CORRELATED EVOLUTION OF MATING STRATEGY AND INBREEDING DEPRESSION WITHIN AND AMONG POPULATIONS OF THE HERMAPHRODITIC SNAIL PHYSA ACUTA

Inbreeding depression is one of the main forces opposing the evolution of self-fertilization. Of central importance is the hypothesis that inbreeding depression and selfing coevolve antagonistically, generating either low selfing rate and high inbreeding depression or vice versa. However, there is limited evidence for this coevolution within species. We investigated this topic in the hermaphroditic snail Physa acuta . In this species, isolated individuals delay the onset of egg laying compared to individuals having access to mates. Longer delays ("waiting times") indicate more intense selfing avoidance. We measured inbreeding depression and waiting time in a large quantitative-genetic experiment (281 outbred families derived from 26 natural populations). We observed large genetic variance for both traits and a strong positive genetic covariance between them, most of which resided within rather than among populations. It means that, within populations, individuals with higher mutation load avoided selfing more strongly on average. This genetic covariance may result from pleiotropy and/or linkage disequilibrium. Whatever its genetic architecture, the fact it emerges specifically when individuals are deprived of mates suggests it is not fortuitous and rather reflects the action of natural selection. We conclude that a diversity of mating strategies can arise within populations subjected to variation in inbreeding depression.     

PARTIAL INBREEDING: EQUILIBRIUM HETEROZYGOSITY AND THE HETEROZYGOSITY PARADOX

The effect of partial inbreeding on equilibrium populations has been extended to any degree of mating. As expected, for distantly related mates, the equilibrium levels of inbreeding and heterozygosity are not affected as much as by partial selfing. Formulas are also given for equilibrium levels of inbreeding and heterozygosity when two or more degrees of mating are present in a population. Inbreeding, other than selfing, may partially explain the deficiency of heterozygotes in outcrossers, part of the “heterozygosity paradox.”     

Estimating Long-Term Mating Systems Using DNA Sequences

Plant mating systems often involve a mixture of self fertilizations and outcross fertilizations. The degree of selfing has a large impact on the genetic composition of natural populations and on the evolution of the mating system itself in response to such factors as inbreeding depression. This paper describes a means of estimating the long-term rate of self-fertilization from samples of alleles taken from individuals in a population. Use is made of the genealogy of pairs of alleles at a locus within individuals and pairs between individuals. The degree of selfing is closely related to the extent to which the number of nucleotide sites differing within an individual is reduced relative to the number differing between individuals. Importantly, the estimate of long-term selfing is largely independent of population size and is not affected by historical fluctuations in population size; instead it responds directly to the mating system itself. The approach outlined here is most appropriate to evolutionary problems in which the long-term nature of the mating system is of interest, such as to determine the relationship between prior inbreeding and inbreeding depression.     

Does life in unstable environments favour facultative selfing? A case study in the freshwater snail <Emphasis Type="Italic">Drepanotrema depressissimum</Emphasis> (Basommatophora: Planorbidae)

One of the main advantages of self-fertilization is to provide reproductive assurance when pollen or mates are scarce. In plants, partial or facultative selfing limits the risk of pollination failure. In preferentially outcrossing species, this may result in mixed-mating. In hermaphroditic animals, recent studies suggest that mixed mating might be much rarer than in plants. However more studies are required to substantiate this claim, especially focusing on species whose lifestyle entails a high potential benefit of reproductive assurance via selfing. We studied a hermaphroditic snail, Drepanotrema depressissimum, which inhabits very unstable and fragmented freshwater habitats. Individuals often have to recolonize newly refilled ponds after long droughts, a situation of low population density and hence low mate availability in which selfing could be an advantage. We estimated selfing rates in natural populations from Guadeloupe (Lesser Antilles), and used laboratory experiments to characterize the reproductive behaviour and success of individuals with or without mates. We detected no sign of selfing in natural populations. Even when given no other option, isolated individuals were extremely reluctant to self. They produced either no or very small clutches, and in the latter case initiated egg-laying later than non-isolated individuals. Self-fertilized clutches suffered near-total (98%) inbreeding depression at the juvenile stage. The example of D. depressissimum therefore shows that a species can overcome periods of mate shortage and habitat instability without the potential to rely on facultative selfing. We hypothesize that metapopulation persistence in this landscape is probably related to a form of dormancy (aestivation in dry ground) rather than to recolonization by rare immigrants and reproductive assurance.     

