Interaction of tight binding repressors with lac operators. An analysis by DNA-footprinting

To increase our understanding of protein-DNA interaction in general, and in particular that of lac repressor with lac operator, we have investigated the interaction of tight binding (Itb) repressors with wild type (WT) operator and Oc operators. Nine Oc and a WT operator were cloned and sequenced. Three different Oc and an O+ were then chosen for the footprint analysis of six Itb repressors and WT repressor. Distinct protection patterns for the various repressor-operator pairs were observed at low repressor concentrations whereas, at high repressor concentrations, a stretch of 24 bases of the lower strand of the four different operators was protected in most cases. This protection pattern at high repressor concentration was almost completely redundant for all repressor-operator pairs, in spite of the fact that the affinities of the various pairs differed by more than three orders of magnitude. Two exceptions to this general observation were the two tight binding repressors R67 and R78a. These had been mapped in a region that codes for amino acid residues involved in subunit interaction. The two repressors showed reduced protection of O+ and of some Oc operators at the 3' (right) end of the lower strand. Dimethylsulfoxide, which is known to increase the affinity of O+ for repressor, did not increase the number of bases protected by WT repressor on the lower strand of O+. The footprinting results presented here clearly demonstrate that lac repressor can maximally protect about 24 bases of the lower strand of the operator and that the number and kind of interactions occurring in this region determine the strength of the repressor-operator interaction.     

Tight-binding repressors of the lac operon: selection system and in vitro analysis.

The isolation and characterization of altered repressors of the lac operon which have an increased affinity for an operator should give useful clues about the molecular basis for the very tight and specific interaction between repressor and operator. A selection system has been devised which allows the isolation of such repressor mutants. This system selects for mutant repressors which can overcome lac operator-constitutive (Oc) mutations. By using in vivo assays, 24 candidates were obtained which, compared with wild type, have an increased trans effect of their repressor on one or several Oc operators. Three of these candidates have been investigated in vitro; the affinity of their repressor for inducer was unchanged, whereas the affinity for wild-type operator was increased 15-, 86-, and 262-fold, respectively.     

Effects of dominant-negative lac repressor mutations on operator specificity and protein stability

The specific binding of dominant-negative (I-d) lactose (lac) repressors to wild-type (wt) as well as mutant (Oc) lac operators has been examined to explore the sequence-specific interaction of the lac repressor with its target. Mutant lacI genes encoding substitutions in the N-terminal 60 amino acids (aa) were cloned in a derivative of plasmid pBR322. Twelve of these lacI-d missense mutations were transferred from F'lac episomes using general genetic recombination and molecular cloning, and nine lacI missense mutations were recloned from M13-lacI phages [Mott et al., Nucl. Acids Res. 12 (1984) 4139-4152]. The mutant repressors were examined for polypeptide size and stability, for binding the inducer isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG), as well as binding to wt operator. The mutant repressors' affinities for wt operator ranged from undetectable to about 1% that of wt repressor, and the mutant repressors varied in transdominance against repressor expressed from a chromosomal lacIq gene. Six of the I-d repressors were partially degraded in vivo. All repressors bound IPTG with approximately the affinity of wt repressor. Repressors having significant affinity for wt operator or with substitutions in the presumed operator recognition helix (aa 17-25) were examined in vivo for their affinities for a series of single site Oc operators. Whereas the Gly-18-, Ser-18- and Leu-18-substituted repressors showed altered specificity for position 7 of the operator [Ebright, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83 (1986) 303-307], the His-18 repressor did not affect specificity. This result may be related to the greater side-chain length of histidine compared to the other amino acid substitutions.     

Recognition of DNA by single-chain derivatives of the phage 434 repressor: high affinity binding depends on both the contacted and non-contacted base pairs.

