Nodulin gene expression in effective root nodules of white sweetclover (Melilotus alba Desr.) and in ineffective nodules elicited by mutant strains of Rhizobium meliloti

Fifteen nodulins and several nodule-stimulated gene productswere expressed in effective, nitrogen-fixing root nodules ofwhite sweetclover (Melilotus alba Desr. cv. U389), as determinedby two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of in vitro translationproducts. The number and gel position of eight leghaemoglobin(Lb) products, as well as a product tentatively identified asnodule-stimulated glutamine synthetase (GS), was similar toprevious reports of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L. cv. Iroquois)nodulins. Three mutants of Rhizobium meliloti, including anexoH mutant, a lipopolysaccharide mutant, and a nifH mutant,elicited ineffective sweetclover nodules blocked at empty (bacteria-free),partially infected, or fully infected stages of nodule development,respectively. In these ineffective nodules, the nodulin Nma30and nodule-stimulated NSTma42 were expressed early in development,while a group of four nodulins and two nodule-stimulated productswere intermediate in order of expression. Lb, GS and the latenodulin Nmal2a were expressed later, following infection. TheexoH mutant, Rm7154, appeared to be a leaky mutant, as a smallpercentage of the plants developed nitrogen-fixing nodules about4 weeks after inoculation. The sequential expression of a largenumber of nodulins and nodule-stimulated products, as well asthe availability of sweetclover nodulation mutants indicatesthat sweetclover is a useful diploid system for analysis ofhost genes essential to the Rhizobium/legume symbiosis. Key words: Nitrogen fixation, nodulation mutants, nodulins     

Nodule-specific host proteins in effective and ineffective root nodules of Pisum sativum

Nodule-specific root proteins – so called nodulins – were identified in root nodules of pea plants by an immunological assay. Nodulin patterns were examined at different stages of nodule development. About 30 nodulins were detectable during development. Some were preferentially synthesized before nitrogen fixation started, whereas the majority were synthesized concomitantly with leghaemoglobin. Some of the nodulins were located within the peribacteroid membrane. Ineffective Rhizobium strains (a natural nod⁺fix^- and a pop ^-fix^-) appeared to be useful in studying the expression of nodulin genes. Synthesis of some nodulins was repressed in ineffective root nodules, indicating that nodulins are essential for the establishment of nitrogen fixation. In both types of ineffective root nodules, leghaemoglobin synthesis was not completely repressed. Low amounts of leghaemoglobin were always detected in young ineffective root nodules whereas in old nodules no leghaemoglobin was present.     

cDNA cloning and developmental expression of pea nodulin genes

A cDNA library prepared from pea nodule poly(A)⁺ RNA was screened by differential hybridization with cDNA probes synthesized from root and nodule RNA respectively. From the cDNA clones that hybridized exclusively with the nodule probe five clones, designated pPsNod 6, 10, 11, 13 and 14 and each containing unique sequences, were further characterized together with one leghemoglobin and one root-specific cDNA clone. In vitro translation of RNA selected by the pPsNod clones showed that the corresponding genes encode nodulins with molecular weights ranging from 5 800 to 19 000. During pea root nodule development expression of the five PsNod genes starts more or less concomitantly with the onset of nitrogen fixing activity in the nodules and the time course of appearance and accumulation of the nodulin mRNAs is similar to that of leghemoglobin mRNA. In ineffective pea root nodules expression of the PsNod genes is induced but the final accumulation levels of the mRNAs are markedly reduced to various degrees. The expression of another nodulin gene, designated ENOD2, was followed using a heterologous soybean cDNA clone as probe. In pea root nodules the ENOD2 gene is expressed at least five days before the PsNod and leghemoglobin genes, and in contrast to the PsNod mRNAs the concentration of the ENOD2 mRNA is the same in wild type and fix ^- nodules. The results described suggest that in root nodules several regulatory mechanisms exist which determine the final nodulin mRNA amounts accumulating in the root nodule.     

Nodulin gene expression during soybean (Glycine max) nodule development

In vitro translation products of total RNA isolated from soybean nodules at successive stages of nodule development were analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. In that way the occurrence of over 20 mRNAs specifically transcribed from nodulin genes was detected. The nodulin genes could be divided into two classes according to the time of expression during nodule development. Class A comprises at least 4 nodulin mRNAs which are found when a globular meristem is present in the root cortex. These class A nodulin genes have a transient expression. Class B nodulin genes are expressed when the formation of a nodule structure has been completed. Bradyrhizobium japonicum nod ⁺ fix^-mutants, with large deletions spanning the nif H,DK region, still induced nodules showing normal expression of all nodulin genes, indicating that the nif H,DK region is not involved in the induction of nodulin genes. In nodules induced by Bradyrhizobium japonicum nod ⁺ fix^-mutant HS124 the bacteria are rarely released from the infection thread and the few infected cells appear to be collapsed. All class A and class B nodulin genes are expressed in HS124 nodules with the exception of 5 class B genes.     

