Multiple cholinergic differentiation factors are present in footpad extracts: comparison with known cholinergic factors.

Sweat glands in rat footpads contain a neuronal differentiation activity that switches the phenotype of sympathetic neurons from noradrenergic to cholinergic during normal development in vivo. Extracts of developing and adult sweat glands induce changes in neurotransmitter properties in cultured sympathetic neurons that mimic those observed in vivo. We have characterized further the factors present in the extract and compared their properties to those of known cholinergic factors. When assayed on cultured rat sympathetic neurons, the major activities in footpad extracts from postnatal day 21 rat pups that induce choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) and vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and reduce catecholamines and neuropeptide Y (NPY) are associated with a soluble protein of 22-26 x 10(3) M(r) and a pI of 5.0. These properties are similar to those of ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF). Moreover, the purified fraction from footpads has ciliary neurotrophic activity. Antibodies to CNTF that immunoprecipitate all differentiation activity from sciatic nerve extracts, a rich source of CNTF, immunoprecipitate 80% of the cholinergic activity in the footpad extracts, 50% of the VIP and 20% of the NPY activities. Neither CNTF protein nor CNTF mRNA, however, can be detected in immunoblot and northern analysis of footpads even though both CNTF protein and mRNA are evident in sciatic nerve. CNTF-immunoreactivity is associated with a sparse plexus of sensory fibers in the footpad but not with sweat glands or the Schwann cells associated with them. In addition, in situ hybridization studies with oligonucleotide probes failed to reveal CNTF mRNA in sweat glands. Comparison of the sweat gland differentiation activity with the cholinergic differentiation factor from heart cells (CDF; also known as leukemia inhibitory factor or LIF) suggests that most of the cholinergic activity in foot pads is biochemically distinct from CDF/LIF. Further, antibodies that block the activity of CDF/LIF purified from heart-cell-conditioned medium do not block the ChAT-inducing activity present in footpad extracts of postnatal day 8 animals. A differentiation factor isolated from skeletal muscle did not induce cholinergic properties in sympathetic neuron cultures and therefore is unlikely to be the cholinergic differentiation factor produced by sweat glands. Taken together, our data suggest that there are at least two differentiation molecules present in the extracts and that the major cholinergic activity obtained from footpads is related to, but distinct from, CNTF. The second factor remains to be characterized. In addition, CNTF associated with sensory fibers may make a minor contribution to the cholinergic inducing activity present in the extract.     

Acquisition of cholinergic and peptidergic properties by sympathetic innervation of rat sweat glands requires interaction with normal target

The sweat glands, a target of cholinergic sympathetic neurons, were replaced with parotid gland, a target of noradrenergic sympathetic neurons, in neonatal rats. This transplantation paradigm allowed sympathetic neurons that would normally innervate the sweat glands and develop a cholinergic phenotype to innervate the parotid gland instead. The innervation of the transplanted parotid gland did not develop a cholinergic phenotype, as assessed by choline acetyltransferase activity and acetylcholinesterase immunoreactivity, but continued to express intense catecholamine fluorescence. In addition, immunoreactivity for vasoactive intestinal peptide, normally expressed by the sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands but not the parotid, was observed in only a small percentage of the parotid-associated fibers. These results suggest that cellular interactions between neurons and their targets play an important role in the differentiation of mature neurotransmitter and neuropeptide phenotypes in vivo.     

Target determination of neurotransmitter phenotype in sympathetic neurons

While the majority of sympathetic neurons are noradrenergic, a minority population are cholinergic. At least one population of cholinergic sympathetic neurons arises during development by a target-dependent conversion from an initial noradrenergic phenotype. Evidence for retrograde specification has been obtained from transplantation studies in which sympathetic neurons that normally express a noradrenergic phenotype throughout life were induced to innervate sweat glands, a target normally innervated by cholinergic sympathetic neurons. This was accomplished by transplanting footpad skin containing sweat gland primordia from early postnatal donor rats to the hairy skin region of host rats. The sympathetic neurons innervating the novel target decreased their expression of noradrenergif traints and developed choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) activity. In addition, many sweat gland-associated fibers acquired acetylcholinesterase (AChE) staining and VIP immunoreactivity. These studies indicated that sympathetic neurons in vivo alter their neurotransmitter phenotype in response to novel envronmental signals and that sweat glands play a critical role in the cholinergic and peptidergic differentiation of the sympathetic neurons that innervate them. The sweat gland-derived cholinergic differentiation factor is distinct from leukemia inhibitory factor and ciliary neurotrophic factor, two well-characterized cytokines that alter the neurotransmitter properties of cultured sympathetic neurons in a similar fashion. Recent studies indicate that anterograde signalling is also important for the establishment of functional synapses in this system. We have found that the production of cholinergic differentiation activity by sweat glands required sympathetic innervation, and the acquisition and maintenance of secretory competence by sweat glands depends upon functional cholinergic innervation. 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Cholinergic differentiation of rat sympathetic neurons in culture: effects of factors applied to distal neurites.

