. Kinematic measurements of tibiofemoral motion were made using a previously-described point-cluster technique. Repeated-measures ANOVA (α=0.017) was used to compare ACL-reconstructed knees to their contralateral knees at four distinct points during the stance phase of walking. An offset towards external tibial rotation in ACL-reconstructed knees was maintained over all time points (95%CI 2.3±1.3°). Twenty-two out of twenty-six individuals experienced an average external tibial rotation offset throughout stance phase. Varus–valgus rotation and knee flexion were not significantly different between reconstructed and contralateral knees. These findings show that differences in tibial rotation during walking exist in ACL reconstructed knees compared to healthy contralateral knees, providing a potential explanation why these patients are at higher risk of knee osteoarthritis in the long-term.     

A reproducible method for studying three-dimensional knee kinematics

The methods used in movement analysis often rely on the definition of joint coordinate systems permitting three-dimensional (3D) kinematics. The first aim of this research project was to present a functional and postural method (FP method) to define a bone-embedded anatomical frame (BAF) on the femur and tibia, and, subsequently, a knee joint coordinate system. The repeatability of the proposed method was also assessed. Using FP method to define the BAFs, 4 kinematic parameters (flexion/extension, abduction/adduction, tibial internal/external rotation, and antero-posterior translation) were computed for 15 subjects walking on a treadmill. The repeatability for all four kinematic parameters was then assessed, using intra- and inter-observer settings. After pooling the results for all observers, the mean repeatability value ranged between 0.4 degrees and 0.8 degrees for rotation angles and between 0.8 and 2.2 mm for translation.     

Mechanical energy and effective foot mass during impact loading of walking and running

The human heel pad is considered an important structure for attenuation of the transient force caused by heel-strike. Although the mechanical properties of heel pads are relatively well understood, the mechanical energy (Etot) absorbed by the heel pad during the impact phase has never been documented directly because data on the effective foot mass (Meff) was previously unavailable during normal forward locomotion. In this study, we use the impulse-momentum method (IMM) for calculating Meff from moving subjects. Mass-spring-damper models were developed to evaluate errors and to examine the effects of pad property, upper body mass, and effective leg spring on Meff. We simultaneously collected ground reaction forces, pad deformation, and lower limb kinematics during impact phase of barefoot walking, running, and crouched walking. The latter was included to examine the effect of knee angle on Meff. The magnitude of Meff as a percentage of body mass (M(B)) varies with knee angle at impact and significantly differs among gaits: 6.3%M(B) in walking, 5.3%M(B) in running, and 3.7%M(B) in crouched walking. Our modeling results suggested that Meff is insensitive to heel pad resilience and effective leg stiffness. At the instant prior to heel strike, Etot ranges from 0.24 to 3.99 J. The combination of video and forceplate data used in this study allows analyses of Etot and Etot as a function of heel-strike kinematics during normal locomotion. Relationship between Meff and knee angle provides insights into how changes in posture moderate impact transients at different gaits.     

The effect of kinematic and kinetic changes on meniscal strains during gait

The menisci play an important role in load distribution, load bearing, joint stability, lubrication, and proprioception. Partial meniscectomy has been shown to result in changes in the kinematics and kinetics at the knee during gait that can lead to progressive meniscal degeneration. This study examined changes in the strains within the menisci associated with kinematic and kinetic changes during the gait cycle. The gait changes considered were a 5 deg shift toward external rotation of the tibia with respect to the femur and an increased medial-lateral load ratio representing an increased adduction moment. A finite element model of the knee was developed and tested using a cadaveric specimen. The cadaver was placed in positions representing heel-strike and midstance of the normal gait, and magnetic resonance images were taken. Comparisons of the model predictions to boundaries digitized from images acquired in the loaded states were within the errors produced by a 1 pixel shift of either meniscus. The finite element model predicted that an increased adduction moment caused increased strains of both the anterior and posterior horns of the medial meniscus. The lateral meniscus exhibited much lower strains and had minimal changes under the various loading conditions. The external tibial rotational change resulted in a 20% decrease in the strains in the posterior medial horn and increased strains in the anterior medial horn. The results of this study suggest that the shift toward external tibial rotation seen clinically after partial medial meniscectomy is not likely to cause subsequent degenerative medial meniscal damage, but the consequence of this kinematic shift on the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis following meniscectomy requires further consideration.     

