Homologous pairing and topological linkage of DNA molecules by combined action of E. coli recA protein and topoisomerase I

E. coil RecA protein and topolsomerase I, acting on superhelical DNA and circular single strands in the presence of ATP and Mg²⁺, topologically link single-stranded molecules to one another, and single-stranded molecules to duplex DNA. When super-helical DNA is relaxed by prior incubation with topoisomerase, it is a poor substrate for catenation. Extensive homology stimulates the catenation of circular single-stranded DNA and superhelical DNA, whereas little reaction occurs between these forms of the closely related DNAs of phages φX174 and G4, indicating that, in conjunction with topoisomerase I, RecA protein can discriminate perfect or nearly perfect homology from a high degree of relatedness. Circular single-stranded G4 DNA reacts with superhelical DNA of a chimeric phage, M13Goril, to form catenanes, at least half of which survive heating at 80°C following restriction cleavage in the M13 region, but few of which survive following restriction cleavage in the G4 region. Electron microscopic examination of catenated molecules cleaved in the M13 region reveals that in most cases the single-stranded G4 DNA is joined to the linear duplex M13(G4) DNA in the homologous G4 region. The junction frequently has the appearance of a D loop, with an extent equivalent to 100 or more bp. We conclude that a significant fraction of catenanes were hemicatenanes, in which the single-stranded circle was topologically linked, probably by multiple turns, to its complementary strand in the duplex DNA. These observations support the previous conclusion that RecA protein can pair a single strand with its complementary strand in duplex DNA in a side-by-side fashion without a free end in any of the three strands.     

Restricted uptake of ethidium bromide and propidium diiodide by denatured closed circular DNA in buoyant cesium chloride

Alkali-denatured closed circular DNA forms, on neutralization, a relatively stable species first described by Pouwels et al. (1968). In contrast to single-stranded DNA, this denatured two-stranded closed circular DNA species bands densely and co-bands approximately with closed circular duplex DNA in ethidium bromide-CsCl equilibrium density gradients. In CsCl gradients containing propidium diiodide, denDNA I is denser than DNA I, nicked circular DNA and single-stranded φX174 viral DNA. The magnitude of the separations between the above DNAs allows preparative isolation of each when all four are present in the same gradient. The denDNA I has a novel open circular appearance in the electron microscope when cast on standard aqueous hypophases. This species becomes tightly twisted when cast on either aqueous or formamide hypophases containing ethidium bromide. We have concluded from these observations that the high buoyant density of denDNA I in dye-CsCl gradients, relative to single-stranded DNA, is the result of a restricted uptake of dye.     

Bacteriophage phi X174 RF DNA replication in vivo. A study by electron microscopy.

We have investigated bacteriophage φX174 RF ² DNA replication by electron microscopy. Three different, types of replicative intermediates were observed: rolling circles, partially duplex DNA circles and structures consisting of two DNA circles connected at a single point.Rolling circles with a single-stranded or partially double-stranded DNA tail were both observed. After cleavage of the rolling circles with the restriction endonuclease from Providentia stuartii 164 (PstI) the startpoint of rolling circle replication could be located at 21 map units from the PstI cleavage site in agreement with the previously determined position of the origin of φX RF DNA replication.Partially duplex DNA circles consist of circular viral DNA strands and incomplete complementary DNA strands. After cleavage of these molecules with PstI information about the startpoints of the synthesis of the complementary DNA strand was obtained.The connected DNA circles always contain one completely double-stranded DNA circle whereas the other circle consists of either single-stranded, partially duplex or completely duplex DNA.Part of the duplex-to-duplex DNA circles represent the well-known figure eight or catenated circular dimers. The other connected DNA circles presumably represent replication intermediates which arise by the association of the end of the genome length tail of the rolling circle with the origin-terminus region. This is suggested by the fact that the point of contact between the two DNA circles is located at approximately 21 map units from the Pst1 cleavage site, i.e. at the origin-terminus region of the φX genome. The connected DNA circles may be intermediates in the circularization and cleavage of the genome-length tail of the rolling circles in vivo.A model for φX174 RF DNA replication in vivo summarizing the data obtained by biochemical (Baas et al., 1978) and electron microscopic analysis of replicative intermediates is presented (Fig. 9).     