Inbreeding depression due to overdominance in partially self-fertilizing plant populations

The effect of the rate of partial self-fertilization and viability selection on the magnitude of inbreeding depression was investigated for the overdominance genetic model. The influence of these factors was determined for populations with equilibrium genotypic frequencies. Inbreeding depression was measured as the normalized disadvantage in mean viability of selfed progeny as compared to outcrossed progeny. When caused by symmetric homozygous disadvantage at a single locus it is shown always to be less than one-third. Moreover, for fixed rates of self-fertilization, its maximum value is found at intermediate levels of homozygous disadvantage. As the rate of self-fertilization increases, inbreeding depression increases and the homozygote viability that results in maximum depression tends toward one-half the heterozygote viability. Symmetric selection against homozygotes at multiple loci can lead to substantially higher values than selection at a single-locus. As the number of independent loci involved increases, inbreeding depression can reach high levels even though the selfing rate is low. Viability distributions for progenies produced from both random mating and self-fertilization were derived for the case of symmetric selection at independently assorting multiple loci. Distributions of viabilities in progenies resulting from mixtures of selfing and outcrossing were shown to be bimodal when inbreeding depression is high.     

RESPONSE TO SELECTION IN PARTIALLY SELF-FERTILIZING POPULATIONS. I. SELECTION ON A SINGLE TRAIT

Self-fertilization is a common form of reproduction in plants and it has important implications for quantitative trait evolution. Here, I present a model of selection on quantitative traits that can accommodate any level of self-fertilization. The “structured linear model” (SLM) predicts the evolution of the mean phenotype as a function of three distinct quantities: the mean additive genetic value, the directional dominance, and the mean inbreeding coefficient. Stochastic simulations of truncation selection demonstrate the accuracy of the SLM in predicting changes in the mean and variance of a quantitative trait over the full range of selfing rates. They also illustrate how complex interactions between selection and mating system determine the population distribution of inbreeding coefficients and also the amount of linkage disequilibrium. Changes in the genetic variance due to linkage disequilibria, which are commonly referred to as the “Bulmer effect,” are greatly magnified by selfing. This complicates the relationship between selfing rate and response to selection. Like the random mating theory, the parameters of the SLM can be estimated from phenotypic data.     

Inbreeding: One word, several meanings

The way geneticists use the word “inbreeding” can be somewhat puzzling. How can the same word be applied to situations as different as the presence of commong ancestors in the pedigrees of two individuals, on one hand, and the attitude towards marriage in a population, on the other? How can the same parameter, i.e., the “inbreeding coefficient F,” be used both, to measure the degree of genetic resemblance between individuals within a single population and also to measure the degree of genetic differences between groups of individuals.It will be useful for the sake of translation as well as for that of clarity, to delineate the various situations in which geneticists are led to refer to “inbreeding.”We shall see that this one word is used in, at least, five concepts: relationship between relatives; genetic drift; departure from panmixia of mating behaviour; subdivision of a population into several isolated groups; and divergence between the actual genotypic structure of a population and the reference “Hardy-Weinberg Structure.”     

A Measure of the Various Modes of Inbreeding in Kalmia latifolia

Inbreeding can occur in several ways. For a given species, analysingoverall inbreeding down to its component parts can be usefulin explaining how and why inbreeding is maintained in a population.Kalmia latifolia, a long-lived evergreen shrub, was chosen forthis study for two reasons: its unique floral morphology suggestedthat it was specially adapted to assure reproduction in thedelayed mode of self-fertilization, and previous studies hadsuggested that populations that were more limited by pollinatorsshowed higher rates of within-flower self-fertilization whenpollinators were excluded. Floral manipulations, controlledpollinations, and paternity analysis were performed to determinethe most common form of inbreeding within a flower, among flowersof one individual, or among related individuals. Although plantsare capable of setting seed within a flower, the overall rateof inbreeding was low. Among the modes of inbreeding withinone individual, a negligible selfing rate among emasculatedflowers suggests that selfing is more prevalent within a flowerthan among flowers on the same plant. In addition, as the multi-locusestimate of inbreeding was less than the single-locus estimate,inbreeding among related individuals also contributes to thenatural level of inbreeding. Copyright 2000 Annals of BotanyCompany Kalmia latifolia; mountain laurel; pollination; geitonogamy; autogamy; self-fertilization; inbreeding     

