Yeast iso-1-cytochrome c: genetic analysis of structural requirements

We describe the use of classical and molecular genetic techniques to investigate the folding, stability, and enzymatic requirements of iso-1-cytochrome c from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Interpretation of the defects associated with an extensive series of altered forms of iso-1-cytochrome c was facilitated by the recently resolved three dimensional structure of iso-1-cytochrome c [(1987) J. Mol. Biol. 199, 295-314], and by comparison with the phylogenetic series of eukaryotic cytochromes c. Residue replacements that abolish iso-1-cytochrome c function appear to do so by affecting either heme attachment or protein stability; no replacements that abolish electron transfer function without affecting protein structure were uncovered. Most nonfunctional forms retained at least partial covalent attachment to the heme moiety; heme attachment was abolished only by replacements of Cys19 and Cys22, which are required for thioether linkage, and His23, a heme ligand. Replacements were uncovered that retain function at varying levels, including replacements at evolutionarily conserved positions, some of which were structurally and functionally indistinguishable from wild type iso-1-cytochrome c.     

Structure determination and analysis of yeast iso-2-cytochrome c and a composite mutant protein.

As part of a study of protein folding and stability, the three-dimensional structures of yeast iso-2-cytochrome c and a composite protein (B-2036) composed of primary sequences of both iso-1 and iso-2-cytochromes c have been solved to 1.9 A and 1.95 A resolutions, respectively, using X-ray diffraction techniques. The sequences of iso-1 and iso-2-cytochrome c share approximately 84% identity and the B-2036 composite protein has residues 15 to 63 from iso-2-cytochrome c with the rest being derived form the iso-1 protein. Comparison of these structures reveals that amino acid substitutions result in alterations in the details of intramolecular interactions. Specifically, the substitution Leu98Met results in the filling of an internal cavity present in iso-1-cytochrome c. Further substitutions of Val20Ile and Cys102Ala alter the packing of secondary structure elements in the iso-2 protein. Blending the isozymic amino acid sequences in this latter area results in the expansion of the volume of an internal cavity in the B-2036 structure to relieve a steric clash between Ile20 and Cys102. Modification of hydrogen bonding and protein packing without disrupting the protein fold is illustrated by the His26Asn and Asn63Ser substitutions between iso-1 and iso-2-cytochromes c. Alternatively, a change in main-chain fold is observed at Gly37 apparently due to a remote amino acid substitution. Further structural changes occur at Phe82 and the amino terminus where a four residue extension is present in yeast iso-2-cytochrome c. An additional comparison with all other eukaryotic cytochrome c structures determined to date is presented, along with an analysis of conserved water molecules. Also determined are the midpoint reduction potentials of iso-2 and B-2036 cytochromes c using direct electrochemistry. The values obtained are 286 and 288 mV, respectively, indicating that the amino acid substitutions present have had only a small impact on the heme reduction potential in comparison to iso-1-cytochrome c, which has a reduction potential of 290 mV.     

Substitutions of proline 76 in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. Analysis of residues compatible and incompatible with folding requirements

Fine-structure genetic mapping previously revealed numerous nonfunctional cyc1 mutations having alterations at or near the site corresponding to amino acid position 76 of iso-1-cytochrome c from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. DNA sequencing of the alterations in four of these cyc1 mutations indicated that the normal Pro-76 was replaced by Leu-76. Revertants containing at least partially functional iso-1-cytochromes c were isolated, and the alterations were analyzed by DNA sequencing and protein analysis. Specific activities of the altered iso-1-cytochromes c were estimated in vivo by growth of the strains in lactate medium; compared to normal iso-1-cytochrome c with Pro-76, the following activities were associated with the following replacements: approximately 90% for Val-76, approximately 60% for Thr-76, approximately 30% for Ser-76, approximately 20% for Ile-76, and 0% for Leu-76. In order to develop an understanding of the factors that determine whether or not an altered iso-1-cytochrome c will function, we undertook a theoretical analysis which led to the conclusion that the activity of the proteins was dependent on both short- and long-range interactions. Short-range interactions were estimated from studies on known protein structures which gave the likelihood that various amino acids would be found in a local backbone configuration similar to the native protein; long-range interactions with the rest of the molecule were analyzed by considering the size of the side chain. We believe this approach can be used to analyze a wide variety of mutant proteins.     

