The problems of eukaryotic and prokaryotic DNA packaging and in vivo conformation posed by superhelix density heterogeneity

Systems for gel electrophoresis in the presence of one of the intercalative unwinding ligands, ethidium or chloroquine, have been developed which permit the resolution of highly supercoiled closed circular DNA molecules differing by unit values of the topological winding number, alpha. All native closed circular DNAs examined, including the viral and intracellular forms of SV40 and polyoma DNA, bacterial plasmid DNAs, and the double stranded closed circular DNA genome of the marine bacteriophage, PM2, are more heterogeneous with respect to the number of superhelical turns present than are the thermal distributions observed in the limit products of the action of nicking-closing (N-C) enzyme on the respective DNAs. In the cases of SV40 and polyoma, where it has been shown that the supercoiling is a combined consequence of the binding of the four nucleosomal histones, H2a, H2b, H3 and H4, and the action of N-C enzyme, the breadth of the distributions within the form I DNAs poses specific problems since the work of other laboratories indicates that the number of nucleosomes on the respective minichromosomes falls within a narrow distribution of 21. If it is assumed that all nucleosomes have identical structures, and that the DNA within a nucleosome is not free to rotate, the native DNA would be anticipated to be less heterogeneous than the thermal equilibrium mixtures present in N-C enzyme relaxed SV40 and polyoma DNAs.The absolute number of superhelical turns (at 37 degrees C in 0.2 M NaCl) in virion polyoma DNA has been determined to be 26 +/- 1, which is the same value obtained for virion SV40 DNA. This is consistent with the observations that polyoma DNA has a higher molecular weight, a lower superhelix density, but the same number of nucleosomes as SV40 DNA. In addition, the distributions within the virion and intracellular form I DNAs of both SV40 and polyoma were found to be indistinguishable.Images     

Effect of salt on the binding of the linker histone H1 to DNA and nucleosomes

The linker histones are involved in the salt-dependent folding of the nucleosomes into higher-order chromatin structures. To better understand the mechanism of action of these histones in chromatin, we studied the interactions of the linker histone H1 with DNA at various histone/DNA ratios and at different ionic strengths. In direct competition experiments, we have confirmed the binding of H1 to superhelical DNA in preference to linear or nicked circular DNA forms. We show that the electrophoretic mobility of the H1/supercoiled DNA complex decreases with increasing H1 concentrations and increases with ionic strengths. These results indicate that the interaction of the linker histone H1 with supercoiled DNA results in a soluble binding of H1 with DNA at low H1 or salt concentrations and aggregation at higher H1 concentrations. Moreover, we show that H1 dissociates from the DNA or nucleosomes at high salt concentrations. By the immobilized template pull-down assay, we confirm these data using the physiologically relevant nucleosome array template.     

Rat liver HMG1: a physiological nucleosome assembly factor.

Incubation of rat liver single-stranded DNA-binding protein HMG1 with the four core histones at 0.15 M NaCl favors histone association primarily into tetramers and, to a lesser extent, into octamers. The assembly of pre-formed histone-HMG1 complexes with DNA yields nucleosome-like subunits which satisfy most of the criteria defining native core particles: (i) the circular DNA extracted from the complexes is supercoiled indicating that the initially relaxed DNA acquired superhelical turns during complex formation in the presence of topoisomerase I; (ii) the digestion of the complexes with micrococcal nuclease yields a DNA fragment of approximately 140 bp in length; (iii) electron microscopy of the reconstituted complexes shows a beaded structure with the DNA wrapped around the histone cores, leading to a reduction in the contour length of the genome compared with free DNA. Moreover, in the presence of HMG1, nucleosome assembly occurs rapidly at 0.15 M NaCl. Therefore, in addition to its DNA-binding properties, HMG1 mediates the assembly of nucleosomes in vitro under conditions of physiological ionic strength. The possible involvement of these properties in the DNA replication process is discussed.     

