Determinants of cation transport selectivity: Equilibrium binding and transport kinetics

ConclusionThe equilibrium ion-binding properties of ion channels and transporters can be difficult to discern from crystal structures alone, as proteins often adopt different lowest energy states depending on the ions bound. In cases where transport is slow, their inherent ion-binding preferences can be used to infer their transport preferences. However, in cases where transport is fast, the transport selectivity can hide their equilibrium preferences by accentuating the kinetics of ions hopping through a channel over its inherent ion-binding preferences. Thus, depending on the arrangement of ion-binding sites in a channel’s selectivity filter, one can achieve either selective or nonselective ion transport.The equilibrium K⁺ selectivity of some nonselective channels suggests a potential mechanism whereby they could evolve into a fast K⁺-selective channel. K⁺ channels and nonselective channels like CNG and HCN are related to one another in both sequence and structure, suggesting an evolutionary link between them. Swap experiments show that only a few mutations separate a nonselective channel from a K⁺-selective channel. One might imagine an evolutionary path between these channels in which the equilibrium preference for a K⁺ ion in a nonselective channel evolves into a K⁺-selective channel through these few mutations to create the selective ion queue. Alternatively, a slow single-ion channel with an equilibrium and transport preference for K⁺ ions could be transformed into a fast multi-ion channel through mutations that create a queue of K⁺-selective ion-binding sites, as is seen in most K⁺ channels studied to date.In the case of multi-ion selectivity filters, such as those found in K⁺ channels, the selectivity filter can be viewed as the active site that interacts with different queues of ions and water molecules. At least three properties emerge from multi-ion queues: (1) high conductance by reducing the affinity of multiple bound ions versus single ions; (2) high selectivity by allowing disfavored ions time to dissociate back into solution; and, consequently, (3) robust selectivity in an environment where ion concentrations can change. For transporters and carriers, the equilibrium preference and slow transport naturally create robust selectivity. In all these cases, equilibrium-based ion selectivity is achieved by slowing transport enough so that the disfavored ion is able to dissociate back into solution before transport takes place.     

Functional characterization of a ClC transporter by solid-supported membrane electrophysiology

EcClC, a prokaryotic member of the ClC family of chloride channels and transporters, works as coupled H⁺/Cl⁻ exchanger. With a known structure and the possibility of investigating its behavior with different biochemical and biophysical techniques, the protein has become an important model system for the family. Although many aspects of its function have been previously characterized, it was difficult to measure transport on the same sample under different environmental conditions. To overcome this experimental limitation, we have studied EcClC by solid-supported membrane electrophysiology. The large transport-related transient currents and a simple way of relating transport rates to the measured signal have allowed a thorough investigation of ion selectivity, inhibition, and the dependence of transport on changes in ion concentration and pH. Our results confirm that the protein transports larger anions with about similar rates, whereas the smaller fluoride is not a substrate. We also show that 4,4′-diisothiocyano-2,2’-stilbenedisulfonic acid (DIDS), a known inhibitor of other anion transport protein, irreversibly inhibits EcClC from the intracellular side. The chloride dependence shows an apparent saturation at millimolar concentrations that resembles a similar behavior in eukaryotic ClC channels. Our experiments have also allowed us to quantify the pH dependence of transport. EcClC shows a strong activation at low pH with an apparent pKa of 4.6. The pronounced pH dependence is lost by the mutation of a conserved glutamate facing the extracellular solution that was previously shown to be an acceptor for transported protons, whereas it is largely retained by the mutation of an equivalent residue at the intracellular side. Our results have provided a quantitative basis for the transport behavior of EcClC, and they will serve as a reference for future investigations of novel electrogenic transporters with still-uncharacterized properties.     