Isolation and Characterization of Amber Suppressors in Yeast

Nonsense suppressors were obtained in a haploid yeast strain containing eight nutritional mutations, that are assumed to be amber or ochre, and the cyc1-179 amber mutation that has a UAG codon corresponding to position 9 in iso-1-cytochrome c. Previous studies established that the biosynthesis and function of iso-1-cytochrome c is compatible with replacements at position 9 of amino acids having widely different structures (Stewart and Sherman 1972). UV-induced revertants, selected on media requiring the reversion of one or two of the amber nutritional markers, were presumed to contain a suppressor if there was the unselected reversion of at least one other marker. The 1088 suppressors that were isolated could be divided into 78 phenotypic classes. Only 43 suppressors of three classes caused the production of more than 50% of the normal amount of iso-1-cytochrome c in the cyc1-179 strain. Genetic analyses indicated that all of these highly efficient amber suppressors are allelic to one or another of the eight suppressors which cause the insertion of tyrosine at ochre (UAA) codons (Gilmore, Stewart and Sherman 1971). Furthermore, only tyrosine has been identified at position 9 in iso-1-cytochrome c in cyc1-179 strains suppressed with these efficient amber suppressors.     

Amino acid replacements in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. Comparison with the phylogenetic series and the tertiary structure of related cytochromes c

The structural and folding requirements of eukaryotic cytochromes c have been investigated by determining the appropriate DNA sequences of a collection of 46 independent cyc 1 missense mutations obtained in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and by deducing the corresponding amino acid replacements that abolish function of iso-1-cytochrome c. A total of 33 different replacements at 19 amino acid positions were uncovered in this and previous studies. Because all of these nonfunctional iso-1-cytochromes c are produced at far below the normal level and because a representative number are labile in vitro, most of the replacements appear to be affecting stability of the protein or heme attachment. By considering the tertiary structure of related cytochromes c, the loss of function of most of the mutant iso-1-cytochromes c could be attributed to either replacements of critical residues that directly interact with the heme group or to replacements that disrupt the proper folding of the protein. The replacements of residues interacting with the heme group include those required for covalent attachment (Cys-19 and Cys-22), ligand formation (His-23 and Met-85), and formation of the immediate heme environment (Leu-37, Tyr-53, Trp-64, and Leu-73). Proper folding of the protein is prevented by replacements of glycine residues at sites that cannot accommodate side chains (Gly-11 and Gly-34); by replacements of residues with proline, which limit the torsion angle (Leu-14 and His-38); and by replacements apparently unable to direct the local folding of the backbone into the proper conformation (Pro-35, Tyr-72, Asn-75, Pro-76, Lys-84, Leu-99, and Leu-103). Even though most of the missense mutations occurred at sites corresponding to evolutionarily invariant or conserved residues, a consideration of the replacements in functional revertants indicates that the requirement for residues evolutionarily preserved is less stringent than commonly assumed.     

Altered absorption spectra of iso-1-cytochromes c from mutants of yeast.

Low temperature (-190 degrees) spectrophotometric recordings were made of mutant strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing various altered sequences of iso-1-cytochromes c. All mutants with replacements of the tryptophan 64 residue had abnormal Calpha-bands, in which the alpha2-peaks were accentuated to various degrees by being more separated from the major alpha1-peaks and by making up a larger portion of the total Calpha-peak. The altered iso-1-cytochromes c included those having the normal tryptophan 64 replaced by phenylalanine, leucine, tyrosine, cysteine, serine, or glycine as well as those having replacements at position 64 and additional replacements at other sites. Tryptophan 64 in iso-1-cytochrome c, which corresponds to tryptophan 59 in vertebrate cytochromes c, appears to be an important residue for preserving the electronic environment of the heme group. It is uncertain, however, whether altered spectra are due specifically to the abnormal residues at position 64 or due to distorted tertiary structures caused by the replacements.     

