Behavioural relevance of polarization sensitivity as a target detection mechanism in cephalopods and fishes

Aquatic habitats are rich in polarized patterns that could provide valuable information about the environment to an animal with a visual system sensitive to polarization of light. Both cephalopods and fishes have been shown to behaviourally respond to polarized light cues, suggesting that polarization sensitivity (PS) may play a role in improving target detection and/or navigation/orientation. However, while there is general agreement concerning the presence of PS in cephalopods and some fish species, its functional significance remains uncertain. Testing the role of PS in predator or prey detection seems an excellent paradigm with which to study the contribution of PS to the sensory assets of both groups, because such behaviours are critical to survival. We developed a novel experimental set-up to deliver computer-generated, controllable, polarized stimuli to free-swimming cephalopods and fishes with which we tested the behavioural relevance of PS using stimuli that evoke innate responses (such as an escape response from a looming stimulus and a pursuing behaviour of a small prey-like stimulus). We report consistent responses of cephalopods to looming stimuli presented in polarization and luminance contrast; however, none of the fishes tested responded to either the looming or the prey-like stimuli when presented in polarization contrast.     

Coding of azimuthal directions via time-compensated combination of celestial compass cues

Many animals use the sun as a reference for spatial orientation [1-3]. In addition to sun position, the sky provides two other sources of directional information, a color gradient [4] and a polarization pattern [5]. Work on insects has predominantly focused on celestial polarization as an orientation cue [6, 7]. Relying on sky polarization alone, however, poses the following two problems: E vector orientations in the sky are not suited to distinguish between the solar and antisolar hemisphere of the sky, and the polarization pattern changes with changing solar elevation during the day [8, 9]. Here, we present neurons that overcome both problems in a locust's brain. The spiking activity of these neurons depends (1) on the E vector orientation of dorsally presented polarized light, (2) on the azimuthal, i.e., horizontal, direction, and (3) on the wavelength of an unpolarized light source. Their tuning to these stimuli matches the distribution of a UV/green chromatic contrast as well as the polarization of natural skylight and compensates for changes in solar elevation during the day. The neurons are, therefore, suited to code for solar azimuth by concurrent combination of signals from the spectral gradient, intensity gradient, and polarization pattern of the sky.     

Discriminative responses of squid (Loligo pealeii) photoreceptors to polarized light

Cephalopods behaviorally respond to polarized light. Electrophysiology experiments with the squid, Loligo pealeii, demonstrated that spike responses from individual photoreceptors are a cosine2 function of the e-vector orientation of a polarized stimulus. The discrimination limit to this polarization sensitivity depended upon the difference between the orientation of a polarized stimulus with a preferred e-vector. The limit ranged from 2 degrees to 9.2 degrees with a direct stimulus in the dark or 4.8 degrees -22.1 degrees with non-directed background illumination and the cells were least discriminative at the preferred orientations. This limit can be explained partly by the variability in anatomical alignment of microvilli in the photoreceptors around a dominant axis. A few light-sensitive retinal fibers showed no polarization sensitivity. The coding of polarization information suggests that light intensity is transformed into an average spike rate. This average results from silent periods interspersed between bursts of spikes, each burst possessing a consistent interspike interval. The variations in the length and frequency of silent periods depend upon the difference between the polarization e-vector and a preferred e-vector orientation. The minimal discriminated orientation of a squid photoreceptor agrees well with the minimum behavioral discrimination of polarized light by another cephalopod, the octopus.     

Effects of stimuli shape and polarization in evoking deimatic patterns in the European cuttlefish, Sepia officinalis, under varying turbidity conditions

Cuttlefish possess the complex ability to identify approaching threats and then to selectively express the appropriate defense. We examined the visual cues used by Sepia officinalis cuttlefish during predator detection and the responses they selected. Using computer-generated stimuli, we set out to quantitate the deimatic responses to artificial looming stimuli of different shapes and contrasts. Defensive behavior gradually intensified as geometrical shapes resembled an image of a fish. Therefore, in addition to an object’s size or its sudden increase in size, cuttlefish use form recognition to identify a threat. Cuttlefish demonstrated equal performance in predator detection trough clear water when presented with intensity versus polarization contrasts. However, when the water turbidity increased, the cuttlefish still detected looming fish shapes based on polarization contrast even when intensity information alone did not suffice. These results demonstrate the interplay between intensity and polarization information transmission and processing in the spatial domain. As nectobenthic organisms, cuttlefish probably experience low visibility conditions on a regular basis. The ability to see further into turbid water and to better detect an approaching object would be beneficial for their survival.     

