Epigenetic mechanical factors in the evolution of long bone epiphyses

In developing vertebrate long bones in which endochondral ossification occurs, it is preceded or accompanied by perichondral ossification. The speed and extent of perichondral apposition relative to endochondral ossification varies in different taxa. Perichondral ossification dominates early long bone development in extinct basal tetrapods and dinosaurs, extant bony fish, amphibians, and birds. In mammals and lizards, perichondral and endochondral ossification proceed more synchronously. One of the most important epigenetic factors in skeletogenesis is mechanical loading caused by muscle contractions which begin in utero or in ovo . It has been previously shown that the stress distributions created perinatally in the chondroepiphysis during human skeletal development can influence the appearance of secondary ossification centres. Using finite element computer models representing bones near birth or hatching, we demonstrate that in vertebrates in which perichondral ossification significantly precedes endochondral ossification, the distribution of mechanical stresses in the ossifying cartilage anlagen tends to inhibit the appearance of secondary ossification centres in the ends of long bones. In models representing vertebrates in which endochondral ossification keeps pace with perichondral apposition, the appearance of secondary centres is promoted. The appearance of secondary centres leads to the formation of bony epiphyses and growth plates, which are most common in mammals and extant lizards. We postulate that genotypic factors influencing the relative speed and extent of perichondral and endochondral ossification interact with mechanical epigenetic factors early in development to account for many of the morphological differences observed in vertebrate skeletons.     

Growth cartilage calcification and formation of bone trabeculae are late and dissociated events in the endochondral ossification of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rana catesbeiana</Emphasis>

Endochondral ossification in the growth cartilage of long bones from the bullfrog Rana catesbeiana was examined. In stage-46 tadpoles and 1-year-old animals, the hypertrophic cartilage had a smooth contact with the bone marrow and the matrix showed no calcification or endochondral bone formation. In spite of showing no aspects of calcification, the chondrocytes exhibited alkaline phosphatase activity and some of them died by apoptosis. However, matrix calcification and endochondral ossification were observed in 2-year-old bullfrogs. Calcium deposits appeared as isolated or coalesced spherical structures in the extracellular matrix of hypertrophic cartilage. Bone trabeculae were restricted to the central area at the sites where the hypertrophic cartilage surface was exposed to the bone marrow. Cartilage matrix calcification and the formation of bone trabeculae were not dependent on each other. Osteoclasts were involved in calcified matrix resorption. These results demonstrate that the calcification of hypertrophic cartilage and the deposition of bone trabeculae are late events in R. catesbeiana and do not contribute to the development and growth of long bones in adults. These processes may play a role in reinforcing bony structures as the bullfrog gains weight in adulthood. In addition, the deposition of bone trabeculae is not dependent on cartilage matrix calcification.     

Relationship between the chondrocyte maturation cycle and the endochondral ossification in the diaphyseal and epiphyseal ossification centers

The chondrocyte maturation cycle and endochondral ossification were studied in human, fetal cartilage Anlagen and in postnatal meta‐epiphyses. The relationship between the lacunar area, the inter‐territorial fibril network variations, and calcium phosphorus nucleation in primary and secondary ossification centers were assessed using light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) morphometry. The Anlage topographic, zonal classification was derived from the anatomical nomenclature of the completely developed long bone (diaphysis, metaphyses and epiphyses). A significant increase in the chondrocyte lacunar area was documented in the Anlage of epiphyseal zones 4 and 3 to zone 2 (metaphysis) and zone 1 (diaphysis), with the highest variation from zone 2 to zone 1. An inverse reduction in the intercellular matrix area and matrix interfibrillar empty space was also documented. These findings are consistent with the osmotic passage of free cartilage water from the interfibrillar space into the swelling chondrocytes, which increased the ion concentrations to a critical threshold for mineral precipitation in the matrix. The mineralized cartilage served as a scaffold for osteoblast apposition both in primary and secondary ossification centers and in the metaphyseal growth plate cartilage, though at different periods of bone Anlage development and with distinct patterns for each zone. All developmental processes shared a common initial pathway but progressed at different rates, modes and organization in diaphysis, metaphysis and epiphysis. In the ossification phase the developing vascular supply appeared to play a key role in determining the cortical or trabecular structure of the long bones. J. Morphol. 277:1187–1198, 2016. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Osteohistological insight into the early stages of growth in Mussaurus patagonicus (Dinosauria,Sauropodomorpha)