Evaluation of cooperative interactions between substructures of iso-1-cytochrome c using double mutant cycles

A double mutant cycle has been used to evaluate interaction energies between the global stabilizer mutation asparagine 52 --> isoleucine (N52I) in iso-1-cytochrome c and mutations producing single surface histidines at positions 26, 33, 39, 54, 73, 89, and 100. These histidine mutation sites are distributed through the four cooperative folding units of cytochrome c. The double mutant cycle starts with the iso-1-cytochrome c variant AcTM, a variant with no surface histidines and with asparagine at position 52. Isoleucine is added singly at position 52, AcTMI52 variant, as are the surface histidines, AcHX variants, where X indicates the histidine sequence position. The double mutant variants, AcHXI52, provide the remaining corner of the double mutant cycle. The stabilities of all variants were determined by guanidine hydrochloride denaturation and interaction energies were calculated between position 52 and each histidine site. Six of the seven double mutants show additive (AcH33I52, AcH39I52, AcH54I52, AcH89I52, and AcH100I52) stability effects or weak interaction energies (AcH73I52) of the histidine mutations and the N52I mutation, consistent with cooperative effects on protein folding and stability being sparsely distributed through the protein structure. The AcH26I52 variant shows a strong favorable interaction energy, 2.0 +/- 0.5 kcal/mol, between the N52I mutation in one substructure and the addition of His 26 to an adjacent substructure. The data are consistent with an entropic stabilization of the intersubstructure hydrogen bond between His 26 and Glu 44 by the Ile 52 mutation.     

Mutation of asparagine 52 to glycine promotes the alkaline form of iso-1-cytochrome c and causes loss of cooperativity in acid unfolding

The kinetics and thermodynamics of the alkaline and acid conformational transitions of a Lys 79 --> Ala/Asn 52 --> Gly (A79G52) variant of iso-1-cytochrome c are studied. The Lys 79 --> Ala mutation is designed to limit heme ligation in the alkaline conformer to Lys 73. The Asn 52 --> Gly mutation is intended to shift the population of the alkaline conformer to physiological pH based on the hierarchical nature of the cooperative substructures of this protein. The midpoint pH for formation of the alkaline conformer is approximately 7.45. The kinetics for the alkaline conformational transition of the A79G52 variant are consistent with the ionization constant, pK(H), for the trigger group controlling formation of the alkaline conformer being approximately 9.5. This pK(H) is low for alkaline conformers involving lysine-heme ligation but is consistent with the pK(a) of the highest of three ionizable groups which modulate formation of the histidine-heme alkaline conformer of a His 73 variant of iso-1-cytochrome c [Martinez, R. E., and Bowler, B. E. (2004) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 6751-6758]. The acid transition of the A79G52 variant is split into two phases. Both the Lys 79 --> Ala and Asn 52 --> Gly mutations are expected to affect the buried hydrogen bond network of cytochrome c, suggesting that this network is an important modulator of the acid unfolding of cytochrome c.     

Confirmation of UAG as a nonsense codon in bakers' yeast by amino acid replacements of glutamic acid 71 in iso-1-cytochrome c

The yeast mutant cy1–76 is more than 99% deficient in iso-1-cytochrome c. Twelve intragenic revertants of cy1–76 have approximately normal amounts of iso-1-cytochromes c, which are altered by replacement of glutamic acid 71 with either tryptophan, leucine, tyrosine, serine, glutamine or lysine. It is concluded that position 71 in functioning iso-1-cytochrome c can be radically varied, and that the defect in cy1–76 is a nonsense codon, UAG, corresponding to position 71.Tryptophan is the replacement in 4 of the 12 revertants of cy1–76. Tryptophan is similarly abundant as a replacement of lysine 9 in the previously studied 42 revertants ofcy1–179, but is not a replacement in the 45 previously studied revertants of cyl-9. Since amino acid replacements indicate that either UAA or UAG nonsense mutations occur in all three mutants, these new results confirm the previously recognized distinction between the two nonsense codons: one, evidently UAG, can be reverted to a tryptophan codon, while the other, apparently UAA, cannot; apparently UGA does not encode tryptophan in yeast.     