A cellular basis for polarized-light vision in rainbow trout

Polarized light sensitivity was examined in single units of the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) torus semicircularis, a sub-tectal visual area with a high degree of ultraviolet sensitivity. First, chromatically isolated torus units with inputs from each of the four cone mechanisms found in the trout visual system were separately examined for e-vector sensitivity. UV ON-response units showed polarization sensitivity for vertical ly (0° and 180°) polarized stimuli, while ON-response units of the short, middle and long cone mechanisms were not polarization sensitive. No OFF-response units of the UV or short cone mechanism were observed, but OFF-response units of the middle and long cone mechanisms show polarization sensitivity for horizontally (90°) polarized stimuli. Second, e-vector sensitivity was observed in color-coded units which received inputs from more than one cone mechanism and showed different sign responses (ON or OFF) at different points of the spectral sensitivity curve. Biphasic units which had ON input from the UV cone mechanism and OFF inputs from the middle and long cone mechanisms showed polarization opponency. This opponency was observed with a 380 nm stimulus when the threshold sensitivities of the alpha-band absorption peak of the UV mechanism and the beta-band absorption peak of the middle and long cone mechanisms were equal. We believe that biphasic torus units provide a possible cellular basis for polarized light vision in rainbow trout.Abbreviations UV ultraviolet - S short - M middle - L long - PS polarization sensitivity - TS torus semicircularis - ONR optic nerve response     

Spatial orientation of trout to partially polarized light

Summary The results of this study reveal that rainbow trout (Oncorhyncus mykiss formerly Salmo gairdneri) are capable of orienting to polarized light fields, and that the degree of polarization of the polarized light field affects the accuracy of orientation behavior. As previously shown, rainbow trout can accurately orient to a plane polarized light field after several sessions of food-rewarded training. The present data demonstrate that the accuracy of such orientation decreases the degree of polarization of the plane-polarized light field is lowered. In testing sessions, different concentrations of latex beads were introduced into a cuvette positioned below the light source to degrade the degree of polarization. There was evidence that trout could still detect the evector and use it in making orienting responses when the light was only 65% polarized. However, most of the test trout did not demonstrate orienting ability at levels of polarization below the 75% level.     

Light adaptation in Drosophila photoreceptors: I. Response dynamics and signaling efficiency at 25 degrees C

Besides the physical limits imposed on photon absorption, the coprocessing of visual information by the phototransduction cascade and photoreceptor membrane determines the fidelity of photoreceptor signaling. We investigated the response dynamics and signaling efficiency of Drosophila photoreceptors to natural-like fluctuating light contrast stimulation and intracellular current injection when the cells were adapted over a 4-log unit light intensity range at 25 degrees C. This dual stimulation allowed us to characterize how an increase in the mean light intensity causes the phototransduction cascade and photoreceptor membrane to produce larger, faster and increasingly accurate voltage responses to a given contrast. Using signal and noise analysis, this appears to be associated with an increased summation of smaller and faster elementary responses (i.e., bumps), whose latency distribution stays relatively unchanged at different mean light intensity levels. As the phototransduction cascade increases, the size and speed of the signals (light current) at higher adapting backgrounds and, in conjunction with the photoreceptor membrane, reduces the light-induced voltage noise, and the photoreceptor signal-to-noise ratio improves and extends to a higher bandwidth. Because the voltage responses to light contrasts are much slower than those evoked by current injection, the photoreceptor membrane does not limit the speed of the phototransduction cascade, but it does filter the associated high frequency noise. The photoreceptor information capacity increases with light adaptation and starts to saturate at approximately 200 bits/s as the speed of the chemical reactions inside a fixed number of transduction units, possibly microvilli, is approaching its maximum.     