Here, we describe the bone histology of juvenile specimens of the basal sauropodomorph Mussaurus patagonicus and interpret its significance in terms of the early growth dynamics of this taxon. Thin sections from three juvenile specimens (femur length, 111–120 mm) of Mussaurus were analysed. The sampled bones consist of multiple postcranial elements collected from the Late Triassic Laguna Colorada Formation (El Tranquilo Group, Patagonia). The cortical bone is composed of fibrolamellar bone tissue. Vascularisation is commonly laminar or plexiform in the long bones. Growth marks are absent in all the examined samples. The ‘epiphyses’ of long bones are all formed by well-developed hypertrophied calcified cartilage. The predominance of woven-fibred bone matrix in cortical bones indicates a fast growth rate in the individuals examined. Moreover, given the existence of growth marks in adult specimens of Mussaurus, as in other sauropodomorphs, and assuming that the first lines of arrested growth was formed during the first year of life, the absence of growth marks in all the bones suggest that the specimens died before reaching their first year of life. Compared with the African taxon Massospondylus carinatus (another basal sauropodomorph for which the bone histology has been previously studied), it appears that Mussaurus had a higher early growth rate than Massospondylus.     

ADAM17 Controls Endochondral Ossification by Regulating Terminal Differentiation of Chondrocytes

Endochondral ossification is a highly regulated process that relies on properly orchestrated cell-cell interactions in the developing growth plate. This study is focused on understanding the role of a crucial regulator of cell-cell interactions, the membrane-anchored metalloproteinase ADAM17, in endochondral ossification. ADAM17 releases growth factors, cytokines, and other membrane proteins from cells and is essential for epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) signaling and for processing tumor necrosis factor alpha. Here, we report that mice lacking ADAM17 in chondrocytes (A17ΔCh) have a significantly expanded zone of hypertrophic chondrocytes in the growth plate and retarded growth of long bones. This abnormality is caused by an accumulation of the most terminally differentiated type of chondrocytes that produces a calcified matrix. Inactivation of ADAM17 in osteoclasts or endothelial cells does not affect the zone of hypertrophic chondrocytes, suggesting that the main role of ADAM17 in the growth plate is in chondrocytes. This notion is further supported by in vitro experiments showing enhanced hypertrophic differentiation of primary chondrocytes lacking Adam17. The enlarged zone of hypertrophic chondrocytes in A17ΔCh mice resembles that described in mice with mutant EGFR signaling or lack of its ligand transforming growth factor α (TGFα), suggesting that ADAM17 regulates terminal differentiation of chondrocytes during endochondral ossification by activating the TGFα/EGFR signaling axis.     

BAC constructs in transgenic reporter mouse lines control efficient and specific LacZ expression in hypertrophic chondrocytes under the complete Col10a1 promoter

During endochondral ossification hypertrophic chondrocytes in the growth plate of fetal long bones, ribs and vertebrae play a key role in preparing growth plate cartilage for replacement by bone. In order to establish a reporter gene mouse to facilitate functional analysis of genes expressed in hypertrophic chondrocytes in this process, Col10a1- BAC reporter gene mouse lines were established expressing LacZ specifically in hypertrophic cartilage under the control of the complete Col10a1 gene. For this purpose, a bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC RP23-192A7) containing the entire murine Col10a1 gene together with 200 kb flanking sequences was modified by inserting a LacZ-Neo cassette into the second exon of Col10a1 by homologous recombination in E. coli. Transgenic mice containing between one and seven transgene copies were generated by injection of the purified BAC-Col10a1- lLacZ DNA. X-gal staining of newborns and embryos revealed strong and robust LacZ activity exclusively in hypertrophic cartilage of the fetal and neonatal skeleton of the transgenic offspring. This indicates that expression of the reporter gene in its proper genomic context in the BAC Col10a1 environment is independent of the integration site and reflects authentic Col10a1 expression in vivo. The Col10a1 specific BAC recombination vector described here will enable the specific analysis of effector gene functions in hypertrophic cartilage during skeletal development, endochondral ossification, and fracture callus healing. Sonja Gebhard and Takako Hattori equally contributed to this work.     