Cholinergic properties are induced in sympathetic neurons by several factors applied to entire neurons in culture. Evidence from work with the rat sweat gland model indicates that factors located in target tissues can induce cholinergic differentiation in vivo. We now report that when leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), heart cell-conditioned medium (HCCM), or dermal fibroblast-conditioned medium (DFCM) is applied to only distal neurites in compartmented cultures of rat sympathetic neurons, the neurons exhibit an increase in specific choline acetyltransferase activity and a concomitant decrease in levels of tyrosine hydroxylase. LIF, HCCM, and DFCM also induce neurite fasciculation, thus suggesting an additional role of cholinergic switching factors in regulating axon-axon and/or axon-substrate adhesion. These results demonstrate that rat sympathetic neurons have the cellular machinery to respond to cholinergic differentiation cues located in peripheral targets, analogous to the response to nerve growth factor.     

Regulation of vasoactive intestinal peptide expression in sympathetic neurons in culture and after axotomy: The role of cholinergic differentiation factor/leukemia inhibitory factor

Vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) expression increases in sympathetic neurons when they are grown in dissociated cell or explant cultures and when they are axotomized in vivo. In dissociated cell culture, the magnitude of the VIP increase was reduced when nonneuronal cells were removed and medium conditioned by ganglionic nonneuronal cells increased VIP in neuron-enriched cultures. Antiserum Against cholinergic differentiation factor (also leukemia inhibitory factor; CDF/LIF), but not against ciliary neurotrophic factor, immunoprecipitated this activity. Medium conditioned by sympathetic ganglion explants also contained a VIP-stimulatory molecule that was immunoprecipitated by CDF/LIF antiserum, and CDF/LIF antiserum partially blocked VIP induction in explants. CDF/LIF mRNA was increased in dissociated cell cultures, in ganglion explants and in vivo after axotomy. Our results suggest that CDF/LIF released from ganglionic nonneuronal cells plays an important role in regulating VIP after axotomy. 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

The early expression of VAChT and VIP in mouse sympathetic ganglia is not induced by cytokines acting through LIFRbeta or CNTFRalpha

Sympathetic ganglia consist of noradrenergic and cholinergic neurons. The cholinergic marker protein vesicular acetylcholine transporter (VAChT) and the neuropeptide vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), co-expressed in mature cholinergic sympathetic neurons, are first detectable during embryonic development of rat sympathetic ganglia. However, the subpopulation of cholinergic sympathetic neurons which innervates sweat glands in mammalian footpads starts to express VAChT and VIP during the first postnatal weeks, under the influence of sweat gland-derived signals. In vitro evidence suggests that the sweat gland-derived cholinergic differentiation factor belongs to a group of neuropoietic cytokines, including LIF, CNTF and CT-1, that act through a LIFRbeta-containing cytokine receptor. To investigate whether the embryonic expression of cholinergic properties is elicited by a related cytokine, the expression of VAChT and VIP was analyzed in stellate ganglia of mice deficient for the cytokine receptor subunits LIFRbeta or CNTFRalpha. The density of VAChT- and VIP-immunoreactive cells in stellate ganglia of new-born animals was not different in LIFRbeta(-/-) and CNTFRalpha(-/-) ganglia as compared to ganglia from wild-type mice. These results demonstrate that the early, embryonic expression of VAChT and VIP is not induced by cytokines acting through LIFRbeta- or CNTFRalpha-containing receptors.     

Effects of ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) and depolarization on neuropeptide expression in cultured sympathetic neurons.