Sequential expression of two late nodulin genes in the infected cells of alfalfa root nodules.

The Nms-22 and leghemoglobin (Lb) genes are expressed exclusively in the infected cells of alfalfa root nodules. Expression of these two late nodulin genes originated at distinct cellular boundaries within the symbiotic region of the nodule. The Nms-22 gene was expressed in all infected cells, including those just adjacent to the meristematic region. Lb gene expression was induced in older infected cells and was most prominent in the mature region of the nodule. Despite this temporal separation of gene expression, both the Nms-22 and Lb genes were expressed in nodules elicited by bacA mutants in which bacteroid development has been blocked just after release from the infection thread.     

Plant genes induced in the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis

Rhizobium, Bradyrhizobium and Azorhizobium can elicit the formation of N₂-fixing nodules on the roots or stems of their leguminous host plants. The nodule formation involves several developmental steps determined by different sets of genes from both partners, the gene expression being temporally and spatially coordinated. The plant proteins that are specifically synthesised during the formation and function of the nodule are called nodulins. The nodulins that are expressed before the onset of N₂ fixation are termed early nodulins. These proteins are probably involved in the infection process as well as in nodule morphogenesis rather than in nodule function. The nodulins expressed just before or during N₂ fixation are termed late nodulins and they participate in the function of the nodule by creating the physiological conditions required for nitrogen fixation, ammonium assimilation and transport. In this review we will describe nodulins, nodulin genes and the relationship between nodulin gene expression and nodule development. The study of nodulin gene expression may provide insight into root-nodule development and the mechanism of communication between bacteria and host plant.J.A. Muñoz and A.J. Palomares are with the Departamento de Microbiologia y Parasitología, Facultad de Farmacia, Universidad de Sevilla, 41012 Sevilla, Spain. P. Ratet is with the Institut des Sciences Végétales, CNRS, Avenue de la Terrasse, F-91198 Gif-sur-Yvette, Fance     

Developmental regulation of nodule-specific genes in alfalfa root nodules

We have cloned alfalfa nodule-specific cDNAs that code for leghemoglobin (Lb), glutamine synthetase (GS), and three unidentified nodulins. Hybrid-select translation of nodule RNA followed by 2-D gel electrophoresis showed that the Lb-specific cDNA corresponded to at least four Lb species of 12 kDa. One of the unidentified cDNA clones (N-32/34) corresponded to at least five polypeptides of 32-34 kDa; a second unidentified cDNA clone (N-14) corresponded to an individual polypeptide of 14 kDa. The in vitro translation product(s) of the RNA hybrid selected by the third unidentified cDNA clone (N-22) formed a single band at 22 kDa on a one-dimensional gel. Northern and dot blot analyses of RNA isolated from wild-type nodules and from defective nodules elicited by a variety of Rhizobium meliloti mutants showed that 1) RNAs corresponding to the Lb, nodule-specific GS, and three unidentified nodulins were coordinately expressed during the course of nodule development, and 2) all five nodulins were expressed in Fix- nodules that contained infection threads and bacteroids but were not expressed in nodules that lacked infection threads and intracellular rhizobia.     

The relationship between nodulin gene expression and the Rhizobium nod genes in Vicia sativa root nodule development

The role of the Rhizobium nod genes in the induction of nodulin gene expression was examined by analyzing nodules formed on vetch roots by bacterial strains containing only the nod region. Introduction of an 11-kb cloned nod region of the R. leguminosarum sym plasmid pRL1JI into sym plasmid-cured rhizobia conferred on the recipient strains the ability to induce nodules in which all nodulin genes were expressed. This proves that from the sym plasmid only the nod region is involved in the induction of nodulin gene expression. A transconjugant of Agrobacterium carrying the same nod region induces nodules in which only early nodulin gene expression is detected. Thus, the nod region is essential for the induction of early nodulin gene expression. In this case, nodule cytology may indicate that a defense response of the plant interferes with the induction of late nodulin gene expression. Indirect evidence is presented that indeed the Rhizobium nod genes are also in some way involved in the induction of the expression of late noduling genes. The combination between histological data and pattern of nodulin gene expression furthermore reveals a correlation between nodule structure and nodulin gene expression. This correlation may aid in speculations about the functions of nodulins.     

The roots of nodulins

Nodulin gene expression is an integral and highly specific part of the formation of nitrogen-fixing nodules on the roots of leguminous plants. Dependent on the time of expression during root nodule development, nodulin genes can be divided into early and late nodulin genes. A brief overview of the functions assigned to early and late nodulins is presented. We hypothesize that nodulin genes originate from regular plant genes that evolved to fit the regulatory and/or physiological constraints of symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Data on nodulins and nodulin genes, nodulation taxonomy and nodule development are evaluated in the light of this hypothesis.     