Development of epiphyseal structure and function in Didelphis virginiana (Marsupiala,Didelphidae)

This study addressed the question of how the epiphyses of growing mammals change their external shape and internal architecture during postnatal development. Ontogenetic transformations in the external form and internal structure of the fore‐ and hindlimb epiphyses were examined in a mixed cross‐sectional sample of Didelphis virginiana using two methods: morphometric analysis of linear epiphyseal dimensions and histological staining of serially sectioned epiphyses. Metric data indicate that Virginia opossums are born with relatively short hindlimbs and long forelimbs, but by the time they are weaned their hindlimbs are longer than their forelimbs. Functional integration of the locomotor system in D. virginiana involves a decoupling of fore‐ and hindlimb growth rates so that between birth and weaning, femoral length, diaphyseal cross‐sectional area, and articular surface area increase at a significantly faster rate than the corresponding humeral dimensions. Histological results demonstrate that these differences in growth rate are reflected in morphology of the humeral and femoral growth plate and epiphyseal cartilages. The humeral cartilages exhibit a level of cellular organization characteristic of more mature limb elements at earlier developmental stages compared to the femoral cartilages, which assume this anisotropic structure relatively later in postnatal development. Results presented here also reveal that the formation of articular cartilage and the initiation of epiphyseal ossification in D. virginiana are both correlated with the development of independent positional behaviors prior to weaning. These histological data, therefore, suggest that mechanical loading associated with the postnatal onset of locomotor and postural development may provide an important stimulus for the progression of ossification and the formation of articular cartilage in the epiphyses of growing mammals. J. Morphol. 239:283–296, 1999. © 1999 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

FGF9 can induce endochondral ossification in cranial mesenchyme

Background  

The flat bones of the skull (i.e., the frontal and parietal bones) normally form through intramembranous ossification. At these sites cranial mesenchymal cells directly differentiate into osteoblasts without the formation of a cartilage intermediate. This type of ossification is distinct from endochondral ossification, a process that involves initial formation of cartilage and later replacement by bone.     

Effect of alendronate on endochondral ossification in mandibular condyles of growing rats

The replacement of the calcified cartilage by bone tissue during the endochondral ossification of the mandibular condyle is dependent of the resorbing activity of osteoclats. After partial resorption, calcified cartilage septa are covered by a primary bone matrix secreted by osteoblasts. Osteoadherin (OSAD) is a small proteoglycan present in bone matrix but absent in cartilage during the endochondral ossification. The aim of this study was to analyze the effect of alendronate, a drug known to inhibit bone resorption by osteoclasts, on the endochondral ossification of the mandibular condyle of young rats, by evaluating the distribution of osteoclasts and the presence of OSAD in the bone matrix deposited. Wistar newborn rats (n=45) received daily injections of alendronate (n=27) or sterile saline solution as control (n=18) from the day of birth until the ages of 4, 14 and 30 days. At the days mentioned, the mandibular condyles were collected and processed for transmission electron microscopy analysis. Specimens were also submitted to tartrate resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) histochemistry and ultrastructural immunodetection of OSAD. Alendronate treatment did not impede the recruitment and fusion of osteoclasts at the ossification zone during condyle growth, but they presented inactivated phenotype. The trabeculae at the ossification area consisted of cartilage matrix covered by a layer of primary bone matrix that was immunopositive to OSAD at all time points studied. Apparently, alendronate impeded the removal of calcified cartilage and maturation of bone trabeculae in the mandibular ramus, while in controls they occurred normally. These findings highlight for giving attention to the potential side-effects of bisphosphonates administered to young patients once it may represent a risk of disturbing maxillofacial development.     

