AbrB-like transcription factors assume a swapped hairpin fold that is evolutionarily related to double-psi beta barrels

AbrB is a key transition-state regulator of Bacillus subtilis. Based on the conservation of a betaalphabeta structural unit, we proposed a beta barrel fold for its DNA binding domain, similar to, but topologically distinct from, double-psi beta barrels. However, the NMR structure revealed a novel fold, the "looped-hinge helix." To understand this discrepancy, we undertook a bioinformatics study of AbrB and its homologs; these form a large superfamily, which includes SpoVT, PrlF, MraZ, addiction module antidotes (PemI, MazE), plasmid maintenance proteins (VagC, VapB), and archaeal PhoU homologs. MazE and MraZ form swapped-hairpin beta barrels. We therefore reexamined the fold of AbrB by NMR spectroscopy and found that it also forms a swapped-hairpin barrel. The conservation of the core betaalphabeta element supports a common evolutionary origin for swapped-hairpin and double-psi barrels, which we group into a higher-order class, the cradle-loop barrels, based on the peculiar shape of their ligand binding site.     

Common evolutionary origin of swapped-hairpin and double-psi beta barrels

The core of swapped-hairpin and double-psi beta barrels is formed by duplication of a conserved betaalphabeta element, suggesting a common evolutionary origin. The path connecting the two folds is unclear as the two barrels are not interconvertible by a simple topological modification, such as circular permutation. We have identified a protein family whose sequence properties are intermediate to the two folds. The structure of one of these proteins, Pyrococcus horikoshii PhS018, is also built by duplication of the conserved betaalphabeta element but shows yet a third topology, which we name the RIFT barrel. This topology is widespread in the structure database and spans three folds of the SCOP classification, including the middle domain of EF-Tu and the N domain of F1-ATPase. We propose that swapped-hairpin beta barrels arose from an ancestral RIFT barrel by strand invasion and double-psi beta barrels by a strand swap. We group the three barrel types into a metafold, the cradle-loop barrels.     

beta-Trefoil fold. Patterns of structure and sequence in the Kunitz inhibitors interleukins-1 beta and 1 alpha and fibroblast growth factors.

Previous crystallographic analyses of the Kunitz inhibitors from soybean. Erythrina caffra and wheat, the interleukins-1 beta and 1 alpha and the acidic and basic fibroblast growth factors have shown that they contain a most unusual fold. It is formed by six two-stranded hairpins. Three of these form a barrel structure and the other three are in a triangular array that caps the barrel. The arrangement of the secondary structures gives the molecules a pseudo 3-fold axis. Although the different proteins have very similar structures, many of their sequences have no significant similarities overall. The structural determinants of this fold are described and discussed in this paper. The barrels in the different proteins have the same geometrical features: six strands tilted at 56 degrees to the barrel axis; a barrel diameter of 16 A, and the beta-sheet hydrogen bonded so that it is staggered with a shear number of 12. These features fit McLachlan's equations for ideal barrels formed by beta-sheets. The wide diameter of the barrels is filled by layers of residues that, while not identical in the different proteins, are, in almost all cases, large. The structure of the triangular array of hairpins is determined by the coiling of the strands and the packing of hairpin residues against each other and against residues from the interior of the barrel. The major sequence requirements of this fold are large or medium hydrophobic residues at 18 buried sites. In the different structures the total volume of these residues is 3000 (+/- 120) A. The polyhedron model of protein architecture is used to demonstrate that the main, and in particular the symmetrical, features of this fold arise from the ideal and equal packing of six hairpins, modified only slightly to form hydrogen bonds between the hairpins.     

Clusters in alpha/beta barrel proteins: implications for protein structure, function, and folding: a graph theoretical approach

The alpha/beta barrel fold is adopted by most enzymes performing a variety of catalytic reactions, but with very low sequence similarity. In order to understand the stabilizing interactions important in maintaining the alpha/beta barrel fold, we have identified residue clusters in a dataset of 36 alpha/beta barrel proteins that have less than 10% sequence identity within themselves. A graph theoretical algorithm is used to identify backbone clusters. This approach uses the global information of the nonbonded interaction in the alpha/beta barrel fold for the clustering procedure. The nonbonded interactions are represented mathematically in the form of an adjacency matrix. On diagonalizing the adjacency matrix, clusters and cluster centers are obtained from the highest eigenvalue and its corresponding vector components. Residue clusters are identified in the strand regions forming the beta barrel and are topologically conserved in all 36 proteins studied. The residues forming the cluster in each of the alpha/beta protein are also conserved among the sequences belonging to the same family. The cluster centers are found to occur in the middle of the strands or in the C-terminal of the strands. In most cases, the residues forming the clusters are part of the active site or are located close to the active site. The folding nucleus of the alpha/beta fold is predicted based on hydrophobicity index evaluation of residues and identification of cluster centers. The predicted nucleation sites are found to occur mostly in the middle of the strands. Proteins 2001;43:103-112.     

