High viable cell concentration fed-batch cultures of hybridoma cells through on-line nutrient feeding

A hybridoma cell line was cultivated in fed-batch cultures using a low-protein, serum-free medium. On-line oxygen uptake rate (OUR) measurement was used to adjust the nutrient feeding rate based on glucose consumption, which was estimated on-line using the stoichiometric relations between glucose and oxygen consumption. Through on-line control of the nutrient feeding rate, not only sufficients were supplied for cell growth and antibody production, but also the concentrations of glucose and other important nutrients such as amino acids were maintained at low levels during the cell growth phase. During the cultivation, cell metabolism changed from high lactate production and low oxygen consumption to low lactate production and high oxygen consumption. As a result the accumulation of lactate was reduced and the growth phase was extended. In comparison with the batch cultures, in which cells reached a concentration of approximately 2 x 10(6) cells/mL, a very high concentration of 1.36 x 10(7) cells/mL with a high cell viability (>90%) was achieved in the fed-batch culture. By considering the consumption of glucose and amino acids, as well as the production of cell mass, metabolites, and antibodies, a well-closed material balance was established. Our results demonstrate the value of coupling on-line OUR measurement and the stoichiometric realations for dynamic nutrient feeding in high cell concentration fed batch cultures. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Gamma-interferon production and quality in stoichiometric fed-batch cultures of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells under serum-free conditions

The application of a stoichiometric medium design approach was studied in fed-batch cultivation of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. A serum-free medium containing a very low protein concentration (2 mg/L insulin) was developed. A supplemental medium was formulated according to the stoichiometric equation governing cell growth using cell composition obtained from hybridoma cells. Fed-batch culture was conducted in spinner flasks using the supplemental medium for feeding. Significant improvement in cell growth, by-product reduction, and Gamma-Interferon (IFN-gamma) production was achieved as compared to a typical batch culture. Results indicate that the stoichiometric approach, originally developed for hybridoma cultures, is a fast and effective method for cell culture process design and improvement. The glycosylation of IFN-gamma was monitored off-line during the culture process. The accumulative IFN-gamma glycosylation efficiency was slightly improved as compared to that of the batch culture, due to the nutritional control through the stoichiometric feeding. Periodic glucose starvation was observed during the fed-batch culture as a result of the manual feeding. Pulse-chase radiolabeling assay shows that glucose starvation leads to a deteriorated IFN-gamma glycosylation efficiency. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 56: 577-582, 1997.     

Alteration of mammalian cell metabolism by dynamic nutrient feeding

The metabolism of hybridoma cells was controlled to reduce metabolic formation in fed-batch cultures by dynamically feeding a salt-free nutrient concentrate. For this purpose, on-line oxygen uptake rate (OUR) measurement was used to estimate the metabolic demand of hybridoma cells and to determine the feeding rate of a concentrated solution of salt-free DMEM/F12 medium supplemented with other medium components. The ratios among glucose, glutamine and other medium components in the feeding nutrient concentrate were adjusted stoichiometrically to provide balanced nutrient conditions for cell growth. Through on-line control of the feeding rate of the nutrient concentrate, both glucose and glutamine concentrations were maintained at low levels of 0.5 and 0.2 mM respectively during the growth stage. The concentrations of the other essential amino acids were also maintained without large fluctuations. The cell metabolism was altered from that observed in batch cultures resulting in a significant reduction of lactate, ammonia and alanine production. Compared to a previously reported fed-batch culture in which only glucose was maintained at a low level and only a reduced lactate production was observed, this culture has also reduced the production of other metabolites, such as ammonium and alanine. As a result, a high viable cell concentration of more than 1.0 × 10⁷ cells/mL was achieved and sustained over an extended period. The results demonstrate an efficient nutrient feeding strategy for controlling cell metabolism to achieve and sustain a high viable cell concentration in fed-batch mammalian cell cultures in order to enhance the productivity. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

On-line characterization of a hybridoma cell culture process

The on-line determination of the physiological state of a cell culture process requires reliable on-line measurements of various parameters and calculations of specific rates from these measurements. The cell concentration of a hybridoma culture was estimated on-line by measuring optical density (OD) with a laser turbidity probe. The oxygen uptake rate (OUR) was determined by monitoring dynamically dissolved oxygen concentration profiles and closing oxygen balances in the culture. The base addition for neutralizing lactate produced by cells was also monitored on-line via a balance. Using OD and OUR measurements, the specific growth and specific oxygen consumption rates were determined on-line. By combining predetermined stoichiometric relationships among oxygen and glucose consumption and lactate production, the specific glucose consumption and lactate production rates were also calculated on-line. Using these on-line measurements and calculations, the hybridoma culture process was characterized on-line by identifying the physiological states. They will also facilitate the implementation of nutrient feeding strategies for fed-batch and perfusion cultures. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Improving an on-line feeding strategy for fed-batch cultures of hybridoma cells by dialysis and `Nutrient-Split'-feeding