Leukaemia inhibitory factor (lif) is expressed in hypertrophic chondrocytes and vascular sprouts during osteogenesis

Avascular cartilage is replaced by highly vascularized bone tissue during endochondral ossification, a process involving capillary invasion of calcified hypertrophic cartilage in association with apoptosis of hypertrophic chondrocytes, degradation of cartilage matrix and deposition of bone matrix. All of these events are closely controlled, especially by cytokines and growth factors. Leukaemia inhibitory factor (LIF), a member of the gp130 cytokine family, is involved in osteoarticular tissue metabolism and might participate in osteogenesis. Immunohistochemical staining showed that LIF is expressed in hypertrophic chondrocytes and vascular sprouts of cartilage and bone during rat and human osteogenesis. LIF is also present in osteoblasts but not in osteoclasts. Observations in a rat endochondral ossification model were confirmed by studies of human cartilage biopsies from foetuses with osteogenesis imperfecta. LIF was never detected in adult articular chondrocytes and bone-marrow mesenchymal cells. These results and other data in the literature suggest that LIF is involved in the delicate balance between the rate of formation of calcified cartilage and its vascularization for bone development.     

Site specific effects of zoledronic acid during tibial and mandibular fracture repair

Numerous factors can affect skeletal regeneration, including the extent of bone injury, mechanical loading, inflammation and exogenous molecules. Bisphosphonates are anticatabolic agents that have been widely used to treat a variety of metabolic bone diseases. Zoledronate (ZA), a nitrogen-containing bisphosphonate (N-BP), is the most potent bisphosphonate among the clinically approved bisphosphonates. Cases of bisphosphonate-induced osteonecrosis of the jaw have been reported in patients receiving long term N-BP treatment. Yet, osteonecrosis does not occur in long bones. The aim of this study was to compare the effects of zoledronate on long bone and cranial bone regeneration using a previously established model of non-stabilized tibial fractures and a new model of mandibular fracture repair. Contrary to tibial fractures, which heal mainly through endochondral ossification, mandibular fractures healed via endochondral and intramembranous ossification with a lesser degree of endochondral ossification compared to tibial fractures. In the tibia, ZA reduced callus and cartilage formation during the early stages of repair. In parallel, we found a delay in cartilage hypertrophy and a decrease in angiogenesis during the soft callus phase of repair. During later stages of repair, ZA delayed callus, cartilage and bone remodeling. In the mandible, ZA delayed callus, cartilage and bone remodeling in correlation with a decrease in osteoclast number during the soft and hard callus phases of repair. These results reveal a more profound impact of ZA on cartilage and bone remodeling in the mandible compared to the tibia. This may predispose mandible bone to adverse effects of ZA in disease conditions. These results also imply that therapeutic effects of ZA may need to be optimized using time and dose-specific treatments in cranial versus long bones.     

The PI3K pathway regulates endochondral bone growth through control of hypertrophic chondrocyte differentiation

Background  

The majority of our bones develop through the process of endochondral ossification that involves chondrocyte proliferation and hypertrophic differentiation in the cartilage growth plate. A large number of growth factors and hormones have been implicated in the regulation of growth plate biology, however, less is known about the intracellular signaling pathways involved. PI3K/Akt has been identified as a major regulator of cellular proliferation, differentiation and death in multiple cell types.     

Osteogenesis,homology, and function of the intercostal plates in ornithischian dinosaurs (Tetrapoda,Sauropsida)

Intercostal plates are bony structures positioned lateral to the anterior dorsal ribs in some ornithischian dinosaurs. Some propose these plates are homologous, or functionally analogous, with the uncinate processes of extant avian dinosaurs that assist in breathing, while others suggest they served a defensive function. To elucidate their osteogenesis, homology, and function, a histological survey of intercostal plates from three taxa (Hypsilophodon, Talenkauen, and Thescelosaurus) was undertaken. This study reveals that osteogenesis of intercostal plates closely resembles that of secondary centers of ossification in endochondral bone, typically present in the epiphyses of mammalian long bones. In contrast, ossification of avian uncinate processes begins at a primary ossification center via the development of a bony collar around a cartilaginous model. Based on these data, intercostal plates and avian uncinate processes are likely not evolutionary homologs. Dense packets of obliquely oriented Sharpey’s fibers within the parallel-fibered bone of somatically mature intercostal plates indicate these plates were positioned medial to at least a portion of the hypaxial musculature, which does not support their use as bony armor. Rather, we propose that intercostal plates performed some biomechanical function, either assisting in breathing in a way analogous to avian uncinate processes, or working together with the sternal ribs and sternal plates of these ornithischian taxa to provide increased rigidity to the anterior portion of the ribcage.     