Barrel structures in proteins: automatic identification and classification including a sequence analysis of TIM barrels.

Automated methods for identifying and characterizing regular beta-barrels from coordinate data have been developed to analyze and classify various kinds of barrel structures based on geometric parameters such as the barrel strand number (n) and shear number (S). In total, we find 1,316 barrels in the January 1998 release of Protein Data Bank. Of 1,316 barrels, 1,277 barrels had an even shear number, corresponding to 50 nonhomologous families. The (beta alpha)8 triose phosphate isomerase (TIM) barrel (n = 8, S = 8) fold has the largest number of apparently nonhomologous entries, 16, although the trypsin like antiparallel (n = 6, S = 8) barrels (representing only three families) are the most common with 527 barrels. Of all the protein families that exhibit barrel structures, 68% are found to be various kinds of enzymes, the remainder being binding proteins and transport membrane proteins. In addition, the layers of side chains, which form the cores of barrels with S = n and S = 2n, are also analyzed. More sophisticated methods were developed for detecting TIM barrels specifically, including consideration of the amino acid propensities for the side chains that form the layers. We found that the residues on the outside of the eight stranded parallel beta-barrel, buried by the alpha-helices, are much more hydrophobic than the residues inside the barrel.     

The equilibrium unfolding pathway of a (beta/alpha)8 barrel

The (beta/alpha)(8) barrel is the most commonly occurring fold among enzymes. A key step towards rationally engineering (beta/alpha)(8) barrel proteins is to understand their underlying structural organization and folding energetics. Using misincorporation proton-alkyl exchange (MPAX), a new tool for solution structural studies of large proteins, we have performed a native-state exchange analysis of the prototypical (beta/alpha)(8) barrel triosephosphate isomerase. Three cooperatively unfolding subdomains within the structure are identified, as well as two partially unfolded forms of the protein. The C-terminal domain coincides with domains reported to exist in four other (beta/alpha)(8) barrels, but the two N-terminal domains have not been observed previously. These partially unfolded forms may represent sequential intermediates on the folding pathway of triosephosphate isomerase. The methods reported here should be applicable to a variety of other biological problems involving protein conformational changes.     

Dipole moment in TIM alpha/beta fold proteins

TIM proteins of alpha/beta barrel fold from alpha/beta class as given in SCOP database were taken for dipole moment analysis. In all, 32 structures were analyzed for their dipole moment contributions. Representative structures from 20 super families in the alpha/beta fold, with different enzyme functions and 12 protein domains of TIM family in TIM super family were considered. The active sites of these proteins are located on the C-terminal side of the beta-strands. The molecules of same alpha/beta fold, but differing in their functionality also showed a common electrostatic field pattern along the barrel axis and had the dipole moment along the barrel axis and towards C-terminal end of the beta-strands. However, it is observed from our calculations that the dipole moment direction is possibly a consequence of the structural fold, with distribution of charges playing a modulatory role, and does not contribute to the location of active site. We show here that apart from the commonly held view as proposed by Hol et al [Hol W G L, van Duijnen PT and Berendsen H J C (1978) Nature (London), 273, 443-446] of the role of the alpha helical dipole moment, the beta-sheets in the barrel can also have a considerable dipole moment contribution. Taken together with our dipole moment analysis on integral membrane proteins [Vasanthi G and Krishnaswamy S (2002) Indian J Biochem Biophys 39, 93-100], this suggests the need to examine the role of dipole moment in the case of especially beta sheets forming barrels.     

Gene duplication of the eight-stranded beta-barrel OmpX produces a functional pore: a scenario for the evolution of transmembrane beta-barrels

The repeating unit of outer membrane beta-barrels from Gram-negative bacteria is the beta-hairpin, and representatives of this protein family always have an even strand number between eight and 22. Two dominant structural forms have eight and 16 strands, respectively, suggesting gene duplication as a possible mechanism for their evolution. We duplicated the sequence of OmpX, an eight-stranded beta-barrel protein of known structure, and obtained a beta-barrel, designated Omp2X, which can fold in vitro and in vivo. Using single-channel conductance measurements and PEG exclusion assays, we found that Omp2X has a pore size similar to that of OmpC, a natural 16-stranded barrel. Fusions of the homologous proteins OmpX, OmpA and OmpW were able to fold in vitro in all combinations tested, revealing that the general propensity to form a beta-barrel is sufficient to evolve larger barrels by simple genetic events.     