Multistep chromatin assembly on supercoiled plasmid DNA by nucleosome assembly protein-1 and ATP-utilizing chromatin assembly and remodeling factor

We examine in vitro nucleosome assembly by nucleosome assembly protein-1 (NAP-1) and ATP-utilizing chromatin assembly and remodeling factor (ACF). In contrast to previous studies that used relaxed, circular plasmids as templates, we have found that negatively supercoiled templates reveal the distinct roles of NAP-1 and ACF in histone deposition and the formation of an ordered nucleosomal array. NAP-1 can efficiently deposit histones onto supercoiled plasmids. Furthermore, NAP-1 exhibits a greater affinity for histones H2A-H2B than does naked DNA, but in the presence of H3-H4, H2A-H2B are transferred from NAP-1 to the plasmid templates. These observations underscore the importance of a high affinity between H2A-H2B and NAP-1 for ordered transfer of core histones onto DNA. In addition, recombinant ACF composed of imitation switch and Acf1 can extend closely packed nucleosomes, which suggests that recombinant ACF can mobilize nucleosomes. In the assembly reaction with a supercoiled template, ACF need not be added simultaneously with NAP-1. Regularly spaced nucleosomes are generated even when recombinant ACF is added after core histones are transferred completely onto the DNA. Atomic force microscopy, however, suggests that NAP-1 alone fails to accomplish the formation of fine nucleosomal core particles, which are only formed in the presence of ACF. These results suggest a model for the ordered deposition of histones and the arrangement of nucleosomes during chromatin assembly in vivo.     

Nucleosome assembly in vitro: separate histone transfer and synergistic interaction of native histone complexes purified from nuclei of Xenopus laevis oocytes.

High speed supernatants of Xenopus laevis oocyte nuclei efficiently assemble DNA into nucleosomes in vitro under physiological salt conditions. The assembly activity cofractionates with two histone complexes composed of the acidic protein N1/N2 in complex with histones H3 and H4, and nucleoplasmin in complex with histones H2B and H2A. Both histone complexes have been purified and their nucleosome assembly activities have been analysed separately and in combination. While the histones from the N1/N2 complexes are efficiently transferred to DNA and induce supercoils into relaxed circular plasmid DNA, the nucleoplasmin complexes show no supercoil induction, but can also transfer their histones to DNA. In combination, the complexes act synergistically in supercoil induction thereby increasing the velocity and the number of supercoils induced. Electron microscopic analysis of the reaction products shows fully packaged nucleoprotein structures with the typical nucleosomal appearance resulting in a compaction ratio of 2.8 under low ionic strength conditions. The high mobility group protein HMG-1, which is also present in the soluble nuclear homogenate from X. laevis oocytes, is not required for nucleosome core assembly. Fractionation experiments show that the synergistic effect in the supercoiling reaction can be exerted by histones H3 and H4 bound to DNA and the nucleoplasmin complexes alone. This indicates that it is not the synchronous action of both complexes which is required for nucleosome assembly, but that their cooperative action can be resolved into two steps: deposition of H3 and H4 from the N1/N2 complexes onto the DNA and completion of nucleosome core formation by addition of H2B and H2A from the nucleoplasmin complexes.     

RNA sequences specifically associated with mouse intracisternal A particles.

Electron microscopic examination of the histone H1-depleted, folded genomes of Drosophila melanogaster reveals that they are composed of long cylindrical cables of about 100 Å diameter. Limited single-strand nicking with DNAase I relaxes the 100 Å fibers to a “beads-on-a-string” structure, showing the nucleosomes and internucleosome DNA.Based on these results and other available data, we have constructed a detailed space-filling model for the higher order DNA coiling in chromatin, starting with the symmetrical nucleosome core previously described (Weintraub, Worcel and Alberts, 1976). The model defines the path of the DNA helix and the nucleosome arrangement along the DNA coil for both the 100 Å and the 200–300 Å fibers.Following Sobell et al. (1976), we believe that the DNA is coiled in the 100 Å nucleofilament in a uniform left-handed supercoil of about 90 base pairs (bp) per turn and 47 Å pitch; the 140 bp symmetrical nucleosome cores align themselves along this uniform DNA superhelix so that the isologous outer surfaces of adjacent nucleosomes touch and the internucleosome spacer DNA coils between them. A few single-strand discontinuities [about one nick per 85 kilobases (kb); Benyajati and Worcel, 1976] in the H1-depleted 100 Å fiber can thus relax the negatively supercoiled internucleosome DNA generating the “beads-on -a-string” appearance.We propose that histone H1 binds to the 100 Å diameter superhelix and coils it into tightly packed, 110 Å pitch super-superhelices (“solenoids;” Finch and Klug, 1976) of variable diameter (between 200–300 Å). In our model, the “thick” 200–300 Å fiber is stabilized at metaphase by histone H1-H1 heterologous interactions between adjacent helical turns of the nucleofilament, and the internucleosome spacer DNA is located on the outside. Symmetry considerations demand that changes in the length of the repeat should lead to variations in the number of nucleosomes per helical turn and in the handedness of these turns in the 200–300 Å metaphase fiber.     