Homology of fin lepidotrichia in osteichthyan fishes

Lepidotrichia are dermal elements located at the distal margin of osteichthyan fins. In sarcopterygians and actinopterygians, the term has been used to denote the most distal bony hemisegments and also the more proximal, scale-covered segments which overlie endochondral bones of the fin. In certain sarcopterygian fishes, including the Rhizodontida, these more proximal, basal segments are very long, extending at least half the length of the fin. The basal segments have a subcircular cross section, rather than the crescentic cross section of the distal lepidotrichial hemisegments, which lack a scale cover and comprise short, generally regular, elements. In rhizodonts and other sarcopterygians, e.g. Eusthenopteron, the basal elements are the first to appear during fin development, followed by the endochondral bones and then the distal lepidotrichia. This sequence contradicts the 'clock-face model' of fin development proposed by Thorogood in which the formation of endochondral bones is followed by development of lepidotrichia. However, if elongate basal 'lepidotrichia' are not homologous with more distal, jointed lepidotrichia and if the latter form within a distal fin-fold and the former outside this fold, then Thorogood's 'clock-face' model remains valid. This interpretation might indicate that the fin-fold has been lost in early digited stem-tetrapods such as Acanthostega and Ichthyostega and elongate basal elements, but not true lepidotrichia, occur in the caudal fins of these taxa.     

Expression profile of Xenopus banded hedgehog, a homolog of mouse Indian hedgehog, is related to the late development of endochondral ossification in Xenopus laevis

Late development of endochondral ossification occurs at the boundary between the growth cartilage and bone marrow during the formation of long bones in Xenopus laevis. Since the Indian hedgehog (Ihh) is involved in endochondral ossification in mouse, we investigated the expression of Xenopus banded hedgehog (X-bhh), which is a homolog of mouse Ihh. RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that the X-bhh mRNA was detected from an early stage of limb formation to formation of femurs in mature frogs, and it was associated with the expression of Xenopus-ptc1 (X-ptc1), Xenopus-gli1 (X-gli1), Xenopus-type II collagen (X-col II), Xenopus-runx2 (X-runx2), and Xenopus-osteocalcin (X-ocn) mRNAs. In situ hybridization revealed that chondrogenic cells observed at early limb development expressed X-bhh and X-gli1. At later stages of limb development, chondrocytes, located slightly away from the boundary between the cartilage and bone marrow, expressed the X-bhh, X-ptc1, and X-gli1 mRNAs; however, the mesenchymal cells at the boundary failed to express these mRNAs. The X-bhh, X-ptc1, and X-gli1 mRNAs as well as those of X-runx2 and X-ocn were expressed by the mesenchymal cells in the periosteal region at the tip of the cortical bone, indicating an intimate relationship between X-bhh expression and bone formation in this region. Considered collectively, the present study suggests that X-bhh evolutionally acquired the function to induce osteogenesis; however, the expression profile of X-bhh in epiphysis is closely related to the late development of endochondral ossification in X. laevis.     