We examined the effects of ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) and depolarization, two environmental signals that influence noradrenergic and cholinergic function, on neuropeptide expression by cultured sympathetic neurons. Sciatic nerve extract, a rich source of CNTF, increased levels of vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), substance P, and somatostatin severalfold while significantly reducing levels of neuropeptide Y (NPY). No change was observed in the levels of leu-enkephalin (L-Enk). These effects were abolished by immunoprecipitation of CNTF-like molecules from the extract with an antiserum raised against recombinant CNTF, and recombinant CNTF caused changes in neuropeptide levels similar to those of sciatic nerve extract. Alterations in neuropeptide levels by CNTF were dose-dependent, with maximal induction at concentrations of 5-25 ng/ml. Peptide levels were altered after only 3 days of CNTF exposure and continued to change for 14 days. Depolarization of sympathetic neuron cultures with elevated potassium elicited a different spectrum of effects; it increased VIP and NPY content but did not alter substance P, somatostatin, or L-Enk. Depolarization is known to block cholinergic induction in response to heart cell conditioned medium and we found that it blocked the induction of choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) and peptides by recombinant cholinergic differentiation factor/leukemia inhibitory factor (CDF/LIF). In contrast, it did not antagonize the effects of CNTF on either ChAT activity or neuropeptide expression. Thus, while CNTF has effects on neurotransmitter properties similar to those previously reported for CDF/LIF, the actions of these two factors are differentially modulated by depolarization, suggesting that the mechanisms of cholinergic and neuropeptide induction for the two factors differ. In addition, in contrast to CDF/LIF, CNTF did not alter levels of ChAT, VIP, substance P, or somatostatin in cultured dorsal root ganglion neurons. These observations indicate that CNTF and depolarization affect the expression of neuropeptides by sympathetic neurons and provide evidence for an overlapping yet distinct spectrum of actions of the two neuronal differentiation factors, CNTF and CDF/LIF.     

Evidence for neurotransmitter plasticity in vivo. II. Immunocytochemical studies of rat sweat gland innervation during development

Previous studies of the cholinergic sympathetic innervation of rat sweat glands provide evidence for a change in neurotransmitter phenotype from noradrenergic to cholinergic during development. To define further the developmental history of cholinergic sympathetic neurons, we have used immunocytochemical techniques to examine developing and mature sweat gland innervation for the presence of the catecholamine synthetic enzymes tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and dopamine beta-hydroxylase (DBH) and for two neuropeptides present in the mature cholinergic innervation, vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP). In 7-day old animals, intensely TH- and DBH-immunoreactive axons were closely associated with the forming glands. The intensity of both the TH and DBH immunofluorescence decreased as the glands and their innervation developed. Neither TH-IR nor DBH-IR disappeared entirely; faint immunoreactivity for both enzymes was reproducibly detected in mature animals. In contrast to noradrenergic properties, the expression of peptide immunoreactivities appeared relatively late. No VIP-IR or CGRP-IR was detectable in the sweat gland innervation at 4 or 7 days. In some glands VIP-IR first appeared in axons at 10 days, and was evident in all glands by 14 days. CGRP-IR was detectable only after 14 days. In addition to VIP-IR and CGRP-IR, we examined the sweat gland innervation for several neuropeptides which have been described in noradrenergic sympathetic neurons including neuropeptide Y, somatostatin, substance P, and leu- and met-enkephalin; these peptides were not evident in either developing or mature sweat gland axons. Our observations provide further evidence for the early expression and subsequent modulation of noradrenergic properties in a population of cholinergic sympathetic neurons in vivo. In addition, the asynchronous appearance during development of the two neuropeptide immunoreactivities raises the possibility that the expression of peptide phenotypes may be controlled independently.     

Neonatal treatment with nerve growth factor antiserum eliminates cholinergic sympathetic innervation of rat sweat glands

Most mammalian sympathetic neurons are noradrenergic, and their dependence upon nerve growth factor (NGF) for survival during development is well established. A minor population of sympathetic neurons, including those that innervate sweat glands, is cholinergic. To determine whether cholinergic sympathetic neurons, like their noradrenergic counterparts, require NGF during development, neonatal rats were treated with NGF-antiserum and 3 weeks later their sweat glands were examined for the presence of innervation. Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) staining and vasoactive intestinal polypeptide-like immunoreactivity (VIP-IR) which mark the mature sweat gland innervation were absent from the sweat glands of the anti-NGF treated animals. Further, when the glands were examined with the electron microscope, no axons or nerve terminals were evident. These observations indicate that the elaboration of the sweat gland plexus is NGF-dependent and suggest that at least one population of cholinergic sympathetic neurons in the rat requires NGF for survival. Our findings are consistent with the idea that during development NGF is a required trophic factor not only for noradrenergic sympathetic but also for cholinergic sympathetic neurons.     