Two splice variants derived from a Drosophila melanogaster candidate ClC gene generate ClC-2-type Cl- channels

Members of the ClC family of membrane proteins have been found in a variety of species and they can function as Cl- channels or Cl-/H+ antiporters. Three potential ClC genes are present in the Drosophila melanogaster genome. Only one of them shows homology with a branch of the mammalian ClC genes that encode plasma membrane Cl- channels. The remaining two are close to mammalian homologues coding for intracellular ClC proteins. Using RT-PCR we have identified two splice variants showing highest homology (41% residue identity) to the mammalian ClC-2 chloride channel. One splice variant (DmClC-2S) is expressed in the fly head and body and an additional, larger variant (DmClC-2L) is only present in the head. Both putative Drosophila channels conserve key features of the ClC channels cloned so far, including residues conforming the selectivity filter and C-terminus CBS domains. The splice variants differ in a stretch of 127 aa at the intracellular C-terminal portion separating cystathionate beta synthase (CBS) domains. Expression of either Drosophila ClC-2 variant in HEK-293 cells generated inwardly rectifying Cl- currents with similar activation and deactivation characteristics. There was great similarity in functional characteristics between DmClC-2 variants and their mammalian counterpart, save for slower opening kinetics and faster closing rate. As CBS domains are believed to be sites of regulation of channel gating and trafficking, it is suggested that the extra amino acids present between CBS domains in DmClC-2L might endow the channel with a differential response to signals present in the fly cells where it is expressed.     

Structural basis for ion conduction and gating in ClC chloride channels

Members of the ClC family of voltage-gated chloride channels are found from bacteria to mammals with a considerable degree of conservation in the membrane-inserted, pore-forming region. The crystal structures of the ClC channels of Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium provide a structural framework for the entire family. The ClC channels are homodimeric proteins with an overall rhombus-like shape. Each ClC dimer has two pores each contained within a single subunit. The ClC subunit consists of two roughly repeated halves that span the membrane with opposite orientations. This antiparallel architecture defines a chloride selectivity filter within the 15-A neck of a hourglass-shaped pore. Three Cl(-) binding sites within the selectivity filter stabilize ions by interactions with alpha-helix dipoles and by chemical interactions with nitrogen atoms and hydroxyl groups of residues in the protein. The Cl(-) binding site nearest the extracellular solution can be occupied either by a Cl(-) ion or by a glutamate carboxyl group. Mutations of this glutamate residue in Torpedo ray ClC channels alter gating in electrophysiological assays. These findings reveal a form of gating in which the glutamate carboxyl group closes the pore by mimicking a Cl(-) ion.     

Bead-like passage of chloride ions through ClC chloride channels

The ClC chloride channels control the ionic composition of the cytoplasm and the volume of cells, and regulate electrical excitability. Recently, it has been proposed that prokaryotic ClC channels are H+-Cl- exchange transporter. Although X-ray and molecular dynamics (MD) studies of bacterial ClC channels have investigated the filter open-close and ion permeation mechanism of channels, details have remained unclear. We performed MD simulations of ClC channels involving H+, Na+, K+, or H3O+ in the intracellular region to elucidate the open-close mechanism, and to clarify the role of H+ ion an H+-Cl- exchange transporter. Our simulations revealed that H+ and Na+ caused channel opening and the passage of Cl- ions. Na+ induced a bead-like string of Cl- -Na+-Cl--Na+-Cl- ions to form and permeate through ClC channels to the intracellular side with the widening of the channel pathway.     

Crystal structure of the cytoplasmic domain of the chloride channel ClC-0

Ion channels are frequently organized in a modular fashion and consist of a membrane-embedded pore domain and a soluble regulatory domain. A similar organization is found for the ClC family of Cl- channels and transporters. Here, we describe the crystal structure of the cytoplasmic domain of ClC-0, the voltage-dependent Cl- channel from T. marmorata. The structure contains a folded core of two tightly interacting cystathionine beta-synthetase (CBS) subdomains. The two subdomains are connected by a 96 residue mobile linker that is disordered in the crystals. As revealed by analytical ultracentrifugation, the domains form dimers, thereby most likely extending the 2-fold symmetry of the transmembrane pore. The structure provides insight into the organization of the cytoplasmic domains within the ClC family and establishes a framework for guiding future investigations on regulatory mechanisms.     