Polarization sensitivity as a contrast enhancer in pelagic predators: lessons from in situ polarization imaging of transparent zooplankton

Because light in the pelagic environment is partially polarized, it has been suggested that the polarization sensitivity found in certain pelagic species may serve to enhance the contrast of their transparent zooplankton prey. We examined its potential during cruises in the Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean and at a field station on the Great Barrier Reef. First, we collected various species of transparent zooplankton and micronekton and photographed them between crossed polarizers. Many groups, particularly the cephalopods, pelagic snails, salps and ctenophores, were found to have ciliary, muscular or connective tissues with striking birefringence. In situ polarization imagery of the same species showed that, while the degree of underwater polarization was fairly high (approx. 30% in horizontal lines of sight), tissue birefringence played little to no role in increasing visibility. This is most likely due to the low radiance of the horizontal background light when compared with the downwelling irradiance. In fact, the dominant radiance and polarization contrasts are due to unpolarized downwelling light that has been scattered from the animal viewed against the darker and polarized horizontal background light. We show that relatively simple algorithms can use this negative polarization contrast to increase visibility substantially.     

Behavioral analysis of polarization vision in tethered flying locusts

For spatial navigation many insects rely on compass information derived from the polarization pattern of the sky. We demonstrate that tethered flying desert locusts (Schistocerca gregaria) show e-vector-dependent yaw-torque responses to polarized light presented from above. A slowly rotating polarizer (5.3° s^–1) induced periodic changes in yaw torque corresponding to the 180° periodicity of the stimulus. Control experiments with a rotating diffuser, a weak intensity pattern, and a stationary polarizer showed that the response is not induced by intensity gradients in the stimulus. Polarotaxis was abolished after painting the dorsal rim areas of the compound eyes black, but remained unchanged after painting the eyes except the dorsal rim areas. During rotation of the polarizer, two e-vectors (preferred and avoided e-vector) induced no turning responses: they were broadly distributed from 0 to 180° but, for a given animal, were perpendicular to each other. The data demonstrate polarization vision in the desert locust, as shown previously for bees, flies, crickets, and ants. Polarized light is perceived through the dorsal rim area of the compound eye, suggesting that polarization vision plays a role in compass navigation of the locust.     

A distinct layer of the medulla integrates sky compass signals in the brain of an insect

Mass migration of desert locusts is a common phenomenon in North Africa and the Middle East but how these insects navigate is still poorly understood. Laboratory studies suggest that locusts are able to exploit the sky polarization pattern as a navigational cue. Like other insects locusts detect polarized light through a specialized dorsal rim area (DRA) of the eye. Polarization signals are transmitted through the optic lobe to the anterior optic tubercle (AOTu) and, finally, to the central complex in the brain. Whereas neurons of the AOTu integrate sky polarization and chromatic cues in a daytime dependent manner, the central complex holds a topographic representation of azimuthal directions suggesting a role as an internal sky compass. To understand further the integration of sky compass cues we studied polarization-sensitive (POL) neurons in the medulla that may be intercalated between DRA photoreceptors and AOTu neurons. Five types of POL-neuron were characterized and four of these in multiple recordings. All neurons had wide arborizations in medulla layer 4 and most, additionally, in the dorsal rim area of the medulla and in the accessory medulla, the presumed circadian clock. The neurons showed type-specific orientational tuning to zenithal polarized light and azimuth tuning to unpolarized green and UV light spots. In contrast to neurons of the AOTu, we found no evidence for color opponency and daytime dependent adjustment of sky compass signals. Therefore, medulla layer 4 is a distinct stage in the integration of sky compass signals that precedes the time-compensated integration of celestial cues in the AOTu.     

Oscillatory depth as a function of temporal frequency

The percept of oscillatory motion in depth was generated by a luminance modulation of a sinusoidal nature induced within each dot pair of a stationary random assembly of paired dots. The dots were miniature sources of polarized light viewed through a rotating ocular polarizer, which facilitated both the percept of oscillations and the modulation of luminance at any desired frequency. Depth responses were studied as a function of frequency within the 0-2 Hz range. A strong amplitude decrease was noticed at a mean frequency of f(1)=0.81 Hz; oscillations were perceived as 'rectified' for f > f(1) with an additional minimum of crossed-disparity depth at f(2)=1.60 Hz. It is suggested that the intensity modulation of the light beams mapping the stationary stimuli onto the retinae was a likely factor responsible for the observed depth minima and the rectification of faster oscillations. Results are compared to those obtained in a traditional setting, where the percept of oscillations in depth had been generated by disparity variations due to lateral motion of the stimuli.     

