Leaf quality and insect herbivory in model tropical plant communities after long-term exposure to elevated atmospheric CO2

Results from laboratory feeding experiments have shown that elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide can affect interactions between plants and insect herbivores, primarily through changes in leaf nutritional quality occurring at elevated CO₂. Very few data are available on insect herbivory in plant communities where insects can choose among species and positions in the canopy in which to feed. Our objectives were to determine the extent to which CO₂-induced changes in plant communities and leaf nutritional quality may affect herbivory at the level of the entire canopy. We introduced equivalent populations of fourth instar Spodoptera eridania, a lepidopteran generalist, to complex model ecosystems containing seven species of moist tropical plants maintained under low mineral nutrient supply. Larvae were allowed to feed freely for 14 days, by which time they had reached the seventh instar. Prior to larval introductions, plant communities had been continuously exposed to either 340 l CO₂ l^–1 or to 610 l CO₂ l^–1 for 1.5 years. No major shifts in leaf nutritional quality [concentrations of N, total non-structural carbohydrates (TNC), sugar, and starch; ratios of: C/N, TNC/N, sugar/N, starch/N; leaf toughness] were observed between CO₂ treatments for any of the species. Furthermore, no correlations were observed between these measures of leaf quality and leaf biomass consumption. Total leaf area and biomass of all plant communities were similar when caterpillars were introduced. However, leaf biomass of some species was slightly greater-and for other species slightly less (e.g. Cecropia peltata)-in communities exposed to elevated CO₂. Larvae showed the strongest preference for C. peltata leaves, the plant species that was least abundant in all communites, and fed relatively little on plants species which were more abundant. Thus, our results indicate that leaf tissue quality, as described by these parameters, is not necessarily affected by elevated CO₂ under relatively low nutrient conditions. Hence, the potential importance of CO₂-induced shifts in leaf nutritional quality, as determinants of herbivory, may be overestimated for many plant communities growing on nutrient-poor sites if estimates are based on traditional laboratory feeding studies. Finally, slight shifts in the abundance of leaf tissue of various species occurring under elevated CO₂ will probably not significantly affect herbivory by generalist insects. However, generalist insect herbivores appear to become more dependent on less-preferred plant species in cases where elevated CO₂ results in reduced availability of leaves of a favoured plant species, and this greater dependency may eventually affect insect populations adversely.     

Effects of elevated CO2 and O3 on leaf damage and insect abundance in a soybean agroecosystem

By altering myriad aspects of leaf chemistry, increasing concentrations of CO₂ and O₃ in the atmosphere derived from human activities may fundamentally alter the relationships between insect herbivores and plants. Because exposure to elevated CO₂ can alter the nutritional value of leaves, some herbivores may increase consumption rates to compensate. The effects of O₃ on leaf nutritional quality are less clear; however, increased senescence may also reduce leaf quality for insect herbivores. Additionally, changes in secondary chemistry and the microclimate of leaves may render plants more susceptible to herbivory in elevated CO₂ and O₃. Damage to soybean (Glycine max L.) leaves and the size and composition of the insect community in the plant canopy were examined in large intact plots exposed to elevated CO₂ (~550 μmol mol⁻¹) and elevated O₃ (1.2*ambient) in a fully factorial design with a Soybean Free Air Concentration Enrichment system (SoyFACE). Leaf area removed by folivorous insects was estimated by digital photography and insect surveys were conducted during two consecutive growing seasons, 2003 and 2004. Elevated CO₂ alone and in combination with O₃ increased the number of insects and the amount of leaf area removed by insect herbivores across feeding guilds. Exposure to elevated CO₂ significantly increased the number of western corn rootworm (Diabrotica virgifera) adults (foliage chewer) and soybean aphids (Aphis glycines; phloem feeder). No consistent effect of elevated O₃ on herbivory or insect population size was detected. Increased loss of leaf area to herbivores was associated with increased carbon-to-nitrogen ratio and leaf surface temperature. Soybean aphids are invasive pests in North America and new to this ecosystem. Higher concentrations of CO₂ in the atmosphere may increase herbivory in the soybean agroecosystem, particularly by recently introduced insect herbivores. Handling editor: Gary Felton.     