Single-chain derivatives of the phage 434 repressor, termed single-chain repressors, contain covalently dimerized DNA-binding domains (DBD) which are connected with a peptide linker in a head-to-tail arrangement. The prototype RR69 contains two wild-type DBDs, while RR*69 contains a wild-type and an engineered DBD. In this latter domain, the DNA- contacting amino acids of thealpha3 helix of the 434 repressor are replaced by the corresponding residues of the related P22 repressor. We have used binding site selection, targeted mutagenesis and binding affinity studies to define the optimum DNA recognition sequence for these single-chain proteins. It is shown that RR69 recognizes DNA sequences containing the consensus boxes of the 434 operators in a palindromic arrangement, and that RR*69 optimally binds to non-palindromic sequences containing a 434 operator box and a TTAA box of which the latter is present in most P22 operators. The spacing of these boxes, as in the 434 operators, is 6 bp. The DNA-binding of both single-chain repressors, similar to that of the 434 repressor, is influenced indirectly by the sequence of the non-contacted, spacer region. Thus, high affinity binding is dependent on both direct and indirect recognition. Nonetheless, the single-chain framework can accommodate certain substitutions to obtain altered DNA-binding specificity and RR*69 represents an example for the combination of altered direct and unchanged indirect readout mechanisms.     

Degradation of the DNA-binding domain of wild-type and i-d lac repressors in Escherichia coli.

It has been shown that 28 transdominant mutant lac repressors which have lost operator DNA-binding ability in vivo and in vitro, but still bind inducer and are able to form tetramers (i-d repressors), could be divided into two groups by their capacity or incapacity to bind non-specifically to the phosphate groups of the DNA backbone. All but one of 15 analysed i-d repressors with amino acid substitutions to the C-terminal of residue 52 showed uneffected non-specific DNA binding. All 13 tested i-d repressors with amino acid substitutions to the N-terminal of residue 53 did not bind to double-stranded DNA, and 11 of these repressors derived from missense mutations in the lacI gene were endogenously degraded. The degradation in vivo only affects the amino-terminal 50-60 residues producing a mutant-specific pattern of stable repressor fragments. These fragments are tetrameric and capable of binding inducer in vivo and in vitro. The proteolytic attack presumably takes place during synthesis of the i-d repressors, since the resulting fragments are stable, both in vivo (as shown by a pulse-chase experiment) and in vitro. The proteolysis in vivo depends on the growth conditions of the bacteria and is higher in cells grown in minimal media than in rich media. Wild-type repressor is only susceptible to limited proteolysis in cells grown in minimal media but not in cells grown in rich media. The results suggest that the majority of the sequence alterations before residue 53 in missense mutant i-d lac repressor proteins affect the three-dimensional structure of the amino-terminal DNA-binding domain of the repressor protein, making it susceptible to proteolytic attack by one or several intracellular proteases.     

Mutant λ Repressors with Increased Operator Affinities Reveal New, Specific Protein-DNA Contacts

The binding specificities of four mutant lambda cI repressor proteins with increased affinities for operator DNA were examined. Two mutant repressors (Glu34----Lys and Glu83----Lys) have the same specificity of binding as wild-type repressor, whereas two (Gly48----Ser and Gly48----Asn) have new binding specificities. The Gly48----Asn mutant repressor recognizes lambda operators with changes at base pair 3 with a different order of affinity than wild-type repressor, suggesting that the side chain of Asn48 makes additional specific DNA contacts at or near this base pair. When paired with a change that disrupts the specific interaction of the amino-terminal arm of lambda repressor with DNA (Lys4----Gln), one change that increases the affinity of repressor (Gly48----Ser) suppresses the binding defect of the Lys4----Gln repressor, resulting in a double mutant repressor with a new binding specificity different than that of both its parents and of wild type. These results lend strong support to the model of direct recognition of the lambda operator by lambda repressor proposed from the crystal structure of the repressor/operator complex.     

Lambda repressor mutations that increase the affinity and specificity of operator binding

Intragenic, second-site reversion has been used to identify amino acid substitutions that increase the affinity and specificity of the binding of lambda repressor to its operator sites. Purified repressors bearing the second-site substitutions bind operator DNA from 3 to 600 fold more strongly than wild type; these affinity changes result from both increased rates of operator association and decreased rates of operator dissociation. Three of the revertant substitutions occur in the alpha 2 and alpha 3 DNA binding helices of repressor and seem to increase affinity by introducing new salt-bridges or hydrogen bonds with the sugar-phosphate backbone of the operator site. The fourth substitution alters the alpha 5 dimerization helix of repressor and appears to increase operator affinity indirectly.     