The design of idealized alpha/beta-barrels: analysis of beta-sheet closure requirements

The 8-fold parallel alpha/beta-barrel topology is encountered in proteins that display an impressive variety of functions, suggesting that this topology may be a rather nonspecific and stable folding motif. Consequently, this motif can be considered as an interesting framework to design novel proteins. It has been shown that the shape of the beta-sheet portion of the barrel can be approximated by a hyperboloid. This geometric object may therefore be used as a scaffold to construct an idealized eight-stranded beta-barrel. To facilitate the de novo design of such structures, a collection of modeling tools has been developed allowing secondary structure elements to be mapped onto the scaffold surface and rotation and translation operations to be performed about user defined axes while evaluating their contribution to the conformational energy of the system. These tools have been applied in a systematic study assessing the phi, psi requirements to design symmetric eight stranded beta barrels with optimal hydrogen bonding between adjacent beta-strands. It is observed that: (a) the beta-sheet structure can be closed without introducing irregular stagger between beta-strands and (b) the region of phi, psi dihedral angle space compatible with the formation of regular symmetric eight stranded beta-barrels coincides with the phi, psi region corresponding to average beta-strands in known protein structures, suggesting that barrel closure does not impose gross constraints on beta-strand geometry.     

Similarity and difference in the unfolding of thermophilic and mesophilic cold shock proteins studied by molecular dynamics simulations

Molecular dynamics simulations were performed to unfold a homologous pair of thermophilic and mesophilic cold shock proteins at high temperatures. The two proteins differ in just 11 of 66 residues and have very similar structures with a closed five-stranded antiparallel beta-barrel. A long flexible loop connects the N-terminal side of the barrel, formed by three strands (beta1-beta3), with the C-terminal side, formed by two strands (beta4-beta5). The two proteins were found to follow the same unfolding pathway, but with the thermophilic protein showing much slower unfolding. Unfolding started with the melting of C-terminal strands, leading to exposure of the hydrophobic core. Subsequent melting of beta3 and the beta-hairpin formed by the first two strands then resulted in unfolding of the whole protein. The slower unfolding of the thermophilic protein could be attributed to ion pair formation of Arg-3 with Glu-46, Glu-21, and the C-terminal. These ion pairs were also found to be important for the difference in folding stability between the pair of proteins. Thus electrostatic interactions appear to play similar roles in the difference in folding stability and kinetics between the pair of proteins.     

Crystal structure of uncleaved L-aspartate-alpha-decarboxylase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

L-aspartate-alpha-decarboxylase (ADC) is a critical regulatory enzyme in the pantothenate biosynthetic pathway and belongs to a small class of self-cleaving and pyruvoyl-dependent amino acid decarboxylases. The expression level of ADC in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) was confirmed by cDNA analysis, immunoblotting with an anti-ADC polyclonal antibody using whole cell lysate and immunoelectron microscopy. The recombinant ADC proenzyme from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MtbADC) was overexpressed in E. coli and the protein structure was determined at 2.99 A resolution. The proteins fold into the double-psi beta-barrel structure. The subunits of the two tetramers (there are eight ADC molecules in the asymmetric unit) form pseudo fourfold rotational symmetry, similar to the E. coli ADC proenzyme structure. As pantothenate is synthesized in microorganisms, plants, and fungi but not in animals, structure elucidation of Mtb ADC is of substantial interest for structure-based drug development.     

Structural principles of alpha/beta barrel proteins: the packing of the interior of the sheet

Alpha/beta barrel structures very similar to that first observed in triose phosphate isomerase are now known to occur in 14 enzymes. To understand the origin of this fold, we analyzed in three of these proteins the geometry of the eight-stranded beta-sheets and the packing of the residues at the center of the barrel. The packing in this region is seen in its simplest form in glycolate oxidase. It consists of 12 residues arranged in three layers. Each layer contains four side chains. The packing of RubisCO and TIM can be understood in terms of distortions of this simple pattern, caused by residues with small side chains at some of the positions inside the barrel. Two classes of packing are found. In one class, to which RubisCO and TIM belong, the central layer is formed by a residue from the first, third, fifth, and seventh strands; the upper and lower layers are formed by residues from the second, fourth, sixth, and eighth strands. In the second class, to which GAO belongs, this is reversed: it is side chains from the even-numbered strands that form the central layer, and side chains from the odd-numbered strands that form the outer layers. Our results suggest that not all proteins with this fold are related by evolution, but that they represent a common favorable solution to the structural problems involved in the creation of a closed beta barrel.     

