An improved counterselectable marker system for mycobacterial recombination using galK and 2-deoxy-galactose

Counterselectable markers are powerful tools in genetics because they allow selection for loss of a genetic marker rather than its presence. In mycobacteria, a widely used counterselectable marker is the gene encoding levan sucrase (sacB), which confers sensitivity to sucrose, but frequent spontaneous inactivation complicates its use. Here we show that the Escherichia coli galactokinase gene (galK) can be used as a counterselectable marker in both Mycobacterium smegmatis and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Expression of E. coli galK, but not the putative M. tuberculosis galK, conferred sensitivity to 2-deoxy-galactose (2-DOG) in both M. smegmatis and M. tuberculosis. We tested the utility of E. coli galK as a counterselectable marker in mycobacterial recombination, both alone and in combination with sacB. We found that 0.5% 2-DOG effectively selected recombinants that had lost the galK marker with the ratio of galK loss/galK mutational inactivation of approximately 1:4. When we combined galK and sacB as dual counterselectable markers and selected for dual marker loss on 0.2% 2-DOG/5% sucrose, 98.6–100% of sucrose/2-DOG resistant clones had undergone recombination, indicating that the frequency of mutational inactivation of both markers was lower than the recombination frequency. These results establish a new counterselectable marker system for use in mycobacteria that can shorten the time to generate unmarked mutations in M. smegmatis and M. tuberculosis.     

rpsL+: a dominant selectable marker for gene replacement in mycobacteria

Molecular genetic manipulations in mycobacteria would benefit from procedures which efficiently select for double-crossover events by homologous recombination. Here we describe a vector-host system for gene replacement in mycobacteria, the utility of which was investigated using functional inactivation of the pyrF gene in Mycobacterium smegmatis as a model. This system is based on the expression of the wild-type rpsL gene coding for ribosomal protein S12 in a streptomycin-resistant host. Owing to the absence of a mycobacterial origin the plasmids are unable to replicate autonomously in mycobacteria. The first selection for maintenance of cloned sequences is conferred by the kanamycin-resistance gene. The second simultaneous selection by streptomycin is against maintenance of cloned sequences which contain the gene encoding the streptomycin-sensitive allele of the rpsL gene. By placing the gene for positive selection and that used for negative selection within and outside the target gene of interest, respectively, gene replacement is obtained. A one-step double selection procedure provides a means to distinguish strictly between gene replacement by double crossover versus homologous recombination by single crossover events. The system should have considerable potential for genera or species where single-crossover events or even illegitimate recombination are the predominant recombination mechanisms. It should also be of wide use for the construction of mutants without a selectable phenotype.     

sacB-5-Fluoroorotic Acid-pyrE-Based Bidirectional Selection for Integration of Unmarked Alleles into the Chromosome of Rhodobacter capsulatus

The gram-negative, purple nonsulfur, facultative photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus is a widely used model organism and has well-developed molecular genetics. In particular, interposon mutagenesis using selectable gene cartridges is frequently employed for construction of a variety of chromosomal knockout mutants. However, as the gene cartridges are often derived from antibiotic resistance-conferring genes, their numbers are limited, which restricts the construction of multiple knockout mutants. In this report, sacB—5-fluoroorotic acid (5FOA)—pyrE-based bidirectional selection that facilitates construction of unmarked chromosomal knockout mutations is described. The R. capsulatus pyrE gene encoding orotate phosphoribosyl transferase, a key enzyme of the de novo pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthesis pathway, was used as an interposon in a genetic background that is auxotrophic for uracil (Ura⁻) and hence resistant to 5FOA (5FOA^r). Although Ura⁺ selection readily yielded chromosomal allele replacements via homologous recombination, selection for 5FOA^r to replace pyrE with unmarked alleles was inefficient. To improve the latter step, 5FOA^r selection was combined with sucrose tolerance selection using a suicide plasmid carrying the Bacillus subtilis sacB gene encoding levansucrase that induces lethality upon exposure to 5% (wt/vol) sucrose in the growth medium. Sucrose-tolerant, 5FOA^r colonies that were obtained carried chromosomal unmarked mutant alleles of the target gene via double crossovers between the resident pyrE-marked and incoming unmarked alleles. The effectiveness of this double selection was proven by seeking insertion and deletion alleles of helC involved in R. capsulatus cytochrome c biogenesis, which illustrated the usefulness of this system as a genetic means for facile construction of R. capsulatus unmarked chromosomal mutants.     