DNA synthesis in nucleotide-permeable Escherichia coli cells. VII. Conversion of phi chi-174 DNA to its replicative form

On incubation with deoxynucleoside triphosphates and rATP, ether-treated (nucleotide-permeable) cells convert the single-stranded DNA of adsorbed bacteriophage φX174 particles to the double-stranded replicative forms. The main final product is the doubly-closed replicative form, RFI; a minor product is the relaxed form II. Interruptions in the nascent complementary strand of the viral DNA result in pieces corresponding to 5 to 10% of the unit length of the viral DNA. Pieces of similar size were previously seen in studies of the replication synthesis of Escherichia, coli DNA in ether-treated cells. Since the conversion of the single-stranded φX174 DNA to replicative form is known to be mediated entirely by host factors, it is argued that the viral single strands are replicated by macromolecular factors involed in the replication of E. coli DNA and that this is the reason why new φX174 DNA appears in short pieces. Possible consequences of this interpretation for an understanding of duplex replication are discussed. The joining of the short pieces of complementary φX174 DNA is inhibited at low deoxynucleoside triphosphate concentration (1 μM) but not by nicotinamide mononucleotide, which inhibits the NAD-dependent DNA ligase and blocks the conversion of RFII to RFI in ether-treated cells. The results are discussed with respect to previous studies on cell-DNA synthesis (Geider, 1972). It is argued that there are two polynucleotide joining mechanisms, of which only one requires NAD-dependent ligase action.     

Studies on the phi X174 gene A protein-mediated termination of leading strand DNA synthesis

Recombinant RF (replicate form) I DNAs containing the bacteriophage phi X174 gene A protein-recognition sequence are cleaved by the phi X A protein yielding a phi X RF II X A protein complex (Zipursky, S.L., Reinberg, D., and Hurwitz, J. (1980) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 77, 5182-5186). Such complexes support DNA synthesis in both RF I leads to SS(c) and RF I leads to RF I phi X DNA replication reactions in vitro. Two phi X A protein-recognition sequences were inserted into plasmid pBR322. Both sequences were contiguous with the same strand of the vector DNA and separated by 667 and 4275 base pairs. This recombinant plasmid (G27-4) was cleaved by the phi X A protein at either insert and both inserts support the initiation of RF leads to SS(c) DNA synthesis. This was verified by the finding that replication products were circular molecules of 667 and 4275 nucleotides. This finding is in keeping with the multifunctional activities associated with the phi X A protein; these include the site-specific nicking of RF I DNA which initiates DNA synthesis and site-specific termination resulting in the circularization of the displaced DNA strand. The phi X A protein and the Escherichia coli rep and SSb proteins catalyze the unwinding of phi X RF I DNA in vitro (Scott, J.F., Eisenberg, S., Bertsch, L.L., and Kornberg, A. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 74, 193-197). Recombinant plasmid G27-4 RF I DNA was also unwound in vitro by this enzyme system; in this case, both circular and linear single-stranded DNA molecules of 667 and 4275 nucleotides, as well as full length circular single-stranded DNA were formed. Full length linear DNA was not detected. The two single-stranded circular DNA products formed as leading strands in RF leads to SS(c) reaction mixtures containing G27-4 RF I DNA differed in their ability to support lagging strand DNA synthesis. It was shown that the large single-stranded circular product included DNA sequences homologous to a replication factor Y effector sequence required for RF leads to RF and SS(c) leads to RF replication (Zipursky, S.L., and Marians, K.J. (1980) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 77, 6521-6525). The 4275-nucleotide, but not the 667-nucleotide, single-stranded circular DNA product was converted to a duplex structure.     

Natural DNA sequences can form left-handed helices in low salt solution under conditions of topological constraint

The conformation of DNA that originates from association of complementary single-stranded circles (form V DNA) is investigated in solution at low salt concentration. It is shown that circular dichroism extended to the far ultraviolet region (down to 165 nm) represents a powerful tool for determination of the handedness of double helical DNAs in solution. The positive intense band at 186 nm followed by a strong negative band around 170 nm is characteristic of all right-handed helical forms (B,A) of DNA, whereas the circular dichroism spectrum of the Z form of poly[d(G-C)] of opposite helical sense represents a quasi inversion of these far ultraviolet bands. Thus, form V DNA is found to represent a co-existence of left-handed Z-type and right-handed B double helical stretches in addition to negative superturns. The Raman spectrum of form V DNA provides further support for the contribution of a left-handed double helical conformation, as shown by comparison to the high resolution Raman spectra of poly[d(G-C)] in the Z and B forms.The analysis of present spectroscopic data and the analysis of occurrence of alternating [d(G-C)] purine-pyrimidine sequences in the form V DNA used strongly suggest that in DNA of natural sequence, topological constraint may generate left-handed double helices, a conformation thought so far to be limited to the alternating [d(G-C)] sequences. Such structure could play a role in recognition and regulation of gene expression.     