Target influences on transmitter choice by sympathetic neurons developing in the anterior chamber of the eye

In contrast to the majority of sympathetic neurons which are noradrenergic, the sympathetic neurons which innervate sweat glands are cholinergic. Previous studies have demonstrated that during development the sweat gland innervation initially contains catecholamines which are lost as cholinergic function appears. The neurotransmitter phenotype of sweat gland neurons further differs from the majority in that they contain vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) rather than neuropeptide Y (NPY). In the experiments described here, we addressed the question of whether sympathetic targets influence the neurotransmitter-related properties of the neurons which innervate them; in particular, do sweat glands play a role in reducing the expression of noradrenergic properties and inducing the expression of cholinergic properties and VIP in sympathetic neurons? This was accomplished by cotransplanting to the anterior chamber of the eye of host rats the superior cervical ganglia (SCG) which contains neurons that normally innervate targets other than the sweat glands and differentiate noradrenergically and footpad tissue from neonatal rats. Sweat glands developed in the transplanted footpad tissue and became innervated by the cotransplanted SCG neurons. The transplanted neurons and sweat gland innervation initially exhibited catecholamine histofluorescence which declined with further development in the anterior chamber. After 4 weeks, choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) and VIP immunoreactivities were evident. These observations suggest that as in the neurons which innervate the glands in situ, noradrenergic properties were suppressed and cholinergic function was induced in the neurons which innervated the glands in oculo. To distinguish a specific influence of the sweat glands on transmitter choice, SCG were also cotransplanted with the pineal gland, a normal target of the ganglion. Neurons cotransplanted with the pineal gland continued to exhibit catecholamine histofluorescence and contained NPY immunoreactivity. At least some neurons in SCG/pineal cotransplants, however, developed ChAT immunoreactivity. The target-appropriate expression of catecholamines and peptides in these experiments is consistent with the hypothesis that some transmitter properties are influenced by target tissues. The indiscriminant expression of ChAT, however, suggests that at least in oculo, additional factors can influence transmitter choice.     

The cholinergic neuronal differentiation factor from heart cell conditioned medium is different from the cholinergic factors in sciatic nerve and spinal cord

Environmental cues play an important role in determining the transmitter phenotype of developing sympathetic neurons. Several factors have been described which can induce cholinergic function in cultured sympathetic neurons. We have compared certain biological and immunological properties of three of them, cholinergic differentiation factor (CDF), membrane-associated neurotransmitter-stimulating factor (MANS), and ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF), to determine whether they are different. As previously reported, all three increased acetylcholine synthesis in cultured sympathetic neurons. In addition, MANS as well as CNTF and CDF decreased catecholamine synthesis. CNTF and MANS, but not CDF, promoted the survival of embryonic chick ciliary neurons. Affinity-purified antibodies raised against a synthetic peptide corresponding to the N-terminal sequence of CDF immunoprecipitated CDF, but not MANS or CNTF. These results indicate that although CDF, MANS, and CNTF have similar effects on transmitter synthesis by cultured sympathetic neurons, CDF lacks the ciliary neurotrophic activity of MANS and CNTF. Further, CDF possesses an N-terminal epitope which is absent from both MANS and CNTF. Thus, CDF is distinct from MANS and CNTF, and at least two factors exist which can alter the transmitter phenotype of sympathetic neurons in vitro.     

Cholinergic neuronal differentiation factors: evidence for the presence of both CNTF-like and non-CNTF-like factors in developing rat footpad.

Catecholaminergic sympathetic neurons are able to change their transmitter phenotype during development and to acquire cholinergic properties. Cholinergic sympathetic differentiation is only observed in fibers innervating specific targets like the sweat glands in the rat footpad. A function for ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) in this process has been implied as it is able to induce cholinergic properties (ChAT, VIP) in cultured chick and rat neurons. We show here that a CNTF-like, VIP-inducing activity is present in rat footpads and that its increases 6-fold during the period of cholinergic sympathetic differentiation. Immunohistochemical analysis of P21 rat footpads demonstrated CNTF-like immunoreactivity in Schwann cells but not in sweat glands, the target tissue of cholinergic sympathetic neurons. The expression of this factor in footpads seems to be dependent on the presence of intact nerve axons, as nerve transection results in a loss of CNTF-like cholinergic activity and immunoreactivity. Immunoprecipitation experiments with rat footpad extracts provided evidence for the presence of ChAT-inducing factors other than CNTF, which may independently or together with CNTF be involved in the determination of sympathetic neuron phenotype.     