GENETIC CONSEQUENCES OF OUTCROSSING IN THE CLEISTOGAMOUS ANNUAL,IMPATIENS CAPENSIS. II. OUTCROSSING RATES AND GENOTYPIC CORRELATIONS

The genetic consequences of a plant's mating system depend on both the degree of outcrossing and the genetic relationship between mates. We examined the electrophoretic genotypes of seeds derived from cleistogamous (CL) and chasmogamous (CH) flowers in six populations of the facultatively cleistogamous annual, Impatiens capensis. Multilocus estimates of the outcrossing rates for the strongly protandrous CH flowers ranged from 0.29 to 0.71 and were higher than estimates based on single-locus data. Such results suggest that the CH flowers experience variable levels of both geitonogamous self-fertilization and biparental inbreeding. A new and generally applicable technique based on the relative level of inbreeding within progeny groups provided direct estimates of the correlation between the genotypic values of outcrossed mates. These correlations varied widely among populations and contributed up to half of the inbreeding observed among the CH progeny. Such biparental inbreeding biases estimates of the outcrossing rate based on the mixed-mating model downward and influences mating-system evolution by decreasing the “cost of meiosis.”     

Coevolution of self-fertilization and inbreeding depression. II. Symmetric overdominance in viability

We describe the evolutionary dynamics of a modifier of selfing coevolving with a locus subject to symmetric overdominance in viability under general levels of reduction in pollination success as a consequence of self-fertilization (pollen discounting). Simple models of the evolution of breeding systems that represent inbreeding depression as a constant parameter do not admit the possibility of stable mixed mating systems involving both inbreeding and random mating. Contrary to this expectation, we find that coevolution between a modifier of selfing and a single overdominant locus situated anywhere in the genome can generate evolutionarily attracting mixed mating systems. Two forms of association between the modifier locus and the viability locus promote the evolution of outcrossing. The favored heterozygous genotype at the viability locus develops positive associations with modifier alleles that enhance outcrossing and with the heterozygous genotype at the modifier locus. Associations between outcrossing and high viability evolve immediately upon the introduction of a rare modifier allele, even in the absence of linkage.     

Inbreeding shapes the evolution of marine invertebrates

Inbreeding is a potent evolutionary force shaping the distribution of genetic variation within and among populations of plants and animals. Yet, our understanding of the forces shaping the expression and evolution of nonrandom mating in general, and inbreeding in particular, remains remarkably incomplete. Most research on plant mating systems focuses on self-fertilization and its consequences for automatic selection, inbreeding depression, purging, and reproductive assurance, whereas studies of animal mating systems have often assumed that inbreeding is rare, and that natural selection favors traits that promote outbreeding. Given that many sessile and sedentary marine invertebrates and marine macroalgae share key life history features with seed plants (e.g., low mobility, modular construction, and the release of gametes into the environment), their mating systems may be similar. Here, we show that published estimates of inbreeding coefficients (F_IS) for sessile and sedentary marine organisms are similar and at least as high as noted in terrestrial seed plants. We also found that variation in F_IS within invertebrates is related to the potential to self-fertilize, disperse, and choose mates. The similarity of F_IS for these organismal groups suggests that inbreeding could play a larger role in the evolution of sessile and sedentary marine organisms than is currently recognized. Specifically, associations between traits of marine invertebrates and F_IS suggest that inbreeding could drive evolutionary transitions between hermaphroditism and separate sexes, direct development and multiphasic life cycles, and external and internal fertilization.     

Effect of selection against deleterious mutations on the decline in heterozygosity at neutral loci in closely inbreeding populations.

Transition matrices for selfing and full-sib mating were derived to investigate the effect of selection against deleterious mutations on the process of inbreeding at a linked neutral locus. Selection was allowed to act within lines only (selection type I) or equally within and between lines (type II). For selfing lines under selection type I, inbreeding is always retarded, the retardation being determined by the recombination fraction between the neutral and selected loci and the inbreeding depression from the selected locus, irrespective of the selection coefficient (s) and dominance coefficient (h) of the mutant allele. For selfing under selection type II or full-sib mating under both selection types, inbreeding is delayed by weak selection (small s and sh), due to the associative overdominance created at the neutral locus, and accelerated by strong selection, due to the elevated differential contributions between alternative alleles at the neutral locus within individuals and between lines (for selection type II). For multiple fitness loci under selection, stochastic simulations were run for populations with selfing, full-sib mating, and random mating, using empirical estimates of mutation parameters and inbreeding load in Drosophila. The simulations results are in general compatible with empirical observations.     