Establishment of a Successive Markerless Mutation System in Haemophilus parasuis through Natural Transformation

Haemophilus parasuis, belonging to the family Pasteurellaceae, is the causative agent of Glässer’s disease leading to serious economic losses. In this study, a successive markerless mutation system for H. parasuis using two sequential steps of natural transformation was developed. By the first homologous recombination, the target genes were replaced by a cassette carrying kanamycin resistance gene and sacB (which confers sensitivity to sucrose) gene using kanamycin selection, followed by the second reconstruction to remove the selection cassette, with application of sucrose to further screen unmarked mutants. To improve DNA transformation frequency, several parameters have been analyzed further in this work. With this method, two unmarked deletions in one strain have been generated successfully. It is demonstrated that this system can be employed to construct multi-gene scarless deletions, which is of great help for developing live attenuated vaccines for H. parasuis.     

ThesacB gene cannot be used as a counter-selectable marker inPasteurella multocida

The use of theBacillus subtilis sacB gene as a counter-selectable marker was assessed in serogroup A and B strains ofPasteurella multocida. Expression ofsacB failed to render any of the strains sensitive to sucrose, indicating that thesacB gene can not be used as a positive selection system inP. multocida.     

Genetic Manipulations of the Hyperthermophilic Piezophilic Archaeon Thermococcus barophilus

In this study, we developed a gene disruption system for Thermococcus barophilus using simvastatin for positive selection and 5-fluoroorotic acid (5-FOA) for negative selection or counterselection to obtain markerless deletion mutants using single- and double-crossover events. Disruption plasmids carrying flanking regions of each targeted gene were constructed and introduced by transformation into wild-type T. barophilus MP cells. Initially, a pyrF deletion mutant was obtained as a starting point for the construction of further markerless mutants. A deletion of the hisB gene was also constructed in the UBOCC-3256 (ΔpyrF) background, generating a strain (UBOCC-3260) that was auxotrophic for histidine. A functional pyrF or hisB allele from T. barophilus was inserted into the chromosome of UBOCC-3256 (ΔpyrF) or UBOCC-3260 (ΔpyrF ΔhisB), allowing homologous complementation of these mutants. The piezophilic genetic tools developed in this study provide a way to construct strains with multiple genetic backgrounds that will allow further genetic studies for hyperthermophilic piezophilic archaea.     

pyrF as a Counterselectable Marker for Unmarked Genetic Manipulations in Treponema denticola

The pathophysiology of Treponema denticola, an oral pathogen associated with both periodontal and endodontic infections, is poorly understood due to its fastidious growth and recalcitrance to genetic manipulations. Counterselectable markers are instrumental in constructing clean and unmarked mutations in bacteria. Here, we demonstrate that pyrF, a gene encoding orotidine-5′-monophosphate decarboxylase, can be used as a counterselectable marker in T. denticola to construct marker-free mutants. T. denticola is susceptible to 5-fluoroorotic acid (5-FOA). To establish a pyrF-based counterselectable knockout system in T. denticola, the pyrF gene was deleted. The deletion conferred resistance to 5-FOA in T. denticola. Next, a single-crossover mutant was constructed by reintroducing pyrF along with a gentamicin resistance gene (aacC1) back into the chromosome of the pyrF mutant at the locus of choice. In this study, we chose flgE, a flagellar hook gene that is located within a large polycistronic motility gene operon, as our target gene. The obtained single-crossover mutant (named FlgEⁱⁿ) regained the susceptibility to 5-FOA. Finally, FlgEⁱⁿ was plated on solid agar containing 5-FOA. Numerous colonies of the 5-FOA-resistant mutant (named FlgE^out) were obtained and characterized by PCR and Southern blotting analyses. The results showed that the flgE gene was deleted and FlgE^out was free of selection markers (i.e., pyrF and aacC1). Compared to previously constructed flgE mutants that contain an antibiotic selection marker, the deletion of flgE in FlgE^out has no polar effect on its downstream gene expression. The system developed here will provide us with a new tool for investigating the genetics and pathogenicity of T. denticola.     