Integration of Motion Responses Underlying Directional Motion Anisotropy in Human Early Visual Cortical Areas

Recent imaging studies have reported directional motion biases in human visual cortex when perceiving moving random dot patterns. It has been hypothesized that these biases occur as a result of the integration of motion detector activation along the path of motion in visual cortex. In this study we investigate the nature of such motion integration with functional MRI (fMRI) using different motion stimuli. Three types of moving random dot stimuli were presented, showing either coherent motion, motion with spatial decorrelations or motion with temporal decorrelations. The results from the coherent motion stimulus reproduced the centripetal and centrifugal directional motion biases in V1, V2 and V3 as previously reported. The temporally decorrelated motion stimulus resulted in both centripetal and centrifugal biases similar to coherent motion. In contrast, the spatially decorrelated motion stimulus resulted in small directional motion biases that were only present in parts of visual cortex coding for higher eccentricities of the visual field. In combination with previous results, these findings indicate that biased motion responses in early visual cortical areas most likely depend on the spatial integration of a simultaneously activated motion detector chain.     

Structural reactions to polarized light of microvilli in photoreceptor cells of the moth Spodoptera

Summary Intact armyworm moths (Spodoptera exempta, Farn. Noctuidae) were illuminated by polarized monochromatic light to induce structural changes in the rhabdomeres of the compound eyes. The degree of distortion of their microvilli depends on the light energy absorbed per time unit. Under polarized light, the number of quanta absorbed varies with the position of the plane of polarization relative to the axis of the microvilli (intrinsic dichroism). Therefore, in Spodoptera, different degrees of deformations could be demonstrated in differently oriented rhabdomeres of both types of ommatidia. Moreover, in rhabdoms of the lobed type with fan-like arranged microvilli, different reactions were regularly seen in differently oriented microvilli of one rhabdomere. This indicates that microvilli may react to light individually.Supported by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Sonderforschungsbereich 114 (Bionach)     

The structure of the organ of bellonci of the syncarid crustacean,Anaspides tasmaniae (Thomson)

Summary The organ of Bellonci of Anaspides tasmaniae (Thomson) (Crustacea, Syncarida) is described light and electron microscopically, and a few histochemical tests are reported. Located ventrally in the eyestalk below the medulla interna, the organ is composed of a number of cavities. These are similar in structure in their contents and associated cellular components, which include two types of glia cells delimiting each cavity and the terminal parts of a few dendrites. Each dendrite usually bears two cilia, which project into the cavity where they split up into numerous branches. The organ is supplied by three nerve tracts: two from the medulla terminalis and one from the medulla interna. The sensory pore, which is innervated from the medulla interna, is not closely associated with the organ of Bellonci in Anaspides. No marked secretory activity is detectable by histochemical or ultrastructural observations. It is thought that the organ has a sensory function.This investigation was supported by a grant (to T.K.) from Helge Ax:son Johnsons Stiftelse. One of us (P.S.L.) was on sabbatical leave from the University of Tasmania.     

The functional organization of the crayfish lamina ganglionaris

The light responses of the second order lamina monopolar neurons were examined in the crayfish compound eye. Single cartridge monopolar neurons (M1-M4) exhibited nonspiking hyperpolarizing light responses; for M1, M3 and M4 the transient 'on' response operated over the same intensity range as the receptor, 3.5 log units. M2 operated in a much narrower intensity range (1.5 log unit). The 'on' responses were associated with a 19% increase in conductance. The hyperpolarizing 'on' response can be reversed at 18 mV below the resting membrane potential. The half-angular sensitivity width of monopolar cells (in partially dark-adapted eyes) is 15 degrees X 8 degrees (horizontal by vertical). Off axis stimuli elicit attenuated hyperpolarizing responses associated with a diminished conductance increase or depolarizing responses associated with a net decrease in conductance. The latter result is consistent with the presynaptic inhibition of a 'back-ground' transmitter release which normally persists in the dark. Lateral inhibition is elicited from the area immediately surrounding the excitatory field, and it is associated with diminished transient responses and an accelerated decay of the response. Inhibitory stimuli decrease the conductance change associated with the hyperpolarizing response. The surround stimuli can also elicit depolarizing 'off' responses with reversal potentials positive to the membrane resting potential. It is concluded that the rapidly repolarizing monopolar cell response is modulated by both pre- and postsynaptic inhibitory mechanisms. A compartment model indicates that signal attenuation along a 500 microns length of monopolar cell axon is 22-34%. Simulation of steady-state signal transmission suggests that passive (decremental) conduction is sufficient to convey 66 to 78% of the monopolar cell signal from lamina to medulla. The current-voltage relation in current clamp is linear over the physiological operating range, and there is no evidence for rectification. Hyperpolarization of single monopolar cells (M1-M4) provides a polysynaptic excitatory signal to the medullary sustaining fibers.     