Site-specific mutagenesis using synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotide primers: II. In vitro selection of mutant DNA

A method for the in vitro selection of mutant DNA has been devised as an adjunct to the recently developed method for the use of short enzymatically-synthesized oligodeoxyribonucleotides of defined sequence as sitespecific mutagens for circular DNA. The selection method uses the mutating oligodeoxyribonucleotide as a primer for Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (large fragment) under conditions where there is preferential interaction with mutant DNA template. After ligation using T4 DNA ligase, endonuclease Sl is used to degrade single-stranded non-mutant DNA leaving the desired mutant as closed circular duplex DNA. This paper describes the development of the method using mutants in ØX174 DNA as the model system. Studies on the changes A → G and G → A at position 587 of ØX174 viral DNA (am 3 to wild-type and its reversal) show that one or two cycles of selection can lead to a population of phage consisting of close to 100% mutants.     

The enzymatic replication of DNA.

Enzymatic mechanisms of DNA replication have been investigated using small bacteriophages as probes to illuminate the cellular systems upon which they must rely during infection. Conversion of the circular, single-stranded DNAs of phages M13, G4, and phi X174 to their duplex forms has revealed the participation of diverse ways to start a new chain and a complex DNA polymerase III holoenzyme upon which all these systems depend for chain elongation. The phi X174 system, which is the most exacting and revealing of the host chromosomal replication pattern, includes at least twenty polypeptides for making the viral DNA into a duplex and multiplying the duplex. Resolution and purification of these numerous proteins is in train and their reconstitution into a "replisome"-like structure is envisioned.     

Isolation of specific ribosome binding sites from single-stranded DNA.

The ability of Escherichia coli ribosomes to protect small specific regions of single-stranded bacteriophage DNA from digestion by pancreatic DNAase has been investigated. A procedure is described by which ribosome-protected fragments can be isolated from the DNA of bacteriophage f1 and φX174. Size determination by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis or thin layer homochromatography together with fingerprinting analysis following chemical depurination or digestion with E. coli endonuclease IV were employed to show that these fragments represent a small specific portion of these DNAs. The protection reaction is largely dependent upon components necessary for ribosome binding to mRNA, including GTP, formylmethionyl-tRNA, and initiation factors. Thus, ribosomal binding to DNA mimics the ribosome-mRNA interaction. Furthermore, the regions in f1 and φX174 DNA which are protected differ in sequence from each other.When E. coli endonuclease IV is substituted for pancreatic DNAase in the ribosome protection reaction, a fragment of φX174 DNA is obtained about 150 bases in length which contains all of the pyrimidine tracts in the shorter 50-base fragment obtained with pancreatic DNAase, and a number of additional polypyrimidines.Double-stranded DNAs such as φX174 replicative form do not bind at all to ribosomes in their native state. Heat denaturation of such double-stranded DNAs allows ribosome binding. Protection of the same specific regions as those protected in single-stranded φX174 DNA was observed. A similar specific protection was observed following heat denaturation and ribosome binding with DNA from polyoma virus.     

The A* protein of phi X174 is an inhibitor of DNA replication

Extracts prepared from phi X174 infected E. coli cells inhibited in vitro RF replication The inhibition was dependent upon the presence of A* protein in the reaction and served as an assay to highly purify the A* protein. Purified A* protein bound tightly to duplex DNA as well as single-stranded DNA. The binding of the A* protein to duplex DNA inhibited (I) its single-stranded DNA specific endonucleolytic activity; (II) in vitro synthesis of viral (+) single stranded DNA on an A-RFII DNA complex template; (III) ATP hydrolysis by rep protein and unwinding of the strands of RF DNA. We propose that this inhibitory activity is responsible in vivo for the shut off of E. coli chromosome replication during phi X174 infection, and has a role in the transition from semiconservative RF DNA replication to single-stranded DNA synthesis in the life cycle of phi X174.     