An improved counterselection cassette for use in Haemophilus influenzae

Counterselectable cassettes are extremely useful in molecular biology and allow for the creation of unmarked deletion mutants or the introduction of point mutations. I have constructed an inducible sacB cassette, using the tetracycline repressor. When used in tandem with a kanamycin-resistance marker, the cassette was successful in creating unmarked mutants in Haemophilus influenzae. The inducible nature of the cassette avoids some of the common problems associated with the utilization of sacB in counterselection.     

Efficient and simple generation of unmarked gene deletions in Mycobacterium smegmatis

Genetic research in molecular laboratories relies heavily on directed mutagenesis and gene deletion techniques. In mycobacteria, however, genetic analysis is often hindered by difficulties in the preparation of deletion mutants. Indeed, in comparison to the allelic exchange systems available for the study of other common model organisms, such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Escherichia coli, mycobacterial gene disruption systems suffer from low mutant isolation success rates, mostly due to inefficient homologous recombination and a high degree of non-specific recombination. Here, we present a gene deletion system that combines efficient homologous recombination with advanced screening of mutants. This novel methodology allows for gene disruption in three consecutive steps. The first step relies on the use of phage Che9c recombineering proteins for directed insertion into the chromosome of a linear DNA fragment that encodes GFP and confers hygromycin resistance. In the second step, GFP positive and hygromycin resistant colonies are selected, and in the last step, the gfp-hyg cassette is excised from the chromosome, thus resulting in the formation of an unmarked deletion. We provide a detailed gene deletion methodology and demonstrate the use of this genetic system by deleting the prcSBA operon of Mycobacterium smegmatis.     

Optimization of staphylokinase production inBacillus subtilis using inducible and constitutive promoters

Staphylokinase (SAK) was produced inB. subtillis using two different promoter systems,i.e. the P43 andsacB promoters. To maximize SAK expression inB. subtilis, fermentation control strategies for each promoter were examined. SAK, under P43, a vegetative promoter transcribed mainly by σ^B containing RNA polymerase, was overexpressed at low dissolved oxygen (D.O.) levels, suggesting that thesigB operon is somewhat affected by the energy charge of the cells. The expression of SAK at the 10% D.O. level was three times higher than that at the 50% D.O. level. In the case ofsacB, a sucrose-inducible promoter, sucrose feeding was used to control the induction period and induction strength. Since sucrose is hydrolyzed by two sucrose hydrolyzing enzymes in the cell and culture broth, the control strategy was based on replenishing the loss of sucrose in the culture. With continuous feeding of sucrose, WB700 (pSAKBQ), which contains the SAK gene undersacB promoter, yieldedca. 35% more SAK than the batch culture. These results present efficient promoter-dependent control strategies inB. subtilis host system for foreign protein expression.     

Construction and use of integrative vectors to express foreign genes in mycobacteria

We have constructed a mycobacterial integrative vector by placing two copies of the insertion sequence IS900 flanking a kanamycin-resistance gene into a 'suicide’vector unable to replicate in mycobacteria. The Mycobacterium leprae gene encoding the M. leprae 18kDa protein was cloned between the two copies of IS900 to provide expression signals. Constructs were introduced into Mycobacterium species smegmatis, vaccae and bovis BCG by electroporation and selection for kanamycin resistance. The expression of the 18 kDa gene was analysed by Western blotting. Integration of the vector into the M. smegmatis chromosome was analysed by Southern blotting. One to five copies of the vector were detected in each transformant. The SIV gag p27 gene and the foot-and-mouth disease virus VP1 140-160 epitope were successfully cloned into the 18kDa gene and expression in M. smegmatis was obtained.     