Supercoiling energy and nucleosome formation: the role of the arginine-rich histone kernel.

We have formed complexes of relaxed closed circular Col E1 DNA with various combinations of histones, and examined the effects of treating the complexes with nicking-closing enzyme. Germond et al (1) have shown that when a mixture of the four core histones of the nucleosome (HIA, H2B, H3 and H4) is used in such an experiment, the subsequently isolated DNA is supercoiled. We find that the arginine-rich histone pair, H3 and H4, is sufficient to induce the supercoiling observed in this experiment. Both H3 and H4 are required, and in the absence of either, no other histones are effective. H3 and and H4 are as efficient, per unit weight, as a mixture of the four histones in inducing supercoils. We also show that there is a large difference between the DNA bending energy needed to form a nucleosome and that needed to form one turn of normal superhelical DNA. These two processes are energetically quite distinct and probably separable. We estimate the free energy of interaction between DNA-bound histone pairs, and find that one or two such interactions would generate enough energy to fold the DNA into a nucleosome.     

H1 histone, polylysine and spermine facilitate nucleosome assembly in vitro

Nucleosome formation has been studied in a system containing relaxed Col E1 DNA, core histones and an extract of Drosophila embryos. The formation of nucleosomes was established by the introduction of supercoils into DNA. The degree of DNA supercoiling was shown to be higher if nucleosomes were assembled in the presence of the H1 histone, polylysine (Mr 20 000) or spermine. These agents do not stimulate relaxation and are the more effective the earlier they are added to the reaction. Thus, the H1 histone, polylysine and spermine facilitate nucleosome assembly in vitro.     

Supercoiled DNA folded by nonhistone proteins in cultured mouse carcinoma cells.

Upon gentle lysis of exponentially growing mouse carcinoma cells FM3A by sodium dodecyl sulfate, DNA was released as a "DNA-protein complex" in a folded conformation. No histones could be detected in the DNA-protein complex. The proteins bound to DNA were found to be composed of several kinds of nonhistone proteins with a molecular weight range of 50,000 to 60,000; they appear to play a key role in stabilizing and maintaining the compact and folded structure of the complex. Removal of the proteins by Pronase or 2-mercaptoethanol produced a more relaxed structure sedimenting about half as fast as the original complex in a neutral sucrose gradient. DNA in the folded complex is supercoiled, as indicated by the characteristic biphasic response of its sedimentation rate to increasing concentration of various intercalating agents, actinomycin D, ethidium bromide and acriflavine, with which the cells were treated before lysis. Pronase- or 2-mercaptoethanol-treated relaxed DNA still possessed the characteristic of closed-circular structure as judged from its response to intercalating agents. Nicking with gamma-ray or 4NQO broke these superhelical turns and relaxed the folded complex to slower sedimenting forms equivalent to the relaxed DNA obtained on treatment with Pronase or 2-mercaptoethanol. Viscometric observations of DNA-protein complex were consistent with the above results. A tentative model for the structure of this DNA-protein complex is proposed in which supercoiled DNA is folded into loops by several kinds of nonhistone proteins. Autoradiographic examination of the complex appeared to support this model.     

The number of superhelical turns in native virion SV40 DNA and minicol DNA determined by the band counting method.