Preferential binding of K+ ions in the selectivity filter at equilibrium explains high selectivity of K+ channels

K⁺ channels exhibit strong selectivity for K⁺ ions over Na⁺ ions based on electrophysiology experiments that measure ions competing for passage through the channel. During this conduction process, multiple ions interact within the region of the channel called the selectivity filter. Ion selectivity may arise from an equilibrium preference for K⁺ ions within the selectivity filter or from a kinetic mechanism whereby Na⁺ ions are precluded from entering the selectivity filter. Here, we measure the equilibrium affinity and selectivity of K⁺ and Na⁺ ions binding to two different K⁺ channels, KcsA and MthK, using isothermal titration calorimetry. Both channels exhibit a large preference for K⁺ over Na⁺ ions at equilibrium, in line with electrophysiology recordings of reversal potentials and Ba²⁺ block experiments used to measure the selectivity of the external-most ion-binding sites. These results suggest that the high selectivity observed during ion conduction can originate from a strong equilibrium preference for K⁺ ions in the selectivity filter, and that K⁺ selectivity is an intrinsic property of the filter. We hypothesize that the equilibrium preference for K⁺ ions originates in part through the optimal spacing between sites to accommodate multiple K⁺ ions within the selectivity filter.     

Probing the pore of ClC-0 by substituted cysteine accessibility method using methane thiosulfonate reagents

ClC channels are a family of protein molecules containing two ion-permeation pores. Although these transmembrane proteins are important for a variety of physiological functions, their molecular operations are only superficially understood. High-resolution X-ray crystallography techniques have recently revealed the structures of two bacterial ClC channels, but whether vertebrate ClC channel pores are similar to those of bacterial homologues is not clear. To study the pore architecture of the Torpedo ClC-0 channel, we employed the substituted-cysteine-accessibility method (SCAM) and used charged methane thiosulfonate (MTS) compounds to modify the introduced cysteine. Several conclusions were derived from this approach. First, the MTS modification pattern from Y512C to E526C in ClC-0, which corresponds to residues forming helix R in bacterial ClC channels, is indeed consistent with the suggested helical structure. Second, the ClC-0 pore is more accessible to the negatively charged than to the positively charged MTS compound, a pore property that is regulated by the intrinsic electrostatic potential in the pore. Finally, attempts to modify the introduced cysteine at positions intracellular to the selectivity filter did not result in larger MTS modification rates for the open-state channel, suggesting that the fast gate of ClC-0 cannot be located at a position intracellular to the Cl- selectivity filter. Thus, the proposal that the glutamate side chain is the fast gate of the channel is applicable to ClC-0, revealing a structural and functional conservation of ClC channels between bacterial and vertebrate species.     

A structural perspective on ClC channel and transporter function

The ClC chloride channels and transporters constitute a large family of membrane proteins that is involved in a variety of physiological processes. All members share a conserved molecular architecture that consists of a complex transmembrane transport domain followed by a cytoplasmic domain. Despite the strong conservation, the family shows an unusually broad variety of functional behaviors as some members work as gated chloride channels and others as secondary active chloride transporters. The conservation in the structure and the functional resemblance of gating and coupled transport suggests a strong mechanistic relationship between these seemingly contradictory transport modes. The cytoplasmic domains constitute putative regulatory components that are ubiquitous in eukaryotic ClC family members and that in certain cases interact with nucleotides thus linking ion transport to nucleotide sensing by yet unknown mechanisms.     

A comparison between two prokaryotic potassium channels (KirBac1.1 and KcsA) in a molecular dynamics (MD) simulation study

The two potassium ion channels KirBac1.1 and KcsA are compared in a Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulation study. The location and motion of the potassium ions observed in the simulations are compared to those in the X-ray structures and previous simulations. In our simulations several of the crystallography resolved ion sites in KirBac1.1 are occupied by ions. In addition to this, two in KirBac1.1 unresolved sites where occupied by ions at sites that are in close correspondence to sites found in KcsA. There is every reason to believe that the conserved alignment of the selectivity filter in the potassium ion channel family corresponds to a very similar mechanism for ion transport across the filter. The gate residues, Phe146 in KirBac1.1 and Ala111 in KcsA acted in the simulations as effective barriers which never were passed by ions nor water molecules.     