TET repressor.tet operator complex formation induces conformational changes in the tet operator DNA.

The structural changes of the tet operator DNA upon binding of the TET repressor protein are examined by circular dichroism. For this purpose a 70 bp DNA fragment was prepared which contains both tet operators. About 67% of the base pairs of this DNA are involved in specific interaction with the TET repressor. A rather large change in the CD of the DNA is induced by binding of the TET repressor. The shape of the CD difference spectrum is similar to the respective difference found for the lac operator DNA upon complex formation with the lac repressor. However, the effect induced by the TET repressor on tet operator DNA seems to comprise both the specific and non-specific effect of the lac repressor on the structure of DNA [Culard, F. and Maurizot, J.C. (1981) Nucl. Acids Res. 9, 5157-5184]. Specificity of binding is confirmed by the lack of any effect of the TET repressor on the CD of a 95 bp lac operator containing DNA fragment, by the reduced mobility of TET repressor.tet operator complexes on polyacrylamide gels under CD conditions, and by a titration experiment of tet operator DNA with TET repressor employing the CD change. The latter experiment reveals a stoichiometry of four TET repressors per tet operon control region.     

Interaction of mutant lambda repressors with operator and non-operator DNA

We have described a set of mutations that alter side-chains on the operator binding surface of lambda repressor. In this paper, we study the interactions of 12 purified mutant repressors with operator and non-operator DNA. The mutant proteins have operator affinities that are reduced from tenfold to greater than 10,000-fold compared to wild-type. Nine of the mutants have affinities for non-operator DNA that are similar to wild-type, two mutants show decreased non-specific binding, and one mutant has increased affinity for non-operator DNA. We discuss these findings in terms of the structural and energetic contributions of side-chain--DNA interactions, and show that certain contacts between the repressor and the operator backbone contribute both energy and specificity to the interaction.     

Lac repressor — Lac operator complexes

Complexes between the Lac repressor and a small DNA operator fragment (29 base pairs) were investigated using polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and solution X-ray scattering. Titration of the DNA fragment with the repressor, followed by gel electrophoresis showed that only two types of complexes are formed with repressor/operator ratios of 0.5 and 2. Radii of gyration and forward scattered intensities were obtained from Guinier plots for repressor/operator ratios ranging from 0.3 to 2. They demonstrated that the first complex contains one repressor and two operators, whereas the second one contains four repressors and two operators. Mixing operator and repressor in equimolar concentrations leads to a mixture of both complexes. A possible model for the four repressor/two operator complex is proposed.     

The NH2-terminal arms of trp repressor participate in repressor/operator association.

The 3-dimensional structure of the trp repressor, aporepressor, and repressor/operator complex have been described. The NH2-terminal arms of the protein, comprising approximately 12-14 residues, were not well resolved in any of these structures. Previous studies by Carey showed that the arms are required for full in vitro repressor activity. To examine the roles of the arms more fully we have removed codons 2-5 and 2-8 of the trpR gene and analyzed the resulting truncated repressors in vivo and in vitro. The delta 2-5 trp repressor was found to be approximately 25% as active as the wild type repressor in vivo. In in vitro equilibrium binding experiments, the delta 2-5 trp repressor was shown to be five-fold less active in operator binding. The rate of dissociation of the complex formed between the delta 2-5 trp repressor and operator was essentially the same as the rate of dissociation of the wild type trp repressor/operator complex. However association of the delta 2-5 trp repressor with operator was clearly defective. Since the NH2-terminal arms of the trp repressor appear to affect association predominantly they may play a role in facilitating non-specific association of repressor with DNA as repressor seeks its cognate operators. The delta 2-8 trp repressor was unstable in vivo and in vitro, suggesting that some portion of the NH2-terminal arm is required for proper folding of the remainder of the molecule.     