By a method of overlapping the results obtained after agarose gel electrophoresis under two different sets of conditions, it has become possible to determine the number of superhelical turns in a given DNA by counting the bands present after partially relaxing the DNA (Keller and Wendel, 1974) with highly purified nicking-closing (N-C) enzyme from LA9 mouse cell nuclei. Because native supercoiled DNA is heterogeneous with respect to superhelix density, an average number of superhelical turns was determined. Virion SV40 DNA contains 26 +/- 0.5 superhelical turns, and native Minicol DNA contains 19 +/- 0.5 superhelical turns. The above are values at 0.2 M NaCl and at 37 degrees C, the condition under which the enzymatic relaxations were performed. The superhelix densities determined by the band counting method have been compared with superhelix densities determined by buoyant equilibrium in PDl-CsCl gradients. The Gray, Upholt, and Vinograd (1971) calculation procedure has been used for evaluating the superhelix densities by the latter method with the new statement, however, that relaxed DNA has zero superhelical turns. Comparison of the superhelix densities obtained by both methods permits a calculation of an unwinding angle for ethidium. The mean value from experiments with SV40 DNA is 23 +/- 3 degree. The average number of superhelical turns in SV40, 26, combined with the value, 21, obtained by both Griffith (1975) and Germond et al. (1975) for the average number of nucleosomes per SV40 genome, yields an average of 1.25 superhelical turns per 1/21 of the SV40 genome. If the regions of internucleosomal DNA are fully relaxed, 1.25 correesponds to the average number of superhelical turns with a nucleosome. When analyzed under identical conditions, the limit product generated by ligating a nicked circular substrate in the presence of 0.001 M Mg2+ at 37 degrees C (ligation conditions) is slightly more positively supercoiled than the limit product obtained when the N-C reaction is performed in 0.2 M NaCl at 37 degrees C. The difference in superhelix density as measured in gels between the two sets of limit products for both Minicol and SV40 DNAs is 0.0059 +/- 0.0005. This result indicates that the DNA duplex is overwound in the ligation solvent relative to its state in 0.2 M NaCl.     

Histone H1, polylysine and spermine--factors of nucleosome assembly in vitro

We studied nucleosome assemble in vitro in a system containing the relaxed DNA CoIE1, core histones and a crude extract Drosophila embryos. Supercoiling is a criterium for making conclusions about forming nucleosomes. Supercoiling raises more if nucleosome assemble takes place in the presence of histone H1, polylysine of the 20 000 molecular weight or spermine. These agents do not stimulate the relaxation, and they are more effective when they are added earlier. Thus histone H1, spermine and polylysine can facilitate nucleosome assemble in vitro and with two former agents it may be possibly that the same process takes place in vivo.     

DNA gyrase can supercoil DNA circles as small as 174 base pairs.

DNA gyrase introduces negative supercoils into closed-circular DNA using the free energy of ATP hydrolysis. Consideration of steric and thermodynamic aspects of the supercoiling reaction indicates that there should be a lower limit to the size of DNA circle which can be supercoiled by gyrase. We have investigated the supercoiling reaction of circles from 116-427 base pairs (bp) in size and have determined that gyrase can supercoil certain relaxed isomers of circles as small as 174 bp, dependent on the final superhelix density of the supercoiled product. Furthermore, this limiting superhelical density (-0.11) is the same as that determined for the supercoiling of plasmid pBR322. We also find that although circles in the range 116-152 bp cannot be supercoiled, they can nevertheless be relaxed by gyrase when positively supercoiled. These data suggest that the conformational changes associated with the supercoiling reaction can be carried out by gyrase in a circle as small as 116 bp. We discuss these results with respect to the thermodynamics of DNA supercoiling and steric aspects of the gyrase mechanism.     

Histone stoichiometry and DNA circularization in archaeal nucleosomes.