Side-chain charge effects and conductance determinants in the pore of ClC-0 chloride channels

The charge on the side chain of the internal pore residue lysine 519 (K519) of the Torpedo ClC-0 chloride (Cl-) channel affects channel conductance. Experiments that replace wild-type (WT) lysine with neutral or negatively charged residues or that modify the K519C mutant with various methane thiosulfonate (MTS) reagents show that the conductance of the channel decreases when the charge at position 519 is made more negative. This charge effect on the channel conductance diminishes in the presence of a high intracellular Cl- concentration ([Cl-]i). However, the application of high concentrations of nonpermeant ions, such as glutamate or sulfate (SO42-), does not change the conductance, suggesting that the electrostatic effects created by the charge at position 519 are unlikely due to a surface charge mechanism. Another pore residue, glutamate 127 (E127), plays an even more critical role in controlling channel conductance. This negatively charged residue, based on the structures of the homologous bacterial ClC channels, lies 4-5 A from K519. Altering the charge of this residue can influence the apparent Cl- affinity as well as the saturated pore conductance in the conductance-Cl- activity curve. Amino acid residues at the selectivity filter also control the pore conductance but mutating these residues mainly affects the maximal pore conductance. These results suggest at least two different conductance determinants in the pore of ClC-0, consistent with the most recent crystal structure of the bacterial ClC channel solved to 2.5 A, in which multiple Cl--binding sites were identified in the pore. Thus, we suggest that the occupancy of the internal Cl--binding site is directly controlled by the charged residues located at the inner pore mouth. On the other hand, the Cl--binding site at the selectivity filter controls the exit rate of Cl- and therefore determines the maximal channel conductance.     

Cysteine accessibility in ClC-0 supports conservation of the ClC intracellular vestibule

ClC chloride channels, which are ubiquitously expressed in mammals, have a unique double-barreled structure, in which each monomer forms its own pore. Identification of pore-lining elements is important for understanding the conduction properties and unusual gating mechanisms of these channels. Structures of prokaryotic ClC transporters do not show an open pore, and so may not accurately represent the open state of the eukaryotic ClC channels. In this study we used cysteine-scanning mutagenesis and modification (SCAM) to screen >50 residues in the intracellular vestibule of ClC-0. We identified 14 positions sensitive to the negatively charged thiol-modifying reagents sodium (2-sulfonatoethyl)methanethiosulfonate (MTSES) or sodium 4-acetamido-4'-maleimidylstilbene-2'2-disulfonic acid (AMS) and show that 11 of these alter pore properties when modified. In addition, two MTSES-sensitive residues, on different helices and in close proximity in the prokaryotic structures, can form a disulfide bond in ClC-0. When mapped onto prokaryotic structures, MTSES/AMS-sensitive residues cluster around bound chloride ions, and the correlation is even stronger in the ClC-0 homology model developed by Corry et al. (2004). These results support the hypothesis that both secondary and tertiary structures in the intracellular vestibule are conserved among ClC family members, even in regions of very low sequence similarity.     

Ion transit pathways and gating in ClC chloride channels

ClC chloride channels possess a homodimeric structure in which each monomer contains an independent chloride ion pathway. ClC channel gating is regulated by chloride ion concentration, pH and voltage. Based on structural and physiological evidence, it has been proposed that a glutamate residue on the extracellular end of the selectivity filter acts as a fast gate. We utilized a new search algorithm that incorporates electrostatic information to explore the ion transit pathways through wild-type and mutant bacterial ClC channels. Examination of the chloride ion permeation pathways supports the importance of the glutamate residue in gating. An external chloride binding site previously postulated in physiological experiments is located near a conserved basic residue adjacent to the gate. In addition, access pathways are found for proton migration to the gate, enabling pH control at hyperpolarized membrane potentials. A chloride ion in the selectivity filter is required for the pH-dependent gating mechanism.     