Seeing the forest for the trees: long-term exposure to elevated CO2 increases some herbivore densities

The effects of elevated CO₂ on plant growth and insect herbivory have been frequently investigated over the past 20 years. Most studies have shown an increase in plant growth, a decrease in plant nitrogen concentration, an increase in plant secondary metabolites and a decrease in herbivory. However, such studies have generally overlooked the fact that increases in plant production could cause increases of herbivores per unit area of habitat. Our study investigated leaf production, herbivory levels and herbivore abundance per unit area of leaf litter in a scrub‐oak system at Kennedy Space Center, Florida, under conditions of ambient and elevated CO₂, over an 11‐year period, from 1996 to 2007. In every year, herbivory, that is leafminer and leaftier abundance per 200 leaves, was lower under elevated CO₂ than ambient CO₂ for each of three species of oaks, Quercus myrtifolia, Quercus chapmanii and Quercus geminata. However, leaf litter production per 0.1143 m² was greater under elevated CO₂ than ambient CO₂ for Q. myrtifolia and Q. chapmanii, and this difference increased over the 11 years of the study. Leaf production of Q. geminata under elevated CO₂ did not increase. Leafminer densities per 0.1143 m² of litterfall for Q. myrtifolia and Q. chapmanii were initially lower under elevated CO₂. However, shortly after canopy closure in 2001, leafminer densities per 0.1143 m² of litter fall became higher under elevated CO₂ and remained higher for the remainder of the experiment. Leaftier densities per 0.1143 m² were also higher under elevated CO₂ for Q. myrtifolia and Q. chapmanii over the last 6 years of the experiment. There were no differences in leafminer or leaftier densities per 0.1143 m² of litter for Q. geminata. These results show three phenomena. First, they show that elevated CO₂ decreases herbivory on all oak species in the Florida scrub‐oak system. Second, despite lower numbers of herbivores per 200 leaves in elevated CO₂, increased leaf production resulted in higher herbivore densities per unit area of leaf litter for two oak species. Third, they corroborate other studies which suggest that the effects of elevated CO₂ on herbivores are species specific, meaning they depend on the particular plant species involved. Two oak species showed increases in leaf production and herbivore densities per 0.1143 m² in elevated CO₂ over time while another oak species did not. Our results point to a future world of elevated CO₂ where, despite lower plant herbivory, some insect herbivores may become more common.     

Effects of elevated CO2 and increased nitrogen deposition on photosynthesis and growth of understory plants in spruce model ecosystems

We studied the effects of atmospheric CO₂ enrichment (280, 420 and 560 l CO₂ l^–1) and increased N deposition (0,30 and 90 kg ha^–1 year^–1) on the spruce-forest understory species Oxalis acetosella, Homogyne alpina and Rubus hirtus. Clones of these species formed the ground cover in nine 0.7 m² model ecosystems with 5-year-old Picea abies trees (leaf area index of approx 2.2). Communities grew on natural forest soil in a simulated montane climate. Independently of N deposition, the rate of light-saturated net photosynthesis of leaves grown and measured at 420 l CO₂ l^–1 was higher in Oxalis and in Homogyne, but was not significantly different in Rubus compared to leaves grown and measured at the pre-industrial CO₂ concentration of 280 l l^–1. Remarkably, further CO₂ enrichment to 560 l l^–1 caused no additional increase of CO₂ uptake. With increasing CO₂ supply concentrations of non-structural carbohydrates in leaves increased and N concentrations decreased in all species, whereas N deposition had no significant effect on these traits. Above-ground biomass and leaf area production were not significantly affected by elevated CO₂ in the more vigorously growing species O. acetosella and R. hirtus, but the slow growing H. alpina produced almost twice as much biomass and 50% more leaf area per plant under 420 l CO₂ l^–1 compared to 280 l l^–1 (again no further stimulation at 560 l l^–1). In contrast, increased N addition stimulated growth in Oxalis and Rubus but had no effect on Homogyne. In Oxalis (only) biomass per plant was positively correlated with microhabitat quantum flux density at low CO₂, but not at high CO₂ indicating carbon saturation. On the other hand, the less shade-tolerant Homogyne profited from CO₂ enrichment at all understory light levels facilitating its spread into more shady micro-habitats under elevated CO₂. These species-specific responses to CO₂ and N deposition will affect community structure. The non-linear responses to elevated CO₂ of several of the traits studied here suggest that the largest responses to rising atmospheric CO₂ are under way now or have already occurred and possible future responses to further increases in CO₂ concentration are likely to be much smaller in these understory species.     