Developmental interactions between sweat glands and the sympathetic neurons which innervate them: effects of delayed innervation on neurotransmitter plasticity and gland maturation

The neurotransmitter properties of the sympathetic innervation of sweat glands in rat footpads have previously been shown to undergo a striking change during development. When axons first reach the developing glands, they contain catecholamine histofluorescence and immunoreactivity for catecholamine synthetic enzymes. As the glands and their innervation mature, catecholamines disappear and cholinergic and peptidergic properties appear. Final maturation of the sweat glands, assayed by secretory competence, is correlated temporally with the development of cholinergic function in the innervation. To determine if the neurotransmitter phenotype of sympathetic neurons developing in vivo is plastic, if sympathetic targets can play a role in determining neurotransmitter properties of the neurons which innervate them, and if gland maturation is dependent upon its innervation, the normal developmental interaction between sweat glands and their innervation was disrupted. This was accomplished by a single injection of 6-hydroxy-dopamine (6-OHDA) on Postnatal Day 2. Following this treatment, the arrival of noradrenergic sympathetic axons at the developing glands was delayed 7 to 10 days. Like the gland innervation of normal rats, the axons which innervated the sweat glands of 6-OHDA-treated animals acquired cholinergic function and their expression of endogenous catecholamines declined. The change in neurotransmitter properties, however, occurred later in development than in untreated animals and was not always complete. Even in adult animals, some fibers continued to express endogenous catecholamines and many nerve terminals contained a small proportion of small granular vesicles after permanganate fixation. The gland innervation in the 6-OHDA-treated animals also differed from that of normal rats in that immunoreactivity for VIP was not expressed in the majority of glands. It seems likely that following treatment with 6-OHDA sweat glands were innervated both by neurons that would normally have done so and by neurons that would normally have innervated other, noradrenergic targets in the footpads, such as blood vessels. Contact with sweat glands, therefore, appears to suppress noradrenergic function and induce cholinergic function not only in the neurons which normally innervate the glands but also in neurons which ordinarily innervate other targets. Effects of delayed innervation were also observed on target development. The appearance of sensitivity to cholinergic agonists by the sweat glands was coupled with the onset of cholinergic transmission.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Recombinant Cholinergic Differentiation Factor (Leukemia Inhibitory Factor) Regulates Sympathetic Neuron Phenotype by Alterations in the Size and Amounts of Neuropeptide mRNAs

The cholinergic differentiation factor (CDF) in heart cells is identical to leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF). Recombinant CDF/LIF was shown to alter dramatically neurotransmitter production as well as the levels of several neuropeptides in cultured rat sympathetic neurons. Here it is shown that these changes are likely to be caused by alterations in the mRNA for these proteins and peptides. Growth in 1 nM recombinant CDF/LIF induces mRNA for acetyl CoA: choline-O-acetyltransferase [EC 2.3.1.6; choline acetyltransferase (ChAT)], somatostatin (SOM), substance P, and vasoactive intestinal polypeptide while lowering mRNA levels of tyrosine hydroxylase (EC 1.14.16.2) and neuropeptide Y (NPY). In addition, the sizes of the mRNAs for ChAT, SOM, and NPY are larger after recombinant CDF/LIF treatment.     

Target-dependent specification of the neurotransmitter phenotype: cholinergic differentiation of sympathetic neurons is mediated in vivo by gp 130 signaling

Sympathetic neurons are generated through a succession of differentiation steps that initially lead to noradrenergic neurons innervating different peripheral target tissues. Specific targets, like sweat glands in rodent footpads, induce a change from noradrenergic to cholinergic transmitter phenotype. Here, we show that cytokines acting through the gp 130 receptor are present in sweat glands. Selective elimination of the gp 130 receptor in sympathetic neurons prevents the acquisition of cholinergic and peptidergic features (VAChT, ChT1, VIP) without affecting other properties of sweat gland innervation. The vast majority of cholinergic neurons in the stellate ganglion, generated postnatally, are absent in gp 130-deficient mice. These results demonstrate an essential role of gp 130-signaling in the target-dependent specification of the cholinergic neurotransmitter phenotype.     