The structure of the cytoplasmic domain of the chloride channel ClC-Ka reveals a conserved interaction interface

The cytoplasmic domains of ClC chloride channels and transporters are ubiquitously found in eukaryotic family members and have been suggested to be involved in the regulation of ion transport. All cytoplasmic ClC domains share a conserved scaffold that contains a pair of CBS motifs. Here we describe the structure of the cytoplasmic component of the human chloride channel ClC-Ka at 1.6 A resolution. The structure reveals a dimeric organization of the domain that is unusual for CBS motif containing proteins. Using a biochemical approach combining mutagenesis, crosslinking, and analytical ultracentrifugation, we demonstrate that the interaction interface is preserved in solution and that the distantly related channel ClC-0 likely exhibits a similar structural organization. Our results reveal a conserved interaction interface that relates the cytoplasmic domains of ClC proteins and establish a structural relationship that is likely general for this important family of transport proteins.     

Roles of K149, G352, and H401 in the channel functions of ClC-0: testing the predictions from theoretical calculations

The ClC family of Cl(-) channels and transporters comprises membrane proteins ubiquitously present in species ranging from prokaryotes to mammals. The recently solved structures of the bacterial ClC proteins have provided a good model to guide the functional experiments for the eukaryotic Cl(-) channels. Theoretical calculations based on the bacterial ClC structures have identified several residues critical for the Cl(-) binding energy in the Cl(-) transport pathway. It was speculated that the corresponding residues in eukaryotic Cl(-) channels might play similar roles for the channel functions. In this study, we made a series of mutations in three such residues in eukaryotic ClC Cl(-) channels (K149, G352, and H401 in ClC-0) and studied the functional consequences on the channel properties. A cysteine modification approach was also employed to evaluate the electrostatic effects of the charge placed at these three positions. The experimental results revealed that among the three residues tested, K149 plays the most important role in controlling both the gating and the permeation functions of ClC-0. On the other hand, mutations of H401 alter the channel conductance but not the gating properties, while mutations of G352 result in very little functional consequence. The mutation of K149 into a neutral residue leucine (K149L) shifts the activation curve and leads to flickery channel openings. The anion permeability ratios derived from bi-ionic experiments are also significantly altered in that the selectivity of Cl(-) over other anions is decreased. Furthermore, removing the positive charge at this position reduces and increases, respectively, the accessibility of the negatively and positively charged methane thiosulfonate reagents to the pore. The control of the accessibility to charged MTS reagents and the regulation of the anion permeation support the idea that K149 exerts an electrostatic effect on the channel function, confirming the prediction from computational studies.     

Site-directed fluorescence studies of a prokaryotic ClC antiporter

Channels and transporters of the ClC family serve a variety of physiological functions. Understanding of their gating and transport mechanisms remains incomplete, with disagreement over the extent of protein conformational change involved. Using site-directed fluorescence labeling, we probe ClC-ec1, a prokaryotic ClC, for transport-related structural rearrangements. We specifically label cysteines introduced at several positions in the R helix of ClC-ec1 with AlexaFluor 488, an environment-sensitive fluorophore, and demonstrate that the labeled mutants show H+/Cl- transport activity indistinguishable from that of the wild-type protein. At each position that we examined we observe fluorescence changes upon acidification over the same pH range that is known to activate transport. The fluorescence change is also sensitive to Cl- concentration; furthermore, the Cl- and H+ dependencies are coupled as would be expected if the fluorescence change reflected a conformational change required for transport. Together, the results suggest that the changes in fluorescence report protein conformational changes underlying the transport process. Labeled transporters mutated to remove a glutamate critical to proton-coupled chloride transport retain pH-dependent fluorescence changes, suggesting that multiple residues confer pH dependence on the transport mechanism. These results have implications for models of transport and gating in ClC channels and transporters.     