Leaf δ13C in Pinus resinosa trees and understory plants: variation associated with light and CO2 gradients

 Our objective was to evaluate the relative importance of gradients in light intensity and the isotopic composition of atmospheric CO₂ for variation in leaf carbon isotope ratios within a Pinus resinosa forest. In addition, we measured photosynthetic gas exchange and leaf carbon isotope ratios on four understory species (Dryopteris carthusiana, Epipactus helleborine, Hieracium floribundum, Rhamnus frangula), in order to estimate the consequence of the variation in the understory light microclimate for carbon gain in these plants. During midday, CO₂ concentration was relatively constant at vertical positions ranging from 15 m to 3 m above ground. Only at positions below 3 m was CO₂ concentration significantly elevated above that measured at 15 m. Based on the strong linear relationship between changes in CO₂ concentration and δ¹³C values for air samples collected during a diurnal cycle, we calculated the expected vertical profile for the carbon isotope ratio of atmospheric CO₂ within the forest. These calculations indicated that leaves at 3 m height and above were exposed to CO₂ of approximately the same isotopic composition during daylight periods. There was no significant difference between the daily mean δ¹³C values at 15 m (–7.77‰) and 3 m (–7.89‰), but atmospheric CO₂ was significantly depleted in ¹³C closer to the ground surface, with daily average δ¹³C values of –8.85‰ at 5 cm above ground. The light intensity gradient in the forest was substantial, with average photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) on the forest floor approximately 6% of that received at the top of the canopy. In contrast, there were only minor changes in air temperature, and so it is likely that the leaf-air vapour pressure difference was relatively constant from the top of the canopy to the forest floor. For red pine and elm tree samples, there was a significant correlation between leaf δ¹³C value and the height at which the leaf sample was collected. Leaf tissue sampled near the forest floor, on average, had lower δ¹³C values than samples collected near the top of the canopy. We suggest that the average light intensity gradient through the canopy was the major factor influencing vertical changes in tree leaf δ¹³C values. In addition, there was a wide range of variation (greater than 4‰) among the four understory plant species for average leaf δ¹³C values. Measurements of leaf gas exchange, under natural light conditions and with supplemental light, were used to estimate the influence of the light microclimate on the observed variation in leaf carbon isotope ratios in the understory plants. Our data suggest that one species, Epipactus helleborine, gained a substantial fraction of carbon during sunflecks. Received: 21 March 1996 / Accepted: 13 August 1996     

Influence of elevated CO2 on canopy development and red:far-red ratios in two-storied stands ofRicinus communis

Vertical structure of plant stands and canopies may change under conditions of elevated CO₂ due to differential responses of overstory and understory plants or plant parts. In the long term, seedling recruitment, competition, and thus population or community structure may be affected. Aside from the possible differential direct effects of elevated CO₂ on photosynthesis and growth, both the quantity and quality of the light below the overstory canopy could be indirectly affected by CO₂-induced changes in overstory leaf area index (LAI) and/or changes in overstory leaf quality. In order to explore such possible interactions, we compared canopy leaf area development, canopy light extinction and the quality of light beneath overstory leaves of two-storied monospecific stands ofRicinus communis exposed to ambient (340 μl l⁻¹) and elevated (610 μl l⁻¹) CO₂. Plants in each stand were grown in a common soil as closed “artificial ecosystems” with a ground area of 6.7 m². LAI of overstory plants in all ecosystems more than doubled during the experiment but was not different between CO₂ treatments at the end. As a consequence, extinction of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) was also not altered. However, under elevated CO₂ the red to far-red ratio (R:FR) measured beneath overstory leaves was 10% lower than in ecosystems treated with ambient CO₂. This reduction was associated with increased thickness of palisade layers of overstory leaves and appears to be a plausible explanation for the specific enhancement of stem elongation of understory plants (without a corresponding biomass response) under elevated CO₂. CO₂ enrichment led to increased biomass of overstory plants (mainly stem biomass) but had no effect on understory biomass. The results of this study raise the possibility of an important indirect effect of elevated CO₂ at the stand-level. We suggest that, under elevated CO₂, reductions in the R:FR ratio beneath overstory canopies may affect understory plant development independently of the effects of PAR extinction.     

Will chemical defenses become more effective against specialist herbivores under elevated CO2?