The importance of surface loops for stabilizing an eightfold beta alpha barrel protein.

An important step in understanding how a protein folds is to determine those regions of the sequence that are critical to both its stability and its folding pathway. We chose phosphoribosyl anthranilate isomerase from Escherichia coli, which is a monomeric representative of the (beta alpha)8 barrel family of proteins, to construct a variant that carries an internal tandem duplication of the fifth beta alpha module. This (beta alpha)9 variant was enzymically active and therefore must have a wild-type (beta alpha)8 core. It had a choice a priori to fold to three different folding frames, which are distinguished by carrying the duplicated segment as an insert into one out of three different loops. Steady-state kinetic constants, the fluorescence properties of a crucial tryptophan residue, and limited proteolysis showed that the stable (beta alpha)9 variant carries the insertion between beta-strand 5 and alpha-helix 5. This preference can be explained by the important role of loops between alpha helices and beta strands in stabilizing the structure of the enzyme.     

NMR solution structure of the archaebacterial chromosomal protein MC1 reveals a new protein fold

The three-dimensional structure of methanogen chromosomal protein 1 (MC1), a chromosomal protein extracted from the archaebacterium Methanosarcina sp. CHTI55, has been solved using (1)H NMR spectroscopy. The small basic protein MC1 contains 93 amino acids (24 basic residues against 12 acidic residues). The main elements of secondary structures are an alpha helix and five beta strands, arranged as two antiparallel beta sheets (a double one and a triple one) packed in an orthogonal manner forming a barrel. The protein displays a largely hydrophilic surface and a very compact hydrophobic core made up by side chains at the interface of the two beta sheets and the helix side facing the interior of the protein. The MC1 solution structure shows a globular protein with overall dimensions in the range of 34-40 A, which potentially corresponds to a DNA-binding site of 10-12 base pairs. The presumed DNA-binding site is located on the sequence comprising residues K62-P82, which is formed by a part of strands II2 and II3 belonging to the triple-stranded antiparallel beta sheet and a loop flanked by prolines P68 and P76. The tryptophan W74 that is expected to play a key role in the DNA-binding according to photocross-linking experiments was found completely exposed to the solvent, in a good position to interact with DNA. The overall fold of MC1, characterized by its linking beta-beta-alpha-beta-beta-loop-beta, is different from other known DNA-binding proteins. Its structure suggests a different DNA-binding mode than those of the histone-like proteins HU or HMGB. Thus, MC1 may be classified as a member of a new family.     

Sequence and structural features of the T-fold, an original tunnelling building unit

A similar fold has been found in four archetype enzymes that perform different functions. This new fold has been named the T-fold because it is found in multimeric proteins crossed by a tunnel. The T-fold consists of an antiparallel beta-sheet of four sequential strands, and two antiparallel helices between the second and third strand, layered on the concave side of the beta-sheet. The presently known T-fold proteins share a high structural similarity (a mean of 1.4 A root mean square (r.m.s.) deviation on the common core) while they only exhibit a low level of sequence identity (a mean of 10.5% on the aligned regions). They bind to substrates belonging to the purine or pterin families, and share a fold-related binding site with a glutamate or glutamine residue anchoring the substrate and a lot of conserved interactions. They also share a similar oligomerization mode: several T-folds join together to form a beta(2n)alpha(n) barrel, then two barrels join together in a head-to-head fashion to made up the native enzymes. The T-fold has the characteristics of a globular domain, with a hydrophobic core and a clearly defined topohydrophobic network. It defines a new class of common folds or recurrent domains found in distantly related proteins. However, it is likely not stable in monomeric form and until now is only observed in association with other T-folds through multimerization. Proteins 2000;39:142-154.     

Infrared dichroism of twisted beta-sheet barrels. The structure of E. coli outer membrane proteins

The infrared dichroic ratios of the amide bands from oriented beta-barrels yield an experimental value for the mean orientation, beta, of the beta-strands, relative to the barrel axis. For a barrel of n strands, this then gives the shear number, S, that characterizes the stagger of the beta-sheet. Combining values of beta and n specifies the barrel geometry by using the optimized model of Murzin, Lesk & Chothia for regular barrels. Application to published infrared data on the Escherichia coli outer membrane protein, OmpA yields S=9-10 (n=8), a barrel radius of 0.81(+/-0.01) nm, and an internal free volume of 0.031 nm(3) per residue, where the average twist of the beta-sheets is theta approximately 28 degrees, and their coiling angle is epsilon approximately 1 degrees. Hydrophobic matching of the 2.6 nm transmembrane stretch partly determines the shear number of the OmpA beta-barrel.     