Response of able-bodied persons to changes in shoe rocker radius during walking: Changes in ankle kinematics to maintain a consistent roll-over shape

Recent studies have determined a seemingly consistent feature of able-bodied level ground walking, termed the roll-over shape, which is the effective rocker (cam) shape that the lower limb system conforms to between heel contact and contralateral heel contact during walking (first half of the gait cycle). The roll-over shape has been found to be largely unaffected by changes in walking speed, load carriage, and shoe heel height. However, it is unclear from previous studies whether persons are controlling their lower limb systems to maintain a consistent roll-over shape or whether this finding is a byproduct of their attempt to keep ankle kinematic patterns similar during the first half of the gait cycle. We measured the ankle–foot roll-over shapes and ankle kinematics of eleven able-bodied subjects while walking on rocker shoes of different radii. We hypothesized that the ankle flexion patterns during single support would change to maintain a similar roll-over shape. We also hypothesized that with decrease in rocker shoe radii, the difference in ankle flexion between the end and beginning of single support would decrease. Our results supported these hypotheses. Ankle kinematics were changed significantly during walking with the different rocker shoe radii (p<0.001), while ankle–foot roll-over shape radii (p=0.146) and fore–aft position (p=0.132) were not significantly affected. The results of this study have direct implications for designers of ankle–foot prostheses, orthoses, walking casts/boots, and rocker shoes. The results may also be relevant to researchers studying control of human movements.     

Kinematic motion of the anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee during functionally high and low demanding tasks

The purpose of this study was to determine whether mechanical adaptations were present in patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-deficient knees during high-demand activities. Twenty-two subjects with unilateral ACL deficiency (11 males and 11 females, 19.6 months after injury) performed five different activities at a comfortable speed (level walking, ascending and descending steps, jogging, jogging to a 90-degree side cutting toward the opposite direction of the tested side). Three-dimensional knee kinematics for the ACL-deficient knees and uninjured contralateral knees were evaluated using the Point Cluster Technique. There was no significant difference in knee flexion angle, but an offset toward the knee in less valgus and more external tibial rotation was observed in the ACL-deficient knee. The tendency was more obvious in high demand motions, and a significant difference was clearly observed in the side cutting motions. These motion patterns, with the knee in less valgus and more external tibial rotation, are proposed to be an adaptive movement to avoid pivot shift dynamically, and reveal evidence in support of a dynamic adaptive motion occurring in ACL-deficient knees.     

The importance of quadriceps and hamstring muscle loading on knee kinematics and in-situ forces in the ACL

This study investigated the effect of hamstring co-contraction with quadriceps on the kinematics of the human knee joint and the in-situ forces in the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) during a simulated isometric extension motion of the knee. Cadaveric human knee specimens (n = 10) were tested using the robotic universal force moment sensor (UFS) system and measurements of knee kinematics and in-situ forces in the ACL were based on reference positions on the path of passive flexion/extension motion of the knee. With an isolated 200 N quadriceps load, the knee underwent anterior and lateral tibial translation as well as internal tibial rotation with respect to the femur. Both translation and rotation increased when the knee was flexed from full extension to 30 of flexion; with further flexion, these motion decreased. The addition of 80 N antagonistic hamstrings load significantly reduced both anterior and lateral tibial translation as well as internal tibial rotation at knee flexion angles tested except at full extension. At 30 of flexion, the anterior tibial translation, lateral tibial translation, and internal tibial rotation were significantly reduced by 18, 46, and 30%, respectively (p<0.05). The in-situ forces in the ACL under the quadriceps load were found to increase from 27.8+/-9.3 N at full extension to a maximum of 44.9+/-13.8 N at 15 of flexion and then decrease to 10 N beyond 60 of flexion. The in-situ force at 15 was significantly higher than that at other flexion angles (p<0.05). The addition of the hamstring load of 80 N significantly reduced the in-situ forces in the ACL at 15, 30 and 60 of flexion by 30, 43, and 44%, respectively (p<0.05). These data demonstrate that maximum knee motion may not necessarily correspond to the highest in-situ forces in the ACL. The data also suggest that hamstring co-contraction with quadriceps is effective in reducing excessive forces in the ACL particularly between 15 and 60 of knee flexion.     