Interallelic complementation at the pyrF locus and the homodimeric nature of orotate phosphoribosyltransferase (OPRTase) in Mucor circinelloides

Using 5-fluoroorotic acid (5-FOA) as a positive selection system we isolated mutants of Mucor circinelloides altered in the pyrimidine biosynthetic pathway. These mutants were found to be deficient either in orotidine-5′-monophosphate decarboxylase (OMPdecase), or in orotate phosphoribosyltransferase (OPRTase) activity. Complementation tests among mutants lacking OPRTase activity classified them into three groups, thus suggesting the possibility of interallelic complementation. To investigate this hypothesis a cDNA clone corresponding to the OPRTase-encoding gene of M. circinelloides was isolated by direct complementation of E. coli. The genomic copy transformed to prototrophy one member of each of the three classes of OPRTase-deficient mutants. We therefore concluded that they were all altered at the same locus, the pyrF locus. The corresponding alleles were cloned and sequenced. Comparisons of the amino acid sequence of M. circinelloides OPRTase with those of E. coli and S. typhimurium revealed a high degree of similarity in secondary and tertiary structure. As the two bacterial enzymes exist as dimers, a homodimeric quaternary structure of the M. circinelloides mature protein can be assumed. This would also explain the interallelic complementation between some pyrF mutants. The mutations found could affect either the active site or the structure of the dimer interface of the OPRTase. Received: 22 May 1998 / Accepted: 13 August 1998     

sacB-5-Fluoroorotic acid-pyrE-based bidirectional selection for integration of unmarked alleles into the chromosome of Rhodobacter capsulatus

The gram-negative, purple nonsulfur, facultative photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus is a widely used model organism and has well-developed molecular genetics. In particular, interposon mutagenesis using selectable gene cartridges is frequently employed for construction of a variety of chromosomal knockout mutants. However, as the gene cartridges are often derived from antibiotic resistance-conferring genes, their numbers are limited, which restricts the construction of multiple knockout mutants. In this report, sacB-5-fluoroorotic acid (5FOA)--pyrE-based bidirectional selection that facilitates construction of unmarked chromosomal knockout mutations is described. The R. capsulatus pyrE gene encoding orotate phosphoribosyl transferase, a key enzyme of the de novo pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthesis pathway, was used as an interposon in a genetic background that is auxotrophic for uracil (Ura-) and hence resistant to 5FOA (5FOA(r)). Although Ura+ selection readily yielded chromosomal allele replacements via homologous recombination, selection for 5FOA(r) to replace pyrE with unmarked alleles was inefficient. To improve the latter step, 5FOA(r) selection was combined with sucrose tolerance selection using a suicide plasmid carrying the Bacillus subtilis sacB gene encoding levansucrase that induces lethality upon exposure to 5% (wt/vol) sucrose in the growth medium. Sucrose-tolerant, 5FOA(r) colonies that were obtained carried chromosomal unmarked mutant alleles of the target gene via double crossovers between the resident pyrE-marked and incoming unmarked alleles. The effectiveness of this double selection was proven by seeking insertion and deletion alleles of helC involved in R. capsulatus cytochrome c biogenesis, which illustrated the usefulness of this system as a genetic means for facile construction of R. capsulatus unmarked chromosomal mutants.     

A Simple Method for Multiple Modification of the Escherichia coli K-12 Chromosome

We developed a simple method of generating markerless deletions in the Escherichia coli chromosome. The method consists of two recombination events stimulated by λ Red recombinase. The first recombination replaced a target region with a marker cassette and the second then eliminated the marker cassette. The marker cassette included an antibiotic resistant gene and a negative selection marker (Bacillus subtilis sacB). Since sacB makes E. coli sensitive to sucrose, a markerless deletion strain was successfully selected using its sucrose-resistant phenotype. To stimulate these recombination events, 1-kbp homologous sequences adjacent to the target region were connected to both ends of the marker cassette or connected to each other by PCR. The average efficiency of the recombinations was 24% and 93% respectively. Eliminating the marker cassette with a fragment including an additional sequence, insertion was also possible. This markerless deletion method should be useful in creating a highly modified E. coli chromosome.     