Rep protein as a helicase in an active, isolatable replication fork of duplex phi X174 DNA

Rep protein as a helicase combines its actions with those of gene A protein and single-stranded DNA binding protein to separate the strands of phi X174 duplex DNA and thereby can generate and advance a replication fork (Scott, J. F., Eisenberg, S., Bertsch, L. L., and Kornberg, A. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 74, 193-197). Tritium-labeled rep protein is bound in an active gene A protein. phi X174 closed circular duplex supercoiled DNA complex in a 1:1 ratio. Catalytic separation of the strands of the duplex by rep protein, as measured by incorporation of tritium-labeled single-stranded DNA binding protein, requires ATP at a Km value of 8 microM, and hydrolyzes two molecules of ATP for every base pair melted. When coupled to replication in the synthesis of single-strand viral circles, a "looped" rolling-circle intermediate is formed that can be isolated in an active form containing gene A protein, rep protein, single-stranded DNA binding protein, and DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. Unlike the binding of rep protein to single-stranded DNA, where its ATPase activity is distributive, binding to the replicating fork is not affected by ATP, further suggesting a processive action linked to gene A protein. Limited tryptic hydrolysis of rep protein abolishes its replicative activity without affecting significantly its binding of ATP and its ATPase action on single-stranded DNA. These results augment earlier findings by describing the larger role of rep proteins as a helicase, linked in a complex ith other proteins, at the replication fork of a duplex DNA.     

Phi X 174 gene A protein does not cleave at a mouse mitochondrial DNA sequence homologous to the phi X and G4 cleavage site

The light strand origin of replication of mouse mitochondrial DNA contains a 30-nucleotide region which is 60% homologous to the 30-nucleotide conserved sequence in φX174 and G4 viral DNAs known to contain the viral gene A protein cleavage site. Gene A protein does not cleave closed circular mouse mitochondrial DNA under conditions in which φX174 closed circular DNA is cleaved.     

The mechanism of replication of phi X174 single-stranded DNA. II. The role of viral proteins

We have studied the replication of φX174 DNA in Escherichia coli infected with various amber mutants (cistrons I to VII) of φX. Previous research showing that some of these mutants are able to form replicative form (RF) DNA but are unable to produce net amounts of viral progeny single-stranded DNA has been confirmed and extended. Evidence is presented that a defect in any one of four viral cistrons prevents the asymmetric replication of the RF to produce progeny viral DNA. At least four virus-coded proteins, three of which are part of the mature virion, must be present before single-stranded DNA synthesis can even be initiated; the possibility that single-stranded DNA is made and then degraded or converted to RF is eliminated. Mutants in one cistron (II) do permit the asymmetric replication of RF at late times, but the displaced viral strand is incorporated into a defective particle and subsequently may be partially degraded. Both RFI (superhelix) and RFII are present in roughly comparable amounts throughout the normal latent period in infections with wild-type phage or any of the phage mutants.     

In vivo methylation of replicating bacteriophage phi chi174 DNA

The pattern of DNA methylation during the infection of Escherichia coli C cells with bacteriophage φX174, has been studied. In vivo methylated DNA was isolated and analyzed using the following techniques: velocity sedimentation through neutral and alkaline sucrose gradients, isopycnic analysis, chromatography on benzoylated DBAE-cellulose columns and specific enzymatic digestion. All these analytical methods indicated that the DNA molecules that are methylated during the process of phage φX DNA replication are the replicating intermediates composed of a circular complementary strand and a viral strand larger than one genome length. It is concluded that methylation occurs on the nascent DNA strand of the replicating intermediates involved in the synthesis of progeny single-stranded DNA.     

Figure-8 configuration of dimers of S13 and φX174 replicative form DNA

Evidence from electron microscopy of the replicative form of S13 and φX174 DNA shows the presence of a “figure-8” configuration. This species consists of two monomer length and one dimer length circular strands in covalently closed circular form and containing a fused junction that divides the molecule into two equal circular segments. Its existence is supported by the demonstration that it is converted by digestion with the restriction endonuclease of Hemophilus influenzae strain Rd to α- and X-shaped forms that retain the fused junction, and by examination by electron microscopy in the presence of ethidium bromide, which eliminates tangling and accidental overlays of parts of the DNA molecules. Kgure-8s are present to the extent of about 5% of the dimers present in replicative form DNA. They are proposed to be intermediates in genetic recombination in S13 and φX174.     

Extracellular nucleases of Pseudomonas BAL 31. I. Characterization of single strand-specific deoxyriboendonuclease and double-strand deoxyriboexonuclease activities.