The concept of the feeding strategy was to minimise the formation of inhibiting metabolites and to increase the yield of monoclonal antibodies in fed-batch cultures of hybridoma cells by a balanced supply of substrates. A process control system based on fieldbus technology was used for monitoring and control. External program routines were implemented to control dissolved oxygen (DO) and to calculate the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) and cumulative oxygen consumption (COC) simultaneously. A concentrated feed solution was supplied according to the off-line estimated stoichiometric ratio between oxygen and glucose consumption (GC). Feeding was initiated automatically when the OUR decreased due to substrate limitation. The antibody concentration increased three-fold compared to the conventional batch culture by applying this strategy. But it was not possible to avoid inhibition by ammonia during the fed-batch phase. This was accomplished by the use of a dialysis membrane. Dialysis fed-batch cultures were performed in a membrane dialysis reactor with a `nutrient-split' feeding strategy, where concentrated medium is fed to the cells and toxic metabolites are removed into a buffer solution. This resulted in a ten-fold increase of the antibody concentration compared to the batch. Amino acid concentrations were analysed to identify limiting conditions during the cultivation and to analyse the performance of the nutrient supply in the fed-batch and dialysis fed-batch.     

Analysis of metabolic flux in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis> expressing human-like collagen in fed-batch culture

Metabolic flux distributions of recombinant Escherichia coli BL21 expressing human-like collagen were determined by means of a stoichiometric network and metabolic balancing. At the batch growth stage, the fluxes of the pentose phosphate pathway were higher than the fluxes of the fed-batch growth phase and the production stage. After the temperature was increased, there was a substantially elevated energy demand for synthesizing human-like collagen and heat-shock proteins, which resulted in changes in metabolic fluxes. The activities of the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas pathway and the tricarboxylic acid cycle were significantly enhanced, leading to a reduction in the fluxes of the pentose phosphate pathway and other anabolic pathways. The temperature upshift also caused an increase in NADPH production by isocitrate dehydrogenase in the tricarboxylic acid cycle. The metabolic model predicted the involvement of a transhydrogenase that generates additional NADH from NADPH, thereby increasing ATP regeneration in the respiratory chain. These data indicated that the maintenance energy for cellular activity increased with the increase in biomass in fed-batch culture, and that cell growth and synthesis of human-like collagen could clearly represent the changes in metabolic fluxes. At the production stage, more NADPH was used to synthesize human-like collagen than for maintaining cellular activity, cell growth, and cell propagation. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

A serum substitute for fed-batch culturing of hybridoma cells

We developed a substitute for serum to produce fed-batch cultures of hybridoma cells in serum-free medium and confirmed that the cells could be successfully cultivated this way. Our substitute consisted of 12 components. The specific production rates of lactate and ammonia, which are harmful byproducts from the cells, were significantly reduced compared with a conventional serum-containing batch culture. This reduction led to a higher cell concentration and a longer production lifetime. As a result, the final concentration of monoclonal antibody was 400 mg/L, or five times greater than that in the conventional serum-containing batch culture. The developed substitute is expected to enable fed-batch cultivation in a serum-free condition.     

Fed-batch cultivation of animal cells using different medium design concepts and feeding strategies

In animal cell cultivation, cell density and product concentration are often low due to the accumulation of toxic end-products such as ammonia and lactate and/or the depletion of essential nutrients. A hybridoma cell line (CRL-1606) was cultivated in T-flasks using a newly devised medium feeding strategy. The goals were to decrease ammonia and lactate formation by the design of an initial medium which would provide a starting environment to achieve optimal cell growth. This was followed by using a stoichiometric equation governing animal cell growth and then designing a supplemental medium for feeding strategy used to control the nutritional environment. The relationship between the stoichiometric demands for glutamine and nonessential amino acids was also studied. Through stoichiometric feeding, nutrient concentrations were controlled reasonably well. Consequently, the specific production rate of lactate was decreased by fourfold compared with conventional fed-batch culture and by 26-fold compared with conventional batch culture. The specific production rate of ammonia was decreased by tenfold compared with conventional fed-batch culture and by 50-fold compared with conventional batch culture. Most importantly, total cell density and monoclonal antibody concentration were increased by five- and tenfold respectively, compared with conventional batch culture. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Enhanced productivity of Protein C by recombinant human cells in automated fed-batch cultures