Elevated atmospheric CO₂ is known to affect plant–insect herbivore interactions. Elevated CO₂ causes leaf nitrogen to decrease, the ostensible cause of herbivore compensatory feeding. CO₂ may also affect herbivore consumption by altering chemical defenses via changes in plant hormones. We considered the effects of elevated CO₂, in conjunction with soil fertility and damage (simulated herbivory), on glucosinolate concentrations of mustard (Brassica nigra) and collard (B. oleracea var. acephala) and the effects of leaf nitrogen and glucosinolate groups on specialist Pieris rapae consumption. Elevated CO₂ affected B. oleracea but not B. nigra glucosinolates; responses to soil fertility and damage were also species‐specific. Soil fertility and damage also affected B. oleracea glucosinolates differently under elevated CO₂. Glucosinolates did not affect P. rapae consumption at either CO₂ concentration in B. nigra, but had CO₂‐specific effects on consumption in B. oleracea. At ambient CO₂, leaf nitrogen had strong effects on glucosinolate concentrations and P. rapae consumption but only gluconasturtiin was a feeding stimulant. At elevated CO₂, direct effects of leaf nitrogen were weaker, but glucosinolates had stronger effects on consumption. Gluconasturtiin and aliphatic glucosinolates were feeding stimulants and indole glucosinolates were feeding deterrents. These results do not support the compensatory feeding hypothesis as the sole driver of changes in P. rapae consumption under elevated CO₂. Support for hormone‐mediated CO₂ response (HMCR) was mixed; it explained few treatment effects on constitutive or induced glucosinolates, but did explain patterns in SEMs. Further, the novel feeding deterrent effect of indole glucosinolates under elevated CO₂ in B. oleracae underscores the importance of defensive chemistry in CO₂ response. We speculate that P. rapae indole glucosinolate detoxification mechanisms may have been overwhelmed under elevated CO₂ forcing slowed consumption. Specialists may have to contend with hosts with poorer nutritional quality and more effective chemical defenses under elevated CO₂.     

Consequences of elevated temperature and pCO2 on insect folivory at the ecosystem level: perspectives from the fossil record

Paleoecological studies document the net effects of atmospheric and climate change in a natural laboratory over timescales not accessible to laboratory or ecological studies. Insect feeding damage is visible on well‐preserved fossil leaves, and changes in leaf damage through time can be compared to environmental changes. We measured percent leaf area damaged on four fossil leaf assemblages from the Bighorn Basin, Wyoming, that range in age from 56.1 to 52.65 million years (Ma). We also include similar published data from three US sites 49.4 to ~45 Ma in our analyses. Regional climate was subtropical or warmer throughout this period, and the second oldest assemblage (56 Ma) was deposited during the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), a geologically abrupt global warming event caused by massive release of carbon into the atmosphere. Total and leaf‐chewing damage are highest during the PETM, whether considering percent area damaged on the bulk flora, the average of individual host plants, or a single plant host that occurs at multiple sites. Another fossil assemblage in our study, the 52.65 Ma Fifteenmile Creek paleoflora, also lived during a period of globally high temperature and pCO₂, but does not have elevated herbivory. Comparison of these two sites, as well as regression analyses conducted on the entire dataset, demonstrates that, over long timescales, temperature and pCO₂ are uncorrelated with total insect consumption at the ecosystem level. Rather, the most important factor affecting herbivory is the relative abundance of plants with nitrogen‐fixing symbionts. Legumes dominate the PETM site; their prevalence would have decreased nitrogen limitation across the ecosystem, buffering generalist herbivore populations against decreased leaf nutritional quality that commonly occurs at high pCO₂. We hypothesize that nitrogen concentration regulates the opposing effects of elevated temperature and CO₂ on insect abundance and thereby total insect consumption, which has important implications for agricultural practices in today's world of steadily increasing pCO₂.     

Leaf age effects of elevated CO2-grown white oak leaves on spring-feeding lepidopterans

Folivorous insect responses to elevated CO₂-grown tree species may be complicated by phytochemical changes as leaves age. For example, young expanding leaves in tree species may be less affected by enriched CO₂-alterations in leaf phytochemistry than older mature leaves due to shorter exposure times to elevated CO₂ atmospheres. This, in turn, could result in different effects on early vs. late instar larvae of herbivorous insects. To address this, seedlings of white oak (Quercus alba L.), grown in open-top chambers under ambient and elevated CO₂, were fed to two important early spring feeding herbivores; gypsy moth (Lymantria dispar L.), and forest tent caterpillar (Malacosoma disstria Hübner). Young, expanding leaves were presented to early instar larvae, and older fully expanded or mature leaves to late instar larvae. Young leaves had significantly lower leaf nitrogen content and significantly higher total nonstructural carbohydrate:nitrogen ratio as plant CO₂ concentration rose, while nonstructural carbohydrates and total carbon-based phenolics were unaffected by plant CO₂ treatment. These phytochemical changes contributed to a significant reduction in the growth rate of early instar gypsy moth larvae, while growth rates of forest tent caterpillar were unaffected. The differences in insect responses were attributed to an increase in the nitrogen utilization efficiency (NUE) of early instar forest tent caterpillar larvae feeding on elevated CO₂-grown leaves, while early instar gypsy moth larval NUE remained unchanged among the treatments. Later instar larvae of both insect species experienced larger reductions in foliage quality on elevated CO₂-grown leaves than earlier instars, as the carbohydrate:nitrogen ratio of leaves substantially increased. Despite this, neither insect species exhibited changes in growth or consumption rates between CO₂ treatments in the later instar. An increase in NUE was apparently responsible for offsetting reduced foliar nitrogen for the late instar larvae of both species.     