Interpopulation variation in inbreeding is primarily driven by tolerance of mating with relatives in a spermcasting invertebrate

The degree to which individuals inbreed is a fundamental aspect of population biology shaped by both passive and active processes. Yet, the relative influences of random and non-random mating on the overall magnitude of inbreeding are not well characterized for many taxa. We quantified variation in inbreeding among qualitatively accessible and isolated populations of a sessile marine invertebrate (the colonial ascidian Lissoclinum verrilli) in which hermaphroditic colonies cast sperm into the water column for subsequent uptake and internal fertilization. We compared estimates of inbreeding to simulations predicting random mating within sites to evaluate if levels of inbreeding were (1) less than expected because of active attempts to limit inbreeding, (2) as predicted by genetic subdivision and passive inbreeding tolerance, or (3) greater than simulations due to active attempts to promote inbreeding via self-fertilization or a preference for related mates. We found evidence of restricted gene flow and significant differences in the genetic diversity of L. verrilli colonies among sites, indicating that on average colonies were weakly related in accessible locations, but their levels of relatedness matched that of first cousins or half-siblings on isolated substrates. Irrespective of population size, progeny arrays revealed variation in the magnitude of inbreeding across sites that tracked with the mean relatedness of conspecifics. Biparental reproduction was confirmed in most offspring (86%) and estimates of total inbreeding largely overlapped with simulations of random mating, suggesting that interpopulation variation in mother–offspring resemblance was primarily due to genetic subdivision and passive tolerance of related mates. Our results highlight the influence of demographic isolation on the genetic composition of populations, and support theory predicting that tolerance of biparental inbreeding, even when mates are closely related, may be favoured under a broad set of ecological and evolutionary conditions.     

Purging of inbreeding depression within a population of Oxalis alpina (Oxalidaceae)

? Premise of the study: Variation among individuals in levels of inbreeding depression associated with selfing levels could influence mating system evolution by purging deleterious alleles, but empirical evidence for this association is limited. ? Methods: We investigated the association of family-level inbreeding depression and presumed inbreeding history in a tristylous population of Oxalis alpina (Oxalidaceae). ? Key results: Mid-styled individuals possessed the greatest degree of self-compatibility (SC) and produced more autogamous capsules than short- or long-styled individuals. Offspring of highly self-compatible mid-styled individuals showed reduced inbreeding depression. Mid-styled plants that produced capsules autogamously exhibited reduced stigma-anther separation compared to mid-styled plants that produced no capsules autogamously. Reduced inbreeding depression was not correlated with stigma-anther separation, suggesting that self-compatibility and autogamy evolve before morphological changes in stigma-anther separation. ? Conclusions: Purging of inbreeding depression occurred in SC mid-styled maternal families. Low inbreeding depression in SC mid-styled plants may lead to retention of the mid-styled morph in populations, despite the occurrence of higher selfing rates in mid-styled relative to short- or long-styled morphs. Variation among individuals in levels of self-fertilization within populations may lead to associations between inbreeding lineages and lower levels of inbreeding depression, influencing the evolution of mating systems.     

SEX CHANGE WITH INBREEDING: EXPERIMENTS ON SEPARATE VERSUS COMBINED SEXES

Ipomopsis rubra plants grown in the laboratory initially produced hermaphrodite flowers, but some self- or sib-mated individuals switched to produce large numbers of pistillate (male sterile) flowers. The sex change did not occur with outcrossing. Plants with extreme male sterility were also observed in natural populations, usually in smaller individuals. Male sterility may be compensated by more seeds (resource reallocation), better seeds (avoidance of selfing), or both. Pistillate flowers were smaller, so savings could be used for additional seeds. Selfed seeds had reduced survival and fecundity, so avoidance of selfing could produce better quality offspring. We explored costs and benefits of sex change with two fitness models. The first assumes randomoutcross matings. Estimates of resource reallocation and inbreeding (selfing) depression are sufficient for pistillate inflorescences to have equal or greater fitness than hermaphrodite inflorescences if the selfing rate is high. Frequencies of sex change with intensive self-pollination were consistent with this model. The second model assumes all nonself matings are between sibs in “local mating” groups. Parents may benefit by male sterility in offspring, but gains would be higher if sex change occurred earlier and at higher than observed frequencies.     