Recombinant human kidney cells, 293, were cultivated in serum-free fed-batch cultures for the production of Protein C. By coupling the feeding of concentrated medium to pH control based on established stoichiometric relations, the titer of Protein C increased by more than ten fold as compared to batch culture, even though the total cell concentration increased only by less than two fold. Such a fed-batch culture is a simple system for enhancing the productivity of mammalian cells in culture.     

An unstructured kinetic model of macromolecular metabolism in batch and fed-batch cultures of hybridoma cells producing monoclonal antibody

Growth profiles of the batch and fed-batch culture of hybridoma cells producing monoclonal antibody were simulated using an unstructured model. The model describes the production of cellular macromolecules and monoclonal antibody, the metabolism of glucose and glutamine with the production of lactate and ammonia, and the profiles of cell growth in batch and fed-batch culture. Equations describing the cells arrested in G1 phase [T.I. Linardos, N. Kalogerakis, L.A. Behie, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 40 (1992) 359–368; E. Suzuki, D.F. Ollis, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 34 (1989) 1398–1402] were included in this model to describe the increase of the specific antibody productivity in the near-zero specific growth rate, which was observed in the recent experiments in fed-batch cultures of this study and the semi-continuous culture of hybridoma cells [S. Reuveny, D. Velez, L. Miller, J.D. Macmillan, J. Immnol. Methods 86 (1986) 61–69]. This model predicted the increase of specific antibody production rate and the decline of the specific production rate of cellular macromolecules such as DNA, RNA, protein, and polysaccharide in the late exponential and decline phase of batch culture and at lower specific growth rates in the fed-batch culture.     

Influence of culture modes on the microbial production of hyaluronic acid by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Streptococcus zooepidemicus</Emphasis>

The principal objective of this study was to assess the effects of culture modes including batch culture, pulse fed-batch culture, constant feeding rate fed-batch culture, and exponential fed-batch culture on the production of hyaluronic acid (HA) by Streptococcus zooepidemicus. Batch cultures had the highest levels of HA productivity, whereas fed-batch cultures were more favorable with regard to cell growth, and exponential fed-batch cultures evidenced the highest cell concentrations. A two-step culture model was proposed to enhance HA production: an exponential fed-batch culture was conducted prior to 8 h and then sucrose supplementation was applied for 8 h to start the batch fermentation of S. zooepidemicus. HA production and productivity were increased by 36 and 37% in the proposed two-step culture process as compared with that observed in the batch culture, respectively. The proposed two-step culture model can be applied in the production of secondary metabolites, and particularly of the exopolysaccharides.     

Applications of improved stoichiometric model in medium design and fed-batch cultivation of animal cells in bioreactor

In our previous work (Xie and Wang, 1994a), a simplified stoichiometric model on energy metabolism for animal cell cultivation was developed. Fed-batch experiments were performed in T-flasks using this model in supplemental medium design (Xie and Wang, 1994b). In this work, the major pathways of glucose and glutamine metabolism were incorporated into the stoichiometric model. Fed-batch culture was conducted in a 2-liter bioreactor with appropriate process control strategies. Nutrient concentrations, especially glucose and glutamine, were maintained at constant but low levels through the automated feeding of a supplemental medium formulated using the improved stoichiometric model. The formation of toxic byproducts, such as ammonia and lactate (Hassellet al., 1991), was greatly reduced. The specific lactate production rate was decreased by 62-fold compared with batch culture in bioreactor and by 8-fold compared to fed-batch culture in T-flask using the previous stoichiometric model. Ammonia formation was also decreased compared with both the batch and fed-batch cultures. Most importantly, the monoclonal antibody concentration reached 900 mg l^?1, an increase of 17- and 1.6-fold compared with the batch and fed-batch cultures respectively.     