Effects of elevated carbon dioxide on gas exchange and photochemical and nonphotochemical quenching at low temperature in tobacco plants varying in Rubisco activity

Elevated (700 μmol mol⁻¹) and ambient (350 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ effects on total ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) activity, photosynthesis (A), and photoinhibition during 6 d at low temperature were measured on wild type (WT), and rbcS antisense DNA mutants (T3) of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) with 60% of WT total Rubisco activity (Rodermel et al. (1988) Cell 55: 673–681). Prior to the low temperature treatment, A and quantum yield of PSII photochemistry in the light adapted state (φ_PSII) were significantly lower in T3 compared to WT at each CO₂ level. At this time, total nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ_Total) levels were near maximal (0.75–0.85) in T3 compared to WT (0.39–0.50). A was stimulated by 107% in T3 and 25% in WT at elevated compared to ambient CO₂. Pre-treatment acclimation to elevated CO₂ occurred in WT resulting in lower Rubisco activity per unit leaf area and reduced stimulation of A. At low temperature, A of WT was similar at elevated and ambient CO₂ while stimulation of A by elevated CO₂ in T3 was reduced. In addition, at low temperature we measured significantly lower photochemical quenching at elevated CO₂ compared to ambient CO₂ in both genotypes. NPQ_Total was similar (0.80–0.85) among all treatments. However, a larger proportion of NPQ_Total was composed of q_I,d, the damage subcomponent of the more slowly relaxing NPQ component, q_I, in both genotypes at elevated compared to ambient CO₂. Greater q_I,d, at elevated CO₂ during and after the low temperature treatment was not related to pre-treatment differences in total Rubisco activity.     

Effects of elevated CO2 on growth,photosynthesis and respiration of sweet chestnut (Castanea sativa Mill.)

Two year old sweet chestnut seedlings (Castanea sativa Mill) were grown in pots at ambient (350 µmol·mol^–1) and double (700 µmol·mol^–1) atmospheric CO₂ concentration in constantly ventilated greenhouses during entire growing seasons. CO₂ enrichment caused either no significant change or a decrease in shoot response, depending on yearly weather conditions. Similarly, leaf area was either reduced or unchanged under elevated CO₂. However, when grown under controlled conditions in a growth chamber, leaf area was enlarged with elevated CO₂.The CO₂ exchanges of whole plants were measured during the growing season. In elevated CO₂, net photosynthetic rate was maximum in May and then decreased, reaching the level of the control at the end of the season. End of night dark respiration of enriched plants was significantly lower than that of control plants; this difference decreased with time and became negligible in the fall. The original CO₂ level acted instantaneously on the respiration rate: a double concentration in CO₂ decreased the respiration of control plants and a reduced concentration enhanced the respiration of enriched plants. The carbon balance of a chestnut seedling may then be modified in elevated CO₂ by increased carbon inputs and decreased carbon outputs.     

Effects of nitrogen supply and elevated carbon dioxide on construction cost in leaves of Pinus taeda (L.) seedlings

Seedlings of loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) were grown under varying conditions of soil nitrogen and atmospheric carbon dioxide availability to investigate the interactive effects of these resources on the energetic requirements for leaf growth. Increasing the ambient CO₂ partial pressure from 35 to 65 Pa increased seedling growth only when soil nitrogen was high. Biomass increased by 55% and photosynthesis increased by 13% after 100 days of CO₂ enrichment. Leaves from seedlings grown in high soil nitrogen were 7.0% more expensive on a g glucose g^–1 dry mass basis to produce than those grown in low nitrogen, while elevated CO₂ decreased leaf cost by 3.5%. Nitrogen and CO₂ availability had an interactive effect on leaf construction cost expressed on an area basis, reflecting source-sink interactions. When both resources were abundant, leaf construction cost on an area basis was relatively high (81.8±3.0 g glucose m^–2) compared to leaves from high nitrogen, low CO₂ seedlings (56.3±3.0 g glucose m^–2) and low nitrogen, low CO₂ seedlings (67.1±2.7 g glucose m^–2). Leaf construction cost appears to respond to alterations in the utilization of photoassimilates mediated by resource availability.     