Nodule-specific polypeptides from effective alfalfa root nodules and from ineffective nodules lacking nitrogenase

In addition to leghemoglobin, at least nine nodule-specific polypeptides from the alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.)-Rhizobium meliloti symbiosis were identified by immune assay. Some of these polypeptides may be subunits of larger proteins but none appeared to be subunits of the same multimeric protein. All nine of the nodule-specific polypeptides were localized to within the plant cytosol; they were not found in extracts of bacteroids or in the peribacteroid space. At least one of these nodule-specific polypeptides was found to be antigenically related to nodule-specific polypeptides in pea and/or soybean. Ineffective nodules elicited by R. meliloti strains containing mutations in four different genes required for nitrogenase synthesis contained reduced concentrations of leghemoglobin and of several of the nodule-specific polypeptides. Other nodule-specific polypeptides were unaltered or actually enriched in the ineffective nodules. Many of the differences between the ineffective and effective nodules were apparent in nodules harvested shortly after the nodules became visible. These differences were greatly amplified in older nodules. When the four ineffective nodule types were compared to one another, there were clear quantitative differences in the concentrations of several of the nodule-specific polypeptides. These differences suggest that lack of a functional nitrogenase does not have a single direct effect on nodule development.     

Nodulins and nodulin genes of Glycine max

Summary Nodulins are organ-specific plant proteins induced during symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Nodulins play both metabolic and structural roles within infected and uninfected nodule cells. In soybean, several nodulin genes, coding for abundant nodulins, have been identified and isolated. Structural analysis of some of these genes has revealed their possible mode of regulation and the subcellar location of the protein product. Studies of ineffective symbiosis based on cultivar-strain genotype differences suggested that both partners influence the expression of nodulin genes. Concomitant with nodule organogenesis, the Rhizobium undergoes substantial differentiation leading to the accumulation of nodule-specific bacterial proteins, bacteroidins. The major structural alteration occuring in the infected cell is the formation of a membrane enclosing the bacteroid (peribacteroid membrane). A number of nodulins are specifically targetted to this membrane during endosymbiosis. The induction of nodulins and bacteroidins leads to the formation of an effective nodule. Nodulin genes can be induced in vitro by factors derived from nodules suggesting that trans-activators may be involved in derepression of the host genes necessary for Rhizobium-legume symbiosis.     

Cells expressing ENOD2 show differential spatial organization during the development of alfalfa root nodules

We have used in situ hybridization to examine the spatial organization of cells expressing the early nodulin gene (ENOD2) during the development of alfalfa root nodules. ENOD2 gene expression was found in the nodule parenchyma, uninfected cells surrounding the symbiotic region of both effective and ineffective nodules. However, in empty nodules, ENOD2 gene expression was found in a mass of parenchyma cells at the base of the nodule. Similar results were also observed in 11-day-old nodules that contained infected cells but that had not yet begun to express leghemoglobin. Although early events of nodulation result in the induction of ENOD2 expression in cells at the nodule base, the pattern of cells expressing ENOD2 during nodule growth appears to be correlated with the development of other peripheral tissues.     

Rhizobium nod genes are involved in the induction of two early nodulin genes in Vicia sativa root nodules

Nodulin gene expresison was studied in Vicia sativa (common vetch) root nodules induced by several Rhizobium and Agrobacterium strains. An Agrobacterium transconjugant containing a R. leguminosarum symplasmid instead of its Ti-plasmid, that was previously shown to form empty nodules on pea, induced nodules on Vicia roots in which nodule cells were infected with bacteria. In the Vicia nodules induced by this transconjugant, two so-called early nodulin genes were found to be expressed, whereas in the nodules formed on pea the expression of only one early nodulin gene was detected. In both cases the majority of the nodulin genes was not expressed.Apparently, an intracellular location of the bacteria is not sufficient for the induction of the majority of the nodulin genes. All nodulin genes were expressed in nodules induced by cured Rhizobium strains containing cosmid clones that have a 10 kb nod region of the sym-plasmid in common. Since in tumours no nodulin gene expression was found at all, the Agrobacterium chromosome does not contribute to the induction of nodulin genes. Therefore it is concluded that the signal for the induction of the expression of the two Vicia early nodulin genes is encoded by the nod-region, and the signal involved in the induction of all other nodulin genes has to be located outside the sym-plasmid, on the Rhizobium chromosome. The apparent difference in early nodulin gene expression between pea and Vicia is discussed in the light of the usefulness of Agrobacterium transconjugants in the study of nodulin gene expression.