Analysis of mammalian viable cell biomass based on cellular ATP

Analysis of cellular ATP as a means of measuring viable biomass loading was investigated in hybridoma cell culture. ATP analysis by the luciferin-luciferase assay was compared with trypan blue-stained hemocytometer counts. The cell-specific ATP content varied between 2 and 6 fmol per viable cell over a batch culture. ATP levels were highest during exponential growth, and decreased during the stationary and decline phases. Electronic counting and volume measurements were performed to assay the viable cell biomass. Cell sorting, using fluorescein diacetate, was used to separate viable and nonviable cells in cultures with between 35% and 90% viable cells. Viable cells contained over 2 orders of magnitude greater cell-specific ATP than nonviable cells. Cell-specific ATP correlated directly with the viable cell volume rather than viable cell numbers. Over the range of batch culture conditions, ATP analysis should provide a more accurate measurement of hybridoma viable biomass than hemocytometer counts.     

Application of hypoosmolar medium to fed-batch culture of hybridoma cells for improvement of culture longevity

Cell culture longevity in fed-batch culture of hybridomas is often limited by elevated medium osmolality caused by repeated nutrient feeding. Shotwise feeding of 10x Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) concentrates elevated the osmolality of medium up to 540 mOsm/kg at the end of fed-batch culture of S3H5/gamma2bA2 hybridoma which is known to be lethal to most hybridomas. S3H5/gamma2bA2 hybridoma has been shown to grow without significant growth depression at 219 mOsm/kg in DMEM supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum. To improve culture longevity in fed-batch cultures of S3H5/gamma2bA2 hybridoma, a hypoosmolar medium (223 mOsm/kg) was used as an initial basal medium. The use of hypoosmolar medium delayed the onset of severe cell death resulting from elevated osmolality and allowed one more addition of 10x DMEM concentrates to the culture. As a result, a final antibody concentration obtained was 121.5 microg/mL which is approximately 1.5-fold higher compared to fed-batch culture using a standard medium (335 mOsm/kg). When compared to batch culture, a more than 5-fold increase in the final antibody concentration was achieved. Taken together, the use of hypoosmolar medium as an initial medium in fed-batch culture improved culture longevity of S3H5/gamma2bA2 hybridoma, resulting in a substantial increase in the final antibody concentration.     

High cell density and high monoclonal antibody production through medium design and rational control in a bioreactor

A simple feeding strategy was developed and successfully employed for nutritional control in a 2-L fed-batch culture of hybridoma cells. A previously developed stoichiometric model for animal cell growth was used to design a supplemental medium for feeding. Undialyzed fetal bovine serum and trace metals (Fe(2+), SeO(3) (2-), Li(+), Zn(2+), and Cu(2+)) were fed to the cells periodically in addition to the automatic feeding of other nutrients in the supplemental medium. In this study, the maximum viable cell density was increased from 6.3 x 10(6) to 1.7 x 10(7) cells/mL, and the culture span was extended from 340 to 550 hours. The final monoclonal antibody titer achieved was 2400 mg/L. The specific production rates for ammonia and lactate were further reduced from 0.0045 and 0.0048 in our previous fed-batch experiments to 0.0028 and 0.0036 mmol/10(9) cell h, respectively. Only 3.4% of the total glucose consumption was converted into lactate, compared to 67% in a conventional batch culture.     

Rapamycin reduces hybridoma cell death and enhances monoclonal antibody production

Rapamycin was used as a medium additive to slow the progression of CRL 1606 hybridomas through the cell cycle, under the hypothesis that such a modulation might reduce cell death. Cell cycle distributions for CRL hybridomas in the G1 phase of the cell cycle ranged from 20% to 35% during batch, fed-batch, and continuous culture experiments, independent of culture time, dilution rate, growth rates, or death rates. Rapamycin, an mTOR signaling inhibitor, immunosuppressant, and G1-phase arresting agent, was identified and tested for efficacy in restraining cell cycle progression in CRL 1606 hybridoma cultures. However, in the presence of 100 nM rapamycin, the percentage of cells in the G1 phase of the cell cycle during fed-batch cultures was only increased from 28% to 31% in control cultures to 37% to 48% for those with rapamycin. Accordingly, rapamycin only slightly reduced culture growth rate. Instead, the use of rapamycin more notably kept viability higher than that of control cultures by delaying cell death for 48 h, thereby enabling viable proliferation to higher maximum viable cell densities. Furthermore, rapamycin enhanced specific monoclonal antibody production by up to 100% during high-viability growth. Thus, over the course of 6-day fed-batch cultivations, the beneficial effects of rapamycin on viable cell density and specific productivity resulted in an increase in final monoclonal antibody titer from 0.25 to 0.56 g/L (124%). As rapamycin is reported to influence a much broader range of cellular functions than cell cycle alone, these findings are more illustrative of the influence that signal transduction pathways related to mTOR can have on overall cell physiology and culture productivity.     