DNA-binding site of lac repressor probed by dimethylsulfate methylation of lac operator.

In order to compare the structures of the DNA-binding sites on variants of the lac repressor, we have studied the influence of these variants on the dimethylsulfate methylation of the lac operator. Since a bound protein changes the availability of specific purines in the operator to this chemical attack, comparisons of the methylation patterns will show similarities or differences in the protein DNA contacts. We compared lac repressor, induced lac repressor (repressor bound to the gratuitous inducer isopropyl-β-d-thiogalactoside), mutant repressors having increased operator affinities (X86, I12 and the X86-I12 double mutant) and repressor peptides (long headpiece, residues 1 to 59 and short headpiece. residues 1 to 51). All of these repressors and repressor peptides exhibit the same general pattern of protection and enhancement in the operator; however, the short headpiece pattern differs most from that of the repressor while the induced repressor and the long headpiece show intermediate patterns that are strikingly similar to each other. The mutant repressors do not show an isopropyl-β-d-thiogalactoside effect but otherwise are almost indistinguishable from wild-type repressor. These results demonstrate that all molecules bind to the operator using basically the same protein-DNA contacts; they imply that (1) most and possibly all repressor contacts to operator lie within amino acids 1 to 51, (2) inducer weakens many contacts rather than totally disrupting one or even a few and (3) the tight-binding mutants do not make additional contacts to the DNA.These results are consistent with a model in which the amino-terminal portions of two repressor monomers make the DNA contacts. We show that one can understand the affinity of binding as related to the accuracy of the register of the two amino-terminal portions along the DNA. Furthermore, the action of inducer and the behaviour of the tight binding mutants can be accomodated within a two-state model in which the strongly or weakly binding states correspond to structures in which the amino-terminal regions are rigidly or loosely held with respect to each other.     

Cloning and characterization of several dominant-negative and tight-binding mutants of lac repressor

Using both general recombination and molecular cloning techniques, 13I-, I-d and Itb missense mutations in the lacI gene were transferred from F'lacIq episomes to ColE1 derivative plasmids. Two deletion derivatives of the lacI genes encoding the wild-type (wt) and the tight-binding (Itb) B3 and B5 repressors were also constructed. The mutant repressors were examined for polypeptide size and stability, and for binding to the inducer isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG). Several of the I-d repressors were shown to be partially degraded in vivo, in confirmation of earlier results based on [14C]IPTG binding [Miwa and Sadler, J. Mol. Biol. 117 (1977) 843-868]. The sizes of polypeptides produced by lacI deletion derivatives were consistent with expectations based on the extent of deletion and the location of termination sites within the plasmid sequence. The first 400 bp of several mutant lacI genes were sequenced. Our wt lacI gene differs from another wt lacI sequence (Farabaugh, 1978), containing a single bp change that results in an Ala to Thr substitution at amino acid (aa) 109. We identified bp substitutions and the resultant aa changes for two Itb and two I-d genes; the positions correlated with prior genetic mapping data. Three of these new changes were in the N-terminal domain (headpiece) of repressor, with one change in the core domain at aa 99.     

The N-Terminal Domain of the Repressor of Staphylococcus aureus Phage Φ11 Possesses an Unusual Dimerization Ability and DNA Binding Affinity

Bacteriophage Φ11 uses Staphylococcus aureus as its host and, like lambdoid phages, harbors three homologous operators in between its two divergently oriented repressor genes. None of the repressors of Φ11, however, showed binding to all three operators, even at high concentrations. To understand why the DNA binding mechanism of Φ11 repressors does not match that of lambdoid phage repressors, we studied the N-terminal domain of the Φ11 lysogenic repressor, as it harbors a putative helix-turn-helix motif. Our data revealed that the secondary and tertiary structures of the N-terminal domain were different from those of the full-length repressor. Nonetheless, the N-terminal domain was able to dimerize and bind to the operators similar to the intact repressor. In addition, the operator base specificity, binding stoichiometry, and binding mechanism of this domain were nearly identical to those of the whole repressor. The binding affinities of the repressor and its N-terminal domain were reduced to a similar extent when the temperature was increased to 42°C. Both proteins also adequately dislodged a RNA polymerase from a Φ11 DNA fragment carrying two operators and a promoter. Unlike the intact repressor, the binding of the N-terminal domain to two adjacent operator sites was not cooperative in nature. Taken together, we suggest that the dimerization and DNA binding abilities of the N-terminal domain of the Φ11 repressor are distinct from those of the DNA binding domains of other phage repressors.     