Changes in microtubule and microfibril arrangement during polarotropism inAdiantum protonemata

Polarotropism was induced inAdiantum (fern) protonemata grown under polarized red light by turning the electrical vector 45 or 70 degrees. One hour after the light treatment, tropic responses became apparent in many cells as a slight distortion of the apical dome. Changes in the position of the circumferentially-arranged cortical microtubule band (Mt-band) (Murataet al., 1987) and the arrangement of microfibrils around the subapical part of protonemata were investigated in relation to the polarotropic responses. Twenty minutes after turning the electrical vector, preceding the morphological change of cell shape, the Mt-band began to change its orientation from perpendicular to oblique to the initial growing axis. After 30 min, the Mt-band changed its orientation further under 45 degrees polarized light, but under light rotated 70 degrees, it began to disappear. In phototropic responses induced by local irradiation of a side of the subapical part of a protonema with a non-polarized red microbeam, the Mt-band on the irradiated side disappeared or became faint within 20 min, but neither disappearance nor a change of orientation of Mts occurred on the non-irradiated side. One hour after turning the electrical vector 45 degrees, in half of the cells tested, the innermost layer of microfibrils in the subapical part of the protonema changed its orientation from perpendicular to oblique to the growing axis, corresponding to the changes in the orientation of the Mt-band. After 2 hr, those changes were obvious in all cells examined. The same basic results on the orientation of microfibrils were obtained with protonemata cultured for 2 hr under 70 degrees polarized light. The role of the Mt-band in tropic responses is discussed.     

Polarization-based brightness discrimination in the foraging butterfly, Papilio xuthus

The human eye is insensitive to the angular direction of the light e-vector, but several animal species have the ability to discriminate differently polarized lights. How the polarization is detected is often unclear, however. Egg-laying Papilio butterflies have been shown to see false colours when presented with differently polarized lights. Here we asked whether this also holds in foraging butterflies. After training individuals to feed on nectar in front of an unpolarized spectral light, we carried out three dual-choice tests, where the discrimination of (i) the spectral content, (ii) the light intensity, and (iii) the e-vector orientation were investigated. In the first test, the butterflies selected the trained spectrum irrespective of its intensity, and in the second test they chose the light with the higher intensity. The result of the e-vector discrimination test was very similar to that of the second test, suggesting that foraging butterflies discriminate differently polarized lights as differing in brightness rather than as differing in colour. Papilio butterflies are clearly able to use at least two modes of polarization vision depending on the behavioural context.     

Color and polarization vision in foraging Papilio

This paper gives an overview of behavioral studies on the color and polarization vision of the Japanese yellow swallowtail butterfly, Papilio xuthus. We focus on indoor experiments on foraging individuals. Butterflies trained to visit a disk of certain color correctly select that color among various other colors and/or shades of gray. Correct selection persists under colored illumination, but is systematically shifted by background colors, indicating color constancy and simultaneous color contrast. While their eyes contain six classes of spectral receptors, their wavelength discrimination performance indicates that their color vision is tetrachromatic. P. xuthus innately prefers brighter targets, but can be trained to select dimmer ones under certain conditions. Butterflies trained to a dark red stimulus select an orange disk presented on a bright gray background over one on dark gray. The former probably appears darker to them, indicating brightness contrast. P. xuthus has a strong innate preference for vertically polarized light, but the selection of polarized light changes depending on the intensity of simultaneously presented unpolarized light. Discrimination of polarization also depends on background intensity. Similarities between brightness and polarization vision suggest that P. xuthus perceive polarization angle as brightness, such that vertical polarization appears brighter than horizontal polarization.