Low-glutamine fed-batch cultures of 293-HEK serum-free suspension cells for adenovirus production

Recent developments in gene therapy using adenoviral (Ad) vectors have fueled renewed interest in the 293 human embryonic kidney cell line traditionally used to produce these vectors. Low-glutamine fed-batch cultures of serum-free, suspension cells in a 5-L bioreactor were conducted. Our aim was to tighten the control on glutamine metabolism and hence reduce ammonia and lactate accumulation. Online direct measurement of glutamine was effected via a continuous cell-exclusion system that allows for aseptic, cell-free sampling of the culture broth. A feedback control algorithm was used to maintain the glutamine concentration at a level as low as 0.1 mM with a concentrated glucose-free feed medium. This was tested in two media: a commercial formulation (SFM II) and a chemically defined DMEM/F12 formulation. The fed-batch and batch cultures were started at the same glucose concentration, and it was not controlled at any point in the fed-batch cultures. In all cases, fed-batch cultures with double the cell density and extended viable culture time compared to the batch cultures were achieved. An infection study on the high density fed-batch culture using adenovirus-green fluorescent protein (Ad-GFP) construct was also done to ascertain the production capacity of the culture. Virus titers from the infected fed-batch culture showed that there is an approximately 10-fold improvement over a batch infection culture. The results have shown that the control of glutamine at low levels in cultures is sufficient to yield significant improvements in both cell densities and viral production. The applicability of this fed-batch system to cultures in different media and also infected cultures suggests its potential for application to generic mammalian cell cultures.     

Dynamic optimization of hybridoma growth in a fed-batch bioreactor

This study addressed the problem of maximizing cell mass and monoclonal antibody production from a fed-batch hybridoma cell culture. We hypothesized that inaccuracies in the process model limited the mathematical optimization. On the basis of shaker flask data, we established a simple phenomenological model with cell mass and lactate production as the controlled variables. We then formulated an optimal control algorithm, which calculated the process-model mismatch at each sampling time, updated the model parameters, and re-optimized the substrate concentrations dynamically throughout the time course of the batch. Manipulated variables were feed rates of glucose and glutamine. Dynamic parameter adjustment was done using a fuzzy logic technique, while a heuristic random optimizer (HRO) optimized the feed rates. The parameters selected for updating were specific growth rate and the yield coefficient of lactate from glucose. These were chosen by a sensitivity analysis. The cell mass produced using dynamic optimization was compared to the cell mass produced for an unoptimized case, and for a one-time optimization at the beginning of the batch. Substantial improvements in reactor productivity resulted from dynamic re-optimization and parameter adjustment. We demonstrated first that a single offline optimization of substrate concentration at the start of the batch significantly increased the yield of cell mass by 27% over an unoptimized fermentation. Periodic optimization online increased yield of cell mass per batch by 44% over the single offline optimization. Concomitantly, the yield of monoclonal antibody increased by 31% over the off-line optimization case. For batch and fed-batch processes, this appears to be a suitable arrangement to account for inaccuracies in process models. This suggests that implementation of advanced yet inexpensive techniques can improve performance of fed-batch reactors employed in hybridoma cell culture.     

Fed-batch culture optimization of a growth-associated hybridoma cell line in chemically defined protein-free media

An investigation was made to study the processes of fed-batch cultures of a hybridoma cell line in chemically defined protein-free media. First of all, a strong growth-associated pattern was correlated between the production of MAb and growth of cells through the kinetic studies of batch cultures, suggesting the potential effectiveness of extending the duration of exponential growth in the improvement of MAb titers. Second, compositions of amino acids in the feeding solution were balanced stepwisely according to their stoichiometrical correlations with glucose uptake in batch and fed-batch cultures. Moreover, a limiting factor screening revealed the constitutive nature of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ for cell growth, and the importance of their feeding in fed-batch cultures. Finally, a fed-batch process was executed with a glucose uptake coupled feeding of balanced amino acids together with groups of nutrients and a feeding of CaCl₂ and MgCl₂ concentrate. The duration of exponential cell growth was extended from 70 h in batch culture and 98 h in fed-batch culture without Ca²⁺/Mg²⁺ feeding to 117 h with Ca²⁺/Mg²⁺ feeding. As a result of the prolonged exponential cell growth, the viable and total cell densities reached 7.04 × 10⁶ and 9.12 × 10⁶ cells ml⁻¹, respectively. The maximal MAb concentration achieved was increased to approximately eight times of that in serum supplemented batch culture.