Norepinephrine transporter expression in cholinergic sympathetic neurons: differential regulation of membrane and vesicular transporters

Sympathetic neurons that undergo a noradrenergic to cholinergic change in phenotype provide a useful model system to examine the developmental regulation of proteins required to synthesize, store, or remove a particular neurotransmitter. This type of change occurs in the sympathetic sweat gland innervation during development and can be induced in cultured sympathetic neurons by extracts of sweat gland-containing footpads or by leukemia inhibitory factor. Sympathetic neurons initially produce norepinephrine (NE) and contain the vesicular monoamine transporter 2 (VMAT2), which packages NE into vesicles, and the norepinephrine transporter (NET), which removes NE from the synaptic cleft to terminate signaling. We have used a variety of biochemical and molecular techniques to test whether VMAT2 and NET levels decrease in sympathetic neurons which stop producing NE and make acetylcholine. In cultured sympathetic neurons, NET protein and mRNA decreased during the switch to a cholinergic phenotype but VMAT2 mRNA and protein did not decline. NET immunoreactivity disappeared from the developing sweat gland innervation in vivo as it acquired cholinergic properties. Surprisingly, NET simultaneously appeared in sweat gland myoepithelial cells. The presence of NET in myoepithelial cells did not require sympathetic innervation. VMAT2 levels did not decrease as the sweat gland innervation became cholinergic, indicating that NE synthesis and vesicular packaging are not coupled in this system. Thus, production of NE and the transporters required for noradrenergic transmission are not coordinately regulated during cholinergic development.     

Cell interactions that determine sympathetic neuron transmitter phenotype and the neurokines that mediate them

The transmitter properties of both developing and mature sympathetic neurons are plastic and can be modulated by a number of environmental cues. Cell culture studies demonstrate that noradrenergic neurons can be induced to become cholinergic and that the expression of neuropeptides can be altered. Similar changes in transmitter phenotype occur in vivo. During development, noradrenergic neurons that innervate eccrine sweat glands acquire cholinergic and peptidergic function. This change is dependent upon interactions with the target tissue. Following injury of sympathetic neurons in developing and adult animals, striking alterations take place in peptide expression. Ciliary neurotrophic factor and cholinergic differentiation factor/leukemia inhibitory factor, members of a family that includes several hematopoeitic cytokines, induce cholinergic function and modulate neuropeptide expression in cultured sympathetic neurons. Studies in progress provide evidence that members of this new cytokine family influence the transmitter phenotype of sympathetic neurons not only in vitro but also in vivo. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Development of the cholinergic neurotransmitter phenotype in postganglionic sympathetic neurons

Sympathetic ganglia are composed of noradrenergic neurons and cholinergic neurons that differ in the expression of neurotransmitter-synthesizing enzymes, neurotransmitter transporters and neuropeptides. The analysis of the cholinergic differentiation during development revealed important principles involved in the generation of neuronal diversity, in particular the importance of signals from the innervated target. Some peripheral targets, such as the sweat glands in the mammalian footpads, are purely cholinergically innervated in the adult, whereas skeletal muscle arteries receive both noradrenergic and cholinergic innervation. For sympathetic neurons innervating sweat glands there is convincing evidence that these neurons are initially noradrenergic and that the interaction of innervating fibers and target tissue induces a shift in the neurotransmitter phenotype from noradrenergic to cholinergic. In addition to this target-dependent differentiation, an earlier expression of cholinergic characters was observed in sympathetic ganglia that occurs before target contact. These data raise the possibility that different subpopulations of cholinergic sympathetic neurons, innervating distinct peripheral targets, may develop along distinct schedules. In vitro studies suggest that growth factors of the family of neuropoietic cytokines are involved in the specification of the cholinergic sympathetic phenotype. Recent in vivo studies that interfered with cytokine receptor expression in developing avian sympathetic ganglia indicate that only the late, target-dependent differentiation depends on cytokine signaling. The signals involved in the early, target-independent expression of cholinergic properties remain to be determined, as well as the identity of the target-derived cytokine. Thus, cholinergic sympathetic differentiation seems to be more complex than expected, involving either both target-independent and target-dependent control or only target-induced differentiation, according to the specific neuronal subpopulation and target.