Replacement of a conserved proline and the alkaline conformational change in iso-2-cytochrome c

Although point mutations usually lead to minor localized changes in protein structure, replacement of conserved Pro-76 with Gly in iso-2-cytochrome c induces a major conformational change. The change in structure results from mutation-induced depression of the pK for transition to an alkaline conformation with altered heme ligation. To assess the importance of position 76 in stabilizing the native versus the alkaline structure, the equilibrium and kinetic properties of the pH-induced conformational change have been compared for normal and mutant iso-2-cytochrome c. The pKapp for the conformational change is reduced from 8.45 (normal iso-2) to 6.71 in the mutant protein (Gly-76 iso-2), suggesting that conservation of Pro-76 may be required to stabilize the native conformation at physiological pH. The kinetics of the conformational change for both the normal and mutant proteins are well-described by a single kinetic phase throughout most of the pH-induced transition zone. Over this pH range, a minimal mechanism proposed for horse cytochrome c [Davis, L. A., Schejter, A., & Hess, G. P. (1974) J. Biol. Chem. 249, 2624-2632] is consistent with the data for normal and mutant yeast iso-2-cytochromes c: NH KH----N + H+ kcf in equilibrium kcb A NH and N are native forms of cytochrome c with a 695-nm absorbance band, A is an alkaline form that lacks the 695-nm band, KH is a proton dissociation constant, and kcf and kcb are microscopic rate constants for the conformational change. The Gly-76 mutation increases kcf by almost 70-fold, but kcb and KH are unchanged.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Primary site and second site revertants of missense mutants of the evolutionarily invariant tryptophan 64 in iso-1-cytochrome c from yeast.

The three missense mutants cyc1-132, cyc1-166 and cyc1-189 in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae contain nonfunctional and thermolabile iso-1-cytochromes c and have different replacements of the tryptophan at position 64 which corresponds to the invariant tryptophan residue found in cytochromes c from all eukaryotic species. The cyc1-166 and cyc1-189 mutants contain single replacements of, respectively, serine 64 and cysteine 64, while the cyc1-132 mutant contains a double replacement of glycine 64 and alanine 65 instead of the normal tryptophan 64 and aspartic acid 65. Twenty-three intragenic revertants having at least partially functional iso-1-cytochromes c arose from these three missense mutants by single amino acid replacements of either tryptophan, phenylalanine, tyrosine or leucine at position 64, or by second-site replacements in which the mutant residues at position 64 are retained and the normal serine 45 is replaced by phenylalanine 45. Specific activities of the iso-1-cytochromes c were estimated by growth of strains on lactate medium and are as follows, in terms of the normal, for iso-1-cytochromes c altered specifically in the ways shown: 100% for phenylalanine 64; 25% for tyrosine 64; between 0 and 25% for leucine 64; 100% for phenylalanine 45, cysteine 64; 25% for phenylalanine 45, serine 64; between 0 and 25% for phenylalanine 45, glycine 64, alanine 65; and 0% for serine 64, for cysteine 64, and for glycine 64, alanine 65 iso-1-cytochromes c. The results demonstrate that small residues of glycine, serine, and cysteine at position 64 are incompatible with function; they imply that many of the 10 amino acids accessible by single base-pair substitution but not observed in primary site revertants also are incompatible with function; and they show that large hydrophobic residues of phenylalanine, leucine, and tyrosine at position 64 are capable of restoring at least partial function. The second site revertants indicate that deleterious effects of the three missense mutants can be compensated by the introduction of phenylalanine 45, which may occupy space normally filled by tryptophan 64. Altered shapes of Calpha-band spectra and at least partial instability were characteristics of all iso-1-cytochromes c found lacking tryptophan 64. Apparently, the principal role of the invariant tryptophan is stabilization of the active protein structure, by providing a large hydrophobic group at the proper location.     