The Generation of Successive Unmarked Mutations and Chromosomal Insertion of Heterologous Genes in Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae Using Natural Transformation

We have developed a simple method of generating scarless, unmarked mutations in Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae by exploiting the ability of this bacterium to undergo natural transformation, and with no need to introduce plasmids encoding recombinases or resolvases. This method involves two successive rounds of natural transformation using linear DNA: the first introduces a cassette carrying cat (which allows selection by chloramphenicol) and sacB (which allows counter-selection using sucrose) flanked by sequences to either side of the target gene; the second transformation utilises the flanking sequences ligated directly to each other in order to remove the cat-sacB cassette. In order to ensure efficient uptake of the target DNA during transformation, A. pleuropneumoniae uptake sequences are added into the constructs used in both rounds of transformation. This method can be used to generate multiple successive deletions and can also be used to introduce targeted point mutations or insertions of heterologous genes into the A. pleuropneumoniae chromosome for development of live attenuated vaccine strains. So far, we have applied this method to highly transformable isolates of serovars 8 (MIDG2331), which is the most prevalent in the UK, and 15 (HS143). By screening clinical isolates of other serovars, it should be possible to identify other amenable strains.     

Adaptation of the Yeast URA3 Selection System to Gram-Negative Bacteria and Generation of a ΔbetCDE Pseudomonas putida Strain

A general procedure for efficient generation of gene knockouts in gram-negative bacteria by the adaptation of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae URA3 selection system is described. A Pseudomonas putida strain lacking the URA3 homolog pyrF (encoding orotidine-5′-phosphate decarboxylase) was constructed, allowing the use of a plasmid-borne copy of the gene as the target of selection. The delivery vector pTEC contains the pyrF gene and promoter, a conditional origin of replication (oriR6K), an origin of transfer (mobRK2), and an antibiotic selection marker flanked by multiple sites for cloning appropriate DNA segments. The versatility of pyrF as a selection system, allowing both positive and negative selection of the marker, and the robustness of the selection, where pyrF is associated with uracil prototrophy and fluoroorotic acid sensitivity, make this setup a powerful tool for efficient homologous gene replacement in gram-negative bacteria. The system has been instrumental for complete deletion of the P. putida choline-O-sulfate utilization operon betCDE, a mutant which could not be produced by any of the other genetic strategies available.     

Gene Replacement in Mycobacteria by Using Incompatible Plasmids

A simple and efficient delivery system was developed for making targeted gene knockouts in Mycobacterium smegmatis. This delivery system relies on the use of a pair of replicating plasmids, which are incompatible. Incompatible plasmids share elements of the same replication machinery and so compete with each other during both replication and partitioning into daughter cells. Such plasmids can be maintained together in the presence of antibiotics; however, removal of selection leads to the loss of one or both plasmids. For mutagenesis, two replicating plasmids based on pAL5000 are introduced; one of these plasmids carries a mutated allele of the targeted gene. Homologous recombination is allowed to take place, and either one or both of the vectors are lost through the pressure of incompatibility, allowing the phenotypic effects of the mutant to be studied. Several different plasmid combinations were tested to optimize loss in the absence of antibiotic selection. pAL5000 carries two replication genes (repA and repB), which act in trans, and the use of vectors that each lack one rep gene and complement each other resulted in the loss of both plasmids in M. smegmatis and Mycobacterium bovis BCG. The rate of loss was increased by the incorporation of an additional incompatibility region in one of the plasmids. To facilitate cloning when the system was used, we constructed plasmid vector pairs that allow simple addition of selection and screening genes on flexible gene cassettes. Using this system, we demonstrated that M. smegmatis pyrF mutants could be isolated at high frequency. This method should also be useful in other species in which pAL5000 replicates, including Mycobacterium tuberculosis.     

Catecholates and mixed catecholate hydroxamates as artificial siderophores for mycobacteria

Different mono-, bis- or triscatecholates and mixed mono- or biscatecholate hydroxamates were synthesized as potential siderophores for mycobacteria. Siderophore activity was tested by growth promotion assays using wild type strains and iron transport mutants of mycobacteria as well as Gram-negative bacteria. Some triscatecholates and biscatecholate hydroxamates were active in mutants of Mycobacterium smegmatis deficient in mycobactin and exochelin biosynthesis or exochelin permease, respectively, indicating an uptake route independent of the exochelin/mycobactin pathway. Structure activity relationships were studied. Ampicillin conjugates of some of these compounds were inactive against mycobacteria but active against Gram-negative bacteria.