The culture medium of Pseudomonas BAL 31 contains endonuclease activities which are highly specific for single-stranged DNA and for the single-stranded or weakly hydrogen-bonded regions in supercoiled closed circular DNA. Exposure of nicked DNA to the culture medium results in cleavage of the strang opposite the sites of preexisting single-strand scissions. At least some of the linear duplex molecules derived by cleavage of supercoiled closed circular molecules contain short single-stranded ends. Single-strand scissions are not introduced into intact, linear duplex DNA or unsupercoiled covalently closed circular DNA. Under these same reaction conditions, 0X174 phage DNA is extensively degraded and PM2 form I DNA is quantitatively converted to PM2 form III linear duplexes. Prolonged exposure of this linear duplex DNA to the concentrated culture medium reveals the presence of a double-strand exonuclease activity that progressively reduces the average length of the linear duplex. These nuclease activities persist at ionic strengths up to 4 M and are not eliminated in the presence of 5% sodium dodecyl sulfate. Calcium and magnesium ion are both required for optimal activity. Although the absence of magnesium ion reduces the activities, the absence of calcium ion irreversibly eliminates all the activities.     

Knotted single-stranded DNA rings: A novel topological isomer of circular single-stranded DNA formed by treatment with Escherichia coli ω protein

Treatment of single-stranded circular phage fd DNA with Escherichia coli ω protein yields a new species which sediments 1.2 to 1.5 times faster than the untreated DNA in an alkaline medium. The infectivity of this species in spheroplast assays, after purification of the DNA by zone sedimentation in an alkaline sucrose gradient, is only slightly lower than that of untreated fd DNA. The formation of this species requires Mg(II) and is strongly dependent on salt concentration and temperature. At 37 °C, over 85% of the input DNA can be converted to this form when incubation is carried out in media containing 0.15 to 0.25 m-salt. The yield decreases with increasing temperature or decreasing salt concentration. The increase in sedimentation coefficient of fd DNA in an alkaline medium following treatment with ω is not due to protein binding, as no change was observed upon treatment of the product with phenol or Pronase. Furthermore, neither the buoyant density of this new species in neutral CsCl nor its sedimentation coefficient in a neutral medium is significantly different from the corresponding properties of untreated fd DNA. Examination by electron microscopy shows that the new form has the appearance of a knotted ring of about the same contour length as an untreated monomeric single-stranded fd DNA. The new form can be converted to full-length linear fd DNA by treatment with pancreatic DNAase I. The rate of conversion is approximately the same as that of untreated circular fd DNA to the linear form. These results show that the new form of fd DNA is a novel topological isomer: a knotted single-stranded DNA ring. It is also found that further treatment of the knotted DNA rings with ω at low ionic strength can reverse the reaction, i.e. the knotted DNA rings can be converted back to simple DNA rings indistinguishable from fd DNA from the phage. At intermediate ionic strength the two forms are interconvertible and form an equilibrium mixture. Results similar to those obtained for fd DNA have also been observed for single-stranded circular φX174 DNA. A mechanism based on the known activity of ω protein on double-stranded DNA, the secondary structure of a single-stranded circular DNA, and the experimental results described here is proposed.     

Fibers of RecA protein and complexes of RecA protein and single-stranded phi X174 DNA as visualized by negative-stain electron microscopy

Monomers of purified RecA protein polymerize into helical fibers whose pitch is 7.2 nm to 7.5 nm and whose diameter is 11 nm. Either short (approximately 0.2 micron), single fibers, or bundles of aligned, longer fibers, can be formed preferentially, by varying the Mg2+ concentration. When RecA protein is bound to circular, single-stranded phi X174 DNA it forms helical fibers of different classes of contour lengths, ranging from 0.98 micron, depending upon the conditions of assembly. Two different helical pitches are found, one of 9.3 nm when the incubation buffer contains, besides the obligatory Mg2+, either ATP gamma S or ATP accompanied by single-strand binding protein, and one of 5.5 nm when the latter additives are omitted. Preformed fibers of the compact type can be converted to open ones of 9.3 nm pitch upon addition of ATP gamma S, even after the removal of unbound RecA. All signs of helicity are obliterated upon glutaraldehyde cross-linking except in those fibers whose assembly has been mediated by ATP gamma S. RecA protein and single-strand binding protein are competitively bound to single-stranded DNA. Composite complexes, however, are not encountered unless ATP gamma S is present. Otherwise, segments of DNA that are coated by one or the other protein are seen as separate regions. When the assembly of complexes of single-stranded DNA and RecA is mediated by single-strand binding protein and ATP, the axial separation between successive bases is 0 X 42 nm, somewhat greater than the axial distance between bases in one strand of duplex DNA in the B form. It is proposed that the bases of the single-stranded DNA in the complex are located near its inner surface, and that base-pairing with double-stranded DNA takes place following invasion of the central cavity of the complex.