Impacts of urbanization on insect herbivory and plant defences in oak trees

Systematic comparisons of species interactions in urban versus rural environments can improve our understanding of shifts in ecological processes due to urbanization. However, such studies are relatively uncommon and the mechanisms driving urbanization effects on species interactions (e.g. between plants and insect herbivores) remain elusive. Here we investigated the effects of urbanization on leaf herbivory by insect chewers and miners associated with the English oak Quercus robur by sampling trees in rural and urban areas throughout most of the latitudinal distribution of this species. In performing these comparisons, we also controlled for the size of the urban areas (18 cities) and gathered data on CO₂ emissions. In addition, we assessed whether urbanization affected leaf chemical defences (phenolic compounds) and nutritional traits (phosphorus and nitrogen), and whether such changes correlated with herbivory levels. Urbanization significantly reduced leaf chewer damage but did not affect leaf miners. In addition, we found that leaves from urban locations had lower levels of chemical defences (condensed and hydrolysable tannins) and higher levels of nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) compared to leaves in rural locations. The magnitude of urbanization effects on herbivory and leaf defences was not contingent upon city size. Importantly, while the effects of urbanization on chemical defences were associated with CO₂ emissions, changes in leaf chewer damage were not associated with either leaf traits or CO₂ levels. These results suggest that effects of urbanization on herbivory occur through mechanisms other than changes in the plant traits measured here. Overall, our simultaneous assessment of insect herbivory, plant traits and abiotic correlates advances our understanding of the main drivers of urbanization effects on plant–herbivore interactions.     

Effect of elevated CO2 on interactions betwe en the western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) and the common milkweed, Asclepias syriaca

We measured the effect of elevated CO₂ on populations of the western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis and on the amount of leaf damage inflicted by the thrips to one of its host plants, the common milkweed, Asclepias syriaca. Plants grown at elevated CO₂ had significantly greater aboveground biomass and C:N ratios, and significantly reduced percentage nitrogen. The number of thrips per plant was not affected by CO₂ treatment, but the density of thrips (numbers per gram aboveground biomass), was significantly reduced at high CO₂. Consumption by thrips, expressed as the amount of damaged leaf area per capita, was significantly greater at high CO₂, and the amount of leaf area damaged by thrips was increased by 33%. However overall leaf area at elevated CO₂ increased by 62%, more than compensating for the increase in thrips consumption. The net outcome was that plants at elevated CO₂ had 3.6 times more undamaged leaf area available for photosynthesis than plants at ambient CO₂, even though they had only 1.6 times the overall amount of leaf area. This study highlights the need for measuring the effects of herbivory at the whole-plant level and also the importance of taking herbivory into account when predicting plant responses to elevated CO₂. Received: 9 January 1996 /Accepted: 30 July 1996     

Effects of scale insect herbivory and shading on net gas exchange and growth of a subtropical tree species (Guaiacum sanctum L.)

Summary The scale insect, Toumeyella sp., feeds exclusively on the subtropical hammock tree lignum vitae (Guaiacum sanctum L.). The combined effects of scale herbivory and shading on leaf gas exchange characteristics and growth of lignum vitae trees were studied using a factorial design. Trees grown in full sun or in 75% shade were manually infested with scale or left noninfested. Beginning 4 weeks after infestation, net CO₂ assimilation, stomatal conductance, transpiration, internal partial pressure of CO₂, and water-use efficiency were determined on single-leaves at 4-week intervals for trees in each treatment. At the end of the experiment, net CO₂ assimilation was determined for whole plants. Total leaf area, leaf, stem, and root dry weights, and leaf chlorophyll and nitrogen concentrations were also determined. Scale infested trees generally had lower net CO₂ assimilation, stomatal conductance, and transpiration rates as well as less leaf area, and root, stem, and leaf dry weights than noninfested trees. Twenty four weeks after the shade treatment was imposed, sun-grown trees had approximately twice the leaf area of shade-grown trees. Shade-grown trees compensated for the reduced leaf area by increasing their photosynthetic efficiency. This resulted in no difference in light saturated net CO₂ assimilation on a whole plant basis between sun-grown and shade-grown trees. Chlorophyll and nitrogen concentrations per unit leaf area were greater in leaves of shade-grown trees than in leaves of sun-grown trees. Shading and herbivory by Toumeyella sp. each resulted in decreased growth of Guaiacum sanctum. Scale insect herbivory did not result in greater detrimental effects on leaf gas exchange characteristics for shade-grown than for sun-grown trees. Herbivory by Toumeyella resulted in a greater decrease in tree growth for sun-grown than for shade-grown trees.     