Mimicry of a host anion channel by a Helicobacter pylori pore-forming toxin

Bacterial pore-forming toxins have traditionally been thought to function either by causing an essentially unrestricted flux of ions and molecules across a membrane or by effecting the transmembrane transport of an enzymatically active bacterial peptide. However, the Helicobacter pylori pore-forming toxin, VacA, does not appear to function by either of these mechanisms, even though at least some of its effects in cells are dependent on its pore-forming ability. Here we show that the VacA channel exhibits two of the most characteristic electrophysiological properties of a specific family of cellular channels, the ClC channels: an open probability dependent on the molar ratio of permeable ions and single channel events resolvable as two independent, voltage-dependent transitions. The sharing of such peculiar properties by VacA and host ClC channels, together with their similar magnitudes of conductance, ion selectivities, and localization within eukaryotic cells, suggests a novel mechanism of toxin action in which the VacA pore largely mimics the electrophysiological behavior of a host channel, differing only in the membrane potential at which it closes. As a result, VacA can perturb, but not necessarily abolish, the homeostatic ionic imbalance across a membrane and so change cellular physiology without necessarily jeopardizing vitality.     

A mutant KcsA K(+) channel with altered conduction properties and selectivity filter ion distribution

The selectivity filter of K(+) channels is comprised of a linear queue of four equal-spaced ion-binding sites spanning a distance of 12A. Each site is formed of eight oxygen atoms from the protein. The first three sites, numbered 1-3 from the extracellular side, are made of exclusively main-chain carbonyl oxygen atoms. The fourth site, closest to the intracellular side, is made of four main-chain carbonyl oxygen atoms and four threonine side-chain hydroxyl oxygen atoms. Here we characterize the effects of mutating the threonine to cysteine on the distribution of ions in the selectivity filter and on the conduction of ions through the filter. The mutation influences the occupancy of K(+) at sites 2 and 4 and it reduces the maximum rate of conduction in the limit of high K(+) concentration. The mutation does not affect the conduction of Rb(+). These results can be understood in the context of a conduction mechanism in which a pair of K ions switch between energetically balanced 1,3 and 2,4 configurations.     

The fast gating mechanism in ClC-0 channels

We investigate and then modify the hypothesis that a glutamate side chain acts as the fast gate in ClC-0 channels. We first create a putative open-state configuration of the prokaryotic ClC Cl- channel using its crystallographic structure as a basis. Then, retaining the same pore shape, the prokaryotic ClC channel is converted to ClC-0 by replacing all the nonconserved polar and charged residues. Using this open-state channel model, we carry out molecular dynamics simulations to study how the glutamate side chain can move between open and closed configurations. When the side chain extends toward the extracellular end of the channel, it presents an electrostatic barrier to Cl- conduction. However, external Cl- ions can push the side chain into a more central position where, pressed against the channel wall, it does not impede the motion of Cl- ions. Additionally, a proton from a low-pH external solution can neutralize the extended glutamate side chain, which also removes the barrier to conduction. Finally, we use Brownian dynamics simulations to demonstrate the influence of membrane potential and external Cl- concentration on channel open probability.     

The cytoplasmic domain of the chloride channel ClC-0: structural and dynamic characterization of flexible regions

Eukaryotic members of the ClC family of chloride channels and transporters are composed of a transmembrane ion transport domain followed by a cytoplasmic domain, which is believed to be involved in the modulation of ClC function. In some family members this putative regulatory domain contains next to a well-folded structured part, long sequence stretches with low sequence complexity. These regions, a 96 residue long linker connecting two structured sub-domains, and 35 residues on the C teminus of the domain were found disordered in a recent crystal structure of this domain in ClC-0. Both regions have a large influence on the modulation of channel function in closely related family members. Here we describe a NMR study to characterize the structural and dynamic properties of these putatively unstructured stretches. Our study reveals that the two regions indeed show large conformational flexibility with dynamics on the nanosecond timescale. However, small islands of secondary structure are found interdispersed between the unfolded regions. This study characterizes for the first time the biophysical properties of these protein segments, which may become important for the understanding of novel regulatory mechanisms within the ClC family.