1998 Basmajian Student Award Paper: Movement patterns after anterior cruciate ligament injury: a comparison of patients who compensate well for the injury and those who require operative stabilization

The purpose of this study was to describe kinematic and kinetic differences between a group of ACL deficient subjects who were grouped according to functional ability. Sixteen patients with complete ACL rupture were studied; eight subjects had instability with activities of daily living (non-copers) and eight subjects had returned to all pre-injury activity without limitation (copers). Three-dimensional joint kinematics and kinetics were collected from the knee and ankle during walking, jogging and going up and over a step. Results showed that both groups mitigated the force with which they contacted the floor but non-copers consistently demonstrated less knee flexion in the involved limb. The copers used joint kinematics similar to those of their uninvolved knees and similar to knee motions reported in uninjured subjects. The reduced knee motion in the involved knee of the non-copers did not correlate directly with quadriceps femoris muscle weakness.

The data suggest that the non-copers utilize a stabilization strategy which stiffens the knee joint which not only is unsuccessful but may lead to excessive joint contact forces which have the potential to damage articular structures. The copers use a strategy which permits normal knee kinematics and bodes well for joint integrity.     

Helical motion analysis of the knee--II. Kinematics of uninjured and injured knees during walking and pivoting

The knee kinematics of eight individuals with uninjured knees and of seven individuals with ruptured anterior cruciate ligaments have been investigated during walking and pivoting. The kinematics were measured using a six degree of freedom goniometer and quantitated using helical motion analysis. The helical motion variables reveal clearly that the knee is definitely neither a hinge nor a planar joint and its dynamic behavior changes over the stride. Ligamentous loss results in more adduction and external rotation during certain periods of the stride. Also, the range of translation of the tibia in the medial/lateral direction is reduced, and its average translation is more medial.     

The effects of sloped surfaces on locomotion: a kinematic and kinetic analysis

Previous findings from studies of demanding tasks in humans and slope walking in quadrupeds suggest that human slope walking may require specialized neural control strategies. The goal of this investigation was to gain insight into these strategies by quantifying lower limb kinematics and kinetics during up- and downslope walking. Nine healthy volunteers walked at a self-selected speed on an instrumented ramp at each of five grades (-39%, -15%, 0%, +15%, +39%; or -21 degrees, -8.5 degrees, 0 degrees, +8.5 degrees, +21 degrees, respectively). For each subject, the selected speed was maintained at all grades to minimize the effect of speed on gait dynamics. Points of interest were identified in the kinematic and kinetic outcome measures and compared across grades; a significant grade effect was found for all points except the magnitude of the peak hip extensor moment during late stance. Kinematic postural changes were consistent with the need to raise the limb for toe clearance and heel strike and to lift the body during upslope walking, and to control the descent of the body during downslope walking. The support moment increased significantly during both upslope and downslope walking compared to level: the increases were predominantly due to the increasing hip extensor moment during upslope walking, and to the increasing knee extensor moment during downslope walking. In addition, the hip and knee joint moment patterns showed significant differences from the patterns observed during level walking. This non-uniform distribution of joint moment increases during up- and downslope walking compared to level walking suggests that these three tasks are not governed by the same control strategy.     

Contributions of proximal and distal moments to axial tibial rotation during walking and running

The purpose of this study was to determine the cause and effect relationship between tibial internal rotation and pronation of the foot during walking and heel-toe running. This would allow predictions of orthotic effectiveness in reducing knee pain related to excessive internal tibial rotation. Kinematic and force plate data were collected from twenty subjects performing ten running and ten walking trials across a force plate. Using a least-squares algorithm, attitude matrices for each segment in each frame were obtained and the angular velocity vector of the tibia was calculated. The intersegmental moment at the ankle was calculated from ground reaction force and kinematic data, and the power flow from foot to tibia associated with axial tibial rotation was calculated. In walking, all subjects exhibited a clear power flow from tibia to foot during most of the stance phase, indicating that the foot was following the body. This suggests that the use of foot orthoses to reduce knee pain associated with tibial rotation during walking will not be successful. During running, power flow was also mainly proximal to distal, but there were brief periods of opposite power flow. There was more variability between subjects during running, with five subjects having large distal to proximal power flow peaks. These observations may explain and support previous work that has found variable clinical effects of orthoses between patients.