Thermal denaturation of iso-1-cytochrome c variants: comparison with solvent denaturation.

Thermal denaturation studies as a function of pH were carried out on wild-type iso-1-cytochrome c and three variants of this protein at the solvent-exposed position 73 of the sequence. By examining the enthalpy and Tm at various pH values, the heat capacity increment (delta Cp), which is dominated by the degree of change in nonpolar hydration upon protein unfolding, was found for the wild type where lysine 73 is normally present and for three variants. For the Trp 73 variant, the delta Cp value (1.15 +/- 0.17 kcal/mol K) decreased slightly relative to wild-type iso-1-cytochrome c (1.40 +/- 0.06 kcal/mol K), while for the Ile 73 (1.65 +/- 0.07 kcal/mol K) and the Val 73 (1.50 +/- 0.06 kcal/mol K) variants, delta Cp increased slightly. In previous studies, the Trp 73, Ile 73, and Val 73 variants have been shown to have decreased m-values in guanidine hydrochloride denaturations relative to the wild-type protein (Hermann L, Bowler BE, Dong A, Caughey WS. 1995. The effects of hydrophilic to hydrophobic surface mutations on the denatured state of iso-1-cytochrome c: Investigation of aliphatic residues. Biochemistry 34:3040-3047). Both the m-value and delta Cp are related to the change in solvent exposure upon unfolding and other investigators have shown a correlation exists between these two parameters. However, for this subset of variants of iso-1-cytochrome c, a lack of correlation exists which implies that there may be basic differences between the guanidine hydrochloride and thermal denaturations of this protein. Spectroscopic data are consistent with different denatured states for thermal and guanidine hydrochloride unfolding. The different response of m-values and delta Cp for these variants will be discussed in this context.     

A mutation allowing an mRNA secondary structure diminishes translation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c.

The CYC1-239-O mutation in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae produces a -His-Leu- replacement of the normal -Ala-Gly- sequence at amino acid positions 5 and 6, which lie within a dispensable region of iso-1-cytochrome c; this mutation can accommodate the formation of a hairpin structure at the corresponding site in the mRNA. The amount of the altered protein was diminished to 20% of the wild-type level, whereas the amount of the mRNA remained normal. However, in contrast to the normal CYC1+ mRNA that is associated mainly with four to seven ribosomes, the bulk of the CYC1-239-O mRNA is associated with one to four ribosomes. These results suggest that the stable secondary structure within the translated region of the CYC1 mRNA diminishes translation by inhibiting elongation.     

The role of the internal hydrogen bond network in first-order protein electron transfer between Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c and bovine microsomal cytochrome b5.

An internal water molecule (designated WAT166) is found in iso-1-cytochrome c which is part of a redox-state-dependent hydrogen bond network. The position of this water molecule with respect to the polypeptide fold can be altered or even displaced by site-directed mutagenesis leading to structural perturbations and associated changes in redox potential. Using saturation transfer 1H-NMR methods, this study measures changes in the electron transfer reactivity for three variants of yeast iso-1-cytochromes c in which the position of this water molecule is altered. In particular, the reverse electron transfer rate is measured within a complex formed between either wild-type or variant yeast iso-1-cytochromes c and the tryptic fragment of bovine liver microsomal cytochrome b5. For three variants of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c the rate constants measured by saturation transfer are wild-type (Asn52, E0 = 270 mV, kex = 0.3 s-1), Asn52----Ala (E0 = 240 mV, kex = 0.6 s-1), Asn52----Ile (E0 = 220 mV, kex = 1.0 s-1). The first-order rates are compared with that of a fourth variant Phe82----Gly which has been measured previously (E0 = 220 mV, kex = 0.7 s-1). An analysis of the variation in the observed cross exchange rate using Marcus theory shows that these changes can be predicted quantitatively by the shift in redox potential that accompanies mutagenesis. So, although the perturbation of the internal water molecule by mutagenesis alters both the structure and redox potential of cytochrome c, surprisingly it does not significantly influence the intrinsic electron transfer reactivity of the protein. Studies of the activation parameters suggests that a variation of temperature changes both delta G* and also the prefactor. These data are discussed in terms of models involving dynamic molecular recognition between proteins.     