Effects of elevated carbon dioxide on green leaf tissue and leaf litter quality in an intact Mojave Desert ecosystem

The effects of elevated carbon dioxide (CO₂) on plant litter are critical determinants of ecosystem feedback to changing atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. We measured concentrations of nitrogen (N) and carbon (C) and calculated C : N ratios of green leaves of two desert perennial shrubs, and the same quality parameters plus lignin and cellulose content of leaf litter from four shrub species exposed to elevated CO₂ (FACE technology; Hendrey & Kimball, 1994 ) for 3 years in an intact Mojave Desert ecosystem. Shrubs tested were Larrea tridentata, Lycium pallidum, Lycium andersonii and Ambrosia dumosa. We calculated resorption efficiency from green tissue and leaf litter N data and measured lignin and cellulose content in litter in the last year study. Green leaves of L. tridentata grown under elevated CO₂ had significantly lower N concentrations and higher C : N ratios than shrubs grown in ambient conditions in 1999 (P < 0.05). Lycium pallidum green leaves grown under elevated CO₂ had significantly lower N concentrations and higher C : N ratios than shrubs grown under ambient conditions in 2000 (P < 0.05). There was no CO₂ effect on C content of either species. We found no effect of CO₂ on N or C content, C : N ratios, or lignin or cellulose concentrations in leaf litter of L. tridentata, L. pallidum, L. andersonii, or A. dumosa. There was no significant effect of CO₂ on estimates of shrub resorption efficiency. There was a seasonal effect on green tissue and litter tissue quality for L. tridentata, with lower tissue N content in summer than in spring or winter months. These data suggest that any productivity increases with elevated CO₂ in desert ecosystems may not be limited by lower leaf litter quality and that resorption efficiency calculations are best performed on an individual leaf basis.     

Response to CO2 enrichment of understory vegetation in the shade of forests

Responses of forest ecosystems to increased atmospheric CO₂ concentration have been studied in few free‐air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiments during last two decades. Most studies focused principally on the overstory trees with little attention given to understory vegetation. Despite its small contribution to total productivity of an ecosystem, understory vegetation plays an important role in predicting successional dynamics and future plant community composition. Thus, the response of understory vegetation in Pinus taeda plantation at the Duke Forest FACE site after 15–17 years of exposure to elevated CO₂, 6–13 of which with nitrogen (N) amendment, was examined. Aboveground biomass and density of the understory decreased across all treatments with increasing overstory leaf area index (LAI). However, the CO₂ and N treatments had no effect on aboveground biomass, tree density, community composition, and the fraction of shade‐tolerant species. The increases of overstory LAI (~28%) under elevated CO₂ resulted in a reduction of light available to the understory (~18%) sufficient to nullify the expected growth‐enhancing effect of elevated CO₂ on understory vegetation.     

Leaf and canopy responses to elevated CO2 in a pine forest under free-air CO2 enrichment

Physiological responses to elevated CO₂ at the leaf and canopy-level were studied in an intact pine (Pinus taeda) forest ecosystem exposed to elevated CO₂ using a free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) technique. Normalized canopy water-use of trees exposed to elevated CO₂ over an 8-day exposure period was similar to that of trees exposed to current ambient CO₂ under sunny conditions. During a portion of the exposure period when sky conditions were cloudy, CO₂-exposed trees showed minor (7%) but significant reductions in relative sap flux density compared to trees under ambient CO₂ conditions. Short-term (minutes) direct stomatal responses to elevated CO₂ were also relatively weak (5% reduction in stomatal aperture in response to high CO₂ concentrations). We observed no evidence of adjustment in stomatal conductance in foliage grown under elevated CO₂ for nearly 80 days compared to foliage grown under current ambient CO₂, so intrinsic leaf water-use efficiency at elevated CO₂ was enhanced primarily by direct responses of photosynthesis to CO₂. We did not detect statistical differences in parameters from photosynthetic responses to intercellular CO₂ (A _net-C _i curves) for Pinus taeda foliage grown under elevated CO₂ (550 mol mol^–1) for 50–80 days compared to those for foliage grown under current ambient CO₂ from similar-sized reference trees nearby. In both cases, leaf net photosynthetic rate at 550 mol mol^–1 CO₂ was enhanced by approximately 65% compared to the rate at ambient CO₂ (350 mol mol^–1). A similar level of enhancement under elevated CO₂ was observed for daily photosynthesis under field conditions on a sunny day. While enhancement of photosynthesis by elevated CO₂ during the study period appears to be primarily attributable to direct photosynthetic responses to CO₂ in the pine forest, longer-term CO₂ responses and feedbacks remain to be evaluated.     