Static osteogenesis does not precede dynamic osteogenesis in periosteal ossification of Pleurodeles (Caudata,Amphibia) and Pogona (Squamata,Lepidosauria)

Two successive mechanisms have been described in perichondral ossification: (1) in static osteogenesis, mesenchymal cells differentiate into stationary osteoblasts oriented randomly, which differentiate into osteocytes in the same site; (2) in dynamic osteogenesis, mesenchymal cells differentiate into osteoblasts that are all oriented in the same direction and move back as they secrete collagen fibers. This study is aimed at testing the hypothesis that the ontogenetic sequence static then dynamic osteogenesis observed in the chicken and in the rabbit is homologous and was acquired by the last common ancestor of amniotes or at a more inclusive node. For this we analyze the developmental patterns of Pleurodeles (Caudata, Amphibia) and those of the lizard Pogona (Squamata, Lepidosauria). We processed Pleurodeles larvae and Pogona embryos, prepared thin and ultrathin sections of appendicular bones, and analyzed them using light and transmission electron microscopy. We show that static osteogenesis does not precede dynamic osteogenesis in periosteal ossification of Pleurodeles and Pogona . Therefore, the null hypothesis is rejected and according to the parsimony method the ontogenetic sequence observed in the chicken and in the rabbit are convergent. In Pleurodeles and Pogona dynamic osteogenesis occur without a previous rigid mineralized framework, whereas in the chicken and in the rabbit dynamic osteogenesis seems to take place over a mineralized support whether bone (in perichondral ossification) or calcified cartilage (in endochondral ossification). Interestingly, in typical dynamic osteogenesis, osteoblasts show an axis (basal nucleus—distal endoplasmic reticulum) perpendicular to the front of secreted unmineralized bone matrix, whereas in Pleurodeles and Pogona this axis is parallel to the bone matrix.     

The turnover of mineralized growth plate cartilage into bone may be regulated by osteocytes

During endochondral ossification, growth plate cartilage is replaced with bone. Mineralized cartilage matrix is resorbed by osteoclasts, and new bone tissue is formed by osteoblasts. As mineralized cartilage does not contain any cells, it is unclear how this process is regulated. We hypothesize that, in analogy with bone remodeling, osteoclast and osteoblast activity are regulated by osteocytes, in response to mechanical loading. Since the cartilage does not contain osteocytes, this means that cartilage turnover during endochondral ossification would be regulated by the adjacent bone tissue. We investigated this hypothesis with an established computational bone adaptation model. In this model, osteocytes stimulate osteoblastic bone formation in response to the mechanical bone tissue loading. Osteoclasts resorb bone near randomly occurring microcracks that are assumed to block osteocyte signals. We used finite element modeling to evaluate our hypothesis in a 2D-domain representing part of the growth plate and adjacent bone. Cartilage was added at a constant physiological rate to simulate growth. Simulations showed that osteocyte signals from neighboring bone were sufficient for successful cartilage turnover, since equilibrium between cartilage remodeling and growth was obtained. Furthermore, there was good agreement between simulated bone structures and rat tibia histology, and the development of the trabecular architecture resembled that of infant long bones. Additionally, prohibiting osteoclast invasion resulted in thickened mineralized cartilage, similar to observations in a knock-out mouse model. We therefore conclude that it is well possible that osteocytes regulate the turnover of mineralized growth plate cartilage.     

Conditional deletion of Tgfbr2 in hypertrophic chondrocytes delays terminal chondrocyte differentiation

Transforming growth factor β (Tgfb) signaling plays an important role in endochondral ossification. Previous studies of mice in which the Tgfb type II receptor gene (Tgfbr2) was deleted in the limb bud mesenchymal cells or differentiated chondrocytes showed defects in the development of the long bones or the axial skeleton, respectively. Here, we generated mouse embryos in which the Tgfbr2 gene was ablated in hypertrophic chondrocytes. These mice exhibited delays in both the hypertrophic conversion of proliferating chondrocytes and the subsequent terminal chondrocyte differentiation. The expression domains of Col10a1, Matrix metalloproteinase 13, and Osteopontin were small, and the expression of Vascular endothelial growth factor and Platelet endothelial cell adhesion molecule was downregulated. The calcification of the bone collar in the mutant mice was markedly delayed and the periosteum was thin, possibly because of the downregulation of Indian hedgehog expression. We conclude that Tgfb signaling in hypertrophic chondrocytes positively regulates terminal chondrocyte differentiation, angiogenesis in calcified cartilage, and osteogenesis in the bone collar, at least partly through Indian hedgehog signaling in vivo.