Mutants of yeast initiating translation of Iso-1-cytochrome c within a region spanning 37 nucleotides

We used a specially constructed strain, cyc1–345, of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae to isolate revertants that initiated translation of iso-1-cytochrome c at various sites along an extended region of the mRNA. Normal amounts of iso-1-cytochrome c occurred when translation initiated at the abnormal sites corresponding to amino acid positions ?3, ?2, 3 and 5, as well as the normal position ?1; 20% of the normal amounts occurred when translation initiated at the abnormal position 9. These results with cyc1–345 revertants indicate that translation of iso-1-cytochrome c can initiate with the normal efficiency at any site within the region spanning 25 nucleotides. Furthermore, because the lower amount of the short iso-1-cytochrome c in the mutant initiating at position 9 may not necessarily reflect an inefficiency of translation, we believe that translation can initiate with normal or near-normal efficiencies at any site within a 37 nucleotide region, and presumably at any site preceding and following that of the normal initiation codon. These results establish that there is no absolute requirement for a particular sequence 5′ to the initiation codon, and are consistent with our previous suggestion that translation starts at the AUG codon closest to the 5′ end of the mRNA.     

Replacement of the invariant lysine 77 by arginine in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c results in enhanced and normal activities in vitro and in vivo

Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae was used to generate an abnormal iso-1-cytochrome c having an Arg-77 replacement of the normal Lys-77; this Lys-77 residue is evolutionarily conserved in most eukaryotic cytochromes c and is trimethylated in fungal and plant cytochromes c. Examination of strains having a single chromosomal copy of the gene encoding the Arg-77 protein indicated that the altered protein was synthesized at the normal rate and that it had normal or near normal activity in vivo. Examination of enzymatic activities in vitro with cytochrome b2, cytochrome c peroxidase, and cytochrome c oxidase indicated that the altered iso-1-cytochrome c has equal or enhanced catalytic efficiencies. Thus, replacement of the evolutionarily conserved residue Lys-77 produces no or only minor effects both in vivo and in vitro.     

Yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. A 2.8 A resolution three-dimensional structure determination

A molecular replacement approach, augmented with the results of predictive modeling procedures, solvent accessibility studies, packing analyses and translational coefficient searches, has been used to elucidate the 2.8 A (1 A = 0.1 nm) resolution structure of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. An examination of the polypeptide chain folding of this protein shows it to have unique conformations in three regions, upon comparison with the structures of other eukaryotic cytochromes c. These include: residues -5 to +1 at the N-terminal end of the polypeptide chain, which are in an extended conformation and project in large part off the surface of the protein; residues 19 to 26, which form a surface beta-loop on the His18 ligand side of the central heme group; and, the C-terminal end of the helical segment composed of residues 49 to 56, which serves to form a part of the heme pocket. Structural studies also show that the highly reactive sulfhydryl group of Cys102 is buried within a hydrophobic region in the monomer form of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. Dimerization of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c through disulfide bond formation between two such residues would require a substantial conformational change in the C-terminal helix of this protein. Another unique structural feature, the trimethylated side-chain of Lys72, is located on the surface of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c near the solvent-exposed edge of the bound heme prosthetic group. On the basis of the results of these and other structural studies, an analysis of the spatial conservation of structural features in the heme pocket of eukaryotic cytochromes c has been conducted. It was found that the residues involved could be divided into three general classes. The current structural analyses and additional modeling studies have also been used to explain the altered functional properties observed for mutant yeast iso-1-cytochrome c proteins.