Photosynthetic sunfleck utilization potential of understory saplings growing under elevated CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> in FACE

Few studies have evaluated elevated CO₂ responses of trees in variable light despite its prevalence in forest understories and its potential importance for sapling survival. We studied two shade-tolerant species (Acer rubrum, Cornus florida) and two shade-intolerant species (Liquidambar styraciflua, Liriodendron tulipifera) growing in the understory of a Pinus taeda plantation under ambient and ambient+200 ppm CO₂ in a free air carbon enrichment (FACE) experiment. Photosynthetic and stomatal responses to artificial changes in light intensity were measured on saplings to determine rates of induction gain under saturating light and induction loss under shade. We expected that growth in elevated CO₂ would alter photosynthetic responses to variable light in these understory saplings. The results showed that elevated CO₂ caused the expected enhancement in steady-state photosynthesis in both high and low light, but did not affect overall stomatal conductance or rates of induction gain in the four species. Induction loss after relatively short shade periods (<6 min) was slower in trees grown in elevated CO₂ than in trees grown in ambient CO₂ despite similar decreases in stomatal conductance. As a result leaves grown in elevated CO₂ that maintained induction well in shade had higher carbon gain during subsequent light flecks than was expected from steady-state light response measurements. Thus, when frequent sunflecks maintain stomatal conductance and photosynthetic induction during the day, enhancements of long-term carbon gain by elevated CO₂ could be underestimated by steady-state photosynthetic measures. With respect to species differences, both a tolerant, A. rubrum, and an intolerant species, L. tulipifera, showed rapid induction gain, but A. rubrum also lost induction rapidly (c. 12 min) in shade. These results, as well as those from independent studies in the literature, show that induction dynamics are not closely related to species shade tolerance. Therefore, it cannot be concluded that shade-tolerant species necessarily induce faster in the variable light conditions common in understories. Although our study is the first to examine dynamic photosynthetic responses to variable light in contrasting species in elevated CO₂, studies on ecologically diverse species will be required to establish whether shade-tolerant and -intolerant species show different photosynthetic responses in elevated CO₂ during sunflecks. We conclude that elevated CO₂ affects dynamic gas exchange most strongly via photosynthetic enhancement during induction as well as in the steady state. Received: 1 April 1999 / Accepted: 16 August 1999     

Effect of Long Term Exposure to High CO2 Concentrations on Photosynthetic Characteristics of Prunus Avium L. Plants

The effect of two elevated carbon dioxide concentrations, 700 µmol(CO₂) mol^–1 (C700) and 1 400 µmol(CO₂) mol^–1 (C1400), on photosynthetic performances of 1-year-old Prunus avium L. plant was studied. Plants grown at C700 were characterised by increased net photosynthetic rate (P _N) as compared to those grown at C1400. Plant photosynthetic adjustment to C1400 resulted in 27 % higher P _N than in control at atmospheric CO₂ concentration (C _a) at the beginning of the experiment (3–4 weeks) with a consequent decline to the end of the experiment. Thus, 1 400 µmol(CO₂) mol^–1 had short-term stimulatory effect on plant P _N. Both chlorophyll (Chl) a and b concentrations dramatically decreased during exposure to C1400. Compensation irradiance was increased by 57 % in C700 and by 87 % in C1400. Photochemical efficiency () was affected by balloon environment, however, a clear stimulatory effect of C700 was detected. Opposite influence of both elevated CO₂ concentrations on P _Nmax was established: slight increase by C700 (2.7 % at C_a), but considerable decrease by C1400 (63 % at C_a). Exposure to C700 enhanced compensation irradiance by 42 %, while C1400 by only 21 %. Either C700 or C1400 did not reduce stomatal conductance (g _s). Leaf area per plant (LAR) was more stimulated by C700 than by C1400. High unit area leaf mass, specific leaf area, and dry matter accumulation in roots without affecting tissue density characterised plants grown in C1400. However, when considering the root : shoot ratio, these plants allocated less carbon to the roots than plants from other treatments.