Deoxyribonucleic acid-binding studies on the hut repressor and mutant forms of the hut repressor of Salmonella typhimurium.

In Salmonella typhimurium the genes coding for the enzymes of histidine utilization (hut) are clustered in two adjacent operons, hutMIGC and hut(P,R,Q)UH. A single repressor, the product of the C gene, regulates both operons by binding at two operator sites, one near M and one in (P,R,Q). The deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA)-binding activity of the repressor was measured using DNA's containing separate operators. The repressor had greater activity when assayed using DNA containing the operator of the (P,R,Q)UH operon than when assayed using DNA containing the operator of the MIGC operon. The binding to either operator was absent in the presence of the inducer, urocanate. The DNA-binding activities were also determined for two super-repressors. The super-repressors had altered DNA-binding properties, although the self-regulated nature of the repressors complicated the analysis of the results. A purfication procedure for the wild-type repressor is presented. The purified repressor was somewhat unstable, and additional experiments using it were not performed.     

Enhanced operator binding by trp superrepressors of Escherichia coli

The trp repressor of Escherichia coli binds to the operators of three operons concerned with tryptophan biosynthesis and regulates their expression. trp superrepressors can repress expression of the trp operon in vivo at lower tryptophan concentrations than those required by the wild-type repressor. The five known superrepressors have been purified and characterized using a modified filter binding assay. In four of the five superrepressors, EK13, EK18, DN46 and EK49, negatively charged wild-type residues located on the surface of the repressor that faces the operator are replaced by positively charged or neutral residues. Each of these proteins has higher affinity for the trp operator than wild-type repressor. Decreased rates of dissociation of the repressor-operator complex were found to be responsible for the higher affinities. The fifth superrepressor, AV77, has an amino acid substitution in the turn of the helix-turn-helix DNA-binding motif. This superrepressor was indistinguishable from wild-type repressor in our filter binding assay. We conclude that rapid dissociation of repressor from operator is important for trp repressor function in vivo. The negatively charged wild-type residues that are replaced in superrepressors are probably responsible for the characteristic rapid dissociation of the trp repressor from the trp operator.     

Studies of gene control regions. III. Binding of synthetic and modified synthetic lac operator DNAs to lactose repressor.

Chemically synthesized lactose operator DNA was tested for binding with lactose repressor protein. These operator DNAs were found to (1) bind specifically to lactose SQ repressor as measured by release of binding with the inducing ligand isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactoside, (2) have dissociation half-lives of 37 seconds (21 base-paired duplex) and 46 seconds (26 base-paired duplex) and (3) have dissociation half-lives with x86 repressor of 9 minutes (21 base-paired duplex) and 18 minutes (26 base paired duplex). Modified operators containing 5-bromodeoxyuridine and deoxyuridine at specific sites were also prepared. These analogs bound both repressors about as tightly as the wild type sequence.     

Mutant lac repressors with new specificities hint at rules for protein--DNA recognition.

Proteins which recognize specific sequences of DNA play a fundamental role in the regulation of protein synthesis in all organisms. A particular helix of the bacterial protein lac repressor recognizes the bases in the major groove of the lac operator. We show that the first two residues of this recognition helix interact independently with two base pairs. This allows us in many cases to predict repression as an indicator of strength of the repressor-operator complex. Rules of recognition can be derived for 16 symmetric operators. They also apply to the gal repressor and possibly to other bacterial repressors.