Structural analysis of the 2.8 A model of Xylose isomerase from Actinoplanes missouriensis

The structure of Xylose isomerase (X.I.) from Actinoplanes missouriensis has been solved to 2.8 Angstroms resolution. Phases were determined from a single Eu3+ derivative and from the noncrystallographic 222 symmetry of the tetrameric molecule. An atomic model was built and subjected to restrained crystallographic refinement. The resulting model is shown to be closely similar to the recently reported X.I.'s structures from three other bacterial sources. Each monomer is found to be composed of an eight-stranded alpha/beta "T.I.M." barrel forming an N-terminal domain of 328 residues followed by a large loop of 66 residues embracing an adjacent subunit. Analysis of intersubunit packing shows that the X.I. tetramer is an assembly of two tight dimers. The beta barrel fits a simple hyperboloid model as other T.I.M. barrels do. The active site, identified as the binding site for the inhibitor xylitol, is located at the carboxyl end of the beta strands in the barrel next to a pair of binding sites for Eu3+ ions, which are assumed to be sites for the divalent ions involved in catalysis. Active sites in the tetramer are oriented towards the interface between dimers. It is suggested that subunit interfaces might stabilize the active site region and this might explain the oligomeric nature of other alpha/beta barrel enzymes.     

Crystal structure of a novel trimethoprim-resistant dihydrofolate reductase specified in Escherichia coli by R-plasmid R67

Crystalline R67 dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) is a dimeric molecule with two identical 78 amino acid subunits, each folded into a beta-barrel conformation. The outer surfaces of the three longest beta strands in each protomer together form a third beta barrel having six strands at the subunit interface. A unique feature of the enzyme structure is that while the intersubunit beta barrel is quite regular over most of its surface, an 8-A "gap" runs the full length of the barrel, disrupting potential hydrogen bonds between beta-strand D in subunit I and the adjacent corresponding strand of subunit II. It is proposed that this deep groove is the NADPH binding site and that the association between protein and cofactor is modulated by hydrogen-bonding interactions along one face of this antiparallel beta-barrel structure. A hypothetical model is proposed for the R67 DHFR-NADPH-folate ternary complex that is consistent with both the known reaction stereoselectivity and the weak binding of 2,4-diamino inhibitors to the plasmid-specified reductase. Geometrical comparison of this model with an experimentally determined structure for chicken DHFR suggests that chromosomal and type II R-plasmid specified enzymes may have independently evolved similar catalytic machinery for substrate reduction.     

Energetic approach to the folding of alpha/beta barrels

The folding of a polypeptide into a parallel (alpha/beta)8 barrel (which is also called a circularly permuted beta 8 alpha 8 barrel) has been investigated in terms of energy minimization. According to the arrangement of hydrogen bonds between two neighboring beta-strands of the central barrel therein, such an alpha/beta barrel structure can be folded into six different types: (1) left-tilted, left-handed crossover; (2) left-tilted, right-handed crossover; (3) nontilted, left-handed crossover; (4) nontilted, right-handed crossover; (5) right-tilted, left-handed crossover; and (6) right-tilted, right-handed crossover. Here "tilt" refers to the orientational relation of the beta-strands to the axis of the central beta-barrel, and "crossover" to the beta alpha beta folding connection feature of the parallel beta-barrel. It has been found that the right-tilted, right-handed crossover alpha/beta barrel possesses much lower energy than the other five types of alpha/beta barrels, elucidating why the observed alpha/beta barrels in proteins always assume the form of right tilt and right-handed crossover connection. As observed, the beta-strands in the energy-minimized right-tilted, right-handed crossover (alpha/beta)8-barrel are of strong right-handed twist. The value of root-mean-square fits also indicates that the central barrel contained in the lowest energy (alpha/beta)8 structure thus found coincides very well with the observed 8-stranded parallel beta-barrel in triose phosphate isomerase (TIM). Furthermore, an energetic analysis has been made demonstrating why the right-tilt, right-handed crossover barrel is the most stable structure. Our calculations and analysis support the principle that it is possible to account for the main features of frequently occurring folding patterns in proteins by means of conformational energy calculations even for very complicated structures such as (alpha/beta)8 barrels.