Mating system and ploidy influence levels of inbreeding depression in Clarkia (Onagraceae)

Inbreeding depression is the reduction in offspring fitness associated with inbreeding and is thought to be one of the primary forces selecting against the evolution of self-fertilization. Studies suggest that most inbreeding depression is caused by the expression of recessive deleterious alleles in homozygotes whose frequency increases as a result of self-fertilization or mating among relatives. This process leads to the selective elimination of deleterious alleles such that highly selfing species may show remarkably little inbreeding depression. Genome duplication (polyploidy) has also been hypothesized to influence levels of inbreeding depression, with polyploids expected to exhibit less inbreeding depression than diploids. We studied levels of inbreeding depression in allotetraploid and diploid species of Clarkia (Onagraceae) that vary in mating system (each cytotype was represented by an outcrossing and a selfing species). The outcrossing species exhibited more inbreeding depression than the selfing species for most fitness components and for two different measures of cumulative fitness. In contrast, though inbreeding depression was generally lower for the polyploid species than for the diploid species, the difference was statistically significant only for flower number and one of the two measures of cumulative fitness. Further, we detected no significant interaction between mating system and ploidy in determining inbreeding depression. In sum, our results suggest that a taxon's current mating system is more important than ploidy in influencing levels of inbreeding depression in natural populations of these annual plants.     

Effect of recurrent selfing on inbreeding depression and mating system evolution in an autopolyploid plant

Genome duplication resulting in polyploidy can have significant consequences for the evolution of mating systems. Most theory predicts that self‐fertilization will be selectively favored in polyploids; however, many autopolyploids are outcrossing or mixed‐mating. Here, we examine the hypothesis that the evolution of selfing is restricted in autopolyploids because the genetic cost of selfing (i.e., inbreeding depression) increases monotonically with successive generations of inbreeding. Using the herbaceous, autotetraploid plant Chamerion angustifolium, we generated populations with different inbreeding coefficients (F= 0, 0.17 and 0.36) through three consecutive generations of selfing and compared their magnitudes of inbreeding depression in a common environment. Mating system estimates for four natural populations confirmed that tetraploid selfing rates (s_m= 0.25, SE = 0.02) are similar to those of diploids (s_m= 0.12, SE = 0.12; F_1,2= 1.34, P= 0.37) indicating that both cytotypes are predominantly outcrossing. Compared to an outbred control line, mean inbreeding depression for seed production, survival, and height (vegetative and total) in the inbred line differed among generations (inbreeding coefficients). Across all stages, inbreeding depression (relative to control) was positively related to generation (inbreeding coefficient). Although the initial costs of inbreeding in extant and newly synthesized polyploids may be low compared to diploids, the monotonic increase in inbreeding depression with repeated inbreeding may limit the extent to which selfing variants are favored.     

MEASURES OF PHENOTYPIC SELECTION ARE BIASED BY PARTIAL INBREEDING

When populations are partially inbred due to the population structure or to a mixed mating system like partial self-fertilization, some individuals will be more inbred than others. This heterogeneity among individuals in the history of inbreeding can greatly complicate the interpretation of measures of quantitative genetic variability when the traits studied exhibit inbreeding depression. Partial inbreeding can also bias measures of phenotypic selection toward the detection of strong directional and stabilizing selection. In this paper, data are presented from several inbreeding experiments conducted on two partially selfing, annual populations of the monkeyflower Mimulus guttatus that show that the means of many of the morphological and phenological traits measured were affected by inbreeding. These findings imply that estimates of heritabilities and additive genetic covariances would not reflect the potential for these populations to respond to selection. Phenotypic selection analyses conducted on naturally occurring plants, involving linear regressions of relative seed production on the traits, revealed significant directional selection on many of the same quantitative traits measured in the inbreeding studies. However, when the same selection analyses were performed on plants with known histories of inbreeding, part of the statistical relationship between relative seed number and the traits was found to be due to the mating system: inbred individuals had both lower seed production and different mean values for the traits than outcrossed individuals. It is also shown, with a hypothetical example, that partial inbreeding can bias measures of stabilizing selection toward the detection of strong stabilizing selection. Partial inbreeding therefore tends to make directional and stabilizing selection appear stronger than it is, and it may be that natural selection in the wild is actually weaker than many studies of partially inbred species suggest.