Recombinant (r)HMfB (archaealhistone B fromMethanothermusfervidus) formed complexes with increasing stability with DNA molecules increasing in length from 52 to 100 bp, but not with a 39 bp molecule. By using125I-labeled rHMfB-YY (an rHMfB variant with I31Y and M35Y replacements) and32P-labeled 100 bp DNA, these complexes, designated archaeal nucleosomes, have been shown to contain an archaeal histone tetramer. Consistent with DNA bending and wrapping, addition of DNA ligase to archaeal nucleosomes assembled with 88 and 128 bp DNAs resulted in covalently-closed monomeric circular DNAs which, following histone removal, were positively supercoiled based on their electrophoretic mobilities in the presence of ethidium bromide before and after relaxation by calf thymus topoisomerase I. Ligase addition to mixtures of rHMfB with 53 or 30 bp DNA molecules also resulted in circular DNAs but these were circular dimers and trimers. These short DNA molecules apparently had to be ligated into longer linear multimers for assembly into archaeal nucleosomes and ligation into circles. rHMfB assembled into archaeal nucleosomes at lower histone to DNA ratios with the supercoiled, circular ligation product than with the original 88 bp linear version of this molecule. Archaeal histones are most similar to the globular histone fold region of eukaryal histone H4, and the results reported are consistent with archaeal nucleosomes resembling the structure formed by eukaryal histone (H3+H4)2tetramers.     

Assembly of nucleosome-like structures mediated by cauliflower DNA topoisomerase

Nucleosome-like structures have been efficiently assembled in vitro by interaction of cauliflower histones, pBR322 DNA and cauliflower DNA topoisomerase, as assayed by supercoiling of relaxed circular DNA and by digestion with micrococcal nuclease. The optimum ionic strength for supercoiling was 150 mM KCl and the optimum weight ratio of histone to DNA was approximately 1.0. Four histones, H2A, H2B, H3 and H4, were necessary for the optimum assembling conditions, and the nucleosomes assembled protected DNA fragments of approximately 150 bp in length. It was found that cauliflower DNA topoisomerase acts not only as a DNA-relaxing enzyme but also as a chaperon factor for nucleosome assembly.     

Novel nucleosomal particles containing core histones and linker DNA but no histone H1

Eukaryotic chromosomal DNA is assembled into regularly spaced nucleosomes, which play a central role in gene regulation by determining accessibility of control regions. The nucleosome contains ∼147 bp of DNA wrapped ∼1.7 times around a central core histone octamer. The linker histone, H1, binds both to the nucleosome, sealing the DNA coils, and to the linker DNA between nucleosomes, directing chromatin folding. Micrococcal nuclease (MNase) digests the linker to yield the chromatosome, containing H1 and ∼160 bp, and then converts it to a core particle, containing ∼147 bp and no H1. Sequencing of nucleosomal DNA obtained after MNase digestion (MNase-seq) generates genome-wide nucleosome maps that are important for understanding gene regulation. We present an improved MNase-seq method involving simultaneous digestion with exonuclease III, which removes linker DNA. Remarkably, we discovered two novel intermediate particles containing 154 or 161 bp, corresponding to 7 bp protruding from one or both sides of the nucleosome core. These particles are detected in yeast lacking H1 and in H1-depleted mouse chromatin. They can be reconstituted in vitro using purified core histones and DNA. We propose that these ‘proto-chromatosomes’ are fundamental chromatin subunits, which include the H1 binding site and influence nucleosome spacing independently of H1.     

Development of a fluorescent probe for the study of nucleosome assembly and dynamics

To develop a probe for use in real-time dynamic studies of nucleosomes, core histones (from Drosophila) were conjugated to a DNA-intercalating dye, thiazole orange, by a reaction targeting Cys 110 of histone H3. In the absence of DNA, the conjugated histones are only very weakly fluorescent. However, upon reconstitution into nucleosomes by standard salt dialysis procedures, the probe fluoresces strongly, reflecting its ability to intercalate into the nucleosomal DNA. The probe is also sensitive to the nature of the DNA-histone interaction. Nucleosomes reconstituted by stepwise salt dialysis give a fluorescence signal quite different from that of the species formed when DNA and histones are simply mixed in low salt. In addition, changing either the DNA length or the type of sequence (nucleosome positioning sequences versus random DNA of the same size) used in the reconstitution alters the resulting fluorescence yield. The results are all consistent with the conclusion that a more rigid, less flexible nucleosome structure results in less fluorescence than a looser structure, presumably due to structural constraints on dye intercalation. This probe should be well suited to analyzing nucleosome dynamics and to following factor-mediated assembly and remodeling of nucleosomes in real time, particularly at the single-molecule level.